- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Udayanath Pani v. Basanti Dalai & Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion by A. Pasayat, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion arises from a claim petition filed by dependants of Jayakrushna Dalai (also referred to as Jayaram Dalai), who died on 20-2-1984 after being struck by a bus registered O.R.U 7248, belonging to the appellant (the vehicle owner). The claimants alleged the vehicle was driven rashly and negligently. The Second Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Cuttack (the Tribunal) accepted the accident and negligence facts, assessed compensation at Rs. 56,000/-, and fixed the insurer's liability at Rs. 50,000/-. The vehicle owner (appellant) challenged the Tribunal's direction that a part of the compensation be fastened on him (and on the insurer), contending that the insurer should have been made to pay the entire award because of the insurer's alleged failure to produce the full policy with its defence.
Procedurally, the insurer later filed a copy of the policy and sought its acceptance as additional evidence; that prayer was allowed by the Trial/Tribunal. The present Miscellaneous Appeal sought to challenge the Tribunal's apportionment and the legal consequences of the alleged non-production/incomplete production of the insurance policy.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the insurer's liability should be treated as unlimited (i.e., required to pay the entire compensation) because a complete copy of the insurance policy (including all endorsements) was not produced before the Tribunal with its defence.
- Whether an insurer is required as a general rule to file a copy of the insurance policy along with its written defence in a motor accident claim petition where the insurer seeks to restrict its liability to a portion (statutory or otherwise).
- Whether an adverse inference can be drawn against the insurer (requiring indemnification of the entire award) when relevant particulars of the policy (such as endorsements) are not produced.
- Whether the Tribunal's quantified compensation (Rs. 56,000/-) and the quantum of liability fastened on the insurer (Rs. 50,000/-) should be disturbed by the appellate court in the light of the procedural and documentary facts.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Owner's) Arguments
- The insurer did not take a definite defence before the Tribunal that its liability was limited to Rs. 50,000/- or was otherwise limited; therefore the entire compensation should be payable by the insurer.
- Because the insurer had not enclosed a full copy of the policy with its defence, a presumption should arise that the insurer's liability was unlimited; the appellant relied on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore (1988 A.C.J. 270) and an unreported decision (Akhaya Kumar Sahoo v. Kumari Chkabirani Sethi, Misc. Appeal No. 254/1984) in support of this proposition.
Claimants' Contentions (as set out in the record)
- The deceased was standing at a bus stop when the offending bus dashed against him and ran over him, causing instantaneous death; the vehicle was driven rashly and negligently.
- The deceased, aged 42, worked as a truck driver earning Rs. 1,200 per month and contributed Rs. 800 per month to the family; the dependants claimed Rs. 99,500/- in total. The Tribunal accepted the accident and negligence but quantified compensation at Rs. 56,000/-, rejecting the claimed income and contribution figures.
Insurer's Position (as recorded)
- The insurer had not immediately filed a complete policy copy with its defence but subsequently filed a copy of the policy and sought to have it accepted as additional evidence; the Tribunal permitted this on the basis that only a certificate of insurance and an incomplete duplicate of the policy had been filed by the insured before the Tribunal.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 1697 | Principles of vicarious liability — master liable for acts of servant in course of employment. | Used to explain why the vehicle owner (master/insured) becomes liable for negligence of driver (servant) acting in course of employment, thereby creating insurer's potential indemnity obligation. |
| National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore, 1988 A.C.J. 270 (Supreme Court) | Requirement and desirability that insurer file a copy of the insurance policy where it seeks to limit its liability; adverse view of not producing the policy. | Cited and analyzed at length. The Court emphasized that the case involved non-production of the policy before lower fora and that the Supreme Court accepted a xerox copy at the Civil Appeal stage limiting liability to Rs. 20,000/-. The present Court held that the decision does not lay down an absolute rule that non-production automatically makes insurer's liability unlimited. |
| Prafulla Kumar Misra v. Balaram Sahu, 1975 A.C.J. 29 | View that, in Orissa, the driver is not a necessary party to a claim petition under the relevant rules; claim form columns name owner and insurer but not the driver. | Relied upon to explain procedural practice in Orissa that notice is sent to owner and insurer and that the driver is not made a party in the Tribunal proceedings under the local Rules. |
| Akhaya Kumar Sahoo v. Kumari Chkabirani Sethi, Misc. Appeal No. 254 of 1984 (unreported, disposed 6-4-1990) | Adverse inference can be drawn where relevant policy endorsements/details are not produced; insurer held liable to pay entire amount in that factual matrix. | Distinguished and explained: the court noted that in that case endorsements (Nos. 23, 26, 21, 16, 13 and 57(H)) were not filed, leading to adverse inference. The present Court held that only where "relevant particulars" are absent so that quantum of insurer's liability cannot be ascertained should an adverse inference be drawn. |
| Quinn v. Leathern, 1901 A.C. 495 (Lord Halsbury) | Principle that a case is an authority for what it actually decides (ratio decidendi) and not for every observation. | Quoted to caution against over-extending precedents beyond their ratio; used to support the Court's approach to interpreting National Insurance Co.'s case and other authorities. |
| Merrington v. British R v. Board, (1972) 2 W.L.R. 537 (per Lord Morris of Borth-y-Gest) | Reinforces the limitation of judicial utterances to their factual context and ratio. | Quoted to underline that judicial statements must be read in context and that only ratio carries binding authority. |
| State of Orissa v. Sudhansu Sekhar Misra, A.I.R. 1968 S.C. 547 | Support for treating decisions as authority only for what they decide (caution against extracting isolated sentences). | Used to buttress the Court's warning against building broad rules from isolated observations in prior judgments. |
| Amarnath Om Prakash v. State of Punjab, (1985) 1 SCC 345 : A.I.R. 1985 S.C. 218 | Similar cautionary principle on the ambit of judicial pronouncements and their ratio. | Referred to for the same purpose of restricting follow-on consequences to the actual ratio of earlier decisions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through a structured analysis which can be summarized in the following steps, reflecting only what the opinion states:
- Acceptance of primary facts: The Tribunal accepted the occurrence of the accident and that the bus was driven rashly and negligently. The Tribunal assessed compensation at Rs. 56,000/- and fixed the insurer's liability at Rs. 50,000/-. The present appeal contests the legal effect of the insurer's documentary production.
- Legal framework: The Court explained the underlying legal position — liability for damages initially rests on the wrongdoer (driver) and, by vicarious liability, on the owner/master when the servant acts in the course of employment (citing Sitaram Motilal Kalal). Insurance policies exist to indemnify owners; the policy is the primary document showing the insurer's extent of liability. Relevant statutory provisions mentioned include sections 94–96 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and sections 147–149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and procedural Rule 6 of the Orissa Motor Vehicles (Accidents Claims Tribunals) Rules, 1960 with respect to who must be given notice.
- Procedural practice in Orissa: The Court observed that in Orissa the driver is not a necessary party to claim petitions (citing Prafulla Kumar Misra), and claim forms are framed to name the owner and insurer. This contextualized why the insurer's documentary production is important for determining its liability.
- Analysis of National Insurance Co. case: The Court closely examined National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore. It noted that in that case the policy was not produced before the Tribunal or High Court and only a xerox copy was filed before the Supreme Court; the Supreme Court criticized the insurer's non-production but still accepted the xerox copy to limit liability to Rs. 20,000/-. The present Court concluded that National Insurance Co.'s case does not establish an absolute rule that mere non-production of the policy automatically makes the insurer's liability unlimited.
- When is production required? The Court applied principles from the Code of Civil Procedure (Order VIII, Rules 1 and 5; and Rule 8-A) by analogy: where a defendant bases his defence on a document in his possession/power he should produce it with his written statement. Translating that analogy, the Court held that the insurer is required to file the policy to show a limited liability only when a positive assertion is made (e.g., the claim or pleading asserts or implies an unlimited liability or the insurer takes a defence that liability is not unlimited). It is not a universal obligation in every case to file the policy with the defence.
- Adverse inference and completeness of the policy: The Court accepted that where relevant particulars of the policy (endorsements or clauses affecting liability) are not produced, an adverse inference can be drawn — as in the unreported Akhaya Kumar Sahoo case where missing endorsements led to an order that the insurer pay the whole award. But the Court clarified that an adverse inference is justified only when all relevant details necessary to ascertain the quantum of indemnity are not before the Tribunal.
- Application to present record: In this case, an incomplete copy of the policy had been filed earlier by the insured but the insurer later filed a copy as additional evidence; the Tribunal had permitted its acceptance. The Court directed that the Tribunal should consider the filed policy afresh, allow the insurer to file the copy, and permit the insured and claimants to lead evidence regarding insurer's liability. The Court refused to disturb the Tribunal's assessment of compensation and the Rs. 50,000/- liability at that stage, subject to the Tribunal's final decision on whether liability is unlimited.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Miscellaneous Appeal is DISPOSED OF.
Implications and direct consequences (as stated by the Court):
- The Tribunal's quantification of compensation at Rs. 56,000/- is affirmed; the appellate Court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's reasoning on quantum.
- The amount of Rs. 50,000/- previously fastened on the insurer by the Tribunal remains unaltered for the time being, but this is subject to the Tribunal's final determination on whether the insurer's liability is unlimited.
- The insurer shall be permitted to file a copy of the policy before the Tribunal; the insured and the claimants shall be allowed to lead evidence as to the insurer's liability.
- Procedural directions: Parties were directed to appear before the Tribunal on 26th June 1991 when the Tribunal shall fix a date for adjudication; the insurer shall file a copy of the policy on that date and the Tribunal shall accept and act on it for adjudication, giving opportunities to the parties.
- No costs were awarded.
Note: This summary is confined strictly to the statements, findings and directions contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce facts or inferences not expressly present therein.
A. Pasayat, J.:— The owner of a vehicle which was involved in an accident has called in question the legality of the direction given by the Second Motor Accidents. Claims Tribunal, Cuttack (in short the ‘Tribunal’), fastening a part of the compensation awarded on him. The award was made on the basis of a claim petition filed by the dependants (hereinafter referred to as the ‘claimants’) of one Jayakrushna Dalai alias Jayaram Dalai who lost his life on 20-2-1984 in an accident wherein a bus bearing registration No. O.R.U 7248 belonging to the appellant was involved.
2. The background tacts and the grounds of challenge as described by the claimants are as follows:
On the fateful date at about noon while the deceased was standing by the side of Jagatsingbpur-Cuttack road at Kaijanga bus stop, the offending vehicle dashed against him, knocked him down and ran over him resulting in his instantaneous death. The vehicle was being driven in a rash and negligent manner, the deceased at the time of death was 42 years old and was serving as a truck driver and getting Rs. 1200/- per month, out of which his contribution to the family was Rs. 800/- per month. A total claim oi Rs. 99,500/- was made by the widow of the deceased, seven minor children and dependant parents. The Tribunal accepted the factum of accident as alleged, and that the vehicle was being driven in a rash and negligent manner. On consideration of the evidence placed on behalf of the claimants, it did not accept the income and contribution as claimed, and quantified the compensation at Rs. 56,000/-. The liability of the insurance company, i.e, the New India Assurance Company (hereinafter referred to as the “insurer”) was held to be Rs. 50,000/-.
3. According to the appellant, the entire compensation awarded should have been made payable by the insurer. It is pleaded that the insurer did not take a definite defence that its liability was not beyond Rs. 50,000/- or that its liability was not unlimited; and in any event it having not enclosed a copy of the policy along with its defence, should be liable to pay the entire amount. In support of the plea, strong reliance is placed on a decision of the Supreme Court reported in 1988 A.C.J 270 : National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore, and an unreported decision of this Court in Misc. Appeal No. 254 of 1984 (Akhaya Kumar Sahoo v. Kumari Chkabirani Sethi) disposed of on 6-4-1990. According to the appellant, the latter decision is also an authority for the proposition that the entire policy having not been produced by the insurer before the Tribunal, a presumption arises that the liability of the insurer is unlimited.
4. Since similar pleas are advanced in many cases, I feel that an elaborate discussion on the acceptability of the pleas is desirable.
5. Before adverting to the acceptability of the pleas, it may be noted here that the insurer had filed a copy of the policy and prayed for its acceptance as additional evidence. After hearing the parties, the prayer was accepted. This was done because the certificate of insurance, and an incomplete duplicate copy of policy was filed on behalf of the insured before the Tribunal.
6. A person who suffers injuries or the dependants of a deceased losing his life in an accident are entitled to compensation. The liability is initially that of the person who is responsible for the accident. Therefore, primarily the responsibility for damages is that of the driver. But law is settled that master is vicariously liable for the acts of his servant acting in the course of his employment. Unless the act is done in the course of employment, the servant's act does not make the master liable. In other words, for the master's liability to arise, the act must be a wrongful act authorised by the master or a wrongful and unauthorised mode of doing some act authorised by the master. (See A.I.R 1966 S.C 1697 : Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt ). Therefore, by application of the principles relating to vicarious liability, the owner of the vehicle becomes liable. To get indemnification of any compensation which may become payable the owner who is also described as the insured, enters into an agreement with any insurance company like the insurer in the instant case, which for a premium undertakes to indemnify any liability that may be fastened on an insured. The insurance policy is the basic document from which the intention of the insured and the insurer can be fathomed. It shows the extent of liability of the insurer. The Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’) and the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘new Act’) provide the necessity for insurance, the requirements of policies, the limits of liabilities and the duty of the insurer to satisfy judgments against persons insured in respect of third-party risks. Sections 94, 95 and 96 of the Act and sections 147, 148 and 149 of the new Act are relevant for the purpose.
7. So far as the State of Orissa is concerned, the driver is not a necessary party in a claim petition. Section 110-B of the Act and section 168 of the new Act lay down that the Tribunal shall specify the amount which would be paid by the insurer or owner or driver of the vehicle involved in the accident or by all or any of them, as the case may be. Even though under section 110-B of the Act (section 168 of the new Act) the driver of the vehicle involved in the accident may be made liable for compensation, under rule 6 of the, Orissa Motor Vehicles (Accidents Claims Tribunals) Rules, 1960 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Rules’) notice of the application for damages has to be sent only to the owner of the vehicle involved in the accident and its insurer and not to the driver. Columns 15 and 16 of the prescribed form for the application under the Rules are meant for naming the owner of the vehicle and its insurer. There is no column for naming the driver. The driver, therefore, cannot be held liable in an inquiry prescribed under the Act. This is the view expressed by this Court in Prafulla Kumar Misra v. Balaram Sahu, 1975 A.C.J 29. Since the liability is originally that of the insured it has to be place materials before the adjudicating Tribunal to show what is the quantum of indemnification undertaken by the insurer. In National Insurance Co.'s case (supra), the Supreme Court was dealing with a case where policy was not produced either before the Tribunal or before the High Court, and only while the Civil Appeal was being heard, a xerox copy of the policy was placed before the Court. The attitude adopted by the insurance company is not filing a copy of the policy before the Tribunal or the High Court was seriously viewed. The claimants are not expected to possess the policy or a copy thereof and the owners for the reasons best known to them do not choose to produce them. The Supreme Court emphasised on the desirability of production of a document which is in possession of a party for an effective adjudication. In that background, it was held that the insurance company concerned should file a copy of the insurance policy along with its defence where it wants to take a defence in a claim petition that its liability is not in excess of the statutory liability, (underlining by me). Nevertheless considering the xerox copy of policy that was filed, the Supreme Court held that the insurer's liability could not be in excess of Rs. 20,000/-. It was nowhere laid down in the said decision as an absolute proposition that wherever the copy of the policy is not filed with the defence, the liability of the insurer become unlimited. In fact had it been so, the Supreme Court would not have accepted the xerox copy of the policy filed by the insurer to insurer to restrict the liability to Rs. 20,000/-, when compensation of Rs. 1 lakh was awarded. The Court emphasised on the desirability of filing the copy of policy, because insurance company is an instrumentality of the State, which is expected to act fairly and avoid litigation. Order 8, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short the ‘Code’) permits a defendant to present a written statement of his defence at or before the first hearing, or within such time as the Court may permit. Rule 5 of the said Order provides that every allegation of fact in the plaint, if not denied specifically or by necessary implication, or stated to be not admitted in the pleading of the defendant, shall be taken to be admitted except as against a person under disability. Rule 8-A also provides that where a defendant bases his defence upon a document in his possession or power, he shall produce it in Court when the written a statement is presented by him and shall, at the same time, deliver the document or a copy thereof, to be filed with the written statement. Applying the analogy, where there is a positive assertion that the liability of an insurer is unlimited or claims to that effect are made, then only the question of the insurer taking a defence that its liability is not unlimited arises. Unless such a positive assertion is made in the claim petition and/or in the objection filed by the insured, the question of the insurer taking a defence that its liability is not unlimited does not arise. Thus, it cannot be laid down as a general principle that in all cases the insurer is required to file a copy of the policy to show that its liability is not unlimited. Such a situation will only arise when there is a positive assertion in that regard. It need not be emphasised that the casual approach of the insured in not effectively participating in the proceeding, and not even producing the policy which is a document over which he has the primary custody is to be discouraged. The Tribunals should insist on the insured filing the policy, and require it to indicate the reason why it does not do so, and in appropriate cages draw adverse inferences. That would curb the tendency of the owners in not effectively participating in the proceedings, and resultantly fastening unintended liability on the insurer. The conduct of the insurers is not always appreciaitable. More often than not, they show a very casual approach. Routine objections are filed and the participation in the adjudicatory process in ineffective. It is high time that they take a stock of the whole situation.
8. The residual question is whether in the unreported decision of this Court in the case of Akhaya Kumar Sahoo (supra), the Court laid down as a principle that wherever the complete policy is not produced before the Court, adverse inference can be drawn and the insurer can be asked to indemnify the entire Liability. According to me, the document should be complete in the sense that all relevant particulars which show the extent of liability undertaken for indemnification ate clearly brought for consideration. In the last mentioned case, the Division Bench found that the relevant particulars were not produced. This is apparent from paragraph 12 itself on which much stress has been laid by the insured. The Court found that though the policy in question indicated that the same was subject to clause M.V.C and endorsement Nos. 23, 26, 21, 16, 13 and 57(H), these endorsements were not filed. Therefore, adverse inference was drawn, and it was held that the insurer was to pay the entire awarded amount. Where, however all the relevant details are before the Tribunal from which actual quantum of liability undertaken to be indemnified, can be ascertained, the question of fastening the unlimited liability on the insurer would not arise.
9. The pleas of the appellant that the insurer's liability is unlimited do not get any countenance from the two decisions on which reliance was placed. It is needless to repeat the oft quoted truism of Lord Halsbury (See Quinn v. Leathern, 1901 A.C 495) that a case is an authority for what it actually decides and not for what may seem to follow logically from it. There is always peril in treating the words of a speach or a judgment as though they were words in a legislative enactment and it is to be remembered that judicial utterances are made in the setting of the facts of a particular case. (Per Lord Morris of Borth-y-Gest in Merrington v. British R v. Board, (1972) 2 W.L.R 537). A decision is only an authority for what it actually decides. What is of essence in a decision is its ratio and not every observation found therein nor what logically follows from the various observations made in it. It is not a profitable task to extract a sentence here and there from a judgment and to build upon it. (See State of Orissa v. Sudhansu Sekhar Misra, A.I.R 1968 S.C 547 and Amarnath Om Prakash v. State of Punjab, (1985) 1 SCC 345 : A.I.R 1985 S.C 218).
10. Adverting to the present case, I find that an incomplete copy of the policy was filed by the insured before the Tribunal. The insurer has filed a copy of the policy for consideration as additional evidence. It would be appropriate that this document should be considered by the Tribunal afresh. The insurer shall be permitted to file a copy of the policy before the Tribunal, and the insured and the claimants shall be permitted to lead evidence as regards the liability of the insurer.
11. So far as the quantum of liability is concerned, the amount of Rs. 50,000/- fastened by the Tribunal on the insurer remains unaltered subject to final decision by the Tribunal on the question whether liability is unlimited or not. The quantum of compensation awarded is also affirmed, as I do not find any infirmity in the process of reasoning indicated by the Tribunal. To avoid unnecessary delay, I direct the parties to appear before the Tribunal on 26th of June, 1991 when the Tribunal shall fix up a date for adjudication. The insurer shall file a copy of the policy on that date. No further notice shall be issued to the parties. The Tribunal shall accept the copy to be filed by the insurer and shall act on it for the purpose of adjudication, giving opportunity to the parties as afore directed.
12. The Miscellaneous Appeal is disposed of. No costs.
13. Ordered accordingly.
Alert