Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

B. Pattnaik Mines (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Bijoyananda Pattnaik And Others

Orissa High Court
Dec 20, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — P.C. Misra, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s B. Pattnaik Mines (Pvt.) Ltd., a company under liquidation, filed the present application through the Official Liquidator under section 543 of the Companies Act, 1956, seeking enquiries and assessment of damages against a delinquent director for misfeasance and breach of trust alleged to have caused loss of company assets and led to liquidation.

The company was incorporated on March 19, 1956, with its head office at Tulsipur, Cuttack; the office was later shifted to other premises in the same locality. The company was wound up with effect from April 9, 1975. The application under section 543 was filed on April 9, 1981. Respondent No. 8 raised a limitation defence and an application was filed to hear limitation as a preliminary point.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application under section 543(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, filed by the Official Liquidator on April 9, 1981, is barred by the limitation period prescribed in section 543(2).
  2. Whether the Official Liquidator (as applicant under section 543) can invoke the additional one-year period of limitation provided by section 458A of the Companies Act — in other words, whether the application under section 543 can be treated as an application "in the name of and on behalf of the company" so as to attract the extension under section 458A.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No. 8's Arguments

  • The application is barred by limitation: section 543(2) prescribes a five-year period from the date of the winding up order, or first appointment of the liquidator, or of the misfeasance/misapplication, whichever is longer.
  • All acts of misfeasance complained of occurred well before the winding up order (April 9, 1975); calculation of limitation from the winding up order would result in expiry before the application date, so the present application (filed April 9, 1981) is time-barred.
  • The applicant is not entitled to the additional one-year extension under section 458A because the basic conditions for that section are absent (i.e., the application is not in the name of and on behalf of the company).

Applicant (Official Liquidator / M/s B. Pattnaik Mines) Arguments

  • The applicant contended the application is within limitation because an additional period of one year is available under section 458A of the Companies Act, 1956.
  • The applicant argued that the Official Liquidator, while acting in liquidation, represents the company and therefore the section 543 application should be treated as being filed in the name of and on behalf of the company (which would attract the extension under section 458A).
  • The applicant moved under Order 6, Rule 17 CPC to amend the cause title to substitute the description of the applicant to read: "the Official Liquidator of M/s. B. Pattnaik Mines (P) Ltd. in liquidation".

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Official Liquidator, Palai Central Bank Ltd. (In liquidation) v. K. Joseph Augusti, [1966] KLJ 246 The liquidator or a creditor/contributory when making an application under section 543 does so in his own independent right and not as representing the company; such an application is not in the name and on behalf of the company. The court relied on this principle to conclude that an application under section 543, filed by the official liquidator, is not an application "in the name of and on behalf of the company" and therefore does not qualify for the extension under section 458A.
Company Act Case No. 1 of 1982 (this court) Confirmed that section 543 confers an independent remedial right on the official liquidator and others named, and that forms and rules indicate the official liquidator appears in his own name under section 543. The court followed this prior order and applied its reasoning: section 543 applications are made by the official liquidator in his own name (Form No.121 under Rule 260), so section 458A's extension (which applies only to suits/applications in the name and on behalf of the company) is inapplicable.
Modi Vanaspati Manufacturing Company v. Katihar Jute Mills (Pvt.) Ltd., AIR 1969 Cal 496 The case was relied upon by applicant's counsel; it contains observations about company actions during liquidation. The court held the decision to be of no relevance to the specific point under consideration (i.e., whether a section 543 application is in the name and on behalf of the company for the purpose of section 458A).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a textual and purposive analysis of section 543 and of section 458A of the Companies Act, 1956, and also considered procedural rules and prior authorities addressing the relationship between a liquidator's application under section 543 and applications or suits brought "in the name and on behalf of the company."

  1. The court set out the text of section 543: it empowers the court, on application by the official liquidator (or liquidator, creditor or contributory) made within the time specified in subsection (2), to examine conduct and compel restitution or compensation for misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust. Subsection (2) prescribes a five-year limitation measured from the winding up order, the first appointment of a liquidator, or the date of the misfeasance/misapplication, whichever is longer.
  2. The court identified that section 458A provides an additional period of one year but observed that this extension applies only to suits or applications "in the name and on behalf of the company," and both limbs (in the name of, and on behalf of, the company) must be satisfied for the section to apply.
  3. Relying on the Kerala High Court decision in Official Liquidator, Palai Central Bank Ltd. v. K. Joseph Augusti and this court's prior Company Act Case No. 1 of 1982, the court concluded that an application under section 543 is made by the official liquidator in his own independent right (even though the relief obtained is for the benefit of the company). The procedural forms (Form No. 121 under Rule 260 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959) list the official liquidator — not the company — as the applicant.
  4. The court emphasized the distinction between the general powers of the liquidator under section 457 and the special remedial power conferred by section 543. Exercising the power under section 543 is not the same as bringing suit "in the name and on behalf of the company" under section 457(1) or the rubric of section 458A.
  5. The court rejected the applicant's contention that every action of the official liquidator should be regarded as action in the company's name for the purpose of extension under section 458A, observing that such a view would confer an advantage (the extra year) on the official liquidator that would not be available to a creditor or contributory.
  6. The court allowed the applicant's procedural amendment under Order 6, Rule 17 CPC to correct the description of the applicant in the cause title to reflect the Official Liquidator of the company in liquidation, but expressly held that this amendment does not affect the limitation point.
  7. Applying these legal principles to the facts — notably the filing dates and the five-year window in section 543(2) — the court concluded that the present application is not entitled to the section 458A extension and is therefore time-barred.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the application under section 543 of the Companies Act, 1956, filed by the Official Liquidator on April 9, 1981, is barred by limitation and is therefore dismissed.

Implications:

  • The court allowed the technical amendment to the cause title under Order 6, Rule 17 CPC to describe the applicant correctly as the Official Liquidator in liquidation, but expressly held that such an amendment does not alter the limitation position.
  • The decision means that the Official Liquidator's section 543 application will not proceed because it did not satisfy the limitation period and could not benefit from the extension under section 458A since the application was not found to be made "in the name of and on behalf of the company."
  • No broader change in law or new precedent was announced beyond the court's application of existing authorities and procedural rules to the facts of this case; the ruling follows earlier decisions on the point.

End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

P.C Misra, J.:— On an application filed by respondent No. 8, the question of limitation was decided to be heard as a preliminary point.

2. M/s. B. Pattnaik Mines (Pvt.) Ltd. is a company which is under liquidation. The present application has been filed by the company represented by the official liquidator under section 543 of the Companies Act, 1956, praying for making all necessary enquiries to be made and to assess the damages against the delinquent director of the company for whose misfeasance and breach of trust, the company lost its assets and was led to a situation for its liquidation.

3. The admitted facts are that the company was incorporated on March 19, 1956, when its head office was at Tulsipur, Cuttack. Subsequently, the office was shifted to other premises in the same locality. There was a proceeding for winding up of the company and the company was wound up with effect from April 9, 1975. This application under section 543 of the Companies Act was filed on April 9, 1981. It has been contended by respondent No. 8 that this application is barred by limitation. In support of the aforesaid contention, it has been urged that the limitation for filing of an application under section 543(1) of the Act is five years from the date of the order for winding up, or of the first appointment of the liquidator in winding up, or of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust, as the case may be, whichever is longer.

4. In this application, all the acts of misfeasance complained of were much prior to the order of winding up which was passed on April 9, 1975. As argued by respondent No. 8, the period of five years, if calculated from the date of the order of winding up, would expire on May 9, 1980, and, therefore, the present application under section 543(1) of the Act having been filed on April 9, 1981, is barred by limitation.

5. Learned counsel appearing for the applicant has contended that the application would be within the period of limitation as a further period of one year would be available under section 458A of the Act. It is urged by learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 8 that the applicant is not entitled to the extended period of one year under section 458A of the Act inasmuch as the basic conditions necessary for the application of the said section are absent in this case. Thus, the only question which requires to be considered for the purpose of limitation is whether section 458A of the Act can be taken advantage of by the petitioner.

6. An analysis of the scope of section 543 of the Act would be necessary for examining whether the extended period of one year would be available to an official liquidator for an application under section 543 of the Act. Section 543 of the Act is quoted below for ready reference:

“543. Power of court to assess damages against delinquent directors, etc.—(1) If in the course of winding up a company, it appears that any person who has taken part in the promotion or formation of the company, or any past or present director, manager, liquidator or officer of the company—

(a) has misapplied, or retained, or become liable or accountable for, any money or property of the company; or

(b) has been guilty of any misfeasance or breach of trust in relation to the company;

the court may, on the application of the official liquidator, or the liquidator, or of any creditor or contributory, made within the time specified in that behalf in sub-section (2), examine into the conduct of the person, director, manager, liquidator or officer aforesaid, and compel him to repay or restore the money or property or any part thereof respectively, with interest at such rate as the court thinks just or to contribute such sum to the assets of the company by way of compensation in respect of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust, as the court thinks just.

(2) An application under sub-section (1) shall be made within five years from the date of the order for winding up, or of the first appointment of the liquidator in winding-up, or of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust, as the case may be, whichever is longer.

(3) This section shall apply notwithstanding that the matter is one for which the person concerned may be criminally liable.”

7. Under the said section, the court is empowered to examine the conduct of the person, director, manager, liquidator or officer of the company and compel him to repay or restore the money or property or any part thereof with interest at such rate as the court thinks just or to contribute such sum to the assets of the company by way of compensation in respect of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust, as the court thinks just. The court is not empowered to proceed suo motu against the aforesaid persons. Action under the said section can be taken by the court only on the application of the official liquidator or the liquidator or of any creditor or contributory if made within the period of limitation specified in that behalf in sub-section (2) of the said section. Sub-section (2) of section 543 prescribes a period of five years for such an application from the date of the order for winding-up, or of the first appointment of the liquidator in winding up, or of the misapplication, retainer, misfeasance or breach of trust, as the case may be, whichever is longer. The additional period of one year under section 458A would be available for any suit or application in the name and on behalf of the company. It is, therefore, necessary to examine whether the application under section 543 of the Act filed by the official liquidator is an application in the name and on behalf of the company which is being wound up by the court. In order that section 458A would apply, both the conditions, i.e, the application in the name of the company and on behalf of the company, must be satisfied. In the decision in Official Liquidator, Palai Central Bank Ltd. (In liquidation) v. K. Joseph Augusti, [1966] KLJ 246, their Lordships observed:

“I might also point out that when the liquidator, or a creditor, or a contributory makes an application under section 543 he does not do so as representing the company but in his own independent right, although for the benefit of the company. His position, it seems to me, is analogous to that of a junior member suing in respect of joint family property. In making an application under section 543, the liquidator is not exercising the power conferred by section 457(1). He does not apply in the name and on behalf of the company, but as Forms Nos. 120 and 121 of the forms in the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, rightly set out, in his own name. I would add that he applies in his own behalf although on the terms of section 543, the order can only be for payment or restoration to the company.”

8. This court, in Company Act Case No. 1 of 1982, where a similar question came up for consideration, relied on the reasonings given by the Kerala High Court and held as follows:

“Section 543 of the Act undoubtedly conferred a new remedial right on the official liquidator and others named in that section for enforcement of some rights as the company itself would have enforced by way of suits, although the application is meant for the benefit of the company. In making an application under section 543, the official liquidator has not exercised the powers conferred on him by section 457, subsection (1), but he exercised the powers which section 543 itself confers on him. Rule 260 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, under sub-rule (1) requires summons of section 543 to be issued in Form No. 121. In the said form the official liquidator of the company or a creditor or a contributor of the said company and not the company itself is set out to be the applicant. Thus, it is the official liquidator who is authorised under section 543 to apply in his own behalf for the appropriate relief, though the ultimate order to be passed by the court is for the benefit of the company. This view is supported by a decision in Official Liquidator, Palai Central Bank Ltd. (In liquidation) v. K. Joseph Augusti, [1966] KLJ 246.

The language of section 458A is explicit and clear that it applies to only suits and applications in the name and on behalf of the company filed by the official liquidator. As has been discussed earlier, the present application filed by the official liquidator under section 543 of the Act would not be construed as an application in the name and on behalf of the company. The extended period of limitation provided under section 458A of the Act would not be available to be applied. I would, therefore, conclude that the present application is barred by limitation.”

9. Learned counsel appearing for the applicant has argued that the official liquidator, while dealing with the liquidation proceeding, represents the company and, therefore, the application under section 543 filed by the official liquidator must be taken to be an application in the name and on behalf of the company. Such an argument has been repelled by this court in the order passed in Company Act Case No. 1 of 1982, and the reasons given there need not be repeated in this case again. If every action of the official liquidator must be deemed to be in the name and on behalf of the company, the result would be that the official liquidator would be entitled to the additional period of one year limitation whereas any creditor or contributory would not be entitled to such benefit. Mr. Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the applicant, has relied on the provisions contained in section 457 of the Act which defines the powers of the liquidator. But the general power vested with the official liquidator under the said section is distinct from the special powers conferred on him by section 543 of the Act. This aspect of the matter has also been dealt with in the order passed in Company Act Case No. 1 of 1982. A decision of the Calcutta High Court in Modi Vanaspati Manufacturing Company v. Katihar Jute Mills (Pvt.) Ltd., AIR 1969 Cal 496, which has been relied upon is of no relevance so far as the point under consideration is concerned. The legal proposition that a company continues to live until it is wound up and that the every action of the official liquidator is on behalf or for the benefit of the company is not in dispute. But, in order that the additional period of one year to extend the period of limitation can be taken advantage of, the application must be one in conformity with the provisions of section 458A of the Act.

10. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has filed an application under Order 6, rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code, to amend the description of the applicant in the cause title of the application. The original application under section 543 of the Act was filed by M/s. B. Pattnaik Mines Pvt. Ltd. represented by the official liquidator, Orissa High Court, Cuttack. The same is required to be substituted as “the Official Liquidator of M/s. B. Pattnaik Mines (P) Ltd. in liquidation”. I would allow the amendment as section 543 empowers the official liquidator to make the application. But, by such an amendment, the case of the petitioner so far as the question of limitation is concerned would not improve.

11. In conclusion, I would hold that the application under section 543 of the Act is barred by limitation and is, therefore, liable to be dismissed which I hereby do.