Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Baikunthanath Dalai v. Bula Alias Digambar Jena & Others (Crl Mic. 985/89)

Orissa High Court
Aug 14, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Legal Opinion — D.P. Mohapatra, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

Baikunthanath Dalai, the informant in G.R. Case No. 260 of 1989 (S.D.J.M., Nayagarh), lodged an FIR on 1-8-1989 (Sarankul Police Station) alleging that a group of persons belonging to a rival faction assaulted Arjuna Jena on the village road. The prosecution alleged that the accused came armed with weapons (Farsa, swords, Katari, knives, bombs, guns and lathis), assaulted Arjuna Jena, exploded bombs and fired guns to prevent rescue; the injured Arjuna Jena was taken to hospital and died at 9 p.m. on the same day. The FIR led to registration of G.R. Case No. 260 of 1989 under sections 147/148/326/336/324/302/149, Indian Penal Code and sections 25(a)/37 of the Arms Act.

Multiple accused filed successive bail applications before the Sessions Judge, Puri. The Sessions Judge passed several orders between 15-9-1989 and 18-10-1989: some applications were rejected and others were allowed; at times batches of accused were released on bail while other accused were refused. The informant (petitioner) filed two petitions under section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure challenging the Sessions Judge's orders that admitted various accused to bail. The petitions were heard together and culminated in the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order granting bail can be cancelled under section 439(2), Cr. P.C., in the absence of any allegation or proof that the accused misused their liberty after being admitted to bail.
  2. Whether the Sessions Judge's successive admissions of accused to bail, without indicating any material change in circumstances and while appearing to sift the merits of the prosecution case, constituted an illegal or arbitrary exercise of judicial discretion warranting cancellation of bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Informant) — Shri S.K. Padhi

  • Submitted that the impugned orders of the Sessions Judge admitting the accused to bail were palpably and manifestly illegal, erroneous and improper.
  • Contended that those orders should not be allowed to stand (i.e., should be set aside/cancelled).

Accused / Opposite Parties — Shri D.P. Dhal

  • Contended that there is no allegation that the accused misused their liberty after being admitted to bail.
  • Argued that the prosecution has not alleged that investigation or trial has been impeded due to the accused being on bail; therefore the Sessions Judge's orders admitting them to bail should not be interfered with.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chhaila Pradhan v. Bansidhar Pradhan, 62 (1986) C.L.T. 699 That bail granted illegally or by a wrong/arbitrary exercise of judicial discretion can be cancelled even without supervening circumstances occurring after grant of bail. Cited as authority for the proposition that cancellation of bail is permissible where bail was granted improperly; used to support quashing of the Sessions Judge's bail orders despite absence of misuse of liberty by accused post-bail.
Sri Pitambar Swain v. Ainthu alias Ashok Kumar Sahu, 66 (1988) C.L.T. 820 Support for the principle that bail improperly granted can be cancelled even if no subsequent misuse of liberty is shown. Relied upon alongside other C.L.T. authorities to establish settled law permitting cancellation of improperly granted bail without supervening circumstances.
Prasanta Kumar Dhal v. State, 67 (1989) C.L.T. 272 Another authority reinforcing that cancellation of bail is permissible where bail was granted illegally/improperly irrespective of later conduct by the accused. Used cumulatively with other C.L.T. decisions to justify cancellation of the Sessions Judge's orders admitting accused to bail.
Kumud Mohapatra v. Abhina Mallick alias Abhimanyu Mallick, 1989 (II) C.L.R. 373 That successive applications for bail by the same accused should not be entertained unless there has been a material change in circumstances that warrants reconsideration. Applied to criticize the Sessions Judge for entertaining successive bail applications without any indicated material change of circumstances; supported the conclusion that the Sessions Judge erred in principle.
Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980) 2 SCC 559; A.I.R. 1980 S.C. 785 That while considering an application for bail it is not proper to sift the materials to ascertain the merits of the prosecution case (i.e., the court should not conduct a mini-trial of the merits when deciding bail). Invoked to demonstrate that the Sessions Judge wrongly attempted to sift evidence/merits in some orders; used to show improper approach in considering bail petitions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the sequence of orders passed by the Sessions Judge between 15-9-1989 and 18-10-1989. It noted the following key points, taken from the orders and the record:

  1. The Sessions Judge entertained and allowed successive applications for bail for various accused without indicating any material change in circumstances between applications. The Court treated this as inconsistent with the settled rule that successive applications by the same accused should not be entertained unless there has been a material change in circumstances (citing Kumud Mohapatra).
  2. The Sessions Judge passed apparently contradictory orders within a fairly short time span. In some orders he treated the fact that main assailants were absconding and that tension prevailed as relevant; in others he rejected similar circumstances as irrelevant. The Court viewed this as inconsistency in approach.
  3. The Sessions Judge, in examining the bail applications, in some instances attempted to sift the materials and evaluate the merits of the prosecution case (for example, assessing nature and location of injuries and inflammatory facts). The Court found this approach improper, relying on the principle laid down in Niranjan Singh that it is not proper to sift the materials to decide bail.
  4. The Court concluded that irrelevant matters had been taken into consideration and that the judicial discretion vested in the Sessions Judge had been exercised illegally and arbitrarily in several orders.
  5. Relying on established authorities (including Chhaila Pradhan, Sri Pitambar Swain and Prasanta Kumar Dhal), the Court reiterated that bail granted illegally or improperly may be cancelled even in the absence of subsequent misuse of liberty by the accused. Consequently, the absence of any allegation that the accused misused their liberty after being released on bail did not preclude cancellation if the grant of bail itself was improper.
  6. Applying these principles to the facts and the chronology of inconsistent and contradictory orders, the Court held that allowing those bail orders to stand would amount to an abuse of the process of the Court and occasion failure of justice. Therefore, cancellation under section 439(2), Cr. P.C., was appropriate.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The applications are allowed. The orders passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Puri admitting the accused-opposite parties to bail are hereby quashed and set aside.

Direct Effect / Immediate Consequence:

  • The accused-opposite parties whose bail orders were quashed are directed to surrender before the trial Court immediately.
  • The impugned bail orders of the Sessions Judge are cancelled under section 439(2), Cr. P.C.

Broader Implications:

The Court grounded its decision on existing authorities and established principles (as cited in the opinion). The opinion does not announce any novel legal principle; it applies settled law to the facts and the procedural chronology before it. Therefore, the immediate consequence is the cancellation of the specific bail orders in question and the direction for surrender; no new precedent or broader legal rule beyond the application of cited authorities was articulated in this opinion.

Disposition: Applications allowed.

Show all summary ...

D.P Mohapatra, J.:— Baikunthanath Dalai, the informant in G.R Case No. 260 of 1989 of the Court of the S.D.J.M, Nayagarh has filed these two petitions under sections 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure CCr. P.C’ for short) assailing the orders of the Sessions Judge, Puri admitting the accused-opp. parties to bail. Since the petitions relate to the same criminal case and the contentions raised by the petitioner in both the cases are similar, with consent of the learned counsel for the parties they have been heard together and are being disposed of by this order.

2. On the First Information Report lodged by the petitioner in Sarankul Police Station on 1-8-1989 G.R Case No. 260 of 1989 was initiated against the. opp. parties and some others under sections 147/148/326/336/324/3021149, I.P.C and sections 25(a)/37 of the Arms Act. The case of the prosecution, shortly stated, was that since two years prior to the occurrence there was party faction in the village; while the petitioner and the deceased Arjuna Jena were in the minority group the accused persons belonged to the majority group. On 1-8-1989 at about 6.30 a.m while the petitioner come out of his house to the village road (Danda) he saw Arjuna Jena having a wash near the tube-well. The accused-opp. parties along with others being armed with deadly weapons like Farsa, swords, Katari, knives, bombs', guns and lathis came there, caught hold of Arjuna Jena and severaly assaulted him with the weapons hold by them, they also exploded bombs and fired from the guns to scare away the villagers who tried to come to the rescue of Arjuna Jena. The injured Arjuna Jena was shifted to the Hospital where he expired at 9 p.m on the same day. The F.I.R was lodged at about 9 a.m and the Investigating Officer who went to the spot at 9.30 a.m on the next day found a pool of blood at the place of occurrence on the village Danda. It appears from the records received from the Court of the Sessions Judge, Puri that different batches of accused persons filed applications from time to time for being released on bail which were disposed of by the Court by different orders. Therefore it will be convenient to discuss the orders chronologically.

3. By order dated 15-9-1989 the learned Sessions Judge disposed of the two applications registered as Criminal Misc. Case No. 619 of 1989 and Criminal Misc. Case No. 731 of 1989. Though from the cause title in the certified copy of the order only five accused persons are mentioned as petitioners, it appears from the records that he dealt with the prayer for bail of seven accused persons. The applicants in Criminal Misc. Case No. 619 of 1989 were Bula alias Digambar Jena, Laxman Pal, Gobardhan Parida, Murali Pradhan and Hadibandhu Pradhan and those in Criminal Misc. Case No. 731 of 1989 were Ananda Chandra Parida and Dasa Pala alias Dalai. While rejecting the prayer of all the applicants the Sessions Judge observed as follows:

“……Admittedly all these petitioners were present and attacked the deceased. There is direct evidence against the petitioner Bula alias Digambar. Jena that he assaulted the deceased with a lathi on his hand while others were assaulting him with Katari and Farsa and knives. The post-mortem report is not yet received and the case diary is not available. The action of the petitioners created panic in the locality as they exploded bombs and also fired from the guns to scare away the villagers and did not allow them to save the life of the deceased who was assaulted by the other accused persons. So the intention of the petitioners is clear that they formed an unlawful assembly with common intention to cause the death of the deceased. The main culprits are absconding and the investigation is still under progress. Under these circumstances, I. think this is not a fit case to release the petitioners on bail at this stage……..”

4. Shortly thereafter the petitioners in Criminal Misc. Case No. 619 of 1989 and three others, namely, Dasa Pala alias Dalai, Ananda Chandra Parida and Maheswar Pradhan filed application for being released on bail which was registered as Criminal Misc. Case No. 781/22 of 1989. The learned Sessions Judge by his order dated 21-9-1989 disposed of the application with the direction that the petitioners 1 to 7 in the case be released on bail. The prayer of petitioner No. 8 Maheswar Pradhan for bail was rejected. He observed in the order:

“……On the other hand there is evidence that the deceased was assaulted by Ramesh Behera, Chandramani Parida, Dibyasingha Paikra with Farsa, Chiranjib Parida with Katari on the left palm, Raghu Parida with sword on the right leg and right arm, Bharat Behera with the Katari on the right thigh and Digambar Jena with lathi on the right hand of the deceased. Admittedly, as found from the post-mortem report as well as from the injury report, it is seen that all the injuries inflicted on the deceased were mostly on the legs, thigh and on the arms. There was no fatal injury on the head.

The contention of the Addl. P.P that the main assailants are still absconding and are not yet apprehended and that they were threatening to the other members of the informant party is no ground for consideration of the bail petition of the present petitioners. A total number of 30 accused persons could not have caused only 8 to 9 injuries on the deceased and that too on only legs and hands. The, bead injury is simple and is not at all fatal as found from the post-mortem report.

Since there is no direct evidence of assaulting the deceased against petitioners Nos. 1 to 7, 1 am inclined to release them on bail.”

5. Within seven days thereafter another application for bail was filed on behalf of fourteen accused persons, viz., Prafulla Jena, Ramesh Behera, Dasarathi Behera, Harihar Naik, Kasi Parida, Babu alias Gokulananda Pradhan, Jagannath alias Jaguli Pradhan, Binayak Samantara, Bishnu Pala, Bharat alias Huna Behera, Dibyasingha Paikara, Chandramani Parida, Raghu Parida and Chiranjibi Parida which was registered as Criminal Misc. Case No. 811 of 1989. The said application was disposed of by order dated 27-9-1989 rejecting the prayer for bail of petitioner No. 6 Babu alias Gokulananda Pradhan, petitioner No. 10 Bharat alias Huria Behera, petitioner No. 11 Dibyasingh Paikara, petitioner No. 12 Chandramani Parida, petitioner No. 13 Raghu Parida and petitioner No. 14 Chiranjibi Parida; the order shows that all other petitioners in Criminal Misc. Case No. 811 of 1989 and the 14 petitioners in Criminal Misc. Case No. 816 of 1989 were released on bail. The certified copy of the order does not show the names of the petitioners in Criminal Misc. Case No. 816 of 1989 nor does the discussion in the order clearly spell out anything about them. The orders passed on 21-9-1989 and 27-9-1989 are under challenge in Criminal Misc. Case No. 985 of 1989. The six applicants whose prayer for bail was rejected by the order dated 27-9-1989 filed another application for bail (Criminal Misc. Case No. 847/89) which was disposed of by the learned Sessions Judge by order dated 18-10-1989. All the applicants were admitted to bail. It was observed in the order:

……In the dying declaration the deceased named Ramesh Behera with Farsa, Jaga Parida with a sword, Raghu Parida with a Khanda assaulted him and Bula Jena assaulted him with a lathi, Huria Behera threw a bomb and Babu Pradhan also threw a bomb whereas the statements of the eye witnesses are different. The petitioners Chandramani Parida, Dibyasingha Paikara and Chiranjibi Parida were not at all named as his assailants by the deceased. Amongst the persons named, Ramesh Behera, Jaga Parida, Bula Jena were already released on bail as there was no sufficient evidence against them. From the statements of the witnesses, it is seen that the petitioner Huria Behera gave a blow with a Katari on the right thigh of the deceased and also threw some bombs. The petitioner Dibyasingh Paikara gave a Farsa blow on the left arm and Chandramani Parida with a sword assaulted on the left thigh and Raghu Parida gave a blow with a Kati on the left hand and left leg. Most of the injuries on the deceased were on the legs and hands only. This shows that the petitioners had no intention to kill him but only to leave him with assaults. Moreover, when the deceased did not name the petitioners Chandramani Parida and Dibyasingha Paikara end Chiranjibi Parida and the blows given by them as per the statements of the witnesses are not on the head or on the neck or on the chest of the deceased and similarly the other petitioners also did not assault the deceased on the vital parts of the body and as the investigation is almost completed, the petitioners be released on bail of Rs. 5000/- with one surety each for the like amount the satisfaction of this Court……”

6. This order is under challenge in Criminal Misc. Case No. 1057 of 1989.

7. Shri S.K Padhi appearing for the petitioner submitted that the impugned orders passed by the learned Sessions Judge admitting the accused-opp. parties to bail are palpably and manifestly illegal, erroneous and improper and they should not be allowed to stand.

8. Shri D.P Dhal appearing for the accused-opposite parties, on the other hand, contended that since there is no allegation that the opp. parties have misutilised their liberty after being admitted to bail and the prosecution has not come up with any allegation that it is facing difficulty investigation of trial of the case on account of the opp parties being at the orders passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Puri should not be interfered with.

9. It is not in dispute that in the present case there is no allegation that the accused-opp. parties have committed any overt act after they were admitted to bail. The question therefore is whether in such a case the order granting bail can be cancelled under section 439(2)) Cr. P.C. No doubt, while considering an application for cancellation of.bail the Court ordinarily looks for some supervening circumstances indicating that the accused has misutilised the liberty granted to him by being admitted to bail, but that is neither a statutory sine qua non nor a rule of universal application. The position has to be taken us well settled that bail granted illegally or improperly by a wrong and arbitrary exercise of judicial discretion can be cancelled even if there is absence of supervening circumstances against the accused after grant of bail. (See 62 (1986) C.L.T 699 : Ckkaila Pradhan v. Bansidhar Pradhan, 66 (1988) C.L.T 820 : Sri Pitambar Swain v. Ainthu alias Ashok Kumar Sahu and 67 (1989) C.L.T 272 : Prasanta Kumar Dhal v. State). It is also an well accepted principle that successive applications for bail by the some accused should not be entertained unless the Court is satisfied that in the meantime there has been a material change in the circumstances which warrants reconsideration of the matter. (See 1989 (II) C.L.R 373 : Kumud Mohapatra v. Abhina Mallick alias Abhimanyu Mallick).

10. On perusal of the different orders passed by the learned Sessions Judge from time to time, relevant portions of which have been quoted/discussed earlier, it is clear that he has entertained and allowed successive applications for bail without indicating any material change in circumstances completely ignoring the settled position of law as indicated above has passed apparently contradictory orders within a fairly short span of time between 15-9-1989 and 18-10-1989 and has also tried to sift the materials with a view to ascertain the merits of the prosecution case against the accused-opp. parties, which, as observed by the Supreme Court in the case of Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, reported in (1980) 2 SCC 559 : A.I.R 1980 S.C 785 and in the case of Chhaila Pradhan v. Banshidhar Pradhan, reported in 62 (1986) C.L.T 699 (supra), is not proper approach while considering ‘an application for bail. It also appears from the discussions in the orders that the learned Sessions Judge has approached the matter differently while passing the orders from time to time; in one order he considers the circumstances like many of the accused persons being still at large and tension prevailing in the area as relevant circumstance while in another order he outright rejects similar circumstance as irrelevant. The orders clearly reveal that irrelevant matters were taken into consideration and the judicial discretion vested in him was exercised illegally and arbitrarily. On giving my anxious consideration to the matter, I am of the view that if the orders granting bail to the accused-opp. parties are allowed to stand, it would amount to abuse of the process of the Court and occasion failure of justice. I am satisfied that this is a fit case where bail granted to the accused-opp. parties should be cancelled under section 439(2), Cr. P.C The applications are therefore allowed and the orders passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Puri admitting the accused-opp. parties to bail are hereby quashed and set aside. They are directed to surrender before the trial Court immediately.

11. Applications allowed.