Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Orissa v. Ananda Prasad Mandal .

Orissa High Court
Jan 10, 1985
Smart Summary (Beta)

Written Summary of the Opinion (P.C. Misra, J.; G.B. Patnaik, J. concurred)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from Money Suit No. 340/6 of 1969/73 in the Court of the First Additional Subordinate Judge, Cuttack. The sole defendant in that suit (the State of Orissa) is the appellant in this appeal. The plaint initially sought recovery of Rs. 39,713.92 with pendente lite and future interest; the plaintiff's own calculations within the plaint indicate an outstanding balance of Rs. 33,759.92 (after accounting for payments claimed to have been made). The plaintiff, a carriage and transport contractor, alleges that at the request of the Executive Engineer, Public Health Division, Cuttack (acting for the State), he transported materials (cement, C.I. & G.I. pipes, A.C.C. sheets, etc.) between 21-5-1965 and 21-8-1965 and submitted bills totalling Rs. 87,659.83. The plaintiff alleges payments totalling Rs. 48,759.92 were made by the defendant and that further payments were withheld despite demands and a notice under Section 80, C.P.C.; after the notice the defendant made a part payment of Rs. 15,000. The suit claimed the unpaid balance plus interest.

In the written statement the defendant denied the plaint's allegations and described a contemporaneous administrative history involving tender processes, orders and correspondence among the Superintending Engineer (P.H. Circle, Bhubaneswar), the Chief Engineer, and the Executive Engineer, P.H. Division, Cuttack. The defence included assertions about invalidated tenders, temporary directions to adopt Drainage & Sewerage (D.&S.) Division rates for urgent work, subsequent administrative decisions affecting rate application and recoveries, a requirement that contractors execute agreements (which the plaintiff refused, citing sub judice proceedings), and claims that recoveries due from the plaintiff exceeded his outstanding bills. The defendant also pleaded limitation and that the suit was barred by Article 299 of the Constitution. At trial the Subordinate Judge found for the plaintiff, awarding payment at the D.&S. rates, compensation under Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act, and interest at 6% (pendente lite and future). This appeal challenges primarily the trial court's conclusion regarding entitlement to payment at the D.&S. rates.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to payment of his remaining bills at the Drainage & Sewerage (D.&S.) Division rates.
  2. Whether the defendant's claim for set-off or recoveries against the plaintiff's dues is sustainable (including whether any excess payment was made to the plaintiff).
  3. Whether the suit is barred or otherwise affected by Article 299 of the Constitution (as pleaded by the defendant).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant / State of Orissa) Arguments

  • Tenders for transportation were rejected by the Superintending Engineer (letter No. 9032 dated 30-9-1964) because essential items were omitted; fresh tenders were to be invited.
  • Until finalisation of the new tender, urgent carriage work was to be done at the lowest rates then approved for the Drainage & Sewerage Division, as per administrative directions.
  • The plaintiff performed work on verbal orders without written contract formation and filed an application to be paid at D.&S. rates; some bills were paid but 12 remained pending.
  • Administration issued later instructions (including a memo of 5-8-1965) banning payments to transport contractors pending enquiries, and the Chief Engineer issued subsequent decisions (letters dated 3-12-1965, 24-8-1967, 22-5-1968, and a Superintending Engineer letter dated 22-5-1969) affecting payment and recovery procedures.
  • As per the rates decided by the authority, the defendant contends the plaintiff's pending bills amount to Rs. 12,234.45 rather than the larger figure claimed; recoveries due from the plaintiff purportedly exceed his dues and earnest money (N.D.C.) has been held up.
  • The defendant also pleaded the suit was barred by limitation and by Article 299 of the Constitution.

Respondent's (Plaintiff / Contractor) Case

  • The plaintiff was a carriage and transport contractor who carried materials at the request of the Executive Engineer, P.H. Division, Cuttack, between 21-5-1965 and 21-8-1965, and the works were accepted and benefited the defendant.
  • The plaintiff submitted 19 bills totalling Rs. 87,659.83 and alleges payments of Rs. 48,759.92 were made, leaving the balance unpaid; after a Section 80, C.P.C. notice, a part payment of Rs. 15,000 was made, but no further payment followed.
  • The plaintiff contends he is entitled to payment at the D.&S. rates (those rates had been approved for urgent work by correspondence from the Superintending Engineer and the Chief Engineer) and seeks recovery of the unpaid balance with interest.
  • At trial the plaintiff relied on the correspondence and past practice showing payment at D.&S. rates (7 bills had already been paid at those rates) and invoked restitution/compensation principles under Section 70 of the Contract Act for works done and accepted.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on contemporaneous administrative correspondence and the effect of those communications on the parties' contractual relationship and rates payable.

Step-by-step account of the reasoning as expressed in the opinion:

  1. The court identified the principal issue on appeal as whether the plaintiff was entitled to have his unpaid bills paid at the Drainage & Sewerage (D.&S.) Division rates. It examined the documentary record (letters and memos identified as Exts. 38, D, E, 24, 40, C and others) relied upon at trial.
  2. The Superintending Engineer's letter of 30-9-1964 (Ext. 38) was read as directing that urgent carriage work should be executed at the lowest rates recently approved for the D.&S. Division until fresh tenders were finalised. The Chief Engineer's subsequent correspondence (Ext. D and Ext. C) and the Superintending Engineer's letter (Ext. E) corroborated that for urgent works payment was to be made at approved D.&S. rates.
  3. The court observed that the plaintiff actually executed the carriage work in the stated period (21-5-1965 to 21-8-1965) and that the defendant did not allege the work was unsatisfactory or that the Government did not benefit from it. Seven of the plaintiff's bills had been passed and paid at D.&S. rates, which the court treated as direct evidence that the parties operated on that basis for the relevant works.
  4. The Chief Engineer's later decision (reflected in some correspondence) limiting carriage jurisdiction to 30 miles and directing that carriage charges should be paid at declared or scheduled rates (whichever is less) was characterised by the court as an administrative deviation from the rate agreed to between the parties for the carriage of those materials.
  5. The court applied the principle that once a party agrees to execute work at a particular rate and the work is executed to the satisfaction of the other party, the paying party cannot unilaterally vary the agreed terms to the prejudice of the performing party. On this basis the court held it was beyond the competency of the Chief Engineer to vary the agreed rate to the plaintiff's detriment after the work had been done under the agreement or implied agreement.
  6. Regarding the defendant's assertion of a right to set-off or recovery exceeding the plaintiff's dues, the court noted there was no material on record showing any excess payment to the plaintiff when calculations were made at the D.&S. rates; the defendant's set-off claim was therefore rejected as baseless.
  7. The trial court's finding that the plaintiff fulfilled the conditions contemplated under Article 299 (despite lack of a formal executed deed of contract) was not disturbed: correspondence between parties showed the requisite conditions were fulfilled and the suit was maintainable. The court also upheld the award of reasonable compensation under Section 70 of the Contract Act.
  8. The appellate court further noted that the counsel for the appellant did not press other points from the memorandum of appeal, and concluded that the trial court's findings and decree should be confirmed in favour of the plaintiff.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The appeal is dismissed. The appellate court affirmed the trial court's decree that the plaintiff is entitled to payment of his remaining bills at the Drainage & Sewerage Division rates, to reasonable compensation under Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act, and to interest at the rate of 6% per annum (from the date when the last payment was made until institution of the suit, and pendente lite and future interest at 6%).

Direct consequences and implications for the parties:

  • The State of Orissa (appellant) must permit payment of the plaintiff's unpaid bills calculated at the D.&S. rates as established by the extant correspondence and practice; the defendant's claim for set-off is rejected on the record.
  • The plaintiff is entitled to compensation under Section 70 of the Contract Act for works accepted and performed, and to interest as awarded by the trial court.
  • The court explicitly states there will be no order as to costs in the result.

Broader legal impact: The opinion does not discuss any broader precedential implications beyond the direct dispute between the parties. The decision confirms the trial court's application of established contract principles to prevent unilateral administrative variation of agreed rates after performance, but the opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal doctrine.


Judges: P.C. Misra, J. (authoring); G.B. Patnaik, J. agreed. Final disposition: Appeal dismissed.

Show all summary ...

P.C Misra, J.:— The sole defendant in Money Suit No. 340/6 of 1969/73 of the Court of the First, Additional Subordinate Judge, Cuttack, is the appellant in this appeal. This is a suit by the plaintiff for recovery of a sum of Rs. 39,713.92 with pendente lite and future interest from the defendant who is the State of Orissa.

2. The plaintiff's case in brief is that the plaintiff is a carriage and transport contractor and his business is to carry materials to different destinations. The plaintiff alleges that at the request of the Executive Engineer, Public Health Division, Cuttack, acting on behalf of the State of Orissa the plaintiff carried various materials, such as cement C.I & G.I pipes A.C.C sheets, to different places during the period from 21-5-1965 to 21-8-1965. The works executed by the plaintiff were duly accepted by the defendant who enjoyed the benefits thereof. The plaintiff submitted bills for a total sum of Rs. 87,659.83 for the said works. From time to time the defendant paid a total sum of Rs. 48,759.92 towards the said bills. The plaintiff's case is that the balance amount out of the said bills had not been paid by the defendant in spite of repeated demands for which the plaintiff served a notice under S. 80, C.P.C on the defendant who on receipt of the same made a part payment of Rs. 15,000/- and did not make any further payment thereafter. According to the plaintiff's calculation, a sum of Rs. 33,759.92 has remained outstanding against the defendant for the recovery of which the suit has been filed along with the interest thereof.

3. The defendant denies all the plaint allegations made in the plaint and contends that during the year 1964-1965 tenders for transportation of materials were invited and forwarded to the Superintending Engineer for his decision. On scrutiny it was found that certain essential items were not included in the tender. Therefore, the Superintending Engineer, P.H Circle, Bhubaneswar, in his letter No. 9032 Dt. 30-9-1964 rejected the tenders and asked the Cuttack P.H Division to invite fresh tenders for the work. The Superintending Engineer in the aforesaid letter also ordered that for urgent cases of carriage the lowest rates for the carriage tender decided in respect of Drainage and Sewerage Division should be adopted and the lowest tenderer or any other contractor might to asked to execute the work till the tenders were finalised for the Division. Thereafter the next tender was invited on 16-6-1965 and a decision was taken on 23-8-1965 by the Superintending Engineer in his letter No. 10/274 dt. 23-8-1965. The plaintiff executed the work of transportation of materials during the period from 21-5-1965 to 21-8-1965 on the verbal orders of the officers of the Division as no written order was issued at any level. On 31-5-1965 the plaintiff filed an application praying that he be paid at the rates accepted for the Drainage and Sewerage Division. For the works executed by the contractor, he was paid 7 bills and 12 of his bills were kept pending for payment. In the meanwhile the Superintending Engineer in memo. No. 244 dt. 5-8-1965 issued an order to ban payment to transport contractors and called for detailed informations on the tenders invited from March, 1962 onwards. Accordingly, detailed informations were furnished to the Superintending Engineer, P.H Circle, Bhubaneswar. The Superintending Engineer referred the matter to the Chief Engineer who in his letters No. 471 dt. 3-12-1965 and No. 628 dt. 24-8-1967 gave decision in the matter. Subsequently, on a reference for clarification, the Chief Engineer in his letter No. 431 dt. 22-5-1968 gave the decision regarding the payment of the bills. Further clarifications on several points were sought for and the latest decision of the Superintending Engineer was received vide letter No. 217 dt. 22-5-1969. According to the said decision, the contractors were to execute agreements for final disposal of their cases and recoveries were to be made from them from their pending bills. The plaintiff was asked to execute the agreement but he refused to do so on the plea that the matter was sub judice. As per the rates decided by the authority, the claim of the plaintiff for his pending bills comes to Rs. 12,234.45 instead of Rs. 48,759.92 as claimed by him. The defendant has appended a statement of the total recovery made from the contractor and has stated that it is not possible to make any further payment to the plaintiff as the recovery to be made from him is much more than his dues. It has also been stated that since the outstanding bills of the plaintiff are insufficient to meet the recovery, his earnest money deposited in the shape of N.D.C has also been held up. The defendant has also pleaded that the suit is barred by limitation and is hit by the provisions of Art. 299 of the Constitution. The defendant ultimately prays for dismissal of the suit.

4. The learned Subordinate Judge on consideration of the evidence laid before him has come to the conclusion that the decision of the Chief Engineer referred to in the written statement is obviously a deviation from the terms of the contract agreed upon by the parties and that the plaintiff is entitled to be paid at the rates as decided by the Drainage and Sewerage Division as per the letter in Ext. 38. The learned trial Judge has further held that there is no material on record to show that any excess payment has been made to the plaintiff calculated at the Drainage and Sewerage rates and for that reason, the defendant is not entitled to reopen the bills already paid. As regards the maintainability of the suit due to the bar under Art. 299 of the Constitution, it has been held that though formal deed of contract was not executed between the parties, the correspondence between them shows that the requisite conditions contemplated under Art. 299 of the Constitution have been fulfilled. Besides, the learned Subordinate Judge has held that the plaintiff is entitled to claim compensation for the works done under S. 70 of the Contract Act. Interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum from the date when the last payment was made till the institution of the suit was allowed and the suit has accordingly been decreed on contest with costs. Pendente lite and future interest has also been allowed at the rate of 6 per cent per annum.

5. The main question that has been urged in this appeal is as to whether the plaintiff is entitled to the payment of his bills at the Drainage and Sewerage rates. The learned trial Judge has held that the Superintending Engineer asked the Executive Engineer, P.H Division, Cuttack, vide his letter No. 9032 Dt. 30-9-1964 (Ext. 38) to call for fresh tenders with a specific direction to get the urgent works done at the lowest rates then approved by the Executive Engineer, Drainage and Sewerage Division, till the tenders were finally decided. It is not disputed that the plaintiff executed the works as per the orders of the defendant between 21-5-1965 and 21-8-1965. It has not been alleged by the defendant that the works executed by the plaintiff were not satisfactory or that the Government has not been benefited by the said works. The plaintiff submitted 19 bills in all out of which 7 bills were passed and paid to the plaintiff. The remaining 12 bills, namely, Exts. 10, 12 to 15 and 17 to 23, remained unpaid. From the letter dt. 2/3-12-1965 (Ext. D) of the Chief Engineer, Public Health, Orissa, to the Superintending Engineer, P.H Circle, Bhubaneswar, it appears that the Drainage and Sewerage rates as approved by the Superintending Engineer on 30-9-1964 were to be adopted. From the letter dt. 15-12-1965 (Ext. E) of the Superintending Engineer, P.H Circle, Bhubaneswar, to the Executive Engineer, P.H Division, Cuttack, it appears that for urgent works, the payment was to be made at the approved D. & S. rates. The same would be the inference on a reference to Exts. 24 and 40, in view of the letter in Ext. 38 from the Superintending Engineer to the Executive Engineer, P.H.D, Cuttack, in which it has been clearly stated that in case of urgent works, the Executive Engineer, P.H.D, may contact the Executive Engineer, D. & S. Division and have the lowest rates recently approved for his Division and get the works executed at those rates. The Chief Engineer, P.H, Orissa, in his letter in Ext. C. as well as in Ext. 40 decided that as the jurisdiction of carriage of the materials of the D & S Division was limited to 30 miles, the carriage charges should be paid at the declared rates or scheduled rates whichever is less. As per this decision of the Chief Engineer, the other bills of the plaintiff were not passed at the D & S rates. Obviously the aforesaid decision of the Chief Engineer was a deviation from the terms of the contract agreed upon by the parties for the carriage of the materials. Once the plaintiff agreed to execute the work at a particular rate and got the work done to the satisfaction of the defendant, it is no more open for the defendant or any of its officer to vary the rate to the prejudice of the plaintiff. It is not disputed by the defendant that the plaintiff's bills were not submitted at the D & S rates. As a matter of fact, 7 of the bills of the plaintiff were passed and paid at the D & S rates which clearly indicates that the transportation work was to be carried out by the plaintiff at the D & S rates. After an agreement was arrived at between the parties for execution of a contract work, it is no more open for either of the parties to take a unilateral decision deviating the agreed terms to the prejudice of the other. In that view of the matter, it was beyond the competency of the Chief Engineer to issue orders to pass the bills of the plaintiff at a rate different from the one earlier agreed upon. Thus, in consideration of the evidence on record we confirm the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge that the plaintiff is entitled to get the payment of his remaining bills at the D & S rates.

6. Nothing has been placed before this Court to show that any excess payment has been made to the plaintiff calculating his dues at the D & S rates. The claim of the defendant for a set-off is, therefore, without any basis and is liable to be rejected.

7. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant did not press any of the other point: taken in the memorandum of appeal. The plaintiff is entitled to reasonable compensation under S. 70 of the Contract Act and the rates approved under Exts. D, E and 24 are reasonable.

8. In the result, we do not find any merit in this appeal and accordingly the same is dismissed. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.

G.B Patnaik, J.:— I agree.

Appeal dismissed.