Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Achyutananda Behera v. State Of Orissa And Others

Orissa High Court
Feb 20, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, described as a village agricultural worker (originally appointed as a village level worker in December 1964), challenged by way of an application under Article 226 of the Constitution his transfer from Bahanaga in the district of Balasore to Jeypore in the district of Koraput. The petitioner’s employment history in the record: initial posting in Sambalpur (December 1964), transfer to Balasore (December 1968), posting to Ganjam (April 1976), transfer to Bahanaga in Balasore (July 1983), and finally a transfer order dated 12 April 1984 (annexure 3) effecting his removal to Jeypore on “administrative grounds” issued by the Additional Director of Agriculture and Food Preservation, Orissa.

The petitioner contended that the transfer was motivated and mala fide, alleging that the order was made at the behest of Sri Chintamani Jena, a Member of Parliament, and that the transfer to a place about 800 kilometres away was not due to exigencies of public service but resulted from the prodding of Sri Jena. In the return, the opposite parties acknowledged that the transfer followed representations by Sri Jena, who forwarded villagers’ complaints and requested that the petitioner be transferred outside his home district.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transfer order was mala fide or a colourable exercise of power because it was made at the behest of an external political actor (Sri Chintamani Jena) rather than on the administrator’s independent satisfaction of administrative exigency.
  2. Whether an administrator’s transfer order becomes vulnerable to challenge if the administrator abdicates his independent decision-making and acts solely on the insistence of a legislator or third party without making inquiries.
  3. Whether the transfer, effected to a place about 800 kms away and described as done on “administrative grounds,” could be sustained in the absence of evidence that the administrator applied his mind and ascertained the truth of the complaints.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The transfer from Bahanaga to Jeypore was motivated and mala fide.
  • The transfer was effected at the behest of Sri Chintamani Jena, Member of Parliament, rather than arising from any exigency of public service.
  • The distance of the transfer (about 800 kms) and the circumstances indicate the move was punitive and politically motivated.

Opposite Parties' / Respondents' Contentions

  • The return stated the transfer was made at the instance of Sri Chintamani Jena, who had received complaints from villagers of Gundurimara; the authorities produced the letters and the villagers’ complaint as annexures.
  • The opposite parties took a categorical stand that the transfer followed the suggestion of the Member of Parliament based on villagers’ complaints.

Additional Government Advocate

  • It was contended that the transfer order (annexure 3) was innocuous in nature because it did not state a reason; therefore, it could not be characterized as mala fide or punitive.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court set out general principles governing transfers of public servants and then applied those principles to the facts before it:

  1. General legal principles articulated by the court:
    • An order of transfer is not normally assailable unless it is infected by mala fides or oblique motives; typically the administrator is best placed to judge the exigencies of public service and the interests of administration.
    • The competent transfer authority’s jurisdiction is broad and “indisputable” unless restricted by rules or instructions.
    • The burden of proving mala fides rests heavily upon the person who alleges it; allegations of mala fides are frequently asserted but not proved, and proof may require positive evidence though in some circumstances surrounding facts may lead irresistibly to an inference of mala fide.
    • If the administrator abdicates his functions and acts solely at the behest of an outside or extra-legal agency (e.g., a legislator), the transfer may be a colourable exercise of power and subject to challenge as mala fide.
  2. Application of those principles to the facts:
    • The official return disclosed that Sri Chintamani Jena had written two letters (dated 7 March 1984 and 23 March 1984) forwarding villagers’ petitions and requesting transfer of the petitioner to a distant place so that he could not “indulge in village politics.” The letters and the villagers’ complaint were placed on record by the respondents.
    • The court observed that Sri Jena’s letters did not show he made any personal inquiry to verify the truth of the allegations; he acted on the complaints of villagers and requested the petitioner’s transfer.
    • The court emphasized that when allegations are made against an employee, it is “desirable, nay imperative” that the administrator himself ascertain the truth and act only upon his own satisfaction that circumstances warrant a transfer.
    • The court found that in this case the administrator did not apply his mind or make any effort to ascertain the truth; instead, the administrator acted “on the prodding of the legislator” and thereby abdicated his independent exercise of jurisdiction.
    • Because the transfer was effected to a distant place (about 800 kms away) upon the request of the legislator and without independent administrative inquiry, the court inferred mala fides in the transfer and held the transfer order vulnerable to challenge as a colourable exercise of power.
  3. Relief-focused reasoning:
    • The court quashed the transfer order as mala fide but expressly clarified that the quashing did not prevent the authorities from taking appropriate action if they independently concluded that the petitioner’s continuance at Bahanaga was not in the public interest or the interest of administration.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ application was allowed and the transfer order of the petitioner from Bahanaga to Jeypore (annexure 3) was quashed on the ground that the administrator abdicated his independent decision-making and acted at the behest of a legislator, rendering the transfer mala fide and a colourable exercise of power.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that the challenged transfer order was set aside and the petitioner’s challenge succeeded; there was no order as to costs.
  • The court made clear that the authorities retain the power to revisit the matter and take such action as they may consider proper if they, on independent satisfaction, find the petitioner’s continuance at the earlier posting to be against public interest or administration. In other words, the quashing was not an absolute bar to a legitimately motivated transfer founded on independent administrative inquiry.
  • The opinion contains a warning against politicisation of administration and interference by elected representatives in administrative decisions such as transfers, but it does not purport to lay down a novel legal precedent beyond the application of established principles concerning mala fide transfers and abdication of administrative function.

Source: Opinion authored by Patnaik, J., with Behera, J. concurring, as provided in the supplied text.

Show all summary ...

Patnaik, J.:— The petitioner, a village agricultural worker, has assailed in this application under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India his transfer from Bahanaga in the district of Balasore to Jeypore in the district of Koraput.

2. The petitioner was appointed as a village level worker (redesignated as village agricultural worker) in December 1964, and was posted in the district of Sambalpur. In December 1968, he was transferred to Balasore. In April 1976, he was posted in the district of Ganjam. In July 1983, he was transferred to Bahanaga in the district of Balasore. By order, dated 12 April, 1984 (annexure 3), he was transferred to Jeypore by the Additional Director of Agriculture and Food Preservation, Orissa, on administrative grounds.

3. The petitioner has assailed the transfer as motivated and mala fide. He has made a grievance that the order of transfer has been made at the behest of Sri Chintamani Jenat a Member of the Parliament. He has asserted that his transfer to Jeypore, a place 800 kms. away from Bahanaga, has not been in the exigency of public service but at the prodding of Sri Jena.

4. In the return submitted by the opposite parties, it is stated that the transfer was made at the instance of Sri Chintamani Jena to whom allegations had been made against the petitioner by some residents of Gundurimara village in the district of Balasore. The opposite parties have annexed the letters of Sri Jena addressed to the Director of Agriculture, Orissa, as per annexures A and B. The complaint made by the villagers to Sri Jena is annexed to annexure 1. They have taken a categorical stand that the transfer was on the suggestion of the member of Parliament on the complaint made to him by villagers.

5. An order of transfer unless infected by mala fides or oblique motives is not assailable. The administrator is the best judge of the exigencies of public service, the interests of administration. Unless fettered by rules or instructions, the jurisdiction of the authority competent to transfer is indisputable. But where the exercise is for collateral purpose or with oblique motives, it is a colourable exercise of power and is mala fide. The burden of establishing a mala fide transfer like any allegation of mala fide is heavy on the person who alleges it. Allegations of mala fide are often made than proved. Mala fides may be established by positive evidence; often an uphill task. Circumstances may, however, irresistibly lead to an inference of mala fide. Where the administrator by abdicating his functions acts solely at the behest of an outside or extra-legal agency or authority, the order of transfer would be open to challenge as colourable exercise of power, as mala fide. A transfer would be vulnerable if it is made on political considerations but not on administrative grounds or exigency of public service.

6. It is contended by the learned Additional Government Advocate that the order of transfer as per annexure 3 is innocuous in nature. It does not indicate the reason. Hence, it cannot be characterised as mala fide or punitive.

7. The return submitted by the opposite parties furnishes the reason; the insistence of Sri Jena for the transfer is indicated as the basis. Sri Jena wrote two letters to the Director of Agriculture, Orissa — one on 7 March, 1984 and the other on 23 March, 1984. The first letter is to the following effect:

“This is regarding the unsocial activities and involvement in village politics of one Sri Achyutananda Behera, V.A.W, in Basta Block of Balasore district. The enclosed petition of the villagers of Gundurimara village where Sri Behera is a permanent resident, has vividly described the misdeeds and anti-people activities of Sri Behera, which I should not repeat in my letter, to consume your precious time, only except to request you, to kindly pay your personal attention to this matter, so that Sri Behera may be transferred to a distant block, which will debar him to be involved in village politics and creating groupism in the village, which will ultimately harm the progress and development of the village, as this was a very peaceful village having full unity among the villagers, from the time immemorial.

Soliciting your kind and favourable action in the matter, I remain. With my personal regards.”

The second letter is as follows:

“Enclosing herewith a petition mentioning serious allegations against Sri Achyutananda Behera, V.A.W, Bahanaga Block of Balasore district, I am to state that I wrote a D.O letter on this issue to your predecessor after receiving such petition by the villagers, to transfer this V.A.W, considering his illegal and unlawful activities but of no avail. However, the villagers of Gundurimara village where Sri Behera is a permanent resident, have again brought similar allegations against him, which can be ascertained from the enclosed petition sent herewith, for your kind perusal. It is, revealed from the petition that Sri Behera though serving as a V.A.W in Sathi G.P under Bahanaga Block which is situated about 60 to 70 kms. from his native village Gundurimara under Basta Block of the same Balasore district. But it is very surprising that how this Government servant is allowed to come to his village 3 to 4 days in every week leaving his headquarters with or without headquarters leaving permission, where he is indulging in group politics and other unsocial activities.

However, being a Government servant, he is creating hindrance in the village unity and peaceful atmosphere which was there from the time immemorial, he should not be allowed to continue in his home district, Balasore, and if transferred to a distant place, he will not have the scope to come to his home so frequently, to create disturbances in his native village, which is hampering the developmental works in the village.

In considering the serious charges brought against the V.A.W, I would requset you to kindly pay your personal attention to this matter and please exercise your good offices, so that this V.A.W may be transferred outside his home district soon, so that he may not be able to indulge in village politics which is creating disturbances on the peaceful atmosphere in the village as well as co-existence, for which act of your kindness and sympathy, the villagers shall remain ever grateful to you.

Soliciting a very early favourable orders from your end, I remain. With thanks.”

[Emphasis supplied.]

8. Allegations are sometimes made maliciously or recklessly. Sometimes they are founded on baseless gossip. With the inroad of politics into various strata of society, it is not seldom that allegations are politically motivated. Therefore, when allegations are levelled against an employee, it is desirable, nay imperative, that the administrator should himself ascertain the truth and act on his own satisfaction that the circumstances warrant a transfer.

9. Any citizen can plead before an administrator for redress of his personal grievances or the grievances of the public at large, for pushing through the various schemes and projects, for social welfare programmes. Who can better serve as a spokesman than a legislator, an elected representative of the people? He is not only a law maker but a spokesman of the people inside the Legislature and outside it. He can plead, canvass and claim for the people and in the public interest. But it should not be lost sight of that there exists clear distinction between pleading, canvassing and claiming on the one hand and interference on the other. The respective jurisdictions of the legislator and the administrator are well defined. It is not permissible for one to cross the boundary and trespass into the jurisdiction of the other. Much of the bane of the present administration is due to the breach of the rule; due to politicisation of administration, interference of politicians in matters of transfer, investigation and arrest of offenders, etc.

10. Coming to the facts on hand: Certain complaints were received by Sri Jena. His letters do not reveal that he made any enquiry himself to ascertain the truth. Nevertheless he acted on the complaints made to him by villagers. It could be that the allegations were untrue, politically motivated or malicious. It could be that the petitioner was an impediment to the unsocial activities of some villagers. He might have raised his voice of protest against their unholy combination. It, could be that he belonged to a different political persuasion and hence his presence in the locality was inconvenient for them. Many hypothetical situations can be thought of. It, therefore, behoved the administrator to bring to bear his independent mind on the facts and circumstances of the case. That would have been fair play in action. It the administrator was satisfied that the petitioner had indulged in undesirable activities or was negligent in discharge of his functions or that his presence at the station was detrimental to the interests of the administration and was not in public interest, he hid undoubted jurisdiction to shift the petitioner. Here, the administrator did not apply his mind at all. No endeavour was made to ascertain the truth. He acted on the prodding of the legislator who had in turn acted on the complaint of some villagers. There was, therefore, absence of exercise of jurisdiction by way of abdication thereof. He even acted on the dotted lines. The petitioner was shifted to Jeypore in Koraput District (a distant place as suggested by Sri Jena) about 800 kms. away. The transfer was, therefore, mala fide and we quash the same. We make it clear that our quashing of the order of transfer aforesaid, does not prevent the authorities from taking such action as they consider proper if they are satisfied that the continuance of the petitioner at Bahanaga is not in public interest or in the interest of administration.

11. With the aforesaid observations, we allow the writ application. There would be no order for costs.

12. Behera, J.:— I agree.