- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Prafulla Mohanty v. Ashok Kumar Das Opp. Party.
Judgment Summary — B.N. Misra, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure challenges an order of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cuttack (dated 28-2-1983) taking cognizance under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code and issuing summons in I.C.C. No. 54 of 1983.
The opposite party (complainant) alleged that he had delivered twenty-five English-language folk-tales to the petitioner (an old college friend) around 1974 because the petitioner represented that he had contacts with publishers in England who would publish the tales and thereby earn royalties for the complainant. The complainant later discovered a 1975 English-published book titled "Indian Village Tales" in the petitioner's name, containing thirteen of the stories listed in the complaint. The complaint alleged offences under Section 420 IPC and also mentioned Sections 406 and 120-B IPC and Section 63 of the Copyright Act. A photocopy of an alleged letter dated 2-10-1974 from the petitioner was filed with the complaint. The Magistrate recorded the complainant's initial deposition on 28-2-1983 and took cognizance under Section 420 IPC.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the allegations and materials before the Magistrate disclosed a prima facie case under Section 420, IPC such that the Magistrate's order taking cognizance and issuing process should stand;
- Whether, at the stage of taking cognizance, the High Court should interfere with the Magistrate's exercise of discretion where the Magistrate is prima facie satisfied (i.e., scope of High Court interference in revisional jurisdiction in such matters);
- Whether the facts as alleged, even if accepted, disclose criminal cheating (requiring proof of dishonest intention at the time of inducement) or are matters properly cognizable by a civil court (i.e., whether the dispute is essentially civil).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the allegations made by the opposite party, taken as a whole, do not disclose a prima facie case under Section 420 IPC.
- Consequently, the order of the learned Magistrate taking cognizance under Section 420 should be quashed.
Opposite Party's Arguments
- Learned counsel for the opposite party submitted that at the stage of taking cognizance the Magistrate is not required to enter into a detailed discussion on the merits of the case; the Magistrate need only be prima facie satisfied.
- Where cognizance is based on prima facie satisfaction of the Magistrate, there is no justification for interference by the High Court in revisional jurisdiction.
- The opposite party relied on the decision in Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Koujalagi & Others (1976 3 SCC 736) to support that submission.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Koujalagi & Others (1976 3 SCC 736) | At the stage of issuing process the Magistrate is to be prima facie satisfied from the complaint or evidence; he should not enter into detailed merits. The High Court's revisional jurisdiction is limited. Illustrative grounds where Magistrate's order issuing process can be quashed include: (1) no case on face of complaint; (2) allegations inherently improbable; (3) discretion capricious/arbitrary; (4) fundamental legal defects. | The Court relied on these principles as the governing test for interference with the Magistrate's order, then examined whether any of the illustrative grounds applied on the materials before it. |
| The State of Kerala v. A Pareed Pillai (1972 3 SCC 661) | To convict for cheating it must be shown that the dishonest intention existed at the time the representation or promise was made; subsequent non-fulfillment alone is insufficient to infer dishonest intention. | The Court applied this principle to hold that the materials did not show dishonest intention at the time of inducement and therefore did not make out an offence of cheating. |
| Lord Match Industries v. M.S. Selvasekaran (55 1983 C.L.T. 24) | Distinction between breach of contract and cheating depends on the accused's intention at the time of inducement; a representation about a future event must be shown to have been known false when made. Mere breach of contract does not give rise to criminal prosecution. | The Court relied on this exposition to reinforce that, absent evidence of dishonest intention when the promise was made, the dispute remains a civil matter and cannot be the basis for a criminal prosecution for cheating. |
| S.B. Goenka v. Rajendra Prasad Agarwalla (1982 Cri L J. 1228) | Not every breach of contract constitutes cheating; dishonest intention cannot be inferred simply from non-fulfillment of a promise. | The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that a criminal charge of cheating requires more than proof of failure to perform a promise and that the record lacked material to satisfy the Magistrate of dishonest intention. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court applied the legal standards from the cited authorities to the facts and materials before the Magistrate. The reasoning proceeded in these steps:
- Examination of the complaint allegations: The complaint alleged that the petitioner induced the opposite party by promising publication in England and royalties as the author, in reliance on which the opposite party delivered twenty-five stories; thirteen were subsequently published in 1975 under the petitioner's name.
- Comparison with the opposite party's initial deposition: In his initial deposition the opposite party changed his account of the inducement, stating that the petitioner had agreed to undertake publication on a co-authorship basis and that sale proceeds were to be divided equally. The court found this version inconsistent with the complaint allegation of sole authorship with royalties to the opposite party.
- Evaluation of documentary material: The alleged letter dated 2-10-1974, filed as a photocopy, did not corroborate the complainant's allegation of inducement or deception.
- Application of the law on cheating: Relying on precedent, the court emphasized that to constitute cheating under Section 420 IPC, dishonest intention must be shown to exist at the time of making the representation/promissory inducement; mere subsequent non-fulfilment or breach of a promise generally constitutes a civil dispute, not a criminal offence.
- Conclusion on prima facie case: Given the contradictory versions (complaint vs. deposition), lack of corroboration in the letter, and absence of material showing dishonest intention at the relevant time, the court was not satisfied that a prima facie case under Section 420 IPC had been made out.
- Abuse of process finding: Because the record did not support a prima facie criminal offence, continuation of criminal proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of the court.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is allowed and the criminal proceeding in I.C.C. No. 54 of 1983 (file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cuttack) is quashed.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The specific criminal proceedings against the petitioner in I.C.C. No. 54 of 1983 were quashed and the petition was allowed.
- Scope of decision: The Court treated the dispute as one that, on the materials before it, was essentially civil in nature (a breach or dispute over authorship/contract) rather than a matter showing the requisite dishonest intention for criminal cheating under Section 420 IPC. The Court did not purport to lay down a broader new legal principle beyond applying existing authorities to these facts.
This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or law beyond the text of the judgment.
B.N Misra, J.:— This petition has been filed under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash the proceedings initiated against the petitioner in I.C.C No. 54 of 1983 in the court of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cuttack. On a complaint petition filed by the opposite party against the petitioner the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate by order dated 28-2-1983 took cognizance under Section 420, I.P.C and summons have been issued against the petitioner. It is this order of the learned Magistrate which is under challenge in this case.
2. The case of the opposite party (complainant) is that the petitioner was an old college friend of his. The opposite party had written a number of traditional folk-tales in English language and the petitioner had suggested to the opposite party that he had contact with reputed publishers in England with whom he could make arrangements for publication of the folk-tales which would fetch good money to the opposite party towards royalty as the author.
3. The opposite party believed the representation of the petitioner and around the year 1974 delivered twenty-five stories written by him in English to the petitioner. A few months before filing the complaint petition, the opposite party came across a book named “Indian Village Tales” published in England in 1975 under the authorship of the petitioner and in that book thirteen stories described in the schedule to the complaint petition which had been given by the opposite party to the petitioner were published, without acknowledging the authorship of the opposite party. According to the opposite party, the petitioner deceived him and got the stories published under his own name as the author thereby committing an offence punishable under Section 420, I.P.C The opposite party has also alleged in the complaint petition that the petitioner had committed offences under Sections 406 and 120-B of the I.P.C and under Section 63 of the Copyright Act. Along with his complaint petition, the opposite party has filed a photo-stat copy of a letter dated 2-10-1974 alleged to have been written by the petitioner to the opposite party. The learned Magistrate recorded the initial deposition of the opposite party on 28-2-1983 and took cognizance under Section 420, I.P.C
4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has urged that the allegations of the opposite party against the petitioner and his entire case before the learned Magistrate do not disclose a prima-facie case under Section 420, I.P.C and therefore the order of the learned Magistrate taking cognizance under the Said section must be quashed. Learnes counsel appearing for the opposite party has, on the other hand, submitted that at the stage of taking cognizance the learned Magistrate is not required to enter into a detailed discussion on the merits of the case and therefore when the cognizance is based on a prime-facie satis-faction of the learned Magistrate, there is no justification or scope for interference by this Court. In this context it would be useful to refer to Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Koujalagi & Others . 1976 3 SCC 736, wherein the Supreme Court observed :—
“It is well settled by a long catena of decisions of this Court that at the stage of issuing process the Magistrate is mainly concerned with the allegations made in the complaint or the evidence led in support of the same and he is only to be prima facie satisfied whether there are sufficient grounds for proceedings against the accused. It is not the province of the Magistrate to enter into a detailed discussion of the merits or de-merits of the case nor can the High Court go into this matter in its revisional jurisdiction which is very limited one.
5. It was also observed:—
“It is true that in coming to a decision as to whether a process should be issued the Magistrate can take into consideration, inherent improbabilities appearing on the face of the complaint or in the evidence led by the complainant in support of the allegations but there appears to be a very thin line of demarcation between a ptobability of conviction of the accused and established of a prima facie case against him. The Magistrate has been given an undoubted discretion in the matter and the discretion has to be judicially exer-cised by him. Once the Magistrate has exercised his discretion it is not for the High Court, or even this Court, to substitute its own discretion for that of the Magistrate or to examine the case on merits with a view to find out whether or not the allegations in the complaint, if proved, would ultimately end in conviction of the accused. These considerations, in our opinion, are totally foreign to the scope and ambit of an inquiry under section 202 of the Code of Criminal Procedure which culminate into an order under Section 204 of the Code. Thus it may be safely held that in the following cases an order of the Magistrate issuing process against the accused can be quashed or set aside:
(1) where the allegations made in the complaint or the statement of the witnesses recorded in support of the same taken at their face value make out absolutely no case against the accused or the complaint does not disclose the essential ingredients of an offence which is alleged against the accused;
(2) where the allegations made in the complaint are potently absurd and inherently improbable so that no prudent person can ever reach a conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused;
(3) where the discretion exercised by the Magistrate in issuing process is capricious and arbitrary having been based either on no evidence or on materials which are wholly irrelevant or inadmissible; and
(4) where the complaint suffers from fundamental legal defects, such as, want of sanction, or absence of a complaint by legally competent authority and the like.
6. The cases mentioned by us are purely illustrative and provide sufficient guidelines to indicate contingencies where the High Court can quash proceedings.” Bearing in mind the principles of law enunciated in the aforesaid decision, the facts of the present case may now be scrutinised. According to the averments made in paragraphs 3 to 7 of the complaint petition the alleged inducement of the petitioner is stated to be that the petitioner would publish in England the stories written by the opposite party who would stand to gain good money towards royalty as the author. The further allegation is that on the basis of the aforesaid inducement the opposite party had delivered twenty-five stories to the petitioner and the petitioner got thirteen of those published in 1975 under his own authorship with the dishonest intention of cheating the opposite party. In the complaint petition there is no mention of any suggestion by the petitioner for co-authorship or division of profits. However, in his initial deposition the opposite party changed his version as regards the inducement and stated that the petitioner had agreed to undertake the publication on co-authorship basis and that the sale proceeds were to be divided equally. This statement of the opposite party renders his allega-tion as to inducement contained in the complaint petition untrue. The two versions taken at their face value are inconsistent and contradictory and it is impossible to say which one is true. The contents of the alleged letter of the petitioner to the opposite party dated 2-10-1974 do not at all corroborate the allegations of inducement or deception. The complaint petition, the initial deposition and the letter do not show that the petitioner had any dishonest intention at the time he offered the inducement around the year 1974 even assuming that he had made such an inducement and subsequently failed to fulfil his promise. It was pointed out in The State of Kerala v. A Pareed Pillai . 1972 3 SCC 661, that to hold a person guilty of the offence of cheating, it had to be shown that his intention was dishonest at the time of making the promise and that such a dishonest intention could not be inferred from the mere fact that he could not subsequently fulfil the promise. In Lord Match Industries v. M.S Selvasekaran . 55 1983 C.L.T 24., it was held:—
“The distinction between mere breach of contract and cheating would depend upon the intention of the accused at the time of the alleged inducement which may be judged by his subsequent act, but of which the subsequent act is not the sole criterion. Mere breach of a contract cannot give rise to a criminal prosecution. Where a charge of cheating rests upon a representation, which is impugned as false and which relates not to an existing fact but to a future event, it has to be shown that the representation was false to the knowledge of the accused at the time when it was made. It is but little to the purpose to show that in fact, the representation has turned out to be untrue. An essential ingredient of the offence of cheating is the damage or harm caused or likely to be caused to the victim in body, mind, reputation, property. Generally speaking a criminal offence consists of an act done by the accused with a specific criminal intent or state of mind consti tuting mens rea. It has been laid down by this Court in S.B S.B Goenka… v. Rajendra Prasad Agarwalla…Opposite Party. (1982 Cri L J. 1228), that every breach of contract does not constitute an act of cheating. Dishonest intention cannot be inferred from the mere fact that the accused person did not subsequently fulfil the promise. In the absence of materials for the satisfaction of the Magis trate that the accused person had any dishonest intention at the time the alleged promise or inducement was made, an offence of cheating cannot be said to have been established. In such cases, the dispute would be purely of a civil nature and the proceeding initiated in the criminal court would be an abuse of the process of the Court.”
With respect, I agree with the aforesaid observations. Even assuming that the allegations of the opposite party are true, the dispute would be one for cognizance by the civil court, not the criminal court. On perusal of the materials on record, I am not satisfied that a prima-facie case under Section 420, I.P.C has been made out. In these circumstances, initiation and continuance of the proceedings in the criminal court would be an abuse of the process of Court.
7. In the result, this petition is allowed and the criminal proceeding against the petitioner in I.C.C No. 54 of 1983 in the file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cuttack is quashed.
8. Petition allowed.
Alert