- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Alekh Pradhan And Others v. Bhramar Pal And Another Opposite Parties.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs filed a petition on 2-9-77 praying for deputing a survey-knowing Commissioner to measure the disputed area in a suit that was part-heard and adjourned to 6-9-77. This petition was served on the defendants but was rejected by the court on 6-9-77, with the court stating that the plaintiffs were at liberty to appoint a private Commissioner and submit his report within two days. The plaintiffs then engaged a pleader-surveyor who measured the disputed area and submitted his report on 12-9-77. Subsequently, on 15-9-77, the plaintiffs filed a petition to examine the pleader-surveyor as a witness, which the court allowed by the impugned order. The petitioners challenged this order through a Civil Revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court had the legal competence and jurisdiction to allow the plaintiffs to examine a private pleader-surveyor as a witness after rejecting their petition to appoint a court surveyor.
- Whether the court acted illegally or improperly by permitting examination of the pleader-surveyor at the stage of the suit after the prayer for a court-appointed surveyor was rejected and the hearing was considered closed.
- Whether the Civil Revision petition against the impugned order was maintainable under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The court, having rejected the plaintiffs' prayer for appointing a survey-knowing Commissioner on 6-9-77, could not legally allow the plaintiffs to examine a private pleader-surveyor as a witness at a later stage.
- The court acted illegally by suggesting or directing the plaintiffs to engage a private Commissioner after rejecting the earlier petition for a court-appointed surveyor.
- The hearing of the suit was closed on 6-9-77, thus the court lacked jurisdiction to permit examination of any witness thereafter.
Respondent's Arguments (as represented by Mr. Das)
- The court never directed or asked the plaintiffs to appoint a private Commissioner; it only observed that plaintiffs were at liberty to do so.
- The court had jurisdiction under sub-rule (4) of Rule 2 of Order XVIII of the CPC to permit examination of any witness at any stage for reasons to be recorded.
- The order rejecting the appointment of a court surveyor was motivated by the desire to expedite disposal of the suit and did not close the hearing entirely.
- The plaintiffs submitted the pleader-surveyor's report within the time allowed, and the court legitimately allowed examination of that witness thereafter.
- The Civil Revision petition was not maintainable as the impugned order did not decide any right or obligation of the parties in the suit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sub-rule (4) of Rule 2 of Order XVIII of the Code of Civil Procedure | Empowers the court to direct or permit any party to examine any witness at any stage, for reasons to be recorded. | The court relied on this provision to hold that it had jurisdiction to allow the plaintiffs to examine the pleader-surveyor as a witness even after rejecting the appointment of a court surveyor and after the hearing was adjourned. |
| Baldevdas Shivlal v. Filmistan Distributors, (1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406 | Clarifies that not every order in a suit amounts to a 'case decided' under Section 115 CPC; only orders adjudicating rights or obligations qualify. | The court used this precedent to determine that the impugned order did not decide any right or obligation of the parties and thus the Civil Revision petition was not maintainable on that ground. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the procedural history, noting that the plaintiffs' initial petition for a court-appointed surveyor was rejected to avoid delay in disposing of the suit, but the court permitted the plaintiffs to appoint a private Commissioner. The court emphasized the jurisdiction granted by sub-rule (4) of Rule 2 of Order XVIII of the CPC, allowing examination of any witness at any stage before judgment for reasons to be recorded. The hearing was not closed on 6-9-77 as the court allowed submission of the private surveyor's report and subsequently permitted examination of the pleader-surveyor. The court found no illegality or impropriety in the impugned order, concluding that it was within the court's discretion and jurisdiction to permit such examination. Additionally, the court noted that the impugned order did not decide any right or obligation of the parties, referencing the precedent in Baldevdas Shivlal v. Filmistan Distributors, thus rendering the Civil Revision petition on this ground untenable.
Holding and Implications
The Civil Revision petition challenging the impugned order is dismissed with costs.
The direct effect of this decision is that the impugned order permitting the plaintiffs to examine the pleader-surveyor as a witness stands affirmed. The court below retains jurisdiction to allow examination of witnesses at any stage prior to judgment, and the petitioners are entitled to challenge the surveyor's report and deposition during trial. No broader precedent was set, and the decision primarily confirms the discretionary power of the court under the relevant procedural rules.
1. The impugned order enables the plaintiffs, opposite parties in this case, to examine a pleader-surveyor as plaintiffs' witness whose survey report has already been filed in the court below. On 2-9-77 when the suit was part-heard and adjourned to 6-9-77 for examining witnesses, the plaintiffs filed a petition praying for deputing a survey-knowing Commissioner to measure the disputed area. A copy of that petition had been served on the defendants, the petitioners in this case. That petition could not be disposed of on that day and was taken up for consideration on 6-9-77. On 6-9-77 the court examined further witnesses for the plaintiffs, but rejected the said petition. While rejecting that petition it mentioned in the order sheet that the plaintiffs were at liberty to take out a private Commissioner for the above purpose and may submit his report in court within two days. The plaintiffs thereafter took a pleader-surveyor for the measurement of the disputed area, and his report was submitted on 12-9-77 within the extended period allowed by the court. On 15-9-77 the plaintiffs filed a petition to enable them to examine that survey-knowing advocate in that suit. The court by the impugned order has allowed the said petition.
2. Mr. Das, the learned counsel for the petitioners contends that the court, after rejecting the prayer of the plaintiffs on 6-9-77 for directing a survey-knowing Commissioner to measure the disputed area, could not have allowed the plaintiffs to examine the private pleader-surveyor at this stage of the suit. Mr. Das further states that the court acted illegally in asking the plaintiffs to take a private Commissioner to measure the disputed area after rejecting the plaintiffs' previous application dated 2-9-77 for appointing a survey-knowing Commissioner for that work. It is incorrect to state that the court below at any point of time asked the plaintiffs to take a private Commissioner in this case. While rejecting the aforesaid petition dated 2-9-77 of the plaintiffs for appointment of a survey-knowing Commissioner by the court, the court merely observed that the plaintiffs were at liberty to take a private Commissioner for that purpose. Therefore, the court never asked or gave any direction to the plaintiffs in this matter. After the pleader-surveyor did the measurement, his report was submitted in the court and after the submission of the said report the plaintiffs made a prayer to the court to allow the said pleader-surveyor to be examined as a witness on behalf of the plaintiffs. The court on a consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case as mentioned in the impugned order has allowed the said prayer. In this Civil Revision against the said order I have at first to see if the court was legally competent and had the jurisdiction to pass the said order or not.
3. Sub-rule (4) of R. 2 of O. XVIII in the amended Code of Civil Procedure is as follows:—
“Notwithstanding anything contained in this rule, the Court may, for reasons to be recorded, direct or permit any party to examine any witness at any stage.”
4. Previous to this, R. 2 of O. XVIII of the CPC as it stood amended by this Court was as follows:—
“Explanation:— Nothing in this rule shall affect the jurisdiction of the Court to direct any party to examine any witness at any stage, for reasons to be recorded by the court in writing.”
5. From the above provision it is quite evident that the court has the jurisdiction to direct or permit any party to examine any witness at any stage. So, the court was legally competent and acted within its jurisdiction to pass the impugned order.
6. Mr. Das contends that the court was not legally justified in allowing the plaintiffs to examine this witness after rejecting the plaintiffs' prayer to appoint a court surveyor for that work and after closing the hearing of the case on 6-9-77. It appears from the order sheet of the suit that the court did not entertain the plaintiffs' prayer to appoint a court surveyor for the job at that time as it considered that by doing so the disposal of the old suit would be very much delayed. While rejecting that prayer it merely expressed that the plaintiffs might get that work done by a private Commissioner if they so desired within only a very few days allowed by the Court. So whatever order on this matter was passed on 6-9-77 was, as I find, actuated by a desire to dispose of the old suit within a short time. So one cannot question the legality of the said order, nor does the order appear so patently improper as to require interference in revision on assessment of facts in a matter purely within the legal competence and discretion of the court.
7. Moreover, it is incorrect to say that on 6-9-77 the hearing of the suit was completely closed for all intents and purposes. The order of that date shows that the court enabled the plaintiffs to submit the private surveyor's report if they so desired, within the short time fixed by it. After the filing of the surveyor's report in court on 12-9-77, on the petition of the plaintiffs the impugned order was passed. As per sub-rule (4) of R. 2 of O. XVIII of the CPC quoted above, the court has the power and jurisdiction to direct or permit any party to examine any witness at any stage.
8. ‘At any stage’ of course would mean any stage previous to the delivery of the judgment in the case, whereafter the court loses seisin over the suit. So, as per the said provision, till the passing of the judgment in the matter a court has the power and jurisdiction to allow any witness to be examined in a case. In the impugned order, the court has stated the reasons which impelled it to allow the plaintiffs' petition to examine the private pleader-surveyor as a witness for the plaintiffs. The reasons stated in that connection do not appear to be patently incorrect, improper or illegal. Therefore, the court had the discretion and it acted within its jurisdiction to pass the impugned order allowing examination of the surveyor as a witness for the plaintiffs.
9. On the above considerations I do not see any compelling reason to quash the said order in this Civil Revision. It, of course, goes without saying that the petitioners in this revision must be given, if they so desire, an opportunity by the court below to meet and challenge the said report and the deposition of the surveyor if he is ultimately examined in the court below.
10. Mr. Pal at the outset contended that this Civil Revision was not maintainable as by the impugned order the court has not decided any right or obligation of the parties in controversy in this suit.
11. The expression ‘any case which has beendecided’ in Section 115 of the CPC has been explained in the Explanationattached to that section which is as follows:—
“Explanation:— In this section, the expression ‘any case which has been decided’ includes any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the course of a suit or other proceeding.”
12. In the decision reported in (1969) 2 SCC 201 : AIR 1970 SC 406 (Baldevdas Shivlal v. Filmistan Distributors) it has been held that every order of the court in course of a suit does not amount to ‘a case decided’. In this connection it has been said that (at p. 410):—
“A case may be said to be decided if the court adjudicates for the purpose of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy; every order in the suit cannot be regarded as a case decided within the meaning of Section 115 of the CPC”
13. By the impugned order, no right or obligation of the parties in controversy in the suit has been decided. That being so, the abovementioned contention of Mr. Pal appears to be well founded.
14. The Civil Revision is accordingly dismissed with costs.
15. Revision dismissed.
Alert