- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hatakishore Sahu v. Industrial Tribunal, Orissa, And Others
Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Hatakishore Sahu, was appointed by the management of the United Puri-Nimapara Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. as a junior supervisor on 10 May 1963, and was posted as assistant junior supervisor at Markandpur Service Co-operative Society on 18 August 1965. He was suspended on 14 August 1970 and served with a chargesheet on 17 August 1970; he submitted an explanation denying the charges on 26 August 1970. The bank passed an order of dismissal dated 21 October 1970 which it directed should operate retrospectively from 14 August 1970. No domestic enquiry was held by the bank prior to the dismissal.
The petitioner raised an industrial dispute by complaint dated 23 January 1971. After unsuccessful conciliation, the State referred the dispute to the Labour Court which registered it as Industrial Dispute Case No. 14 of 1972. The reference framed the question whether the removal of the petitioner effective from 14 August 1970 was legal and, if not, what relief was due.
The Labour Court heard evidence (management led evidence despite no domestic enquiry) and by award dated 11 March 1974 held that the termination was justified. The petitioner filed a writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution seeking to quash the Labour Court award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the employer's order of dismissal dated 21 October 1970 could validly be given retrospective effect from 14 August 1970.
- Whether, in the absence of a domestic enquiry, a termination—when subsequently held justified by the Tribunal—takes effect from the date of the employer's order or from the date of the Tribunal's award (i.e., whether the termination relates back or is effective only from the award date).
- What relief, if any, the employee is entitled to in terms of back wages given the timing of suspension, the dismissal order and the Tribunal's award.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Sri Nanda)
- The dismissal order dated 21 October 1970 could not lawfully be made retrospective to 14 August 1970; a dismissal must be effective from the date it is passed.
- Because no domestic enquiry was held, the dismissal order dated 21 October 1970 is without jurisdiction and, if the Tribunal could justify termination only after its award, the effective date of termination should be the Tribunal's award date (11 March 1974); accordingly, the petitioner should receive back-wages from 21 October 1970 until 11 March 1974.
Management / Labour Court Position (as reflected in the opinion)
- The management led independent evidence before the Labour Court to justify the termination despite having held no domestic enquiry, and the Labour Court found the termination justified in its award dated 11 March 1974.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Phulbari Tea Estate v. Workmen [A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 1111] | Supports the principle that where no domestic enquiry has been held or the enquiry is defective, the employer may adduce independent evidence before a Tribunal to justify termination. | The Court relied on this case as part of settled law permitting employers to justify dismissals before the Tribunal by independent evidence where no proper domestic enquiry was held. |
| P.H. Kalyani v. Air France, Calcutta [A.I.R. 1963 S.C. 1756] | Establishes limits of the Sasa Musa observation and distinguishes situations where management held no enquiry from those where a (possibly defective) inquiry was held; confirms that approval by the Tribunal can relate back when employer had reached a bona fide conclusion after inquiry. | The Court relied on the Constitution Bench's distinguishing of Sasa Musa to hold that where the employer had reached a conclusion (even after a defective inquiry) and the Tribunal finds dismissal justified, the Tribunal's approval relates back to the employer's dismissal date. |
| Motipur Sugar Factory (Private) Ltd. v. Workmen [A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1803] | Affirms that a defective enquiry stands on the same footing as no enquiry and that the Tribunal can itself examine the evidence and justify or set aside dismissal. | The Court used this decision to support the proposition that defective inquiry = no inquiry and that the Tribunal may independently assess evidence to decide whether dismissal was proper. |
| Sasa Musa Sugar Works (Private) Ltd. v. Shobrati Khan [A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 923] | Contains an observation that where the management held no enquiry and converted S.33 proceedings into the inquiry, the management would be bound to pay wages until a case for dismissal was made out in S.33 proceedings (i.e., dismissal effective from tribunal decision in that specific factual situation). | The Court considered and distinguished this observation: it applies where the employer neither dismissed the employee nor had come to the conclusion that a case for dismissal was made out. Therefore the Court held Sasa Musa's observation inapplicable to the present facts. |
| Management of Ranipur Colliery v. Bhuban Singh [A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 833] | Used in the reasoning in P.H. Kalyani to illustrate that where an employer held an inquiry and later applied for permission under S.33, approval would relate back to the date when the employer had reached the bona fide conclusion. | The Court referenced this line of authority (as discussed in P.H. Kalyani) to support the principle that Tribunal approval can relate back to the employer's dismissal date where the employer had come to a bona fide conclusion after inquiry. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court’s analysis proceeded in two main parts corresponding to the petitioner's contentions.
First, addressing the retrospective operation contention, the Court reiterated the settled principle that an order of dismissal is effective from the date it is passed and cannot be given retrospective effect. The Labour Court had stated that the dismissal dated 21 October 1970 would operate from 14 August 1970; the High Court held that that was an unlawful exercise of jurisdiction. Consequently the High Court modified the operative date: the order of dismissal would be operative from 21 October 1970 and the petitioner was entitled to arrears of wages from his suspension date (14 August 1970) up to 21 October 1970.
Second, and more elaborately, the Court examined the contention that, because no domestic enquiry was held, the dismissal could not be validly effective until the Labour Court's award (11 March 1974). The Court summarized settled law (citing the Supreme Court decisions) as follows:
- An employer cannot lawfully dismiss an employee without holding an enquiry in accordance with natural justice.
- Where a domestic enquiry exists the Tribunal must examine its propriety.
- Where there is no enquiry, or the enquiry is defective, the employer may justify dismissal before the Tribunal by adducing independent evidence, and the Tribunal may either approve or set aside the dismissal.
- A defective enquiry is, in practical terms, equivalent to no enquiry.
- When the Tribunal approves a dismissal that was previously ordered by the employer (whether there was a defective inquiry or none), that approval relates back to the date the employer made the order, provided the Tribunal finds the dismissal justified on the evidence.
- Only in the narrow situation where the employer had neither dismissed the employee nor reached a conclusion that dismissal was justified does the dismissal take effect only from the Tribunal's order.
The Court considered the Sasa Musa observation relied upon by the petitioner and explained that it applies only where the employer neither dismissed nor came to a conclusion that a case for dismissal was made out (i.e., where the Tribunal's proceedings essentially become the employer's enquiry). The Court noted that this observation had been distinguished by the Constitution Bench in P.H. Kalyani.
Applying these principles to the facts, the Court recorded that the Labour Court had held the employer's order of dismissal (21 October 1970) to be justified despite there having been no domestic enquiry. Because the Tribunal accepted the employer's order as justified, its approval necessarily related back to the employer's order date. Therefore the dismissal was effective from 21 October 1970, not from 11 March 1974.
The Court also noted limits to the High Court's writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227: the High Court cannot, in exercise of that jurisdiction, receive further evidence to re-justify an employer's termination which the Tribunal has already considered and upheld on independent evidence.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed in part: the Court issues certiorari quashing the Labour Court award (annexure 2) only to the extent that it stated the dismissal dated 21 October 1970 operated retrospectively from 14 August 1970.
Immediate consequences for the parties:
- The operative date of dismissal is fixed as 21 October 1970.
- The petitioner is entitled to back-wages for the period from 14 August 1970 (date of suspension) to 21 October 1970 (date dismissal is held effective).
- The remainder of the Labour Court award—specifically the part holding that the dismissal was justified—is not quashed and thus stands.
- The writ application is therefore allowed in part and dismissed in part, and there is no order as to costs.
Broader precedent or legal change: The Court based its decision on established Supreme Court authorities and expressly treated the issue as concluded by those authorities. The opinion does not purport to set any new principle of law beyond applying existing precedents to the facts before it.
S.K. Ray, J. concurred with the judgment.
G.K Misra, C.J:— Petitioner was appointed by the management of the United Puri-Nimapara Central Co-operative Bank, Ltd., Puri (opposite party 2), (hereinafter to be referred to as the bank), as a junior supervisor on 10 May 1963. He was posted as assistant junior supervisor at Markandpur Service Co-operative Society on 18 August 1965. He was suspended from duty on 14 August 1970. A chargesheet was served on him on 17 August 1970. He submitted his explanation denying the charges on 26 August 1970. He was dismissed from service by an order (annexure 1) on 21 October 1970, with a direction that the dismissal order would be effective retrospectively from 14 August 1970. The order of dismissal was passed without any enquiry being held by the bank. Petitioner raised an industrial dispute with regard to his illegal termination of service by filing a complaint on 23 January 1971, before the District Labour Officer-cum-Conciliation Officer, Puri. The conciliation having failed the Conciliation Officer submitted his report of failure of conciliation to the State Government (opposite party 3), who on consideration of the failure report referred the dispute for adjudication by the Labour Court (opposite party 1). The dispute referred was as follows:
“Whether removal from service of Hatakishore Sahu, assistant junior supervisor-cum-secretary of Markandpur Service Co-operative Society by the management of the United Puri-Nimapara Central Co-operative Bank, Ltd., Puri, with effect from 14 August 1970, is legal and or justified? If not to what relief he is entitled?”
The reference was registered in the file of the Labour Court as Industrial Dispute Case No. 14 of 1972. Though no domestic enquiry had been held by the bank, evidence was led before the Labour Court by the management to justify the termination. By its award (annexure 2), dated 11 March 1974, opposite party 1 held that the termination was justified. It is to quash this order the writ application has been filed by Hatakishore Sahu (petitioner) under Arts. 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
2. Sri Nanda for the petitioner advanced the following contentions:
(i) The order of dismissal, dated 21 October 1970, making it effective retrospectively from 14 August 1970, is contrary to law and without jurisdiction.
(ii) There being no domestic enquiry the order of termination passed by opposite party 1 was without jurisdiction and the order of termination would be effective from 11 March 1974, when the award was passed by opposite party 1.
3. The first contention is sound. It is now well-settled that an order of dismissal would be effective from the date when it is passed and it cannot have any retrospective operation. The Labour Court exercised its jurisdiction illegally in saying that the dismissal order, dated 21 October 1970, would be effective from 14 August 1970, when the order suspension was passed. It is also well-settled that this Court has got jurisdiction to legalise the matter by modifying the order of dismissal in saying that it would be effective from the date when it was passed. Thus the order of dismissal will be operative with effect from 21 October 1970, and the petitioner would be entitled to arrears of wages from 14 August to 21 October 1970.
4. The second contention requires careful examination. Sri Nanda's contention is that without valid domestic enquiry the services of the petitioner could not have been terminated and consequently the dismissal order, dated 21 October 1970 (annexure 1), is without jurisdiction. According to him, the order of termination would be effective from 11 March 1974, when the award (annexure 2) was passed by the Labour Court. He accordingly contends that the petitioner would be entitled to back-wages from 21 October 1970 till 11 March 1974. For reasons to be indicated, this contention is wholly unsound.
5. Law is now well-settled that an employer cannot terminate the services of an employee without holding a domestic enquiry in accordance with the principles of natural justice. It is also settled that where the domestic enquiry has either not been held or has been held improperly it is open to the employer to adduce independent evidence before the Tribunal to justify the order of termination (See Phulbari Tea Estate v. Workmen [A.I.R 1959 S.C 1111]; P.H.Kalyani v. Air France, Calcutta, Calcutta [A.I.R 1963 S.C 1756] and Workmen of the Motipur Sugar Factory (Private), Ltd. v. Motipur Sugar Factory (Private), Ltd. [A.I.R 1965 S.C 1803].
In the last case all the previous decisions were reviewed.
6. After taking independent evidence it is open to the Tribunal either to approve the order of termination or to set it aside. If the order is set aside the employee would be entitled to all arrear wages and other benefits of service from the date when his services were illegally terminated.
The question for consideration, however, is as to from what date the order of termination would be effective when the Tribunal holds that such order was justified. Sri Nanda contends that it would be effective from the date of the award and not from the date when the order of termination was passed by the employer.
7. By holding that the order of termination passed by the employer is justified the Tribunal accepts the order of termination as having been properly passed by the employer. Patently the Tribunal's order relates back to the impugned order of termination and the order of dismissal would be effective from the date when it was passed by the employer.
Sri Nanda, however, places reliance on Sasa Musa Sugar Works (Private), Ltd. v. Shobrati Khan [A.I.R 1959 S.C 923], where the following observation occurs:
“…. But as the management held no enquiry after suspending the workmen and proceedings under S. 33 were practically converted into the inquiry which normally the management should have held before applying to the Industrial Tribunal, the management is bound to pay the wages of the workmen till a case for dismissal was made out in the proceedings under S. 33.”
An identical argument was advanced in P.H.Kalyani v. Air France, Calcutta, Calcutta [A.I.R 1963 S.C 1756] (vide supra), by placing reliance on the aforesaid observation and the same was repelled by their Lordships in a Constitution Bench by distinguishing that case. The observation runs thus (at page 1759):
“…. We are of opinion that those observations cannot be taken advantage of by the appellant. That was a case where an application had been made under S. 33(1) of the Act for permission to dismiss the employees and such permission was asked for though no inquiry whatsoever had been held by the employer and on decision taken that the employees be dismissed. It was in those circumstances that a case for dismissal was made out only in the proceedings under S. 33(1) and, therefore, the employees were held entitled to their wages till the decision of the application under S. 33. The matter would have been different if in that case an inquiry had been held and the employer had come to the conclusion that dismissal was the proper punishment and then had applied under S. 33(1) for permission to dismiss. In those circumstances the permission would have related back to the date when the employer came to the conclusion after an inquiry that dismissal was the proper punishment and had applied for removal of the ban by an application under S. 33(1): (See Management of Ranipur Colliery v. Bhuban Singh [A.I.R 1959 S.C 833]. The present is a case where the employer had held an inquiry though it was defective and has passed an order of dismissal and seeks approval of that order. If the inquiry is not defective, the Labour Court has only to see whether there was a prima facie case for dismissal, and whether the employer had come to the bona fide conclusion that the employee was guilty of misconduct. Thereafter on coming to the conclusion that the employer had bona fide come to the conclusion that the employee was guilty i.e, there was no unfair labour practice and no victimization, the Labour Court would grant the approval which would relate back to the date from which the employer had ordered the dismissal. If the inquiry is defective for any reason, the Labour Court would also have to consider for itself on the evidence adduced before it whether the dismissal was justified. However, on coming to the conclusion on its own appraisal of evidence adduced before it that the dismissal was justified its approval of the order of dismissal made by the employer in a defective inquiry would still relate back to the date when the order was made. The observations, therefore, in Sasa Musa Sugar Company case [A.I.R 1959 S.C 923] (vide supra), on which the appellant relies apply only to a case where the employer had neither dismissed the employee nor had come to the conclusion that a case for dismissal had been made out. In that case the dismissal of the employee takes effect from the date of the award and so until then the relationship of employer and employee continues in law and in fact.”
The same view was taken in Workmen of Motipur Sugar Factory (Private), Ltd. v. Motipur Sugar Factory (Private), Ltd. [A.I.R 1965 S.C 1803]. It was clearly observed in that case that a defective inquiry stands on the same footing as no enquiry and in either case the Tribunal had jurisdiction to go into the facts and the employer would have to satisfy the Tribunal that on fact the order of dismissal or discharge was proper.
8. On an analysis of the aforesaid decisions we may lay down the following propositions as well established:
(1) An employer cannot dismiss or discharge an employee without making an enquiry in accordance with the principles of natural justice.
(2) Where there has been a domestic enquiry it is for the Tribunal to see if the enquiry had been properly made or not.
(3) If there has been no domestic enquiry at all or the enquiry is defective the employer is to justify before the Tribunal the order of dismissal or discharge by proof of relevant evidence.
(4) A defective enquiry stands on the same footing as no enquiry.
(5) So far as the jurisdiction of the Tribunal is concerned, there is no difference in principle in the matter of giving independent evidence by the employer whether the matter comes before the Tribunal for approval under S. 33 or on a reference under S. 10.
(6) It is only where the employer neither dismissed the employee nor came to the conclusion that a case for dismissal has been made the order of termination would be held effective from the date when the Tribunal passed the order and there would be no question of relating back the order of termination.
(7) Where, however, the employer passed an order of termination whether without holding an enquiry or after holding a defective enquiry, the order of termination would be effective from the date it was passed by the employer if it has been held to have been justified by the Tribunal.
9. In this case opposite party 1 held in the award (annexure 2) that the order of dismissal, dated 21 October 1970, was justified. The conclusion of the employer was reached without holding any domestic enquiry. Applying the aforesaid principles it is clear that the order of termination would be effective from 21 October 1970, and not from 11 March 1974, when the award was passed. The argument of Sri Nanda that the order of termination was passed in two stages is born of confusion. There are no two stages. The order of the employer without holding an enquiry is not liable to be quashed on the analogy of Art. 311 (2) of the Consitution. In exercise of the writ jurisdiction under Arts. 226 and 227 the High Court has no power to take further evidence to justify an order of termination otherwise bad held without enquiry or after improper enquiry. By judicial decisions it has now been established that such an order of termination is not liable to be quashed if on enquiry before the Tribunal the order can be justified by the employer on independent evidence. The entire concept of law is one integrated whole and cannot be divided into two stages. The matter is concluded by the aforesaid Supreme Court decisions and is no longer arguable.
10. On the aforesaid analysis, a writ of certiorari be issued quashing annexure 2 in part to the extent it says that the order of dismissal from service passed on 21 October 1970, would operate retrospectively from 14 August 1970. The petitioner would be entitled to back-wages from 14 August to 21 October 1970. The other part of the award saying that the order of dismissal is justified is not liable to be quashed. In the result, the writ application is allowed in part but in the circumstances there will be no order as to costs.
11. S.K Ray, J.:— I agree.
Alert