- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ganesh Panigrahi v. Jura Sahu And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S. Acharya, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a second appeal by the unsuccessful plaintiff against the decision of the Additional Subordinate Judge, Berhampur in Title Appeal No. 14 of 1969. The plaintiff alleged ownership and possession of two adjacent plots (nos. 775 and 774). To the north of these plots lies defendants' plot no. 690, which is at a lower level. The plaintiff claimed that the defendants had, to damage the plaintiff's land and create a shortcut for surplus water, forcibly dug a nala across the plaintiff's two suit plots and thereby caused wrongful loss. The plaintiff attempted to obstruct the defendants but failed, alleging the defendants had influence and official support.
Defendants 1 to 3 contested the suit, asserting a customary/easementary right to let the surplus water from their higher plot (no. 690) flow through the plaintiff's lower plot (no. 775). Defendants 4 and 5 did not contest and were set ex parte. The trial Court made extensive factual findings about relative levels and topography, which the appellate Court on reappraisal confirmed. The trial and appellate Courts dismissed the plaintiff's suit; this appeal challenges those decisions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff was entitled to a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from digging a nala on the suit lands or from damaging or interfering with the plaintiff's possession and enjoyment of the suit land, despite the plaintiff's having recently raised a portion of his land;
- Whether, on the facts found (relative levels and topography), the owner of the lower land (plaintiff) could obstruct the natural flow of surplus water from the higher land (defendants' plot) or whether the lower land was obliged to accept the natural flow (i.e., the existence/operation of a natural servitude by reason of relative levels); and
- Whether equitable principles (in particular the maxim that "he who seeks equity must do equity" and the requirement that a claimant come to court with "clean hands") precluded the plaintiff from obtaining injunction relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaintiff asserted ownership and possession of plot nos. 775 and 774 as described in the plaint and sought protection of his land from defendants' alleged wrongful acts.
- The plaintiff (through counsel Mr. Misra) contended that he has the right to use and enjoy his land as he pleases; the portion of plot no. 775 raised by him was for the beneficial enjoyment of his land.
- Mr. Misra argued that the defendants had no right to dig a nala or otherwise damage the plaintiff's land, and therefore the courts below erred in refusing a permanent injunction restraining such acts and interference.
Defendants' Arguments
- Defendants 1–3 asserted a customary and easementary right to discharge surplus water from their higher plot no. 690 through the plaintiff's plot no. 775; historically the surplus water flowed through plot no. 775 and other plots.
- They alleged that the plaintiff, after failing to purchase plot no. 690, artificially raised a portion of plot no. 775 (by putting earth) to obstruct natural flow and with the ulterior motive of damaging plot no. 690 and rendering it unfit for cultivation, and thereafter instituted the suit to harass the defendants.
- They contended that unless the plaintiff's raised ridge was removed, plot no. 690 would become unfit and useless for all intents and purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Basheshar Nath v. Municipal Committee, Moga — A.I.R. 1940 Lah. 69 | Illustration of the equitable principle that a claimant for injunction must come with "clean hands" and that equity requires the applicant to "do equity". | Used to support the proposition that because the plaintiff had acted unfairly (raising a ridge that obstructed natural flow), he could not obtain equitable relief by way of injunction. |
| Seeni Chettiar v. Santhanathan Chattiar — I.L.R. 20 Mad. 58 at p. 67 (Full Bench) | Support for the equitable requirement that a party seeking injunction must have acted honestly and without taint; referenced alongside Basheshar Nath on "clean hands". | Cited to reinforce the court's view that the plaintiff's unfair conduct disentitled him to injunction relief. |
| Gibbons v. Lenfestey — A.I.R. 1915 P.C. 165 | Principle that when two contiguous fields are at different levels, nature may impose a servitude on the lower tenement obliging it to receive water from the higher. | Applied to hold that the lower land may be obliged to receive natural water from the higher land; supported the finding that the plaintiff could not prevent the natural outlet for the defendants' water. |
| John Young and Co. v. Bankeir Distillery Company — 1893 A.C. (per Lord Watson) | Statement that the upper owner's right to send down natural water and the lower owner's obligation to receive it arise from relative levels; the lower may not object if the flow is due to gravitation unless unduly increased by operations in aemulationem vicini. | Quoted to establish the general rule of natural flow and to show that the plaintiff's obstruction (an artificial ridge) amounted to an inequitable interference with the natural outlet. |
| Shaik Hussain Sahib v. Pachipulusu Subbayya — A.I.R. 1926 Mad. 449 (Full Bench) | Held that an owner of land at a lower level who raises an obstruction to the natural flow of water will be restrained if it causes or tends to cause damage to the owner of the higher land. | Relied upon to support the proposition that obstruction by the lower landowner is impermissible when it causes damage to the higher landowner; helped justify denying relief to the plaintiff who created an obstruction. |
| Sheogulam Singh v. Rambahadur Singh — A.I.R. 1938 Pat. 73 (per Fazl Ali, J.) | Affirms that an owner of higher-level land has a natural right, incident to ownership, to discharge water upon adjacent lower land. | Used to reinforce the view that the defendants (owners of higher plot no. 690) had the natural right to discharge surplus water onto the plaintiff's lower plot. |
| Patneedi Rudrayya v. Velugubantala Venkayya — 1961 S.C.D. 783 (Supreme Court) | Observation that water on higher ground must, by gravity, flow to lower ground; where the owner of lower ground creates an embankment impeding natural flow he obstructs the natural outlet; flood water of the kind to which higher land is periodically subjected is included. | Applied to the facts: the plaintiff's artificial ridge impeded the natural outlet and thereby caused or threatened damage to the defendants' higher land. |
| Kaosal Mohan Powar v. Kodu Dajiba Powar — A.I.R. 1946 Nag. 75 | Holds that the owner of lower land is bound to accept water discharged in the ordinary course from higher land and cannot raise artificial barriers causing accumulation on another's property even to protect his own. | Invoked to support the court's conclusion that the plaintiff could not lawfully raise barriers (the ridge) that caused harm to the defendants' higher plot and therefore could not obtain injunctive protection. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's reasoning follows a sequence of factual findings and legal application:
- Factual findings affirmed by both the trial and appellate Courts: plot no. 690 (defendants) is at a higher level than plot no. 775 (plaintiff); the plaintiff recently raised the level of a portion of plot no. 775 (a ridge) adjoining the southern boundary of plot no. 690; surrounding lands' topography means surplus water could discharge only through plot no. 775.
- The Courts relied on admissions in cross-examination by the plaintiff and his witnesses and on the Commissioner's local inspection report (Ext. B), which indicated the ridge was recently constructed and soft earth suggested recent filling. The Commissioner found the ridge adjoining plot no. 690 and at a slightly higher level than plot no. 690.
- The courts concluded the plaintiff's pleaded position that his plot 775 was at a higher level than plot 690 was false; the evidence supported the opposite. This finding was not successfully challenged on appeal.
- The court applied equitable principles governing injunctions: injunction is an equitable remedy and requires that the applicant have "clean hands" and have acted fairly, honestly and without taint or illegality. The court cited Basheshar Nath and Seeni Chettiar for these equitable maxims.
- Given the established facts that the plaintiff had constructed a ridge obstructing the natural flow and that this obstruction caused or threatened damage to the defendants' plot, the plaintiff was found to have acted unfairly and without "clean hands." Consequently, the equitable remedy of injunction was not appropriate.
- Independently, the court applied the law on natural servitudes and the obligation of a lower tenement to accept natural water from a higher one (Gibbons v. Lenfestey; John Young; Sheogulam Singh; Patneedi Rudrayya; Kaosal Mohan Powar). Those authorities establish that where relative levels make natural discharge inevitable, the lower land is obliged to accept the flow and cannot create artificial barriers to the detriment of the higher land.
- On the facts found (the ridge obstructing the outlet and causing damage), these principles supported refusal of the plaintiff's relief because the plaintiff's act of obstruction both produced the harm and disentitled him to equitable protection.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. The Courts below were justified in dismissing the plaintiff's suit, and there is no merit in the appeal.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiff's claim for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from digging a nala, damaging the suit lands, or interfering with the plaintiff's possession and enjoyment of the suit land is refused; the plaintiff's suit was dismissed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.
- Reasoning basis: The dismissal rests on two interrelated grounds explicitly stated by the court — (a) equitable preclusion because the plaintiff did not come with "clean hands" after constructing the obstructive ridge; and (b) established principles of natural servitude obliging a lower tenement to accept natural discharge from an adjacent higher tenement, so that artificial obstruction by the lower landowner causing damage is impermissible.
- Broader precedent: The opinion applies established authorities to the facts but does not state that it is creating any new legal principle or overruling precedent. No broader new precedent was announced beyond applying existing equitable and water-flow doctrines to the facts of this case.
Final Disposition: Appeal dismissed with costs. ("Appeal dismissed." as recorded in the original opinion.)
S. Acharya, J.:— The unsuccessful plaintiff in both the Courts below has preferred this second appeal against the decision passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Berhampur in Title Appeal No. 14 of 1969.
2. The plaintiff's case, in brief, is that he owns and possesses plot nos 775 and 774 as specifically described in the plaint. To the adjacent north of the said two plots, the defendants have their plot no. 690 at a lower level than the above-mentioned two suit plots. The surplus water from plot no. 690 was being discharged from time immemorial through plot nos. 742, 745 and other plots downwards belonging to other persons. The defendants being in inimical terms with the plaintiff and in order to damage the plaintiff's land and to have a short cut way for the surplus water on plot no. 690, forcibly dug a Nala on the above-mentioned two suit plots thus causing wrongful loss and damage to the plaintiff. The plaintiff tried to obstruct the above highhanded action of the defendants, but failed in his attempt as the defendants are influential persons and had the support of the police and other local authorities.
3. Defendant nos. 4 and 5 did not contest the suit and were set ex parts.
4. The plea of defendant nos. 1 to 3 is that they have customary and easementary right of taking water through the above-mentioned suit plots. According to them plot no. 690 stands at a higher level than its adjacent plot no. 775 belonging to the plaintiff, and since time immemorial the surplus water from plot no. 690 used to naturally flow out through plot no. 775 and thereafter through other plots in the locality. It is averred that the plaintiff being a rich man wanted to purchase the said plot no. 690, but as he failed in his attempt, he recently raised the level of a portion of plot no. 775 adjacent to plot no. 690 by putting earth on the same, thereby causing obstruction to the natural flow of the surplus water from plot no. 690 through plot no. 775, with the ulterior motive of damaging the defendants' aforesaid plot no. 690 and making it unfit for cultivation. Soon after raising the level of plot no. 775 as aforesaid, the plaintiff instituted this suit to harass the defendants. They have specifically asserted that unless the aforesaid portion of plot no. 775 recently raised by the plaintiff is not suitably removed in order to allow the surplus water from plot no. 690 to flow out through plot no. 775 as before, plot no. 690 would become unfit and useless for all intents and purposes.
5. Undisputedly plot no. 690 belonging to the defendants is to the adjacent north of plot no. 775 belonging to the plaintiff.
6. The trial Court on an elaborate and thorough appreciation of the evidence on record finds that plot no. 690 is at a higher level than plot no. 775. It also finds that the plaintiff recently by putting earth raised the level of a portion of his plot no. 775 to the extent of about 100 to 120 feet in breadth, adjacent to and all through the sourthern boundary of plot no. 690. It also finds that the lands adjoining plot no. 690 on its east, north and west are all at a higher level than plot no. 690, but the lands to its south, excepting the elevated portion of plot no. 775, are at a lower level. It has categorically discarded the plaintiff's case that the water from plot no. 690 flows out on its north-east corner through the lands of other persons. It has arrived at a definite conclusion that because of the topography of the land and the situation of the aforesaid two plots the surplus water on plot no. 690 could only be discharged through plot no. 775 and not through any other plot.
7. The appellate Court on a fresh reappraisal of the evidence on record in a convincing manner has confirmed the aforesaid findings of fact arrived at by the trial Court.
8. The two Courts in arriving at the aforesaid findings have taken into consideration certain admissions made by the plaintiff's witnesses. The plaintiff himself in 1is cross-examination has admitted that the eastern and northern sides of plot no. 690 are at a higher level, and its western side is at a much higher level due to the existence of a hillock on that side. He has also admitted that the sourthern side of the aforesaid plot is not at a higher level. P.W 2 in his cross-examination has admitted that to the north of plot no. 690 the lands are at a higher level, whereas the lands on the southern side of that plot are gradually sloping down. P.W 3 has also admitted in his cross-examination that the lands on the eastern, western and northern sides of plot no. 690 are at a higher-level than the lands on the southern side and the lands to the south of the said plot are at a lower level. He has also admitted that if the elevated portion of plot no. 775 is opened, water from plot no. 690 would flow towards the south. He has also admitted that apart from the said elevated portion on plot no. 775 the other portion of plot no. 775 is sloping towards the south, and that if a channel is dug on that elevated portion of plot no. 775 the water on plot no. 690 will pass through plot no. 775. The report Ext. B of the Commissioner who made a local inspection shows that the elevated portion (referred to hereafter as the ridge) is on plot no. 775 and is adjoining plot no. 690 and that ridge is at a slightly higher level than plot no. 690. The Commissioner at the time of his local inspection found that the earth on the said ridge was soft, indicating thereby that the said ridge had been recently constructed.
9. On a careful perusal of the judgments of both the Courts below I am satisfied that the above-mentioned findings of fact are born out by the relevant evidence on record and are perfectly correct and justified, and there is absolutely no reason to interfere with the aforesaid findings of fact in this second appeal. Mr. Misra, the learned counsel for the appellant, has also not been able to assail the aforesaid findings of fact on any convincing ground.
10. Mr. Misra, however, urged that inspite of the finding of the Court below that the plaintiff recently raised a portion of his own land, the plaintiff's specific prayer to restrain the defendants from committing damages or mischief of any kind on the plaintiff's own land should not have been rejected. According to Mr. Misra, as the plaintiff has the right to use, utilise and enjoy the aforesaid two plots belonging to him in any manner he likes, and he raised the aforesaid portion for the beneficial enjoyment of his own land, and the defendants do not have any right in digging a Nala or doing anything on the suit land, much less to damage and/or adversely affect the plaintiff's lands in any manner, the Court below acted illegally in not granting the plaintiff's prayer for a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from digging a Nala on the suit lands belonging to the plaintiff and/or from damaging the same in any other manner or from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit land.
11. An injunction, as is well known, is an equitable remedy and accordingly the maxim of equity that he who seeks equity must do equity is applicable to a case in which such an equitable remedy is prayed for. Moreover, the plaintiff asking for such a relief should be able to show that he has come to Court with ‘clean hands’. The law for the issue of injunction as provided in the Specific Relief Act is governed by the aforesaid equitable principles. In the above view of the matter, the plaintiff who asks for an injunction must be able to satisfy the Court that his own acts and dealings in the matter have been fair, honest and free from any taint or fraud or illegality, and that if, in his dealings with the person against whom he seeks the relief, he has acted in an unfair or unequitable manner, he cannot have this type of relief. The views expressed and the principles enunciated on this question in the decision reported in Basheshar Nath v. Municipal Committee, Moga . A.I.R 1940 Lah. 69., and in the Full Bench decision reported in Seeni Chettiar v. Santhanathan Chattiar . I.L.R 20 Mad. 58 at p. 67. may be seen.
12. From the pleadings, the evidence on record (specially the above-mentioned admissions of the plaintiff and his witnesses), the Commissioner's local inspection report Ext. B, and the concurrent findings and conclusions of the two Courts below it is quite evident that the surplus water on plot no. 690 was all along flowing through plot no. 775 belonging to the plaintiff and the plaintiff before filing this suit raised the level of the northern portion of plot no. 775 by putting earth on the same, thereby obstructing the natural flow of water from plot no. 690 through plot no. 775. The lands on the north, east and west of plot no. 690 being at a higher level, some surplus water from all these lands must be flowing to plot no. 690. By the aforesaid construction of the ridge by the plaintiff on plot no. 775 he has obstructed all that water to flow out of plot no. 690. thereby causing damage to and depreciation in the value of the aforesaid plot. The defendants assert that unless the said ridge is not suitably removed, plot no. 690 would become unfit and useless for all intents and purposes. Their assertion, on the facts established in this case, appears to be well founded. Moreover the plaintiff after putting up the aforesaid ridge on plot no. 775 instituted this suit on the plea that plot no. 775 is at a higher level than plot no. 690, which pleas has been established to be absolutely a false one. On the above facts it can verily be said that the plaintiff has not come to Court with ‘clean hands’; rather his dealings in this affair have been most unfair, unconscionable and unequitable, and so he is not entitled to the equitable remedy by way of injunction as prayed for by him.
13. The reliefs prayed for by the plaintiff cannot be granted on another consideration also. Their Lordships of the Privy Council in Gibbons v. Lenfestey . A.I.R 1915 P.C 165., have held that where two contiguous fields one of which stands on a higher ground than the other belonging to two different persons, nature itself may be said to constitute a servitude on the inferior tenement by which it is obliged to receive water which falls from the superior.
14. Lord Waston in John Young and Co. v. Bankeir Distillery Company . 1893 A.C at p. 693. says:
“The right of the upper heritor to send down, and the corresponding obligation of the lower heritor to receive, natural water whether flowing in a definite channel or not, and whether upon or below the surface, are incidents of property arising from the relative levels of their respective lands and the strata below them. The lower heritor cannot object so long as the flow, whether above or below ground, is due to gravitation, unless it has been unduly and unreasonably increased by operations which are in aemulationem vicini.”
15. In the Full Bench decision reported in Shaik Hussain Sahib v. Pachipulusu Subbayya . A.I.R 1926 Mad 449., on a review of many English cases it has been held that if the owner of the land at the lower level raises on obstruction to the natural flow of water he will be restrained if it causes or tends to cause damage to the owner of that on the higher level.
16. Justice Fazl Ali in Sheogulam Singh v. Rambahadur Singh . A.I.R 1938 Pat. 73., says that the owner of a plot of land on a higher level has, as a natural right and as an incident to the ownership of the plot, the right to discharge water upon an adjacent plot of land lying on the lower level.
17. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Patneedi Rudrayya v. Velugubantala Venkayya . 1961 S.C.D 783., have observed that the water on a higher ground must by operation of the force of gravity flow on the lower ground. Where the owner of the lower ground by creating an embankment impedes the natural flow of water he would be obstructing the natural outlet for the water. It makes little difference that the water happens to be not merely rain water but flood water provided the flood is of the kind to which the higher land is subjected periodically.
18. In the decision reported in Kaosal Mohan Powar v. Kodu Dajiba Powar . A.I.R 1946 Nag. 75., it has been held that the owner of the lower land is bound to accept water discharged in the ordinary and in the matter of course of affair from the higher land and cannot raise artificial barriers on his land which would cause water to accumulate on another's. property thereby causing damage in any manner to the owner of the higher land. He cannot do this even if it is necessary to protect his own property.
19. On the views expressed and/or the principles enunciated in the above-mentioned cases and on the facts established in this case, the plaintiff, who has instituted this case after raising the level of a strip of his land adjacent to plot no. 690 thereby obstructing the natural flow of the surplus water from plot no. 690 through plot no. 775, cannot obviously get the protection of the relief prayed for by him.
20. On the above considerations I am satisfied that the Courts below were perfectly justified in dismissing the plaintiff's suit.
21. There is therefore no merit in this appeal which is accordingly dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert