Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abodha Kumar Mohapatra And Others v. State Of Orissa And Others Opposite Parties.

Orissa High Court
Sep 6, 1968
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Orissa Medical Colleges Admissions — 1968)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Principal of S.C.B. Medical College, Cuttack issued a Notice dated 22 June 1968 (published 28 June 1968) inviting applications for admission to the three Government-run medical colleges in Orissa for 1968. Paragraph 16 of the Notice represented that selection would be made on the basis of merit determined by marks in the Science (medical) subjects (Physics, Chemistry and Biology) in the qualifying examination, with specified additional weightage for B.Sc and deductions for past failures. The last date for applications was extended to 20 July 1968 and 1,497 students applied.

On 14 August 1968, the Government of Orissa (Health and Family Planning Department) issued a letter directing changes to selection procedures: (a) eliminate any student securing less than 50% in the Pre-Professional examination; (b) select students securing 50% and above in group subjects according to merit from respective regions tagged to individual colleges and fill remaining seats from other regions; (c) reserve 15% of seats for lady students; and (d) allow spot selection by Principals. The Government letter was issued on the day the Selection Board was to meet.

Petitioners (student applicants, including two lady students) challenged the August 14, 1968 Government letter in writ petitions, alleging it altered the basis of selection represented in the Notice, unlawfully excluded higher-mark candidates, introduced unreasonable discrimination (region-wise and aggregate elimination), and retrospectively created reservation for lady students. The State defended its authority to issue the directive and argued that it could change admission rules.

The High Court heard the analogous writ petitions and considered preliminary objections (including a faint objection about non-joinder of provisionally selected candidates) which it rejected as untenable because selections were provisional and, in any event, the Court would not disturb candidates already admitted. The Court then proceeded to decide the merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Government letter dated 14 August 1968 (the impugned Government letter) lawfully altered the basis of selection stated in the Notice dated 22 June 1968.
  2. Whether the provision for region-wise (territorial) classification of seats in the impugned letter was violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  3. Whether the region-wise provision amounted to discrimination solely on the basis of place of birth and thus violated Article 15(1) of the Constitution.
  4. Whether the directive eliminating students with less than 50% aggregate marks (regardless of medical-group marks) was arbitrary and unlawful when it contradicted the Notice's specified merit criteria.
  5. Whether the retrospective reservation of 15% of seats for lady students (not provided for in the Notice) could be validly introduced to affect candidates who had already applied relying on the Notice.
  6. Whether the Government and Selection Board could be judicially reviewed for changing representations contained in the Notice, and whether equitable estoppel obliges the Government to honour the representations once acted upon by applicants.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Notice (22 June 1968) represented that selection would be on the basis of merit determined by marks in medical-group Science subjects (paragraph 16); candidates applied relying on this representation.
  • The impugned Government letter of 14 August 1968 altered the basis of selection to eliminate candidates with less than 50% aggregate and to effect regionwise selection, thereby eliminating many otherwise better-qualified candidates and introducing unreasonable discrimination.
  • The 50% aggregate cutoff was irrelevant to assessing fitness for medical study because the Notice specified medical-group marks as the criterion; eliminating candidates with high medical-group marks but lower aggregates was irrational and discriminatory.
  • Regionwise classification had no reasonable nexus with the object of obtaining the best candidates for medical colleges and therefore violated Article 14.
  • The provision reserving 15% of seats for lady students was not in the Notice and, introduced retrospectively, unfairly prejudiced male candidates who had applied in reliance on the Notice; such reservation could not be retroactively imposed to the petitioners' detriment.
  • The Government and Selection Board were estopped from departing from the Notice's representations once candidates had acted to their prejudice; the Court can grant relief to enforce the representations.
  • Selections made pursuant to the impugned letter were arbitrary and discriminatory; the petitioners sought declaratory and consequential relief (reconsideration/selection according to the Notice).

Opposite Parties' Arguments

  • A preliminary objection: the petitions were not maintainable because the provisionally selected students had not been impleaded. The Court rejected this objection as selections were provisional and admissions already made would not be disturbed.
  • Substantive defence: the Government asserted that it has power to change admission rules and is the sole judge of its actions; candidates who acted on representations in the Notice have no enforceable right except what the Government chooses to recognise. The State contended that it could change rules and issue guidance to the Selection Board.
  • The opposite parties did not specifically deny the petitioners' allegation (in paragraph 25(j) of a petition) that the discrimination was solely on place of birth; this absence of denial was treated as an admission by the Court for the purposes of the petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Rajendran v. State of Madras, Writ Petn. Nos. 194, 196 & 202 of 1967; AIR 1968 SC 1012 District-wise (territorial) allocation of seats for admission to medical colleges can violate Article 14 because it may deny admission to better candidates in favour of lesser qualified candidates from another area; classification must have nexus with the object to be achieved. The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision to hold that region-wise (territorial) selection in the impugned Government letter violated Article 14 and had no reasonable nexus with the object of securing the best medical talent.
Union of India v. Anglo Afgan Agencies, AIR 1968 SC 718 Principles supporting equitable estoppel and the circumstances in which the Government's representations can be enforced against it where persons have acted to their prejudice. The Court invoked the principles underlying this decision to support its conclusion that petitioners who acted on the Notice's representations were entitled to equitable relief (estoppel) against the Government's retrospective change.
Kumari Akhtar v. Principal, Osmania Medical College, AIR 1959 Andh Pra 493 Authoritative support (Division Bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court) for enforcing representations in admission contexts and principles of equity/estoppel in similar situations. The Court cited this decision alongside the Anglo Afgan Agencies case to reinforce the applicability of equitable estoppel to the facts, supporting the conclusion that Government could not renege on the Notice to the petitioners' detriment.
Sri Channabasaviah v. State of Mysore, AIR 1965 SC 1293 (obiter quoted) Observations emphasizing equality and equal protection before the law and the duty of public institutions to act so as to inspire public confidence, even if doing so causes inconvenience. The Court quoted these observations as a reminder to authorities that equality and public confidence justify interference even at some inconvenience to Government or selected candidates; used as a moral and constitutional reinforcement of its order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise analysis grounded in the Notice, the impugned Government letter, the facts as recorded in the Index Register, and applicable constitutional principles and precedents:

  1. The Notice (22 June 1968) unambiguously represented that selection would be made on the basis of merit determined by marks in medical-group Science subjects, with specified weightages and deductions (paragraph 16). Applicants relied on those representations and applied accordingly.
  2. The Government letter of 14 August 1968 altered the basis of selection on the very day the Selection Board was to meet. Its key provisions (50% aggregate cutoff; region-wise selection; 15% reservation for lady students; spot selection by Principals) fundamentally departed from the Notice and affected the chances of many candidates who had higher medical-group marks but were excluded by the new rules.
  3. On region-wise classification: The Court held that a provision directing selection "from the respective regions tagged to the individual colleges" was directly hit by Article 14. It relied on P. Rajendran (AIR 1968 SC 1012) and explained the governing principle: classification is permissible only if there is a reasonable nexus between the classification and the object to be achieved (here, securing the best medical talent). Region-wise allocation lacked that nexus and would result in inferior candidates being admitted over superior candidates.
  4. On Article 15(1): The petition alleged the region-wise scheme discriminated solely on place of birth. The opposite parties did not specifically deny that allegation in their numerous counter-affidavits. The Court read the Index Register's "Home district" column together with the impugned phrase "from the respective regions" to conclude that the discrimination was indeed based on place of birth and therefore violative of Article 15(1).
  5. On the 50% aggregate elimination: The Court found that eliminating candidates below 50% in the aggregate, regardless of medical-group marks, contradicted the Notice's criterion and arbitrarily excluded better-qualified candidates. Such a departure could not be justified merely because the Government's power to issue directives is executive in character.
  6. On the Government's power and estoppel: The Court rejected the argument that the Government was the sole judge and could change the rules with impunity. It held that when prospective candidates act to their prejudice on a Government representation in a Notice, courts can enforce the representation. The petitioners' claim was founded in equity: the Government was estopped from issuing the impugned letter to the candidates' detriment. The Court invoked the principles in Union of India v. Anglo Afgan Agencies and the Andhra Pradesh decision (Kumari Akhtar) to support equitable relief.
  7. On reservation for lady students: The Court held that introducing a 15% reservation for women after applications had been made was retrospective and prejudicial to other candidates who applied under the Notice's open merit scheme. Even if such reservation might be reasonable in another context, it could not be retrospectively applied to affect the petitioners who had relied on the Notice.
  8. Remedies and direction: Because the impugned letter introduced multiple unconstitutional and illegal changes, the Court struck it down and declared the provisional selection list made pursuant to it void and inoperative. The Court interpreted paragraph 9 of the Notice to require preparation of a single list in order of merit (per paragraph 16), with the first twenty candidates given choice of college and subsequent allotment to colleges in order of merit; it provided detailed directions (single consolidated merit list, option for first twenty, allotment mechanics, preservation of students already admitted, and deadline for completion).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned Government letter dated 14 August 1968 is invalid and is struck down as violative of the Constitution and otherwise illegal.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The list of candidates provisionally selected pursuant to the impugned Government letter is declared void and inoperative.
  • The concerned authorities are directed to make selections and allotment of seats strictly in accordance with the Notice dated 22 June 1968, particularly paragraph 16 (basis of merit determined by marks in medical-group Science subjects with specified weightages/deductions) and paragraph 9 (as interpreted by the Court regarding a single consolidated merit list and the option for the first twenty candidates).
  • Specific implementation directions given by the Court included:
    • Prepare one single list in order of merit (including lady candidates) based on paragraph 16 criteria.
    • Give the first twenty candidates in order of merit the option to join any of the three medical colleges.
    • Allot remaining seats in the three colleges strictly in order of merit from that list, following paragraph 9's scheme as interpreted.
    • If vacancies remain, fill them from remaining candidates in strict order of merit; actual allotment left to authorities' discretion.
    • Do not disturb students already admitted whose cases were brought to the Court's notice.
    • Apply to the appropriate University authorities for reasonable extension of time for admission; complete selection, allotment and publication by 12 September 1968.
  • Costs: The petitioners were awarded one set of consolidated costs and one hearing fee assessed at Rs. 200.

Broader implications: The Court applied established Supreme Court and High Court authorities (cited in the opinion) to strike down retrospective and territorially discriminatory changes to admissions criteria. The decision enforces the principle that governmental representations in admission notices, relied upon by applicants to their prejudice, can be enforced by courts on equitable grounds; the Court did not purport to lay down a novel principle beyond applying the cited authorities.

Disposition: Petitions allowed, in the terms set out above.

Show all summary ...

Barman, C.J:— In these writ petitions analogously heard some student candidates including two lady students — as applicants for admission during the Medical Colleges in Orissa during the year 1968 relying on a Notice dated June 22, 1968 issued by the Principal, S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack and published in the Orissa Gazette dated June 28, 1968, fixing the criteria for determination of merit of candidates eligible for selection and inviting applications for admission to the Medical Colleges — challenge the legality of the letter dated August 14, 1968 issued by the Government of Orissa in the Department of Health and Family Planning. It is said that by this impugned letter the Government issued certain executive instructions which had the effect of eliminating many otherwise qualified candidates by a process of unreasonable Mscrimination, regionwise selection of candidates, and making special provisions for lady students retrospectively thereby altering, to the detriment of the candidates who had already applied, the very basis of selection as originally represented in the Notice inviting applications for admission, issued by the Principal, S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack, on June 22, 1968. This letter of August 14, 1968 is challenged by the petitionera as unconstitutional, as affecting their fundamental rights and also otherwise illegal. For brevity, the Notice of June 22, 1968 is hereinafter referred to as “the notice” and the letter of Government dated August 14, 1968 as “the impugned Government letter”.

2. As in the previous years, during the present year (1968) the Principal, S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack, as chairman of Selection Board for selection of candidates for admission into the Medical Colleges issued the Notice inviting applications for admission to the Medical Colleges in the State—S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack, Burla Medical College and Medical College, Berhampur— all run by the Government of Orissa. The Notice specified the conditions for eligibility including the basis of merit as determined by the marks in science subjects, reservation of a limited number of seats for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, the nominees of the Government of India and other State Governments; the minimum educational qualification required was a pass in the science subjects Physics, Chemistry and Biology (Botany and Zoology) in the qualifying examination i.e I. Sc. or Pre-Professional examination or in examination recognised, as equivalent thereto. In paragraph 16 hereinafter quoted read with paragraph 2 it was clearly represented that the selection of candidates will be made on the basis of merit determined by marks in the Science subjects (Medical group only) in the qualifying examination. It was also represented that additional weightage of marks would be given for candidates who have passed B.Sc, the rate of percentage of weightage varying according to the Class (First Class, Second Class, Distinction or Pass as the case may be); provision was also made for deduction of marks for each previous failure in the qualifying examination—all as fully stated in paragraph 16 of the Notice. The last date for receipt of the applications in the office of the Principal, S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack, was fixed as July 10, 1968 as stated in paragraph 15 of the Notice. The last date for application was later on extended to July 20, 1968. The Index Register of the candidates prepared by the concerned authorities shows that 1497 students applied for admission.

3. Relying an the representation made in paragraph 16 of the Notice that selection will be made in the order of merit determined on the basis of marks obtained in the Science subjects (Medical group only) in the qualifying examination (I.Sc or Pre-Professional or its equivalent examination), the petitioners including some student candidates with admittedly high marks in the Medical group as appears from the Index Register, applied for admission. For appreciation of the merit of the petitioners (including the two lady students) as determined by marks, in the Science subjects (Medical group) a few instances with the marks and the Index numbers as tabulated in the Index Register produced by the Advocate General are given below:

Number of the Writ petition. Total percentage of marks. Index Number O.J.C No. 825/68 65.66 1180 O.J.C No. 822/68 63.66 1273 O.J.C No. 836/68 63.33 1355 O.J.C No. 819/68 62.66 1148 O.J.C No. 815/68 61.66 1318 O.J.C No. 823/68 (lady student) 61.33 883 O.J.C No. 839/68 (lady student) 58.66 1050

4. In spite of higher marks than those obtained by the provisionally selected candidates, the petitioners are stated to have been wrongfully eliminated as hereinafter fully discussed.

5. On August 14, 1968, that is the day on which the Selection Board was to meet, the Government by their impugned letter issued a directive to the concerned authorities purporting to alter the entire basis of selection based on merit in contravention of paragraph 16 of the Notice in which it was represented that the marks obtained by the candidates in the Science subjects Physics, Chemistry and Biology (Botany and Zoology) Medical group only, would be the determining factor. It is this directive or instruction of the Government as contained in the impugned Government letter which is being challenged in these writ petitions as unconstitutional and otherwise illegal.

6. The impugned Government letter dated August 14, 1968 is quoted below:

18732IMMEDIATE

GOVERNMENT OF ORISSA HEALTH AND FAMILY PLANNING DEPARTMENT

No.———/H

Sri K.S Samantarai, B.A, O.A.S, Under Secretary to Government

The Director of Health Services, Orissa, Dated the August, 1968.

Subject: Admission of students into the Medical Colleges during 1968.

In continuation of Government letter No. 13042, dated 15-6-68, I am directed to say that Government have been pleased to decide that no student securing less than 50 per cent of marks in the Pre-Professional Examination should be entertained for admission into the medical colleges and from amongst the rest the students securing 50 per cent and above marks in the group subjects, viz. Physics. Chemistry and Biology should be selected according to merit from the respective regions tagged to the individual colleges and the remaining seats will be filled up by the meritorious students from the other regions.

2. Spot selection will be made by the Principal according to merit.

3. It is also decided that 15 per cent of the total number of seats will be reserved for lady students.

4. The Principals of the Colleges are being informed of the above decision.

Yours faithfully.

Under Secretary to Government S.P/14.8

IMMEDIATE

Memo No. 17146 (3)/H. dated 14th Aug. 1968

Copy forwarded to the Principals of the 8 Medical Colleges for information and immediate necessary action.

Under Secretary to Government.

7. In pursuance of the directive contained in the impugned Government let-fear, candidates who had obtained much lower marks than the petitioners were provisionally selected as appears from the lists published by the Principal, S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack, and which appeared in the issue of the Samaj dated August 17, 1968, for admission into the First Year M.B.B.S course of the three Medical Colleges of the State. This is dear from a scrutiny of the Index Register; for instance, the candidate bearing index number 271 who was selected obtained only 49.66 per cent whereas, as already shown, the candidate petitioner in O.J.C No. 825/68 (index No. 1180) who obtained 65.66 per cent on the basis of the determination of merit made according to paragraph 16 of the Notice, has been eliminated.

8. The points argued on behalf of the petitioners challenging the impugned Government letter are in substance these: The authority vested in the State and its officers who issued the Notice, though executive in character, is from its very nature an authority required to deal with the matter, namely selection of candidates, in a manner consonant with the basic concept of justice, equity and fair-play; the State and its officers are bound to act in accordance with the said Notice already issued as early as in June about two months before the selection in August; if there is failure on the part of the State or its officers to so act in accordance with the Notice or if their action is to the detriment of the citizen and in violation of the representations made in the Notice, then such action by or on behalf of the Government is open to scrutiny and rectification by this Court. Relying on the representations made in the Notice the candidates applied; they believed that the Government would carry out the said representations holding out a promise that the applications would be considered on the basis of merit to be determined by the marks obtained in the Science subjects (Medical group only) in the qualifying examination as aforesaid. In such a case the State has no power to alter the very basis of selection in the manner they have done by the issue of the impugned Government letter, on the other hand, the State was bound to honour the representations. The impugned Government letter and the action taken the pursuance of that letter were arbitrary end had introduced discrimination. It was further submitted that the conditions for admission as laid down in the Notice had the force of law.

9. It was further submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the impugned Government letter, though stated to have been issued for the purpose of providing guidance to the Selection Board, in fact only made provisions for different categories of unreasonable discrimination in the matter of Selection. Firstly, it laid down a process of elimination of students who obtained less than 50 per cent marks (in the aggregate) including subjects outside the Medical group in the qualifying examination (I.Sc or Pre-professional examination or its equivalent). It also involves unreasonable classification in that candidates with high marks in the Medical group only in the qualifying examination (I.Sc or Pre-professional or its equivalent) — merely because they may have obtained less than 50% in the aggregate—would be outright eliminated from being considered, while candidate with more than 50 per cent marks in humanities or Arts subjects (which have nothing to do with Medical group) but with marks less than 50 per cent in the Medical group of subjects would be preferred; such classification has no reasonable relationship with the object of selection for admission into Medical Colleges, namely that it must be beneficial to the Medical profession; in order to attain that object, the marks obtained in the subjects constituting the medical group only should be considered as provided in paragraph 16 of the Notice. This impugned process of elimination of students who obtained high percentage of marks in the medical group of the subjects because they obtained less than 50 per cent marks in the aggregate in the qualifying examination is unreasonably discriminatory; such outright elimination is unreasonable because such students, if they also possess B.Sc degree although given additional weightage in marks as provided in paragraph 16 of the Notice are still eliminated. The instructions in the impugned Government letter to shut out in one sweep all candidates securing below 50 per cent in the aggregate in the qualifying examination without giving any consideration to the marks obtained by them in the subjects under the medical group, has thus resulted in gross discrimination. Secondly, the impugned Government letter provides for discrimination on a regional basis, which is violative of the Constitution as offending Article 14. Thirdly, the provision in the impugned letter making reservation of 15 per cent of the total number of seats for lady candidates — not originally provided for in the Notice — could not be made subsequently so as to retrospectively affect the chances of otherwise qualified male candidates who applied on the basis of the representation in paragraph 16 of the Notice that selection would be made on the basis of merit as determined only by the marks and additional weightage as stated therein from among the eligible qualified candidates placed in order of merit irrespective of sex — male or female. In any event, such special reservation could not be made retrospectively so as to affect the rights of the better qualified male candidates.

10. It was also submitted that the Selection Board acted under pressure of a directive issued by the Government; in other words, the Selection Board as quasi judicial body was not free to act according to the procedure laid down in paragraph 16 of the Notice. It was stated that the selection was mala fide having been made on extraneous considerations and in pursuit of some illegitimate aim. But in the view that we have taken on the other points raised in these writ petitions, we do not think it necessary to express any opinion on the question of mala fide.

11. A preliminary objection was taken — though faintly — on behalf of the opposite parties, that the writ petitions are not maintainable by reason of the selected students not having been impleaded as opposite parties. In our opinion, the objection is not tenable. The notice in the Samaj publishing the lists of candidates selected states that the candidates were “provisionally selected” for admission into the First Year Class of the M.B.B.S course of the Medical Colleges of the State. It also states that the candidates should report themselves before the Principals of the Colleges for which they are selected on or before August 24, 1968 for medical examination and admission and if they failed to get themselves admitted by the stipulated period, their names would be expunged from the selection list. The selection being thus only provisional, the candidates in the provisional list cannot claim admission as of right. That apart, in the course of hearing we made it clear that the candidates who had already been admitted — as brought to our notice — would not be disturbed. That apart, in the view that we have taken of the scope of these writ petitions and the grant by us of declaratory relief there is no substance in the point questioning the maintainability of the petitions for non-joinder of parties.

12. Coming now to the merits, the impugned regionwise classification in the Government letter is in these terms:

“xxxxxx

the students securing 50 per cent and above marks in the group subjects viz., Physics, Chemistry and Biology should be selected according to merit from the respective regions tagged to the individual colleges and the remaining seats will be filled up by meritorious students from other regions.”

13. In our opinion, this provision for region-wise classification is directly hit by Article 14 of the Constitution. In the latest decision of the Supreme Court in P. Rajendran v. State of Madras, Writ Petn. Nos. 194, 196 and 202 of 1967 decided on January 17, 1968 : (AIR 1968 SC 1012) a similar provision made in the Rules for admission to the Medical Colleges in Madras State providing for district wise distribution of seats was struck down an violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. Their Lordships accepted the argument made on behalf of the petitioners that districtwise distribution violates Article 14 because it denies equality before the law or equal protection of the laws, inasmuch as such allocation of seats may result in candidates of inferior calibre being selected in one district while candidates of superior calibre cannot be selected in another district.

14. The reasoning on which their Lordships of the Supreme Court took the said view in the aforesaid case is in substance this: The question whether districtwise allocation is violative of Article 14 will depend on what is the object to be achieved in the matter of admission to Medical Colleges. Considering the fact that there is a larger number of candidates than seats available, selection has got to be made. The object of the selection must be to secure the best possible talent so that the country may have the best possible doctors. If that is the object, it must necessarily follow that object would be defeated if seats are allocated district by district. It is true that Article 14 does not forbid classification, but the classification has to be justified on the basis of nexus between the classification and the object to be achieved, even assuming that territorial classification may be a reasonable classification. Their Lordships also made it clear that the mere fact that the classification by itself is reasonable is not enough to support it unless there is nexus between the classification and the object to be achieved. Therefore, as the object to be achieved in a case of the kind with which we are concerned is to get the best talent for admission to professional colleges, allocation of seats districtwise has no reasonable relation with the object to be achieved, if anything, such classification will result in many cases in the object being destroyed, and if that is so, the classification, even if reasonable, would result in discrimination, inasmuch as better qualified candidates from one district may be rejected while less qualified candidates from other districts may be admitted.

15. We are satisfied that the opposite parties including the State of Orissa have made out no case for regionwise selection of students in the Medical Colleges. We are also satisfied that such selection results in discrimination and there is no nexus between territorial distribution and the object to be achieved, namely, admission of the best talent on the basis of the merit judged by marks obtained by candidates in the Science subjects (medical group) already indicated. We are accordingly of opinion that selection of candidates on regionwise basis is violative of Article 14 and no justification worth the name in support of the classification has been made out.

16. The said provision in the impugned Government letter relating to region-wise classification is also attacked as violative of Article 15(1) of the Constitution in so far as it makes a discrimination solely on the basis of place of birth as contended in paragraph 25(j) of O.J.C No. 823 of 1968 filed on August 20, 1968. Neither in counter-affidavit dated August 26, 1968 filed therein by the Under Secretary to the Government of Orissa, Health Department, nor in any of the four successive counter-affidavits in O.J.C No. 815 of 1968 (which were adopted as counters to the other writ petitions, all analogously heard) filed on behalf of the opposite parties on August 22, 23, 26 and 29, 1968, the specific averment that the impugned Government letter creates discrimination solely on the basis of place of birth made in the aforesaid paragraph 25(j) of the petition in O.J.C No. 823 of 1968 was denied or refuted. Thus, there having been no denial of the allegation made in paragraph 25(j) of the petition in O.J.C No. 823 of 1968 that the discrimination has been made solely on the basis of place of birth, that allegation must be taken to have been admitted by the opposite parties.

17. In our opinion, there is a good deal, of force in the argument that the aforesaid provision in the impugned Government letter is also violative of Article 15(1). This our view gains support from the fact that in the Index Register of candidates who applied for admission there are 5 columns, namely (1) Index No. (2) Name and address for correspondence of the student (3) Home district (4) Percentage and (5) Remark. Column 3 headed “Home district” is not without significance. Column 3 (“Home District”) — as distinct from column 2 “Name and address for correspondence of the student” — should be read with the relevant provision in the impugned Government letter directing that candidates should be selected according to merit “from the respective regions”. The phrase “from the respective regions” read with column 3 “Home District” of the Index Register and the specific averment in paragraph 25(j) of the writ petition O.J.C No. 823/68 not denied by the opposite parties is sufficiently indicative — and indeed conclusive—that the discrimination involved in the provision was solely on the ground of place of birth. In any case, the contention that the discrimination was solely on the basis of place of birth not having been controverted by the opposite parties in any of their several successive counter-affidavits, must be held to have been admitted; such discrimination is clearly violative of Article 15(1) also.

18. The next attack is on that part of the directive contained in the impugned Government letter laying down that:

“No student securing less than 50 per cent of marks in the Pre-professional examination should be entertained for admission into the medical colleges”.

19. The implication of this directive is that by this the Government totally eliminated a large number of candidates who were otherwise better qualified by reason of their having obtained higher marks in the Science subjects (medical group) with additional weightage for B.Sc candidates, all in accordance with the principles for determination of merit as represented in the Notice. Paragraph 16 of the Notice which contains the representation that selection would be made on the basis of merit as fully stated therein, is quoted below.

“16. The selection of candidates will be done by a Selection Board consisting of the Principals of the three Medical Colleges. The selection will be made on the basis of merit determined by the marks obtained by them in the Science subjects (Medical group only i.e Physics, Chemistry and Biology (Botany and Zoology)) in the qualifying examination, i.e, I. Sc or Pre-professional examination or an examination recognised as equivalent thereto. Additional weightage in the following manner may be given, provided that the total weightage for all items does not exceed 15 per cent in the case of a 1st Class B.Sc (Hons) candidate and 10 per cent in all other cases.

(a) B.Sc 1st Class (Hons) 10 Per cent B.Sc 2nd Class (Hons) 8 Per cent B.Sc (Distinction) 6 per cent B.Sc (Pass) 5 per cent

(b) Participation in the inter-University/State sports recognised by the Government of Orissa and certified by the principals of the Institutions last attended 5 per cent

(c) Children of the defence service personnel recruited during the emergency, i.e from 26th October, 1962 to 9th January, 1968 who have rendered approved military service as defined in the Political & Services Department Circular No. 6225(88) General dated the 2nd May, 1963, 5 per cent

(d) Holders of ‘B’ Class certificate in N.C.C 2 per cent Holders of ‘C Class Certificate in N.C.C 3 per cent

(certificates issued by the Group headquarters or by the Director, N.C.C will only be taken into consideration).

20. N.B — Qualifications & Sports, N.C.C certificates submitted at the time of application will only be considered.

(e) 5 marks will be deducted from the marks secured in the qualifying examination i.e I.Sc and Pre-professional for each failure.

21. The list of selected candidates will be notified in the College and published in the local dailies. Individuals will also be intimated in the address given by them to take admission”.

22. It was argued on behalf of the opposite parties that the power of the Government to change the rules for admission cannot be restricted on the ground that the representation held out by Government in the Notice had not been carried out; that the Government is the sole Judge of the validity of its actions, and that the candidates who acted on the representations made in the Notice, have no right except what the Government choose to recognise or accept. This exalted claim about the nature of the authority claimed by the Government requires examination.

23. The question is: Once the candidates have acted on the said representation made in the Notice and relying on the same had made applications for admission on the basis thereof, can the Government later on abruptly to the detriment of the candidates give a directive to the Selection Board purporting to eliminate the better qualified candidates who have secured high marks in the Science subjects (Medical group) with additional weightage for B.Sc candidates? In our opinion, the Government cannot so change the rules abruptly in the manner done. The reasons are these: It is not the case of the Government that the representations made in the Notice were subject to any condition that Government would not be bound to admit students on the basis of merit as determined by marks obtained in the Medical group of Science subjects, if the Government deem it inexpedient to make admissions on that basis. We are unable to accept the argument that the Government is not bound to honour the said representation, relying on which the candidates acted to their detriment in our opinion, assuming that the power of the Government in issuing the directives to the concerned authorities is executive in character, even so when it was represented by Government in the Notice that selection for admission will be made on the basis of merit as determined by marks obtained in the Science subjects (Medical group only) in the qualifying examination, the Court has the power to direct the concerned authorities to honour the said representation made to the candidates who had acted on such representation and have been denied the consideration which was due to them on the basis of marks obtained by them in the Medical group of Science subjects. If the Government had acted arbitrarily in issuing their directive in their impugned letter, it is open to judicial review. Where the candidates have acted to that prejudice upon a representation made in the Notice, their claim to be considered on the basis of marks obtained by them in the medical group of subjects cannot be arbitrarily rejected.

24. In such a case, the Court is competent to grant relief in appropriate cases if, contrary to the representation made in the Notice, the concerned authorities decline to consider the applications on the basis of that representation. Therefore, even assuming that the representations in the Notice offering inducement to the prospective medical students are in character executive, the Government and its officers are, on the authorities of the Supreme Court, not entitled at their mere whim to ignore the said representations made in the Notice. We cannot therefore accept the argument that the Government is the sole judge in such matters and that the Courts are powerless to grant relief if due consideration is not given to the applications of the petitioners who acted to their prejudice relying on the representations in the Notice. To concede to the concerned authorities that power is to strike at the very root of the rule of law. The authority of the concerned authorities even though executive in character, was from its nature an authority to deal with the matter in manner consonant with the basic concept of justice and fairplay; if they made an order subsequently which was not consonant with the basic concept of justice and fairplay, their action is open to scrutiny and rectification by the courts.

25. While taking this view, we must make it clear that the petitioners are not seeking to enforce any contractual right; they are only seeking to enforce compliance with the representations made in the Notice. We are of the view that even if the power of the concerned authorities is executive in character, the petitioners are entitled to resort to the Court and claim that the said representations in the Notice be ordered to be honoured.

26. Thus, the claim of the petitioners is appropriately founded upon the equity which arises in their favour as a result of the representations made on behalf of the Government in the Notice and the action taken by the petitioners acting upon the said representations under the belief that the concerned authorities would carry out the representations made by them or on their behalf. On the fact proved in this case, no ground has been suggested before us for exempting the Government or the concerned authorities from the equity arising out of acts done by the petitioners to their prejudice relying upon the representations. The Government and the authorities concerned are thus estopped from issuing the impugned letter which rules of equity and good conscience prevent them from using against the candidates including the petitioners. The Government is not exempt from liability to carry out the representations in the Notice as to the basis of merit on marks for selection and they cannot on some undefined and undisclosed ground of necessity or expediency fail to carry out the said representations made in the Notice nor claim to be the sole judge of their own implied commitment or obligation to the candidates on an ex parte appraisement of the circumstances in which the claim of the petitioners founded upon the equity has arisen.

27. So having made the representation that if a candidate satisfied the standard or criteria set up for selection of candidates as stated in paragraph 16 of the Notice, it is not open to the concerned authorities to retract from the same — as they purported to do here — by the issue of the impugned Government letter. By the representations in the Notice the petitioners were led into the belief that they had good chance of being selected, having obtained a reasonably high percentage of marks in the Science subjects (Medical group only) in the qualifying examination with additional weightage in the case of B.Sc candidates all as represented in the Notice. It is not denied that some of the petitioners did obtain a high percentage of marks in the Science subjects medical group in the qualifying examination as recorded in the index Register. But for the assurance or representation made in the Notice, they would have applied to other Colleges and, in all probability, might have secured admission. In these circumstances, we feel that the principle of legal or equitable estoppel would apply to this case.

28. This our view is fully supported by the principles underlying the decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Anglo Afgan Agencies, AIR 1968 SC 718 and also a Division Bench decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Kumari Akhtar v. Principal, Osmania Medical College, AIR 1959 Andh Pra 493.

29. The petitioners also attack the Government directive in the impugned letter which makes a special provision for lady students and lays down that

“it was also decided that 15 per cent of the total number of seats will be reserved for lady students”.

30. In the Notice there was no special provision for reservation of seats for lady candidates. The Notice only provided for selection on the basis of merit determined by marks as laid down in paragraph 16; the only reservation made was for candidates belonging to scheduled castes and scheduled tribes and a few nominees of the Government of India, and the other State Governments against a limited number of reserved seats. Under the scheme of the Notice, lady candidates have to take their chances along with other candidates in open competition on merit on the basis of marks as provided therein. In fact, having regard to the high marks obtained by the lady students as appears from the Index Register inasmuch as a large number of lady students obtained more than 60 per cent the highest marks obtained by a lady student being 76 per cent, whereas the highest marks obtained by a male student is 79.55 per cent — there appears to be no compelling necessity for making a special provision for lady students. Even in spite of this position if the Government had still contemplated making a special provision for lady candidates for admission into the Medical Colleges, they could have done so when they issued the Notice on June 22, 1968. It is not open to the Government now to make any such special reservation as they purport to do in the impugned Government letter because in that event, in open competition on merit it will affect the chance of candidates in general who would otherwise have been selected strictly on merit on, the basis of marks as laid down in paragraph 16 of the Notice, without any special consideration or weightage being given to women candidates as such. Therefore, as in the case of other impugned provisions the principle of legal or equitable estoppel must, for the same reasons, equally apply to the provision in the impugned letter purporting to reserve a certain percentage of seats for lady students. In any event, such a provision for reservation, even if otherwise justified as reasonable, cannot, in the circumstances of the present case, be permitted to retrospectively affect the chances of selection of candidates who, along with women applicants, had already applied on the basis of the representations made in paragraph 16 of the Notice.

31. There is no doubt that the directives contained in the impugned Government letter — on the basis of which the selections have been made — have, on account of the various processes of discrimination as indicated above, operated to the detriment of the petitioners affecting not only their chances of selection but also perhaps their ranking in order of merit. Therefore leaving aside the allegation of mala fide which it is not the practice of this Court to investigate unless a strong case is made out — there is sufficient justification for interference by this Court.

32. Ultimately, the position comes to this: The impugned Government letter dated August 14, 1968, as violative of the provisions of the Constitution and as otherwise illegal, is struck down and has to be ignored. The concerned authorities are to make selection of candidates for admission into the First Year M.B.B.S course of the three Medical Colleges during this year (1968) on the basis of merit according to the provisions contained in paragraph 16 of the Notice. In this context, for the guidance of the concerned authorities, paragraph 9 of the Notice needs some clarification. That paragraph reads as follows:

“9. Subject to the condition that the 1st twenty students in order of merit will be given the option to apply and join any of the three medical colleges, the rest of the candidates belonging to the undermentioned districts and places shall be selected for admission to the colleges as noted against each.

(a) Balasore, New Capital, Cuttack, Keonjhar and Mayurbhanj S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack. (b) Bolangir Dhenkanal Kalahandi, Sambalpur and Sundergarh Burla Medical College. (c) Ganjam, Koraput, Phulbani, Puri (excluding New Capital) Medical College, Berhampur.

33. Remaining meritorious students of the aforesaid districts who cannot be admitted in the Medical Colleges as noted above, will be directed to take admission in other Colleges where there may be vacancies”.

34. It was stated by the learned Government Advocate that 400 students are to be admitted in the three Medical Colleges this year, the respective quotas for the three colleges being 150 students for the S.C.B Medical College, Cuttack; 150 for the Burla Medical College; and 100 for the Medical College, Berhampur.

35. Paragraph 9 of the Notice to terms and read with paragraph 2, contemplates that only one list of candidates — selected strictly in order of merit as provided in paragraph 16 — has to be prepared without making any distinction between male and female candidates. This is apparent from the condition that the first twenty students selected in order of merit have the option to join any of the three colleges; unless such a single common list is prepared, selection of the first twenty meritorious students will not be possible. After taking out these twenty candidates from the list for the purpose mentioned above, the paragraph proceeds to provide for the admission of the “rest of the candidates”. The “rest of the candidates” in the context would obviously mean the others left out in the said single list prepared on the basis of merit, who have to be allotted, for the purpose of admission, in order of merit, in the various colleges as mentioned in the said paragraph. That this is the intention is also clear from the use of the expression “remaining meritorious students” occurring in the last sub-paragraph of paragraph 9. The word “remaining” in the context can only mean those candidates left out, in the single list prepared on the basis of merit. The scheme underlying paragraph 9, therefore, is that out of a single list prepared of all selected candidates, in order of merit, the first twenty should be given the choice to join any of the colleges they liked; for the remaining seats, allotment will be made from out of the remaining candidates in order of merit in the same list, to the various colleges in the manner indicated in paragraph 9; and if after that some more seats still remain to be filled up, allotment will be made again from the same list, strictly in order of merit, to the Medical Colleges at the discretion of the authorities.

36. It is clear therefore from a reading of paragraph 9 of the Notice that the concerned authorities have to take steps to prepare only one single list of candidates, selected in order of merit in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 16 and after giving the option to the first twenty candidates to choose any of the colleges, the remaining selected candidates in the said list are to be allotted in order of merit to the three Medical Colleges in the manner indicated therein and as clarified above. If the selection of candidates is itself made on a territorial basis — districtwise or regionwise — that will be open to objection as violating the Constitution for reasons already discussed, but once selection is made strictly on the basis of merit as provided in paragraph 16 and one single list of candidates is prepared, in order of merit on the basis of such selection, there can be no objection to allotment of the candidates to the various Medical Colleges in the manner indicated in paragraph 9 which is a matter of convenience. This, in our opinion, is what is provided in that paragraph.

37. In this view of the matter and on a reasonable interpretation of paragraph 9 of the Notice in the light of the legal principles as discussed above, the concerned authorities are directed to implement and give effect to the same in the manner as hereinafter indicated.

38. It is declared that the impugned Government letter dated August 14, 1968, is invalid as violative of the provisions of the Constitution and otherwise illegal, and it is accordingly struck down, and the list of candidates provisionally selected in pursuance of the impugned Government letter is declared void and inoperative. The concerned authorities are directed to make the selections and allotment of seats strictly in accordance with the Notice dated June 22, 1968, including paragraph 9 as interpreted in the manner indicated above and paragraph 16 thereof.

39. The concerned authorities are accordingly directed to implement this our decision as indicated below:

(a) There will be one single list in order of merit of all selected candidates (including therein lady candidates) drawn up on the basis of merit as determined by marks obtained by them in the Science subjects (Medical group only i.e Physics, Chemistry and Biology (Botany and Zoology) in the qualifying examination or any examination recognised as equivalent thereto) after giving additional weightage as is due to them — all according to paragraph 16 of the Notice.

(b) Then, the first twenty candidates in order of merit out of the aforesaid list will be given the option to join any of the three Medical Colleges in the State.

(c) As regards the allotment of candidates to the remaining seats in the three colleges (after the allotment of the first twenty candidates as above), the required number of candidates for admission this year will be adjusted from the said list strictly in order of merit, in accordance with paragraph 9 as interpreted by us.

(d) If after such adjustment there are still any vacancies in the respective quotas of the three colleges, such vacancies may be filled up from the remaining selected candidates, strictly in order of merit in the said list, the actual allotment being left to the discretion of the authorities concerned.

(e) The students already admitted into the three colleges — whose cases were brought to our notice at the time of the hearing of these writ petitions — are not to be disturbed.

40. The concerned authorities are also directed to apply to the appropriate authorities of the University concerned for reasonable extension of time for admission of students into the Medical Colleges in view of the special circumstances. We trust that all concerned including the University authorities will implement the decision of this Court regarding selection, allotment and admission of students into the Medical Colleges this year (1968) according to the Notice of June 22, 1968, and the directions given above.

41. We further direct that the selection of candidates, allotment of candidates to the Medical Colleges in accordance with the above directions, and the publication of the list are all to be completed by September 12, 1968 at the latest.

42. Before closing this judgment we would remind the concerned authorities of the following observations of Mr. Justice Hidayatullah (as he then was) in a judgment of the Supreme Court:

“xxxxxx

43. If equality and equal protection before the law has any meaning, and if our public institutions are to inspire that confidence which is expected of them, we will be failing in our duty if we did not, even at the cost of considerable inconvenience to Government and the selected candidates, do the right thing. If any blame for the inconvenience is to be placed, it certainly cannot be placed upon the petitioning candidates, the candidates whom this order displaces, or this Court.”:(Sri Channabasaviah v. State of Mysore, AIR 1965 SC 1293).

44. In the result, therefore, the writ petitions are allowed in terms as aforesaid. The petitioners are entitled to one set of consolidated costs, and one hearing fee which we assess at Rs. 200.

45. Acharya, J.:— I agree.

K.S.B

46. Petitions allowed.