Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ladi Jagannadham v. Padmabati Baurani .

Orissa High Court
Oct 28, 1960
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — S. Barman, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The present Miscellaneous Appeal was filed by the Employer (appellant) against an order of the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, Koraput dated 15 September 1958, which granted compensation of Rs. 2,400 to the widow (respondent) of a deceased worker under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (Act VIII of 1923).

Material facts as found in the record: on 27 January 1954 the deceased, described as a Khalasi engaged in piling paddy bags at Trinath Rice Mill, Gunupur (Koraput district), was allegedly crushed when a paddy bag fell on him; he died on the same day. The widow claimed that the deceased earned Rs. 2 to Rs. 3 per day and was about 35 years old at death. The Commissioner awarded compensation on the basis of these earnings and applicable provisions of the Act.

The employer appealed, disputing two principal points: (1) that the deceased was not a workman of the Rice Mill (possibly employed by government agents/sub-agents), and (2) that the death did not result from the alleged accident but from alcohol poisoning as indicated by a doctor's certificate and a chemical examiner's report. The respondent (claimant) did not appear in this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the deceased fell within the statutory definition of "workman" under section 2(1)(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, read with Schedule II.
  2. Whether the deceased's death resulted from an accident arising out of and in the course of employment, rendering the employer liable under section 3(1)(b)(i), or whether it was excluded as being directly attributable to the workman being under the influence of drink or drugs.
  3. Whether the employer could be held liable if the deceased was employed by an agent or sub-agent (issue raised with reference to section 12(1) of the Act).
  4. The correct quantum of compensation under section 4 read with Schedule IV, and the relevant exercise of power under section 10-A(4).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Employer) Arguments

  • The deceased was not a workman of the Rice Mill but a casual worker or an employee of government-appointed agents or sub-agents who stored paddy at the Mill; hence the Mill (employer) was not liable.
  • Even if employed at the Mill, the deceased was not in the course of employment at the time of death.
  • The death resulted from over-drinking and alcohol poisoning, not from an accident; this was said to be supported by a doctor's certificate and the Chemical Examiner's report showing presence of alcohol and a smell of country liquor.
  • No external injuries were found on the body, supporting the contention that death was due to alcohol poisoning rather than crushing by a falling bag.
  • The Mill was not registered as a factory and, the employer contended, was not required to maintain a muster-roll; further, although they referenced rolls in their statement, those rolls were not produced.
  • Reliance was placed on section 12(1) of the Act in support of the proposition that liability may rest with a sub-agent rather than the Mill.

Respondent's (Claimant) Arguments / Evidence

  • The widow and fellow workmen testified that the deceased was employed by the Rice Mill and regularly attended except on Sundays; the widow stated he worked for the Mill and not for any other person.
  • Eye-witness testimony described finding the deceased with paddy bags lying over him and that removal of the bags revealed he had been crushed; these witnesses supported the claim that death was caused by a falling bag while engaged in Mill work.
  • The claimant relied on the earnings asserted (Rs. 2–3 per day) and consequent calculation of compensation under Schedule IV and section 4 of the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in logical stages directly tied to statutory definitions and the evidence on record.

1. Definition of "workman": The court considered section 2(1)(n) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, which defines "workman" and referred to Schedule II as illustrative of the capacities that qualify a person as a workman. The court emphasized that Schedule II is illustrative and must be read with the provision.

2. Evaluation of evidence on employment status: The Commissioner had heard five witnesses for the claimant, including three fellow workmen and the widow, whose evidence indicated the deceased worked for the Rice Mill and regularly attended work. P.W.3 specifically stated regular attendance except Sundays. Although the employer's counter-petition referenced employee rolls, the rolls were not produced. The court treated non-production of those rolls (despite the Mill being operational for years) as adverse to the employer. The employer also called five witnesses (partners, sub-agent, supplier, clerk), but the court found these to be interested witnesses and their evidence unreliable. On this basis the court accepted the Commissioner's finding that the deceased was a workman within the meaning of the Act.

3. Causation — accident versus alcohol poisoning: The court examined section 3(1)(b)(i), which makes an employer liable for personal injury caused by an accident arising out of and in the course of employment, subject to the exclusion where injury is directly attributable to the workman being under the influence of drink or drugs. The claimant's witnesses gave direct evidence that a heavy bag fell upon the deceased, crushing him. A doctor (O.P.W.5) noted one abrasion on the body. The court observed that the impact of a heavy bag can cause fatal injury without leaving extensive external injuries; therefore the absence of multiple external injuries did not preclude a fatal crushing injury.

The court explicitly weighed the employer's evidence (doctor's certificate and chemical examiner's report indicating smell or presence of alcohol) against the positive eyewitness testimony. It held that the mere presence of smell of country liquor or some alcohol detected by the chemical examiner was insufficient to outweigh the direct, positive eyewitness evidence of the accident. Consequently, the court rejected the employer's contention that death was due to alcohol poisoning.

4. Admissibility of an inspection report: The opinion notes an inspection report dated 8 June 1954 which the employer contended was inadmissible. The court stated that the respondent did not explain how the document came before the Commissioner. However, the court declined to express an opinion on admissibility because its decision on the merits rested on sufficient other evidence.

5. Quantum of compensation: The court considered section 4(1)(a) and Schedule IV (relating to rates of compensation where death results from injury) and section 10-A(4) (powers of the Commissioner). The Commissioner had fixed compensation at Rs. 2,400 on the basis of the deceased's daily wages of Rs. 2–3 (equated to approximately Rs. 75 per month as permitted under Schedule IV). The court found the Commissioner’s method and the award to be based on sound principle and reasonable, and therefore declined to interfere with the quantum.

On the whole of this evidence and legal framework, the court affirmed the Commissioner's findings that the deceased was a workman and that death resulted from an accident arising out of and in the course of employment, making the employer liable to pay the compensation awarded.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Direct effects and immediate consequences:

  • The decision of the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, Koraput dated 15 September 1958 awarding Rs. 2,400 to the widow is upheld.
  • The employer's appeal is dismissed and the employer remains liable for the compensation awarded by the Commissioner.
  • No order as to costs of the appeal was made because the respondent did not appear.

The opinion does not announce or rely upon any novel legal principle or reported precedent; it applies statutory definitions and evidentiary evaluation to affirm the Commissioner's factual findings and the compensation award.

Show all summary ...

S. Barman, J.:— The Employer is the appellant, in this Misc. Appeal, from an order of the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, Koraput, dated September 15, 1958 allowing compensation to the widow of the workman (respondent herein) under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (Act VIII of 1923) of a sum of Rs. 2,400/- under the said Act.

2. The claim of the respondent,—who is the widow of the alleged workman, arose thus: while her husband, on January 27, 1954 was piling up paddy bags as a Khalasi in the Trinath Rice Mill, Gunupur, in the district of Koraput, one bag is alleged to have fallen over him, as a result of which he died, on the same day. The claimant's case is that her husband was earning Rs. 2/- to Rs. 3/- per day. The deceased workman is stated to be aged about 35 years at the time of his death.

3. The deceased workman's widow claimed lump sum of Rs. 2,400/- on the basis of remuneration that the husband was earning from his employment at the rice mill. The defence to the claim,—as stated by the employer, which is Trinath Rice Mill, of whom the appellant Ladi Jagannadham is a partner,—is that the deceased was not a workman of the employer; that the Government had employed agents and sub-agents for procuring paddy; these agents are stated to have stored paddy in the Rice Mill for the purpose of being converted into rice; if at all, the workman was an employee of the agent or sub-agent and not of the Rice Mill; that the accident did not take place during the course of employment; that as a matter of fact the deceased Khalasi died not on account of the accident, but due to over drinking and alcohol poisoning as,—according to the employer,—is shown by the doctor's certificate and the chemical examiner's report; that in short, death was not due to fall of bag but due to alcohol poisoning and that there was no external injury on the body of the deceased.

4. The Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation,—on the evidence adduced before him found that the deceased workman died from the accident; that he was workman under the Rice Mill and was entitled to a sum of Rs. 2,400/- on the basis that he was earning Rs. 2/- to Rs. 3/- per day, that is to say Rs. 75/- per month on an average, as permissible under Schedule IV read with section 4 of the Act. Hence the appeal by the employer.

5. Mr. N.V Ramdas learned counsel for the employer, first contended that the deceased was not a workman of the Rice Mill and further that he did not die as a result of the accident as alleged.

6. On the question,—whether the deceased was a workman,—the point has to be considered in the light of the definition of ‘workman’ as defined in the Workmen's Compensation Act, section 2(1)(n) of the Act defines ‘workman’ to mean any person (other than a person whose employment is of a casual nature and who is employed otherwise than for the purpose of employer's trade or business) who is employed on monthly wages not exceeding Rs. 400/- in any such capacity as is specified in Schedule II of the Act, whether the contract of employment was made before or after the passing of the Act and whether such contract is express or implied, oral or in writing.

7. In this regard Schedule II,— which gives a list of persons, who subject to the provisions of section 2(1)(n) are included in the definition of ‘workman’; is also to be taken into consideration; the Schedule gives a list of persons who are to be deemed as workman within the meaning of section 2(1)(n); it gives a comprehensive list which though not exhaustive is certainly illustrative of the nature of the work which makes an employee a workman within the meaning of the Act.

8. Mr. Ramdas's contention in this regard is that the deceased was not a regular employee of the Rice Mill but was only a casual worker of the Rice Mill. The learned counsel also relies on section 12(1) of the Act, in support of his proposition, that if the deceased was a workman of the subagent, the employer cannot be made liable for the accident caused to the employee of the sub-agent.

9. On the question whether the deceased was a workman, five witnesses were called, on behalf of the claimant, including three fellow workmen of the deceased, namely, P.Ws 1, 2 and 3 and also P.W 5 the widow herself. The evidence of these witnesses is to the effect that the deceased was a workman of the Rice Mill in their employment. The evidence of the widow P.W 5 is that her husband was working for the Rice Mill and not for any other person.

10. In this context, I notice the evidence of P.W 3, who states that the deceased was regularly attending the Mill except on Sundays when the Rice Mill was closed. Apart from evidence, even from the counter petition filed by the employer, it appears that the deceased's engagement was of a casual nature though he was not a regular employee under the Rice Mill. In paragraph 1 of the statement filed by the employer there is a reference to the rolls of the employees of the Mill, which, however, has not been produced to show the names of the employees which actually have been entered in the rolls of the workmen of the establishment.

11. The alleged non-mention of the deceased Khalasi's name in the rolls of the workmen of the Mill would have supported the employer's case that the deceased was not a regular worker of the Mill in its rolls. The non-production of the rolls of the employees, certainly leads to certain presumption against the employer on the point. The employer takes the stand that the Mill having not been registered as a factory, under the Factories Act, it was not required to maintain a muster-roll of the workmen working in the Mill.

12. That, however, is no explanation for their not producing the rolls of the employees of the Mill referred to in the said statement. It is in evidence that this Mill has been working for the last 10 years from 1944. Therefore it is not believable that the Mill did not preserve any rolls of their employees who were engaged in the concern. In any event, the fact of their not producing the rolls, goes against the employer on the question whether the deceased was a workman or not.

13. On this point, the employer also called five witnesses, including the partners of the Mill being O.P.W 1, the sub-agent, O.P.W 2, paddy supplier O.P.W 3, and the Clerk of the Mill O.P.W 4. The evidence of none of these persons is reliable, because they are all interested witnesses. In this view of the evidence I accept the finding of the Commissioner, that the deceased was a workman within the meaning of the Act.

14. On the question,—whether the deceased died due to the accident as alleged,—the Act provides for the employer's liability for compensation as provided in section 3(1)(b)(i) which lays down that if a personal injury is caused to a workman, by accident arising out of or in the course of employment, his employer is liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of Chapter II of the Act, provided that the employer shall not be so liable, in respect of any injury, not resulting in death caused by an accident which is directly attributable to the workman having been at the time under the influence of drink or drugs.

15. In the present case, the evidence, called on behalf of the claimant, proves that on the date of the accident the deceased came to the Mill in the usual course and was carrying paddy bags, in course of which, one of the bags fell on him and he was crushed thereunder. A fellow workman P.W 1 said that he along with others had found the deceased lying on the floor of the Mill with some bags over him; that after removal of the bags, the Khalasis carried the body of the deceased to the office room; the evidence of the claimant's witnesses clearly shows that there can be no mistake about the fact of the accident due to which the deceased died.

16. In this context the evidence of the doctor O.P.W 5 has to be taken into consideration. According to his evidence there was one abrasion on the body of the deceased. The nature of the accident due to the fall of bag is such that it is quite possible that death can be caused without external injury due to the impact of the heavy bag on the body of the deceased. Thus viewed, the absence of any other external injury on the body of the deceased does not rule out the possibility of death due to the fall of the bag without leaving external injuries.

17. It is thus clear from evidence that the deceased died due to the accident in course of his employment under the Mill. It is clear from the evidence of the deceased's fellow-workmen that the deceased died due to the fall of heavy bag on him. In the face of such direct evidence of fall of a heavy bag on the deceased which crushed him to death, I do not accept the employer's case of the deceased having died due to over drinking and alcohol poisoning as alleged.

18. The mere presence of smell of country liquor on opening the stomach of the deceased, as found in the post-mortem report or detection of some alcohol by the Chemical Examiner, is not enough to outweigh the positive evidence of the eye witnesses to the accident. I am satisfied that, whatever may be the reason of smell of country liquor or presence of alcohol, — the immediate cause of the deceased's death was the said accident.

19. My above view on both these points is also supported by certain passages from an inspection report dated June 8, 1954 which, according to Mr. Ramdas, is not admissible in evidence. The respondent claimant not having appeared in this appeal, there is no explanation forthcoming how this document came to be introduced in the proceedings before the Commissioner. On the question of admissibility, I do not want to express my opinion because my decision, on merits, is based on sufficient evidence.

20. As to the amount of compensation, section 4(1)(a) of the Act provides that the amount shall be, where death results from injury in the case of an adult in receipt of monthly wages falling within limits shown in the first column of Schedule IV — the amount shown against such limits in the second column thereof; the other relevant provision in this context is section 10-A(4) which gives powers to the Commissioner as provided in that section.

21. In the present case, the Commissioner came to the conclusion that the claimant is entitled to Rs. 2,400/- on the basis of his daily wages of Rs. 2/- to Rs. 3/- per day. I am satisfied that the compensation awarded to the claimant was based a sound principle as provided for in Schedule IV of the Act and is reasonable. Therefore I do not propose to interfere with the finding of the Commissioner on the question of amount of compensation.

22. In conclusion, therefore, the decision of the Commissioner is upheld. This appeal is accordingly dismissed. The respondent not having appeared, I make no order as to costs of this appeal.

23. Appeal dismissed.