- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sarvajanik Jan Kalyan Parmarthik Nyas v. State Of M.P And Others
Case Summary: Writ Petition Concerning Registration of Annexure/P-1
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner purchased immovable property from respondent No. 4 by a sale deed executed on 24-6-2005 (Annexure/P-1). The sale deed was presented for registration before the Sub-Registrar, Bhopal. The Collector of Stamps initially directed payment of deficit stamp duty of Rs. 97,13,400/-. On appeal to the Commissioner, Bhopal Division, this amount was reduced to Rs. 54,86,897/ (order dated 26-10-2005). The Board of Revenue maintained that reduction on 18-5-2006. The petitioner deposited an additional stamp duty of Rs. 54,86,947/- on 12-6-2006 (challan dated 12th June, 2006).
The Nazul Officer, Bhopal (respondent No. 4) informed the Collector of Stamps by letter dated 28-6-2006 that a case regarding the subject land was pending before him and requested that registration of the document not be taken. The Sub-Registrar communicated to the petitioner's counsel that the pending Nazul case should be disposed of for registration to proceed. Although there was no formal order refusing registration, the petitioner filed an appeal with the District Registrar (by post because not entertained by hand). The District Registrar replied on 7-9-2006 that in the absence of an order of refusal to register Annexure/P-1, no appeal could be entertained.
Aggrieved by this sequence of events, the petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking a direction that registration of Annexure/P-1 not be denied on account of the alleged pendency of the Nazul dispute.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Sub-Registrar is empowered to refuse to register Annexure/P-1 on the ground that a dispute as to title in respect of the land is pending before the Nazul Officer.
- Whether absence of title in the vendor (i.e., that the document deals with property not belonging to the person by whom it purports to have been executed) is a valid ground for refusal of registration under the Registration Act and the M.P. Registration Rules, 1939 (specifically Rules 35 and 36).
- Whether the petitioner should have resorted to appeal provisions under the Registration Act (sections 72, 76) or instituted proceedings under section 77 instead of filing the writ petition.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Petitioner's) Arguments — Shri Alok Aradhe (Senior Counsel)
- The Sub-Registrar was duty bound to register Annexure/P-1 since the requisite stamp duty had been paid.
- There is no provision in the statute or rules empowering the Sub-Registrar to refuse registration on the ground of a pending title dispute; the reason given by the Sub-Registrar was illegal and arbitrary.
Respondents' Arguments — Shri P.N. Dubey (Deputy Advocate General)
- The Sub-Registrar was within his powers to refuse registration because the title of the land is disputed and the vendor may not be competent to execute the sale deed for want of title.
- The grounds enumerated in Rule 35 are not exhaustive, so there may be valid reasons for refusal beyond those listed.
- The petitioner ought to have preferred an appeal under section 76 of the Registration Act, or alternatively could have instituted suit under section 77.
- The subject land is Government land, and registering the document could prejudice the State's interest; registration might allow mutation and dealings to the detriment of the Government.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the statutory framework governing registration and the powers/duties of registering officers:
- Part XII of the Registration Act, 1908 governs the powers of the Sub-Registrar to register documents. Section 71 requires that any Sub-Registrar refusing to register a document (except for jurisdictional reasons) make an order of refusal, record reasons in Book No. 2, endorse the document with "registration refused", and provide a copy of reasons to a person executing or claiming under the document. Section 72 makes an order of refusal appealable.
- Under section 69 of the Registration Act, the M.P. Registration Rules, 1939 were framed. Rule 35 enumerates valid reasons for refusal. Importantly, Rule 36 expressly provides that registration shall not be refused on various grounds, including that the document deals with property not belonging to the person by whom it purports to have been executed (i.e., absence of title).
- The court observed that the vendor had not denied execution of Annexure/P-1; rather, the Sub-Registrar refused to register the document on the ground that a title dispute was pending before the Nazul Officer.
- Applying Rules 35 and 36 together with the statutory scheme, the court concluded that the Sub-Registrar has no authority to refuse registration solely because the vendor lacks title or because a title dispute is pending. Rule 36 specifically prevents refusal on account of a document dealing with property not belonging to the executant, and thus absence of title is an expressly invalid ground for refusal.
- The court addressed the respondents' contention that Rule 35 is not exhaustive and that other valid reasons might exist. While acknowledging that Rule 35 may not be exhaustive, the court emphasized that Rule 36 contains an express prohibition on refusal for absence of title, and therefore the Sub-Registrar's action in withholding registration on that ground amounted to dereliction of duty.
- Regarding procedural remedies suggested by the respondents (appeal under section 76 or suit under section 77), the court noted that the District Registrar correctly declined to entertain the petitioner's appeal because no formal order of refusal had been made. The court also found that no right to sue had accrued to the petitioner under the grounds enumerated in section 77.
- On the Government-land objection, the court observed that although the State might have legitimate concerns, the mere pendency of a Nazul case did not justify the Sub-Registrar's refusal. The court noted the Nazul Officer's letter of 28-6-2006 showing a pending dispute, but also remarked that more than a year had passed without reported developments and that the Government retained the ability to take protective action even after registration.
- Balancing these considerations, the court directed that, absent any restraint order from a court of competent jurisdiction, the Sub-Registrar should register Annexure/P-1 in accordance with law within a specified period after a certified copy of the judgment is provided.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Writ petition allowed; the Sub-Registrar is directed to register Annexure/P-1 subject to the conditions stated in the order.
Direct consequences and implementation:
- The writ petition was allowed and the court directed that, in the absence of any restraint order from a court having competent jurisdiction, respondent No. 1 (the Sub-Registrar) shall register the document contained in Annexure/P-1 within one week after the expiry of one month from the date of the judgment, upon receipt of a certified copy of the order, and in accordance with law.
- Respondents were directed to take appropriate action for protection of the interest of the Government within the one-month period; the court fixed one month for that purpose.
- No order as to costs was made.
Broader implications: The court expressly interpreted the Registration Act and M.P. Registration Rules to conclude that a Sub-Registrar cannot refuse registration merely because a title dispute is pending or because the executant may not hold title. The opinion did not set out additional broader consequences beyond the direct relief granted to the petitioner and directions to the respondents to take protective measures if necessary.
1. Facts involved in the petition are in very narrow compass. Petitioner purchased an immovable property from respondent No. 4 on 24-6-2005. Sale deed was executed by respondent No. 4 as revealed in Annexure/P-1 and was presented for registration before the Sub-Registrar, Bhopal. He referred it to the Collector of. Stamps, who vide order dated 31-8-2005 directed for payment of deficit stamp duty to the extent of Rs. 97,13,400/-. An appeal was preferred before the Commissioner, Bhopal Division, Bhopal who vide his order dated 26-10-2005 reduced the amount of additional stamp duty to Rs. 54,86,897/-. This order was maintained by the Board of Revenue on 18-5-2006. Accordingly, the petitioner on 12-6-2006 deposited an additional stamp duty to the tune of Rs. 54,86,947/- vide challan dated 12th June, 2006. Nazul Officer, Bhopal (respondent No. 4) vide his communication dated 28-6-2006 informed the Collector of Stamps that the case with respect to the subject land proposed to be transferred in favour of petitioner is pending before him and therefore, no action for registration of the document be taken. Accordingly, the Sub-Registrar, Bhopal informed the petitioner's counsel that the pending case before the Court of Nazul may be got disposed of expeditiously in order to enable him to proceed with the registration of Annexure/P-1. Although, there was no order refusing to register Annexure/P-1, the petitioner by way of abundant precaution, submitted an appeal before District Registrar, Bhopal. This appeal was preferred by post because it was not entertained by hand. However, the District Registrar, Bhopal vide his letter dated 7-9-2006 informed the petitioner that in the absence an order of refusal to register Annexure/P-1, no appeal can be entertained.
2. Aggrieved by the aforesaid event, the present writ petition has been submitted on the ground that the registration of the sale deed contained in Annexure/P-1 cannot be legally denied on account of alleged pendency of dispute in the Court of Nazul at Bhopal of the land proposed to be sold/conveyed through Annexure/P-1.
3. Shri Alok Aradhe, learned senior counsel and Shri P.N Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General made their respective submissions.
4. Shri Aradhe, learned senior counsel contended that Sub-Registrar is duty bound to make registration of Annexure/P-1 since, the requisite stamp duty has already been paid. According to the learned senior counsel there is absolutely no provision which empowers the Sub-Registrar to refuse the registration of Annexure/P-1 and the reason assigned by him is totally illegal and arbitrary.
5. Per contra Shri P.N Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General, the Sub-Registrar was within his-powers to refuse the registration because the title of the land in question is not undisputed and the vendor of Annexure/P-1 is not competent to execute the sale deed for want of title.
6. On perusal of the scheme of Registration Act, it may be seen that Part XII of the Registration Act, 1908 deals with the powers of Sub-Registrar to register the document. Section 71 is a key provision in the Act with regard to the power of Sub-Registrar to refuse to register a document which is as follows:—
“71. Reasons for refusal to register to be recorded — (1) Every Sub-Registrar refusing to register a document, except on the ground that the property to which it relates is not situate within his sub-district, shall make an order of refusal and record his reasons for such order in his Book No. 2 and endorse the words “registration refused” on the document; and, on application made by any person executing or claiming under the document, shall, without payment and unnecessary delay, give him a copy of the reasons so recorded.
(2) No registering officer shall accept for registration a document so endorsed unless and until, under the provisions hereinafter contained, the document is directed to be registered.”
Order of refusal has been made appealable under section 72 of the Act. Present case is not on the basis of denial of execution, therefore, reference to other provisions of Registration Act is not required. In exercise of powers under section 69 of the Registration Act, M.P Registration Rules 1939 have been framed. Rule 35 enumerates the valid reason for refusal to register a document. It may be seen that the absence of title with the vendor is not enumerated as a valid reason for refusal to register a document. On the other hand, as per Rule 36, absence of title with the vendor cannot be treated as a valid ground for refusal to register the document. Rule 36 is reproduced below for convenience:—
“36. When registration not to be refused. — Registration shall not be refused on the ground that any person executing or claiming under the document is unwilling that it shall be registered or that want or failure of consideration or denial or execution with free consent (as defined in section 14 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872) is pleaded by the executant of the document, although he admits execution or that the document deals with property not belonging to the person by whom it purports to have been executed or that the transaction is fraudulent or opposed to public policy or that the document was executed under coercion or by fraud or under misrepresentation:
Provided that the terms of the deed shall be clearly explained to the parties; and, whenever any such plea as above indicated is raised or any objection is taken to the terms of the document, the fact shall be recorded by the registering officer in an endorsement in Form 6 of Appendix A. The procedure to be followed on refusal to sign endorsement is laid down in section 58 of the Act.”
7. In the present case the vendor of Annexure/P-1 has not denied the execution, it is only the Sub-Registrar who is not discharging his duty to register the document (Annexure/P-1) on the ground that a dispute about title is pending in the Court of Nazul and the document cannot be registered during the pendency of such a title dispute. Duties and powers of registering officers are contained in Part XI of the Registration Act. None of the provision empowers the registering officers to refuse to register a document in case of dispute of title. Cumulative effect of the provisions contained in Part XI, XII, Rules 35 and 36 makes it clear that the Sub-Registrar has no authority to refuse to register a document on the ground that the vendor/transferor of Annexure/P-1 has no title to the property in question and is not competent to execute the sale deed. Obviously, the vendee/transferee would derive by virtue of the register document, right, title and interest which the transferor had at the time of execution of the deed. There would be no effect on the validity of transfer merely on account of pendency of case before Nazul Officer. No transfer of immovable property is prohibited even during the pendency of such a dispute. Only thing is that the transferee would get the right, title and interest of the transferee, if its vendor succeeds in the litigation. Keeping this in mind, it cannot be said by no stretch of imagination that merely on account of pendency of dispute before the Court of Nazul, the registering officer has a power to refuse to register the document.
8. Shri P.N Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General submitted that the reasons mentioned in Rule 35 as valid reasons are not exhaustive and there may be valid reasons apart from those mentioned in Rule 35. This submission cannot be said to be without substance. However, it may not be lost sight off that in Rule 36, it is clearly mentioned that registration shall not be refused on the ground that the document deals with property not belonging to the person by whom it purports to have been executed. Thus, the absence of title with the executant of the document has not been prescribed as a valid ground in express and specific language. This being so, although the grounds enumerated in Rule 35 may not be exhaustive, but one thing is definite that the refusal to register a document on the ground of absence of title with the vendor has been prescribed as an invalid ground and the Sub-Registrar, Bhopal in not registering the document contained in Annexure/P-1 on such a ground is found to have acted in dereliction of duties. Shri Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General further submitted that an appeal ought to have been preferred under section 76 of the Registration Act. This has been already rightly negatived by the Registrar vide Annexure/P-7 on the ground that order of refusal has not been passed at all. Further, contention of Shri Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General that the suit could have been filed under section 77 of the Act is also without any force because no right to sue accrued in favour of the petitioner on the grounds enumerated thereunder.
9. Shri P.N Dubey, learned Dy. Advocate General stated that the subject land is Government land and cannot be permitted to be dealt with in the impugned manner. He apprehended that if such a document is registered, the petitioner would be able to seek mutation and deal with the property to the detriment of the interest of State Government. This apprehension, though, seems lucrative, does not contain seriousness. The title dispute was found pending before Nazul Officer as revealed in his letter dated 28th June, 2006 contained in Annexure/P-4. More than a year has elapsed and no development is reported in the case by learned Dy. Advocate General. Had the Government authorities been really serious and sincere in the matter, the case could have been decided by this time and the necessary steps for protection of Government property would have been taken. No such step having been taken, it is quite late in a day to expect this Court not to allow the petitioner to insist the registering officer to register the purchase deed contained in Annexure/P-1. It may further be seen that the Government authority would be still at liberty to take appropriate steps to protect the Government land despite registration of Annexure/P-1. Thus, this objection also would not detain this Court from directing the Sub-Registrar, Bhopal to act in pursuance of the provisions of law contained in the Registration Act and the Rules made therein.
10. In the result, the writ petition deserves to be allowed and hence allowed hereby. Respondents are expected to take appropriate action in the matter for protection of the interest of the Government. Period of one month is fixed for the purpose. It is accordingly, directed that in the absence of any restraint order from a Court having competent jurisdiction, respondent No. 1 shall register the document contained in Annexure/P-1 within a week after expiry of one month from today in accordance with law on receipt of certified copy of this order.
No order as to costs.
Writ petition allowed.
Alert