- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Computer Sciences Corporation India Pvt. Ltd. v. Harishchandra Lodwal
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed the present revision against the order dated 24-1-2003 passed by the VII Additional District Judge, Indore, in Arbitration Execution Case No. 9/02, which dismissed the petitioner's application for transfer of decree. The arbitral award in favour of the petitioner was passed on 1-11-2002. The petitioner filed an application under section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for enforcement of the award before the learned court below and also moved an application for transfer of the decree, praying that since the respondents reside in Delhi the decree be transferred to a court in Delhi. The learned court below dismissed the transfer application on the ground that the petitioner was at liberty to file execution proceedings at Delhi itself. The petitioner challenged that dismissal by way of the present revision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in view of section 42 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the court which has jurisdiction over the arbitration proceedings alone has jurisdiction over all subsequent applications (including execution) arising out of that agreement and arbitral proceedings.
- Whether the decree (arising from the arbitral award) can be executed at a court in Delhi without the court which passed the decree (Indore) transferring the decree to the transferee court under the relevant provisions (as urged, sections 37 and 39).
- Whether the learned court below erred in dismissing the petitioner's application for transfer of decree on the ground that the petitioner could directly file execution proceedings at Delhi.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner relied on section 42 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which (as quoted in the opinion) provides that where an application under this Part has been made in a court with respect to an arbitration agreement, that court alone shall have jurisdiction over the arbitral proceedings and all subsequent applications arising out of that agreement and the arbitral proceedings shall be made in that court and in no other court.
- The petitioner referred to section 2(e) of the Act for the definition of "Court" (the principal civil court of original jurisdiction in a district, and includes the High Court in its ordinary original civil jurisdiction, having jurisdiction to decide questions forming the subject-matter of the arbitration if that had been the subject-matter of a suit).
- The petitioner relied on section 36 of the Act, which provides that an award (after the time for challenge under section 34 has expired or such challenge has been refused) shall be enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in the same manner as if it were a decree of the court.
- The petitioner further submitted (referring to the Code) that section 37 defines the court which passes the decree and section 39 lays down the procedure for transfer of decree; consequently, unless and until the court which passed the decree sends it for execution to another court of competent jurisdiction (i.e., transfers it), the transferee court cannot execute the decree under sections 37 and 39 (as stated in the opinion).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court considered the submissions based on the quoted statutory provisions. It accepted the petitioner's reliance on section 42 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which vests exclusive jurisdiction over arbitral proceedings and all subsequent applications arising from the arbitration agreement in the court where an application under that Part has been made. The court noted the definition of "Court" in section 2(e) and the enforcement mechanism under section 36 (that the award is to be enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure as if it were a decree).
Applying these provisions to the facts, the court concluded that because the award was passed at Indore, the court at Indore has jurisdiction over subsequent proceedings arising from that arbitration agreement. The court reasoned that execution in Delhi could not properly proceed unless the court at Indore transferred the decree to a court at Delhi pursuant to the provisions identified (sections 37 and 39 as invoked in the opinion). The learned court below's conclusion — that the petitioner was free to pursue execution directly at Delhi — was treated as incorrect on this basis.
Consequently, the court set aside the impugned order and directed the learned court below to consider the petitioner's application for transfer so that the petitioner may proceed with execution of the decree at Delhi if transfer is granted.
Holding and Implications
The impugned decree dated 24-1-2003 is set aside and the petition is disposed of.
Direct consequences for the parties: The court below (which had dismissed the transfer application) is directed to consider the petitioner's application for transfer of the decree to enable the petitioner to pursue execution at Delhi. The immediate effect is that the dismissal of the transfer application is vacated and the transfer application must be considered afresh by the court below.
No broader precedent was announced beyond application of the cited statutory provisions to the facts: the opinion applies sections 42 and 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and refers to sections 37 and 39 (as the procedural basis for transfer), but it does not purport to lay down a novel principle of law beyond the statutory construction and its application to this case.
Being aggrieved by the order dated 24-1-2003 passed by VII ADJ, Indore, in Arbitration Execution Case No. 9/02, whereby application for transfer of decree has been dismissed, the present revision has been filed.
2. Short facts of the case are that the award was passed in favour of the petitioner on 1-11-2002. Petitioner moved an application under section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for enforcement of the award before the Learned Court below. Petitioner also moved another application for transfer of the decree. Further prayer was that since respondents are residing at Delhi, therefore the decree be transferred to the court of Delhi. By the impugned order Learned Court below has dismissed the appeal on the ground that the petitioner is at liberty to file the execution proceedings at Delhi itself.
3. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that section 42 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 laid down the jurisdiction which reads as under:—
42. Jurisdiction. — “Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in this Part or in any other law for the time being in force, where with respect to an arbitration agreement any application under this Part has been made in a court, that court alone shall have jurisdiction over the arbitral proceedings and all subsequent applications arising out of that agreement and the arbitral proceedings shall be made in that court and in no other court.”
4. It is submitted that in view of section 42 of the Act the execution petition can be filed before the court alone, who has jurisdiction over the arbitration proceedings and all subsequent applications arising out of that agreement and the arbitral proceedings shall be made in that court and in no other court. Learned Counsel further placed reliance on section 2(e) of the Act which defines the court reads as under:—
2. Definitions. — (1) In this Part, unless the context otherwise requires,—
(a) …………
(b) …………
(c) …………
(d) …………
(e) “Court” means the principal Civil Court of original jurisdiction in a district, and includes the High Court in exercise of its ordinary original civil jurisdiction, having jurisdiction to decide the questions forming the subject-matter of the arbitration if the same had been the subject-matter of a suit, but does not include any Civil Court of a grade inferior to such principal Civil Court, or any Court of Small Causes;
5. It is submitted that under section 36 of the Act award has to be enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure in the same manner as if it were the decree of the court section 36 of the Act which reads as under:—
36. Enforcement. — “Where the time for making an application to set aside the arbitral award under section 34 has expired, or such application having been made, it has been refused, the award shall be enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) in the same manner as if it were a decree of the court.”
6. Learned Counsel further submits that section 37 of the Code defines the court which passes the decree and section 39 lays down the procedure for transfer of decree. It is submitted that unless and until the decree is sent for execution by the court it passed the decree for execution to another court of competent jurisdiction the transferee court cannot execute decree under sections 37 and 39 of the Act.
7. Learned court below has disposed of the application holding that the petitioner is competent to execute the decree at Delhi.
8. In view of the aforesaid position of law, since award is passed at Indore therefore unless and until the Court at Indore transfers the decree to the court at Delhi, it cannot be executed. In view of this decree dated 24-1-2003, is set aside with the direction to the court below to consider the application for transfer so as to enable the petitioner to proceed with the execution of decree at Delhi.
9. With the aforesaid observations this petition stands disposed of.
Order accordingly.
Alert