Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Ratan Tiwari v. State Of M.P And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Mar 20, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an Assistant Jailor in the Jail Department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh, was subjected to a criminal case under Section 13(1)(d)/13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Following investigation, he was placed under suspension by an order dated 8-2-2000. The trial concluded with the petitioner’s acquittal by judgment dated April 30, 2001, passed by the Special Judge, Jabalpur. The petitioner thereafter sought reinstatement by submitting a copy of the judgment to the competent authority, but was denied reinstatement. Consequently, he challenged this denial before the State Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur, which rejected his claim by order dated 17-1-2002. The present petition challenges that Tribunal order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after an order of acquittal in a criminal case, the petitioner should be permitted to rejoin government service despite the continuation of an appeal in the criminal proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner was acquitted in the criminal trial and therefore should be reinstated in service.
  • Reference was made to Rule 9(1)(b) of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966, which governs suspension related to criminal proceedings.
  • Cited the Division Bench decision of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Surinder Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh and Anr [1985 (3) SLR 254] supporting reinstatement post-acquittal.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The petitioner was acquitted by benefit of doubt, and criminal proceedings are ongoing due to the appeal filed against the acquittal.
  • Suspension should continue during the pendency of the appeal as it is considered a continuation of the trial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surinder Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh and Anr [1985 (3) SLR 254] Principle that acquittal ends trial and appeal is not a continuation of trial for suspension purposes The court found this precedent to be the nearest authority on the issue and agreed that suspension cannot continue merely because an appeal is pending, thus supporting reinstatement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Rule 9(1)(b) of the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966, which permits suspension when a criminal case against a government servant is under investigation, enquiry, or trial. The court noted that the petitioner was placed under suspension under this provision during the investigation and trial phases. However, with the judgment of acquittal dated April 30, 2001, the trial phase concluded, and the provision permitting suspension on this ground ceased to apply.

The court rejected the respondents’ contention that suspension should continue during the pendency of the appeal, holding that an appeal does not amount to a continuation of the trial. This interpretation was aligned with the precedent set by the Himachal Pradesh High Court in Surinder Kumar’s case. The court emphasized that extending suspension beyond the trial phase until final adjudication by the appellate court would impose undue hardship on the government servant and would amount to reading additional conditions into the rule that are not present.

Accordingly, the court concluded that the Tribunal erred in rejecting the petitioner’s claim for reinstatement and set aside the Tribunal’s order.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was to set aside the order dated 17-1-2002 of the State Administrative Tribunal and direct that the petitioner be reinstated in service with all benefits available in accordance with law.

The direct effect of this decision is the petitioner’s reinstatement following acquittal in the criminal trial despite the continuation of an appeal. The court did not establish a new precedent beyond reaffirming the principle that suspension based on criminal proceedings ends with the trial and is not extended by the pendency of an appeal.

Show all summary ...

1. Through this petition, order of State Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur, dated 17-1-2002 passed in Original Application No. 3116/2001 is challenged whereby claim/relief of petitioner has been rejected.

2. Petitioner was Assistant Jailor in Jail Department, Government of Madhya Pradesh. Criminal case under Section 13(1)(d)/13(2), Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 was registered against him. After investigation of the case, he was challenged. Consequently, he was placed under suspension by order dated 8-2-2000. The trial ended in the acquittal of the petitioner by judgment dated April 30, 2001 passed by Special Judge, Jabalpur in Special Criminal Case No. 4/2000.

3. Petitioner submitted application annexed therewith copy of the judgment to the competent authority (Annexure P-3) seeking reinstatement in service. However, he was not permitted to do so. Therefore, petitioner challenged the action of respondents before the Tribunal, which did not find favour with his plea for reinstatement and rejected the same by order dated 17-1-2002.

4. Question for determination is whether after order of acquittal passed in the case, petitioner should be permitted to join the service.

5. Shri S.C. Sharma, learned Counsel for the petitioner, contended that trial has ended in acquittal, therefore, respondents should permit the petitioner to join the service. Reference is made to Rule 9(1)(b) of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966. Besides, Division Bench decision of High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Surinder Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh and Anr. [1985 (3) SLR Page 254].

6. Shri P.D. Gupta, learned Deputy Advocate General, submits that the petitioner has been acquitted giving benefit of doubt and appeal is in continuation of the initial criminal proceedings against him.

7. The matter was adjourned to enable Counsel for parties to find out whether any other decision deals with the subject. No other decision except Surendra Kumar's case (supra) is brought to our notice. Therefore, we proceed to examine the matter on the available facts and status of legal position. Rule 9(1)(b) of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 provides that:--

"Where a case against him in respect of any criminal offence is under investigation, enquiry or trial."

Therefore, a person can be placed under suspension. One of the circumstances for placing the Government servant under suspension is when a case against him in respect of any criminal offence is under investigation, inquiry or trial. Part IV of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966, deals with suspension. Rule 9(1) provides for circumstances when a person can be placed under suspension by the Government. Petitioner was placed under suspension under the above quoted Rules which means he remains under suspension when criminal offence against him is under investigation, enquiry or trial. Investigation, enquiry or trial is over after announcement of judgment dated April 30, 2001. Therefore, this provision stands exhausted and petitioner can revert back to service. To hold otherwise would mean reading something in the provision which it does not provide. Further it may cause immense hardship to person to wait for the final adjudication of the matter by the Final Court. Therefore, submission of Shri P.D. Gupta, learned Dy. Advocate General cannot be appreciated to the extent that once a person is placed under suspension, he continues under suspension during the appeal as well. We find ourselves in agreement with the decision of High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Surendra Kumar's case (supra) being nearest to the point involved in this case rather deciding the same question and also that preferment of appeal is not continuance of the trial.

8. Therefore, what emerges out of the aforesaid discussion is that the Tribunal has not considered the matter in right perspective, therefore, order dated 17-1-2002 is set aside. The petitioner shall be taken back into service and allowed benefits available to him in accordance with law.