Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shrinarayan Laxman Prasad Tiwari And Others v. State Of M.P And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
May 3, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent No. 5 was the Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Sanai. Petitioner No. 1 was the Up-Sarpanch and petitioners 2 to 8 were Panchas of the same Gram Panchayat. A motion of no-confidence was passed against respondent No. 5 on 21-8-1995. Respondent No. 5 challenged the no-confidence motion by preferring a revision under Rule 5 of the M. P. Panchayat (Appeal and Revision) Rules, 1995 before the Collector. By an order dated 21-8-1995 the Collector set aside the resolution of the no-confidence motion, finding that the notice for the meeting was not despatched by the Secretary to the Panchas within the time fixed under the rules and that separate (individual) notices were not given to the Panchas; the Collector held these defects vitiated the no-confidence motion. Aggrieved by the Collector's order, the petitioner filed the present writ petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the motion of no-confidence was valid in law given the finding that notices were not despatched through the Secretary to every Panch as required seven days before the meeting under Rule 3(3) of the Rules.
  2. Whether the Collector had revisional power under Rule 5 of the M. P. Panchayat (Appeal and Revision) Rules, 1995 to set aside the no-confidence resolution.
  3. Whether the High Court should exercise its discretionary writ jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 to interfere with (set aside) the Collector's order which itself set aside the no-confidence resolution — in particular, whether the Court should refuse relief if quashing the Collector's order would revive an illegal resolution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the petitioner (Shri Kochar) was unable to refute the Collector's factual finding that notices were not despatched in the prescribed time and that individual notices were not given.
  • Counsel nonetheless submitted that since all the Panchas including the Sarpanch participated in the meeting, no prejudice resulted from the defect in service and therefore the no-confidence motion should not be vitiated on this ground.
  • Petitioner's counsel relied on precedents (notably Balkrishan Patel v. Brijendra Patel and Motilal Ramchandra v. Gram Panchayat) to support the proposition that a motion should not be defeated on technical grounds where there is substantial compliance or where there was overwhelming attendance and majority.
  • The writ petition was also founded principally on the ground that the Collector had no revisional power under Rule 5 to set aside a no-confidence motion (relying on a Single Judge judgment, as stated in the opinion).

Respondent's Arguments

  • Mr. Ruprah, appearing for respondent No. 5, did not dispute the legal position that no revision lies before the Collector against the passing of a no-confidence motion.
  • He submitted that the discretionary remedy of a writ should not be invoked in favour of the petitioner because setting aside the Collector's order would revive an illegal resolution; in such circumstances the Court should refuse to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226/227.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balkrishan Patel v. Brijendra Patel, 1985 MPLJ 332 = 1985 JLJ 522 Principle that a motion should not be defeated for technical reasons where there is substantial compliance; it is undemocratic to keep a person in office who has lost majority. The Court noted the decision but held it distinguishable because in that case the challenge was lack of valid service on five Panchas; the present case concerned non-despatch of notice seven days before and absence of notice to every member, so facts differ.
Bansilal Motilal v. Collector, West Nimar (referenced within cited passages) Held that on passing a no-confidence motion against the Sarpanch, the post is automatically vacated when the motion is passed in substantial compliance with the statute; such effect cannot be arrested even by a stay from the High Court. Referred to in the quoted passage from Balkrishan Patel; used to illustrate the substantial compliance line of authority, but the Court treated the authorities dealing with substantial compliance as distinguishable on facts.
Motilal Ramchandra v. Gram Panchayat, Jamurdisarvar, 1983 JLJ SN19 Held that where a no-confidence resolution is carried by an overwhelming majority, the case is not fit for interference under Article 226 even if there was irregularity in service of notice. The Court considered this precedent but found it distinguishable because in that case 22 out of 23 members were present; the present case did not have comparable attendance and therefore the precedent did not apply.
Gayasuddin Khan v. Gram Panchayat Tal, 1971 MPIJ 1012 Holds that a meeting is not validly convened if the notice required by the rules (including 7 clear days' notice) is not given; absence of proper notice can render a meeting invalid and a notice by an unauthorised person does not validate the meeting. The Court treated this Division Bench decision as directly on point and followed it: because notices were not despatched seven days before and some members were not served, the no-confidence motion in the present case was held not to be in accordance with law.
Godde Venkateswara Rao v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1966 SC 828 Principle that a High Court should refuse to exercise its discretionary power to quash an order where quashing would restore an illegal order; the discretionary writ jurisdiction may be declined where exercising it would defeat the ends of justice. The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority to support its conclusion that, although the Collector may have lacked revisional power, the High Court should not set aside the Collector's order because doing so would revive an illegal no-confidence resolution; accordingly the Court declined to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the relevant statutory requirement: Rule 3(3) of the M. P. Panchayat Rules requires the prescribed authority to ensure that notice of the meeting to consider a no-confidence motion be despatched through the Secretary to every member of the Panchayat seven days before the meeting. The Collector had found that this requirement was not complied with: notices were not despatched within the prescribed time and individual notices were not given.

The petitioner's counsel did not successfully challenge the Collector's factual finding regarding non-despatch of the notice. The petitioner argued however that because all Panchas (including the Sarpanch) participated in the meeting, no prejudice was caused and the motion should not be invalidated on a mere technicality. That submission was supported by authorities emphasizing substantial compliance and non-interference where an overwhelming majority attended or voted.

The Court examined the precedents relied upon by the petitioner and distinguished them on their facts. Decisions that refused interference where there was substantial compliance or near-universal attendance (for example Motilal Ramchandra and Balkrishan Patel) were held to be inapposite because those cases involved either effective service on most members or overwhelming attendance; the present case involved a failure to despatch notice seven days prior and failure to give notice to every member.

The Court relied on Gayasuddin Khan (a Division Bench decision) which held that absence of the required 7 clear days' notice and failure of proper service could render a meeting invalid and even described such a gathering as not being a valid meeting under the rules. The Gayasuddin Khan reasoning emphasized the democratic purpose of the notice requirement — to provide an opportunity for the Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch to meet, explain, remove misunderstandings and defend against the motion.

Applying that legal principle to the facts, the Court concluded that the no-confidence motion in the present case was not in accordance with law because the statutory notice requirement was not met.

The Court then addressed whether it should exercise its discretionary writ jurisdiction (under Articles 226/227) to set aside the Collector's order. Although the petition was founded on the contention that the Collector had no revisional power under Rule 5, the Court observed that at the time the Collector exercised jurisdiction the law was unsettled and the Collector's order was based on essentially the same ground the Court itself would have applied under its writ jurisdiction. However, the Court concluded that interfering with the Collector's order would revive an illegal no-confidence resolution. Because the grant of relief under Article 226/227 is discretionary and is to be exercised for the advancement of justice, the Court declined to exercise its discretion in favour of the petitioner where doing so would defeat, rather than subserve, justice.

The Court fortified this discretionary conclusion by reference to the Supreme Court decision in Godde Venkateswara Rao, where the High Court was held to have rightly refused to exercise extraordinary discretionary power to quash a government order because quashing would have restored an illegal order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The Court held that the no-confidence motion passed against respondent No. 5 was not in accordance with law because the statutory requirement of causing the notice to be despatched seven days before the meeting to every Panch was not complied with; the Collector's setting-aside of the resolution on that ground was therefore founded on a valid legal premise.
  • Although the petitioner's primary contention was that the Collector lacked revisional power under Rule 5, the Court declined to quash the Collector's order because quashing would have the effect of reviving an illegal resolution; the exercise of writ jurisdiction is discretionary and the Court refused relief in the circumstances.
  • Direct effect on the parties: the Collector's order setting aside the no-confidence resolution remains undisturbed and the writ petition is dismissed. No costs were awarded.
  • The opinion did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities; the Court distinguished some authorities and followed others where directly on point.

Note: This summary is compiled exclusively from the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those stated therein.

Show all summary ...

1. Respondent No. 5 is the Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat Sanai whereas petitioner No. 1 is the Up-Sarpanch of the said Gram Panchayat and petitioners 2 to 8 are its Panchas. A motion of no-confidence was passed against respondent No. 5 on 21-8-1995. Aggrieved by the passing of the no-confidence motion, respondent No. 5 preferred revision under Rule 5 of the M. P. Panchayat (Appeal and Revision) Rules, 1995 before the Collector, who by its order dated 21-8-1995 set aside the resolution of the no-confidence motion. While doing so, it held that the notice was not despatched by the Secretary to the Panchas according to time fixed under the rules nor separate notice were given to them. This in the opinion of the Collector vitiated the no-confidence motion. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, petitioner has preferred this writ petition filed under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

2. It is relevant here to state that Rule 3 of the Rules contemplates that the notice of the meeting to consider the no-confidence motion, specifying the date, time and place thereof, shall cause to be despatched by the Prescribed Authority through the Secretary of the Gram Panchayat to every member of the Panchayat concerned, Seven days before the meeting. The Collector has found that the notice was not despatched within the time prescribed under the aforesaid Rules, nor individual notices were given to the Panchas.

3. Shri Kochar appearing on behalf of the petitioner could not point out anything to demonstrate that the aforesaid finding recorded by the Collector is in any way erroneous. However, he submits that in view of the fact that all the Panchas including the Sarpanch having participated in the meeting to consider the no-confidence motion, no prejudice is caused and notwithstanding the fact that notices were not despatched, seven days before the meeting, the no-confidence motion shall not be vitiated on this ground. Accordingly, it is submitted that the Collector committed an error in setting aside the no-confidence motion. In support of the aforesaid submission, learned counsel has placed reliance on a Division Bench Judgment of this Court in the case of Balkrishan Patel v. Brijendra Patel, 1985 MPLJ 332 = 1985 JLJ 522. My attention has been drawn to the following passage of the said Judgment, which reads as follows:-

"It is settled view of this Court that if there is substantial compliance of this provision, a motion cannot be defeated for technical reasons and it is undemocratic to keep a person on the post when he lost majority. This Court in Bansilal Motilal v. Collector, West Nimar, has held that on passing a no-confidence motion against the Sarpanch, the post of Sarpanch is automatically vacated, this effect cannot be arrested even by the operation of the stay order passed by the High Court. Such must be effect when a no-confidence motion is passed in substantial compliance to section 18 of the Act. So, this Court in Motilal Ramchandra v. Gram Panchayat, Jamurdisarvar, 1983 JLJ S.N.(19) has held that when a no-confidence resolution against Sarpanch carried by overwhelming majority, the case is not fit for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution even if there was irregularity in the service of the notice of the majority."

4. In the aforesaid case, the no-confidence motion was sought to be challenged on the ground that there was no valid service of notice about the meeting on five Panchas and in the background of the aforesaid fact, this Court found that no-confidence motion cannot be defeated on technical ground, if there is substantial compliance of the provision. However, in the present case, the ground on which the illegality of the no-confidence motion is challenged is that the notice was not despatched 7 days before the meeting as also the notice was not given to every member of the Panchayat. Accordingly the decision relied on by the learned counsel is clearly distinguishable.

5. Yet another decision, on which the learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance is the Division Bench Judgment of this Court in the case of Motilal Ramchandra v. Gram Panchayat, Jamurdisarvar, 1983 JLJ SN19, and my attention has been drawn to the following paragraph, which reads as under:-

"The matter may also be considered from another aspect. The Gram Panchayat consisted of 23 members at the relevant time including the petitioner. In the meeting held on 12-10-1981, 22 members were present. 18 members supported the no-confidence resolution against the petitioner and 4 of them voted against it. The no-confidence resolution was carried by an overwhelming majority. In the circumstances even if there was some irregularity in the service of notice on the petitioner, in our opinion, it is not a fit case, in which interference is called for under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Petition is dismissed."

In the aforesaid case, irregularity in service of notice was considered immaterial as 22 members out of 23 were present. Irregularity in service in the aforesaid background was considered immaterial. This is not the situation here as such, the authority cited is clearly distinguishable.

6. Rule 3(3) of the Rules, which is relevant for the purpose reads as follows:-

"(3) On receiving the notice under sub-rule (1) the prescribed authority shall satisfy himself about the admissibility of the notice with reference to sections 21(3), 28(3) and 35(3), as the case may be. On being thus satisfied, he shall fix the date, time and place for the meeting of the Gram Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat or Zila Panchayat, as the case may be, which shall not be more than fifteen days from the date of receipt of the said notice. The notice of such meeting specifying the date, time and place thereof shall be caused to be despatched by him through the Secretary of the Gram Panchayat or Chief Executive Officer of the Janpad or Zila Panchayat, as the case may be, to every member of the Panchayat concerned seven days before the meetin."

7. A plain reading of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that notice of the meeting to consider the no-confidence motion has to be despatched by the Prescribed Authority through the Secretary of the Gram Panchayat to every member of the Panchayat concerned 7 days before the meeting.

8. In the present case, the notice was not despatched to every member of the Panchayat 7 days before the meeting. The consequence of short period notice, as pointed out by Shri Ruprah came up for consideration before a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Gayasuddin Khan v. Gram Panchayat Tal, 1971 MPIJ 1012, wherein it has been held as follows:-

"In the instant case no notice was given by the Secretary. In fact the annexure to the petitioner shows that the notice was not served by the Secretary. Not only that, but three members as well as the Sarpanch were also not served with notices for the purpose of this no-confidence motion. Even the petitioner himself has not been served. This position has been admitted in the return. If that is so the meeting cannot be said to have been validly convened. In fact we may say that there was no meeting at all. If a person who is not authorised to call a meeting calls one, the meeting is not validly convened even if the members collect. Mere gathering of the persons at the request of an unauthorised person is not a meeting under the rules. There should always be 7 clear day's notice of the meeting. That has also not happened. The importance of this provision is that a vote of no-confidence may not he very lightly passed. There should be opportunity for the Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch against whom a vote of no-confidence has to he moved to convince the members or to satisfy them that the grounds on which the motion is being moved will have no basis. There should be scope for removal of misunderstanding. That is necessary for all democratic institutions."

In view of the aforesaid Division Bench Judgment of this Court which is clearly on the point, I have no hesitation in holding that the motion of no- confidence passed against respondent No. 5 was not in accordance with law.

9. The writ petition is mainly founded on the ground that the Collector has no revisional power to set aside the motion of no-confidence under Rule 5 of the M. P. Panchayat (Appeal and Revision) Rules, 1995. In support of the aforesaid submission, learned counsel has placed reliance on the Judgment of a learned Single Judge of this Court. Mr. Ruprah appearing on behalf of respondent No. 5 does not dispute the aforesaid legal position that no revision lies before the Collector against the passing of the no-confidence motion, but he submits that the discretionary remedy of writ cannot be involved in favour of the petitioner, as the setting aside the order of the Collector will lead to revival of an illegal resolution. Accordingly it is submitted that it is not a fit case for exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

10. When the jurisdiction of the Collector was invoked, law was in a fluid state and it came to be settled only after this Court's judgment. Had respondent No. 5 approached this Court, this Court could have interfered with the resolution on the same ground as that assigned by the Collector under its writ jurisdiction. In the background of the aforesaid situation, now I am obliged to consider whether it is a fit case for interference under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India. The grant of relief under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India is discretionary one. Power to issue prerogative writs, orders or directions as also power of superintendence over subordinate courts or Tribunals have been conferred on this Court, for advancement of justice. In this context, it is often said that the matter of grant of writ is not a matter of right but of discretion. As held earlier, no-confidence motion passed against respondent No. 5 is illegal and interference with the order of the Collector will lead to revival of an illegal resolution. Accordingly exercise of discretion by this Court instead of sub-serving the ends of justice shall definitely defeat the same. Accordingly, I am not inclined to exercise my discretion in favour of the petitioner.

11. I am fortified in my view from the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Godde Venkateswara Rao v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1966 SC 828, wherein it has been held as follows:-

"In those circumstances, was it a case for the High Court to interfere in its discretion and quash the order of the Government dated April 18, 1963? If the High Court had quashed the said order, it would have restored an illegal order, it would have given the Health Centre to a village contrary to the valid resolutions passed by the Panchayat Samiti. The High Court, therefore, in our view, rightly refused to exercise its extraordinary discretionary power in the circumstances of the case.

12. For the reasons stated above, I refrain from exercising my discretion. The writ petition stands dismissed. No costs.