Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr. Omprakash Soni v. Ashok Kumar Bhargava And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Mar 28, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was elected as Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Miana, Tehsil and District Guna. The election was challenged by respondent No. 1. The petitioner filed an application before respondent No. 5 contending that the election petition filed against him ought to be summarily dismissed because it had not been presented in compliance with Rule 3(2) of the M.P. Panchayat Raj (Election Petitions Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1990 ("the Rules"). The parties agreed the election petition was governed by those Rules.

The Election Court (recorded as Annexure P-1) held that copies of the election petition filed were not attested by the election petitioners themselves; rather, attestation had been made only by the advocate for the election petitioner. The opinion under review considers whether the failure to have the petition copies attested by the petitioner under his own signature (as required by Rule 3(2)) renders the election petition liable to summary dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the attestation requirement under Rule 3(2) of the M.P. Panchayat Raj Rules, 1990 is mandatory.
  2. If mandatory, whether failure to have copies of the election petition attested by the petitioner under his own signature necessitates summary dismissal of the election petition under Rule 8 of the Rules (and by parity, Section 86(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951).
  3. Whether attestation by the advocate for the petitioner can substitute for attestation by the petitioner himself.
  4. Whether the fact that Rule 3(1) permits presentation by an authorised representative affects the attestation requirement of Rule 3(2).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and Supreme Court decisions interpreting that Act. He contended that Rule 3(2) of the Rules is pari materia with Section 81(3) of the Act and therefore mandatory.
  • The petitioner argued that non-compliance with Rule 3 should result in summary dismissal of the election petition in terms of Rule 8, which the petitioner contended is pari materia with Section 86(1) of the Act.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied on prior decisions of this Court (a Division Bench decision in Tikaram v. Darshanlal, 1988 (1) MPWN 139, and a Single Bench decision in Writ Petition No. 1162/1994) which had held that Rule 3(2) is not mandatory.
  • Learned counsel for the respondents also pointed out that Rule 3(1) permits presentation of the election petition by an authorised representative (not only in person), and argued that this should inform interpretation of Rule 3(2). A related point raised was that Section 83(1) of the Act requires personal presentation; the respondents relied on distinctions in wording between the statute and the Rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sharif-Ud-Din v. Abdul Gani Lone, AIR 1980 SC 303 Attestation by the advocate cannot substitute for attestation by the petitioner under his own signature. The court relied on this decision to hold that attestation by an advocate does not save the petition; the objective of attestation by the petitioner is to fix responsibility and prevent tampering.
F. A. Sapa v. Singora, AIR 1991 SC 1557 Interpretation of verification and attestation requirements under the Representation of the People Act: failure to verify may not be fatal, but failure to comply with Section 81(1) and 81(3) (attestation and supply of copies) is fatal and mandates summary dismissal. The court followed this Supreme Court decision as directly on point and concluded that Rule 3(2) (pari materia with Section 81(3)) is mandatory; non-compliance requires summary dismissal of the election petition.
Tikaram v. Darshanlal, 1988 (1) MPWN 139 (Division Bench) Held (at that time) that Rule 3(2) is not mandatory. The court noted this decision and a Single Bench decision following it, but distinguished/followed the contrary Supreme Court authority and therefore did not follow the Division Bench's earlier conclusion.
Writ Petition No. 1162/1994 (Single Bench of this Court) Followed the Division Bench view that Rule 3(2) is not mandatory. The court observed that the Single Bench followed the Division Bench, but held itself bound by the later Supreme Court authority and therefore reached the opposite conclusion.
M. Karunanidhi v. H.V. Handa, AIR 1983 SC 558 Related to proper deposit of security under the Act. The court stated this decision was not attracted to the facts of the present case because the issue there was security deposit, which is not at issue here.
M. Kamalam v. Dr V.A. Syed Mohammed, AIR 1978 SC 840 Signatures placed at the end of the affidavit rather than on the election petition — held not a valid ground for dismissal (in that case). The court noted this decision was not applicable because the specific question of attestation/non-attestation of petition copies was not before the Supreme Court in that case.
Z.B. Bukhari v. B.R. Mehra, AIR 1975 SC 1788 Case relied upon by respondents (details in text indicate it was distinguishable on facts). The court observed the decision but found it distinguishable on facts and did not treat it as controlling for the attestation issue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the text of Rule 3(2) and Rule 8 of the Rules and Sections 81(3) and 86(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. It observed that the provisions in the Rules and corresponding sections in the Act are similarly worded, so decisions under the Act provide a reliable guide for interpreting the Rules.

The court addressed the distinction between two types of procedural defects by reference to Supreme Court authority: while mere defects in verification (under the Code of Civil Procedure requirements) may not be fatal to an election petition, the Supreme Court had clearly held that failure to comply with the attestation and copy-supply requirements of Section 81(3) is fatal and mandates summary dismissal.

On that basis, the court concluded that Rule 3(2) (which requires that every copy of an election petition be attested by the petitioner under his own signature) is mandatory because it is pari materia with Section 81(3). The court explicitly followed the Supreme Court decision in F. A. Sapa v. Singora for this proposition.

The court addressed the respondents' submission about Rule 3(1) permitting presentation by an authorised representative. It held that the difference in phraseology between Rule 3(1) (which allows presentation by an authorised representative) and Section 83(1) of the Act (which requires presentation by the petitioner in person) is immaterial for interpreting the attestation requirement in Rule 3(2). The court observed that the rule-making authority deliberately permitted presentation by an authorised person but did not alter the attestation requirement in Rule 3(2), which weighs against the respondents' argument.

The court also relied on Sharif-Ud-Din v. Abdul Gani Lone to hold that attestation by an advocate cannot be treated as equivalent to attestation by the petitioner; the purpose of petitioner-attestation is to fix responsibility and prevent tampering.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the attestation requirement under Rule 3(2) of the M.P. Panchayat Raj (Election Petitions...) Rules, 1990 is mandatory in so far as it deals with the concept of attestation, and failure to comply with that provision will lead to summary dismissal of the election petition.

The court concluded that the Election Court's decision (Annexure P-1), which did not dismiss the election petition notwithstanding the absence of attestation by the petitioner, was contrary to law. Accordingly, the writ petition was allowed and Annexure P-1 was quashed; this quashing "will automatically result in the dismissal of [the] election petition."

Implications for the parties: The direct effect is that the election petition against the petitioner is dismissed due to non-compliance with Rule 3(2). The court followed binding Supreme Court authority and did not attempt to depart from that precedent; the opinion applies established principles rather than announcing a new legal rule.

Show all summary ...

1. The brief facts for the purposes of this writ petition be noticed.

2. The present petitioner was elected as Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Miana, Tehsil and District of Guna. His election was challenged by the respondent No. 1. The present petitioner filed an application before the respondent No. 5 pleading that the election-petition deserves to be dismissed summarily as this has not been presented in terms of Rule 3(2) of the M. P. Panchayat Raj (Election Petitions Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1990 (hereinafter referred to as 'Rules'). The learned counsel for the parties are agreed that the election-petition is to be filed under the aforementioned rules.

3. The election Court has given its decision. The copy of the same is placed on record as Annexure P-1. It has come to the conclusion that copies of the election petition were not attested by the election petitioners. On facts at least, the learned counsel for the parties are agreed that copies of the election-petition when filed were not attested by the election-petitioner. It was attested only by the advocate appearing on behalf of the election-petitioner. It is on these premises arguments have been addressed.

4. The question arises as to whether the provisions of Rule 3(2) are mandatory or not. For this, reliance is being placed by the petitioner's counsel on the provisions of Representation of the Peoples Act, 1951 (hereinafter, referred to as the 'Act') and the decision rendered thereunder. According to the counsel for petitioner, Rule 3(2) of the Rules is in pan materia with the Sections 81(3) of the Act. He also submits that when there is non-compliance of Rule 3, the petition has to be dismissed summarily in terms of Rule 8. It is again contended that Rule 8 of the Rules is in pari materia with Section 86(1) of the Act.

5. Before noticing further arguments it would be relevant to note these provisions.

These are as under:--

"Rules 3 and 8 of the Rules:

Rule 3. Presentation of election petitions.-- (1) An election petition shall be presented to the prescribed authority during the office hours by the person making the petition, or by a person authorised in writing in this behalf by the person making the petition within thirty days from the date on which the election or co-option in question was notified.

(2) Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof petition and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under this own signature to be a true copy of the petition.

Rule 8. Procedure on receiving petition--If the provisions of Rule 3 or Rule 4 or Rule 7 have not been complied with, the prescribed authority shall dismiss the petition:

Provided that the petition shall not be dismissed without giving petitioner an op-poertunity of being heard.

Sections 81(3) and 86(1) of the 1951 Act--Section 81(3).-- Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under this own signature to be a true copy of the petition.

Section 86(1)-- The High Court shall dismiss an election petition which does not comply with the provisions of Section 81 or Section 82 or Section 117."

6. A perusal of the two provisions makes it apparent that there are similarly worded and as such decisions given under the Act can be safely taken as guide for interpretation of the Rules under which the petition was filed.

7. The question which arises is as to whether failure to attest the election petition would lead to dismissal of the election petition or not. The learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on two judgments given by the Supreme Court in the case of Sharif-Ud-Din v. Abdul Gani Lone., AIR 1980 SC 303 and F. A. Sapa v. Singora, AIR 1991 SC 1557.

8. The learned counsel for the respondents has also placed reliance on a decision given by the Division Bench of this Court in Tikaram v. Darshanlal, 1988 (1) MPWN 139 and a Single Bench decision of this Court in Writ Petition No. 1162/1994. The Single Bench has placed reliance on the Division Bench decision noticed above. In both the decisions, this Court has held that the provisions of Rule 3(2) are not mandatory.

9. In my view, in view of the judgment given by the Supreme Court in F. A. Sapa's case (AIR 1991 SC 1557) (supra) there is no doubt that the only interpretation which is possible to be given is that Rule 3 dealing with concept of attestation is mandatory. In the above case, the question before the Supreme Court was, (i) as to whether failure on the part of the election petitioner to verify theelection petition as per the requirements of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 is fatal and (ii) what are the consequences of no attestation.

10. So far as verification is concerned, the Supreme Court concluded that failure to verify the election petition in the terms of Code of Civil Procedure may not be fatal. In para 20 it was observed as under:

"..... It is thus clear from this decision which is binding on us that mere defect in the verification of the election petition is not fatal to the maintainability of the petition and the petition cannot be thrown out solely on that ground. As observed earlier since Section 83 is not one of three provisions mentioned in Section 86(1), ordinarily it cannot be construed as mandatory unless it is shown to be an integral part of the petition under Section 81."

11. However with regard to non-compliance of Ss. 81(1) and 81(3), it was said in no uncertain words that failure to attest and comply with these provisions would be fatal and the election petition is necessarily to be dismissed summarily. This aspect has been considered in detail in para 29 and it would be useful to note the same:

"The next objection is based on the language of Section 81 of the R. P. Act. This section deals with the presentation of an election petition. Sub-section(1) thereof says that an election petition may be presented by any candidate at such election or any elector within 45 days from, but not earlier than, the date of election of the returned candidate or if there are more than one. returned candidate at the election and the dates of their election are different, the later of those dates. This sub section specifies on what ground or grounds the election of the returned candidate can be challenged, who can challenge the election and imposes a period of limitation for filing such a petition. sub-section (1) of this section was omitted by Article 47 of 1966. Then comes Sub-section (3) which stipulates that every elec tion petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition, and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition. This sub-section enjoins (i) supply of such number of copies of the petition as are respondents, and (ii) every such copy must be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition, There is no controversy regarding the first aspect, the controversy centres round the second part. It must be remembered that non-

14. Reliance was again placed on a decision given by the Supreme Court, reported as M. Karunanidhi v. H.V. Handa, AIR 1983 SC 558. This decision is not attracted to the facts of the present case. The question was with regard to proper deposit of security. This is not an issue in the present case.

15. Another case on which reliance is being placed is M. Kamalam v. Dr V.A Syed Mohammed., AIR 1978 SC 840. In this case, signatures were put by the petitioner as the end of the affidavit and not on the election petition. It was held that this is again not a valid ground for dismissal of the election petition. This decision is again not applicable to the facts of the present case because the question of attestation and non-attestation was not there before their Lordships of the Supreme Court.

16. Another decision on which reliance is being placed by the learned counsel for the respondents is Z.B. Bukhari v. B.R. Mehra, AIR 1975 SC 1788. This decision is again distinguishable on facts.

17. As such in view of the fact that there is a direct decision of the Supreme Court dealing with the question of attestation, I respectfully follow the same and conclude that failure to comply with the provisions of Rule 3(2) which are pari materia with Section 81(3) of the 1951 Act would lead to summary dismissal of the election petition.

17A. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents has again pointed out that Rule 3(1) permits the election petition to be presented by the election petitioner or the authorised representative. According to him this should be taken note of while interpretating Rule 3(2) of the Rules. A further argument has also been raised that Section 83(1) requires election petition to be presented by the election petitioner in person. I am of the view that the difference in phraseology in Section 83(1) and Rule 3(1) would be totally immaterial for interpretating Rule 3(2) which is as noticed above is pari materia with Section 81(3). The Rule making Authority was alive to the fact and it chooses to permit presentation by the authorised person and did not make similar provisions in Rule 3(2). This as a matter of fact goes against the argument raised by learned counsel for the respondents.

18. Attestation by an advocate would also not save the petitioner. This view was expressed in the case of Sharif-ud-Din's case (AIR 1980 SC 303) (supra). In para 19 it was said that:

"The attestation by the advocate for the petitioner cannot be treated as the equivalent of attestation by the petitioner under his own signature. The object of requiring the copy of an election petition to be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition is that the petitioner should take full responsibility for its contents and that the respondents should have in their possession a copy of the petition duly attested under the signature of the petitioner to be the true copy of the petition at the earliest possible opportunity to prevent any unauthorised alteration or tampering of the contents of the original petition after it is filed into Court."

19. No doubt a Division Bench of this Court held that Rule 3(2) of the Rules is not mandatory but this decision is earlier to the above noted decision given by the Supreme Court of India. The Single Bench decision has followed the Division Bench. I however, am bound by the decision given by the Supreme Court of India and following the same hold that Rule 3 of the Rules is mandatory in so far as it deals with the concept of attestation. As such, non-dismissal of the election petition by the election Court was contrary to law. This petition is accordingly allowed. The order Annexure P/1 is quashed. This will automatically result in the dismissal of election petition.