Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Ghaffar v. State Of Madhya Pradesh

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 21, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (V.D. Gyani, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an elderly man (over sixty years), alleged that his sons and son-in-law were taken away by the Mhow police on the night of 15 August 1992 and were shown as arrested on 18 August 1992 in connection with an offence under section 457, Indian Penal Code, registered at the police station. The petitioner sought their release before the A.C.J.M., unsuccessfully. On 19 August 1992 he was asked by a senior police officer to see his son Anis at the Civil Hospital, Mhow, and upon arrival was taken to the mortuary where he found Anis dead with several injuries. Public unrest followed (a call for "Mhow Band") and the petitioner complained to higher authorities without result.

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking: (i) registration of an offence under sections 302 and 387 IPC and investigation; (ii) proceedings against the accused and their abettors; and (iii) award of compensation of Rs. 2,00,000 to the petitioner.

The High Court, presided by V.D. Gyani, J., considered the petition, the post-mortem reports prepared by a panel of five doctors, subsequent chemical (viscera) reports, submissions by senior counsel Shri Khan for the petitioner and the Government Advocate for the respondents, and authorities cited in the petition and by the Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the police should register a case and investigate an alleged custodial death by registering offences under sections 302 and 387 IPC and proceed against the accused and abettors.
  2. Whether monetary compensation (exemplary costs) should be awarded to the petitioner for the alleged custodial death and failure of authorities to act.
  3. What role, if any, should be attributed to the conduct of the panel of doctors who conducted the post mortem, and whether their conduct requires further inquiry as part of the criminal investigation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented)

  • The petitioner (through Shri Khan, Senior Advocate) alleged custodial violence resulting in the death of his son and contended that police and other authorities failed to act to register or investigate cognizable offences.
  • Counsel argued that the panel of doctors performing the post mortem behaved improperly by not seeking or awaiting a viscera (chemical) report before offering final opinions and by initially withholding a definite opinion on cause of death despite recording multiple ante-mortem injuries.
  • It was contended that Article 21 of the Constitution had been violated and that exemplary costs/monetary compensation were appropriate; several Supreme Court authorities on compensation were placed before the Court (Rahul Shah, Sebastian Hongray, Bhimsingh).

Respondents' Arguments (as presented)

  • The Government Advocate submitted that the petition contained many disputed facts which required inquiry and that compensation could not be awarded without investigation and resolution of those factual disputes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335; AIR 1992 SC 604 The requirement under section 154(1) Cr.P.C. that if information discloses a cognizable offence the officer in charge of a police station is bound to record it and register a case; 'reasonableness' or 'credibility' of information is not a condition precedent for registration of a case. The Court relied on this authority to direct that when an information discloses commission of a cognizable offence the police must register a case and investigate in accordance with law, and accordingly granted the first two reliefs sought by the petitioner (registration and investigation).
Rahul Shah, (1983) 3 SCC 141; Sebastian Hongray, (1984) 3 SCC 82; Bhimsingh, (1985) 4 SCC 677 General principle recognised by the Supreme Court that in appropriate cases courts have jurisdiction to award damages/compensation or exemplary costs for loss, humiliation or indignity suffered. The Court placed reliance on these authorities in considering the question of monetary compensation and awarded exemplary costs/compensation of Rs. 1,00,000 to the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several distinct steps, each grounded in material before it and the authorities cited:

  1. Registration and investigation: The Court applied the principle from State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal that an officer in charge must record information and register a case where information discloses a cognizable offence under section 154(1) Cr.P.C. The petition alleged a custodial death with multiple injuries and, on that basis, the Court found no legal hesitation in directing registration of offences and investigation under sections 302 and 387 IPC.
  2. Role of the post mortem and the doctors: The Court examined in detail the post mortem reports prepared by a panel of five doctors and expressed serious concern at their conduct. It noted:
    • The initial post mortem report (requisition dated 19-8-1992) recorded multiple ante-mortem contusions and other findings, but stated that "no definite opinion can be given regarding the cause of death" and that viscera pieces had been sent for chemical analysis.
    • The doctors did not ask the police for the viscera/chemical report at the time of the post mortem, nor did they indicate in their initial report that they would await the chemical analysis before giving an opinion.
    • When the viscera/chemical report (dated 30-11-1992) was placed before the Court, it ruled out poisoning; following that, the doctors filed further opinions (26-4-1993 and 5-5-1993) concluding that death was due to syncope from the cumulative effect of multiple injuries, while also noting alternative possible explanations (e.g., vaso-vagal shock from fright, pre-existing cardiac conditions) and citing Modi's textbook.
    • The Court criticised the doctors for their initial "deliberate calculated silence" and for failing to give a definitive opinion on cause of death despite a spectrum of positive findings (numerous ante-mortem contusions, pale organs, empty heart chambers, no bony injury, no foreign material suggesting traffic accident, viscera excluding poisoning).
  3. On commenting and prejudice: The Court emphasised that, having directed registration and investigation, it should refrain from making further comments that might prejudice either party's case during the inquiry; accordingly, while critical of the doctors' conduct, the Court limited further comment so as not to prejudice the investigation.
  4. Compensation: Balancing the gravity of the case and the submissions, the Court held that exemplary costs by way of compensation were appropriate despite the need for further inquiry into disputed facts. It considered the authority of prior Supreme Court decisions on compensation and awarded Rs. 1,00,000 to the petitioner as exemplary cost, while allowing the petitioner to pursue ordinary proceedings for damages in the appropriate forum and stating that the awarded amount would be taken into account in such proceedings.
  5. Practical directions: The Court directed that the investigation, taking into account the role of the doctors, should be completed as early as possible and specified a target period of three months from the date of the order. The Court also allowed the State to recover the compensation amount from those found responsible and permitted the petitioner to apply for court-fee exemption in any further suit, with the award to be adjusted accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling:

The petition was allowed. The Court directed that a case be registered and investigated where information discloses a cognizable offence; it ordered an investigation into the alleged custodial death and condemned the conduct of the panel of doctors for withholding a definite cause of death initially. The Court awarded exemplary costs/compensation of Rs. 1,00,000 to the petitioner to be paid by the respondent-State and allowed counsel's fee of Rs. 2,500 if certified.

Immediate Consequences for the Parties:

  • The police are ordered to register a case and investigate the alleged offences (sections 302 and 387 IPC) in accordance with law.
  • The investigation must take into account the role played by the doctors who performed the post mortem and should, where practicable, be completed within three months from the date of the order.
  • The respondent-State is directed to pay Rs. 1,00,000 as exemplary compensation to the petitioner; the State is permitted to recover this sum from any persons found responsible for perpetrating the crime.
  • The petitioner is allowed to pursue civil remedies for recovery of damages; he may apply for exemption from court fee and, if successful, the awarded amount shall be taken into account in such proceedings.
  • Counsel's fee of Rs. 2,500 is allowed, if certified.

On precedent and broader law: The Court applied existing Supreme Court authority (State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal) to compel registration and investigation and relied on other Supreme Court authorities in principle for awarding compensation. The opinion itself does not claim to announce a new legal precedent; it applies established principles to the facts before the Court.

Disposition: Petition allowed with costs of Rs. 1,00,000 (one lac) and counsel's fee of Rs. 2,500 (if certified). Investigation directed to be completed within three months.

Show all summary ...

V.D Gyani, J.:— The petitioner, an old man, past sixty, whose sons and son-in-law were allegedly carried away by Mhow police on the night of 15th August, 1992, and later shown to have been arrested on 18-8-1992, in connection with an offence under section 457, Indian Penal Code registered at the Police Station, had moved the Court of A.C.J.M for their release but in vain. It was on 19th that he was asked by a senior police officer to see his son Anis in the Civil Hospital at Mhow. The petitioner rushed to the hospital, he was taken to the mortuary by doctor in charge, only to find him lying dead with several injuries on his body. A call for ‘Mhow Band’ was given by public, accordingly Mhow was kept ‘Band’.

2. The petitioner petitioned and complained to higher authorities but to no avail. He has now approached this Court with the present petition praying for the following orders:

(i) Registration of offence under sections 302 and 387, Indian Penal Code and investigate same in accordance with law,

(ii) To proceed against the accused as also the abettors of the crime,

(iii) Award of compensation of Rs. 2 lacs to the petitioner.

3. By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, full of shocking facts and disturbing features, Shri Khan, Sr. Advocate, has attempted and embarked on a mission to fight injustice and to help a poor under privileged, the petitioner, whose son, as alleged has been the victim of custodial violence resulting in death, has tried to put both, his favor and felicity coupled with scholarship into the case, but as it invariably happens the failed idealist, discovers to his chagrin that even the noblest of efforts, falls short, in face of constrain, the staggering case lead tremendous time pressure, limited resources, and the bureaucratic hurdles, at times, put forth, but it must be said to his credit, that he has tried to overcome all these with utmost perseverance and a sense of commitment.

4. So far as the first two reliefs are concerned, in view of the law as laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 : AIR 1992 SC 604, there can be no legal hitch or hesitation in granting the same. We accordingly grant the same. The Supreme Court has held as follows:

“31. Be it noted that in section 154(1) of the Code, the legislature in its collective wisdom has carefully and cautiously used the expression “information” without qualifying the same as in section 41(1)(a) or (g) of the Code wherein the expressions, “reasonable complaint” and “credible information” are used. Evidently, the non-qualification of the word “information” in section 154(1) unlike in section 41(1)(a) and (g) of the Code may be for the reason that the police officer should not refuse to record an information relating to the commission of a cognisable offence and to register a case thereon on the ground that he is not satisfied with the reasonableness or credibility of the information. In other words, ‘reasonableness’ or ‘Credibility of the said information is not a condition precedent for registration of a case. A comparison of the present section 154 with those of the earlier Codes will indicate that the legislature had purposely thought it fit to employ only the word “information” without qualifying the said word. Section 139 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1861 (Act XXV of 1861) passed by the Legislative Council of India read that ‘every complaint or information’ preferred to an officer in charge of a police station should be reduced into writing which provision was subsequently modified by section 112 of the Code of 1872 (Act X of 1872) which thereafter read that ‘every complaint’ preferred to an officer in charge of a police station shall be reduced into writing. The word ‘complaint’ which occurred in previous two Codes of 1861 and 1872 was deleted and in that place the word ‘information’ was used in the Codes of 1882 and 1955 which word is now used in the sections 154, 155 and 157 and 190(c) of the present Code of 1973 (Act if of 1974). An overall reading of all the Codes makes it clear that the condition which is sine qua non for recording a First Information Report is that there must be an information and that information must disclose a cognisable offence.

32. It is, therefore, manifestly clear that if any information disclosing a cognisable offence is laid before an officer in charge of a police station satisfying the requirements of section 154(1) of the Code, the said police officer has no other option except to enter the substance thereof in the prescribed form, that is to say, to register a case on the basis of such information.”

5. It is accordingly ordered that on disclosing a commission of cognisable offence the police should register a case and investigate the same in accordance with law. It is to be borne in mind that those who abetted a commission of offence either directly or indirectly by their acts of commission or omission, should not escape the arms of law.

6. It is in this context, that the role played by the panel of doctors who performed post mortem examination, and submitted their report, calls for a serious consideration.

7. So far as compensation is concerned, the same shall be discussed at the appropriate stage, presently we are concerned with the re-autopsy report.

8. The first hurdle in the case, as put forth is by the five mighty medical minds, combined who in their uniquely, unanimous post mortem examination report have come out with an opinion so far unsurpassed, unmatched, unequalled in its remarkable unanimity and unique in the sense, that all of them wilfully refuse to see the light of the day, and indulged in successfully, withholding, not only withholding but also concealing and destroying evidence that is demonstrably clear and relevant in a criminal trial. ‘Experts’ as they are, their eyes do not reach the light, their ears are not sensitive to the truth so loudly proclaimed by the bleeding injuries as noted by them; their own potential positive findings as recorded on the post mortem examination report. Even the bruise may prove to be fatal, when it involves an important internal organ. Multiple bruises though individual, trivial and slight because of grievous hurt and result in death due to shock and internal haemorrhage. Therefore, the Code of Ethics remains in print but violated in practice, at times with impunity. While reports of medical malpactices galore and appear almost every day in press; but the case at hand is a classic one, where even the dead has not been spared by the medical men.

9. The primary object of forensic autopsy is to determine the cause of death it is here that the pathologists owe a duty even to the dead. Sadly enough the five medical minds entrusted with the task have betrayed the faith by keeping mum on the point. Apart from determining the cause of death these doctors again, forgot the dictum propounded by Dabot in the U.S.A as back as 1912 that even the dead can teach the living, which still holds good — emphasising the value of autopsies in detecting diagnostic errors.

10. The medico legal post mortem examintion as has been pointed out by Bernard Knight, a celebrated authority on Forensic Pathology dubiously poor opinion is often worse than no opinion at all, as in the later case the legal authorities will at least be aware of the deficiency in their evidence, rather than be misled by the often dogmatic inaccuracies by an inexperienced doctor.

11. It would not be out of place to note that a panel consisting of the following doctors carried the post mortem examination:

(i) Dr. M.S Vishnar

(ii) Dr. G.D Mundra

(iii) Dr. K.C Porwal

(iv) Dr. Suman Agrawal

(v) Dr. P. Dube.

12. The post mortem examination report with its requisition has been placed on record. The requisition dated 19-8-1992 received at 6.15 p.m which reads as follows:

The following are findings of the panel of doctors, highly qualified and experienced:

“On external examination of dead body of young aged about 28 years. Eye balls were open, pupils dilated and fixed, conjunctive pale blood stained fluid coming out from both nostrils fall pale, lips and tongue were pale, tongue was inside the oral cavity and nails were pale, skin pale, Rigur mortis was present no external injury over genital organs and sphincter was normal and not relaxed.”

The following injuries were found:

(1) Transverse contusion reddish blue 4″ × 3½″ on (1) arm middle part on auterolatecal aspect on dissection no bony injury.

(2) Abrasion circular in shape 1½″ × ¾″ with formation on (L) forearm on anterolateral aspect in middle.

(3) Transverse contusion 3″ × 2½″ on autero media aspect mid of (L) leg,

(4) Vertical abrasion 1″ × ¼″ anterior aspect of upper ⅓ of (L) leg,

(5) Contusion 2″ × 2″ reddish blue on anterior aspect of (R) leg before knee,

(6) Contusion 1″ × ½ × ½″ on front of lower ⅓ of (R) leg,

(7) Contusion 3″ × 2″ on dorsum of mid of (R) foot reddish blue in colour,

(8) Contusion 2½″ × 2″ on dorsum of mid of (L) foot, reddish blue in colour,

(9) multiple reddish blue contusions on both buttocks,

(10) Transverse contusions 6″ × ¾″ on the back on sacral region, reddish blue in colour,

(11) Contusion reddish blue in colour 8″ × 3″ on back of (L) thigh upper half,

(12) Contusion reddish blue 4″ × 2″ on back of lower ⅓ of (L) thigh,

(13) Multiple contusions reddish blue on (L) scapular region,

(14) Circular abrasion ¼″ × ¼″ on medial side of (R) wrist.

All above contusions on dissection — the subcutaneous tissues of muscles were cognested. No bony injury any where and no rupture of any major verse were noted.

NOTE: All the injuries were antemortem, caused by hard and blunt object. Their opinion reproduced below:

(1) In our opinion no definite opinion can be given regarding the cause of death. However viscera (pieces) have been presented sealed and handed over to the same police constable to be sent for chemical analysis.

(2) Duration of death was between 18 to 24 hrs. at the time of performing post mortem examination.

(3) Articles: (a) Yellow shirt (b) Black fullpant (c) Blue underwear (d) White baniyan

All the four articles after examination in sealed packet, handed over to the same police constable.

(4) Dead body after P.M examination was handed over to the same police constable.

13. The doctors at no point of time asked for the viscera report from the police nor have they, in their post mortem/examination report, indicate that before giving any opinion they would await the viscera report from the chemical examiner. It was during the course of hearing of this petition, particularly when the magisterial enquiry papers were placed before us, that we asked the Government Advocate to place the viscera report on record. On such report being placed on record by the G.A, the doctors concerned were noticed; accordingly they appeared before this Court. They have filed yet another report in the light of viscera report dated 30-11-1992. It clearly indicates a few passages extracted and cited from Modi's Text Book of Medical Jurisprudence. There is hardly anything, even in the subsequent report filed by the doctors.

14. Shri Khan argued that if the doctors had relied or desired for such a report, they could have asked for it from the police; but they never did so and now they are seeking shelter behind the views expressed by Modi in his Medical Jurisprudence, ignoring the hard realities and their own findings.

15. The viscera report dated 30-11-1992 rules out the possibility of any poisoning.

16. The doctors on 26-4-1993, submitted the following opinion in writing, which reads as follows:

“After seeking the chemical analysis report of viscera of Mohd. Anees s/o Abdul Gaffar whose post mortem examination was carried out on 20-8-1992, our final opinion is that Mohd. Anees s/o Abdul Gaffar died of syncope as a result of cumulative effect of multiple injuries on body.”

On further opportunity being given to the doctors they have come out with a detailed opinion dated 5-5-1993 regarding the post mortem examination of deceased Mohd. Anees, which is also reproduced below:

“A detailed opinion regarding the post mortem examination of the deceased Mohd. Anees s/o Abdul Gaffar (which was carried out by the undersigned doctors) is submitted as under:

On external examination it was found that the skin, nails, face, tongue, lips and conjunctiva were found pale.

The internal examination revealed that abdominal organs such as liver, spleen and kidneys were found pale and the chambers of heart were empty.

All the above mentioned findings in the absence of any poisoning are suggestive of the cause of death being syncope as a result of shock due to cumulative effect of multiple injuries on the body as described in the post mortem report. However there are certain other reasons which can give rise to such type of post mortem findings such as:

(1) A person may the of shock from fright without any marks of violence (due to vaso vagant shock or relex cardiac arrest)

Refnc. Modi's Text Book of Medical Jurisprudence Page No. 281, Twenty first edition. Third reprint.

(2) Premortem conditions e.g heart disease, hypertension, diabetes, mellitus etc. can render the victim more vulnerable to stress reaction.

Refnc. Modi's Text Book of Medical Jurisprudence Page 281, Twenty first edition, Third reprint.

Note: This detailed report is being submitted after seeing the chemical analysis report of viscera on 26-4-1993.

Sd/- doctors.”

17. It cannot be disputed that the pathologist performing autopsy must offer best and reasoned opinion that the facts permit. When the circumstances are so clearly indicative as in the instant case that he can justifiable give cause of death other than unascertainable, and yet not giving it. It is not only unethical but also being dishonest to the dead. Just have a look at their own positive potential findings. What needs to be emphasised is the necessity of obtaining the best possible history and co-relating the pathological findings or lack of them with all the circumstances. While it is also true that a pathologist performing autopsy should not overspeculate where the facts do not warrant it, but in the case at hand there is a whole spectrum of findings recorded by the panel of doctors performing post mortem examination pointing to the degree of certainty so obvious, yet these mighty medical minds without an exception, have opted for, and preferred to remain silent on the cause of death for reasons best known to them.

18. A deliberate calculated silence, where definite conclusive opinion without an element of uncertainty could have been returned. Should one believe that the doctors performing autopsy ought always to bear in mind that even an excellent autopsy can virtually be wasted if the cause of death is withheld (as in the present case).

19. A large number of wounds as noted above, have been found by the doctors, performing autopsy. Yet they are hesitant in coming out with a definite opinion and seeking shelter behind purely academic opinion expressed by Modi in his Text Book. It is not a theoretical opinion sought from them. They are supposed to base their report on positive facts or lack of them. Our prime is the certification of cause of death after autopsy. It was for the reason that the panel was constituted. But what a pity five mighty medical minds were bent upon withholding the opinion in face of their own findings. Findings apart even, lack of such findings as any foreign body or material like dust particles being found in and around the wounded parts of the body even the remote possibility of a traffic accidental death was ruled out. Yet these doctors kept mum for reasons best known to them. By no stretch of imagination could it be the case of sudden or unexpected death, requiring some other pathological processes.

20. There is no finding recorded by the doctors so as to suggest coronary atheroma laminaror (sic.) a focal infract or any arterial disease indicating aorotic aneurysm. In absence of such findings and positive potential facts and findings as recorded it is incomprehensible that the doctors could not have given the report. There is absolutely nothing to indicate any injury from physical agents such as electricity and lightning or that from firearms or explosive so as to pose a question of accidental or suicidal death before forensic pathology. In absence of such finding as indicated above, a crucial question that arises for consideration is as to what prevent or deter the team of doctors performing post mortem examination from giving a honest opinion. Almost daily, cases of negligence reports ranging from discrepancies of gross unceptitive towards the patients on the part of the medical professional appearing in their living or appearing in the press.

21-22. It is not the doctors' case that they waited for the chemical examiner's report or they asked for it, till they are actually summoned by the Court. The injuries, as found and noted by them, clearly point to their cumulative effect — death. Both chambers of heart were found empty, no particles of dust or any foreign matter are noted to have been found in or around the wounded parts. Thus, the possibility of traffic accidental death is ruled out. Yet, these, doctors kept mum on the cause of death for reasons best known to them. There is no such finding recorded by these doctors so as to suggest any cardio-myopathy or aortic aneurysm. The brain and heart were found as healthy. There is nothing to indicate that it could be an incident of fatal pulonary embolism, coronary thrombosis, cerebral thrombosis or haemorrhage. In face of concrete positive findings, as recorded by them, yet they referring to purely academic opinion in Modi's text book, suggesting neurogenic shock, is hardly of any avail to them.

23. So far as the doctors are concerned, it is a conspiracy of silence, and a telling testimony of readiness at heels, to oblige the authority rather than ‘truth’ but a lie remains a lie even if chanted as a hymn by five or fifty. It does not become truth.

24. Shockingly the deplorable state of affairs of Law and Order, as revealed by this petition. It is deeply regrettable that a man be put to death unjustly in order to preserve the order, dignity and tranquility of the state — a state preservable only at such a cost would not be worth preserving. Shri Khan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, therefore, contended that Article 21 of the Constitution, has been denuded of all its efficacy and its sanctity, wilfully sacrilege by both police and physicians combined, and claimed exemplary cost by way of compensation to be awarded to the petitioner for the wrong done to him.

25. Placing reliance on cases after cases starting from Rahul Shah's case, (1983) 3 SCC 141, followed by Sebastian Hongray's, (1984) 3 SCC 82, Bhimsingh's, (1985) 4 SCC 677, it was urged that it is a fit case for grant of monetary compensation by way of exemplary costs. The Supreme Court, has no doubt held, that in appropriate case the Court has jurisdiction to award damages or compensation for alleged losses, humiliation and indignation suffered by the petitioner.

26. Learned Government Advocate, appearing for the respondents submitted that the petition is full of disputed facts calling, for inquiry before any compensation could be awarded.

27. In view of the direction made above, for investigating the case in accordance with law, it would not be proper, for us at this stage to comment any further; lest it prejudices either party. But the question of awarding exemplary cost by way of compensation, can still be considered. In this view of the matter and considering the gravity of the case, to our mind exemplary cost, by way of compensation, of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rs. One Lac) paid by the respondent-State to the petitioner, would meet the ends of justice. Ordered accordingly. We, however, make it clear that it is open to the petitioner to take recourse to the ordinary course of law, for recovery of damages. He can even apply for exemption from payment of Court Fee, if he is so advised and in the event such an application is made, the Court concerned, shall consider it, in accordance with law and with human approach. The above amount shall be taken into account in such a case. It is open to the State to recover the above sum, from those found responsible for perpetrating the crime.

28. The investigation as directed, taking into account the role played by the doctors, in view of the time lapsed, should be completed as early as possible say within three months from today.

29. With this direction, this petition stands allowed with cost of Rs. 1,00,000/- (one Lac). Counsel's fee Rs. 2,500/- (Two thousand five hundred), if certified.

Petition allowed.