- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Babulal And Another v. State Of Madhya Pradesh
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners filed a petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking quashing of proceedings instituted against them under Sections 107 and 116 CrPC. The petitioners produced a photostat copy of a notice (Ex. P/5) directing them to appear before the Court on 6-1-1990 and a certified copy of an order dated 6-1-1990. The certified order, as produced, had been passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (S.D.M.) and bears the case number 256/89 in a matter between the State (through P.S., Tukoganj) and Dhannalal s/o Chenaram.
The record also contains a Section 111 CrPC order calling upon the non-applicant to furnish security of Rs. 1000 for keeping the peace for six months; the next date shown was 6-1-1990. The petitioners appeared on that date, filed personal bonds which were accepted by the Executive Magistrate, and were granted time to file surety; the case was thereafter fixed for 19-3-1990.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notice (Ex. P/5) issued to the petitioners is valid where the notice appears to have been issued by a Naib-Tahsildar while the certified order is shown as passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (S.D.M.).
- Whether any transfer of the proceedings from the S.D.M. to the Naib-Tahsildar was effected in accordance with law (i.e., whether a valid transfer order exists).
- Whether the notice supplied adequate "gist of information" to enable the person proceeded against to know the substance of the information and to reply, or whether the deficiency vitiates the notice and the proceedings.
- Whether the routine practice of passing orders under Section 111 CrPC on pre-cyclostyled proformas, without evidence of judicial application of mind, vitiates the proceedings initiated under Chapters involving Sections 107-112 CrPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The notice (Ex. P/5) is invalid because it appears to have been issued by a Naib-Tahsildar even though the order (certified copy) bears the S.D.M.'s signature — a Naib-Tahsildar cannot, by law, direct issuance of such a notice when the proceedings are before the S.D.M.
- There is no order of transfer on record showing that the case pending before the S.D.M. was lawfully transferred to the Naib-Tahsildar.
- The notice lacks the necessary "gist of information" (it merely mentions a dispute regarding rented accommodation without specifying acts or overt acts or identifying the premises/tenants), making it impossible for the petitioners to frame a reply; therefore the notice is vitiated.
- Reliance was placed on prior authority (Mansoor & Ors. v. State of M.P., 1985) to show lack of application of mind in issuing the notice and on Jagdip & Anr. v. State (1987) to support the proposition that cyclostyled, blank-filled orders vitiate proceedings.
State's / Respondent's Arguments
- The State's counsel submitted that the title printed on the form mentioning the S.D.M. was merely a printed form artifact, and in fact the order was passed by the Naib-Tahsildar.
- It was also submitted (from the record) that the District Magistrate had authorized Naib-Tahsildars to try proceedings under Sections 107 and 116 CrPC (i.e., an argument of authority to try such matters).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mansoor and Ors. v. State of M.P., 1985 (2) CURRENT CRIMINAL JUDGMENTS 313 | Used to show lack of application of mind in issuing a notice/order. | The petitioners relied on this decision to support their contention that the notice exhibited lack of judicial application of mind; the Court treated it as supportive of concerns about mechanical issuance of notices. |
| Jagdip and Anr. v. State, 1987 (2) CRIMES (Delhi) 472 | Holds that cyclostyled or blank-filled forms lacking substance of information vitiate proceedings; requirement that the person proceeded against must know the substance of the information (in light of Sections 107 and 112 CrPC). | The Court quoted and applied the reasoning to the present facts, using it to emphasize that orders and notices lacking substance and produced by mechanical proformas are vitiated and subject to quashing. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining both procedural form and substantive sufficiency of the notices and orders on the record.
First, on the point of authority vs. transfer, the Court distinguished between "authority" and "transfer." While the State indicated that the District Magistrate had authorised Naib-Tahsildars to try proceedings under Sections 107 and 116 CrPC (an argument of authority), the Court treated the crucial question as whether the pending case before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate had been transferred in accordance with law to the Naib-Tahsildar. The Court observed that there was no transfer order placed on the record and that the certified copy filed by the petitioners showed the order as having been passed by the S.D.M. Consequently, the issuance of the notice by a Naib-Tahsildar (Ex. P/5) in circumstances where the record indicated the S.D.M. had passed the order made the notice invalid at its inception.
Second, the Court examined the contents of the notice and concluded it did not supply the required "gist of information." The notice merely referred to a dispute regarding rented accommodation without specifying the acts or overt acts, the premises, or the tenant/co-tenant involved. The Court held such paucity of information rendered it difficult for any person to submit an intelligible reply, making the notice defective and liable to be quashed.
Third, the Court considered more broadly the practice of passing orders under Section 111 CrPC on pre-cyclostyled proformas. It emphasized that an order under Section 111 is a condition precedent to taking further steps under Sections 107–110 and must contain the requisite recorded satisfaction and be communicated. The Court found on the record that such orders were being passed on pre-printed proformas with minimal insertions and without demonstrated judicial application of mind — a practice described by the Court as a "farce."
The Court reiterated the legal duty of a Magistrate to apply his mind to the information received before passing an order under the relevant provisions; mechanical completion of proformas cannot substitute for this statutory duty. Relying on the quoted passage from Jagdip, the Court concluded that where the substance of the information is not stated and the order is mechanistically produced, the proceedings are vitiated by gross illegality.
Because of these defects — invalid issuance (by a non-presiding officer without a transfer order), lack of substance in the notice, and reliance on cyclostyled proformas without recorded application of mind in Section 111 orders — the Court determined that the notices and the proceedings could not stand.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court quashed the notice (Ex. P/5) and, on grounds of procedural irregularity and lack of judicial application of mind in orders under Section 111 CrPC, quashed the proceedings instituted under Sections 107 and 116 CrPC as reflected in the record.
Implications:
- The direct consequence is that the notice in question and the proceedings based on the defective orders were quashed in this petition.
- The Court expressly deprecated the prevailing practice of using pre-cyclostyled proforma orders for matters under Section 111 CrPC and warned Sub-Divisional Magistrates and Executive Magistrates against continuing that practice, indicating that continued use may lead to similar quashings.
- The opinion emphasizes strict adherence to procedural requirements and the necessity of recording the substance of information and judicial application of mind when passing preliminary orders under Section 111 and related provisions. (The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new statutory rule beyond these holdings; it quashes the impugned proceedings on the facts and defects found on the record.)
1. Shri Sonavane for the petitioners. Shri S. M. Jain, Deputy Government Advocate for the State.
2. They are heard on the petition Under Section 482, Criminal Procedure Code preferred by the petitioners praying for quashing of proceedings instituted against them Under Sections 107, 116, Criminal Procedure Code.
3. The petitioners have placed on record photostat copy of the notice, Ex. P/5, calling upon them to appear before the said Court on 6-1-1990. A certified copy of the order dt. 6-1-1990 has also been placed on record. This order, as per the certified copy, has been passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate. The case number as given in the notice, Annexure-P/5 as well as the certified copy is the same - 256/89. The parties are also the same - State through P. S., Tukoganj v. Dhannalal s/o Chenaram.
4. So far as notice, Ex. P/5 is concerned, it is apparent that if the proceedings were before the S.D.M., a Naib-Tahsildar cannot by any stretch of law direct issuance of notice, even for appearance. It is the Presiding Officer of the Court, who to direct issuance of notice. This notice is, therefore, invalid at its very inception and is liable to be quashed and is accordingly quashed.
5. So far as proceedings pending before the S.D.M. as evidence by certified copy of the order-sheet dt. 6-1-1990 are concerned, a fresh notice has been directed to be issued Under Section 111, Criminal Procedure Code, calling upon the non-applicant to furnish security in a sum of Rs. 1000/- for keeping peace for a period of six months. The next date fixed is 6-1-1990. Record of this case is available. On 6-1-1990 the petitioners made their appearance before the Court and filed their personal bonds, which were accepted by the Executive Magistrate. Time was granted to them for filing the surety. Now the case is fixed for 19-3-1990.
6. Shri Sonavane urged that the very issuance of notice itself stands vitiated. The title shows that it was from the Court of Sub-Divisional Magistrate. Learned Dy. Govt. Advocate was therefore, asked if it was the S.D.M., who had passed the order, how can this be when order being passed by the S.D.M. and notice being issued by the Naib-Tahsildar, reconciled. Going through the record it was submitted that the District Magistrate has authorised the Naib-Tahsildars to try such proceedings Under Sections 107 and 116, Criminal Procedure Code.
7. It is not the question of authority. The question is one of transfer. Whether the case which was pending before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate was transferred in accordance with law to the Court of Naib-Tahsildar. There is no such order placed on record. Undeniably the order was passed, as per the certified copy filed by the petitioner, by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate.
8. Shri Jain, however, states that it was merely the printed form, which mentions the S.D.M. in its title, although as a matter of fact, the order was passed by the Naib-Tahsildar.
9. Petitioners' counsel placed reliance on a decision of this Court in Mansoor and Ors., v. State of M. P., 1985 (2) CURRENT CRIMINAL JUDGMENTS page 313 and submitted that it shows lack of application of mind in issuing the notice. .
10. It must be added that these proceedings, which certainly affect citizens' right, should not be routinely adhered to and the required procedure must be strictly followed. If these provisions are not followed, its necessary consequence would be either irregularity or an incurable irregularity in the proceedings. It was stressed by the petitioners' counsel that the irregularities in the present proceedings are of incurable nature. The gist of information has not been supplied to the petitioners. Merely saying that a dispute with regard to a rented accommodation without specifying any act or overact on the part of the petitioners, would not constitute the type of information, which is required to be furnished by the person proceeded against. There is no such information in the notice so as to enable the notice to ascertain the premises or the name of the tenant or co-tenant, who are involved in the dispute. In such circumstances, it is difficult for any person to submit a reply to the notice. This notice is also liable to be quashed and is accordingly quashed.
11. The further question that arises for consideration is whether the defect in the notice would result in vitiating the notice as a whole or it can be corrected at a later stage. The petitioners' counsel maintained that proceedings as a whole would stand vitiated. He placed reliance on a decision in Jagdip and Anr. v. State, 1987 (2) CRIMES (Delhi) page 472, wherein it has been held :
"No grounds which may have persuaded the Court to initiate the proceedings Under section 107 of the code are stated in the order. The blanks are filled in the cyclostyled form. No substance of any information on the basis of which the Court purported to act is stated anywhere. The Courts of law are under an obligation to attend to the provision under which they are acting. They would not be discharging their duties if they do not find time even to read the provisions. Without reading the provision the Court will not become acquainted with its . requirements. The proceedings initiated against the petitioners are vitiated by gross illegality. In view of the postulations in Section 107 and Section 112 of the Code, it is the right of the person or persons proceeded against to know the substance of the information on the basis of which the Magistrate may have acted. Orders passed under those provisions are open to scrutiny at the hands of the Courts of superior jurisdiction."
12. The record shows that even orders Under Section 111, Criminal Procedure Code are passed on pre-cyclostyled proformas. A mere reading of section would show that an order under this section (popularly known as a preliminary order) is a condition precedent for taking further steps in any proceeding Under Sections 107-110. Such order, with its required contents, must be recorded and communicated even where the Police have brought before the Magistrate a person under arrest as a suspected offender (e.g. Under Sections 41, 56 ante) or Under Section 151, even though no summons need be issued because the person is already before the Court.
13. It cannot be denied or disputed that an order made under this provision has a serious repercussion on the individual proceeded against and the record shows the use of pre-cyclostyled proformas with some insertions here or there in passing such orders. No amount of urgency can be oa substitute for this sort of mechanism in passing judicial orders on serious consideration of facts alleged in the complaint. This is nothing short of a farce. The first thing that a Magistrate is required to do after receipt of information is to apply his mind to such information and if he is satisfied on such application of mind, that there is ground for proceeding under this Chapter, he is required to pass an order in writing. This cannot be reduced to a mechanical process, as is evidenced from the record of this case. It is for this reason (and not for the reason as argued by the learned counsel that notice is defective) that the proceedings as a whole are liable to be quashed and are accordingly quashed.
14. In the end the prevailing practice of using pre-cyclostyled forms/proforma orders with a few insertions in the space left blank , in such serious matters, which call for judicial application of mind and recording of satisfaction, as contemplated by Section 111, Criminal Procedure Code must be deprecated in no uncertain terms. It is inconceivable that judicial orders, though required to be passed by Executive Magistrates, could be reduced to cyclostyled proformas. Second Schedule appended to the Code of Criminal Procedure contains Forms of various descriptions. It was never the intention of the Legislature to provide proforma orders to be passed Under Section 111, Criminal Procedure Code. It needs to be impressed upon the Sub-Divisional Magistrate and Executive Magistrates making use of such pre-cyclostyled orders Under Section 111, Criminal Procedure Code, that they must shun this practice forthwith, lest the proceedings may meet the same fate as in this petition.
Alert