- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kamla Devi Mantri v. Grasim Industries Ltd., Birlagram, Nagda And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
Smt. Kamla Devi Mantri filed a petition under section 155 read with section 108 of the Indian Companies Act, 1956 against Grasim Industries Limited and Smt. Sarla Devi Somani. The petitioner alleged that respondent No. 2, her daughter, wrongfully obtained registration as a joint shareholder for 10,774 shares without the petitioner's consent or consideration. The petitioner claimed exclusive ownership of these shares, purchased between 1967 and 1982, which were always reflected as her property in tax returns. She alleged that the respondent manipulated share records to register herself as a joint holder, despite the petitioner’s efforts to have her name removed from the register. The Company refused to rectify the register without the respondent’s consent. The petitioner sought rectification of the Register of Members to remove the respondent’s name and claimed damages and injunctions.
The respondent denied the allegations, asserting that the petitioner had consciously decided to register the shares jointly with her and executed a Will bequeathing the shares to the respondent after her death. The respondent contended that the petitioner acted with full understanding and independent legal advice. The respondent also alleged undue influence by the petitioner’s son, Hari Prasad Mantri, who was said to have instigated the petitioner to file the petition with ulterior motives.
The matter was contested with the petitioner alleging fraud, misrepresentation, and undue influence, while the respondent maintained the legality and validity of the joint registration and Will. The Court was called upon to decide whether to exercise its summary jurisdiction under section 155 of the Companies Act to rectify the share register.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court can exercise its jurisdiction under section 155 of the Companies Act, 1956 to rectify the Register of Members by removing the name of respondent No. 2 as a joint shareholder based on allegations of fraud, misrepresentation, and undue influence.
- Whether the allegations of fraud, undue influence, and misrepresentation can be adjudicated in summary proceedings under section 155 or require a full trial in a Civil Court.
- Whether the purported transfer of shares to respondent No. 2 was valid and lawful, considering compliance with relevant provisions of the Companies Act, including sections 82, 108, and 187-C.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The respondent wrongfully obtained registration as a joint shareholder without the petitioner’s consent or any consideration paid.
- The petitioner never intended to transfer the shares and the signature on the transfer deed was procured by misrepresentation, fraud, or undue influence.
- The insertion of the respondent’s name was illegal, void ab initio, and violated provisions of the Companies Act, including sections 82, 108, and 187-C.
- The petitioner sought rectification of the share register and damages for illegal action, along with injunctions.
Respondent's Arguments
- The petitioner consciously decided to register the shares jointly with the respondent and executed a registered Will bequeathing the shares to the respondent after her death.
- The arrangements were effected with full understanding and independent legal advice from solicitors and tax practitioners.
- The petitioner’s son, Hari Prasad Mantri, exerted undue influence over the petitioner and instigated the petition as part of a scheme to upset the petitioner’s arrangements.
- The petition is liable to be dismissed for invoking summary jurisdiction under section 155 by suppressing material facts and because serious disputes of fact cannot be resolved in summary proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S. Bhagat Singh v. The Piar Bus Service Ltd., AIR 1959 Punjab 352 | Section 155 of the Companies Act is for summary remedy in non-controversial matters; serious disputes require Civil Court adjudication. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the present case involves serious disputes unsuitable for summary proceedings. |
| Jayshree Shantaram Vankudre v. Rajkamal Kalamandir Private Ltd., AIR 1960 Bombay 136 | Proceedings under section 155 are summary and complicated issues should be decided in Civil Courts. | Supported the view that complicated factual disputes in this petition require a full trial. |
| Surendra Kaur v. Singh Engineering Works (P.) Ltd., (1977) 47 Comp. Cas. 638 | Where title is seriously disputed and facts are complicated, section 155 cannot be invoked; remedy lies in Civil Court. | The Court applied this principle to decline jurisdiction under section 155 due to serious factual disputes. |
| Mahendra Kumar Jain v. Federal Chemical Works Ltd., (1955) 35 Comp. Cas. (SC) 651 | Serious disputes over title and facts require Civil Court adjudication, not summary proceedings. | Reinforced the limitation of section 155 jurisdiction in presence of serious disputes. |
| Smt. Puran Devi v. S. Gumam Singh, (1977) 47 Comp. Cas. 796 | Complicated factual questions involving civil rights cannot be decided in company petitions under section 155. | Used to support refusal of summary jurisdiction in the present case. |
| Public Passenger Service Ltd. v. M.A Khadar, (1966) 36 Comp. Cas. (S.C) 1 | Court may refuse relief under section 155 if matter is complex and better suited for suit. | The Court exercised discretion to dismiss petition and direct parties to Civil Court. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recognized that under section 155(3) of the Companies Act, 1956, it has power to decide questions relating to the title of persons in the register and to rectify the register. However, the Court emphasized that section 155 is intended to provide a summary remedy in non-controversial matters or where quick decisions are necessary to prevent irreparable harm. The Court cited multiple precedents holding that serious disputes involving allegations of fraud, misrepresentation, undue influence, and complicated factual questions require full trial in a Civil Court rather than summary proceedings under section 155.
In this case, the petitioner challenged the validity of a registered Will and letters authorizing joint registration of shares on grounds of fraud and undue influence. The Court found these issues to be complex and requiring detailed evidence and full adjudication, which cannot be done in summary proceedings based only on affidavits. The Court also noted the respondent's claim that the petitioner acted with independent legal advice and full understanding, further indicating disputed facts.
Therefore, the Court held that the petition was not suitable for adjudication under section 155 and that the petitioner was free to pursue remedies in a Civil Court where all factual disputes could be properly examined.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED WITH NO ORDER AS TO COSTS.
The Court dismissed the petition under section 155 of the Companies Act, 1956, on the ground that the matter involves serious disputes of fact and complicated questions of law which are unsuitable for summary proceedings. The petitioner is directed to seek relief through appropriate Civil Court proceedings. No new precedent was established; the decision reinforces the principle that section 155 is not a substitute for trial in cases involving contested title and allegations of fraud or undue influence.
1. Smt. Kamla Devi Mantri, residing at 6/3, Queens Park, Calcutta, has filed this petition under section 155 read with section 108 of the Indian Companies Act, 1956 against the Grasim Industries Limited, Birlagram, Nagda (hereinafter referred to as the Company) and Smt. Sarla Devi Somani.
2. The Company is incorporated under the coporate name and style of the Gwalior Rayon Silk Manufacturing (Weaving) Compnay Limited. The authorised share capital of the Company is thirty crores and fifty lakhs divided into 2,50,00,000 ordinary shares of Rs. 100/- each. The paid up share capital of the Company is Rs. 23,07,00,000 divided into 2,15,90,000 ordinary shares of Rs. 10/- each fully paid up and 1,48,275 preference shares of Rs. 100/- each fully paid up. The aforesaid share capital of the Company and the objects with which the company was established, as Enumerated in para 5 of the petition, are not in dispute. Articles 44, 45, 46, 47, 50, 51, 54, 55, 56, 58, 59 and 60, as enumerated in para 5(b) are also not in dispute. It is also a common ground that the respondent No. 2 is the daughter of the petitioner.
3. The grievance of the petitioner is that the respondent No. 2 Smt. Somani has wrongfully and illegally obtained registration in her name as the second joint holder along with the petitioner as the first named share-holder in respect of petitioner's 10774 ordinary shares of Rs. 10/- each fully paid up in the first respondent on the basis of a purported transfer apparently. But in fact the petitioner neither intended to transfer the aforesaid shares nor received any consideration for such transfer as the said second respondent has no right, title or interest in the said 10774 shares. The petition has, therefore, been filed to seek rectification of the register of the Register of Members of the first respondent by deleting the name of the second respondent therefrom as the joint share-holder in respect of the aforementioned shares thereby retaining the name of the petitioner alone on the said register and the said share certificates.
4. The circumstances averred in support of the aforesaid reliefs sought by the petitioner are that on various dates between 1967 and 1982 the petitioner purchased 10774 ordinary shares in the company for valuable consideration and they were duly registered in her name. The petitioner has always been and still claims to be the sole, exclusive and absolute owner of the said shares and they are and have always been in her exclusive possession. She has also shown the aforesaid shares along with her other property in her wealth tax and income-tax returns as her own exclusive property. Similarly the dividends on the aforesaid shares were also shown in the returns before the Tax Authorities.
5. The petitioner is the widow of one Malchand Mantri, who died in or about 8th January, 1971. Since then she has not been keeping good health. She also cannot read or write and even speak properly. In view of the aforesaid physical condition of the petitioner she always reposed trust and confidence on her son G.P Mantri and after his death in 1979, on his two sons namely Shrikant Mantri and Devendra Mantri, who used to manage and look after her entire financial matters, including the shares in question. Smt. Somani, who often came and stayed with the petitioner at her residence at Calcutta had full access to the valuable, movable and other properties and documents of the petitioner. During her intermittent temporary stays Smt. Somani offered assistance and advice to the petitioner in the matter of looking after her properties and affairs and, therefore, the petitioner at the instance of Smt. Somani signed various documents on different occasions. But she came to know of the real sinister implications and most prejudicial consequences of signing the documents at the instance of Smt. Somani. Only recently when in October 1987 the petitioner received a proxy form from Pilani Investment and Industries Corporation Ltd. in which company also the petitioner has purchased shares, wherein she found that the name of Shrikant Mantri was mentioned as the second joint holder of the said shares. The petitioner was astonished to know that the name of someone else in addition to her name had been put up on the-said shares. Therefore, she took steps to find out the details about all her shares, including the shares in question. The respondent No. 2 Smt. Somani had so managed that the record of the shares could not reach the hands of the petitioner and, therefore, till October, 1987 the petitioner could not know of the aforesaid manipulation of respondent No. 2. In view of the relationship between the petitioner and the respondent No. 2 she could not openly agitate the action of respondent No. 2 in getting the names of others inserted in the share certificates. She, however, persuaded the respondent No. 2 to issue necessary letter acknowledging her absence of interest in the said 10774 shares and evincing absence of any objection to the deletion of her name from the Register of Members of the respondent Company as the second registered holder of the said shares, jointly with the petitioner. However, the respondent No. 2 did not yield to the persuasion of the petitioner.
6. Thereafter on enquiry the petitioner came to know that prompted by greed the respondent No. 2 by taking undue advantage of clause 69 of the Articles of Association of the Company had submitted to the company a transfer deed or deeds purportedly containing the petitioner's signatures showing transfer of the said 10774 shares jointly to the petitioner and the respondent No. 2 and on the basis of that, obtained the registration of the name of the second respondent as the second named joint holder of the said 10774 shares in the Register of Members of the first respondent. Therefore, on November 3, 1987 the petitioner wrote a letter to the Company expressing her intention to have the Register of Members of the first respondent rectified by deleting the name of the second respondent as the joint holder, whereupon the Company asked the petitioner to execute transfer deeds along with the second respondent Smt. Somani to delete the name of Smt. Somani from the share register as joint holder of the said 10774 shares, upon which the petitioner informed the Company of her inability to obtain the signature of Smt. Somani in the transfer deed and requested the Company to do the needful on the basis of her letter dated 3rd November, 1987. But the Company, vide its reply dated 5th December, 1987 refused to rectify its share register unless and until the deeds were executed by the second respondent Smt. Somani along with the petitioner. The petitioner also sent a letter on November 21, 1987 asking the second respondent to make a suitable declaration acknowledging that she had no right, title or interest in the said shares, but in vain.
7. According to the petitioner the insertion of the name of the second respondent as the joint holder of the said shares in the Register of Members of the Company was and is illegal, invalid, void and inoperative ab initio. She, therefore, seeks a relief for the removal of the name of the second respondent from the shares in question as a joint holder of the shares because she never executed any transfer deed intending to transfer any of the shares in question in favour of the second respondent as the joint holder of the shares. The signature of the petitioner has been procured on misrepresentation or fraudulently and/or by undue influence. The petitioner had no occasion to transfer the shares to respondent No. 2 and this fact is evident from the fact that she has not received any consideration for the alleged transfer. Even if the signature or signatures of the petitioner on the said transfer deed even if proved were procured without her consent in the aforementioned circumstances. The transfer is also illegal in view of the violation of Section 82 of the Companies Act, 1956 and the Company had no power to approve the said transfer of shares. The transfer of shares is also in violation of Section 108 of the Companies Act, 1956. It has also been averred that the provisions of section 187-C of the Companies Act, 1956 have also not been complied with. A claim for award of damages has been made in view of the illegal action of the respondent. Therefore, a relief for rectification of the records of the first respondent in respect of inserting the name of the respondent No. 2 as joint share-holder and also on the share certificates is sought. A prayer of injunction against the respondents pending the petition has also been made.
8. The petition has been resisted by the respondent No. 2 through her constituted attorney Shri Bafkishan Toshniwal on the ground that the application is liable to be dismissed inter alia on the ground that the petitioner has invoked the summary jurisdiction of the Hon'ble Court under the provisions of section 155 of the Companies Act by suppressing material facts from the Court. According to respondent No. 2 Smt. Kamla Devi Mantri is the widow of Malchand Mantri, who died on 8th January, 1971 and she is about 87 years of age and respondent No. 12 Smt. Somani is the daughter of the petitioner. The petitioner was owner of various movable and immovable properties, including the shares in question and the shares stood in the sole name of the petitioner. Immediately before December 1985 she irrevocably decided to transfer the said shares into the joint names of the petitioner and respondent No. 2 so that they can hold the said shares as joint owners during her life time and intended that after her death the respondent No. 2 should be the sole and absolute owner thereof. The petitioner also executed a registered will on 13th December 1988 and her intention pertaining to the shares finds place in Clause 5 of the aforesaid will wherein she had expressed her desire to bequeath the said 10774 duly paid up equity shares in Grasim Industries Limited, including all bonus shares which might be issued by the said Company from time to time to the respondent No. 2 herein. A copy of the will has been annexed as Annexure-A. In pursuance to the aforesaid decision of the petitioner she, vide letter dated 12th December, 1985 applied to the respondent Company to have the said shares registered in the joint names of the petitioner and respondent No. 2. Later on by letter dated 18th December, 1985 the petitioner directed the respondent Company that on her death the respondent No. 2 should be treated as the sole owner and sole holder of all the shares which would be standing in the joint names. By their letter dated 27th January, 1986 the respondent Company agreed to transmit the said shares into the name of the respondent No. 2; on furnishing death certificate of the petitioner in due course. Since then the respondent No. 2 and the petitioner became joint owners of the shares till the death of the petitioner and on the death of the petitioner the respondent No. 2 will become the sole and absolute owner of the said shares. The aforesaid transactions and arrangements, including the execution of the Will were advised by a well known and competent firm of solicitors Khaitan and Company, Advocates. The petitioner effected the aforesaid arrangements with full understanding of the implications and on independent legal advice from her solicitors and Income-tax Practitioners.
9. It has been further averred that since September, 1987 the eldest son of the petitioner one Hari Prasad Mantri had been able to isolate the petitioner from her other relations and regular advisers and has been in a position to dominate her Will. Other relations and advisers have been denied access to the petitioner. As a result the petitioner is not in a position to obtain independent legal advice relating to any of her affairs. Thus, taking advantage of the aforesaid relationship, advanced age and failing health of the petitioner the aforesaid Hari Prasad Mantri has been scheming to upset the arrangements the petitioner had entered into consciously with the help and advice of regular advisers and the instant petition is a part of the said scheme of the said Hari Prasad Mantri. The said Hari Prasad Mantri has also instigated the petitioner to file a suit in the Alipore Court, West Bengal, in respect of a tenancy agreement between the petitioner and The Manipur Tea Company Pvt. Ltd. He also brought into existence the purported deed of Trust dated 7th October, 1987. The aforesaid Mantri has also instigated the petitioner to initiate a criminal proceeding under section 144, Criminal Procedure Code against Shrikant Mantri and Devendra Kumar Mantri on false and untenable grounds. As such it is quite apparent that the said Hari Prasad Mantri has prevailed upon the petitioner to file the instant application under section 155 of the Companies Act with an ulterior motive. The letters written to the Company and the instant petition have been filed by the said Hari Prasad Mantri in the name of the petitioner by exercising undue influence on the petitioner. The allegations made in the petition have been emphatically denied by the respondents and they have also denied violation of any provisions of the Companies Act in recording the respondent No. 2 as joint holder of the shares with the petitioner. The other facts have also been pleaded in the reply, mentioning the circumstances under which the petitioner took a decision to transfer the shares in question to the respondent No. 2 and how the circumstances changed as a result of the influence of Hari Prasad Mantri. It has, therefore, been pleaded that the petition be dismissed.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner Shri Chitale has strenuously argued that the Will in question was not executed by the petitioner of her own free will, but the Will was executed as a result of fraud and misrepresentation. Similarly the petitioner never consciously and of her own will, ever made a request to the Company to record the name of the respondent No. 2 as a joint holder of the shares. The whole transaction has been effected fraudulently by misrepresentation and exercising undue influence on the petitioner.
11. On the other hand the learned counsel for the respondents Shri Waghmare argued that the nature of the allegations made in the petition cannot be a subject matter of enquiry in this petition. Proceedings under section 155 of the Companies Act are summary in nature and, therefore, the only course open to the petitioner is to seek the relief by filing a Civil Suit and no relief on the grounds as claimed by the petitioner can be given to the petitioner in this petition in view of the serious allegations pertaining to fraud, misrepresentation and undue influence.
12. It is not in dispute before me that this being a case prior to the amendment in the Indian Companies Act, 1956, this Court can exercise powers under section 155 of the Indian Companies Act as it stood before the amendment. According to section 155(3) of the Companies Act, the Court is empowered to decide any question relating to the title of any person who is a party to the application to have his name entered in or omitted from the register and is also empowered generally to decide any other question which it is necessary or expedient to decide in connection with the application for rectification. However, the object of this provision under the Companies Act is to provide a summary remedy in non-controversial matters or in matters where a quick decision may be necessary to obviate any irreparable injury to the party. In S. Bhagat Singh v. The Piar Bus Service Ltd., Amritsar, AIR 1959 Punjab 352 it has been held that the provisions of section 155 of the Companies Act are not intended for settling controversies under several” heads necessitating a regular investigation. When serious disputes are involved the proper forum for their adjudication is a Civil Court. The proceedings for rectification of Register of Members are of summary nature. Therefore, where a summary remedy may be necessary to obviate an irreparable injury to a party, then section 155 can be invoked. In Jayshree Shantaram Vankudre v. Rajkamal Kalamandir Private Ltd., AIR 1960 Bombay 136 the Bombay High Court has also taken the same view that the proceedings under section 155 of the Companies Act are summary in nature and issues of complicated nature arising therein should not be decided in those proceedings. The proper forum for adjudication of those disputes is a regular Civil Court. The Allahabad High Court in (1977) 47 Company Cases 638 in the case of Surendra Kaur v. Singh Engineering Works (P.) Ltd., placing reliance on the Supreme Court judgment of Mahendra Kumar Jain v. Federal Chemical Works Ltd., (1955) 35 Comp. Cos. (SC) 651 has held that where the petitioner's title was itself seriously disputed and where there are several disputed questions of facts requiring determination, section 155 could not be applied and share register could not be rectified and the petitioner was free to pursue the remedies in the Civil Court. Similarly the Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Smt. Puran Devi v. S. Gumam Singh, (1977) 47 Comp. Cos. 796 has held that the complicated question of facts involving civil rights of the parties cannot be decided in a company petition. section 155 of the Companies Act being for exercise of the summary jurisdiction, the Company Court would refuse to exercise jurisdiction under this section, where complicated facts are involved for determination of the petition. Proceedings under section 155 are meant for rectification of mistake or error of a minor nature. Reliance has been placed on Public Passenger Service Ltd. v. M.A Khadar, (1966) 36 Comp. Cas. (S.C) 1, wherein the Supreme Court has held that where by reason of complexity or otherwise the matter can more conveniently be decided in a suit, the Court may refuse relief under section 155 in exercise of the discretionary jurisdiction and relegate the parties to a suit.
13. In the instant case the Will executed by the petitioner-has been challenged by her on the basis of fraud, misrepresentation and indirectly the petitioner has sought a relief from this Court to ignore a registered Will which is executed by the petitioner on the ground of fraud, misrepresentation and undue influence. Similarly the letters alleged to have been written by the petitioner to the Company seeking inclusion of the name of respondent No. 2 as a joint holder of the shares along with the petitioner is also challenged on the basis of undue influence, fraud and misrepresentation. These are issues which can very well be decided in the Civil Court, where detailed evidence can be led by the parties pertaining to the relationship of petitioner and respondent No. 2 and the circumstances under which the Will was executed and the letters were sent to the Company in respect of inclusion of the names of respondent No. 2 in the shares as a joint holder and also intimation to the Company that in the event of the death of the petitioner the respondent No. 2 shall be the sole owner of the shares. These questions cannot be decided on the basis of the affidavits and in the summary proceedings before the Court.
14. Therefore, in view of the aforementioned decisions of the different High Courts, with which I repectfully agree, it is not a fit case wherein invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under section 155 of the Companies Act the petition, may be admitted for adjudication. This petition filed by the petitioner is, therefore, dismissed with no order as to costs.
Petition dismissed.
Alert