- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gangaram Bendil v. Rashmi Parihar And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This Letters Patent Appeal was filed by the returned candidate (the appellant) against an order dated 18-8-1986 made by a learned single Judge in Election Petition No. 23 of 1985. The election petitioner (respondent No. 1) challenged the appellant's election to the Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly from No. 16, Lashkar East constituency in the 1985 election on the ground of corrupt practice.
After service of the election petition, the appellant filed his return and objected to the maintainability of the petition on the ground that the petitioner had not served a true copy of the affidavit (which the appellant contended was an integral part of the petition) duly attested on the respondents, and therefore the petition was liable to be dismissed under Section 81 read with Section 86 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. On this objection the following preliminary issue was framed and decided against the appellant by the learned single Judge:
"(i). Whether the affidavit contemplated in the proviso to Section 83(1) of the Act is integral part of the Election Petition? If so, whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for the alleged non-compliance of the provisions of Sections 81(3) and 83(1) of the Act?"
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the affidavit contemplated in the proviso to Section 83(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 is an integral part of an election petition.
- If the affidavit is integral, whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for alleged non-compliance with Sections 81(3) and 83(1) of the Act (particularly where the copy of the affidavit supplied omitted the designation and endorsement of the person who administered the oath).
- Whether a letters patent appeal against the interlocutory order of the learned single Judge was maintainable under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent (a preliminary objection was raised on this ground, but the Court declined to decide it and proceeded to the merits).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (counsel: Shri R.K. Shinde)
- The learned single Judge correctly held that the affidavit is an integral part of the petition.
- However, the Judge erred in not holding that the endorsements made by the officer administering the oath are intrinsic to the affidavit; omission of those endorsements in the copies furnished under Section 81(3) is fatal to the maintainability of the petition.
- An affidavit sworn before an unauthorised officer would not be an affidavit in law; therefore omission to supply particulars about the officer administering the oath is a material omission going to the root of the petition, especially given the strict legislative intent behind Sections 81(3) and 86 of the Act.
Respondent No.1's Arguments (counsel: Shri P.L. Dubey)
- Contended that the impugned order did not amount to a 'judgment' under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent and therefore the letters patent appeal might be incompetent (the Court did not decide this preliminary objection and proceeded on merits).
- Disputed the correctness of the learned single Judge's finding that the affidavit formed an integral part of the petition, but supported the Judge's conclusion that the omission of the rubber stamp endorsement of the Deputy Registrar in the copy of the affidavit did not render the copy invalid or violative of Sections 81(3) and 83(1) of the Act.
- Relied on the text of Section 81(3) (speaking of supply of copies of the petition) and Section 86(1) (providing for dismissal for non-compliance with Section 81 or 82 or 117) to argue that the requirement specifically relates to copies of the petition and that the proviso to Section 81(1) (which requires an affidavit in a prescribed form where corrupt practice is alleged) does not make the omission complained of fatal.
- Relied on prior decisions (including pre-1956 position and authorities such as Kidwai Hussain Kamil v. Yadav Ram Sewak; N. P. Chengalrava Naidu v. C. N. Pattabhi Reddi; Mahesh Prasad Sinha v. Manjay Lal) to support his construction that the requirements were satisfied and the petition was not liable to be dismissed for the defect complained of.
- Sought to distinguish Supreme Court decisions M. Kamalam v. V.A.S. Mohammed and M. Karunanidhi v. H.V. Handa relied upon by the learned single Judge; the Court did not accept the attempted distinction.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Laxmi Narain v. Ramratan, 1986 Jab LJ 238; AIR 1986 Madh Pra 165 (Full Bench) | That a letters patent appeal against an interlocutory order amounting to 'judgment' in an election petition is competent. | The Court observed that, in view of this Full Bench decision, it was not disputed that such an appeal is competent; however, the Court chose not to decide the preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the appeal and proceeded to decide the appeal on merits. |
| M. Kamalam v. V.A.S. Mohammed, AIR 1978 SC 840 | Interprets Section 81(3) and Section 83 and holds that the affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 83(1) forms part of the election petition; the copy required under Section 81(3) would include the affidavit. | The Court relied on the passage from this Supreme Court decision to support the conclusion that the affidavit is an integral part of the election petition and that copies filed under Section 81(3) should include a copy of the affidavit. |
| M. Karunanidhi v. H.V. Handa, AIR 1983 SC 558 | Cited by the learned single Judge (along with M. Kamalam) in support of the proposition that the affidavit forms an integral part of an election petition. | The respondent sought to distinguish this authority, but the Court did not accept the attempted distinction and treated the authority as supportive of the single Judge's view that the affidavit is integral to the petition. |
| Kidwai Hussain Kamil v. Yadav Ram Sewak (reported reference as cited in the opinion) | Relied upon by respondent to show that the requirement of filing an affidavit is given in the proviso to Section 81(1) and to support the contention that the petition could not be said to be wanting in the requirement of Section 81(3). | The Court recorded that respondent relied on this authority, among others, in support of his contention that the defect was not fatal; the Court nevertheless rejected the appellant's contention that the omission complained of rendered the petition invalid. |
| N. P. Chengalrava Naidu v. C. N. Pattabhi Reddi (1963) 25 ELR 168; AIR 1964 Andh Pra 164 | One of the decisions relied upon by respondent to support the construction of Sections 81 and 83 advanced by respondent. | The Court noted reliance upon this authority but based its conclusion on the reasoning in M. Kamalam and related authorities; the Court found no authority to show that the particular defect in the copy of the affidavit was fatal. |
| Mahesh Prasad Sinha v. Manjay Lal (1963) 25 ELR 130; AIR 1964 Pat 53 | Relied upon by respondent to support the contention about the scope of filing requirements and that the petition remained compliant. | Referenced by the Court as among the authorities relied upon by respondent; the Court nonetheless held that omission of the officer's endorsements in the copy supplied was not fatal. |
| Sahodrabai Rai v. Ram Singh Aharwar, (1968) 3 SCR 13 : AIR 1968 SC 1079 | Explained that Sub-section (2) of Section 81 applies only to schedules or annexures which are an integral part of the election petition, not to documents which are merely evidence; used to support that an affidavit in the proviso to Section 83(1) is part of the petition where it is integral. | The Court quoted and relied on the passage explaining the scope of Sub-section (2) and used that reasoning to support the view that the affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 83(1) forms part of the election petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded in two main stages: (A) whether the affidavit is an integral part of an election petition, and (B) whether the omission of particulars about the officer administering the oath and his endorsements in the copy of the affidavit supplied to the respondent rendered the petition liable to dismissal.
A. On whether the affidavit is integral to the petition
- The Court accepted the reasoning of the Supreme Court in M. Kamalam and the exposition in Sahodrabai Rai that the proviso to Section 83(1) and the context of Section 81 indicate that the affidavit contemplated there is intended to be regarded as part of the election petition.
- The Court quoted M. Kamalam to show that Section 83 deals with the contents of an election petition and that the affidavit in support of corrupt practice allegations is introduced in the section dealing with contents; by analogy with Sub-section (2) (which treats certain annexures as integral), the affidavit forms an integral part of the election petition.
- On that basis the Court agreed with the single Judge's conclusion that the affidavit forms part of the election petition and that copies filed under Section 81(3) would, on a fair reading, include a copy of the affidavit.
B. On whether omission of endorsements and officer particulars in the copy supplied was fatal
- The Court examined the precise statutory language of Section 81(3) (which speaks of copies of the petition and their attestation as true copies) and Section 81(1) proviso (which prescribes the affidavit in the prescribed form).
- The Court held that what is material are the form and contents of the affidavit insofar as they pertain to the allegations and particulars of corrupt practice; procedural formalities such as how the oath was administered and the officer's endorsement are not the substantive "contents" of the affidavit for the purposes of these provisions.
- The Court observed that neither Section 81(3) nor Section 81(1) expressly requires that the endorsements of the officer administering the oath be reproduced in the copies filed under Section 81(3), or that such endorsements form part of the petition's contents.
- The Court noted that the appellant could not cite any authority holding a defect of this nature to be fatal to maintainability; while recognising the principle of strict construction in election law, the Court found no reason to treat the omission as fatal.
- The Court further reasoned that accepting the appellant's argument would lead to absurd results (for example, extending the argument to require reproduction of court-fee particulars or stamp nature in copies), and concluded that the omission did not go to the root of the petition.
On the basis of these conclusions the Court found no substance in the appeal and dismissed it.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Letters Patent Appeal is DISMISSED. The Court affirmed the learned single Judge's relevant conclusions (notably that the affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 83(1) is an integral part of the election petition) and rejected the contention that omission of the officer's endorsements and designation in the copy of the affidavit furnished under Section 81(3) was fatal to the petition's maintainability. The Court made no order as to costs.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's Letters Patent Appeal failed; the single Judge's preliminary determination adverse to the appellant stands as to the issues addressed in this appeal, and the alleged omission in the copy of the affidavit did not invalidate the election petition or require its dismissal.
- Broader legal implication: The Court applied existing authorities (notably M. Kamalam and Sahodrabai Rai) to confirm that the affidavit in support of corrupt practice allegations is to be treated as part of the election petition. The Court declined to hold that the particular procedural omission complained of was precedent-setting; it treated the omission as non-fatal and did not purport to establish a new broad rule beyond the application of these authorities to the facts.
This summary is confined to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.
1. This Letters Patent Appeal by the returned candidate is directed against an order passed on 18-8-1986 by the learned single Judge of this Court in a pending Election Petition No. 23 of 1985.
2. The respondent No. 1 challenged the election of the appellant as a member of the Legislative Assembly of the State of Madhya Pradesh from No. 16, Lashkar East constituency in the election held in 1985 on the ground of corrupt practice. After service of notice of the election petition, the appellant filed his return and, inter alia, raised an objection about the maintainability of the petition on the ground that
"the affidavit is an integeral part of the petition and a true copy thereof duly attested under the signatures of the petitioner has to be served on the respondents. But the petitioner has not served a true copy of the affidavit on the Answering Respondent. As such the petition is liable to be dismissed summarily under Section 81 read with Section 86 of the Act."On the basis of this objection, following issue was framed, tried and decided as a preliminary issue against the appellant by the impugned order of the learned single Judge : --
"(i). Whether the affidavit contemplated in the proviso to Section 83(1) of the Act is integral part of the Election Petition? If so, whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for the alleged non-compliance of the provisions of Sections 81(3) and 83(1) of the Act?"
3. In view of a full Bench decision of this Court in Laxmi Narain v. Ramratan. 1986 Jab LJ 238 : (AIR 1986 Madh Pra 165), it was not disputed that a letters patent appeal against an interlocutory order, amounting to 'judgment' within the meaning of Clause 10 of the Letters Patent, passed in an election petition by a single Judge is competent. It was, however, submitted by Shri P.L. Dubey the learned counsel for the election petitioner that the impugned order in the present appeal did not amount to 'judgment' within the meaning of Clause 10 of the Letters Patent and therefore the appeal was incompetent. Several authorities were cited in support of the contention, but we do not propose to decide the preliminary objection about maintainability of the appeal, or to deal with various cases cited on either side and proceed to decide the appeal on merits.
4. It was not disputed that the election petition was accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed form and that the requisite number of copies of the petition along with affidavit were filed with the election petition. It was also not in dispute that the affidavit was sworn in before a competent person and that the copies of affidavit filed with the copies of petition were attested by the election-
petitioner under her own signatures to be true copies of the affidavit. The copy of the affidavit supplied to the appellant was complete in all respect, it omitted to reproduce the designation of the person, who administered oath to the election-petitioner, as also the endorsement made by him in the original affidavit at the time of administering the oath. It was, therefore, contended that the appellant was not supplied with a true copy of the affidavit and as it formed integral part of the petition, the election petition was liable to be dismissed in view of the mandatory provisions of Section 81(3), read with Section 86 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, (for short, the "Act").
5. Shri R.K. Shinde, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the learned single Judge came to a right conclusion that the affidavit formed integral part of the petition, but erred in not holding that the endorsements made by the officer administering oath were intrinsic part of the affidavit and, therefore, omission to mention them in the copies furnished in accordance with Section 81(3) of the Act was fatal to the maintainability of the petition. According to him, an affidavit sworn before an unauthorised officer would be no affidavit in the eye of law. Consequently the omission to give the said particualrs in the copy of the affidavit supplied to the appellant would be a material omission, going to the root of the petition, in the light of the legislative intent and purpose in making strict provisions in Sections 81(3) and 86 of the Act.
6. In his elaborate and forceful argument, Shri P.L. Dubey, the learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 disputed the correctness of the finding recorded by the learned single Judge that the affidavit formed integral part of the petition and at the same time, supported his finding that
"mere omission in the copy of the 'affidavit' R-l/2(b) of the rubber stamp endorsement of the Deputy Registrar did not render the copy served on the respondent invalid and violative of Sections 81(3) and 83(1) of the Act."In support the first part of his argument, Shri Dubey drew our attention to the provisions of Section 81(3), which speak of supply of copies of petition and not of an affidavit and those of Section 86(1), providing for dismissal of a petition, which does not comply with the provision of Section 81 or Section 82 or Section 117 of the Act. He also relied on the provision of the Act prior to its amendment in 1956 and in Kidwai Hussain Kamil v. Yadav Ram Sewak. ( 1963) 25 ELR 35 : ( AIR 1964 All 86) N. P. Chengalrava Naidu v. C. N. Pattabhi Reddi. (1963) 25 ELR 168 : ( AIR 1964 Andh Pra 164) and Mahesh Prasad Sinha v. Manjay Lal ( 1963) 25 ELR 130 : (AIR 1964 Pat 53) and submitted that the requirement of filing an affidavit was given in proviso to Section 81(1) and therefore, the petition could not be said to be wanting in requirement of Section 81(3), or to be liable to dismissal under Section 86(1) of the Act.
7. Though Shri Dubey tried to distinguish the two decisions of the Supreme Court in M. Kamalam v. V.A.S. Mohammed, AIR 1978 SC 840; and M. Karunanidhi v. H.V. Handa, AIR 1983 SC 558, relied on by the learned single Judge for his conclusion that the affidavit forms integral part of an election petition, we do not find ourselves inclined to accept the argument, or to take a view contrary to one taken by the learned single Judge. Apart from the reasons given by the learned Judge, we find support to the view taken in the following passage from the decision of the Supreme Court in M. Kamalam (ibid) : --
"5. Now the first question which arises is as to what constitutes an election petition for the purpose of Section 81, Sub-section (3). Is it confined only to election petition proper or does it also include a schedule or annexure contemplated in Sub-section (2) of Section 83 or a supporting affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 83, Sub-section (1)? To answer this question, we must turn to Section 83 which deals with contents of an election petition. Sub-section (1) of that section sets out what an election petition shall contain and provides that it shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 for the verification of pleadings. The proviso requires that where the petitioner alleges any corrupt practice, the election petition shall also be "accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed form in support of the allegation of such corrupt practice and the particulars thereof." The context in which the proviso occurs clearly suggests that the affidavit is intended to be regarded as part of the election petition. Otherwise, it need not have been introduced in a section dealing with contents of an election petition nor figured as a proviso to a Sub-section which lays down what shall be the contents of an election petition. Sub-section (2) also by analogy supports this inference. It provides that any schedule or annexure to an election petition shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in the same manner as an election. It is now established by the decision of this Court in Sahodrabai Rai v. Ram Singh Aharwar, (1968) 3 SCR 13 : AIR 1968 SC 1079, that Sub-section (2) applies only to a schedule or annexure which is an integral part of the election petition and not to a schedule or annexure which is merely evidence in the case but which is annexed to the election petition merely for the sake of adding strength to it. The scope and ambit of Sub-section (2) was explained in the following words by Hidayatullah, J., speaking on behalf of the Court in Sahodrabai's case (supra) at pages 19-20 (of SCR) : (at pp. 1082, 1083 of i AIR) :
We are quite clear that Sub-section (2) of Section 81 has reference not to a document which is produced as evidence of the averments of the election petition but to averments of the election petition which are put, not in the election petition but in the accompanying schedules or annexures. We can give quite a number of examples from which it would be apparent that many of the averments of the election petition are capable of being put as schedules or annexures. For example, the details of the corrupt practice there in the former days used to be set out separately in the schedules and which may, in some cases, be so done even after the amendment of the present law. Similarly, details of averments too compendious for being included in the election petition may be set out in the schedules or annexures to the election petition. The law then requires that even though they are outside the election petition, they must be signed and verified but such annexures or schedules are then treated as integrated with the election petition and copies of them must be served on the respondent if the requirement regarding serviceof the election petition is to be wholly complied with. But, what we have said here does not apply to documents which are merely evidence in the case but which for reason of clarity and to lend force to the petition are not kept back but produced or filed with the election petitions. They are in no sense an integral part of the averments of the petition but are only evidence of those averments and in proof thereof. It would, therefore, be seen that if a schedule or annexure is an integral part of the election petition, it must be signed by the petitioner and verified, since it forms part of the election petition. The subject-matter of Sub-section (2) is thus a schedule or annexure forming part of the election petition and hence it is placed in Section 81 which deals with the contents of an election petition. Similarly, and for the same reasons, the affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 81 Sub-section (1) also forms part of the election petition. The election, petition is in truth and reality one document, consisting of two parts, one being the election petition proper and the other being the affidavit referred to in the proviso to Section 81, Sub-section (1). The copy of the election petition required to be filed under first part of Sub-section (3) of Section 81, would, therefore, on a fair reading of that provision along with section 83, include a copy of the affidavit. That is why the appellant attached a copy of the affidavit to the copy of the election petition proper and filed the two as one single document along with the election petition.
8. Now the main surviving controversy between the parties relates to the effect of omission to give particulars about the officer administering oath to the election-petitioner and his endorsements in the copy of the affidavit supplied to the appellant. Here also we are of the view that the conclusions reached by the learned single Judge calls for no interference. The learned counsel for the appellant could not give us any authority to snow that the defect of the nature pointed out in the copy of the affidavit supplied to the appellant was ever considered to be fatal to the maintainability of an election petition. He remained satisfied by citing authorities after authorities to establish that filing of copies of petition and their attestation to be a true copy of the petition under Section 81(3) were essential requirement for maintainability of an election petition and that the provisions required, strict literal construction. We have no dispute with the general principle of law laid down by the Supreme Court and different High Courts in their various decisions about strict interpretation of election law, but we see no reason to hold the alleged defect in the copy of the affidavit supplied to the appellant to be fatal.
9. Section 81 speaks of the contents of a petition. The proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 81 requires an election petition based on corrupt practice to be
"accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed form in support of the allegation of such corrupt practice and the particulars thereof."
In other words, what is material is the form and the contents of the affidavit pertaining to the allegations and particulars of corrupt practice in the election petition. The procedural formalities of administration of oath and endorsement on the affidavit about completion of the formalities cannot, therefore, be said to be the contents of the affidavit and their non-production in the copy of the affidavit cannot be taken to be fatal to the maintainability of an election petition.
10. It is also worthy to note that Section 81(3) of the Act speaks of copies of petition and provides attestation of every copy as a true copy of the petition. A petition means a petition conforming to the requirements of Section 83 of the Act. Neither Section 81(3), nor Section 81(1) anywhere provides that the endorsements of the officer administering oath would form1 part of the contents of the affidavit or of the petition, or that the copy of the petition or affidavit filed under Section 81(3) must show or reproduce such endorsements.
11. It may be seen that the argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that the endorsements of the officer administering oath, would amount to contents of the affidavit or petition, if accepted, would lead to very many absurd results. The argument may be extended to omission of mentioning in the copy of petition or affidavit the amount of Court-fee paid on the petition or the affidavit, as also the nature of stamps used, i.e., judicial or non-judicial, because a petition or affidavit without adequate Court-fee or proper stamps would not be a valid petition or affidavit in the eye of law. For all these reasons, we find no substance in this appeal and it must fail.
12. The respondent No. 3, Shri Dharti Pakad Madan Lal supported the impuged order of the learned single Judge and the arguments of Shri P.L. Dubey, counsel for the respondent No. 1. He did not argue any new point, requiring any separate dicsussion.
13. In the result, this Letters Patent appeal is hereby dismissed. In the circumstances of the case, we make no order as to costs of the appeal.
Alert