Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tata Exports Ltd. v. The Union Of India And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 30, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a company incorporated under the Indian Companies Act, 1956, manufactures finished leather, garments and shoe uppers at a factory in Dewas. Finished leather and the petitioner's end products are exempt from excise duty. For finishing leather the petitioner produces and uses two materials on a captive basis: (1) pigment slurry — made by mixing pigment powders (e.g. titanium dioxide) with solvents and preservatives in an on‑site Research & Development cell and used directly in tanning; and (2) nitrocellulose lacquer — prepared by mixing nitrocellulose, alkyds and solvents with or without pigments or water, used in manufacture of finished leather. The pigment powders and solvents were purchased on which excise had already been paid; the slurry and lacquer were produced for captive consumption and were not marketed.

Central Excises law: Item No. 14 I(2)(iii) of the First Schedule charges water pigment finishes for leather at 10% ad valorem; Item No. 14 III(i) charges nitrocellulose lacquers at 20% ad valorem. Notification No. 80/80 exempted excisable goods where first clearances of that good did not exceed Rs. 5 lakhs and clearances of all excisable goods manufactured did not exceed Rs. 20 lakhs. The petitioner's output value of slurry and lacquer did not exceed Rs. 5 lakhs in the year in question though the factory's finished-product outturn exceeded Rs. 20 lakhs.

Events leading to litigation: In October 1980 excise enforcement officers threatened seizure unless the petitioner obtained a licence and paid duty. The petitioner filed classification lists under protest and disputed that manufacture (and duty) arose. Despite protest, the department recovered Rs. 20,051.74 in duty on slurry and lacquer up to 31-12-1980. The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 on 16-1-1981 challenging the duty, Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and the Notification dated 20-2-1982 giving retrospective effect to amended Rules 9 and 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944. The record shows multiple affidavits, returns, rejoinders and an amendment to challenge Section 51 and the retrospective notification. The matter was referred to the principal seat because validity of Rules 9 and 49 was in question.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether excise duty is leviable on the pigment slurry produced and used by the petitioner, under Item No. 14 I(2)(iii) (water pigment finishes for leather) of the First Schedule.
  2. Whether excise duty is leviable on nitrocellulose lacquer produced and used by the petitioner, under Item No. 14 III(i) of the First Schedule.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to exemption under Notification No. 80/80 (i.e., whether the value of clearances of slurry and lacquer falls below Rs. 5 lakhs for the purposes of the exemption, notwithstanding the factory's overall turnover).
  4. Whether amended Rules 9 and 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 can be given retrospective effect from the date of framing (1944) by virtue of Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and Notification dated 20-2-1982 — and whether that retrospective operation is intra vires the Constitution (including Article 19(1)(g)).
  5. Whether the writ petition was maintainable given the availability of an alternative remedy of appeal under Section 35 of the Central Excise Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The pigment slurry is not a manufactured product: it is merely pigment powder dispersed into a liquid (no chemical change), contains no film former and is not a marketable product but part of the single stream of production of finished leather.
  • Nitrocellulose lacquer was used in the manufacture of finished leather but the finished leather is totally exempt; the exemption under Notification No. 80/80 should be applied to the lacquer itself (i.e., exemption if lacquer clearances < Rs. 5 lakhs), and finished leather's exempt status cannot be used to defeat that calculation.
  • Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and the Notification of 20-2-1982 giving retrospective effect to Rules 9 and 49 are invalid and violative of Article 19(1)(g) and inconsistent with Section 37 of the Central Excise Act; retrospective provision is impermissible.
  • The petitioner paid duty under protest after threats of seizure; the writ petition is maintainable notwithstanding the existence of an appeal route because the classification was filed under protest and the petitioner challenges the retrospective legislative amendment (which could not have been challenged in a statutory appeal).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The pigment slurry qualified as "water pigment finishes for leather" and, therefore, duty was chargeable under Item No. 14 I(2)(iii).
  • Notification No. 80/80 did not apply because the aggregate clearances of all excisable goods from the petitioner's factory exceeded Rs. 20 lakhs.
  • Rules 9 and 49 were validly given retrospective effect by Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and Notification dated 20-2-1982; the department relied on that retrospective operation in its position and filings.
  • The petitioner had an alternative remedy by way of appeal under Section 35 of the Central Excise Act; therefore, the writ petition ought not to be maintained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Union of India v. Delhi Cloth Mills, AIR 1963 S.C. 791 Defines "manufacture": not every change is manufacture; need transformation into a new and different article having distinctive name, character or use. Used to test whether pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer amount to 'manufacture'. The court applied the requirement of a substantive transformation.
South Behar Sugar Mills v. Tata Chemicals, AIR 1968 S.C. 922 Affirms that manufacture requires emergence of a new and different article with distinctive name, character or use. Relied upon to reinforce the standard for determining whether a process amounts to manufacture.
Sandoz India Ltd. v. Union of India, 1980 E.L.T. 696 (Bombay H.C.) Processing a pigment from solid to liquid by addition of dispersing agents and water did not result in 'manufacture' where chemical composition was unchanged; burden of proof lies on taxing authority. Applied to pigment slurry: the court observed chemical properties unchanged and placed the burden on the taxing authority to show a distinct commodity resulted.
Shakti Insulated Wires v. Union of India, 1982 E.L.T. 10 (Bombay H.C.) Mere carrying out of a process does not necessarily amount to 'manufacture' under Section 2(f). Supported the proposition that incidental or ancillary processing does not automatically create a new excisable product.
Coromandel Proorite v. Government of India, 1985 (20) E.L.T. 257 (Madras H.C.) If a process does not produce a distinct and commercially new product (distinct chemical properties retained), there is no 'manufacture'. Cited to support conclusion that where end product retains chemical properties of input, there is no manufacture — relied on for pigment slurry analysis.
Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, 1985 (20) E.L.T. 179 (S.C.) Reiterates that processes creating a new commodity commercially known as distinct and separate (character, use, name) constitute 'manufacture'. Used as authoritative restatement of the manufacture test; applied to conclude nitrocellulose lacquer is a manufactured article.
Dunlop India v. Union of India, AIR 1977 S.C. 597 Classification of articles by reference to their end‑use is irrelevant for excise classification. Applied to reject the respondents' argument that end‑use in the finished leather should classify the slurry as excisable water pigment finishes.
State of Tamil Nadu v. Kandaswami, AIR 1975 S.C. 1891 After total exemption from tax, goods cease to be taxable goods. Applied to hold that the petitioner's exempt finished leather could not be counted when computing clearances for Notification No. 80/80; thus lacquer clearances alone govern exemption.
J.K. Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills v. Union of India, 1983 E.L.T. 239 (Delhi H.C.) Retrospectivity conferred by Section 51 of Finance Act, 1982 does not automatically make rules ultra vires; retrospective operation is only vitiated if unreasonable/arbitrary; Explanation limits criminal liability. The court expressly endorsed this decision and its reasoning to uphold retrospective operation of Section 51 and the amended rules as intra vires.
I. Hirday Narain v. Income Tax Officer, Bareilly, AIR 1971 S.C. 34 Once a writ petition has been entertained and the alternative remedy was time‑barred, the petition should be held maintainable. Applied to hold the petition maintainable where classification and duty were protested and because the petitioner challenged retrospective legislation not challengeable in an appeal.
Bharat Commerce Industries v. Union of India (unreported, M.P. No. 351/80, dated 2-11-1983) Distinguished on facts where duty was paid without protest and refund sought later. Used to distinguish that case from the present facts; not applied as authority to deny the petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed each disputed item by applying the settled tests for "manufacture" drawn from higher authorities:

  1. Pigment slurry: the court examined the composition and process. Evidence (including the chemical examiner's report and admissions in the respondents' pleadings) showed that the slurry consisted essentially of the pigment powder (titanium dioxide) dispersed in water/solvent without a film former and with no change in chemical composition. Applying the line of authority that a mere physical change (solid to dispersed liquid form) without transformation into a distinct article is not manufacture, the court concluded that pigment slurry is not a manufactured excisable commodity and therefore not chargeable under Item No. 14 I(2)(iii).
  2. Nitrocellulose lacquer: the court found that the mixing of nitrocellulose, alkyds and solvents (with or without pigments) produced a resultant product that was different in character from the raw ingredients. On the authorities requiring a new commodity having distinctive character, use or name for a finding of manufacture, the court concluded that nitrocellulose lacquer is a manufactured excisable commodity and therefore prima facie chargeable under Item No. 14 III(i).
  3. Application of Notification No. 80/80 (exemption threshold): the court held that the exempt status of finished leather meant that finished leather could not be counted as a taxable clearance for purposes of calculating the Rs. 20 lakh threshold in Notification No. 80/80. Citing Kandaswami, exempt goods cease to be taxable goods; thus nitrocellulose lacquer clearances alone were to be considered. Since the value of lacquer clearances was below Rs. 5 lakhs, lacquer was exempt under Notification No. 80/80.
  4. Retrospective operation of Rules 9 and 49 via Section 51 Finance Act, 1982: the petitioner argued such retrospectivity was constitutionally impermissible. The court endorsed the reasoning of the Delhi High Court in J.K. Cotton that retrospective operation per se does not make a provision ultra vires unless the retrospectivity is unreasonable or arbitrary to the extent of violating legislative competence. The Explanation to Section 51 (not attracting criminal liability) and the availability of civil remedies and recoveries meant the retrospectivity was not, in the court's view, unreasonable. Therefore Section 51 and the retrospective application to Rules 9 and 49 were held to be intra vires.
  5. Maintainability in view of alternative remedy: the respondents' contention that an appeal under Section 35 was the appropriate remedy was considered. The court relied on I. Hirday Narain and its own earlier decisions to hold that a writ petition was maintainable where the petitioner had filed classification under protest and paid duty under compulsion/threat, and where the petitioner was challenging retrospective legislation which could not be assailed in a statutory appeal. The court distinguished the unreported Bharat Commerce Industries decision on its facts.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core rulings):

  • The petition is partly allowed.
  • The orders of the Superintendent, Central Excise dated 13-11-1980 and of the Assistant Collector dated 12-11-1980 are quashed.
  • The respondents are directed to refund Rs. 20,051.74 collected from the petitioner as excise duty on pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer for the year 1980.
  • Outstanding security amount is to be refunded to the petitioner.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications (direct consequences and limits):

  • On the specific facts, pigment slurry produced by the petitioner is not an excisable manufactured article (no excise liability arose on the slurry).
  • Nitrocellulose lacquer, although a manufactured excisable article, was found to be exempt under Notification No. 80/80 on the factual finding that its clearances were below Rs. 5 lakhs and finished leather (being totally exempt) could not be counted for the threshold calculation.
  • The court upheld the validity of Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and the retrospective application of Rules 9 and 49 as not being unconstitutional on the grounds advanced before the court; retrospective amendments will be scrutinised for unreasonableness/arbitrariness but are not void per se.
  • The petition was held maintainable despite the availability of a statutory appeal because the petitioner acted under protest and challenged retrospective legislation not susceptible to challenge in an appeal; the decision distinguishes cases where duty was paid without protest.
  • No broader or novel legal principle was announced beyond applying and endorsing existing authorities on the test of "manufacture", the relevance of end‑use in classification, the effect of total exemption, and the circumstances in which retrospective operation of tax rules may be sustained. The decision operates primarily to grant relief to the petitioner on the facts pleaded and proved.

This summary is confined to matters expressly stated in the provided opinion and does not add external facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text.

Show all summary ...

1. In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution the petitioner is challenging levy of duty on pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer under Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944, and also challenging Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and Notification dated 20-2-1982 giving retrospective effect to Rules 9 and 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, from the date of framing of the rules.

2. The petitioner is a Company incorporated under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act, 1956. The petitioner has a factory at Dewas wherein it is manufacturing finished leather, garments and shoe uppers. These products are exempted from excise duty. For the completion of manufacturing of finished leather, the petitioner apply pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer to the leather in the course of manufacture of finished leather. At the said factory, the petitioner has a Research and Development Cell in a separate building about 100 metres from the factory and within the same campus where amongst other activity, the petitioner mixes pigment powders like titanium dioxide with certain solvents. These pigment powders and solvents are obtained from the market and are products upon which the duty of excise has been paid. After adding preservatives, the mixture of pigment powder and solvents become slurry. This slurry is used directly by the petitioner in the tanning of leather and is part and parcel of the process to obtain finished leather. Similarly, in the case of nitrocellulose lacquer, certain chemicals such as nitrocellulose, alkydes etc. are combined with solvents with or without water, with or without pigments depending upon the end use. The resultant mixture is also used by the petitioner for manufacture of finished leather. The pigment slurry as well as nitrocellulose lacquer are used for captive consumption in the petitioner's factory. Under Notification No. 80/80, the Central Government exempted excisable goods specified therein from the whole of the duty of excise leviable thereon if the first clearances did not aggregate rupees 5 lacs in value provided that the clearances of all excisable goods manufactured should not exceed rupees 20 lacs in value. The total value of slurry and lacquer did not exceed 5 lacs of rupees in the year in question though the outturn of the finished product i.e. leather was much above 20 lacs in the relevant year. Section 3 of the said Act provides that there shall be levied and collected in such manner as may be prescribed duties of excise on all excisable goods other than salt which are produced or manufactured in India at the rates set forth in the First Schedule to the Act. Under Section 2(d) 'excisable goods' means goods specified in the First Schedule as being subject to a duty of excise and includes salt. In Section 2(f) 'manufacture' includes any process incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufectured product Rule 9(1) of the said Rules prescribe the time and manner of payment of duty on excisable goods to be removed from one place where they are produced, cured or manufactured or any premises appurtenant thereto, which may be specified by the Collector in this behalf, whether for consumption, export or manufacture of any other commodity in or outside such place until excise duty leviable thereon has been paid at such place and in such manner as is prescribed in these rules. Under Rule 49(1) duty is chargeable only on removal of goods from the factory premises or from an approved place of storage. These rules, as they stand, were amended in 1982 but by Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 these rules were given retrospective effect from the date of framing of the rules i.e. 1944, as per Notification dated 20-2-1982. Under Item No. 14 I(2)(iii) in the First Schedule to the Act water pigment finishes for leather is chargeable to 10% of excise duty ad valorem and under Item No. 14 III(i) nitrocellulose lacquers, clear and pigmented and nitrocellulose ancillaries in liquid, semi-solid or pasty form is chargeable at the rate of 20% ad valorem. Here the question is whether excise duty is leviable on pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer used by the petitioner under the aforesaid items, whether the goods so manufactured were exempted from excise duty under Notification No. 80/80 as their total value was less than 5 lacs though the turnover of the faetory was over 20 lacs and whether the Rules 9 and 49 can be given retrospective effect from the date of framing of the rules.

3. In the month of October 1980 Officers of the Enforcement Branch of the Excise Department visited the factory and threatened to seize the existing stock of pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer as they were manufacturing and clearing them without a vaild licence and without paying excise duty leviable thereon and the petitioner was made to apply for a licence on 29-10-1980 under Rule 176. However, the petitioner by their letter dated 10-11-1980 pointed out that it is not manufacturing water pigment finishes for leather but only mixing pigment with certain solvents with a view to convert pigment from dry form to slurry. Similarly, in case of nitrocellulose lacquer, certain chemicals are mixed with solvents and there is no manufacture. The products so mixed are used for completion of manufacture of finished leather. The said pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer are used in the single stream of production of finished leather and do not ever leave the factory or the place of manufacturing nor are the same ever sold or supplied to the open market. The pigment slurry so produced is not a marketable product. So the classification list was being filed under protest. The Supsrintendent of Central Excise by letter dated 13-11-1980 pointed out that the slurry and the lacquer could not be cleared without payment of duty and Notification No. 80/80 was not applicable as value of clearances of the petitioner's factory of alt excisable goods exceeded rupees 20 lacs and, therefore, classification list submitted by the petitioner was returned and was directed to file revised classification list which was done on 24-11-1980 under protest pointing out that no excise duty is payable on slurry and lacquer. In spite of the protest, the respondents recovered duty on slurry and lacquer amounting to Rs. 20,051.74 p. up to 31-12-1980 under Item No. 14 I(2) (iii) and 14 III(i) of the First Schedule. The petitioner thereafter filed the present petition at the Indore Bench of this Court on 16-1-1981. The respondents submitted their return on 22-6-81 denying the allegations made by the petitioner. On 16-9-81 the petitioner filed counter-affidavit to the return, of its Chief Accountant Mohanlal Jain. The respondents filed reply to the rejoinder on 11-1-1982. The petitioner then filed another counter-affidavit of its Chief Accountant on 19-3-1982 and in consequence the respondents filed affidavit of Assistant Collector Yadav Kholkute on 8-4-82 pointing out that the Rules 9 and 49 have been given retrospective effect under Finance Act of 1982. The petitioner, therefore, filed an application for amendment of the petition on 9-8-82 challenging Section 51 of the Finance Act and the Notification giving retrospective effect to these rules which was allowed and amendment incorporated. Additional return was filed by the respondents on 23-2-1983. The petitioner then filed rejoinder to the additional return on 5-3-1984 and the respondents filed reply to this rejoinder on 26-2-1985. Since validity of Rules 9 and 49 was under challenge, the case was sent to the main seat of this Court for hearing.

4. The Supreme Court in Union of India v. Delhi Cloth Mills-AIR 1963 S.C. 791 has held that manufacture implies a change, but every change is not manufacture and yet every change of an article is the result of treatment, labour and manipulation. But something more is necessary and there must be transformation ; a new and different article must emerge having a distinctive name, character or use. Relying on this decision, the Supreme Court in South Behar Sugar Mills v. Tata Chemicals--AIR 1968 S.C. 922 further held that there must be such a transformation that a new and different article must emerge having a distinctive name, character or use. In Sandoz India Ltd. v. Union of India-.1980 E.L.T. 696 a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that the processing of the physical form from a solid state to a liquid state by the addition of dispersing agents and water did not result in manufacture as there was no change in the chemical composition of the pigment. In Shakti Insulated Wires v. Union of India-1982 E.L.T 10, the Bombay High Court further held that it is obvious that merely because some process is carried on any article it would not necessarily amount to a manufacture of a fresh article amounting to 'manufacture' under Section 2(f) of the Act. In Coromandel Proorite v. Government of India- 1985(20) E.L.T. 257 a Division Bench of the Madras High Court held that if as a result of the process, raw-materials have been transformed into a distinct and commercially new product, then alone the process can be taken to be a manufacture. In this case since the end product brought about by the process of mixture or dilution continues to have the same chemical properties as resin, there cannot be said to be any manufacturing process. Recently, the Supreme Court in Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India-1985 (20) E.L.T. 179 reiterated that any process or processes creating a new commodity commercially known as a distinct and separate commodity having its own character, use and name would be 'manufacture'. It is settled law that in a case of taxation the burden of proving that the necessary ingredients prescribed by the taxing provision are satisfied is entirely upon the taxing authority [(Sandoz India Ltd. v. Union of India (Supra)]. It is, therefore, primarily for the taxing authority to satisfy the Court that formulation of pigment slurry is entirely distinct commodity having entirely distinct name, character and use as compared with the pigment itself.

5. It is evident that pigment slurry is merely a mixture made by mixing pigment powders like titanium dioxide with water containing chemical wetting agents. This is done only to facilitate application of pigment to leather. Chemical properties and characteristics of the pigment powder remaining unchanged when it becomes slurry. Pigment slurry is only powder in a wet form. Though in the return, the respondents contended that pigment slurry is water pigment finishes for leather falling under Item No. 14 I (2) (iii) of the First Schedule, this was met in the rejoinder by the petitioner dated 16-9-1981 pointing out that water pigment finishes involve 'film former' for pigment dispersion in water. Making of pigment slurry does not involve addition of any film former. Reference has been made of the book R.N. Shreve on Chemical Process Industries. In the reply to the rejoinder dated 11-1-1982 in para 6 it has been admitted by the respondents that pigment slurry manufactured by the petitioner does not contain film former, yet the product thus manufactured is used for processing the finished leather. So it can be said that by not mixing film former, they are producing an inferior quality of water pigment finishes for leather. In support, report of the Chemical Examiner in Central Excise Office was produced that on analysis of the pigment slurry, the ingredients found was titanium dioxide i.e. the powder which was used for making the slurry and there is no change in the end product. Again in the affidavit of the Asstt. Collector dated 8-4-82 it was admitted that the petitioner is manufacturing pigment slurry without using film former for processing the leather. The Supreme Court in Dunlop India v. Union of India- AIR 1977 S.C. 597 held that classification of articles with reference to their end-use is totally irrelevant. It is, therefore, clear that petitioner is not manufacturing water pigment finishes for leather which is leviable to excise duty under Item No. 14 1(2) (iii) of the First Schedule. But this cannot be said so far as nitrocellulose lacquer which is being prepared by the petitioner in its factory by mixing certain chemicals such as nitrocellulose, alkyds and combined with solvents with or without water and with or without pigment depending upon the end-use. So the resultant product is something different from the ingredients used for making them and so the petitioner is manufacturing nitrocellulose lacquer which is leviable to duty under Item No. 14 111 (i) of the First Schedule. But as the finished product of the petitioner i.e. leather goods, are totally exempted from excise duty, the same cannot be taken into consideration in order to assess excise duty on nitrocellulose under the exemption granted under Notification No. 80/80. Under this notification, nitrocellulose lacquer would be totally exempt from excise duty in case the value of the clearances of this product is less than 5 lacs. For calculating this amount, the total value of the finished product of the petitioner cannot be taken into consideration as the finished product is totally exempted from excise duty. The Supreme Court in State of Tamil Nadu v. Kandaswami-AIR 1975 S.C. 1891 held that after total exemption from tax, goods ceased to be taxable goods. Therefore, although nitrocellulose lacquer was chargeable to excise duty under Item No. 14 III(i) of the First Schedule, but as the value of production of this article was less than 5 lacs, the petitioner is exempted from paying any duty on this product under Notification No. 80/80.

6. Now remains challenge of the petitioner to Section 51 of the Finance Act of 1982 and Notification dated 20-2-1982 giving retrospective effect to the amended Rules 9 and 49 of the Excise Rules, 1944, on the ground that it is not permissible in law to provide for a statutory provision like Section 51 of the Finance Act giving retrospective effect to the rules and it is inconsistent with Section 37 of the Central Excise Act and is violative of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. This restriction has no justification whatsoever and is neither reasonable nor in public interest. We are satisfied that there is .no merit in this contention and the rules are intra vires of the Constitution. We fully endorse the decision of the Delhi High Court in J.K. Cotton Spinning &. Weaving Mills and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors.-1983 E.L.T. 239 wherein it has been held as under :-

"Merely because the rules operate retrospectively by virtue of the provisions of Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982, it would not make the rule or the section ultra vires the legislative authority. However, if the retrospec-tivity is unreasonable to the extent that the whole legislation appears to be arbitrary then the provisions can be struck down as being ultra vires. Since in terms of the Explanation under Section 51 of the Finance Act, it is clear that criminal liability will not be attracted because of retrospective amendment and moreover civil liabilities such as recovery of duty not levied or not paid or short levied or short paid or erroneously refunded has to be done in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the rules as in force from time to time, therefore, there is no unreasonableness on account of length of retrospectivity of the amendment and Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982 and Rules 9 and 49 of Central Excise Rules as amended are vaild."

The only question that now survives for consideration is the contention of the respondents that since the petitioner had an alternative remedy of appeal Under Section 35 of the Central Excise Act against the impugned orders, the present petition is not tenable. The Supreme Court in I. Hirday Narain v. Income Tax Officer, Bareilly† ., Bareilly-AIR 1971 S.C. 34 held that once a writ petition has been entertained and the alternative remedy was time-barred, the petition should be held to be maintainable. Following this decision, this Court has held in a series of decisions that once a petition has been admitted, it could not be dismissed on the ground of alternative remedy. The unreported decision in Bharat Commerce Industries v. Union of India-M.P. No. 351/80, dated 2-11-1983 is clearly distinguishable because in that case the petitioner had paid excise duty on blended fabrics without protest and without dispute. They claimed refund of duty by filing a petition on the ground that it is paid under mistake and such a mistake being discovered only when Gujarat High Court held in a Judgment that duty is not leviable on blended fabrics under tariff entry in question. In the present case, classification list was filed under protest by the petitioner on the threats given by the respondents to paralyse the petitioner's operation by seizure of stock unless licence was taken and excise duty was paid. So the excise duty was paid under protest. Besides, the petitioner has challenged validity of Section 51 of the Finance Act, 1982, and the Notification dated 20-2-1982 which could not have been challenged in an appeal that could be preferred Under Section 35 of the Act.

7. Therefore, the petition is partly allowed, the orders of the Superintendent, Central Excise, dated 13-11-1980 and that of the Assistant Collector, Central Excise, dated 12-11-1980 are hereby quashed and the respondents are directed to refund excise duty of Rs. 20,051.74p. collected from the petitioner as excise duty on pigment slurry and nitrocellulose lacquer for the year 1980. In the circumstances, there shall be no order as to costs. The outstanding security amount be refunded to the petitioner.