Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ude Singh & Sons v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, M.P

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 26, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — Reference under Section 256(1), I.T. Act, 1961

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference arises under Section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and asks whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that no valid partnership came into existence and that registration of the firm was rightly refused.

Relevant factual matrix (as stated in the opinion):

  • There was a joint Hindu family consisting of Sardar Ude Singh (karta) and his two sons, Sardar Sant Singh and Sardar Manmohan Singh. The family carried on business in the name "Sardar Ude Singh and Sons".
  • A partition took place on 1 July 1959. As a result, the business at Junnardeo was allotted to Sant Singh. The total business assets were determined at Rs. 79,432; after excluding ornaments and life insurance premium the assets counted as Rs. 76,396, and Rs. 76,185 was shown as introduced as capital in the business. The business name was continued.
  • Three successive partnership deeds were executed:
    • 9 July 1959 (effective 5 July 1959): Sant Singh, his son Santosh Singh and daughter Sukhdeo Kaur were partners; several minors (including two minor sons and one son of unsound mind) were admitted to benefits; capital in books stood at Rs. 76,185; partnership continued to 31 March 1962.
    • 5 November 1962 (effective 1 April 1962): Sukhdeo Kaur had withdrawn by marriage; Kuldip Singh became major; partnership of Sant Singh, Santosh Singh and Kuldip Singh (with Daljit and Azad admitted to benefits); capital remained as per books (Rs. 76,185); this partnership lasted until 31 March 1965.
    • 1 April 1965: a third deed where Daljit withdrew and Azad became major; Sant Singh, Santosh Singh, Kuldip Singh and Azad Singh shared profits and losses equally (25% each).
  • The assessee-firm applied for registration under Section 26A for assessment years 1960–61 and 1961–62 and under Section 184 for assessment years 1962–63 to 1964–65.
  • The Income-tax authorities, including the Tribunal, refused registration on the ground that the capital of Rs. 76,185 was not distributed among the coparceners when the partnership business was commenced; the Tribunal observed no material showed any partial partition of the capital among coparceners and therefore held there could be no legal partnership.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the cases, the Tribunal was right in holding that no partnership, that is valid in law, came into existence and registration was rightly refused?

Arguments of the Parties

Tribunal / Revenue Arguments

  • The Tribunal refused registration because the capital (Rs. 76,185) shown as invested in the partnership was not distributed among the coparceners when the partnership was said to have commenced.
  • In the absence of any partial partition of the capital or the business amongst Sant Singh and his sons, the business continued to be coparcenary (joint family) property and could not in law constitute a partnership.

Assessee's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the assessee relied on several precedents (cases listed in the opinion) to support the contention that a partnership existed and registration should have been granted.
  • The assessee contended there was an implied partition effected by the execution of the partnership deeds.
  • It was further contended (late, and not earlier put before the authorities) that the karta (Sant Singh) contributed joint family assets as capital while other members contributed skill and labour, and therefore a valid partnership came into existence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tolaram Bejoy Kumar v. CIT [1978] 112 ITR 750, 753 (SC) Authorities show that where a business is allotted on partition to one coparcener, the business and capital do not necessarily become that coparcener's separate property but may remain coparcenary property. The court used this principle to conclude the business and capital that came to Sant Singh on partition constituted coparcenary property of Sant Singh and his sons, not separate property of Sant Singh.
Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal v. CEPT [1956] 29 ITR 521 (SC) It is inconsistent with the nature of a joint undivided family to treat coparceners as simultaneously both coparceners and partners with respect to coparcenary properties. The court relied on this authority to support the view that, despite partnership deeds, the business remained a joint family business and could not be treated as a partnership in law when based on undivided coparcenary assets.
Sundar Singh Majithia v. CIT [1942] 10 ITR 457 (PC) Members of an HUF may enter into a partnership in respect of a portion of joint property which they have partitioned among themselves. The court distinguished this case on the ground that in the instant matter there was no partition of the joint property invested in the partnership.
Lachhman Das v. CIT [1948] 16 ITR 35 (PC) Partnership may exist where a karta and a member of the joint family invest separate property in a partnership. Distinguished: in the present case none of the partners introduced separate property into the partnership.
CIT v. Sri Hukumchand Mannalal & Co. [1970] 78 ITR 18 (SC) A partnership is not invalid merely because two or more partners are members of an HUF and represent the family's interest; but it is not authority for treating members as partners in respect of joint family assets without partition. The court treated this decision as limited: it allows family members representing the family to partner with strangers, but does not support a partnership constituted solely of family members in respect of undivided family assets.
Ghewarchand Kewalchand v. CIT [1978] 111 ITR 391 (MP) A joint family business partitioned among members who then entered into partnership to carry on the same business — similar to Sundar Singh Majithia. Distinguished because in the present case there was no prior partition of the joint family business before the partnership deeds.
CIT v. Ratanchand Darbarilal [1975] 100 ITR 258 (MP) Listed by the court as supporting the proposition that where joint family assets are not partitioned, the business remains a joint family business and not a partnership. Relied upon as supporting authority for the court's conclusion that no partnership existed in the instant facts.
Shah Prabhudas Gulabchand v. CIT [1970] 77 ITR 870 (Bom) Listed by the court as supporting the same conclusion regarding non-transformation of joint family business into partnership absent partition. Used as supporting precedent for the court's conclusion.
Manilal Dharamchand v. CIT [1970] 78 ITR 96 (Bom) Listed by the court as further supporting authority for the position that non-partitioned coparcenary assets continuing in business do not create a partnership. Used to bolster the court's conclusion that the so-called partnership was, in substance, the joint family business.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in the following steps (faithful to the opinion):

  1. Recognition of Partition and Nature of Assets:

    The court accepts that a partition occurred on 1 July 1959 and that the family business at Junnardeo was allotted to Sant Singh. However, relying on authority, the court observes that in Sant Singh's hands the business and the capital invested did not become his separate property but remained coparcenary property of Sant Singh and his sons.

  2. No Evidence of Partial Partition of Capital or Business:

    The court found no evidence of any partition of the business or the capital assets invested in it between Sant Singh and his sons until 1 April 1964. The capital figure of Rs. 76,185 remained in the books and was not shown as divided among members.

  3. Substance over Form — Partnership Deeds Do Not Automatically Effect Partition:

    Although partnership deeds were executed at various times, the court emphasized that execution of such deeds, by itself, does not effect a partition of coparcenary property. An implied partition requires an unequivocal act showing intention to separate; the court observed that if a real intention to separate had existed, the capital would have been divided and recorded in the books showing each member's share.

  4. Legal Principle — Coparcenary Assets Cannot Simultaneously Remain Undivided and Form the Basis of a Partnership Among Coparceners:

    The court relied on authoritative decisions (notably Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal) to support the proposition that it is not consistent with the notion of a joint undivided family for coparceners to be both coparceners and partners with respect to the same coparcenary properties. In the absence of partition, the business carried on under the partnership deeds was, in substance, the joint family business.

  5. Distinguishing Precedents Relied on by Assessee:

    The court considered the cases cited for the assessee and distinguished them on their facts: where prior partition or investment of separate property by a family member existed, partnership could validly be recognized. Those circumstances were absent here. Similarly, authorities that permit family members to partner with outsiders do not support a partnership exclusively of family members based on undivided family assets.

  6. Procedural Limitation on New Factual Contentions:

    The court noted the late contention that the karta contributed joint family assets while other members contributed skill and labour, forming a partnership. Because this raised new questions of fact not advanced before the Income-tax authorities, the court declined to consider them and therefore did not examine the legal proposition whether contribution of skill/labour alone (without partition) could create a partnership involving joint family assets.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court concluded that, on the facts and in law, there was no valid partnership in existence because the capital and business remained coparcenary property and no partition of those assets was shown; consequently, registration of the firm for the relevant assessment years was rightly refused by the authorities.

Implications:

  • Direct consequence: The Tribunal's refusal to register the firm was upheld because the purported partnership was, in substance, the continuation of the joint Hindu family business based on undivided coparcenary assets.
  • The court distinguished the present facts from cases where partition preceded the formation of a partnership or where separate property was introduced by a member; those cases do not aid the assessee here.
  • The opinion does not assert that it establishes any new broad legal principle beyond applying existing authorities; it treats earlier cases as controlling or distinguishable. The court also declined to address a new factual proposition (skill/labour contribution) not earlier pleaded to the tax authorities, and therefore did not lay down a rule on that point.

This summary strictly reflects the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or legal conclusions beyond those expressly contained in the text.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a reference under Section 256(1) of the I.T. Act, 1961, referring for our answer the following question of law :

"Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the cases, the Tribunal was right in holding that no partnership, that is valid in law, came into existence and registration was rightly refused ?"

2. There was a joint Hindu family consisting of Sardar Ude Singh and his two sons, Sardar Sant Singh and Sardar Manmohan Singh. The family carried on business in the name of Sardar Ude Singh and Sons. A partition took place in the family on 1st July, 1959. In this partition, the business carried on in the name and style of Sardar Ude Singh and Sons at Junnardeo came to the share of Sant Singh. The total assets of the business were determined at Rs. 79,432. After excluding ornaments of Rs. 1,700 and life insurance premium of Rs. 1,336, the balance figure of assets came to Rs. 76,396 out of which a sum of Rs. 76,185 Was introduced as capital in the business. The business name of Sardar Ude Singh and Sons was continued.

3. A partnership deed was executed on 9th July, 1959, to be effective from 5th July, 1959. In this partnership Sant Singh, his son, Santosh Singh, and daughter, Sukhdeo Kaur, were partners. Sant Singles two minor sons, namely, Kuldip Singh and Azad Singh, and another son, namely, Daljit Singh, who was of unsound mind, were introduced to the benefits of the partnership. The share of profits of Sant Singh, jointly with his wife, was 30 per cent. Santosh Singh's share was also 30 per cent. in profits. Sukhdeo Kaur and the three beneficiaries were entitled to 10 per cent. share in the profits. Sant Singh and Santosh Singh each were responsible for the losses to the extent of 40 per cent. Sukhdeo Kaur was responsible for loss to the extent of 20 per cent. The rights and interests of Sukhdeo Kaur were to cease after her marriage. As regards the capital, Clause 6 of the partnership deed provided that

"the capital of the firm will be counted as it stands in the account books without carrying any interest thereon, unless objected by any working partner"
. The capital in the books of account stood at Rs. 76,185. This partnership continued up to 31st March, 1962.

4. A fresh partnership deed was executed on 5th November, 1962, to be effective from 1st April, 1962. Sukhdeo Kaur by that time had got married and she withdrew from the partnership. Kuldip Singh also by that time had become major. The new partnership consisted of Sant Singh, Santosh Singh and Kuldip Singh. Daljit Singh and Azad Singh were admitted to the benefits of the partnership. The shares of Sant Singh and Santosh Singh were 30 per cent. each in profits and 40 per cent. each in losses. Kuldip Singh was allotted a share of 15 per cent. in profits and 20 per cent. in losses. Daljit Singh and Azad Singh got 10 per cent. and 15 per cent. share in profits, respectively. The capital of the partnership was to remain the same as standing in the books of account. The amount that stood in the books of account in the capital account was Rs. 76,185, the same figure as appeared in the earlier years. This partnership remained in existence till 31st March, 1965.

5. A third partnership deed was executed on 1st April, 1965. Daljit Singh withdrew from the partnership. Azad Singh by that time had become major. In accordance with this partnership, Sant Singh, Santosh Singh, Kuldip Singh and Azad Singh. became partners sharing profits and losses in the ratio of 25 per cent. each.

6. The assessee-firm applied for registration under Section 26A for the assessment years 1960-61 and 1961-62 and under Section 184 for the assessment years 1962-63 to 1964-65. The I.T. authorities, including the Tribunal, refused registration to the firm on the ground that the capital of Rs. 76,185 was not distributed amongst the coparceners when the partnership business was commenced. The capital was shown as distributed between the partners with effect from 1st April, 1965, and, thereafter, the firm was registered from the assessment year 1966-67. It was observed by the Tribunal that there was no material to hold that there was any partial partition of the capital shown to be invested in the partnership business. In the absence of partial partition amongst the coparceners regarding the capital invested in the partnership business, the Tribunal held that there could be no legal partnership.

7. There is no dispute that there was a partition between Ude Singh and his two sons, Sant Singh and Manmohan Singh. In this partition, the business carried on by the joint Hindu family in the name of Sardar Ude Singh and Sons at Junnardeo was allotted to Sant Singh. However, in the; hands of Sant Singh the business and the capital invested in it did not become Sant Singh's separate property and it became the coparcenary property consisting of Sant Singh and his sons: [See Tolaram Bejoy Kumar v. CIT [1978] 112 ITR 750, 753 (SC)]. There is no evidence either of partition of the business or of the capital assets invested in it between Sant Singh and his sons till 1st April, 1964. The so-called partnership business which was carried on under the three partnership deeds was the same business which came to Sant Singh in the partition of the HUF property. The sum of Rs. 76,185 which was shown to be invested as capital in the partnership business was the capital value of the business received in partition by Sant Singh and constituted coparcenary property of Sant Singh and his sons. In the absence of any partial partition amongst Sant Singh and his family members with reference to the business or the capital assets, the partnership business in effect was carried on by the family members wholly with the aid of coparcenary assets. In these circumstances, it was not possible to hold that there was in law a partnership. The partnership business was in a true sense the joint family business in spite of the execution of the partnership deeds. As observed by the Supreme Court in Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal v. CEPT [1956] 29 ITR 521, 526:

"...it would cut at the very root of the notion of a joint undivided family to hold that with reference to coparcenary properties the members can at the same time be both coparceners and partners."

8. The rulings relied upon by the learned counsel for the assessee are all distinguishable. In Sundar Singh Majithia v. CIT [1942] 10 ITR 457 (PC), it was held that the I.T. Act does not prohibit members of an HUF from entering into a partnership in respect of a portion of the joint property which they have partitioned among themselves. The distinguishing feature of this case is that there was partition of the joint property invested in the partnership. In the case before us there is no such partition. In Lachhman Das v. CIT [1948] 16 ITR 35 (PC), there was a partnership between the karta and one of the members of the joint family who invested his separate property in the partnership. In the case before us, none of the partners invested any separate property. The learned counsel heavily relied upon the case of CIT v. Sri Hukumchand Mannalal & Co. [1970] 78 ITR 18 (SC). In that case it was held that a partnership is not invalid merely because two or more of its partners are members of an HUF and represent the interest of the family. The case is not an authority for the proposition that members of a joint Hindu family can enter into a partnership consisting of themselves in respect of a joint family asset without partitioning it. Further, it also does not militate against the view taken in Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal's case [1956] 29 ITR 521 (SC) that

"it is difficult to visualize the situation of a joint Hindu family entering into a partnership with strangers through its karta and the junior members of the family also at the same time becoming its partners in their personal capacity"
. All that is decided in the case of Sri Hukumchand Mannalal & Co. [ 1970] 78 ITR 18 (SC) is that two or more members of a joint Hindu family representing the family may enter into partnership with strangers. Another case relied upon is Ghewarchand Kewalchand v. CIT [1978] 111 ITR 391 (MP). In this case, a joint family business was partitioned amongst the members who thereafter entered into a partnership to carry on the same business. This case is similar to the case of Sundar Singh Majithia [ 1942] 10 ITR 457 (PC) and is distinguishable on the point that the joint family business was first partitioned before making it a partnership business. In our case, there is no partition of the joint family business.

9. As seen earlier, in the instant case, the so-called partnership at all stages consisted of Sant Singh and his family members. The capital asset invested in the business was joint family property and was not partitioned. No separate property was brought into the partnership by the members. In the circumstances, the legal position was that the business continued to be a joint family business and did not transform itself into a partnership business. There was no partnership in law. Apart from the Supreme Court case of Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal [1956] 29 ITR 521 (SC), our conclusion is supported by the following cases : CIT v. Ratanchand Darbarilal [1975] 100 ITR 258 (MP), Shah Prabhudas Gulabchand v. CIT [1970] 77 ITR 870 (Bom) and Manilal Dharamchand v. CIT [1970] 78 ITR 96 (Bom).

10. The learned counsel for the assessee submitted that there was an implied partition by execution of the partnership deeds. The contention cannot be accepted. It is true that a partition can be effected by any unequivocal act giving out an intention to separate, yet it cannot be accepted that a partition is brought about merely by execution of a partnership deed. If the members of a family intended to separate, the amount of the capital invested in the business would have been divided and the share of each member shown separately in the account books.

It was lastly contended that this was a case where the karta, namely, Sant Singh, contributed joint family assets towards the capital of the partnership and the other members contributed their skill and labour and hence in law there came into existence a valid partnership. This contention which involves new questions of fact was never put forward before the I.T. authorities and cannot be raised before us. It is, therefore, not necessary for us to examine the legal position whether a member of a joint Hindu family by contributing his skill or labour or both can, without more, enter into a partnership with the karta of the family.