Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Munnilal Kailash Chandra v. Akabai

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 20, 1959
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion (Revision concerning Order 21 Rule 58 and applicability of High Court rules after the States Reorganisation)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present revision arises from execution proceedings in a Court at Gwalior. A decree was executed against Kailash Chandm (judgment-debtor) and the decree-holder, Akabai, caused the judgment-debtor's house to be attached. On 13 March 1959 Munnilal and others (objectors) filed an objection petition under Order 21 Rule 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The executing Court did not decide that objection petition but fixed the house for sale on 1 July 1959. On 8 May 1959 the objectors filed an application praying that the sale be stayed until disposal of their objection petition. The executing Court rejected the stay application, applying Rule 58(2) of Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by the Nagpur High Court. The objectors challenged that order by filing the present revision petition. The revision court was thus required to consider (a) whether rules made by the Nagpur High Court under Section 122 of the Civil Procedure Code, which were in force in the former State of Madhya Pradesh, were enforceable in territories that before 1-11-1956 formed the Part B State of Madhya Bharat (including Gwalior), and (b) whether the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rules made by the High Court at Nagpur under Section 122 of the Code of Civil Procedure and in force in the former State of Madhya Pradesh immediately before reorganisation (1 November 1956) are enforceable in territories of the new State of Madhya Pradesh which, until 31-10-1956, formed the Part B State of Madhya Bharat (i.e., whether those High Court rules apply to the present execution in Gwalior).
  2. Whether the executing Court was bound to stay the sale pending disposal of the objection petition under Order 21 Rule 58(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure (as contended and supported by several earlier decisions).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (objectors') Arguments — as presented by Shri Swami Saran

  • The decree was passed and is being executed in a Court at Gwalior, which was part of the former State of Madhya Bharat; therefore rules made by the Nagpur High Court for the former Madhya Pradesh cannot apply to this territory unless and until they are adapted for the new State of Madhya Pradesh under the States Reorganisation Act.
  • The executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2); reliance was placed on a series of precedents supporting the proposition that a stay is required in such circumstances.

Decree-holder's Arguments — as presented by Shri Babulal Agarwal

  • Section 54 of the States Reorganisation Act should be read to mean that the rules made by the High Court of the former Madhya Pradesh under the Code of Civil Procedure apply to the whole of the new State of Madhya Pradesh from the appointed day (1 November 1956), and therefore the Nagpur High Court amendments to Order 21 Rule 58 should govern procedure in the execution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Varadaiah Chetti v. Narasimhalu, Chetty, AIR 1932 Mad 41 Cited by petitioner in support of the contention that the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2). The court noted the citation but declined to express any opinion on the point because the executing Court had not yet considered the stay application in the perspective of those authorities.
Sasthi Charan Biswas v. Gopal Chandra Saha, AIR 1937 Cal 390 Cited by petitioner in support of the contention that the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2). The court recorded the reliance but did not adjudicate the correctness or applicability of the precedent in this revision, leaving the matter to the executing Court's consideration.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Poona Electric Supply Co. Ltd., AIR 1947 Bom 263 Cited by petitioner in support of the contention that the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2). The court acknowledged the citation but did not decide the legal point in this revision; it refrained from expressing an opinion and directed that the executing Court consider the stay application afresh.
Shrichand v. Santosh Kumar, MBLJ 1953 HCR 493 Cited by petitioner in support of the contention that the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2). The court noted the authority but did not apply or decide upon it; the court left the question open for the executing Court to examine.
Shrikisan Shiv Pratap v. Dhulchand Kasturchand, MBLJ 1954 HCR 842 Cited by petitioner in support of the contention that the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2). The court recorded the reliance and explicitly refrained from expressing any opinion on the precedential issue in this revision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court structured its analysis around the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 ("the Act") and the relationship between that Act and rules made by High Courts under Section 122 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC).

1. The court examined statutory definitions in Section 2 of the Act (including the "appointed day", "corresponding new State", "corresponding State", "existing State", and the definition of "law") to interpret the scope and effect of reorganisation on pre-existing laws.

2. Section 119 of the Act contains a deeming provision which, the court held, operates to preserve for territorial application the laws in force immediately before the appointed day in the territories to which they applied. The court explained that by this fiction the reorganisation does not, of itself, change the territorial operation of laws; therefore laws which were in force in the territories of Madhya Bharat immediately before 1-11-1956 continue to apply in those territories even though the map and nomenclature of States have changed.

3. Section 120 provides a machinery for adaptations and modifications (including repeal or amendment) of laws to facilitate their application in newly formed or altered territories. The court observed that adaptations under Section 120 may be made by the appropriate Government within one year from the appointed day and such adaptations operate until altered by competent authority.

4. Rules made by a High Court under Section 122 CPC (which permits High Courts to make rules regulating their own procedure and the procedure of civil courts subject to their superintendence) are "law" within the meaning of Section 2 of the Act and are akin to delegated/subordinate legislation engrafted on the First Schedule to the CPC. Consequently, those High Court rules made for the "corresponding State" of Madhya Pradesh continued to be operative in the territories to which they previously applied, but they do not automatically become operative in territories of the new State that were formerly a different existing State (such as Madhya Bharat) unless they are adapted under Section 120.

5. The court rejected the decree-holder's reliance on Section 54 of the Act. It construed Section 54 as relating to "practice and procedure in the High Court" (Part V of the Act) and not to practice and procedure in all civil courts generally. Therefore Section 54 does not operate to import rules made under Section 122 CPC (which regulate procedure in all civil courts) across the whole of the new State irrespective of prior territorial application. The court concluded that such High Court rules are governed by Section 119 (the saving/deeming provision) and the adaptation machinery under Section 120, rather than Section 54.

6. Applying the above statutory analysis to the facts, the court held that in the territories of the former State of Madhya Bharat (including Gwalior) the CPC as it stood in those territories on 31-10-1956 continues to operate. Therefore the unamended text of Order 21 Rule 58 in the First Schedule of the CPC governs the present execution; the amendment to Rule 58 made by the former Madhya Pradesh High Court (Nagpur) does not apply in those territories because it has not been adapted under Section 120 for those areas.

7. As to whether the executing Court was bound to stay the sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2), the court recorded the petitioners' reliance on multiple precedents but declined to express any opinion on that legal question in this revision because the executing Court had not yet considered the stay application in that legal perspective. The court emphasized that the inquiry under Order 21 Rule 58 is summary in nature and should be expedited; it noted the delay between 13 March 1959 (institution of the objection) and the proposed sale date 1 July 1959.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The revision is allowed. The order passed by the executing Court on 26 June 1959 is set aside. The application dated 8 May 1959 filed by the objectors shall be considered afresh in the light of the court's observations, and until the disposal of that application the sale is to remain stayed. There shall be no orders as to costs of this revision.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The executing Court's order rejecting the stay application (dated 26 June 1959) has been set aside, the stay is directed to continue until the executing Court disposes of the May 8, 1959 application, and the executing Court must reconsider that application in the light of the legal analysis provided regarding the territorial operation of the CPC and High Court rules after reorganisation.
  • On law and precedent: The court's decision clarifies, in the context of these facts, that High Court rules made under Section 122 CPC remain territorially limited by the pre-existing territorial application and are governed by Section 119's saving provision; they do not automatically apply to territories formerly belonging to another existing State unless adaptations are made under Section 120. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel general proposition of constitutional law beyond this statutory construction and does not decide the separate legal question whether an executing court must stay sale under Order 21 Rule 58(2) — that question was left for the executing Court to consider.

No other broader or new precedent was declared beyond the statutory interpretation applied to the facts of this case; the court expressly refrained from deciding the precedential authorities cited on the stay question.

Show all summary ...

1. This revision raises an interesting point. The question is whether the Rules made by the High Court at Nagpur in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 122 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter called 'The Code') and which were in force in the former State of Madhya Pradesh as it existed before the Reorganization of States on 1-11-1956, are enforceable in that territory of the new Madhya Pradesh which upto 31-10-1950 was called the Part B State of Madhya Bharat.

2. The material facts are these. In execution of a decree against Kailash Chandm (judgment-debtor), Akabai (decree-holder) got his house attached. Munnilal and others filed an objection petition under Order 21 Rule 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure on 13-3-1959. Without deciding that petition, the executing Court fixed 1-7-1959, for the sale of the house. The objectors then filed an application on May 8, 1959 praying that the sale be stayed until the disposal of their objection petition. The executing court rejected this application, by applying Rule 58(2) of Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by the Nagpur High Court. Aggrieved by the same the objectors have filed this revision petition.

3. The contention of Shri Swami Saran, learned counsel for the petitioners is that the decree was passed by and is being executed in a Court at Gwalior, and Gwalior was a part of the former Madhya Bharat State so that unless and until the Rule made by the Nagpur High Court is adapted in the new State of Madhya Pradesh, it can have no application to this execution.

4. In order to appreciate this point, the scheme of the States Reorganisation Act 1956 (hereinafter called 'The Act') has to be examined.

5. Under Section 2 of the Act the following definitions are relevant:

(a) "appointed day" means the 1st day of November, 1930.

(d) "corresponding new State" means in relation to the existing State of Bombay, Madhya Pradesh, Mysore, Punjab or Rajasthan, the new State with the same name, and in relation to the existing Slate of Travancore-Cochin, the new State of Kerala.

(e) "corresponding State means, in relation to the new State of Bombay, Madhya Pradesh, Mysore, Punjab of Rajasthan, the existing State with the same name, and in relation to the new State of Kerala, the existing State of Travncore-Cochin.

(g) "Existing State" means a State specified in the First Schedule to the Constitution, at the commencement of this Act;

(h) "law" includes any enactment, ordinance, regulation, order, bye-law, rule, scheme, notification or other instrument having the force of law in the whole or in any part of the territory of India;

6. Section 9 (of part II) provides for the formation of a new State of Madhya Pradesh comprising of the territories enumerated therein including the territories of the 'corresponding State' of Madhya Pradesh (except certain districts) and the territories of the 'existing State' of Madhya Bharat except Sunel.

7. Part V deals with "High Courts."

8. Part XI is about "Legal and Miscellaneous Provisions." In this part Section 119 reads thus:

"The provisions of Part II shall not be deemed to have effected any change in the territories to which any law in force immediately before the appointed day extends or applies and territorial references in any such law to an existing State shall, until otherwise provided by a competent Legislature or other competent authority, be construed as meaning the territories within that State immediately before the appointed day."

9. This section provides for a fiction and makes it very clear by the deeming provision that for the purpose of the application of the laws it must be forgotten that there has been reorganization of States'. Whatever laws were in force immediately before November 1, 1956 continue to operate in the respective areas of the existing States. In other words, all the laws which were in force in the territories of Madhya Bharat continue to operate in those territories notwithstanding the alteration of the territories or the formation of the new State and notwithstanding that the then existing State of Madhya Bharat does not today exist on the map of India.

10. Section 120 provides a machinery for making laws uniform if the State Government or the legislature so desired. Section 120:

For the purpose of facilitating the application of any law in relation to any of the States formed or territory altered by the provisions of Part II, the appropriate Government may, before the expiration of one year from the appointed day, by order make such adaptations and modifications of the law, whether by way of repeal or amendment, as may be necessary or expedient, and thereupon every such law shall have effect subject to the adaptations and modifications so made until altered, repealed or amended by a competent Legislature or other competent authority.

11. It cannot be doubted that rules made by a High Court under Section 122 of the Civil P. C. are covered by the definition of the word "law" in Section 2 of the Act. Section 122 of the Civil Procedure Code runs thus:

"High Courts for Part A States and Part B States may, from time to time after previous publication, make rules regulating their own procedure and the procedure of the Civil Courts subject to their superintendence, and may by such rules annul, alter or add to all or any of the rules in the First Schedule."

It is obvious enough that any of the rules in the first schedule or the Code could be annulled, altered or added to by such rules as a High Court made under that power. Rules made in exercise of that power became a part and parcel of the first schedule of the Civil Procedure Code so tar as that State was concerned. In that view of the matter, the rules made by the High Court of the "corresponding State" of Madhya Pradesh (that is, the former M. P. which existed prior to November 1, 1956) continued to be operative in those territories of the new Madhya Pradesh State even after November 1, 1956. But since they have not yet been adapted under Section 120 of the States Reorganisation Act for the other territories of the "corresponding new State (that is, the present State of Madhya Pradesh) they arc not operative and cannot regulate the procedure of the Civil Courts there. The territories of the former State of Madhya Bharat are, therefore, outside the operation of those rules.

12. Shri Babulal Agarwal learned counsel) for the decree-holder relies on Section 54 of the Act and argues that the rules made by the High Court of the former Madhya Pradesh under the Code of Civil Procedure apply to the whole of Madhya Pradesh as from the appointed day (that is, November 1, 1956). Section 54 runs thus:

"Subject to the provisions of this Part, the law In force immediately before the appointed day with respect to practice and procedure in the High Court for the corresponding State shall, with the necessary modifications, apply in relation to the High Court for a new State, and accordingly, the High Court for the new State shall have all such powers to make rules and orders with respect to practice and procedure as are, immediately before the appointed day, exercisable by the High Court for the corresponding State:. . . ."

13. In my opinion Section 54 docs not apply to the rules made under the Civil Procedure Code regulating the procedure of the Civil Courts. This section speaks of the law.... .with respect to practice and procedure in the High Court ......." The law, rules and orders referred to in the section are these which deal with the practice and procedure in the High Court" and not those which deal with practice and procedure "in all courts." The scheme of the Act itself supports that view because Section 54 falls in Part V of the Act, which relates to "High Courts."

14. A Rule made by a High Court in exercise of the Dowers vested in it under Section 122 of! the Code of Civil Procedure is a piece of delegated or subordinate legislation. It is to be read as engrafted on the first schedule. It regulates procedure in all civil courts. It will be governed by Section 119 and not by Section 54 of the Act.

15. It must, therefore, be held that the Code of Civil Procedure as was in force in the territories of the former Madhya Bharat State on 31-10-1956 continues to operate in those areas of the new State of Madhya Pradesh. Therefore Order 21 Rule 58 as it stands in the first schedule of the Code of Civil Procedure applies to the present execution and the amendment made by the former Madhya Pradesh High Court does not apply to this case.

16. The next contention of Shri Swami Saran is that the executing court was bound to stay the whole case. It was imperative under Order 21, Rule 58(2). He relies on decisions reported in M. Varadaiah Chetti v. Narasimhalu, Chetty, AIR 1932 Mad 41; Sasthi Charan Biswas v. Gopal Chandra Saha, AIR 1937 Cal 390; Commr. of Income Tax v. Poona Electric Supply Co. Ltd., AIR 1947 Bom 263 and those reported in Shrichand v. Santosh Kumar, MBLJ 1953 HCR 493 and Shrikisan Shiv Pratap v. Dhulchand Kasturchand, MBLJ 1954 HCR 842. I must guard myself from expressing any opinion on that "oint because the executing Court has not yet considered the application for stay in the above perspective. Before I part with this case, I must observe that an enquiry under Order 21 R, 58 of the Code is of a summary nature and should be expedited. In the instant case the objection had been instituted on March 13, 1959. If it had been disposed on by 30-6-1959 which means 3 1/2 months, all these questions would not have arisen. Let me hope that this will now be done with expedition .

17. For reasons stated above, this revision is allowed, the order passed by the executing Court on June 26, 1959 is set aside and it is directed that the application dated May 8, 1959 filed by the objector shall be considered in the light of the above observations and until the disposal of the last mentioned application (May 8, 1959) the sale shall remain stayed. There shall be no orders as to costs of this revision.