Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Raj Kumari And Another v. Union Of India .

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 14, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from a railway accident on 16.7.1991 in which the deceased, Sheo Ram Singh, died. The appellants are dependants of the deceased and sought compensation under the provisions of Section 82A of the Railways Act, 1890. The Claims Commissioner and the lower court denied the claim on the ground that the appellants had failed to prove that the deceased was a "bona fide passenger" (i.e., that he held a valid railway ticket, pass or permission). Although the lower court rejected the claim on that ground, it assessed the quantum of compensation at Rs. 50,000 (the maximum amount fixed in Section 82-A as it stood at the relevant time). The appellants appealed against the denial of compensation; the present opinion addresses that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether payment of compensation under Section 82A of the Railways Act, 1890 was rightly denied to the appellants on the ground that they failed to prove that the deceased was a "bona fide passenger" (i.e., possessed a valid ticket, pass or permission).
  2. On whom does the onus of proof lie in claims under Section 82A where the deceased died in a railway carriage: the dependants asserting entitlement or the railway administration asserting that the deceased was a ticketless traveller?
  3. Whether any presumption under the Evidence Act (notably Section 114) can be raised in favour of the deceased being a bona fide passenger in the circumstances of a railway death.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the dependants-appellants contended that the claim for compensation could not have been negatived by the lower court on the ground that the dependants failed to prove the deceased was a bona fide passenger.

Railways' Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the Railways supported the decision of the Claims Commissioner, relying on the rulings in Ramchandra Prasad v. Union of India, AIR 1939 Patna 316, and Sundari v. Union of India, 1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad), to the effect that liability under Section 82-A arises only if the deceased was a bona fide passenger and not for the death of a trespasser or ticketless traveller.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramchandra Prasad v. Union of India AIR 1939 Patna 316 That liability of railway administration under Section 82-A of the Act to pay compensation for death in a railway accident arises only if the deceased was a 'bona fide passenger' and not for the death in such accident of any trespasser or ticketless traveller. The Court said it agreed with the view in Patna High Court but found the decision distinguishable on facts because in that case there was evidence that the deceased possessed no valid permission, pass or ticket. The Court also noted that that decision did not discuss the question of any presumption and of onus of proof under the Evidence Act.
Sundari v. Union of India 1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad) That liability of railway administration under Section 82-A of the Act to pay compensation for death in a railway accident arises only if the deceased was a 'bona fide passenger' and not for the death in such accident of any trespasser or ticketless traveller. The Court said it agreed with the view in the Allahabad Full Bench but found it distinguishable on facts because in that case there was evidence showing the deceased possessed no valid permission, pass or ticket; the decision did not address presumptions or onus under the Evidence Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the allocation of onus under the Evidence Act and the scheme of the Railways Act. It observed that ordinarily, under Sections 101 and 102 of the Evidence Act, the burden to prove facts on which legal right or liability depends lies on the person who asserts those facts. However, the Court considered whether the burden of proving that the deceased held a valid ticket, pass or permission during the journey (in which he died) could reasonably be placed on the dependants. The Court found that such a burden would be impossible for dependants to discharge because they typically have no means of knowledge as to whether the deceased had purchased a ticket or held permission, and any ticket or pass might have been lost in the accident.

The Court referred to Sections 66, 68, 113 and 122 of the Railways Act to show that a person is deemed to be a passenger when he travels on a ticket, pass or with permission, and that Section 68 contains a prohibition against travelling without a pass, ticket or permission. Quoting Section 68, the Court noted that travelling without ticket or permission is penalised under the Act. Having regard to the prohibition in Section 68, the Court held that a presumption may be drawn under Section 114 of the Evidence Act that a person found dead as a result of an accident in a railway carriage was a bona fide passenger.

The Court concluded that, because ticketless travel is an illegal act and the railway administration has special means of knowledge (for example, records of ticket issuance or records of checks by staff), the burden to prove that the deceased was a ticketless traveller or not a bona fide passenger should be on the railway administration. The Court further observed that Section 82-A is a beneficial piece of legislation designed to provide fixed monetary compensation to victims of railway accidents, and it would be unjust to place an impossible onus on dependants that would effectively deny them the benefit of the legislation.

While the Court agreed with the Patna and Allahabad High Court rulings that compensation under Section 82 (referred to in the opinion as Section 82-C in one paragraph) is payable only to dependants of a bona fide passenger, it distinguished those cases on the facts because in those decisions there was evidence that the deceased possessed no valid permission, pass or ticket. The Court noted that those decisions did not discuss presumptions or onus under the Evidence Act, issues which the present Court addressed.

On the facts before it, the Court held that a presumption should be drawn in favour of the deceased being a bona fide passenger and that the Railways' contention that no specific plea had been raised was "too hyper-technical," observing that the parties had led evidence on the question of whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED

Holding: The Court allowed the appeal. It directed that the appellants, as dependants of the deceased passenger, are entitled to be paid a sum of Rs. 50,000/- as compensation for the death of the deceased passenger. The appellants are also to receive the costs of the appeal; counsel's fee of Rs. 500/- to be paid if certified.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that the appellants receive Rs. 50,000/- as compensation and costs as directed. The Court's reasoning places the evidential onus of proving that the deceased was a ticketless traveller (and therefore not a bona fide passenger) on the railway administration, and it recognizes a permissible presumption under Section 114 of the Evidence Act in favour of the deceased being a bona fide passenger where a person is found dead as a result of a railway accident. The opinion does not state any further broader implications beyond the application of these principles to the appeal.

Show all summary ...

1. The only accident on 16.7.1991, were rightly denied question involved in this appeal is whether payment of compensation by the learned the appellants as dependants of the deceased Judge as Ad hoc Claims Commissioner Sheo Ram Singh, who died in a railway under the provisions of Section 82A of the Railways Act, 1890, on the ground that they failed to prove that the deceased was a 'bona fide passenger' meaning thereby that he did not hold a valid railway ticket, pass or permission for the journey.

2. Learned counsel appearing for the dependants-appellants herein contends that the claim for compensation could not have been negatived by the lower court on the ground mentioned above.

3. Learned counsel appearing for the Railways supports the decision of the Claims Commissioner on the basis of the ruling of Patna High Court reported in Ramchandra Prasad v. Union of India AIR 1939 Patna 316 and Full Bench decision of Allahabad High Court reported in Sundari v. Union of India 1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad).

4. The aforesaid decisions cited at the Bar (Sic. held that liability of) railway administration under Section 82-A of the Act to pay compensation for death in a railway accident arises only if the deceased was a 1 bona fide passenger' and not for the death in such accident of any trespasser or ticketless traveller.

5. The main question that arises in this case is on whom the onus of proof lies in such claim cases and whether any presumption under the Evidence Act can be raised. Normally under Sections 101 and 102 of the Evidence Act, the burden to prove such facts, on which the legal right or liability depends, is on such person who asserts existence of these facts. But the question before us is whether the burden of proof that the deceased held a valid ticket, pass or permission during his journey, in which he died in accident, can be placed on his dependants. Obviously, such burden of proof is impossible to be discharged by the dependants, who can have no means of knowledge, whether the deceased, before boarding the train, had purchased a valid ticket, pass or permission from the railway authorities. It is likely that such a deceased passenger held a valid ticket, pass or permission, but the same is lost in the accident with the death of person and loss of his belongings, if any.

6. The provisions of Sections 66, 68, 113 and 122 of the Act do indicate that the person is deemed to be a 'passenger' when he travels either on ticket, pass or with permission of the authorised officer of the Railways. Section 68 contains prohibition against travelling without pass or ticket or permission and provides as under:

68. Prohibition against travelling without pass or ticket.-(1) No person shall, without the permission of a railway servant empowered in this behalf by the railway administration, enter or remain in any carriage on a railway for the purpose of travelling therein as a passenger unless he has with him a proper pass or ticket.

(2) A railway servant granting the permission referred to in Sub-section (1) shall ordinarily grant to the passenger a certificate that the passenger has been permitted to travel in such carriage upon condition that he subsequently pays the fare payable for the distance to be travelled.

7. The provisions of Sections 113 and 122 of the Act make travelling without ticket punishable under certain circumstances and liable for payment of fare and fine. The scheme and the Act seen as a whole makes it evident that the entry into a railway carriage required of a person to obtain a ticket, pass or permission and in absence thereof, his action or omission is punishable with imprisonment or fine, including removal from the carriage. In our opinion, when a person is found dead as a result of accident in a railway carriage, in which he was travelling, a presumption may be drawn under Section 114 of the Evidence Act keeping in view of the prohibition under Section 68 of the Act against boarding a train without ticket that the deceased was a bona fide passenger. Since ticketless travel is an illegal act and exposes such traveller to penal action, the presumption is of innocence in favour of such one of the travellers or passengers in a train. It is for the railway administration to prove contrary and the burden in such circumstances that the deceased was a ticketless traveller or was not a bona fide passenger, should be on the railway administration which has special means of knowledge as to whether any ticket was issued to that deceased or whether at any point, before or at the end of journey, he was checked and detected by staff of the railway as an unauthorised person without ticket, pass or permission. We have to keep in mind that the provision contained in Section 82-A of the Act is a beneficial piece of legislation to compensate monetarily at a fixed sum each victim involved in railway accident. The argument of the learned counsel for the Railways cannot be accepted that the burden is on the dependants of the deceased passenger to prove that the deceased, who died in railway accident, possessed a valid ticket or pass. To place such onus of proof on the dependants would amount to denial of the benefit of such legislation to them for reasons beyond their control because such onus is impossible to be discharged.

8. We fully agree with the views of the Patna and Allahabad High Courts that compensation under Section 82-C is payable only to the dependants of bona fide passenger who died in an accident and not to every traveller of the ill-fated train. The aforesaid views of Patna and Allahabad High Courts are, however, distinguishable on facts because there existed evidence on record in these cases to show that the deceased passenger possessed no valid permission, pass or ticket. Such is not the case before us. The decisions, however, do not discuss or decide the question of any presumption and of onus of proof under the Evidence Act in such cases.

9. In the case before us, the presumption has to be drawn that the deceased was a bona fide passenger who lost his life in the railway accident. The contention of the learned counsel for the Railways is too hyper-technical that no specific plea in that behalf was raised in the claim petition. We find that the parties were fully alive to the issue and the evidence was led by them on the question whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger or not.

10. The lower court although rejected the claim on the ground that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger but has assessed the quantum of compensation payable at Rs. 50,000/-, which is the maximum limit of amount of compensation fixed in Section 82-A of the Act, as it stood at the relevant time on the date of accident. In view of our finding that the presumption could be raised in favour of the deceased, being a bona fide passenger, the full amount of compensation of Rs. 50,000/-, as quantified by the lower court, cannot be denied to the dependants.

11. In view of the legal discussion aforesaid, the appeal succeeds and is allowed. The appellants as dependants of the deceased passenger are entitled to a sum of Rs. 50,000/- as compensation and the claim deserves to succeed to that extent. It is directed that the appellants are entitled to be paid a sum of Rs. 50,000/- as compensation for the death of the deceased passenger. The appellants shall also get costs of this appeal. Counsel's fee Rs. 500/-, if certified.