Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R.S Sharma, Jabalpur v. M.P Uchcha Siksha Anudan Ayog, Bhopal And Another

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 10, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was working as a Lecturer at Nav-Yug College, Jabalpur, an institution governed by the Madhya Pradesh Ashaskiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ke Vetano Ka Sandaya) Adhiniyam, 1978 ("the Adhiniyam"), and recruitment to such grant-in-aid institutions is regulated by the Madhya Pradesh Ashaskiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ki Bharti) Niyam, 1979 ("the Recruitment Rules").

The petitioner challenged two communications from respondent No.1 (M. P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog, "the Ayog") dated 7-8-1985 (Annexure-F) and 4-3-1986 (Annexure-J) informing the College that the petitioner's selection and appointment as Lecturer were not recognized by the Ayog. As a result, the Ayog withheld grant-in-aid for payment of the petitioner's salary, and the College paid him a fixed salary from its own funds.

The petitioner challenged this action in the Court. The Court considered the petition, the parties' submissions, the Recruitment Rules (including the schedule of minimum qualifications), the minutes/recommendations of the Selection Committee (Annexure R-1, minutes dated 10 February 1985), and a university letter dated 1-4-1987 (Ann. R-2). The Court made findings regarding (a) whether the petitioner possessed the minimum prescribed qualification of two years' research experience, (b) whether the Selection Committee had applied its mind in assessing candidates (particularly whether Ph.D. candidates were considered and found unsuitable), and (c) the scope of the Ayog's power to recognize or refuse recognition of appointments for grant-in-aid purposes. The petition was ultimately dismissed by the Court, without cost, and any security deposited was ordered to be refunded to the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner possessed the minimum prescribed qualifications under the Recruitment Rules—in particular, whether he had "two years' experience of research work" as required by the second proviso to the schedule for appointment as Lecturer.
  2. Whether the Selection Committee's proceedings reflected due application of mind (i.e., whether the committee considered the petitioner's claimed research experience and whether it considered and found Ph.D. candidates unsuitable before choosing a non-Ph.D. candidate).
  3. Whether the Ayog (M. P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog) had statutory power to approve/disapprove or to annul appointments, or whether its power was limited to recognising or refusing to recognise appointments for the purpose of releasing grant-in-aid (i.e., whether the Ayog could withhold grant for salary or otherwise affect the institution's appointment decision).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Ayog's view that the petitioner lacked the minimum qualifications (research experience) is baseless.
  • The petitioner had more than 50% marks throughout from Higher Secondary up to M.Com., and was engaged in research work at the time of his consideration for appointment; therefore he could not have been treated as ineligible by the Ayog.
  • The petitioner's research registration: he had registered for Ph.D. in Commerce with Rani Durgawati Vishwavidyalaya, Jabalpur (registration dated 3-12-1979) and later re-registered with a new topic after the death and illness of his original guide and non-availability of material.
  • Assessment of whether academic attainment constitutes "research experience" is a matter solely for the Selection Committee; the court should not substitute its opinion for that of the committee.
  • The Ayog has no power under the Act and Recruitment Rules to approve/disapprove or annul appointments; its role is limited to sending a nominee as an ex-officio member to the Selection Committee.

Ayog's Arguments

  • The Ayog relied on a university letter dated 1-4-1987 (Ann. R-2) stating that the petitioner had not submitted the progress report in due time for his initial 1979 registration and later re-registered on a different topic with effect from 17-10-1986; hence the petitioner could not claim two years' research experience.
  • Whereas the Selection Committee evaluates whether claimed academic attainment amounts to research experience, the Ayog contended that mere registration for Ph.D. does not constitute research experience unless the candidate places material showing active engagement in research.
  • The Ayog argued that it has functions and powers under the Adhiniyam and the Grant-in-Aid Rules (including Section 13(2)(m) and (o) of the Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog Adhiniyam and Rule 4 of Revised Grant-in-Aid Rules dated 21-2-1979) to recognise or refuse to recognise appointments for the purpose of releasing grants; thus it can withhold grant for salary if it considers an appointment contrary to rules.
  • The Ayog further argued that the Selection Committee could not have resorted to the second proviso (permitting non-Ph.D. appointments) where Ph.D. candidates were available, unless those Ph.D. candidates were considered and found unsuitable. The Chart (Annexure R-1) recorded that at least two candidates with Ph.D. were on the panel.
  • The Ayog additionally argued that the advertisement for the post was defective and not in accordance with the Recruitment Rules, potentially depriving other candidates of opportunity (the Court did not decide this point in view of other findings).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Sudha Trivedi v. State Of M. P. and Ors., Misc. Petition No. 2512 Of 1989 (decided 30-4-1991) Interpreted that the phrase "research organisation" does not qualify "two years' research experience"—i.e., the requirement is two years' research experience even if practical experience in a research laboratory/organisation is absent. The Court relied on this interpretation to construe the schedule entry: it confirmed that two years' research experience by itself can satisfy clause (ii) of the second proviso, without requiring practical experience in a laboratory or research organisation; the enquiry remained whether the petitioner had such research experience and whether the Selection Committee had recorded consideration of it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, constrained to the material and legal provisions before it:

  1. The Court reproduced and analysed the Schedule of minimum prescribed qualifications for Lecturers in Colleges. The schedule provides, as an initial qualification, a doctor's degree or published research work of an equivalent high standard; the first proviso permits relaxation of percentage qualifications where the Selection Committee finds the candidate's thesis or published research of very high standard. The second proviso sets out alternative qualifications where no candidate with a doctorate or equivalent research is available or suitable, including the requirement of "2 years' experience of research work or practical experience in research laboratory, research organisation."
  2. The Court accepted the principle (also urged by the petitioner) that whether a specific academic attainment qualifies as "research experience" is a matter for the Selection Committee's assessment and the Court should not substitute its own view for that of the committee. However, that acceptance did not end the enquiry: the Court must still determine whether the Selection Committee in fact applied its mind and recorded consideration of relevant qualifications.
  3. The Court examined the Selection Committee minutes (Annexure R-1, minutes dated 10-2-1985). Those minutes recorded the committee's resolutions (appointing certain candidates, placing the petitioner at top of the select list) but did not record any consideration of the petitioner's claimed two years' research experience, nor did they disclose that Ph.D. candidates on the panel were considered and found unsuitable.
  4. The Court emphasised the distinction between (a) a requirement that the Selection Committee give reasons for its selections or rejections (which the committee is not required to do) and (b) the requirement that the committee's proceedings disclose due application of mind and advertence to the requirements of the rule. The Court held that, while detailed reasons for each selection are not mandated, the minutes should reflect the committee's awareness of and consideration of key rule requirements—e.g., if Ph.D. candidates were available, the committee must show in its proceedings that it considered them and found them unsuitable before resorting to non-Ph.D. candidates under the second proviso; similarly, the committee should indicate whether it regarded a candidate's research work as sufficient to constitute two years' research experience.
  5. On the material before it (the minutes and the chart showing candidates), the Court found that there were at least two candidates with Ph.D. degrees (Madangopal Beohar and Anil Kumar Sharma) and that at least one such candidate (Anil Kumar Sharma) also satisfied the percentage requirements. The minutes did not show any adjudication that those Ph.D. candidates were unsuitable—hence the committee could not have permissibly applied the second proviso to appoint a non-Ph.D. candidate unless it had expressly found the Ph.D. candidates unsuitable.
  6. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Selection Committee's proceedings did not disclose due application of mind in rejecting Ph.D. candidates and in treating the petitioner as possessing the requisite two years' research experience. The Court described the selection and appointment as "vitiated because of non-application of mind" by the Selection Committee.
  7. Separately, the Court analysed the Ayog's statutory role. It held that the Adhiniyam and the Recruitment Rules do not constitute the Ayog as having power to approve or disapprove appointments; any power of the Ayog to "recognise" or "refuse to recognise" an appointment for purposes of releasing grant-in-aid derives from the Grant-in-Aid Rules and executive instructions. The Ayog therefore has limited power to release or withhold financial grants for salary payment, but it cannot annul an appointment made by the institution.
  8. The Court clarified that the impugned communications by the Ayog refusing to recognise the petitioner's appointment should be understood as statements that, for the purpose of releasing grants for salary payment, the Ayog would not recognise the appointment as duly made in accordance with the rules. The Ayog had not annulled the appointment nor compelled the institution to discontinue the petitioner's services; it had only declined to treat the appointment as qualifying for grant-in-aid.
  9. The Court noted but did not decide the argument regarding alleged defects in the advertisement for the post, as its decision on the Selection Committee's non-application of mind and the Ayog's limited powers made resolution of that point unnecessary.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The petition was DISMISSED (the Court dismissed the petition), but the dismissal was made without any order as to costs, and any security amount deposited by the petitioner was ordered to be refunded.

The Court's operative findings and their immediate consequences for the parties, as stated in the opinion, are:

  • The Court found that the selection and appointment of the petitioner were vitiated because the Selection Committee's minutes did not disclose due application of mind—specifically, they did not show that the committee considered (and found unsuitable) available Ph.D. candidates nor that it considered and adjudged the petitioner's claim of two years' research experience. This amounts to a judicial finding of procedural infirmity in the selection process.
  • The Court held that the Ayog does not possess inherent power under the Adhiniyam or the Recruitment Rules to annul appointments made by an institution; its power to recognise or refuse recognition of appointments is limited to the context of releasing or withholding grant-in-aid under the Grant-in-Aid Rules and related executive instructions. The impugned communications were therefore construed as withholding recognition for grant purposes only, not as annulment of the appointment.
  • Direct practical outcomes ordered by the Court: the petition was dismissed without costs, and any security deposited was to be refunded to the petitioner.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasises the necessity that Selection Committee proceedings disclose a due application of mind to key rule requirements (for example, showing why Ph.D. candidates were not considered suitable before selecting a non-Ph.D. candidate under the second proviso). The Court also clarifies the limited nature of the Ayog's power (recognition for grant purposes rather than authority to annul appointments). The opinion does not purport to set a new precedent beyond its application of these principles to the facts before it, though it cites and relies upon prior authority (Smt. Sudha Trivedi) for statutory interpretation relevant to "research experience."

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioner is working as Lecturer in Nav-Yug College at Jabalpur. The College is an 'institution' governed by the provisions of Madhya Pradesh Ashaskiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ke Vetano Ka Sandaya) Adhiniyam, 1978 (in short 'the Adhiniyam'). The recruitment to the institutions receiving grant-in-aid from respondent No. 1 M. P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog (in short 'the Ayog') is regulated by recruitment rules named as the Madhya Pradesh Ashaskiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ki Bharti) Niyam, 1979.

2. The petitioner is aggrieved by two communications dated 7-8-1985 (Annexure-F) and dated 4-3-1986 (Annexure-J) of the respondent Ayog whereby the Principal of the College has been informed that the selection and appointment of the petitioner as Lecturer in the College have not been recognized by the Ayog. The result of the impugned communications is that the grant-in-aid for payment of salary of the post of the Lecturer to the petitioner is not being released by the Ayog and he is being paid fixed salary from the funds of the institution.

3. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has assailed the action of the Ayog mainly on two grounds. Firstly, it is contended that the stand of the Ayog, as contained in the impugned communications and in its return submitted in reply to this petition that the petitioner does not possess the minimum required qualifications laid down in the Recruitment Rules, is baseless. The learned counsel invited attention of this Court to the petitioner's bio-data and his educational qualifications, which have been mentioned against Entry No. 13 in the chart (Annexure R-l) filed with the return. The submission on behalf of the petitioner is that the petitioner has more than 50% of marks throughout from higher secondary level upto M.Com. and being engaged in research work at the time of consideration of his case for appointment to the post, he could not have been termed by the Ayog as a candidate ineligible for being selected on the post by the selection committee. The argument is that so far as his claim of research experience is concerned, that was exclusively a subject matter within the power of the selection committee and one of the nominees of the Ayog being ex-officio member of the selection committee under the rules, it is not open to the Ayog to treat the petitioner lacking in one of the minimum prescribed qualifications of research experience. It is not in dispute that the petitioner had registered himself for research work for award of Ph.D. degree with Rani Durgawati Vishwavidyalaya, Jabalpur. It is also not in dispute that the petitioner had registered himself for the Ph.D. degree in Commerce under the guidance of late Prof. S. C. Diwakar with effect from 3-12-1979, but he could not complete the research work on the topic he had selected because of the serious illness of his guide, who ultimately died of cancer. There was also non-availability of sufficient material on the topic of his research work. The petitioner, later registered himself with the University for the Ph.D. degree with a new topic of research.

4. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Ayog placed reliance on a letter dated 1-4-1987 (Ann. R-2) sent by the University to the Ayog, informing that the petitioner had not in due time submitted the progress report of his research work on the topic he had selected in the year 1979 and had later registered himself for doing research on a different topic with effect from 17-10-1986. The argument on behalf of the Ayog is that the petitioner can claim no research experience and on that score he lacked one of the minimum qualifications prescribed in the Recruitment Rules.

5. At the out-set we may state that the learned counsel for the petitioner is right in submitting that whether a particular academic attainment claimed by a candidate constitutes research experience within the meaning of the prescribed qualifications, is a matter to be solely assessed and judged by the selection committee and the Court cannot substitute its own opinion for that of the selection committee, obviously because the Court is ill-equipped for the job. The Court cannot substitute itself for the selection committee in that regard and the opinion of the selection committee is final in the matter.

6. The only argument advanced on behalf of the Ayog, which needs consideration is whether in fact the selection committee has duly assessed and judged the work and achievements of the petitioner as a candidate seeking appointment to hold him as possessing the requisite research experience. For decision on the first point concerning research experience, hotly contested between the parties, it is necessary to examine the relevant provisions prescribing minimum educational qualifications in the Schedule to the Recruitment Rules which is reproduced hereunder : -

A. For Lecturers in Colleges :

(a) A doctor's degree or published research work of an equivalent high standard; and

(b) (i) A 2nd Class Master's Degree in the concerned subject with at least 50% marks (B in the seven point scale) or an equivalent degree of a foreign University; and N. B. (while taking into account the marks/grade, the marks/grade obtained in the internal assessment, if any shall be excluded.)

(ii) At least 50 per cent marks at the Bachelor's degree examination on the basis of which division is awarded at the degree level by the University.

(iii) At least 50 per cent marks at the Higher Secondary/Intermediate/ Pre-University Examination as case may be.

Having regard to the need for developing interdisciplinary programmes the degree in (a) above may be in relevant subject :

Provided that if the Selection Committee is of the view that the research work of a candidate as evident from his thesis or from his published work is of very high standard it may relax any of the qualifications prescribed in (b) above :

Provided further that if a candidate possessing a Doctor's degree or equivalent research work is not available/or/is not considered suitable, a person possessing the following qualifications may be recruited -

(i) A 2nd Class Master's Degree in the concerned subject with at least 50 per cent marks (B in the seven point scale), and N. B. (While taking into account the marks/grade, obtained in the internal assessment, if any, shall be excluded.)

(ii) 2 years' experience of research work or practical experience in research laboratory, research organisation; and

(iii) At least 50 per cent marks at the Bachelor's degree examination on the basis of which division is awarded at the degree level by the University; and

(iv) At least 50 per cent marks at the Higher Secondary/Intermediate/ Pre-University Examination, as the case may be OR

(i) A Master's Degree with first class or grade 'A' in a relevant subject; and

(ii) At least 50 per cent marks at the Bachelor's degree examination on the basis of which division is awarded at the degree level by the University; and

(iii) At least 50 per cent marks at the Higher Secondary/Intermediate/ Pre-University Examination, as the case may be :

Provided further that in the case of Categories (B) and (C), a candidate will have to obtain a Doctor's Degree/M.Phil. Degree or have to his credit published research work of equivalent standard within 5 years of appointment failing which he will not earn future increments until he fulfils these requirements.

N. B. - The requirement regarding minimum percentage of marks shall be relaxed upto 50 percent in case of Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribes candidates.

7. On a careful perusal of the above quoted part of the schedule containing minimum prescribed qualifications, it is to be noticed that 'Ph.D. degree or published research work of equivalent high standard' is one of the minimum prescribed qualifications. The first proviso permits relaxation of requirement of the minimum percentage of marks from higher secondary level to the post-graduate level, if, in the opinion of the selection committee, the thesis or the published research work of the candidate is of a very high standard. The second proviso permits the selection committee to consider other candidates for appointment, in case there are no candidates possessing doctorate degree or equivalent research work.

8. Learned counsel for the petitioner has tried to fit in the case of the petitioner in the qualifications prescribed in the second proviso and the sub-clauses mentioned therein. It is to be noticed that in the event of non-availability of a candidate with doctorate degree or equivalent research work, there are three requirements for a candidate to be fulfilled.

(i) Second Class Master's Degree in the concerned subject with at least 50% marks.

(ii) Two years' experience of research work or practical experience in research laboratory, research organisation, coupled with.

(iii) Minimum 50% marks at the higher secondary and graduate levels.

9. The main controversy between the parties is whether the petitioner can be said to be possessing two years' research experience. Evidently, the petitioner seeks appointment as a lecturer in Commerce faculty and hence there can be no question of possessing any practical experience in any research laboratory. It is also not necessary in every subject to have any experience in any research organisation. The above relevant entry in second proviso to the schedule came for interpretation before this Court in the case of Smt. Sudha Trivedi v. State Of M. P. and Ors., Misc. Petition No. 2512 Of 1989 decided on 304-1991, the relevant entry was interpreted to mean that the term 'research organisation' occurring in the entry does not qualify the opening phrase "two years' research experience", but relates to its second part 'practical experience'. The entry was thus understood to mean that it is enough for a candidate for the purpose of the relevant entry of the schedule to have two years' research experience, may be that he may not have any practical experience in any research laboratory or research organisation. What, therefore, is to be considered in this case is - whether the petitioner can claim appointment under second proviso of the schedule and can be deemed to be possessed of two years' experience of research. This claim based on two years' research experience is hotly contested between the parties. The arguments of the learned counsel for the Ayog is that mere registration for Ph.D. degree in a University with no concrete work whatsoever, on the topic of research, does not amount to passessing of two years' experience unless some material exists before the selection committee to show that the candidate was actively engaged in research work. For the purpose of this case we do not wish to enter into that controversy as to whether the petitioner had in fact done any work on the topic of his Ph.D. and whether the research work disclosed by him to the selection committee was sufficient to hold him as possessing two years' experience of research work.

10. The more important question that has been raised on behalf of the Ayog is that the proceedings of the selection committee nowhere reflect that the petitioner's claim of two years' research experience in terms of clause (ii) of the second proviso to the schedule, was duly considered and adjudged by the selection committee for treating him duly qualified. The argument on behalf of the Ayog is that in fact the second proviso of the schedule could not be resorted to, to select and appoint the petitioner because candidates with Ph.D. degree were available but they were deliberately ignored to favour the petitioner with selection and appointment. The attention of the Court was invited to the Chart Annexure R-l which gives the names of the candidates and their educational bio-data, who were considered by the selection committee for selection and appointment. From the aforesaid chart, it is to be found that there were two candidates Madangopal Beohar at Serial No. 8 and Anil Kumar Sharma at Serial No. 10 with Ph.D. degree to their credit. The candidate Anil Kumar Sharma also fulfils other qualifications prescribed of possessing 50 percent and more marks at all levels from higher secondary to post-graduate. The learned counsel for the Ayog submitted that the second proviso of the schedule could be resorted to by the selection committee for considering non Ph.D. candidates only if there were no Ph.D. candidates available or they were not considered suitable by the selection committee.

11. After giving careful consideration to the submission made by the parties on the relevant entries of the schedule containing the minimum prescribed qualifications for appointment as lecturer in the College, we are of the opinion that the contention of the Ayog is sound and has to be accepted. The relevant portions of the recommendations of selection committee have been exhibited as Annexure R-l with the petition. The relevant portion of the minutes of the selection committee reads as under:

"Dated February 10, 1985 Minutes of the Meeting of the Selection Committee held on February 10, 1985 at 12.00 noon in the Vice-Chancellor's Chamber, Pachpedi, Jabalpur for the two posts of Lecturers in Commerce at Nav-Yug Arts and Commerce College, Jabalpur.

MEMBERS PRESENT :

After detailed deliberations over the panel of 5 candidates in merit - order submitted by the selection committee, constituted by the University for the selection of two Lecturers in Commerce, it was 'resolved that Shri Ratan Singh Sharma and Shri Rajesh Kumar Jain of the Panel be appointed as Lecturer (now Asst. Professors) in Commerce on probation for a year but subject to the concurrence of the Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog, Bhopal to these appointments.

Similarly after deliberations over the panel of two candidates in merit order, submitted by the Selection Committee constituted by the University for the Selection of a Lecturer in English, it was

"resolved that Ku. Varsha Singh of the panel be appointed as Lecturer (now Asstt. Professor) in English on probation for a year but subject to the concurrence of the Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog, Bhopal to this appointment."

The minutes of the proceedings of the selection committee do not at all reflect that the selection committee considered the candidature of the petitioner as a holder of two years' research experience as laid down in sub-clause (ii) of the second proviso. The minutes also do not disclose that the selection committee considered the Ph.D. candidates who were available, and found them not suitable for the appointment. The argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner on the contents of the minutes of the selection committee is that the selection committee is not required to state the reasons for selection or rejection of particular candidates. In our opinion, the committee constituted for making selection of teachers or lecturers is not required to state reasons for selection or non-selection of candidates, but it is necessary that its proceedings should disclose due application of mind. The minutes of the selection committee do not disclose that its members were alive to the requirement of the rule in the schedule that if Ph.D. candidates are available, they can be rejected only if found unsuitable and non-Ph.D. could be considered only in such eventuality. The proceedings of the selection committee should have also disclosed from its minutes that the committee was conscious of the requirement of the rule that although a candidate does not possess degree or research work of equivalent standard, he must at least possess two years' 'research experience'. The proceedings of the selection committee in placing the petitioner at the top of the select list did not at all mention that in the opinion of the selection committee, the petitioner's work after registration for Ph.D. was of a nature which could be considered as fulfilling the minimum prescribed qualifications of his possessing 'two years' research experience'.

13. Learned counsel for the Ayog is right in submitting that mere registration for Ph.D. does not amount to research experience unless the candidate is able to place some material before the selection committee to show that he was actively engaged in doing research on the topic selected by him. This requirement of putting on record the relevant statement of facts disclosing due application of mind with due advertence to the rules, in the matter of selection of candidate, is different from stating reasons for selection or non-selection of candidates. The selection proceedings on record (relevant contents of which are quoted above) do not disclose any application of mind on the part of the members of the selection committee in rejecting the candidates who were holders of Ph.D. degree, on the ground of their unsuitability and selecting the petitioner by assigning him position at the top of the select list. Such a requirement on the part of the selection committee do reflect from its proceedings due application of mind can be read as an implied requirement from the contents of the rule in the schedule itself. In this respect it may be noticed that under the first proviso of the schedule, the selection committee has to form an opinion that the research work of a candidate from his thesis or published work, is of such a high standard as to justify relaxation of other minimum prescribed qualifications with regard to percentage of marks from High Secondary to Post-Graduate levels. The intendment of the first proviso to the schedule, therefore, is that the selection committee should record or disclose its view on the above aspect. Similarly, for the purpose of second proviso, which is under consideration before us, it appears incumbent on the selection committee to disclose from the minutes of its proceedings that the candidates with Ph.D. degree are not found suitable and, therefore, other candidates with no Ph.D. degree were considered. Similarly, for the purpose of sub-clause (i) under second proviso, the selection committee has to disclose from its minutes due application of mind that the research work placed before it was found to be sufficient to hold the candidate eligible for the post.

14. In our opinion, therefore, the selection and appointment of the petitioner is vitiated because of non-application of mind on the part of the members of the selection committee in rejecting the candidates with Ph.D. degrees and in placing the petitioner at the top of the select list without considering whether he could be held to have possessed two years' research experience on the basis of the information and material furnished to the selection committee. The argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner cannot, therefore, be accepted that the minutes of the proceedings of the selection committee are not required to disclose the relevant facts in the matter of selection or non-selection of the candidates considered by it.

15. The second point urged on behalf of the petitioner is that the Ayog has no power under the rules to approve or disapprove the appointment of a lecturer in the educational institution and has no right to withhold grant for payment of salary of such a teacher who is appointed, in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the Rules. Our attention was invited to the provisions of the Act and the Recruitment Rules and attempt was made to point out that excepting sending a nominee as an ex-officio member on the selection committee for recruitment of teachers in aided-institutions, the Ayog has no other power or function in the matter of recruitment.

16. Learned counsel appearing for the Ayog placed reliance on Section 2(e) read with 2(i) of the Adhiniyam in which the terms 'Institution' and 'teacher' have been defined. Placing special emphasis on the definition of 'teacher' under Section 2(i) the argument is that a person does not become a 'teacher' to be governed by the provisions of the Act, unless there is prior approval to his appointment by the authority specified by the State Government. It is pointed out that by a notification issued in terms of Section 2(b) and (i) of the Adhiniyam, the Ayog has been specified as the competent authority for State-aided colleges. Attention of the Court is also invited to the provisions of M. P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog Adhiniyam and particularly Section 13(2)(m) and (o) which, among others, prescribe one of the essential functions of the Ayog to maintain standards in higher education by giving grants to educational institutions. Learned counsel for the Ayog also made a reference to the Revised Grant-in-Aid Rules for non-governmental educational institutions in Madhya Pradesh framed on 21-2-1979. Rule 4 of the Grant-in-Aid Rules reads as under :-

"Rule 4. General conditions. - Taking into account the requirement and availability of funds, grants under these rules will be given, to non-Gonvernmental institutions which impart sound and secular instruction. Such grants will be subject to the conditions specified in these rules and also subject to further conditions as may be specified by the State Government from time-to time."

17. On the basis of the above provisions of the Adhiniyam and the M. P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog Adhiniyam and the Revised Grant-in-Aid Rules, the submission on behalf of the Ayog is that since the Ayog makes financial grant for payment of salary to the teachers in aided institutions, it has functions and powers under the aforesaid two enactments and the Grant-in-Aid Rules to recognise or refuse to recognise appointment of teacher to an institution.

18. On the second question raised before us by the parties, it is enough for us to say that the provisions of the Act and the Recruitment Rules do not constitute the Ayog as a body having power to approve or disapprove the appointment made by an educational institution. The power, if any, by the Ayog, in the matter is derived from the Grant-in-Aid Rules and the executive instructions that may have been issued by the State Government thereunder from time to time. The Ayog is an institution which releases financial grants of the State, to the institutions and, therefore, for releasing the grant or withholding it, it has power and function under the Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog Adhiniyam and the Grant-in-Aid Rules, to recognize an appointment or to refuse to recognize the same. The Ayog, therefore, has only for the above limited purpose; power to release or withhold the financial grant to an institution. The Ayog can claim no power to annul an appointment made by the institution.

19. The learned counsel for the Ayog is right in submitting that the impugned communications issued by the Ayog refusing to recognize the appointment should be understood in the right perspective to mean that for the purpose of releasing grants for payment of salary to the petitioner, the Ayog has not held the appointment of the petitioner as duly made in accordance with the Rules, so as to entitle the institution to receive the grant for the same. The Ayog has, by the impugned communication neither annulled the appointment of the petitioner nor is compelling the institution to discontinue his services. All that the Ayog has informed to the institution by the impugned communications is that for the purpose of financial grant, the appointment of the petitioner being contrary to rules, will not be recognised.

20. An attempt was also made by the learned counsel for the Ayog to support the action of the Ayog in the matter of disapproving the appointment of the petitioner, stating that the advertisement issued for the post itself was not in accordance with the Recruitment Rules and the qualifications prescribed in the schedule thereunder. The argument is that because of the defective advertisement, many candidates who could have been considered in competition to the petitioner were deprived of seeking appointment. In our opinion, it is not necessary for us to decide this point urged on behalf of the Ayog, in view of our decision on the first two questions raised before us.

21. Consequently the petition has no force and is hereby dismissed, but without any order as to costs. The security amount, if deposited, be refunded to the petitioner.