- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sanjib Das v. State Of W.B & Ors.
Summary of the Opinion: Use of the Prefix "Doctor/Dr." by Practitioners of Alternative Medicines
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petition challenges whether persons holding degrees, certificates or diplomas to practice alternative medicines may prefix "Dr." or "Doctor" to their names. The petitioner alleges that respondent Nos. 14 and 15 were using the prefix "Dr." and representing themselves as doctors/medical practitioners, though they did not possess an M.B.B.S. or other basic recognized medical qualification. The petitioner relied upon prescriptions issued by respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and made complaints to the Indian Medical Association (IMA) on 3 November 2007, which forwarded the complaint to the Commissioner of Police, Kolkata. The petitioner and other bodies sought action from police and other authorities, but no effective action was taken, prompting this writ petition.
Procedurally, the Indian Board of Alternative Medicines was added as respondent No. 16 by order dated 21 November 2008. By order dated 12 March 2010, leave was granted to prosecute the petition in a representative capacity against respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and similarly situated persons, and advertisement and affidavit directions were issued. Affidavits were filed by respondent Nos. 11, 15 and 16, members of the public supporting alternative medicine practitioners (including Suman Motilal Shah and Partha Mukherjee), and by respondent No. 21 opposing the writ petition. An application led to the addition of further institutions as respondent Nos. 17 to 21.
The Division Bench considered the matter and, by an order dated 12 March 2010, restrained respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and similarly situated persons from using the title "Doctor" or "Dr." The petition ultimately sought directions to State authorities to initiate an enquiry based on the memo No HAD/6 R-37-2001/Pt-1.A 1573/1 dated 14th March, 2008 and to restrain the named respondents and similarly situated persons from using the prefix "Doctor" or "Dr." The Court heard rival contentions, perused records and rendered a decision allowing the writ petition with directions to State authorities and a restraint on the use of "Doctor/Dr." by the named respondents and similarly situated persons. The petition was disposed of and there was no order as to costs. The other judge (Ashim Kumar Banerjee, A.C.J.) agreed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a person who has obtained a degree/certificate/diploma to practice alternative medicines may prefix "Dr." or "Doctor" (or "Dr.") to their name.
- Whether persons using such prefixes without recognized medical qualifications are entitled to practice medicine or be treated as medical practitioners under the statutory scheme, and whether State authorities should be directed to take action (specifically on the memo dated 14 March, 2008).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner alleged respondent Nos. 14 and 15 were representing themselves as doctors by using the prefix "Dr." before their names, yet did not possess an M.B.B.S. or equivalent recognized medical qualification.
- The petitioner argued that respondent Nos. 16 to 21 are not "recognized institutes" within the meaning of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and that their certificates are not included in the schedules to that Act.
- The petitioner relied on section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 to contend that using "doctor" or "Dr." without requisite permission is a punishable offence and that only persons with recognized medical qualifications and registration are entitled to use the prefix.
- The petitioner sought directions to State authorities to act on the memo dated 14 March, 2008 and to restrain the named respondents and similarly situated persons from using the prefix "Doctor" or "Dr."
Respondent Nos. 14 and 15 — Arguments
- They contended they obtained valid certificates from respondent No. 16 (Indian Board of Alternative Medicines) and, having obtained such certificates, were entitled to practice alternative medicines.
- They argued no law prohibits practicing alternative medicines and claimed to have treated patients successfully and even obtained a patent for a particular medicine. They also asserted public satisfaction with their medical relief.
Respondent No. 16 (Indian Board of Alternative Medicines) — Arguments
- Respondent No. 16's affidavit (from its president) admitted that the system of alternative medicines has not been recognised by any Central or State law, but contended there was no law in West Bengal prohibiting use of the prefix "Dr."
- It argued that although "Dr." is used as a prefix, the term "alternative medicines" follows the practitioner's name on letterheads, which, in its view, prevents misrepresentation. It further contended that use of "Dr." helps distinguish practitioners of alternative medicines from quacks.
- Respondent No. 16 emphasized various accolades and international practice and stated it is registered under the West Bengal Societies Registration Act, 1961, relying also upon its own rules and byelaws.
Respondent No. 21 — Arguments
- Respondent No. 21 claimed affiliation under Act XXVI of 1961 and argued that practitioners of Homeopathy, Ayurvedic, Unani and Siddha are entitled to use the prefix "Doctor"; excluding practitioners of alternative medicines from using the prefix would be discriminatory.
- Respondent No. 21 filed an affidavit opposing the writ petition and made submissions consistent with its affidavit.
Other Respondents (General Points advanced on behalf of Respondent Nos. 16–21)
- Affidavits and public filings supported the position that alternative medicine practitioners should be allowed to use the prefix "Dr." and emphasized voluntary acceptance and perceived efficacy of their treatments.
- Some supporting affidavits sought to distinguish alternative medicine practitioners from quacks by the use of the prefix "Dr."
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis focused on the statutory scheme established by the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (the 1956 Act) and the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916. The Court examined definitions and provisions in the 1956 Act, including:
- Section 2(d): definition of the Indian Medical Register — the register maintained by the Medical Council of India;
- Section 21: requirement for the Council to maintain a register of medical practitioners in the prescribed manner, and the register being a public document under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872;
- Section 2(b): definition of the Council as the Medical Council of India constituted under the Act;
- Section 2(h): definition of "recognized medical qualification" as those qualifications included in the schedules to the 1956 Act;
- Sections 10-A and 10-B: scheme showing that no medical qualification granted by a medical college is a recognized medical qualification under the 1956 Act unless the previous permission of the Central Government has been obtained under section 10-A;
- Section 11: recognition of medical qualifications granted by universities or medical institutions in India when included in the first schedule to the Act;
- Section 15: right for persons possessing qualifications included in the schedule to be enrolled on any State Medical Register;
- Section 12: recognition of medical qualifications granted by institutions in countries with reciprocity schemes;
- Section 13: recognition of certain foreign qualifications not included in the schedules but recognized for the purposes of the Act.
The Court combined the scheme of the 1956 Act with section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 (which the petitioner relied on) to derive the legal consequence: only a person holding a recognized medical qualification (as per the 1956 Act) and whose name appears on the register of medical practitioners maintained under that Act is entitled to use the prefix "doctor" or "Dr." The Court observed it is an admitted position that respondent Nos. 16 to 21 and the diplomas/degrees/certificates/licenses issued by them are not recognized under the 1956 Act and are not included in the first schedule. The Court also noted respondent Nos. 16 to 21 do not fall within the second or third schedules of the Act.
The Court rejected the contention that public acceptance, accolades, registration under the West Bengal Societies Registration Act, 1961, or the practice in other jurisdictions confers a right to use the prefix "Dr." The Court held such acceptance or registration does not amount to statutory recognition under the 1956 Act, and therefore does not entitle the holders of such alternative medicine certificates to use the prefix "doctor"/"Dr." or to practice as medical practitioners under that designation.
Applying these principles to the facts before it, the Court concluded that allowing persons without recognized medical qualifications and without registration on the statutory medical registers to use the prefix "Dr." and to practice as medical practitioners would be contrary to the statutory scheme of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, and the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the writ petition and issued directions:
- The State Authorities were directed to take appropriate action on the memo dated 14 March, 2008 (Memo No HAD/6 R-37-2001/Pt-1.A 1573/1) as expeditiously as possible.
- The Court restrained respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and all other persons similarly situated from using the prefix "doctor" or "Dr." in any manner whatsoever with their names.
- The writ petition was disposed of; there was no order as to costs. The other judge concurred.
Implications: The direct and practical consequence of the decision is that the named respondents and similarly situated persons (i.e., persons holding qualifications not recognised under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and not listed in the statutory schedules) are prohibited from using the prefix "doctor" or "Dr." in relation to their names, and State authorities have been directed to take action on the specified memo. The opinion does not purport to set out any broader novel legal doctrine beyond applying the statutory scheme of the 1956 Act and the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 to the facts; no case precedents were cited as establishing new law in this opinion.
Note: This summary is confined to the information contained in the provided court opinion and does not introduce information beyond that text.
Debangsu Basak, J.:— Whether a person having obtained a degree/certificate/diploma to practice alternative medicines can prefix ‘Dr.’ or ‘Doctor’ or any other such prefix to their names, falls for consideration in this writ petition.
Petitioner alleges that the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 are representing themselves as doctors/medical practitioners by using a prefix ‘Dr.’ before their names. Petitioner has relied upon various prescriptions issued by the respondent Nos. 14 and 15. Petitioner says that neither respondent Nos. 14 nor 15 possess an M.B.B.S degree or the basic minimum degree for them to describe themselves as doctors. Petitioner has made a representation to the Indian Medical Association on 3rd November, 2007. The Indian Medical Association forwarded the petitioner's complaint to the Commissioner of Police Kolkata to take necessary action. According to the petitioner, another body of medical practitioners namely I.M.A academy of medical specialties also requested the Commissioner of Police Kolkata to take action. Petitioner claims that the Police Authorities did not take any action. Petitioner made representations to various authorities which did not evoke a favourable reply. In such circumstances, the petitioner has approached this Hon'ble Court for seeking direction on the State respondents to initiate enquiry on the basis of Memo No HAD/6 R-37-2001/Pt-1.A 1573/1 dated 14th March, 2008 and a further order seeking the State respondent to ensure that the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 are restrained from representing themselves as doctors and/or from practicing as medical practitioners without possessing requisite qualification.
By an order dated 21st November, 2008, the Indian Board of Alternative Medicines was added as respondent No. 16. By an order dated 12 March, 2010 leave was granted to prosecute the petition in a representative capacity against the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 as representing all the persons who have been conferred the degrees/diplomas/certificates of registration by the Indian Board of Alternative Medicines Kolkata. Direction for affidavits has been issued from time to time. Affidavits have been filed by the respondent Nos. 11, 15 and 16. Advertisements have been published pursuant to the order dated 12 March, 2010. Affidavits have been filed by a member of the public seeking to support the system of alternative medicines and seeking to support the use of prefix Dr. before the name of practitioner on alternative medicine. Suman Motilal Shah claims to be a registered practitioner having diploma in magnet therapy under the Indian Board of Alternative Medicines has filed an affidavit opposing the grant of reliefs. Mr. Partha Mukherjee has filed a similar affidavit. An application for addition of party has been made on behalf of Suresh Chandra Majumder who states that several institutions enumerated in paragraph 6 to his application are issuing degrees/diplomas/certificates and that candidates of such institutions are using the prefix doctor or Dr. and that they are not entitled to. Suresh Chandra Majumder seeks to support the petitioner. The institutions named in paragraph 6 to the application of Suresh Chandra Majumder who are added as respondents to the Writ Petition as respondent Nos. 17 to 21. The respondent No. 21 has used an affidavit opposing the writ petition.
The Indian Board of Alternative Medicines through its president has affirmed an affidavit stating that although the system of alternative medicines have not been recognized by any Central law or State law no law prohibiting its user is there in West Bengal. Although Dr. is used as prefix the term alternative medicines is used after the name of the practitioner in their letter heads which clarifies the position entirely, and that, therefore, there is no scope for misrepresentation if a prefix Dr. is used. It is also contended that Dr. is used to denote that the practitioner of alternative medicines are distinguished from quacks.
The writ petition received the consideration of the Division Bench from time to time. By an order dated 12 March, 2010 the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and similarly situate persons were restrained from using the title Doctor or Dr, in abbreviated forms with their names.
Counsel for the petitioner contends that the respondent No. 14 and 15 and for that matter any person similarly situate as that of the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 are not entitled to use the prefix Doctor or Dr. to their names. He contends that none of the respondent Nos. 16 to 21 are recognized institutes within the meaning of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. Certificates issued by the respondent Nos. 16 to 21 are not recognized in any of the schedules to the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. The petitioner relies on section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 to contend that user of doctor or Dr. without requisite permission, is a punishable offence. Counsel for the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 contends that they obtained valid certificates from the respondent no. 16. Having obtained such valid certificates they are entitled to practice alternative medicines. No law prohibits them from practicing alternative medicines. The respondent Nos. 14 and 15 contends that they have treated various patients as also obtained patent in respect of a particular medicine. They also contend that the members of the public are satisfied with the quality of medical relief given by them.
The respondent No. 16 has used an elaborate affidavit. In such affidavit the respondent No. 16 has highlighted the various accolades that it received in its field from various institutions and personalities. It also relies on international practice.
In the second affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent No. 16 it has been admitted that the system of alternative medicines has not been recognized by any Central law or State law. The respondent No. 16 however, contends that there is no law in West Bengal prohibiting the user of prefix doctor or dr. prior to the names. Respondent No. 16 claims to be registered under the West Bengal Societies Registration Act, 1961. It has also relied upon its rules and bye laws.
Respondent No. 21 a similarly situate as that of the respondent No. 16 has used an affidavit. In such affidavit the respondent No. 21 claims itself to be an affiliated institution under Act XXVI of 1961. It claims that since persons practicing Homeopathy, Ayurvedic, Unani and Siddha systems of medicines are entitled to use the prefix doctor it would be discriminatory if practitioners of alternative medicines are not allowed to use the same. Submissions have been made on behalf of the respondent Nos. 16 and 21 in line with their affidavit before us.
We have heard the rival contentions of the parties and have perused the records. The Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 has come into effect from 30 December, 1956. The statement of objects and reasons of the 1956 Act postulate that the 1956 Act would provide for the maintenance of an all India register by the Medical Council of India which will contain the names of all Medical practitioners possessing recognized medical qualification.
Section 2(d) of the 1956 Act defines Indian Medical Register to mean the medical register maintained by the Council. Section 21 of the 1956 Act requires the Council to maintain in the prescribed manner a register of medical practitioners. Such register is deemed to be a public document within the meaning of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Council is defined in section 2(b) of the 1956 Act to mean Medical Council of India constituted under the 1956 Act. A recognized medical qualification is defined by section 2(h) of the 1956 Act to mean any of the medical qualifications included in the schedules of the 1956 Act.
It is an admitted position that none of the respondent Nos. 16 to 21 and the diplomas, degrees, certificates and licenses issued by them are recognized under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. Section 15 of the 1956 Act gives right to persons possessing qualifications in the schedule to the Act of 1956 to be enrolled on any State Medical Register. State Medical Register is defined in Section 2(k) of the 1956 Act to mean a register maintained under any law for the time being in force in any State regulating the registration of practitioners of medicines.
The Scheme of the 1956 as appearing in sections 10-A and 10-B shows that no medical qualification granted by a medical college except with the previous permission of the Central Government in accordance with section 10-A shall be a recognized medical qualification for the purpose of the 1956 Act.
Section 11 of the 1956 Act deals with recognition with medical qualification granted by universities or medical institutions in India. The medical qualifications granted by any university or medical institution in India which are included in the first schedule to the said Act is to be recognized medical qualification for the purposes of the 1956 Act. Our attention has also been drawn to section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916. The scheme of the two Acts leads us to hold, only a person holding a recognized medical qualification and having his name in Medical Register, is entitled to use “doctor” or “dr.” as a prefix.
Admittedly, the respondent Nos. 15 to 21 are not included to the first schedule of the said Act. Section 12 of the 1956 Act speaks of recognition of medical qualifications granted by medical institutions in countries with which there is a scheme of reciprocity. The second schedule specifies the medical qualifications granted by medical institutions outside India. Section 13 of the 1956 Act speaks of recognition of medical qualifications granted by medical institutions whose qualifications are not included in the first of the second schedule but recognized as medical qualifications for the purposes of the 1956 Act.
The respondent Nos. 16 to 21 do not fall within the second of the third schedule of the 1956 Act.
Our attention has also been drawn to section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916. The alternative medicines practiced by persons to whom diplomas, degrees, certificates or licenses have been given by the respondent Nos. 16 to 21 may receive favourable acceptance by institutions and personalities. Such acceptance does not in any manner confer a right on such persons to use the prefix doctor or dr. to their name. A person who has obtained a medical qualification in terms of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and whose name appears in the register of medical practitioners as contemplated under the said Act of 1956, is entitled to use the prefix doctor or dr.. To allow any other person to use such prefix and to practice medicines would be against the scheme of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916.
In such circumstances we allow writ petition directing the State Authorities to take appropriate action on the memo dated 14 March, 2008 as expeditiously as possible and restrain the respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and all other persons similarly situated, from using the prefix doctor or dr. in any manner whatsoever with their names.
With the aforesaid directions this writ petition is disposed of.
There would be however no order as to costs.
Ashim Kumar Banerjee, A.C.J:— I agree.
Alert