- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
New Globe Transport Corporation v. Magma Shrachi Finance Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, New Globe Transport Company, entered into a hire-purchase agreement with the respondent, Magma Shrachi Finance Limited, for financing the purchase of a Tata truck. The petitioner paid five installments. On 4 July 2007 the truck (bearing registration WB 23B 1768) was stolen; an FIR was lodged (Liluah PS Case No. 106/2007 under section 379 IPC) and the petitioner informed the respondent and the insurer (National Insurance Company). The criminal investigation ended with a final report under section 173 CrPC reporting no recovery.
An arbitral award dated 5 August 2008 (in favour of the respondent for Rs. 12,51,573 with interest at 24% p.a.) was later raised. The arbitrator purportedly sent the award by registered post with acknowledgment due on 8 August 2008; the envelope was returned with the postal endorsement "Not Claimed." The petitioner contends that it first became aware of the award on 9 July 2010 upon receipt of a letter dated 30 June/30 July 2010 enclosing a copy of the award, and then sought inspection of the original A/D card.
The petitioner filed a Section 34 application on 9 September 2010 challenging the award. The Single Judge framed limitation as a prima facie bar and directed exchange of affidavits. After hearing, the Court held that the endorsement "Not Claimed" amounted to good service on 8 August 2008, found the Section 34 petition barred by limitation under sub-section (3) of section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and dismissed the petition. A prayer for a stay was refused.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Section 34 application challenging the arbitral award dated 5 August 2008 was barred by limitation under sub-section (3) of section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
- Whether service of the arbitral award by registered post with acknowledgment due—returning with the postal endorsement "Not Claimed"—constituted effective service so that limitation would commence from 8 August 2008.
- Which party bears the onus to prove delivery/service of the award and whether a bare denial by the sendee can successfully rebut the presumption of service arising from postal endorsement and statutory presumptions (including reliance upon the General Clauses Act and relevant decisions).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (Appellant)
- The petitioner denied that the award was ever served on them prior to 9 July 2010 and asserted they first learned of the award only upon receipt of a letter dated 30 June/30 July 2010 enclosing a copy of the award.
- The petitioner contended that the endorsement "Not Claimed" on the envelope does not prove valid service; any presumption of service arising from such endorsement is rebuttable and the onus is on the arbitrator (or the Arbitral Tribunal) to prove actual service.
- The petitioner relied on judgments (cited in the petition) to support the proposition that limitation runs from the date the award is actually received by the party and that proof of receipt is necessary before limitation begins.
- The petitioner requested inspection of the original A/D card and related postal records to test the claim of service; they alleged the arbitrator refused to permit inspection when first requested, necessitating formal process to obtain inspection.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent's position was that the arbitrator sent the award by registered post with acknowledgment due on 8 August 2008 and the envelope was returned with the postal endorsement "Not Claimed," which, the respondent argued, demonstrated that the postal authority had tendered the envelope at the petitioner's address but it was not accepted by the petitioner or its representative.
- The respondent argued that the endorsement "Not Claimed" amounts to effective service and that presumption of service arises under provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act (the opinion refers to sub-section (5) of section 31 and clauses of section 3) and under section 27 of the General Clauses Act; the onus to rebut such presumptions is on the sendee.
- The respondent pointed to the fact that subsequent letters and correspondence were received by the petitioner at the same office address (193 Maharshi Devendra Road), and that the petitioner never alleged a change of address or office closure, supporting the inference that the registered post was correctly addressed and tendered.
- The respondent relied on several authorities (including a Division Bench decision in Arun Banerjee & Ors. v. Baidya Nath Mullick & Ors. and the three-Judge Bench decision in C.C. Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed) for the proposition that return with endorsement "Not Claimed" can be treated as good service and that the sendee bears the burden to prove non-service.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Arun Banerjee & Ors. v. Baidya Nath Mullick & Ors., 2008 (3) Calcutta Law Times (High Court) 338 | The Division Bench held that a notice sent by registered post with A/D returned with endorsement "Not Claimed" is tantamount to good service. | The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that "Not Claimed" can amount to effective service and to conclude that the award was served on 8 August 2008. |
| C.C. Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed, 2007 (6) SCC 555 (Three-Judge Bench) | The Court explained that where a sender dispatches notice by post to a correct address, the principle in section 27 of the General Clauses Act could be applied and service is deemed unless the sendee proves non-service; it placed onus on the sendee to prove that the envelope was not really served. | The Court treated the Alavi Haji principle as authoritative and held that the petitioner (sendee) did not discharge the onus of proving non-service; this supported the conclusion that the award was served on 8 August 2008. |
| D. Vinod Shivappa v. Nanda Belliappa, 2006 (6) SCC 456 | The opinion cites this decision as one relied upon by the petitioner, but the Three-Judge Bench in C.C. Alavi Haji expressed doubts about the Division Bench judgment in this case and referred it to a larger Bench. | The Court noted that the Alavi Haji judgment raised doubt about this decision and therefore treated it as of limited precedential value in the present reasoning. |
| Air 1999 Supreme Court 3762 | The opinion cites this Supreme Court report (citation given) but does not specify in the text the precise rule or principle taken from it. | The opinion records the citation as relied upon by the respondent's counsel but does not describe a specific application of this report beyond general support for presumptions of service. |
| 2005 (4) SCC 239 | Cited by the petitioner (citation given) — the text does not specify the principle quoted from this report. | The petitioner's counsel cited this decision in support of the contention that limitation runs from actual receipt; the Court's summary does not identify a distinct application beyond noting the citation. |
| 1956 (1) All India Reporter 670 | Cited by the petitioner; the opinion does not state the specific principle referenced from this older report. | No discrete application described in the opinion beyond inclusion in counsel's list of cited authorities. |
| 2001 (2) Maharastra Law Journal 342 | Cited by the petitioner; the opinion does not specify the legal principle taken from this report. | No separate application described; included among petitioner's citations. |
| 2009 (2) Calcutta High Court Notes 578 | Cited by the respondent; the opinion does not elaborate the precise holding referenced. | The citation was relied on by respondent's counsel as supportive authority; the Court did not separately analyse this note in the reasoning beyond referencing similar authorities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's reasoning proceeded from the established facts in the record and the statutory presumptions and authorities cited by the parties:
- It was an uncontested fact that the petitioner carried on business at 193 Maharshi Devendra Road, Kolkata-6, and that subsequent correspondence addressed to that office had been received by the petitioner at that same address. The petitioner did not contend that the office address had changed or was closed.
- The learned Arbitrator had sent the award in an envelope by registered post with acknowledgment due on 8 August 2008; that envelope was returned with the postal endorsement "Not Claimed." The envelope was sufficiently stamped.
- The Court considered binding authority, notably the Division Bench decision in Arun Banerjee and the Three-Judge Bench decision in C.C. Alavi Haji. The Alavi Haji judgment (2007 (6) SCC 555) was analysed by the Court as holding that when a sender dispatches notice by post to a correct address, the principle in section 27 of the General Clauses Act may be imported and service is deemed effected unless the sendee proves non-service; the onus to rebut the presumption of service lies on the sendee.
- The Court observed that the petitioner (as sendee) did not discharge the onus to prove that the envelope was not really served or that the petitioner was not responsible for non-service. Mere denial without supporting proof was insufficient to rebut the presumption.
- Given these considerations, the Court concluded that the postal endorsement "Not Claimed" amounted to good service. Consequently, the date of service of the award was treated as 8 August 2008, and limitation for filing under Section 34 commenced from that date.
- On the basis that the Section 34 petition was filed on 9 September 2010 and limitation had therefore expired, the Court found the petition barred by limitation under sub-section (3) of section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and dismissed it.
- The Court also refused the petitioner's subsequent prayer for a stay and directed parties to act on a certified photostat copy of the judgment and order on usual undertakings.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED. The Section 34 petition challenging the arbitral award dated 5 August 2008 was dismissed as barred by limitation.
Implications (direct): The Court held that the award was served on the petitioner on 8 August 2008 by virtue of the registered post sent by the arbitrator which was returned with the postal endorsement "Not Claimed." Because the petitioner did not rebut the presumption of service, the limitation period under sub-section (3) of section 34 commenced from 8 August 2008 and the application filed on 9 September 2010 was time-barred. The petitioner's request for a stay was refused. Parties were directed to act on a certified photostat copy of the judgment.
Broader implications: The opinion relied on existing statutory presumptions and precedent (notably C.C. Alavi Haji and the Division Bench decision in Arun Banerjee) to treat "Not Claimed" on registered post as amounting to effective service absent proof to the contrary. The Court did not state that it was laying down a new principle; it applied the cited authorities to the facts at hand.
Ashoke Kumar Dasadhikari, J.:— The petitioner New Globe Transport Company moved this petition under section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging the award dated 5th August, 2008 passed by the learned Arbitrator.
2. Petitioner's case is that they were in transportation business and was in need of finance for purchasing a Tata Truck. They approached the representative of the respondent, Magma Shrachi Finance Limited, a company under Companies Act, 1956. The respondent's representative offered to finance a sum of Rs. 11 lakhs to be repaid in 46 installments at the rate of Rs. 29,810 except for first amounting to Rs. 10,000 commencing from 1st February, 2007 and expiring on 1st December, 2010. The petitioner agreed to the terms and conditions of the respondent company and entered into a hire purchase agreement with them upon signing the documents and papers. The petitioner was also called upon to have said agreement signed by a person known to him who would stand as a guarantor for advancing of the said finance amount and the petitioner did it. Petitioner, thereafter, paid 5 installments on due dates. On 4th July, 2007, the driver of the vehicle being No. WB 23B 1768 loaded with various goods parked the vehicle at a petrol pump situated on NH6 under police station Liluah, District Howrah and had gone to take food at a near by Dhaba. After coming back at about 21.30 hours he did not find the truck. The driver immediately reported the matter to the petitioner who instructed his Manager Rama Shankar Shaw to lodge a complaint immediately. On the same day at 22.25 hours a written complaints as FIR was lodge to the Officer in Charge Liluah Police Station, District Howrah and a case was started being No. 106/2007 under section 379 of the Indian Penal Code. On 4th July, 2007, the petitioner issued a letter to the respondent company informing them that the said vehicle has been stolen on 4th July, 2007, for which complaint has also been lodged with Liluah Police Station. A copy of the FIR was also forwarded to the respondent.
3. Since the truck was insured under National Insurance Company through the insurance cell of the respondent company the petitioner after collecting all officer forms and documents to be filled in for making insurance claim, send the same to the respondents as per their instruction and handed over all documents to the representative of the respondent in connection with pursuing the insurance claim. The Insurance Company appointed a surveyor for enquiring and submission of survey report with regard to the loss suffer by the petitioner. A copy of the letter issued by insurance company on 13th July, 2007 was also forwarded to the respondent. On 30th August, 2007 petitioner also informed the respondent that since the vehicle is not traceable and it has been stolen for which necessary complaint has been lodged and the matter has been reported in the insurance company, it will not be possible for the petitioners to go on paying monthly installments. In the meantime the criminal case which was registered by the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate of Hawrah under section 379 of the Indian Penal Code ended with the final report filed under section 173 of Code of Criminal Procedure specifying therein that no fruitful result was achieved for recovery of lost truck with goods. The orders passed by the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate in theft case from Liluah PS case No. 106 of 2007 along with the final report was sent to the respondent and one Santanu Bhattacharya, representative of the respondent received the same. Several correspondence as regards clarification and other formalities were made with the insurance company which according to the petitioner, was duly communicated to the respondent company.
4. On 9th July, 2010, the petitioner received a letter dated 30th July, 2010, issued by the advocate of the respondent informing that the impugned award has been passed on 5th August, 2008, and a copy whereof were served under cover letter dated 8th August, 2008, written by Sri Pulin Behari Das arbitrator. By the said letter copy of the alleged award was again enclose for the petitioner's reference. It was alleged that the said award has became a decree and since the petitioner have not complied with the directions contain in the award, a sum of Rs. 12,51,573 has became due. The said advocate for the respondent has called upon the petitioner to make payment of the said amount within a period of seven days. Petitioner was shocked and surprised to note the contents of the said letter as to the petitioner's knowledge no award was ever served upon the petitioner nor was the petitioner aware that any proceeding was conducted before publication such alleged award, petitioner thereafter contacted his advocate and ascertained from their records that no such copy of award was received. It was contended by the petitioner that the said award was received by the advocates for the first time on 9th July, 2010, when he received the letter dated 30th June, 2010, along with his enclosures thereto.
5. On 8th August, 2010, your petitioner again received by post a letter dated 31st July, 2010, issued by the advocates for the respondent enclosing therewith a copy of the Tabular statement along with copy of the supporting affidavit and the order dated 27th July, 2010, passed by Hon'ble Justice Sanjib Banerjee. From the copy of the execution application filed by the respondent, the petitioner found the annexed envelope addressed to the petitioner allegedly forwarding the award which shows that the envelop has returned with endorsement ‘Not Claimed’. Since the said copies are Xerox copies and as the petitioner could not understand the same, the petitioner by a letter dated 16th August, 2010 called upon the learned arbitrator to provide for inspection of the said documents and the said letter was served by hand but surprisingly the Arbitrator refused to accept and hence the petitioner was constrained to send the same by speed post with acknowledgment due on 17th August, 2010. It appears from the said award the learned Arbitrator allowed the claim of the respondent to the tune of Rs. 12,51,573/- along with interest at the rate of 24 per cent per annum.
6. The petitioners thereafter filed this application challenging the said award. The application was moved on 9th September, 2010, and the following order was passed :—
“The Court: This is a section 34 application. The award was made and published on 5th August, 2008. Prima facie this application is barred by limitation. However, that question has to be gone into before this application is admitted.
Affidavit-in-opposition is to be filed by 22nd September, 2010. List this application on 30th September, 2010. Affidavit-in-reply may be filed in the meantime.
All parties concerned are to act on a signed photocopy of this order upon the usual undertakings.”
7. As per the order passed on 9th September, 2010, affidavits were exchanged and matter was heard. Mr. Ritobrata Mitra learned Advocate for the petitioner submitted that his client for the first time on 9th July, 2010 came to know about the award only upon receipt of the letter dated 30th June, 2010. He referred paragraph 6 of the affidavit-in-opposition affirm by one Moni Mala Dey being constituted attorney of respondent company and he pointed out that the respondent company came to know from the learned arbitrator that the award was duly sent by him to the petitioner by register post with acknowledgment due card on 8th August, 2008. The envelop containing the arbitral award dated 5th August, 2008, passed by Shri Pulin Behari Das learned Arbitrator was returned to the learned Arbitrator with the postal endorsement ‘Not Claimed’. In view of such endorsement by the postman on the said envelop it is not proved that the award was served. Under no circumstances it could be a good service and if at all there be any presumption such presumption is rebuttable. His client has denied that any service of the said award was made upon them. Upon receipt of the said letter dated 30th June, 2010 annexing the copy of the award on 9th July, 2010 the petitioner came to know about the impugned award and by their letter dated 16th August, 2010 requested the learned Arbitrator to allow inspection of the original A/D card along with all records sent by the Arbitrator at his office at his convenient date and time. However, no reply was received by the petitioners from the learned Arbitrator and thereafter they have filed this petition challenging the impugned award and they are well within time and under no circumstances it could be said that this petition was barred by limitation under sub-section (3) of section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Mr. Mitra learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners cited some judgment to justify his contention that the award must be received by the petitioners unless the award is delivered and received by the petitioners the limitation do not start. Mr. Mitra cited the following decisions :—
1. 2005 volume 4 Supreme Court Cases Page 239.
2. 2006 volume 6 Supreme Court Cases Page 456.
3. 1956 volume 1 All India Report, Page 670.
4. 2001 volume 2 Maharastra Law Journal, Page 342.
He submitted further that Arbitral Tribunal to prove that the award was served and the onus is on the Arbitral Tribunal and his clients denied that the award was ever served before 9th July, 2010, when the petitioners received the letter dated 30th June, 2010, annexing a copy of the award dated 5th August, 2008. And the limitation should run from that date and if it is calculated from 9th July, 2010, then this application is within time.
8. Learned Counsel for the respondent Mr. Mainak Bose submitted that the award was sent by the learned Arbitrator to the petitioner under register post with acknowledgment card on 8th August, 2008 and the said envelop containing the Arbitral award dated 5th August, 2008 passed by Shri Pulin Behari Das learned Arbitrator was returned to the learned Arbitrator with postal endorsement ‘Not Claimed’ and this shows that the envelop containing the Arbitral award was offered by the postal peon at the office of the petitioners at 193 Moharshi Devendra Road, Kolkata-6, Post Office Beadon Street wherefrom the petitioner is carryon his business but the petitioner or their representative was not inclined to receive the said envelop and acknowledge and as such the envelop containing the award have comeback with an endorsement ‘Not Claimed’ and this is a good service and the limitation starts on and from 8th August, 2008, the date when the envelop was sent by the learned Arbitrator to the petitioner by register post with acknowledgment due card. He referred the provision under sub-section (5) of section 31 and clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 3 and sub-section (2) of section 3 and contended presumption of service is there, which is in favour of his client, the respondent herein. He said the address of the petitioner is the same as before and it is never changed and the petitioner is running their business from that address at 193 Moharshi Devendra Road, Kolkata-6. It was not the case of the petitioner that they were not running their business from that place or the envelop sent under register post at 193 Moharshi Devendra Road, Kolkata-6 is a wrong address, therefore, the endorsement on the envelop ‘Not Claimed’ shows good service of the award dated 5th August, 2010 and the presumption of service which is factual one is in their favour which need no further prove either. It was contended that when the petitioner received all subsequent letters and documents at the same address in their office at 193 Moharshi Devendra Road, Kolkata-6, but they refused to receive the said envelop sent by the learned Arbitrator on 8th August, 2008 and accordingly 120 days from that date has long expired and this petition is barred by limitation and should be rejected. He also submits that in spite of the fact the petitioner received the letter dated 30th June 2010, on 9th July, 2010, they took more than a month to write a letter to the learned Arbitrator asking inspection and the date of the letter written by the learned Advocate on behalf of the petitioner's is 16th August, 2010. He also submitted that after the award was passed the learned Arbitrator is functus officio and the endorsement on that envelop ‘Not Claimed’ is sufficient evidence to prove that the award has been served and, in fact, the postal peon tendered the said envelop to the petitioner at the noted address and the petitioner or his representative deliberately and intentionally did not accept the same which amounts good service and it should be presumed as delivered under section 3 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act of 1996 and accordingly this petition is barred by limitation and the same should be rejected.
9. Mr. Bose referred section 27 of the General Clauses Act and submitted that the legal presumption is also in his favour of the respondent. Under no circumstances by a bare denial the same can be rebutted. Mr. Bose cited the following the decisions :—
1. AIR 1999 Supreme Court 3762,
2. 2007 volume 6 Supreme Court Cases Page 555,
3. 2009 volume 2 Calcutta High Court Notes, Page 578,
4. 2008 volume 3 Calcutta Law Times, Page 338.
10. In reply Mr. Mitra submitted that none of the aforementioned judgments is applicable in the instant case of the petitions.
11. I have gone through the pleadings of the respective parties as well as the materials on record and have considered the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the respective parties. It is on record that the petitioner is running his transport business from 193 Moharshi Devendra Road, P.S Jorabagan, Kolkata-6. The learned Arbitrator sent the award in an envelop by register post with acknowledgment due card on 8th August, 2008 which returned with postal endorsement ‘Not Claimed’. The envelop is sufficiently stamped. The petitioner is receiving letters and correspondences at the said address and it was not case of the petitioner that the office was closed or for any other reason the envelop was not received by their office. Subsequent letters and correspondences all were received from the same address. Accordingly there should not be any doubt to presume that the envelop which was sent at the office of the petitioner, was in fact tendered by the postman at the same address but the same has not been accepted. Mr. Bose cited a judgment deliver by the Division Bench of this Hon'ble High Court in case of Arun Banerjee & Ors.… v. Baidya Nath Mullick & Ors.… reported in 2008 volume 3 Calcutta Law Times High Court 338 wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench have held that “The notice was sent on behalf of the plaintiffs to the original defendant under registered post with A/D and the same was returned with the postal endorsement ‘Not Claimed’, which is tantamount to a good service. The notice itself has validly terminated his tenancy with the end of the month of May, 1979 and the same appears to be legal, valid and sufficient.”
12. The other judgment delivered by three-Judges Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in case of (C.C Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed) reported in 2007 Volume 6 Supreme Court Cases Page- 555 have held as follows :—
“Since in Bhaskaran case the notice issued in terms of clause (b) had been returned unclaimed and not as refused, the Court posed the question: “Will there be any significant difference between the two so far as the presumption of service is concerned?” It was observed that though section 138 of the Act does not require that the notice should be given only by “post”, yet in a case where the sender has dispatched the notice by post with correct address written on it, the principle incorporated in section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 (for short “the GC Act”) could profitably be imported in such a case. It was held that in this situation service of notice is deemed to have been effected on the sendee unless he proves that it was not really served and that he was not responsible for such non-service.”
13. In the aforesaid judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court have raised doubt about the judgment of the Division Bench decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court cited by Mr. Mitra (D. Vinod Shivappa v. Nanda Belliappa) reported in 2006 Volume 6 SCC page-456) and referred the same to larger Bench, since the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while delivering the judgment, has not taken into consideration the presumption in respect of an official Act as provided under section 114 of the Evidence Act, 1872.
14. In Paragraph 8 of (C.C Alavi Haji v. Palapetty Muhammed) (supra) it was held that the onus of the sendee to prove that the envelop was not really served and that he was not responsible for such non-service. The petitioner in the present case being the sendee did not prove that the envelop was not served and he was not responsible for such non-service and therefore, there is no rebuttal to the presumption of service.
15. In the aforesaid circumstances, in my opinion, the word ‘Not Claimed’ tantamount to good service and accordingly the award was served upon the petitioner on 8th August, 2008 and, therefore, the petition is barred by limitation under sub-section (3) of section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act of 1996 and as such the same is dismissed.
16. After the judgment was delivered the learned Advocate for the petitioner prays for stay. Such prayer is refused.
17. All parties to act on a Photostat certified copy of these judgment and order on the usual undertakings.
A.D
Alert