Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anjali Metia & Ors. v. West Bengal State Electricity Board & Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Aug 9, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges an order by the learned Single Judge directing the West Bengal State Electricity Board to supply electricity to a portion of a house occupied by the petitioner. The petitioner had applied for an electric connection for the house he occupied but was denied by the Board. The petitioner's mother and two married sisters, who objected to the grant of the connection, were joined as respondents. The house originally belonged to the petitioner's deceased father, Aditya Ranjan Biswas, but was shown in the name of the mother, who allegedly acted as a benamidar. After the father's death, the mother gifted the house to her two daughters, the respondents herein, who resided there with her. The petitioner forcibly occupied a portion of the house against the wishes of the mother and sisters, leading to police intervention and an Executive Magistrate's order for status quo under section 144(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The electricity connection was previously in the mother’s name, transferred to one sister, and subsequently disconnected upon her request. The petitioner applied for a fresh connection in 2004, which was refused by the Board pending proof of possession or right.

The petitioner had also filed a title suit claiming a one-fifth share of the house on the basis that the mother was a benamidar and that he inherited the property by law. This suit was dismissed on the ground that the plea of benami transaction was not tenable in such a suit. The appeal against the dismissal was not pending, only a delay condonation application remained undecided. The learned Single Judge granted the petitioner’s writ petition without addressing these factual and legal complexities.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner qualifies as an occupier within the meaning of section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003, entitling him to an electricity connection.
  2. Whether a person who is a trespasser can claim the right to electricity supply under section 43 of the Electricity Act.
  3. The correctness of the Single Judge’s order directing the Board to supply electricity without examining the petitioner’s lawful possession or right over the premises.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner claimed that the house was constructed from his father's income but held in his mother’s name as a benamidar.
  • He alleged that after his father’s death, he returned to occupy the house, asserting a right to a one-fifth share as per Dayabhaga law.
  • The petitioner contended that the transfer of the house to the mother’s daughters was fraudulent.
  • He applied for an electricity connection on the basis of his occupation of the premises.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The mother and sisters objected to the grant of electricity connection to the petitioner, asserting ownership and possession.
  • The electricity connection was previously in the mother’s name and transferred legally to one sister, who paid all charges and requested disconnection.
  • They relied on police reports and an Executive Magistrate’s order maintaining status quo to oppose the petitioner’s occupation.

West Bengal State Electricity Board’s Position

  • The Board refused to grant the connection to the petitioner without proof of lawful possession or right.
  • Issued instructions to the Station Manager not to effect service connection in the petitioner’s name.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Section 144(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Power of Executive Magistrate to order status quo in cases of dispute or potential breach of peace. Used to maintain status quo regarding occupation of the premises after police report and petition by respondent.
Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003 Right to supply electricity to the occupier of premises. The Single Judge directed supply of electricity to petitioner on the basis of occupation, but this was found to be incomplete without determining lawful occupation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified that the learned Single Judge failed to consider critical factual and legal aspects before directing the electricity supply. The Judge did not address whether the petitioner was lawfully an occupier under section 43 of the Electricity Act. The Court emphasized that a trespasser cannot claim rights as an occupier and thus cannot demand electricity supply under the statute. It noted the petitioner’s title suit was dismissed and no appeal was pending, indicating lack of prima facie lawful possession. The Court underscored the necessity to examine the petitioner’s right or possession before granting electricity connection. Accordingly, the matter was remanded for a detailed examination with directions for the parties to file affidavits and for expeditious disposal within six months.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the appeal and set aside the Single Judge’s order directing the electricity connection to the petitioner. The case was remanded to the learned Single Judge for reconsideration on the basis of full facts and law, specifically whether the petitioner qualifies as an occupier entitled to electricity supply under section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003.

The direct consequence is that no order for electricity supply shall stand until the remand proceedings are completed. The Court did not impose any costs and did not lay down any new legal precedent, restricting the implications to the parties involved.

Show all summary ...

V.S Sirpurkar, C.J:— This appeal is against an order by the learned Single Judge who, while disposing of the writ petition directed the West Bengal State Electricity Board to supply the electricity at the portion of the premises under the occupation of the petitioner. The petitioner had come up before this Court on the ground that though he had applied for the electric connection in respect of the house which he had occupied, he was not being granted that connection by the Board.

2. The learned Judge has simply directed the Board to supply the connection and has made further observation that the supply of electricity to the petitioner would not create any right in favour of the petitioner nor would it be to the prejudice and interest of the private respondents. It is to be seen that in this writ petition, the petitioner's mother and two married sisters are joined as respondents because they had raised an objection to the grant of electricity connection.

3. The petitioner is the son of one Aditya Ranjan Biswas. He has one brother and two married sisters, viz., Bijoli Manna and Anjali Metia. His mother Atashi Rani Biswas is still living. What transpires from the affidavit-in-opposition which was filed before the learned Judge as also from the other documents is that the father of the petitioner Aditya Ranjan Biswas died and before that he was living in a house which was constructed somewhere in the year 1961. The petitioner claimed that this house was constructed from the income of his father, but his father showed the same to be in the name of his mother. In short his plea was that his mother was a benamidar. He contended that before the death of his father he had left the house for four years which fact he has stated in his letter to the Board. He further pleaded that after the death of the father he came back to the house. Now it transpires from the fact pleaded in the petition and also in the affidavit-in-opposition that the mother had gifted this house in favour of her two daughters, the respondents herein and that throughout it is only those two married sisters who looked after the mother. The mother seems to have gifted this house on 6th September, 1994 after the death of the father of the petitioner and, thereafter, the two sisters and the mother were residing in the house. There is a report on the record made to the police that after the death of the father while the three ladies were residing, the petitioner forced his entry into the house and started occupying the portion of the house. On that basis there appears to be an entry in the general diary of the police station. There also appears on record an order dated 7 April, 2005 passed by the Executive Magistrate, Barrackpore in M.P No. 888 of 2005 which proceeding appears to have been instituted on the basis of the petition filed by Smt. Bijoli Manna, one of the appellants herein and the respondent in the writ petition. By this order the Executive Magistrate seems to have exercised his powers under section 144(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure and ordered status quo. It appears that the grant of electric connection was objected to by the private respondents as the existing meter to the concerned house was transferred in the name of Smt. Bijoli Manna. It also appears further that earlier this connection was in the name of the mother and with her consent the connection was transferred. It also further transpires that Smt. Bijoli Manna had paid all the electricity charges including the arrears and, thereafter, had applied to the Board for temporary disconnection. When the petitioner applied in 2004 for fresh connection, the house did not have any supply of electricity as on account of the request made by Smt. Bijoli Manna, the meter supply was disconnected.

4. It also appears that the West Bengal State Electricity Board by its communication dated 24 December, 2004 had sought from the proof of the nature of the possession and/or right of the petitioner. In fact during the debate the learned Counsel for the West Bengal State Electricity Board produced before us xerox copy of the letter dated 24 December, 2004 where clear instructions have been given to the Station Manager, Agarpara Sector, 24-Parganas (North) not to effect any service connection to the property in the name of Sri Debdas Biswas.

5. As if all this is not sufficient, there are documents on records to suggest that Shri Debdas Biswas filed a title suit being T.S No. 303 of 1995 in the Court of the 4th Munsif at Sealdah. This was a title suit claiming 1/5th portion of the house on the ground that the gift deed made by the mother was fraudulent document and the mother in fact was not the owner and she was a benamidar in respect of the house. This suit proceeded ex parte against the defendants, i.e the mother and the two sisters. However, that was dismissed by the learned Munsif on the ground that such a suit was not tenable as the plea of benarni transaction could not be raised in a suit which plea was the basis of the claim of the petitioner. The petitioner claimed that the mother had no right as she was a benamidar and, therefore, after the demise of his father he had inherited 1/5th portion as per the dayabhaga law.

6. In his writ petition very significantly the petitioner has mentioned in paragraph 9 as under:

“That after the death of the petitioner's father. Respondent No. 3 started to stay in the aforesaid premises. Previously also Anjali Metia used to stay at that premises to look after her old father and mother as because Debdas refuse to maintain his parents.”

It is, therefore, clear that the petitioner has strained relations with his mother and sister.

7. Unfortunately all these facts have not been referred to by the learned Judge in his order. The learned Judge seems to have proceeded on the basis that the petitioner was occupying the premises and, therefore, he was entitled to have the electricity connection perhaps on the basis of section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003. Even without discussing a single fact or a single document, the learned Judge has merely given the direction to the West Bengal State Electricity Board to start the electric supply by granting the application filed by the petitioner.

8. We are not, therefore, in a position to agree and uphold the judgment of the learned Single Judge. The learned Single Judge was bound to discuss and decide as to whether the petitioner could be in law termed to be an occupier within the meaning of section 43. A person cannot be allowed to take advantage of his own wrong. Therefore, the person who is a trespasser cannot by continuing his trespass claim the character of an occupier, and as such claim the rightful supply of electricity under section 43 of the Electricity Act. However, this question was not even addressed by the learned Judge. As if all this is not sufficient, the learned Judge should also have noted that the title suit filed by the petitioner for declaration of his 1/5 right in the property is dismissed and the appeal against the same is not pending. It is only a condontion of delay application which seems to have been pending before the Appellate Court and for the reasons known only to the parties and the Court, that application still remains undecided in spite of elapse of four years of its filing. Therefore, at least prima facie the petitioner did not produce any material either before the Board or before the learned Judge justifying his lawful occupation of the premises.

9. We are, therefore, constrained to set aside the judgment and remand the matter back to the learned Single Judge. Needless to mention that because of the setting aside of the judgment there will be no order on the Board to supply the electricity. The learned Judge to whom the matter is remanded is requested to dispose of the matter as early as possible and not beyond six months. The Board as also the parties would be allowed to file their affidavit-in-opposition and affidavit-in-reply before the learned Single Judge.

10. With this, the appeal is allowed but under the circumstances we do not inflict any cost.

11. Xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the learned Counsel for the parties.

Patherya, J.: I agree.

Appeal allowed.
A.D