- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shrikant Mantri & Ors. v. Radheshyam Chotia & Ors.
Judgment Summary — A.P.O No. 458 of 2005
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from an order dated 20 June 2005 passed by the First Court in G.A. No. 61 of 2005. Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 (appellants) in C.S. No. 232 of 1999 challenged that order. The plaintiffs/respondents were the original plaintiffs in the suit; respondent Nos. 3 and 4 correspond to defendant Nos. 5 and 6 in the suit.
The plaintiffs had filed the suit in April/May 1999 seeking leave under section 92 and under Order 1 Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Code, and sought reliefs including removal and appointment of trustees, framing of a management scheme, enquiry into trust funds, and monetary relief. In May 1999 plaintiffs filed interlocutory applications for injunction and to add parties; those interlocutory applications were pending.
In July 1999 the defendants/appellants moved an application seeking to take the plaint off the file (alleging that the leave granted under section 92 and Order I Rule 8 was granted on incorrect basis). That application was pending. The appellants later filed G.A. No. 61 of 2005 seeking rejection/taking off the plaint on the ground that the writ of summons had not been lodged with the Sheriff and remained unserved for about six years and that plaintiffs had not explained why the notice under Order 1 Rule 8 was not published within the stipulated time.
The plaintiffs/respondents filed G.A. No. 1286 of 2005 seeking extension of the returnable date of the writ of summons and condonation of delay. The First Court dismissed the defendants' G.A. No. 61 and allowed the plaintiffs' G.A. No. 1286 by order dated 20 June 2005. The present appeal (A.P.O No. 458 of 2005) challenges that order; another appeal (No. 459 of 2005) challenged allowance of G.A. No. 1286.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendants' application (G.A. No. 61 of 2005) to reject/take off the plaint and dismiss the suit for non-service of the writ of summons should be allowed.
- Whether the plaintiffs' application (G.A. No. 1286 of 2005) for extension of the returnable date of the writ of summons and condonation of delay should be allowed despite the writ remaining unserved for about six years.
- Whether the plaintiffs were estopped by an order dated 12 July 1999 from taking steps (such as issuance/service of the writ) pending disposal of the defendants' demurrer application or the plaintiffs' amendment application.
- Whether established rules under Order 9 Rule 5(1) CPC and related Original Side Rules permit extension/issuance of fresh writs after the prescribed period, or whether the defendants' accrued rights must be protected.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs / Respondents
- The plaintiffs contended they were estopped by the order dated 12 July 1999 from taking further steps in the suit until the defendants' demurrer was disposed of.
- The plaintiffs said they filed an application to amend the plaint on 8 February 2000 and expected to take out and serve summons for the amended plaint only after the demurrer and amendment applications were dealt with; thus service before disposal would serve no useful purpose.
- The plaintiffs asserted they bonafide believed their advocate-on-record would take all procedural steps and that issuance/service of writs is a routine departmental matter for which they were not obliged to supervise or give further instructions.
Defendants / Appellants
- The defendants argued the 12 July 1999 order did not restrain the plaintiffs from serving the writ of summons and that the plaintiffs' intention to amend the plaint did not justify continued non-service; plaintiffs could have served fresh writs after amendment.
- The defendants maintained a valuable right had accrued to them by reason of the plaintiffs' failure to take required procedural steps and that right could not be defeated.
- They contended the writ of summons remained unserved for about six years and no adequate explanation was given for the failure to publish notice or lodge writ with the Sheriff within prescribed time.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 61 CWN 212 — Laxmi Trading… v. Shriram Gobindnarain… | Where plaintiff fails to apply for issuance of fresh summons within the time prescribed (Order 9 Rule 5), the Master cannot entertain an application for extension or for fresh summons; the Court is bound to order dismissal — a valuable right accrues in favour of the defendant. | The court relied on this principle to hold that a valuable right had accrued to the defendants here because the plaintiffs did not take timely steps; this supported dismissal of the plaintiffs' extension application and allowing G.A. No. 61. |
| AIR 1979 Calcutta 8 — Electrical Industries Corporation v. Punjab National Bank | The Division Bench declined to invoke section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone delay where there was no satisfactory explanation about what occurred during the relevant period; Order 9 Rule 5(1) applies to Original Side absent specific provisions to the contrary. | The court invoked this authority to emphasise that absence of a proper explanation militates against condonation under the Limitation Act and that Original Side Rules do not displace Order 9 Rule 5(1); this weighed against granting extension. |
| 91 CWN 391 — Fort Gloster Industries Ltd. v. Tatanagar Transport Corpn. | Application for leave to lodge fresh writ and extension of returnable date was refused having regard to the facts and explanation offered. | The court cited this as an example where, given facts and inadequate explanation, extension was refused; it supported the conclusion that the plaintiffs' explanation here was insufficient. |
| 1992 (2) CHN 161 — State Bank of India v. Tarit Appliances (P) Ltd. | Court found defendants had not waived their right to be served in due course; considering Order 9 CPC and Original Side Rules, extension for issuance/delivery of writs was refused and suit dismissed against those defendants. | The court used this precedent to reinforce that defendants' service rights are not deemed waived and that failure to obtain extension can result in dismissal — supporting dismissal here. |
| Unreported — A.P.O.T No. 780 of 2002 (16 June 2004) — Deepak Prakash v. Jayanta Kumar Bose | There is no justification for granting a plaintiff unlimited time to issue writs beyond the time fixed by Original Side Rules; writs must be served within prescribed period and extension cannot exceed limitation. | The court relied on this unreported Division Bench view to underscore that plaintiffs cannot claim unlimited time and that rules prescribe service within definite time, bolstering the decision to deny extension. |
| Unreported order dated 13.09.2003 — Hindustan Motors Ltd. v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. | A Master cannot extend time for service of fresh summons without giving the petitioner an opportunity to be heard; such action would destroy the petitioner's valuable right. | The court cited this authority to stress procedural fairness and the protection of defendants' accrued rights when considering extensions; it influenced the court's insistence on adherence to procedural rules and protection of defendants' rights. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by examining the chronology and the parties' contentions, the effect of the 12 July 1999 order, and the plaintiffs' stated reasons for non-service (intention to amend the plaint, belief that the advocate-on-record would take routine steps, and that service before disposal of the demurrer/amendment applications would be futile).
Key analytical steps taken by the court:
- Recognition that it was admitted the defendants had knowledge of the suit and were contesting proceedings, yet they did not enter appearance; the First Court treated issuance/service as departmental steps ordinarily handled by the solicitor. The present court revisited that approach.
- Consideration of precedents interpreting Order 9 Rule 5(1) CPC and related Original Side Rules: the court treated those authorities as establishing that defendants acquire a valuable right when plaintiffs do not take timely steps to issue or serve summons, and that the Court should be reluctant to condone unexplained delay under the Limitation Act.
- Analysis of the plaintiffs' estoppel argument: the court found nothing in the 12 July 1999 order that estopped the plaintiffs from taking steps to issue or serve writs. The court rejected the proposition that filing an amendment application justified non-action on issuance/service for an extended period.
- Evaluation of the plaintiffs' reliance on their advocate-on-record: the court observed this defence was inconsistent with the plaintiffs' own assertion that service prior to disposal of demurrer/amendment would have served no useful purpose; therefore the plaintiffs could not shift responsibility to their advocate after having relied on the merits of non-service.
- Application of the cited authorities: the court found these authorities supported the proposition that absent cogent reasons for delay, a valuable right accrues to the defendants and relief by way of extension or fresh issuance should not be granted.
- Conclusion from facts and law: plaintiffs failed to take proper steps within the time prescribed by law and failed to provide proper and cogent reasons for their failure; consequently the defendants' application for dismissal (G.A. No. 61) should have been allowed and the plaintiffs' application for extension (G.A. No. 1286) should have been dismissed.
The court noted that even if the writ was served on 8 July 2005 (as claimed in an application for stay), that fact was irrelevant because the plaintiffs had already failed to act within the periods required by law and had not given adequate explanation for the delay.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court allowed A.P.O No. 458 of 2005, set aside the Order dated 20 June 2005 passed by the First Court, allowed the defendants' application being G.A. No. 61 of 2005, and dismissed the plaintiffs' application being G.A. No. 1286 of 2005. In substance, the suit was ordered to be dismissed for non-service of the writ of summons. There is no order as to costs.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The plaintiffs' extension request was dismissed and the defendants' application to take the plaint off the file / dismiss the suit for non-service succeeded; the challenged order of 20 June 2005 is set aside.
- Procedural principle reinforced: adherence to the time limits and procedural requirements for issuing and serving writs (including the protective effect of Order 9 Rule 5(1) CPC and related Original Side Rules) is mandatory; failure to provide cogent reasons for delay can result in dismissal and defendants' accrued rights are protected.
- No new legal precedent was stated by the court; the decision applies authorities cited to the facts and enforces existing rules rather than establishing a novel principle.
This summary is confined to, and strictly derived from, the information contained in the provided opinion. No facts or holdings beyond those expressly stated in the opinion have been added.
JUDGMENT
T.K Dutt, J.:— Heard the learned advocates for the respective parties. The defendant Nos. 1 to 4 in a suit being C.S No. 232 of 1999 have preferred this appeal challenging an order dated June 20, 2005 passed by the Hon'ble First Court in G.A No. 61 of 2005. The respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are the plaintiffs in the suit and the respondent Nos. 3 and 4 are the defendant Nos. 5 and 6 in the suit.
2. The plaintiffs/respondents filed the suit claiming leave under section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure and also under Order 1 Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiffs/respondents prayed inter alia for a decree for removal of the defendants/appellants as trustees of a certain Smt. Kamla Devi Mantri Charity Trust and for appointment of fit and proper persons as trustees, framing of a scheme for the purpose of proper management and administration of the trust and for enquiry into the funds and accounts standing in the name of the trustees and a decree for a certain sum of money with interest etc. It appears that sometime in May 1999, the plaintiffs moved an interlocutory application for injunction for restraining the defendants/appellants from dealing with the shares which were subject of the Trust Fund and the plaintiffs/respondents also filed an application for adding certain parties as party defendants in the suit. Both the said applications are pending hearing. The defendants/appellants, on coming to know of such proceedings, sometime in July 1999, moved an application for taking the plaint off the file alleging that the leave granted under section 92 and Order I Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Code was granted on an incorrect basis and such leave is liable to be revoked and that on such application an order was passed sometime in July 1999 directing inter alia that the suit not be transferred to the undefended list. The said application is also pending hearing. The appellants/petitioners have alleged in their application being G.A No. 61 of 2005 that on enquiry it transpired that the suit was filed by the plaintiffs/respondents on 12th April, 1999 and till the filing of the said application no Writ of Summons was lodged with the Sheriff. According to the defendants/appellants, the plaintiffs/respondents have no real intention to prosecute the suit and the suit has been filed with an ulterior purpose and as such the suit be dismissed. The defendants/appellants made the aforesaid application being G.A No. 61 of 2005 praying inter alia that the plaint in the said suit be rejected and taken off the file. According to the defendants/appellants the writ of summons remained un-served for 6 years and no explanation was given why the notice in terms of leave granted under Order 1 Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure could not be published in newspapers within the stipulated time or at any time thereafter.
3. The plaintiffs/respondents made an application being G.A No. 1286 of 2005 for extension of the returnable date of the writ of summons and condonation of delay in making the application. The said G.A No. 61 of 2005 and G.A No. 1286 of 2005 were taken up for hearing by the Hon'ble First Court and by the Order dated June 20, 2005 the Hon'ble First Court was pleased to dismiss the defendants/appellants application being G.A No. 61 of 2005 and was pleased to allow the plaintiffs/respondents application being G.A No. 1286 of 2005. This appeal has been filed for dismissal of the defendants/appellants application being G.A No. 61 of 2005. Another appeal being No. 459 of 2005 has been filed by the defendants/appellants challenging the order by which the Hon'ble First Court allowed the G.A No. 1286 of 2005.
4. Both the appeals have been taken up for hearing together since both the appeals arise out of a common Judgment.
5. It appears that by the Judgment which is under consideration in this appeal the Hon'ble First Court found that in the instant case it is an admitted position that the defendants/appellants herein had knowledge of the filing of the suit as they have been contesting the proceedings but did not enter appearance in the suit. The Hon'ble First Court was also pleased to observe that it is apparent that the parties have been contesting the matters before the interlocutory Court and since a demurer application has been taken out it is required to be adjudicated first before the suit was proceeded with. The Hon'ble First Court was of the view that steps for causing the service of the writ of summons are really departmental steps and are normally taken by the Solicitor and/or their Clerks concerned and it is expected that a client after having entrusted the matter to an advocate need not pursue day to day in the matter of lodging of writ of summons and causing summons to be served by the department. The Hon'ble First Court was also of the view that the whole object and purpose of service of writ of summons is to notify the defendant about the filing of the suit so that it is not decreed without any knowledge of the defendants. Taking such view, the Hon'ble First Court was pleased to reject the defendants/appellants application and allow the plaintiffs/respondents application. It appears that the plaintiffs/respondents have served the writ of summons on the appellants/petitioners on July 8, 2005 as has been stated in the application for Stay filed by the appellants/petitioners.
6. In course of argument certain decisions were cited at the Bar:
(1) 61 CWN 212 (Laxmi Trading… v. Shriram Gobindnarain….). In this reported case the writ of summons was returned, unserved and there was a failure on the part of the plaintiff to make an application for issue of fresh summons within the period then prescribed under Order 9 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiff filed the application for issuance of fresh summons after the period of 3 months, which was then prescribed under Order 9 Rule 5 CPC, had already expired. The learned Master disposed of the application by saying that it has been presented after the expiry of time limit of 3 months and as such he could not make any order on such application. The plaintiff then presented the petition to an Hon'ble single Judge of this Court but failed to obtain any relief and thereafter an appeal was preferred. The Hon'ble Appeal Court was pleased to observe that failure of the plaintiff to make any application for issue of fresh summons within the prescribed period resulted in a valuable right being accrued in favour of the defendant. The Hon'ble Appeal Court concluded by holding that—
“It is clear from the terms of the Rule to which I have just referred, that where the plaintiff has not made an application for the issue of a fresh summons within three months, nor has made an application within that period for an extension of time, the Master can no longer entertain an application for such extension, far less an application for the issue of a fresh summons and that in the situation which arises, the Court will be bound to make an order that the suit be dismissed. The learned Master, therefore, was entirely right in the present case in refusing to make any order on the appellant's application and the learned Judge's order appealed from is also right.
For the reasons given above, this appeal is dismissed, but as there is no respondent, there will be no order for costs.”
(2) AIR 1979 Calcutta 8 (Electrical Industries Corporation v. Punjab National Bank). In this reported case there was no dispute that the plaintiff failed to take any of the steps envisaged by Order 9 Rule 5(1) of the Civil Procedure Code within the specified period. In the said case it was argued before the Hon'ble Division Bench that the Court should invoke the provision of section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone the delay in making the application for issue of a fresh summons. The Hon'ble Division Bench was pleased not to exercise the powers under section 5 of the Limitation Act in absence of any explanation as to what happened during a vital period as indicated in the said reported case. It appears that an alternative argument was advanced before the Hon'ble Division Bench by submitting that Order 9 Rule 5(1) of the Civil Procedure Code could not apply to the said case in view of the provisions of Rules 6 and 8 of Chapter (VIII) of the Original Side Rules. The Hon'ble Division Bench was pleased to observe that there is no substance in such alternative argument and that Rules 6 and 8 of Chapter (VIII) of the Original Side Rules do not in any way affect or alter the provisions of Order 9 Rule 5(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure and that said provision [Order 9 Rule 5(1) CPC] in absence of specific provisions in the Original Side Rules, applies to the Original Side as well.
(3) 91 CWN 391 (Fort Gloster Industries Ltd. v. Tatanagar Transport Corpn.). In the said case the application which came up for consideration before the Hon'ble single Judge was an application for leave to lodge fresh writ of summons for service upon the defendant and also for extension of returnable date of the writ. The Hon'ble single Judge was pleased to hold ultimately that having regard to the facts of the said case and the explanation given in the said case, the Hon'ble Court did not find any reason to extend the time for lodging a fresh writ of summons with the Sheriff. Accordingly the said application in the said case was dismissed.
(4) 1992 (2) CHN 161 (State Bank of India v. Tarit Appliances(P) Ltd.). In the said reported case the Hon'ble single Judge was pleased to find that it did not appear from the records of that case that the defendants concerned in the suit had waived their right to be served with the writ of summons in the suit in due course. The relevant provisions of Order 9 CPC and the relevant Rules of Chapter VIII of the Original Side Rules came up for consideration before the Hon'ble single Judge and his Lordship after considering the facts and circumstances of the said case and the relevant provisions of law was pleased to dismiss the application filed by the plaintiff in the said suit for extending the time for issuance of writ of summons and also for taking out and delivering the same to the Sheriff's Office for service upon the defendants. The Hon'ble Court was pleased to allow the application of the concerned defendants by holding that the suit against the two defendants concerned shall stand dismissed.
(5) An unreported case disposed of by an Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court on 16th June, 2004 in A.P.O.T No. 780 of 2002 (Deepak Prakash v. Jayanta Kumar Bose). In the said unreported case the Hon'ble Division Bench was pleased to observe that the said Division Bench saw no reason why the plaintiff should get an unlimited time for issuance of writ of summons when in accordance with Rules of the Original Side it has to be done within fourteen days from the date of institution of the suit. The Division Bench was further pleased to observe that there are enough indications in the Civil Procedure Code and also in the Original Side Rules of this Court that the writ of summons have to be served upon the defendant within a prescribed period and their right to apply for extension of time to serve the writ of summons cannot extend beyond the period of limitation.
(6) An unreported case (order dated 13.09.2003 passed by an Hon'ble single Judge in G.A No. 728 of 2003. G.A No. 3820 of 2002 and C.S No. 577 of 1987 in Hindustan Motors Limited v. National Insurance Company Ltd.). In the said unreported case the Hon'ble single Judge was pleased to hold that the learned Master cannot extend the time for service of the fresh summons without giving an opportunity to the petitioner of being heard, since such action of the Master destroys the valuable right of the petitioner. It appears that in the said unreported case the Hon'ble single Judge was also pleased to consider the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Code and the Original Side Rules in this regard.
7. It appears that the instant suit was filed by the plaintiff/respondent sometime in May 1999. The plaintiff's case in the application being G.A No. 1286 of 2005 was that by virtue of the Order dated 12th July, 1999 passed by the Hon'ble single Judge, the plaintiffs were estopped from taking any further steps in the suit at least till such time the demurer application of the defendants was disposed of. It further appears from the said application that the plaintiffs subsequently made an application for amendment of the plaint and the said application was moved on 8th February, 2000 but the hearing of the said application has been adjourned till after the disposal of the defendants' demurer application. The plaintiffs have stated in their application that the plaintiffs intended to have the plaint in the suit amended and summons taken out for the amended plaint and thereafter have it served upon the defendants and that service of the writ of summons prior to the disposal of defendants' demurer application and prior to the hearing of the amendment application filed by the plaintiffs will serve no useful purpose. The plaintiffs/respondents have also alleged that the plaintiffs bonafide believed and also expected that their learned advocate will do all things needful in the suit and that issuance and the service of writ of summons is entirely procedural and routine matter for which no instructions were necessary from the plaintiff/respondent and the same was the responsibility of the learned advocate-on-Record and that the plaintiffs/respondents were also not under any obligation to find out if their learned advocate-on-Record has taken proper steps in the matter, particularly those which are procedural and are of routine nature.
8. The defendants/appellants have taken the stand in their application being G.A No. 61 of 2005 to the effect that the said order dated 12th July, 1999 do not in anyway restrain the plaintiffs/respondents from serving the writ of summons and that the plaintiffs/respondents' intention to have the plaint amended has not got nothing to do with the non-service of writ of summons on the defendants since the plaintiffs would always have had the liberty to serve fresh writ of summons on the defendants after the amendment of the plaint unless such service was waived. The defendants/appellants further stated that a valuable right has accrued to the defendants, which cannot be defeated.
9. Considering the facts of this case and the decisions (reported and unreported) which have been cited at the Bar, we are of the view that a valuable right has accrued to the defendants in the suit and it does not appear from the records that the defendants have at any point of time waived their rights to be served with the writ of summons in the usual course prescribed by law. In Lakshmi Trading case (supra) the Division Bench of this Court was pleased to hold that where the plaintiff has not made an application for the issuance of fresh summons within the time prescribed nor has made an application within that period for an extension of time, the Master can no longer entertain an application for such extension, far less an application for issue of fresh summons and the Court will be bound to make an order that the suit be dismissed. The Division Bench was pleased to observe that the valuable right had accrued in favour of the defendants. In the case of Satyanarayan Todi (supra) the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court was also not inclined to exercise powers under section 5 of the Limitation Act in absence of proper explanation as to what happened during the relevant period. It further appears that the Hon'ble Division Bench was also pleased to observe that Rules 6 and 8 of Chapter VIII of the Original Side Rules do not in anyway affect or after the provisions of Order 9 Rule 5(1) of the Civil Procedure Code and that Order 9 Rule 5(1) CPC, in the absence of specific provisions in the Original Side Rules, applies to the Original Side as well.
10. Considering the facts of the instant case we cannot accept the case made out by the plaintiffs/respondents in their application for extension of the returnable date of the writ of summons. It cannot be said from a perusal of the said order dated 12.07.1999 passed by the Hon'ble single Judge that the plaintiffs/respondents were estopped from taking further steps in the suit like taking steps for issuance and service of writ of summons upon the defendants. In our view, the filing of the application for amendment of the plaint, which according to the plaintiffs was done after the said order dated 12th July, 1999 was passed, cannot be a ground for preventing the plaintiffs from taking steps for issuance and service of the writ of summons in accordance with relevant Rules. The plaintiffs/respondents' case that they intended to have the plaint in the suit amended and the summons taken out for the amended plaint and thereafter have it served upon the defendants is not an acceptable argument. Such argument, if accepted, would render the Rules meaningless. We are also not satisfied with the plaintiffs/respondents' case of being under bonafide impression and genuine belief that the service of the writ of summons upon the defendants prior to disposal of the defendants' demurer application and prior to the hearing of the amendment application filed by the plaintiffs/respondents will serve no useful purpose. After having tried to make out such case it cannot be appreciated how the plaintiffs/respondents can shift the blame upon his learned advocate-on-Record for not taking proper steps in due time, since the plaintiffs have themselves stated that no useful purpose would have been served if the writ of summons was served prior to the disposal of the defendants' demurer application and prior to the hearing of the amendment application. If this be the ground for the belief of the plaintiffs/respondents then it becomes difficult to appreciate as to how the plaintiffs/respondents can thereafter fix the responsibility entirely upon their learned advocate-on-Record. Thus, considering the facts and circumstances of this case and the decisions which were cited at the Bar, as discussed above, we are of the view that the Hon'ble First Court was not right in dismissing the defendants/appellants' application being G.A No. 61 of 2005. In our view, the suit ought to be dismissed for non-service of writ of Even though it has been stated by the defendants/appellants in their application for any stay that the writ of summons was served on the defendants/appellants on July 8, 2005, it is of no consequence, since the plaintiffs/respondents failed to take proper steps within the time prescribed by law and the plaintiffs have failed to give proper and cogent reason for their failure. Thus, the defendants' application for dismissal of the suit being G.A No. 61 of 2005 stands allowed and consequently, the plaintiffs' application being G.A No. 1286 of 2005 for extension of the returnable date of the writ of summons is dismissed. Thus the Order dated 20th June, 2005 passed by the Hon'ble First Court which is under challenge in this appeal is set aside and the A.P.O No. 458 of 2005 is allowed.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
P.C Ghose, J.:— I agree.
A.P.O No. 458 of 2005 was allowed and the Order under challenge dated 20.6.2005 in this appal is set aside.
S.B
Alert