Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Syed Darain Ahsan Darain v. State Of West Bengal

Calcutta High Court
May 12, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Judgment — C.R.A. No. 240 of 2003 & C.R.A. No. 244 of 2003

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from convictions and sentences imposed by the Additional District & Sessions Judge, 13th Court, 24-Parganas (South), Alipore, in Sessions Trial No. 02(8) of 2001. The criminal case concerned the killing of a political personality, Md. Jahangir (also referred to as "Mogal"), in a busy area of Garden Reach on or about 11/02/2001. According to the FIR and trial evidence, while the deceased was moving along Iron Gate Road towards Garden Reach Road he was accosted by a group of miscreants (8–10 persons), encircled and fired upon at close range; the victim collapsed and was later declared dead at a local nursing home and at S.S.K.M. Hospital. A police case (Garden Reach P.S. Case No. 14 dated 12/02/01) was registered, inquest conducted, a post-mortem performed, incriminating articles seized and witnesses recorded. A charge of murder under section 302 read with section 34 IPC was framed against the two appellants; prosecution examined 24 witnesses, defence examined two. The trial court convicted both appellants under section 302 read with section 34 IPC and sentenced them to life imprisonment with fines. The appellants (Abuzar Hossain @ Gulam Hossain in C.R.A. No. 240/2003 and Syed Darain @ Ahsan in C.R.A. No. 244/2003) appealed against conviction and sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution's case, founded primarily on eye-witness testimony and corroborative medical and seizure evidence, was reliable enough to sustain convictions under section 302 read with section 34 IPC.
  2. Whether the informant who lodged the FIR (P.W.3, referred to as Riaz/Rasid Khan) was the real informant or an imposter, and if inconsistencies in his name/address/signature undermined the FIR's authenticity.
  3. Whether the alleged contradictions and changes in the eye-witnesses' statements (P.W.3, P.W.4, P.W.5, P.W.7, etc.) rendered their testimony unreliable.
  4. Whether defects in the T I (identification) parade and deficiencies in noting identifying marks/features affected the validity of the identification of appellant Abuzar Hossain.
  5. Whether omissions in the FIR (e.g., not naming Abuzar Hossain) and subsequent additions during trial should have entitled the appellants to benefit of doubt (with reference to principles exemplified in Ram Kumar Pande v. State of Madhya Pradesh and section 11 of the Evidence Act).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Sekhar Basu, Senior Counsel)

  • The real informant was not available and the prosecution brought another person as the informant; the FIR names "Rashid Khan" at B/46 Iron Gate Road, whereas P.W.3 testified as "Riaz Khan" at B/43 and said he was also known as "Rashid", with an unexplained inconsistency about signature capability.
  • The prosecution's attempt to treat P.W.3 and P.W.4 as eye-witnesses was flawed because their statements contained contradictions and shifts (e.g., where they were seated, the weapons seen — guns vs. revolvers), suggesting they did not actually witness the incident closely.
  • P.W.5 and P.W.7 were not really close-range eye-witnesses: P.W.6's statement suggested Yusuf and Jahir had scampered away after fireworks, indicating they might not have observed the killing at close quarters.
  • The post-mortem report was unreliable or inconclusive on certain injuries (notably injury No.6 and whether injuries 1–5 were caused by firearms); minor injuries might have resulted from falling rather than shooting.
  • TI Parade had defects and did not note special marks/features of Abuzar Hossain; hence identification from the parade was unreliable.
  • The name of Abuzar Hossain did not appear in the FIR; witnesses' subsequent mentioning of his role only during trial (and some statements being recorded before the FIR) amounted to material omissions in the FIR that should cast doubt on the prosecution case (invoking Ram Kumar Pande and section 11 Evidence Act principles).

Respondent/Prosecution's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Kazi Safiullah, Public Prosecutor)

  • Nearly all eye-witnesses gave vivid, consistent accounts of the incident; their statements at trial matched what was stated during investigation and contained hardly any contradictions.
  • Eye-witnesses were local residents familiar with the appellants and the area was lit by street lights, facilitating correct identification.
  • Medical evidence (post-mortem) corroborated the eye-witnesses' account of bullet injuries, supporting the assertion that death was homicidal and caused by firearms.
  • The prosecution's evidence was therefore overwhelming when direct testimony, medical papers and seizure lists were assessed together; the trial court was justified in convicting under section 302 read with section 34 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Kumar Pande v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1975 SC 1026 Omissions of important facts affecting probabilities are relevant under section 11 of the Evidence Act in assessing veracity of prosecution case. The appellants relied on this case to argue that omissions in the FIR (e.g., absence of Abuzar Hossain's name) should raise doubt. The court considered the argument but concluded that the omissions did not undermine the reliable eye-witness and medical evidence; thus the precedent did not alter the outcome.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded to evaluate the evidentiary matrix by scrutinizing (a) direct testimony of eye-witnesses, (b) corroborative medical evidence (post-mortem), (c) seizure material, and (d) identification evidence from the T I Parade and local recognition.

On the informant's identity: the court noted P.W.3 admitted being called both "Riaz" and "Rasid" and that other local witnesses and the Investigating Officer treated "Riaz" and "Rasid" as the same person. The court found nothing on record to indicate an imposter had been introduced; thus challenges to the informant's identity were rejected.

On the credibility of eye-witnesses: the court emphasized that several witnesses (P.W.3, P.W.4, P.W.5, P.W.7) gave consistent, vivid descriptions of the incident and had seen it from close range. The fact that they were local residents familiar with the appellants and that the area was illuminated by street lights supported reliable identification. The court examined the alleged contradictions highlighted by the defence (differences on seating positions, weapon descriptions, or minor discrepancies) and concluded these did not render the witnesses' accounts unreliable.

On medical and seizure evidence: the post-mortem report (P.W.12, Dr. Amitava Das) recorded two bullet injuries (occipital and right temporal), with the occipital injury being fatal and the temporal injury a grazing; the doctor opined death was homicidal and ante-mortem. A bullet was also seized at the place of occurrence. The court treated the medical and seizure evidence as corroborative of the eyewitnesses' account that shots were fired at close range.

On identification and TI Parade: the court found the T I Parade identification of Abuzar Hossain to have been properly conducted by the Magistrate, free from collusion, and established at the threshold of investigation. The absence of a special mark being noted in the parade sheet was not treated as fatal where multiple local witnesses positively identified the accused and the circumstances supported early identification.

On omissions in the FIR and reliance on Ram Kumar Pande: the court acknowledged the defence submission that important facts omitted from the FIR can be relevant in judging veracity. However, after considering the totality of evidence — consistent eyewitness testimony, corroborative medical findings, seizure recovery and circumstances such as appellants' absconsion — the court found these omissions did not create reasonable doubt warranting acquittal.

The court also considered the appellants' conduct (delay in arrest: Abuzar arrested after nearly a month, Darain after years of absconsion) as a relevant circumstance indicating involvement. The court rejected suggestions that the judgment was based on conjecture or surmise and affirmed that there had been proper appraisal of the record.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The criminal appeals are dismissed. The convictions and sentences under section 302 read with section 34 IPC against both appellants are affirmed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: Both appellants' convictions and life sentences (with fines of Rs. 5,000 each, in default further imprisonment for one year) as imposed by the trial court stand confirmed.
  • Further orders: Appellant Abuzar Hossain (then on bail) was ordered to surrender within 15 days of the judgment to serve the sentence; his bail bond was cancelled and the Trial Court instructed to issue a non-bailable warrant if he failed to surrender. Copies of the judgment were directed to be sent to the Trial Court and to the Superintendent of Jail/Correctional Home; certified copies to be made available on application.
  • Precedential effect: The court did not indicate that it was laying down any new law; the decision rests on applying established principles of assessing eyewitness credibility, corroboration by medical/seizure evidence and evaluation of omissions in FIRs. The judgment affirmed the trial court's fact-finding and did not disturb it.
Show all summary ...

P.K Deb, J.:— The two appeals being C.R.A No. 240 of 2003 and C.R.A No. 244 of 2003 have been directed against the conviction and sentence passed by the learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, 13th Court, 24-Parganas (South), Alipore in connection with Sessions Trial No. 02(8) of 2001.

2. The brutal and shocking incident of murder of a political personality occurred in the busy area of Garden Reach. The prosecution case, as narrated in the FIR and elaborated further during the course of the trial, was to the effect that while Md. Jahangir @ Mogal moved along Iron Gate Road towards Garden Reach Road, he was accosted by few miscreants. Encircling him, the miscreants started firing at him. All the miscreants were reported to have had machines in their hands. Md. Jahangir collapsed on the street after being shot from close range. The miscreants numbering 8 to 10 persons dispersed to different directions on seeing the witnesses converging in the place of occurrence.

3. As blood gushed from the wounds, steps were taken to shift the injured to the nearby nursing home. On examination of the injured in Hannan Nursing Home, the doctor declared him dead. Subsequently, the body of Md. Jahangir was taken to S.S.K.M Hospital for further examination. The attending doctor of S.S.K.M Hospital also declared him dead.

4. With the lodging of the FIR, Garden Reach P.S Case No. 14 dated 12/02/01 was registered. In course of the investigation, the initial task of holding the inquest was conducted by the Investigating Officer. It was followed by sending the deadbody to the morgue for post-mortem examination. The Investigating Officer also seized the incriminating articles. The statements of the eye-witnesses were recorded on the very date of the incident. Eventually, on collection of all the materials, examination of the witnesses, chargesheet was submitted against both the appellants.

5. Following the commitment of the case to the Court of Sessions, charge under section 302 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code was framed against both the appellants. They were charged with having committed the intentional murder of Md. Jahangir in furtherance of their common intention. In the wake of specific denial of the accusations, the prosecution side examined as many as 24 witnesses including the informant, the other eyewitnesses of the occurrence, the witnesses of the seizure, the medical officers examining the deadbody from time to time and the police officers who took active part in the investigation of the case. On the other hand, two witnesses were examined on behalf of the defence. Relying strongly on the statements of the eye-witnesses and the corroborative medical papers, the learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted and sentenced both the appellants for commission of offence under section 302 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. Both the appellants were sentenced to imprisonment for life and also to pay fine of Rs. 5,000/- each, in default, to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for one year.

6. Aggrieved by, and dissatisfied with, the order of conviction and sentence, the appellants filed separate appeals-C.R.A No. 240 of 2003 being filed by appellant Abuzar Hossain @ Gulam Hossain and C.R.A No. 244 of 2003 being filed by appellant Syed Darain @ Ahsan.

7. Challenging the conviction and sentence, Mr. Sekhar Basu, learned Senior Counsel, has submitted that since the real informant was not available during the trial, the prosecution side performed the dubious act of bringing another person as the informant. Mr. Basu has submitted that the FIR itself discloses that the informant Rashid Khan resided in a house at B/46, Iron Gate Road. Nowhere in the FIR, it has been indicated that the informant Rashid Khan was known as Riaz Khan. P.W 3 Riaz Khan testified during the trial that he was also known as Rashid Khan. He claimed to have resided all along in B/43, Iron Gate Road. As it is usually done by illiterate persons, the informant put his LTI on the FIR. P.W 3 during the trial, however, acknowledged that he could sign in English. Such startling disclosure by P.W 3, it is contended by Mr. Basu, gives rise to the genuine doubt as to the authenticity of the FIR maker. The identity of P.W 3 being shrouded in mystery, the Trial Court should not have placed undue importance on the testimony of P.W 3 Riaz Khan.

8. Commenting on the statements of P.W 3 and P.W 4, Mr. Basu has submitted that the prosecution made a futile bid to project those two persons as eye-witnesses of the occurrence. From the contradictory statements made by them during the trial, it can be assumed that they had hardly any occasion to see the incident. As per statement of P.W 4 Md. Samin Ansari, he along with P.W 3 and one Munna seated on chairs in a ‘khatal’. Shifting from the original stand, the witness afterwards stated that near the lamp-post he was gossiping with Md. Riaz Khan and Munna. Similarly, P.W 3 initially alleged that Md. Jahangir was shot from guns. Subsequently, he claimed that firing was made from revolvers.

9. Refuting the claim of the prosecution that P.W 5 and P.W 7 were the eye-witnesses of the occurrence, Mr. Basu has submitted that if the statements of P.W 6 are to be believed, P.W 5 Md. Yusuf and P.W 7 Md. Tahir hardly have had any occasion to see the incident from handshaking distance. Drawing our attention to the statement of P.W 6 Naushad Ali, Mr. Basu submits that the witnesses had disclosed during the trial that P.W 5 Md. Yusuf and P.W 7 Md. Jahir scampered towards Victoria Jute Mill after the bursting of 7/8 crackers in the nearby area. In view of the revelation of real fact and truth, the Trial Court should not have accepted P.W 5 and P.W 7 as witnesses of the occurrence, as argued by Mr. Basu.

10. Describing the post-mortem report as unreliable, Mr. Basu contends that autopsy surgeon has not clarified as to how injury No. 6 was sustained by the deceased Md. Jahangir @ Mogal. The doctor conducting the postmortem examination has not also claimed that injury Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 had been caused as a result of firing by guns. None of the so called eye-witnesses could throw any light as to how such minor injuries were sustained by the victim. The injuries, as referred to in the post-mortem report, might have been sustained as a result of the victim flopping onto the ground, as urged by Mr. Basu.

11. Dealing with the aspect of identification of the appellant Abuzar Hossain during the investigation, Mr. Basu has submitted that since there are apparent defects and loopholes in the T I Parade, the Trial Court should not have placed any reliance on the aspect of indentification of the appellant Abuzar Hossain during the early stage of investigation. It is contended that the special mark of identification of the suspect Abuzar Hossain was not noted in the T I Parade sheet, nor there was any attempt to note down the features of the persons placed in the T I Parade.

12. Commenting on the conviction of the appellant Abuzar Hossain, Mr. Basu submits that the Trial Court altogether overlooked the aspect that the name of the appellant Abuzar Hossain did not figure in the FIR. Despite the claim of P.W 3 Riaz Khan that he had seen the incident from close range, the witness disclosed that he could identify only one miscreant. Had the appellant Abuzar Hossain been present at the spot, the witness could have easily recognized him. In their statements under section 161 Cr. PC, the witnesses P.W 5 and P.W 7 mentioned about the role of Abuzar Hossain in the commission of murder. Such statements of P.W 5 and P.W 7 were incidentally recorded before the recording of the FIR. If the eye-witnesses had really seen the appellant Abuzar Hossain in the commission of crime, it ought to have been reflected in the FIR itself. Efforts being made to introduce such an important fact during the trial, the Trial Court should not have placed any reliance on that aspect. Mr. Basu has referred to the case of Ram Kumar Pande v. State of Madhya Pradesh, reported in AIR 1975 SC 1026, in support of his contention that omissions of important facts, affecting the probabilities of the case, are relevant under section 11 of the Evidence Act in judging the veracity of the prosecution case. In the instant case, there being glaring omissions of important facts in the FIR, the Trial Court ought to have given at least the benefit of doubt in favour of the appellant Abuzar Hossain.

13. Strongly defending the conviction and sentence against both the appellants, Mr. Kazi Safiullah, learned Public Prosecutor, has submitted that since a vivid account of the incident had been given by nearly all the eye-witnesses of the occurrence, the Trial Court had every reason to bank on it. The incident, as told by the eye-witnesses, was also found to be acceptable and convincing. There was hardly any contradiction in the statements of the eye-witnesses. What they stated during the investigation were reproduced during the trial. The eye-witnesses being residents of their locality, it was easier for them to identify the appellants in the street lights. What they stated about the victim sustaining bullet injury also found due corroboration from the post-mortem report. The direct evidence was thus supplemented by medical papers. In the face of presentation of such overwhelming evidence against the appellants, the Trial Court rightly convicted and sentenced them for commission of offence under section 302 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, as contended by Mr. Safiullah.

14. The prosecution heavily relied on the testimony of the eye-witnesses to build up its case. The medical papers and the seizure list were also produced as corroborative piece of evidence. Nearly all the eye-witnesses who had seen the incident were examined on behalf of the prosecution. P.W 3 was said to have lodged the FIR. Following the murder of Mogal in front of B/35, Iron Gate Road, P.W 3 Riaz deposed to the effect that on 11/02/2001 at about 9-30 p.m he found Mogal moving towards B/35, Iron Gate Road after coming down from Bengali Bazar. On hearing the sound of firing, he along with his friend hurried to the spot. He found the appellant Darain along with 8 to 10 persons encircling Mogal from all sides. Those armed miscreants fired at Mogal in front of B/35, Iron Gate Road, as alleged by P.W 3 Riaz. The victim called Mogal collapsed onto the ground with bullet injury. As the witnesses namely Yusuf and Jahir raised alarm, the appellant Darain and his associates threatened them. Struck with fear, the witnesses dispersed towards Garden Reach Nursing Home. The appellant Darain and his associates also dispersed in different directions.

15. P.W 4 Md. Samin Ansari testified that on 11/02/2001 round about 9-45 p.m he found Mogalbhai heading towards B/35, Iron Gate Road from Bengali Bazar. After a while, he heard the sound of firing. Both of them hurried to the spot where they found Darain and 8 to 10 other persons standing near Mogal. Expressing their vow to finish Mogal, the miscreants started firing at him, with the result that Mogal fell on B/35, Iron Gate Road. The witnesses further confirmed that brandishing a revolver, Darain threatened the witnesses namely Yusuf and Jahir when they raised alarm.

16. As disclosed by P.W 5 Md. Yusuf, when Mogalbhai reached in front of B/35, Iron Gate Road from Bengali Bazar he was detained by the appellant Darain, Abuzar Hossain and their associates. All those persons with revolvers in their hands fired at Mogal, with the result Mogal instantly fell down onto the ground. The witness also corroborated the fact that Darain sought to silence him and Jahir by pointing revolver at them when they started raising alarm.

17. P.W 7 Md. Jahir also came out with identical accusation against the appellants. As stated by the witnesses during the course of the trial, Jahangir @ Mogal moved towards B/35, Iron Gate Road after coming down from Bengali Bazar. The witness also confirmed that the appellants namely Darain, Abuzar Hossain and some others encircled Mogal afterwards they indiscriminately started firing at Mogal. Before that they resolved to murder Mogal.

18. P.W 6. Naushad Ali disclosed during the trial that the witnesses namely Yusuf and Jahir were gossiping in front of a shop just prior to the incident. He headed towards the spot on hearing the sound of cracker. On reaching there, he found Mogal lying on the ground with the witnesses Samin and Rasid leaning on him. Like other witnesses, P.W 6 Naushad Ali also noticed injuries on the back of his head.

19. It has emerged from the statements of the eye-witnesses that the victim Mogal was initially taken to a nursing home where he was examined by P.W 10 Dr. Kazi H.A Hannan. The doctor pronounced him dead. Meanwhile, the investigating agency shifted him to S.S.K.M Hospital. The attending doctor of S.S.K.M Hospital also confirmed the death of Mogal @ Jahangir. The body was sent to the morgue for post-mortem examination after initial inquest over the deadbody. P.W 12 Dr. Amitava Das, Autopsy Surgeon, conducted the post-mortem on the deadbody of Mogal. On examination, the doctor found two bullet injuries—one in the occipital region and the other on the right temporal bone. The doctor expressed his view that both the injuries were caused by bullets, with the injury on the occipital being considered fatal. The doctor also opined that the gutter fracture on right temporal was caused by grazing of a bullet. The doctor viewed the death to be homicidal and ante-mortem in nature.

20. The eye-witnesses with one accord claimed the Mogal @ Jahangir was fired from close range. What the witnesses claimed finds due corroboration from the post-mortem report. It is on evidence that several shots were fired by the miscreants. Bullets were pumped into his body. Two bullet injuries were found on the body of Mogal @ Jahangir. There was seizure of another bullet at the place of occurrence. That bullets were used is evidenced by post-mortem report as well as by the seizure list. There is hardly any scope for believing that murder of Mogal was executed somewhere else and that too in different manner.

21. All the eye-witnesses were found to be residents of that locality. The area was also illumined by street lights, as disclosed by P.W 4 and P.W 5. P.W 4, PW. 5 & P.W 7 knew both the appellants before. The illumination of the area by street lights made their task of identification easier. P.W 3, the informant, knew the appellant Mogal well. He also identified the other appellant Abuzar Hossain in the T I Parade. The learned Magistrate did everything to ensure fairness in the T I Parade. The way the T I Parade was conducted gives a fair indication that it was free from collusion. The identification of the appellant Abuzar Hossain was established at the threshold of the investigation. In the face of such concerete identification of the appellants by the eye-witnesses of the occurrence, it is hard to accept the suggestion of the defence that Mogal was murdered by some other miscreants elsewhere.

22. The identity of the informant was challenged during the trial as well as in course of the hearing of the appeal. P.W 3 claimed that he was known by Riaz as well as by Rasid Khan. P.W 3 claimed that he had been all along residing in B/43, Iron Gate Road. The other eye-witnesses, all residents of that locality, have confirmed that Riaz was also known as Rasid Khan. The Investigating Officer also confirmed that Riaz and Rasid are identical person. There is practically nothing on record to make us believe that an imposter had been introduced at the time of trial.

23. All the eye-witnesses namely P.W 3, P.W 4 & P.W 7 have given a vivid and true accounts of the incident. They had seen the occurrence from close range. Since they were the residents of the locality, they had no problem in identifying the assailants. There is nothing on record suggesting that they nurtured ill feelings and harboured animosity against the appellants. In other words, they had no reason whatsoever for falsely implicating the appellants. The evidence of the eye-witnesses is found to be quite consistent. We do not share the view of Mr. Basu that the statements of the eyewitnesses are incongruous and contradictory. What the eye-witnesses stated about assault on Md. Jahangir @ Mogal finds due corroboration from the post-mortem report. The medical report does confirm that the death of Md. Jahangir @ Mogal was caused by bullet injuries. One bullet caused fatal injuries on vital parts of the body with the other bullet grazing the outer surface of the body. There was recovery of one bullet from the place of occurrence. All these facts and circumstances do support the contention of the prosecution that the appellants and his associates fired at Mogal from close range. What the witnesses stated at the time of investigation of the case was maintained all through. There was hardly any deviation of their stand. The Trial Court did the right thing in placing importance on the true and vivid account of the incident as narrated by the eye-witnesses of the incident. Due weightage was also given to the medical reports. The appellant called Abuzar Hossain was arrested after nearly a month, while the appellant Darain could be apprehended after years of absconsion. Their disappearance immediately after the commission of murder was also considered to be a relevant fact for assuming their involvement in the commission of murder. There was proper appraisal of the evidence on record. We are afraid we cannot subscribe to the view that the judgment was passed on conjecture and surmises. In our view, the well-reasoned judgment does not call for any interference. The appeal is thus found devoid of merit.

24. In the result, the criminal appeals are dismissed. The conviction and sentence under section 302 read with section 34 IPC passed against both the appellants are hereby affirmed.

25. The appellant Abuzar Hossain, now on bail, is to surrender within 15 days of passing of the judgment to serve out the sentence. His bail bond stands cancelled.

26. Send down the LCR along with a copy of the judgment to the Trial Court with the intimation that the learned Trial Court shall issue non-bailable warrant against the appellant Abuzar Hossain to secure his detention in the event of appellant Abuzar Hossain not surrendering before the Trial Court within the stipulated period of 15 days of passing of the order.

27. Send another copy of the judgment to the concerned Superintendent of Jail/Correctional Home for information.

28. Certified copy of this judgment be made available on making proper application and after complying with all formalities.

Alok Kumar Basu, J.: I agree.

Criminal appeals dismissed.
S.R.A