Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Aroma Enterprise And Another v. Murshidabad Zilla Parishad And Others

Calcutta High Court
Feb 5, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Murshidabad Zilla Parishad Tender Dispute

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged the fairness of the tendering process conducted by the Murshidabad Zilla Parishad for construction of various roads. The tender notice comprised nine items. The petitioners participated in items numbered 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9. Work orders had already been issued in respect of items 3 and 4. For items 7 and 8 the accepted rate was shown as 12.98% below the estimated rate; the petitioners alleged that acceptance for items 7 and 8 and rejection/non-acceptance in respect of other items was unfair and discriminatory.

The Zilla Parishad filed an affidavit stating that one Co-operative & Construction Society Limited initially offered 56.92% below the estimated rate but later claimed the correct quote was 12.98% below; the authority also alleged that some bids were submitted on lost letterheads and filed an FIR. The Tender and Purchase Committee, after comparing bids, decided to issue fresh sealed tenders for serial/items 1, 2, 5 and 9, on the ground that the lower bids (in those items) were not reasonably comparable with items 3, 4, 7 and 8. The Committee additionally asserted that accepting certain very low bids could save Government money to the extent of Rs. 30–40 lakhs per project.

The High Court entertained the writ petition because the petitioners framed the dispute as one about fairness in a governmental tendering process and directed the parties to file affidavits; an interim direction was given restraining the Zilla Parishad from refunding any funds allotted under Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana without the leave of the Court. The Court ultimately set aside the Tender and Purchase Committee's decision for items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 and directed reconsideration.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decision of the Tender and Purchase Committee in respect of items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 was arbitrary, discriminatory or otherwise violative of principles of fairness in governmental tendering.
  2. Whether a State authority's acceptance or rejection of tenders must be accompanied by recorded reasons and communication to affected tenderers, particularly when lower offers are rejected.
  3. Whether the Zilla Parishad was justified in calling for fresh sealed tenders for certain items and in accepting widely varying bid percentages across different items without reasoned explanation.
  4. What remedial directions should follow if the Committee's decision is found not to be backed by reasons or is discriminatory.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented through their counsel)

  • The pattern of acceptance (items 7 and 8 at 12.98% below estimate) and rejection/non-acceptance of petitioners' lower bids for items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 was unfair and discriminatory.
  • The State/instrumentality must act within the rule of law and not arbitrarily; rejection of the lowest offer must be supported by recorded and communicated reasons so as to permit objective review.
  • There should at least have been negotiation with the petitioners or comparable treatment before rejecting their bids.

Respondent — Murshidabad Zilla Parishad's Arguments

  • The acceptance of tenders by a State authority is a matter of administrative discretion; the authority relied upon the principle that such discretion is permissible provided the action is open, fair, honest and above-board.
  • One bidder (Co-operative & Construction Society Limited) allegedly submitted an absurdly low bid of 56.92% below estimate but later disowned it; the authority treated that bid as spurious and proceeded on the basis of corrected or next-best bids.
  • The Tender and Purchase Committee found the lowest bids in items 1, 2, 5 and 9 not reasonably comparable with items 3, 4, 7 and 8 and therefore decided to issue fresh sealed tenders for the former group.
  • The Committee contended that accepting the very low bids in some items would save government funds (claimed Rs. 30–40 lakhs per project) and thus justified its decision-making process.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahabir Auto v. Indian Oil Corpn, AIR 1990 SC 1031 Permitted writ jurisdiction in tender/contract matters where unfairness, discrimination or arbitrariness governs the decision to enter into or refuse a governmental contract; altered earlier reluctance of writ courts to interfere in commercial disputes. The Court relied on this precedent to justify entertaining the writ petition on the ground that the petition raised issues of fairness in a governmental tendering process; this precedent supported the decision to receive affidavits and consider the matter on merits.
TVL Sundaram Granites v. Imperial Granites Ltd., (1999) 8 SCC 150 : AIR 1999 SC 3835 Acceptance of tender by a State authority is an administrative discretion, but the exercise of that discretion must be open, fair, honest and above-board. The Supreme Court in that case directed reconsideration by inviting fresh applications and provided interim protective measures to avoid prejudice. The Zilla Parishad relied on this case to support its discretion in accepting/rejecting tenders and in calling for fresh sealed tenders. The Court examined the case’s operative approach (including the Supreme Court’s direction to consider prejudice and the grant of interim protective relief) to determine whether calling fresh tenders here caused prejudice and whether any priority or interim protection like in that case was warranted.
Star Enterprises v. CIDCO, (1990) 3 SCC 280 State authorities must act within the rule of law and not arbitrarily; in tender processes the State can refuse even the lowest bid but, when rejecting the lowest offer, it must record reasons and communicate them so as to permit objective administrative and judicial review. The Court gave strong weight to this precedent in concluding that rejection of the petitioners' bids required recorded and communicated reasons. The Court relied on the principle that reasons must be given and that lack of reasons and discriminatory treatment undermined the Committee’s decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging the general rule that writ courts are cautious in interfering with commercial/tender matters but observed that the Supreme Court's decision in Mahabir Auto had broadened circumstances in which writ intervention is appropriate where unfairness or arbitrariness is alleged. Because the petitioners raised a prima facie fairness issue, the matter was entertained and affidavits were ordered.

Factually the Court identified nine items in the tender: petitioners had bids in items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9; items 3 and 4 already had work orders; items 7 and 8 had accepted rates recorded as 12.98% below the estimated rates. The petitioners argued that the pattern of acceptance and rejection across items was discriminatory.

The Zilla Parishad’s affidavit explained that an initial extremely low bid of 56.92% below estimate was later disowned by the alleged bidder and that certain bids were treated as spurious (lost letter pads / FIR). The Committee concluded that the bids for items 1, 2, 5 and 9 were not reasonably comparable with items 3, 4, 7 and 8 and therefore called fresh sealed tenders for those items. The Committee also advanced a justification that accepting the very low bids for some items would save governmental money (claimed at Rs. 30–40 lakhs per project).

Applying precedents, the Court emphasized settled principles: State action in commercial transactions must be open, fair, honest and above-board; rejection of a lowest bid must be supported by recorded reasons and those reasons should be communicated to enable objective review. The Court analyzed the materials and found multiple deficiencies in the authority's explanation:

  • The offer of 56.92% below estimate was deemed "absolutely absurd" and the narrative that documents were stolen appeared concocted; thus reliance on that bid or its later correction to 12.98% lacked credibility in context.
  • The affidavit produced by an upper division assistant was considered not adequately persuasive as a factual, decision‑justifying document; the Court noted the absence of an appropriate, reasoned affidavit by responsible decision‑makers.
  • The Committee's assertion that accepting certain low bids would save Rs. 30–40 lakhs per project was unsubstantiated because no project-wise cost breakdown or calculation was provided; the claim was therefore vague and not a factual explanation sufficient to support disparate treatment.
  • The Committee treated different items inconsistently — for example, a similar contention made for item 1 was ignored — suggesting discriminatory treatment rather than an even-handed decision‑making process.
  • The Court reiterated that while authorities may refuse the lowest or highest bid in pursuit of the best deal, such rejection must be accompanied by reasons and not by an affidavit opinion devoid of fact-oriented explanation.

On the basis of these findings — lack of recorded reasons, inadequate factual explanation, apparent discrimination in treatment across items, and unreliable or insufficient affidavits — the Court concluded that the Tender and Purchase Committee’s decision in respect of items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside the decision of the Tender and Purchase Committee in respect of item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 and directed reconsideration. The writ petition was disposed of.

Core Ruling: The decision of the Tender and Purchase Committee in respect of item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 is set aside and the writ petition is disposed of.

Specific directions and immediate consequences (as ordered in the opinion):

  • The Tender and Purchase Committee is directed to reconsider the matter, granting the parties the fullest opportunity of hearing, and to pass a reasoned order afresh within one month from the date of communication of the Court's order.
  • For effective adjudication, copies of the writ petition with annexures and the affidavits (with annexures) may be treated as part of the record for consideration by the Committee.
  • Until one week after the Committee takes and communicates its fresh decision, no effect or further effect in respect of the tenders will be given by the authority concerned.
  • If during reconsideration the authority finds the petitioners' offers justifiable, it may accept those offers irrespective of whether a reasoned order has then been passed.
  • The writ petition is disposed of and no order as to costs was made.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying established principles; it applies existing Supreme Court authorities to the facts and directs a re‑examination with reasoned findings.

Administrative direction: An urgent xeroxed certified copy of the judgment, if applied for, is to be given to the learned advocates for the parties within one week from the date of compliance with requisites.

Show all summary ...

1. The dispute, raised by the petitioners, is arising out of fairness in dealing with the tender issued by Murshidabad Zilla Parishad.

2. Under normal circumstances, writ Court is very much slow in interfering in respect of tender or contract matters which are in the nature of commercial dispute by holding a view that Civil Court or Forum made for it, is the appropriate Forum for adjudication. However, judicial view changed its mind very much after the principles laid down in the case of Mahabir Auto v. Indian Oil Corpn. reported in AIR 1990 SC 1031. The ratio of the judgment is, in entering or not entering into the contract with the governmental authorities fair play, indiscrimination, arbitrariness might have been the governing factor for entertaining the writ petition. Since Mr. Malay Kumar Bose, learned Senior Counsel appearing in support of the petitioners, said that the dispute is in the nature of fairness of the authority by holding a prima facie view, the Court entertained this matter and directed the parties to file their respective affidavits for the purpose of due consideration. The interim order was passed only to the extent that if any fund is allotted in favour of the Zilla Parishad by Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojona the same will not be refunded back by the Zilla Parishad without the leave of the Court.

3. Factually the petitioners contended before this Court that the concerned Zilla Parishad issued a notice inviting tender in respect of construction of various roads. There are altogether nine items under the notice. Tenderers deposited their tenders giving lower side of the price fixed by the authority in the tender document. The petitioners are participants of tender in respect of item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9. In respect of item Nos. 3 and 4 work orders have already been issued. In respect of item Nos. 7 and 8, 12.98% below than the estimated rates have been accepted. There, the dispute lies. The petitioners contended that nature of acceptance of the tender of the tenderers in respect of item Nos. 7 and 8 is totally unfair and discriminatory.

4. From the affidavit-in-opposition of the authorities by the pen of one employee of the Zilla Parishad it appears that one Co-operative & Construction Society Limited offered a rate of 56.92% below than the estimated rate on 20th September, 2002 but subsequently they informed that the actual quoted rate is 12.98% below than the estimated rate. Some letter pads with signature of authorised signatory were lost for which they lodged FIR in Berhampore Police Station. Someone used their lost letter pads and quoted rate. They requested not to accept the rate of 56.92% below than the estimated rate. The authority concerned found one Banwarilal Agarwal and S.R Construction are second highest bidder in respect of item Nos. 7 and 8 respectively whereunder they offered 25.1% and 22.24% respectively below than the estimated rate. According to the authorities, they have accepted the rates. It has further stated that one Durgapur Unemployed Engineers Industrial Co-operative Limited by their letter dated 25th September, 2002 informed the respondent authority that someone submitted bid rate through their letter heads falsely without their knowledge and they requested to ignore the false bid. Accordingly, the bid rate of such concern was cancelled in respect of serial No. 1. As the lowest Bidders in respect of the serial Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 are 6.2%, 5.3%, 2.75%, 2.5% and 1.3% respectively below than the estimated rate the tender matters were placed before the Tender and Purchase Committee of the Zilla Parishad on 27th September, 2002. Such Committee in a meeting on such date decided to issue fresh sealed tender in respect of serial Nos. 1, 2, 5 and 9 as the highest bid which according to them, are not reasonable comparison with serial Nos. 3, 4, 7 and 8. In the subsequent paragraph, it has further stated that if the work is given to the tenderer accepting the aforesaid price in respect of serial Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 the concerned Zilla Parishad could not save governmental money more than 30 to 40 lakhs for each project in comparison to serial Nos. 3, 4, 7 and 8.

5. Therefore, the basis of consideration is a comparable figure in between the item Nos. 7 and 8 in one hand and item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 on the other hand. As because the accepted rate in respect of item Nos. 7 and 8 is 12.98% below than the estimated rate and in respect of others are 6.2%, 5.3%, 2.75%, 2.5% and 1.3% below than the estimated rate the second category tenders of the tenderers were not accepted.

6. Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the concerned Zilla Parishad, relied upon a Supreme Court judgment reported in (1999) 8 SCC 150 : (AIR 1999 SC 3835) (TVL Sundaram Granites v. Imperial Granites Ltd.) and contended that acceptance of tender by a State authority is its discretion. The only question is that the action should be open, fair, honest and completely above-board. However, in such judgment, accepting the viewpoint of the earlier judgment of the Supreme Court, State Government was directed to consider the matter afresh after inviting fresh applications. Supreme Court held such order cannot cause any serious prejudice to the appellant. Therefore, when the Tender and Purchase Committee of the concerned Zilla Parishad decided to issue fresh sealed tender for the serial/projects in respect of item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 no fault has been committed by them.

7. Mr. Bose, on the other hand, cited a three Judges' Bench judgment reported in (1990) 3 SCC 280 (Star Enterprises v. City and Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra Ltd.) to apprise that the State authority in its dealings with the citizens of India would be required to act within the ambit of rule of law and would not be permitted to conduct its activities arbitrarily. State or its instrumentality entering into the commercial field must act in consonance with the rule of law. While dealing with tenders, State is entitled to look for the best deal and for that it can refuse to accept even the lowest bid. But while rejecting the lowest offer in the tender it must record reasons for such action and communicate the same to the concerned party. The natural justice speaking for the same. Looking for reasons in support of such action provides an opportunity for an objective review in appropriate cases both by the administrative superior and for the judicial process. Mr. Bose, further contended before this Court that there should have been at least a negotiation in between the petitioners and the Zilla Parishad or the appropriate authority before rejection as it was held in connection with others. But the authority discriminated the petitioners from others in adapting different modes of acceptance and rejection of tender.

8. According to me, the submission of Mr. Bose is not at all an ignorable argument in the facts and circumstances of this case. Each case has its own factual basis. The case reported in (1999) 8 SCC 150 : (AIR 1999 SC 3835) (supra) is based on a factual matrix available therein so as to the case reported in (1990) 3 SCC 280 (supra). However, the earlier case has a stronger face value that the latter in view of the strength of the Bench. But the ratio of both the cases is that in case of commercial transactions the governmental action should be open, fair, honest and completely above board which is well-settled by now. Therefore, the only factual question is open for consideration as to whether a fresh tender can be called upon or the situation can be reviewed. The Supreme Court observed in (1999) 8 SCC 150 : (AIR 1999 SC 3835) (supra) that whether the appellant therein faced any prejudice by the order of the High Court or not in inviting fresh application. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the operative part of the judgment on the viewpoint of the Supreme Court as well as of the High Court. Learned counsel appearing therein contended that several interim orders were passed by the High Court and they have invested substantial amounts, set up machineries and engaged man power in carrying on the operations etc. By considering such submissions the Supreme Court observed that the fact situation of the case calls for an order. The ultimate order was passed by saying that they declined to interfere with the judgment of the High Court with a direction upon the State Government to complete the entire exercise within a period from the date of receiving of intimation following the procedure laid down by the High Court but without being influenced by the other observations made therein and till then the appellants shall be permitted to carry on quarry operations on the same terms and conditions as then available. Accordingly, the appeal was disposed of. Therefore, the observations of the High Court, if any, directed the petitioner to carry on the business till the decision and the State was directed to complete the entire exercise within a particular period. Therefore, although the invitation for fresh application was made but in true sense a priority was given to such candidate in view of certain factual aspects available therein. So far as the second judgment reported in (1990) 3 SCC 280 (supra) is concerned, the order is not made on concession but on two positive principles have been set up that acceptance of highest or lowest bid cannot be the criteria of best deal by any State machinery and rejection of any, should be supported by reasons. I am strongly rely upon the ratio of such judgment because some of the factual aspects of the matter are leading this Court to that extent. Various materials of discrimination in accepting the tender Nos. 7 and 8 and rejecting the item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 are available. It is to be remembered that if tenders are opened it should be opened in front of everybody and in such case subsequent chance should not be given to the parties to avail further opportunity because the same can affect the right of other tenderers. Offer of 56.92% below the estimated rate in respect of item Nos. 7 and 8 are absolutely absurd offer. The story of stilling documents etc. appears to be concocted for such fictitious rate. Price subsequently quoted being 12.98% below the estimated rate should not be allowed in such circumstances. But when the similar case has been made out by one of the parties in respect of item No. 1 the same was ignored. It is also surprising that the lower offered rates being 25.1% and 22.24% below than the estimated rates were accepted with a plea that governmental money can be saved by such process and since the petitioners have offered only less than 6.2%, 5.3%, 2.75%, 2.5% and 1.3% respectively below the estimated rate, therefore, such bids cannot be accepted. One should be open minded in respect of accepting or rejecting the offer. An explanation in affidavit giving a comparison in between different items cannot be the appropriate explanation as alleged or at all. The process, which has been challenged here can be given a room for consideration but all items are different from each other so far the prices are concerned, lengths and breadths of the roads, use of materials and various other factors are to be considered in accepting or rejecting such tender. As because one has given such lesser offer than the estimated rate in one item the same cannot be the guidelines for the purpose of rejection of tender in respect of other item in the garb of saving the governmental money. There is a serious question as to whether the governmental money will be saved for once or perpetually. Saving of governmental money cannot be the sole consideration. Saving of money vis-a-vis the quality of work is the matter of consideration. For this reason this Court as well as the Supreme Court repeatedly held that acceptance of lowest or highest bid can be refused. The explanation in the affidavit is a legal expert's opinion in the name of the deponent but not fact-oriented. In case of saving more than 30 to 40 lakhs one has to explain the cost of each project. But no project cost has not been given thereunder. Therefore, such explanation is vague. Moreover, explanation by way of affidavit cannot be an appropriate explanation unless and until it is backed by reasons. It is to be remembered that the Court is considering the decision making process. The affidavit has been filed by an upper division assistant of the concerned Zilla Parishad. Therefore, how far it is to be believed is also a big question before the Court of law. Why the authorities have not come forward in filing an appropriate affidavit is best known to them. There are so many questions in respect of the best deal on the part of the authority. The rejection is neither backed by reasons nor communicated.

9. Therefore, taking into the totality of the matter I am of the view that the decision of the Tender and Purchase Committee of the Zilla Parishad in respect of item Nos. 1, 2, 5, 6 and 9 cannot be sustained.

10. Therefore, the same is set aside with a direction upon such Committee to reconsider this issue upon giving fullest opportunities of hearing to the parties and by passing a reasoned order afresh within a period of one month from the date of communication of this order. For the purpose of effective adjudication a copy of the writ petition with annexures as well as the copy of the affidavits with all annexures can also be treated as part and parcel of documents for consideration. Till one week after taking the decision and communication of the same to the petitioners, no effect or further effect in respect of the tenders, if any, will be given by the authority concerned. During the period of consideration if the authority concerned find that the petitioners' offer is justifiable, the same can be accepted by such authority irrespective of passing any reasoned orders.

11. Thus, the writ petition stands disposed of. No order is passed as to costs.

12. Let an urgent xeroxed certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the learned Advocates for the parties within one week from the date of putting the requisites.

Order accordingly.