Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nilmoni Mazumdar v. Smt. Sanghamitra Mazumdar .

Calcutta High Court
Jul 9, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion arises from an application made by the appellant for a stay of a judgment in an appeal which challenges an order passed under Section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 (HM Act). The appeal lies to the High Court under Section 28(2) of the HM Act. Counsel for the appellant argued that Order 41 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC) did not apply to this appeal because the right of appeal under the special statute (HM Act) is a special right available without an admission hearing. The Court asked Mr. Jyotirmoy Bhattacharyya and Mr. Jiban Ratan Chatterjee to assist on the question. The Court examined the relationship between Section 21 of the HM Act (which adopts the CPC "as far as possible") and the Appellate Side Rules (AS Rules) of the High Court and directed that the records be placed before the appropriate Court for a hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC, subject to that Court's permission.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal under Section 28(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 is required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, or whether it is exempt from that procedure because it arises under a special statute.
  2. Whether an application for an interim order (stay) in such an appeal can be taken up before the hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 has been held, given that Order 41 Rule 11 contemplates the possibility of summary dismissal without notice to the respondent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the appeal under Section 28(2) of the HM Act is a special right of appeal created by a special statute and therefore does not require a hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC.
  • It was argued that the right of appeal is available without any prior admission hearing, and consequently Order 41 Rule 11 CPC cannot apply to such an appeal.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any opposing party's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lalit Chandra Dhar v. Abdul Rauf, AIR 1988 Calcutta 15 (Division Bench) Held that Order 41 Rule 11 of the CPC may be made applicable to appeals under a special statute by the Appellate Side Rules; Rule 11 does not determine admission of an appeal but enables summary dismissal without notice; Appellate Side Rules can require posting for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 even for appeals under other statutes (here, S. 75(3) of the Provincial Insolvency Act). The Court applied the same principle to an appeal under Section 28(2) of the HM Act, treating Lalit Chandra Dhar as directly analogous and persuasive on the point that Appellate Side Rules may make Order 41 Rule 11 applicable to such appeals.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in a sequence tied to statutory text and the Appellate Side Rules:

  1. Section 21 of the HM Act expressly prescribes that proceedings under the HM Act shall, "as far as possible," be regulated by the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). Therefore, the CPC provisions are applicable to proceedings under the HM Act unless the HM Act or rules made under it provide otherwise.
  2. Even if it were assumed (but not admitted) that the CPC could be excluded, the Court noted that the High Court's procedure is governed by its Appellate Side Rules (AS Rules), and such AS Rules cannot be excluded by implication.
  3. The Court examined Chapter V Rule 17 of the AS Rules. Rule 17(a) lists categories of appeals that may be admitted without being set down for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC (for example, appeals from original decrees). Rule 17(b) addresses other appeals and contemplates that after admission they shall be posted for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC. The appeals specifically exempted in clause (a) do not include appeals under Section 28(2) HM Act.
  4. An appeal under Section 28(2) HM Act is an appeal against an order (not an appeal from an original decree) and does not fall within the exemptions in Rule 17(a) or the specific exclusions referenced by Rule 17(b). Consequently, such an appeal is required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC in accordance with Rule 17(b).
  5. The Court stated the general principle that a special statute may create a special remedy, but the normal procedural rules for the Court will apply to appeals under that special statute unless there is an express provision in the statute or in the Court's procedural rules excluding the normal procedure. No such express exclusion appears in the HM Act or its rules for the present context.
  6. The Court relied on the reasoning of the Division Bench in Lalit Chandra Dhar v. Abdul Rauf (AIR 1988 Cal. 15) which held that Rule 11 of Order 41 does not deal with admission of appeals but permits summary dismissal without notice and that Appellate Side Rules can make Rule 11 applicable to appeals under other statutes where there is no incompatible provision in the special statute.
  7. Given that an appeal under Section 28(2) HM Act is susceptible to summary dismissal under Order 41 Rule 11 (i.e., it may be dismissed at threshold without notice), the Court held that an application for an interim order (such as a stay) cannot properly be taken up before the hearing under Rule 11. An interim order can be made only where there is a prima facie case; the Rule 11 hearing (if not dispensed with) is the stage where the prima facie viability of the appeal is determined prior to issuing any interim relief.
  8. On that basis the Court directed that the records be placed before the appropriate Court for a hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC, subject to that Court's permission.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that an appeal under Section 28(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 is required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908.

Direct consequences and practical implications explicitly stated in the opinion:

  • The application for an interim order (stay) cannot be taken up or finally considered until the appeal has been considered under Order 41 Rule 11, because the appeal is liable to be summarily rejected at that stage without notice to the respondent.
  • The Court directed that the records be placed before the appropriate Court for hearing under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC, subject to that Court's permission; and ordered accordingly.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel general precedent beyond applying existing principles and the authority of the cited Division Bench decision; it addresses the procedural question as between the HM Act, the CPC and the High Court's Appellate Side Rules in the particular context of the present appeal.

Show all summary ...

D.K Seth, J.:— The learned Counsel for the appellant had made an application for stay of the judgment in an appeal arising out of an order passed under S. 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 (HM Act). Sub-sec. (2) of S. 28 of HM Act provides for an appeal to a Court to which the appeal lies from the Court having original jurisdiction. In this case, admittedly, appeal lies to the High Court. Section 21 of the HM Act prescribes application of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC) as far as possible. It is contended on behalf of the appellant that this appeal does not require any hearing under Order 41 rule 11 of CPC, since it is a special right of appeal provided under the special statute. The right of appeal is available without any admission of the appeal. According to him, Order 41 rule 11 of CPC cannot apply in respect of such an appeal.

2. Mr. Jyotirmoy Bhattacharyya was along with Mr. Jiban Ratan Chatterjee were requested to assist the Court on the question. The Court records its appreciation of the assistance rendered by them.

3. Since S. 21 of the HM Act specifically makes it clear that all proceedings subject to the provisions contained in HM Act shall be regulated, as far as may be, by CPC. There having been no procedure provided in the Act or any Rules framed thereunder including application under Order 41 rule 11 of CPC, the application thereof cannot be excepted. At the same time, the procedure in the High Court is governed by the Appellate Side Rules (AS Rules). Even if the application, though assuming but not admitting, of CPC can be excluded, still then the application of the AS Rules cannot be excluded.

4. Under the AS Rules, Chapter V Rule 17 provisions have been made for admission of appeals specified in clause (a) thereof without being required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 CPC. The appeals, which are included in clause (a) do not include an appeal under S. 28 sub-sec. (2) of HM Act. Clause (b) of Rule 17 Chapter V of AS Rules prescribes that all other appeals excepting the appeals in clause (b) are required to be set down for hearing under Order-41 Rule 11 CPC. The appeals mentioned in clause (b) of AS Rules, are those, which were excluded, are the same referred to in clause (a). Section 28 sub-sec. (1) of HM Act refers to the decree, which is an original decree, which, by reason of Order 41 CPC is required to be set down for hearing under Rule 11. But by reason of Chapter V Rule 17 clause (a) of AS Rules, the same can be admitted without hearing under Order 41 rule 11 CPC by the Stamp Reporter as an appeal from original decree. An appeal under S. 28(2) of HM Act is an appeal against an order, though not an appeal under Order 43 CPC, yet the miscellaneous appeal not being an appeal from original decree and not being an appeal exempted under clause (a) or clause (b) of Rule 17 Chapter V of AS Rules, is required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 of CPC. The application of Order 41 rule 11 CPC cannot be excluded.

5. A special Statute may provide special remedy. Unless special provision or procedure governing such appeal is specifically made, the normal rules of procedure applicable to such Courts are applicable. Normal procedure applicable to a Court in respect of an appeal under a special statute, can be excluded only by express provision made in such statute or by express provision made in the rules governing the procedure of such Court. As observed above, by reason of Order 41 rule 11 CPC, such an appeal is required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 CPC.

6. Such a view was taken by a Division Bench of this court in Lalit Chandra Dhar v. Abdul Rauf reported in AIR 1988 Calcutta 15 in respect of an appeal under S. 75(3) of the Provincial Insolvency Act. The same principle can be applied to an appeal under S. 28(2) of the HM Act. We may beneficially refer to the observation made therein, particularly, in paragraph 6, 7 and 8 as quoted below:—

“6. But does Rule 11 of Order 41 provide for admission of appeal? Does the Court, under Rule 11, decide as to whether an appeal is to be admitted or not? It appears that an impression has gained ground that a Court really admits an appeal, particularly, a Second Appeal and also a first Miscellaneous Appeal, only after hearing the same under Rule 11 of Order 41. But the impression is wholly erroneous. The appeal cannot but stand admitted at a stage anterior to its hearing under Rule 11 and the Rule only enables the Court to dismiss the appeal at an early stage without sending notice to the lower Court and without serving notice to the respondent. As the rule makes it irresistibly clear, what is determined in a hearing under rule 11 is not whether the appeal is to be admitted, but whether the appeal, which cannot but already stand admitted, is to be dismissed. As the new Rule 11A, inserted by the 1976 Amendment, now makes it further clear, what is heard under Rule 11 is the appeal itself and not the question of its admission. This position would emerge with greater clarity from the relevant provisions of the Appellate Side Rules of this Court Part II, Chapter V Rule 17 and Chapter IX, Rule 79. Rule 17(a) and Rule 79 as aforesaid dispense with any hearing under Order 41, rule 11 of the Code in respect of appeals from Original Decrees and appeals under Workmen's Compensation Act, appeals from Orders under Article 226 of the Constitution, appeals from the decision of the Claims Commissioner under the Indian Railway Act and appeals from the Award of Claims Tribunal under the Motor Vehicles Act, it is provided that in respect of any such appeal, the concerned Department “shall…. admit it and cause it to be registered and to issue notice to the respondent” and it is obvious that if an appeal is to be admitted only on a hearing under Rule 11 of Order 41 of the Code, such a hearing could not be dispensed with and the appeal could not be admitted without such hearing, rule 17(b) provides for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 in respect of appeals from Appellate Decrees and from Orders other than those mentioned above, but clearly provides for admission of such appeal before being placed for hearing under Order 41 rule 11, the relevant words being “shall admit it, cause it to be registered and posted to a Bench for hearing under Order XLI Rule 11 of Civil Procedure Code.

7. The very word may in Order 41 rule 11 cannot but indicate that the Court may or may not hear a matter under Rule 11, and the hearing under the said Rule could not thus be made optional if the same was to be the only channel through which an appeal can be routed in. We should, therefore, have no doubt that rule 11 does not provide for any hearing as to the admission of the appeal and we accordingly repel the contention of Mr. Mitra that if an appeal, for which leave has been granted under S. 75(3) of the Provincial Insolvency Act, is again placed for hearing under Order 41, rule 11 that would amount to another admission hearing, and, therefore, the application of Order 41 rule 11 should be held to be impliedly barred under S. 5(2) of the Provincial Insolvency Act.

8. But even assuming that S. 5(2) of the Provincial Insolvency Act does not make Order 41, rule 11 of the Code applicable to an appeal under S. 75(3) of the said Act, we would still have to hold that the same has been made applicable by the relevant Appellate Side Rules of this Court. rule 17(b) of the Rules, referred to hereinabove, clearly provides that “an appeal from an Appellate Decree or an appeal from an order, other than an appeal under the Workmen's Compensation Act and appeal from an Order under Art. 226 of the Constitution”. Shall after admission and registration be “posted to a Bench for hearing under Order XLI Rule 11 Civil Procedure Code.” As already noted, under Rule 79 (part II, Chapter IX) of the Appellate Side Rules, appeals from the decision of the Claims Commissioner, under the Indian Railways Act and appeals from the Award of Claims Tribunal, under the Motor Vehicles Act have also been excluded from the operation of rule 17(b). Be that as it may, according to these provisions of the Appellate Side Rules, an order appealable under S. 75(3) of the Provincial Insolvency Act, not thus being excluded, will be required to be placed for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 of the Code. It is true that, on its own force, Order 41 can apply only to a decree under the Civil Procedure Code and to such orders as are appealable under the Civil Procedure Code under S. 104 read with Order 43 hereof and it is obvious that an order appealable under S. 75(3) of the Provincial Insolvency Act is neither a decree nor an appealable order under the Code. But the provisions of Order 41 may be made applicable to other appeals also by suitable legislative provision to that effect and Rule 17 of the Appellate Side Rules is such a legislative provision. The Appellate Side Rules have all the authorities of a legislation or statutory law under the provisions of the Charger Act, Clause 36 of the Letters Patent, S. 122 of the Civil Procedure Code and under Article 225 of the Constitution and since Rules 17 of the Appellate Side Rules has made the provisions of Order 41 rule 11 of the Code applicable to various appeals including appeals from an Order under the Provincial Insolvency Act, its application cannot be resisted, particularly, in the absence of any contrary or corresponding provision in the Provincial Insolvency Act. As already noted, we have found no such provision in the Provincial Insolvency Act which is incompatible with the application of Order 41, rule 11 of the Code to appeals under that Act and therefore, its application to such appeals cannot, in our view, be doubted or disputed.

7. Thus, the appeal under S. 28 sub-sec. (2) of HM Act required to be set down for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 CPC.

8. Until such hearing is effected, the application for stay cannot be taken up. Inasmuch as, no interim order can be passed in an appeal which is liable to be summarily rejected without sending notice to the respondent. The application if taken up and interim order is passed, then notice of the application is to be sent. Whereas the dismissal of the appeal under Order 41 rule 11 is contemplated without sending notice to the respondent. An interim order can be passed only if there is a prima facie case. Hearing of the appeal without being dismissed at the threshold before issuing notice determines the prima facie case for issuing interim order. The AS Rules also provides for setting down of the appeal for hearing under Order 41 immediately after it is found in order on its presentation.

9. Let the records be placed before the appropriate Court for hearing under Order 41 rule 11 CPC, subject to its permission.

Order accordingly.

Provincial Insolvency Act.