Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Poysha Industrial Company, Ltd. v. Union Of India And Others

Calcutta High Court
Aug 11, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition challenges an order passed under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, West Bengal, Andaman & Nicobar Islands dated 13 December 1993 and communicated to the petitioner by memo dated 25 January 1994.

The petitioner is a company operating a factory at Budge Budge Trunk Road (Post Office Maheshtolla), District 24 Parganas (S), engaged in manufacturing. The petitioner sought a separate provident fund (PF) code number for the Budge Budge factory. The opinion records that initially a separate code number was not allotted; the petitioner deposited Rs. 41,987.30 towards PF dues for the period September 1987 to July 1988 and informed the PF authorities on 31 August 1988. The opinion contains two references to the date of allotment of a separate code number (the text records both "11 November 1988" and elsewhere "11 December 1988").

After a payment and (according to the petitioner) regular subsequent contributions, the petitioner was served a notice under S. 14-B and the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner assessed damages of Rs. 33,419 and levied the same. The petitioner contended initial delay in depositing PF dues (1987–1989) was due to non-receipt of a code number.

Separately, the petitioner was declared a "sick industrial company" by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) by an order dated 26 October 1993 (the opinion references S. 3(1)(o) / S. 3(1)(2) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985), and a rehabilitation scheme under S. 17 was said to be pending before BIFR. The petitioner claimed that proceedings by respondents were barred by S. 22(1) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act.

The petitioner filed the writ petition seeking a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to withdraw/cancel/rescind the impugned notice/order dated 13 December 1993.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner can be held liable for delayed payment of provident fund contributions for the period 1986–1989 on the ground that a separate PF code number was not allotted to its Budge Budge unit.
  2. Whether proceedings under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 can be instituted or damages levied against an establishment which has been declared a sick industrial company by the BIFR and in respect of which a rehabilitation scheme under S. 17 is pending, in view of S. 22(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985.
  3. Whether the impugned order of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner dated 13 December 1993 should be quashed or set aside because the BIFR's order and the company's sick status were not taken into account when assessing damages under S. 14-B.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Appellant) — summarized submissions

  • The petitioner could not be saddled with responsibility for non-payment of PF dues for the period December 1986 to December 1988 because the PF code number was supplied only on 11 December 1988 (the opinion also elsewhere records 11 November 1988).
  • By an order dated 26 October 1993, the BIFR declared the company to be a sick industrial company and a scheme under S. 17 was pending; under S. 22(1) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act, no proceeding for execution, distress or the like against the property of the industrial company shall lie except with the consent of the Board — therefore the proceedings under S. 14-B were barred and the impugned order should be quashed.
  • Reference was made to Gram Panchayat v. Vallabh Glass Works Ltd. (1990) 2 SCC 440; A.I.R. 1990 S.C. 1017 to support the proposition that S. 22(1) bars certain recovery proceedings during pendency of S. 16/17 matters before BIFR.

Respondents — summarized submissions

  • The Calcutta (Budge Budge) unit was part and parcel of the principal establishment in Maharashtra; therefore non-allotment of a separate code number initially did not excuse non-payment — the petitioner could have used the principal establishment's code number to deposit contributions.
  • The plea of sickness cannot absolve the petitioner from the statutory obligation to make timely payment of PF dues.
  • The respondents were not informed that the company had been declared a sick industrial company by the BIFR, and therefore S. 22(1) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act could not be invoked as a bar to recovery.
  • The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner acted in accordance with law under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act; consequently the impugned order should not be interfered with.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gram Panchayat v. Vallabh Glass Works Ltd., (1990) 2 SCC 440 : A.I.R. 1990 S.C. 1017 Held that during the pendency of proceedings under Ss. 16 and 17 of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act, a proceeding to recover property tax under S. 129 of the Bombay Village Panchayat Act, 1958, shall not lie against the company without consent of the BIFR, by virtue of S. 22(1) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act. The Court considered this decision but distinguished it: it concluded that the Gram Panchayat decision did not apply to proceedings under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act because S. 14-B had been amended (Amendment Act 33 of 1988) to include a proviso empowering the Central Board to reduce or waive damages for establishments declared sick and in respect of which a BIFR-sanctioned rehabilitation scheme exists. Thus the precedent could not be applied to bar S. 14-B proceedings in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed the competing contentions in a step-by-step manner.

  1. On the contention that non-allotment of a separate PF code absolved the petitioner of responsibility for delayed payments, the court rejected that ground. It reasoned that the Budge Budge unit was part of the principal establishment already covered in Maharashtra, and the petitioner could have deposited contributions under the principal establishment's code number by showing the Budge Budge unit as a branch. The later allotment of a separate code for administrative convenience did not justify failure to deposit amounts in time.
  2. The court noted that the impugned order assessed damages of Rs. 33,419 under S. 14-B. The opinion records that, under the law, damages under S. 14-B "can be assessed up to KM) per cent of the amount due" (as recorded in the impugned order text). The court further observed that a submission had been made on behalf of the petitioner that the establishment was sick and payment could not be made in time.
  3. The court examined the BIFR order dated 26 October 1993, which declared the company a sick industrial company under S. 3(1)(o) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act and indicated that BIFR considered rehabilitation practicable and had passed orders under S. 17(2). The court found that this significant fact had not been considered by the Provident Fund Authorities when assessing damages under S. 14-B. It observed that had the PF authorities been made aware of the BIFR determination and the possibility of rehabilitation, different findings might have resulted.
  4. In addressing the contention based on S. 22(1) of the S.I.C. (S.P.) Act and the Gram Panchayat decision, the court distinguished the Gram Panchayat precedent. It found that subsection S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds Act had been amended by Amendment Act 33 of 1988 to add a proviso empowering the Central Board to reduce or waive damages levied under S. 14-B in relation to an establishment that is a sick industrial company and in respect of which a BIFR-sanctioned rehabilitation scheme exists, subject to terms specified in the scheme. Because S. 14-B contains a specific procedure and a statutory mechanism (Central Board's power) for dealing with establishments in this position, the writ court should not supplant or interfere with the Central Board's jurisdiction to reduce or waive damages where Parliament has provided a specific route.
  5. Nevertheless, the court concluded that in the present case the Central Board's (or the appropriate authority's) jurisdiction had not been properly exercised because the PF authorities had not considered the BIFR declaration and the sanctioned scheme. Given that omission, the court found it necessary to set aside the impugned order and remit the matter for fresh consideration by the appropriate authority, directing that a reasoned order be passed in light of the observations made by the court.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition was disposed of by the court by setting aside the impugned order of the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner dated 13 December 1993 and referring the matter back to the appropriate authority for fresh disposal. The court directed that the authority pass a reasoned order in the light of the observations made in the judgment within two months from the date of the order.

Specific Orders and Consequences for the Parties:

  • The impugned assessment/levy of damages (Rs. 33,419 as assessed under S. 14-B) was set aside pending reconsideration.
  • The matter is remitted to the appropriate authority (the Provident Fund authority / Central Board procedure as applicable) to consider the petitioner’s status as a BIFR-declared sick industrial company and the existence/relevance of any sanctioned rehabilitation scheme, and to apply the procedure under S. 14-B (including the proviso added by Amendment Act 33 of 1988) before assessing or deciding on reduction/waiver of damages.
  • There was no order as to costs.
  • Xerox copies of the order were to be supplied to learned advocates on usual undertakings.

The court also observed, as part of its reasoning, that ordinarily a Writ Court should not interfere with the jurisdiction conferred on the Central Board by the proviso to S. 14-B; but because the authority had not exercised that statutory jurisdiction after due consideration of the BIFR order and the sanctioned scheme, interference by setting aside and remitting was warranted. The opinion does not record any broader novel precedent beyond this application of the statutory scheme and the remittal for proper administrative consideration.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. This writ petition is directed against the order (under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. dated 13 December 1993) passed by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, West Bengal, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, which was communicated to the petitioner by Memo No. A/O45.WB/25896.Damage/50/35, dated 25 January 1994.

2. The petitioner-company's case is that it has its factory at Budge Budge Trunk Road, Post Office — Maheshtolla, District - 24 Parganas(S). The company was having business of manufacturing different types of goods. It was alleged that it wanted a separate provident fund code number. The said authorities did not allot the same initially for its Budge Budge factory. Petitioner thereafter deposited a sum of Rs. 41,987.30 paise with the Provident Fund Authorities towards its provident fund dues from September 1987 to July 1988 and the said authorities was informed about the matter on 31 August 1988. On 11 November 1988 a separate code number being WB/25896 was allotted in the name of the petitioner. The petitioner further alleged the after the payment of above mentioned amount the petitioner was regularly depositing the provident fund contribution as required under the provisions of law. The petitioner's further case is that the initial delay in depositing the provident fund contribution from 1987 to 1989 was mainly due to the non-receipt of the code number. The petitioner was thereafter served with a notice under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (hereinafter to be stated as the Act) and the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner without proper consideration of the said fact assessed such damage at Rs. 33,419 levied the same on the petitioner. The further case of the petitioner is that the employees were recruited from 1 April 1987, so they could not be brought under the purview of the Act with effect from December 1986. It was further alleged that the company is a sick unit and the case of the petitioner was referred to the Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (in short BIFR). The proceeding was started by Case No. 58 of 198.3 On 26 October 1993 the company was declared to the sick industrial company within the meaning of S. 3(1)(2) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (in short S.I.C (S.P) Act). It was also alleged that the matter is now pending for final disposal before the Bench of the BIFR. It was accordingly claimed that the respondent authorities cannot take any step against the petitioner under S. 22(1) of the S.I.C (S.P) Act, 1985. The petitioner accordingly filed the writ application praying for rule in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondents to withdraw/cancel/rescind impugned notice.

3. In the affidavit-in-opposition it is alleged by the respondents that the Calcutta unit of the petitioner was started as a part and parcel of its principal establishment in Maharashtra and so though no separate code number could be issued initially still such code number was allotted subsequently to the petitioner for administrative reasons. The petitioner did not pay the provident fund contribution within due date. It was further alleged that the plea of sickness of the company, even if true, cannot absorb the petitioner from the responsibility of making the payment of statutory dues in time. It was also alleged that the respondent were not informed that the company was declared as a sick industrial company.

4. Sri L.C Bihani, learned advocate appearing with Ms. Suchandra Mukherjee, submitted that since admittedly the code number was supplied to the petitioner-company by the respondent authority on 11 December 1988 it could not be a saddled with the responsibility of non-payment of provident fund dues in time from December 1986 to December 1988.

5. The main thrust of Sri Bihani's argument, however, is that by an order, dated 26 October 1993, the Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction declared the company as a sick industrial company within the meaning of S. 3(1)(o) of the S.I.C(S.P) Act and that a scheme referred to under S. 17 is pending in the matter. He further submitted that under S. 22(1) of the S.I.C (S.P) Act no proceeding for execution, distress or the like against any of the properties of the industrial company shall lie except with the consent of the Board. He accordingly prayed for quashing the said proceeding as the impugned order was passed on 13 December 1993 while the scheme under S. 17(2) was under preparation and consideration at the relevant time.

6. Sri Swapan Kumar Dutta, learned advocate for the respondents, submitted that the non-receipt of the code number cannot be a ground for deferred payment of provident fund dues as it was a part and parcel of the company registered at Maharashtra which had its code number. The subsequent allotment of code number, therefore, cannot be a ground for non-payment of the provident fund dues in time. Regarding the question of industry being sick it was contended that the respondent authorities having not been intimated about any proceeding before BIFR that the provision under S. 22(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, shall not be a bar to the realisation of its statutory dues. It was further contended that the respondent authority having acted in terms of law under S. 14-B of “the Act” that the order passed by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner cannot be challenged.

7. Heard the submissions of the learned advocates on both sides. Regarding the first point taken by the petitioner that the provident fund dues of the workers from December 1986 to April 1989 amounting to Rs. 1,89,655.86 paise would not be deposited in time due to the failure by the Provident Fund Authorities to allot a code number cannot be accepted as a valid ground in view of the fact that the principal company of which the petitioner company is only a branch was originally covered in the State of Maharashtra, the petitioner-company could have deposited the amount in the code number of the principal establishment showing it as a branch of the same. Separate code number having been allotted for administrative convenience and on the prayer of the petitioner-company that cannot be taken as a ground for not depositing the amount within time.

8. In the impugned order it appears the sum of Rs. 33,419 has been assessed as damages under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. Under the law such damage can be assessed up to KM) per cent of the amount due. It appears from the impugned order that a submission was made on behalf of the petitioner-company that the establishment was sick and the payment could not be made in time. It is a fact that the company was undergoing losses at the relevant time. As a matter of fact from the order dated 26 October 1993, it appears that the company was declared as a sick industrial company within the meaning of S. 3(1)(o) of the S.I.C (S.P) Act. It also appears from said order hat the BIFR considered that it is practicable for the company to make its net worth positive within the reasonable time and accordingly passed necessary order for the purpose under S. 17(2) of the Act. This aspect of the matter was not taken into consideration by the Provident Fund Authorities in passing the impugned order. Had this fact been pointed to the respondent authorities while assessing damages under S. 14-B of the Act different findings might have been arrived at in the matter.

9. It was contended on behalf of the respondent authorities that the existence of the aforesaid order of BIFR was not brought into the notice of the respondent authorities at the time when the matter was heard and disposed of on 13 December 1993. There is no mention in the impugned order itself that this fact was brought to the notice of the authorities concerned. It was contended on behalf of the petitioner that it is immaterial whether the order of the BIFR was brought to the notice of the respondent authorities or not in view of the fact under S. 22(1) of the S.I.C (S.P) Act, 1986, no proceeding under any law for winding up of the industrial company or for execution, distress or the like against any of the properties of the industrial company or for the appointment of the receiver in respect thereof shall lie or be proceeded with further, except with the consent of the Board or, or as the case may be, the appellate authority. Reference was made in this connection to the decision of Gram Panchayat v. Vallabh Glass Works, Ltd. [(1990) 2 SCC 440 : A.I.R 1990 S.C 1017], where it was held that during the pendency of the proceedings under Ss. 16 and 17 of S.I.C (S.P) Act, 1985, against a company, a proceeding to recover property tax under S. 129 of the Bombay Village Panchayat Act, 1958, shall not lie against the said company without consent of the BIFR, in view of Sub-sec. (1) of S. 22 of the Act. This decision, however, can have no application to a proceeding under S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act. By the Amendment Act 33 of 1988, the said provision was amended by addition of a further proviso to the effect that the Central Board may reduce or waive damages levied under this section in relation to an establishment which is a sick industrial company and in respect of which a scheme for rehabilitation has been sanctioned by the Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction established under S. 4 of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, subject to such terms and conditions as may be specified in the scheme. This amendment was made after the enforcement of S. 22 of S.I.C (S.P) Act. Since no such provision was present in Bombay Village Panchayat Act that the provision of S. 22(1) of the S.I.C (S.P) Act was applied. The second proviso of S. 14-B of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act having specifically laid down the procedure to be followed in relation to an establishment having similar position like the present, and the Central Board being vested with the power to waive or reduce the damage under the said provision, the Writ Court shall not and cannot interfere in exercise of such jurisdiction by the Central Board according to law. But the said jurisdiction of the Central Board having not been exercised properly in the instance case upon consideration of the fact that the petitioner establishment is a sick industrial company and in respect of which a scheme of rehabilitation has been sanctioned by the BIFR that this Court has no other alternative but to set aside the impugned order and refer the matter back to the appropriate authority for disposal of the matter by passing a reasoned order in the light of the observation made above within two months from the date of this order.

10. The writ petition is disposed of accordingly.

11. There will be no order an to costs.

12. Let xerox copies of this order be handed over to the learned advocates for the parties on usual undertakings.