- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Orient Paper & Industries Ltd. v. Union Of India & Others
Summary of the Judgment
Factual and Procedural Background
Between August 1961 and May 1968 a dispute arose over the classification of M.G. Poster Paper manufactured by the petitioner. The Central Excise authorities treated the paper as packing/wrapping paper assessable under Tariff Item 17(4); the petitioner contended it was printing/writing paper assessable under Tariff Item 17(3). Duties were collected by the authorities under Tariff Item 17(4) and paid by the petitioner under protest.
The petitioner appealed through the appellate authorities and ultimately the matter reached the Supreme Court, which on 3 May 1968 remanded the cases to the Collector for fresh decision. The Appellate Collector of Central Excise, by an order dated 30 November 1973, decided 32 appeals in favour of the petitioner. The Government of India reviewed those orders and on 30 September 1976 set aside the order dated 30 November 1973 and directed the Appellate Collector to decide the matters afresh.
The Appellate Collector again heard the appeals and, by orders dated 9 June 1980 and 10 July 1980, held that M.G. Poster Paper should be classified as printing/writing paper and not as packing/wrapping paper, directing that consequential reliefs be granted. The petitioner applied on 23 July 1980 to the Assistant Collector for implementation of those orders. The Assistant Collector, by order dated 3 October 1980, refused to grant refund on two grounds: (1) the appellate orders did not categorically state that a refund of excise duty was to be granted; and (2) the petitioner had passed on the entire amount of the duty to its customers, so any refund to the petitioner would be a fortuitous benefit.
The Assistant Collector rejected the claim for refund. Interim judicial steps followed: by an interim order in December 1980 the Assistant Collector was directed to quantify consequential reliefs by 15 January 1981; when this did not occur the matter was adjourned and ultimately an order directed the respondents to refund Rs. 1,31,15,326.57 to the petitioner upon the petitioner furnishing a bank guarantee. The amount was stated to have been refunded to the petitioner and the bank guarantee kept renewed in terms of the interim orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether M.G. Poster Paper was correctly classified as printing/writing paper (Tariff Item 17(3)) rather than packing/wrapping paper (Tariff Item 17(4)).
- Whether, having succeeded before the Appellate Collector who directed "consequential reliefs", the petitioner was entitled to a refund of excise duty unlawfully realised from it.
- Whether the Assistant Collector could refuse consequential relief (refund) on the basis that the petitioner had passed on the duty to its customers and refunding the petitioner would result in a fortuitous benefit or unjust enrichment.
- Whether the fact that excise duty was collected under compulsion bars the petitioner from obtaining a refund once the appellate authority finds the levy erroneous.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The M.G. Poster Paper should be classified as printing/writing paper under Tariff Item 17(3), and the Appellate Collector's orders (9 June 1980 and 10 July 1980) so held.
- The appellate orders directed that "consequential reliefs be granted" and, in the context of appeals against classification and levy of duty, consequential reliefs necessarily mean refund of the duty unlawfully realized.
- The petitioner had paid duty under protest and preferred appeals; because the levy was found erroneous, the petitioner was entitled to refund of the amounts paid under protest.
- There is nothing unlawful or morally wrong in seeking refund of an unlawful levy; the petitioner paid the duty under compulsion of law.
Respondents' / Assistant Collector's Arguments
- The appellate orders directed "consequential reliefs" but did not categorically state that a refund of excise duty was to be granted.
- The petitioner had sold poster papers to many customers and had realised the excise duty in full from those customers; therefore any refund to the petitioner would be a fortuitous benefit which could not be passed on to the actual consumers who had already borne the burden.
- If any customer were to claim refund, a question of refund might arise in their favour, but the petitioner itself should not be refunded because it had passed on the duty.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union Carbide Company Limited v. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise, 1978 E.L.T. (J.) 190 | Principle that the State must not be permitted to retain unauthorised or illegal tax; where tax is not due but realised by the State, it should be refunded to avoid unjust enrichment and to maintain proper fiscal administration. | The court stated it was "fortified" by this judgment and cited its language to support the conclusion that unlawfully realised excise duty must be refunded and that the State cannot claim unjust enrichment by retaining such sums. |
| Khardah Co. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors., 1983 E.L.T. 2159 | Where excise duty is collected under compulsion, the assessee has a right to refund of amounts held to be excessively realised by the appellate authority; refund claims are enforceable unless barred by specific statutory provisions. | The court noted this decision as adopting a similar view and relied on it to support the conclusion that the petitioner, having paid under compulsion and succeeded on appeal, acquired a right to get back amounts realised in excess. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in a series of logical steps, grounded in the text of the appellate orders and established principles:
- The Appellate Collector had set aside the orders under appeal and directed that "consequential reliefs be granted" to the appellants. In the particular context of an appeal against classification and consequential levy of duty, the court reasoned that "consequential reliefs" can only mean refund of the duty that had been collected from the appellant and found unlawful. The appellant had succeeded on classification; consequently the only feasible relief flowing from that success was refund of unlawfully realised duty.
- The Assistant Collector lacked jurisdiction to restrict the operative effect of the Appellate Collector's orders by refusing to grant the refund on the ground that the petitioner had realised the duty from its customers. By so doing, the Assistant Collector effectively refused to implement the Appellate Collector's direction and thus acted without jurisdiction and erroneously.
- The court rejected the respondents' argument that refund should be denied because the petitioner had passed on the burden to customers. The court observed that the petitioner paid duty under protest and pursued statutory appeals; if a levy was held erroneous by the appellate authority, the Excise Authority had to refund the unlawfully realised amounts. The Excise Authority cannot retain any amount of tax unlawfully gathered from a taxpayer.
- The court also addressed the contention about unlawful enrichment: it found this argument unpersuasive. The court explained that payment of excise duties often occurs under compulsion of law (goods cannot be removed or sold until duty is paid), and that the statutory right of appeal exists to redress unlawful levies. Denying refund would result in unlawful enrichment of the Government and would undermine fiscal administration.
- The court reinforced its conclusion by citing precedents (Union Carbide and Khardah Co. Ltd.) which support the proposition that the State must refund taxes unlawfully realised and that an assessee who paid under compulsion is entitled to refund once the appellate authority finds excessive or erroneous realisation.
- Given that an interim order had already led to quantification and an interim refund of Rs. 1,31,15,326.57 (upon the petitioner furnishing a bank guarantee), and that the Appellate Collector had directed consequential reliefs, the court concluded that the petitioner's entitlement to refund was established and that consequential reliefs must be given effect to.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court held that the petitioner is entitled to the consequential reliefs directed by the Appellate Collector, which in the context of these appeals means refund of the excise duty unlawfully realised; the rule is disposed of in the petitioner's favour and the Registrar, Appellate Side, is directed to return the bank guarantee furnished by the petitioner.
Specific orders and direct effects:
- The court directed that there be an order in terms of the petitioner's prayer (a) (i.e., implementation of consequential reliefs as directed by the Appellate Collector).
- The court noted that the sum of Rs. 1,31,15,326.57 had been refunded to the petitioner upon the petitioner's furnishing a bank guarantee and directed the Registrar, Appellate Side, to return that bank guarantee and absolved the petitioner from its undertaking to keep the bank guarantee renewed.
- The rule was disposed of finally in favour of the petitioner.
- There was no order as to costs.
- The court expressly stated that this order would not prevent the Department from realising any tax in case the Department succeeds in appeals pending in the Tribunal or in any other or further proceedings connected with the case.
Broader implications and precedent:
The opinion emphasizes the settled principle (as illustrated by cited authorities) that taxes unlawfully realised by the State must be refunded and that a taxpayer who pays under compulsion and succeeds on appeal is entitled to recover such amounts. The judgment does not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond applying these established rules; its immediate consequence is the implementation of the Appellate Collector's direction and restoration to the petitioner of amounts found to have been unlawfully collected.
JUDGMENT
1. During the period between August, 1961 and May, 1968 a dispute arose about the classification of M.G Poster Paper manufactured by the petitioner, the Central Excise authorities claimed that the M.G Poster Paper was assessable to duty under Tariff Item 17(4) as packing/wrapping paper whereas the contention of the petitioner company was that the M.G Poster Paper should be assessed to duty under tariff Item 17(3) as printing/writing paper. The Central Excise authorities collected duties on the goods manufactured by it under tariff Item 17(4) and such duties were paid by the petitioner under protest.
2. The petitioner company preferred appeals to the appellate authorities. The appellate proceedings contained for a long time. The matters went upto the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court remanded the cases back to the Collector for deciding afresh on 3rd May 1968. The Appellate Collector of Central Excise decided 32 appeals pending before him for different periods and against different orders by an order dated 30th November, 1973 in favour of the petitioner company. These appellate orders of the Appellate Collector was reviewed by the Government of India and by an order dated 30th September, 1976 the Government of India directing the Appellate Collector to decide the matters afresh after setting aside the order dated 30th November, 1973.
3. The Appellate Collector once again heard the appeals and by two several orders dated 9-6-1980 and 10-7-1980 disposed of all the appeals and held that M.G Poster Paper should be classified as printing/writing paper and not as packing/wrapping papers. The Appellate Collector directed the Excise Department to grant consequential reliefs to the petitioner in both the aforesaid orders. The petitioner on 23rd July, 1980 applied to the Assistant Collector for giving effect to the orders dated 9th June, 1980 and 10th July, 1980 passed by the Appellate Collector. The Assistant Collector by his order dated 3rd October, 1980 refused to grant refund to the petitioner on two grounds.
4. Firstly, in both the appellate orders, the learned Collector had directed to grant consequential reliefs to the appellant. But it had not been categorically stated the rein to grant the refund of excise duty.
5. The second ground was that the petitioner company sold poster papers manufactured by it to a number of customers/wholesalers. Whatever duty has been paid by the company had been realised in full from all such customers. Since the company had already passed on the entire burden of levy of excise duty to their customers from whom they had collected in full the amount of excise duty paid to the department, no refund of the said duty could be claimed by the company. If any customer of the company from whom excise duty had been collected came with a claim of refund on the ground of any duty unlawfully collected by the company, a question of refund might have arisen. But in this case, if any refund is granted to the company, it will accrue to them “as fortuitous benefit because this benefit cannot be passed on to the actual consumers of the goods who have already accepted the burden of taxation.”
6. The claim for refund, therefore, was rejected by the Assistant Collector, Central Excise and Customs, Sambalpure.
7. The Appellate Collector of Central Excise in both the orders dated 9th June, 1980 and 10th July, 1980 had set aside the orders under appeal and directed that ‘consequential reliefs be granted to the appellants’. This order has to be carried out by the Assistant Collector. Consequential reliefs in this context can only mean refund of the duty that has been collected from the appellant company. The appeal was against classification and consequential levy of duty on M.G Poster Paper. The appellant succeeded in the appeals. Consequential relief can only, mean refund of the duty unlawfully realised from the appellant. There cannot possibly be any other relief. The Assistant Collector had no jurisdiction to restrict the operative part of the order passed by the Appellate Collector and refused to grant consequential relief on the ground that the appellant lad in its turn realised the entire amount of the duty from its customers. What in effect the Assistant Collector has done is to refuse to grant consequential relief which he was specifically directed to by the Appellate Collector of Central Excise. The order of the Assistant Collector is entirely without jurisdiction and erroneous.
8. Moreover, the petitioner company cannot be refused refund of duty on the ground that the burden of duty has been passed on ultimately to its customers. The petitioner company paid the duty under protest and preferred an appeal against the levy. If the contention of the respondents is to be accepted, it has to be held that whether the petitioner company succeeds in the appeal or loses the result would be the same. The duty will not be refunded to the petitioner company in any event. The question in the appeal was whether the classification was wrongly made and duty was wrongly realised from the petitioner company. If the classification was wrong and the duty was unlawfully realised, the respondents had to refund the duty which was unlawfully realised. The Excise Authority cannot be permitted to retain any amount of tax which has been unlawfully gathered from a tax payer.
9. There is also another aspect of the case. It has been argued that if the refund application is allowed, there will be unlawful enrichment on the part of the petitioner company. I fail to appreciate this argument. It excise duty has been unlawfully realised from the petitioner and if the petitioner paid the duty under protest, the petitioner is entitled to get back whatever has been paid under protest after he succeeds in the appeal. There is nothing unlawful or morally wrong in preferring appeals against unlawful levy of duty. Otherwise, the provision for appeals become meaningless. Goods are not allowed to be removed sold by the Excise authorities until and unless the excise duty is paid. Therefore, excise levies were paid under compulsion of law by the petitioner company. The Central Excise Act, provides for appeals and the petitioner preferred appeals against what it considered unlawful levy of duty. The Appellate authority has upheld the contention of the petitioner company. If the excise authority thereafter refused to refund the amount which was unlawfully realised by the petitioner, that will be morally and legally a wrongful act. If the petitioner's claim is denied, it will be unlawful enrichment on the part of the Government.
10. I am fortified in the view that I have taken by a Judgment of Sabyasachi Mukherjee, J, in the case of Union Carbide Company Limited v. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise, 1978 E.L.T (J. 190). In that case, it was observed:
“If unjust enrichment is not to be permitted to a litigant, it should not also be permitted to the State. The State has no right to collect unauthorised tax or illegal tax. Goods fiscal administration enjoins that all lawful taxes should be properly collected and taxes which are not due if realised by the State should be refunded. Such fiscal administration alone ensures the atmosphere of tax compliance.”
11. A similar view was taken by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Khardah Co. Ltd. v. Union Of India & Ors., 1983 E.L.T 2159 where it was held that where excise duty was collected under compulsion, the assessee had a right to get the refund of duty after the appellate authority had held that excessive realisation has been made. It was observed in that case that the claim of refund of any amount realised under any authority of law was enforceable in law unless it was barred by any specific statutory provisions.
12. In the instant case, excise duty was realised from the Company under compulsion of law by the excise authority. The Appellate authority has decided that the levy of duty was erroneous in law. The order of the Appellate Authority must be implemented. In fact, the Appellate Collector has given a direction for grant of consequential reliefs to the petitioner. The petitioner has acquired a right to get back the amount that was realised in excess from the petitioner.
13. Therefore, there will be an order in terms of prayer (a).
14. By an interim order passed on December, 1980 Mukherji, 3, directed the Assistant Collector of Central Excise and Customs, Sambalpur Division, to quantify the consequential reliefs to be given to the petitioner company pursuant to the orders passed by the Appellate Collector of Central Excise on 9th June, 1980 and 10th July, 1980. The quantification was to be done within 15th January, 1981. Since it was not done on 16th January, 1981, the case was adjourned till 30th January, 1981. But the quantification was not done by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise even by January 30, 1981. Therefore, an order as passed directing the respondents to refund the sum of Rs. 1,31,15,326.57 p. to the petitioner upon furnishing a bank guarantee to the satisfaction of the Registrar, Appellate Side, the bank guarantee was to be kept renewed till the disposal of the rule.
15. It has been stated that the amount of Rs. 1,31,15,326.57 p. has been refunded to the petitioner upon the petitioner's furnishing a bank guarantee for the said amount and the bank guarantee had been kept renewed in terms, of the aforesaid interim orders dated January 30, 1981.
16. Since I have held in this case that the petitioner is entitled to succeed and the amount of refund claimed by the petitioner has already been paid by the Central Excise authority, there will be an order directing the Registrar, Appellate Side, to return the bank guarantee furnished by the petitioner. The petitioner is absolved from its undertaking to keep the bank guarantee renewed. The Rule is disposed of finally as above.
17. There will be no order as to costs.
18. This order will not prevent the Department concerned from realising any tax in case the Department succeeds in the appeals that are pending in the Tribunal or in any other or further proceedings in connection with this case.
Alert