- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Radheshyam Tulsian v. Collector Of Customs And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, carrying on business as Calcutta Hardware Stores, imported 36 coils of stainless steel sheet in 1980. After paying customs duty on 5th November 1980, the petitioner requested an examination of the goods to determine damage or deterioration. On 7th November 1980, Customs Authorities examined the goods and found 30% damage on 28 coils, with the remaining 8 coils in sound condition. An Insurance Surveyor also confirmed damage due to rough handling during the voyage.
Based on the damage, the petitioner applied for a refund of customs duty under Section 22(1)(a) of the Customs Act, 1962. The Assistant Collector of Customs rejected the refund application on 23rd June 1982, stating the damage was not established before or during unloading in India. The petitioner appealed to the Collector (Appeals), who allowed the appeal on 4th June 1983, setting aside the Assistant Collector's order.
The Collector of Customs then appealed to the Customs, Excise & Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, which dismissed the appeal and application for condonation of delay on 18th July 1985, holding the appeal barred by limitation. Subsequent applications for review and reference to the High Court were also dismissed by the Tribunal. Despite these decisions, the respondents did not refund the claimed amount or pay interest, prompting the petitioner to file the present application under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to a refund of Rs. 2,21,910.30p based on the order of the Collector (Appeals) allowing the refund claim.
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to interest on the refunded amount from the date the refund became due.
- Whether the respondents had jurisdiction to withhold the refund after the Collector (Appeals) order.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner is entitled to the refund of Rs. 2,21,910.30p based on the Collector (Appeals) order dated 4th June 1983.
- The petitioner also claims interest on the refund amount, since the respondents withheld the refund without jurisdiction after the Collector (Appeals) order.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents do not dispute the refund amount but contend that no interest should be allowed on the refund.
- The respondents agreed to refund the sum within a time frame directed by the Court but opposed payment of interest.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dulichand Shreelal v. Collector of Central Excise, 1986 (26) E.L.T 298 | Interest as compensation for unlawful retention of money; refund with interest ordered when duty collection is unauthorized. | The Court applied the principle that retention of money without justification obliges payment of interest, directing refund with interest at 12% per annum from the date refund became due. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the Collector (Appeals) accepted the petitioner’s claim and allowed the refund on 4th June 1983, thereby establishing the petitioner’s entitlement to the refund from that date. Although the Collector of Customs appealed to the Tribunal, no stay order was obtained, and the subsequent applications for condonation of delay, review, and reference were dismissed. Despite this, the respondents failed to refund the amount or pay interest, unjustifiably depriving the petitioner of the use of the money.
Drawing on the precedent in Dulichand Shreelal, the Court held that interest is due as compensation for the respondents’ unauthorized retention of the refund amount. The Court distinguished that while the initial duty collection was authorized, the right to refund arose only after the damage was established and the Collector (Appeals) order was passed. Consequently, withholding the refund after that date was illegal and unjustified, mandating payment of interest at 12% per annum from 4th June 1983 until payment.
Holding and Implications
The application is allowed. The respondents are directed to pay the petitioner Rs. 2,21,910.30p along with simple interest at 12% per annum from 4th June 1983 until the date of payment. The payment must be made within two weeks from the communication of the order.
The decision directly compels the respondents to refund the claimed amount with interest, rectifying the unlawful withholding. No broader precedent beyond the application of established principles on refund and interest was set by this ruling.
1. In this application under Article 226 of the Constitution the petitioner has asked for a mandamus directing the respondents to pay a sum of Rs. 2,21,910.30p with interest @ 18% per annum on compound basis. The facts leading to this application are stated hereinafter.
2. The petitioner carries on business of import under the name and style of Calcutta Hardware Stores. The petitioner imported 36 coils of stainless steel sheet in 1980. In respect of the said consignment the bill of entry for home consumption was submitted and the custom duty was paid on 5th November, 1980 when the said goods were with the Customs Authorities in the Dock. The petitioner applied for examination of the goods by the Customs Authorities for determining the damaged or deterioration in the said goods.
3. On 7th November, 1980 the said goods were examined by the Examining Officer, the said Appraiser and Assistant Collector of Customs (Dock) for the purpose of ascertaining the extent of damage to the goods. It was found that the said goods were actually damaged and damage was quantified to the extent of 30%. The said goods were also examined by the Insurance Surveyor and the report of the Surveyor showed that the said goods had been damaged and deteriorated in quality due to rough and careless handling and/or bad storing during voyage.
4. The Assistant Collector of Customs (Dock) also submitted a report in which he said—
“The damage/deterioration is estimated to the extent of 30% on the 28 coils. The remaining 8 coils are found to be in sound condition”.
5. In view of the aforesaid damage caused to the coils the petitioner became entitled to abatement of duty under Section 22(1)(a) of the Customs Act, 1962 and applied for refund of duty. The Assistant Collector of Customs, Appraising Refund Section dismissed the petitioner's application for refund of duty on 23rd June 1982 on the plea that it had not been established that the said goods have been damaged and/or deteriorated at any time before or during unloading of the goods in India.
6. Being aggrieved by the said order the petitioner preferred an appeal before the Collector (Appeals). After hearing the parties and considering the records the Collector (Appeals) allowed the appeal filed by the petitioner and set aside the order of the Assistant Collector of Customs.
7. Against the said order of the Collector (Appeals) dated 4th 3une, 1983 the Collector of Customs moved an application to the Customs, Excise & Gold (Control), Appellate Tribunal. The petitioner contended before the Tribunal that the said appeal was barred by limitation. The Tribunal was of the view that the appeal was barred by limitation and no sufficient cause was shown for condonation of delay. Accordingly the application for condonation of delay as well as the appeal were dismissed by the Tribunal on 18th Duly, 1985.
8. The Customs Authorities thereafter filed another application before the Tribunal for review on the plea that there had been some mistakes on their part. The matter was considered by the Tribunal and by another order dated 21st February, 1986 the Tribunal rejected the said application on the ground that the Tribunal having passed an order upon consideration of the facts and circumstances of this case it was no longer open to the Tribunal to review or revise its order.
9. The respondents thereafter moved a reference application before the Tribunal praying for a reference on a point of law to the High Court. The Tribunal rejected the reference application by the order dated 10th April 1986. Thereafter no further proceedings were initiated.
10. The learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner contended that the claim of the refund is based on the abatement which the petitioner is entitled to having regard to the order of the Collector (Appeals). It is also contended that the petitioner is entitled not only to the refund of Rs. 2,21,910.30p. but interest as well on the said amount. It is contended ihat after the order was passed by the Collector (Appeals) on 4th June, 1983 the respondents did not have any jurisdiction to withhold the refund although further proceedings might have been taken by them.
11. Mr. N.C Roychowdhury, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents has not disputed the fact narrated in this application. It is his contention that the department will refund the sum of Rs. 2,21,910.30p. within such time as the Court may direct but the Court should not allow any interest on the facts and circumstances of this case.
12. I have considered the rival contentions. It appears that the Collector (Appeals) accepted the contention of the petitioner and allowed the appeal of the petitioner on 4th June, 1983. In other words in view of the order of the Collector (Appeals) the petitioner became entitled to the refund.
13. Although the Collector of Customs preferred appeal before the Tribunal but no order of stay was obtained nor was any application filed for such stay. Ultimately the application for condonation of delay, the appeal, the application for review and the reference application had been dismissed one after another by the Tribunal. The matter was not proceeded further. Even after the order was passed by the Tribunal rejecting the application for reference on 10th April, 1986 the respondents did not issue the refund order to the petitioner. It is surprising that the respondents Without there being any ground for withholding the refund deprived the petitioner of the use and enjoyment of the said sum of Rs. 2,21,910.30p. since 4th June, 1983 when the order of the Appellate Authority was made.
14. In the case of Dulichand Shreelal v. Collector of Central Excise reported in 1986 (26) E.L.T 298 I held that the interest is the return or compensation for the use or retention of another's money. Since the respondents had retained and enjoyed the benefit of such money they were bound to pay interest. In that case the collection of the duty was held to be unauthorised. The refund was directed to be issued along with interest @ 12% per annum from the date of collection till the date of actual payment. In this case the collection initially was not unauthorised because there was no examination of the goods, The bill of entry was processed and the petitioner paid the duty on 15th November, 1980. The right to claim refund accrued to the petitioner only after the goods have been examined and found damaged. The petitioner thereafter made the application for refund which was rejected by the Assistant Collector. The Collector (Appeals) by his order dated 4th June, 1983 allowed the claim for refund. The petitioner, therefore, was entitled to the refund on 4th June, 1983. There is no reasonable excuse for withholding the refund from that date and accordingly it must be held that withholding of the refund was unauthorised and illegal. Since the respondents enjoyed the benefit of the said sum of Rs. 2,21,910.30p. they are under an obligation to pay interest to the petitioner. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of this case this application is allowed with a direction upon the respondents to pay the sum of Rs. 2,21,910.30p. with simple interest @ 12% per annum from 4th June, 1983 till the date of payment. The respondents shall pay the said sum with interest in terms of the order to the petitioner within two weeks from the date of communication of this order.
15. Let the certified copy of the judgment be made available within three days after the judgment is signed.
Alert