- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Hindusthan Charity Trust.
Factual and Procedural Background
The assessee, a trust, filed for a refund under section 48 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, for the assessment year 1960-61. The income in question was derived from dividends. The assessee had paid Rs. 18,950 on March 9, 1960, to another trust called Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust. The Income Tax Officer (ITO) scrutinized this payment and, considering the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust to be a private trust, taxed Rs. 10,850 of the amount at the maximum rate, as the assessee failed to prove that the donation was for a public charitable or religious purpose.
On appeal before the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (AAC), the assessee argued that the donation was made in good faith to a charitable trust and that a good faith donation cannot be treated as non-charitable. The AAC held that the onus was on the assessee to prove the charitable application of the funds, which was not done, and thus rejected the claim. The assessee then appealed to the Tribunal, submitting that the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust had already been held to be a religious and charitable trust by the Tribunal in a later order dated April 18, 1967, invalidating the basis of the ITO and AAC's conclusions. The Revenue maintained the correctness of the authorities' conclusions.
The Tribunal, after examining the relevant order, concluded that the assessee could not be charged with having paid the amount for a non-charitable purpose and accepted the assessee's claim.
Further background includes a deed of trust executed on December 30, 1959, for the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust, containing public charitable and religious objects. The Tribunal had earlier held (February 8, 1961) that amounts transferred to the trust were held for religious or charitable purposes and that exemption under section 4(5)(i) applied from that date. However, the Tribunal did not consider whether the trust deed was void or uncertain on the present occasion as it was not before them.
The key question referred to the court was whether the Tribunal's conclusion that the assessee was entitled to exemption for the sum paid to the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was correct in law.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal was correct in law in holding that the assessee was entitled to exemption in respect of the sum of Rs. 10,850 paid to Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust.
- Whether the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust qualifies as a public charitable trust for the purposes of exemption under the Income-tax Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments
- The donation was made under the belief that the recipient trust was a charitable trust.
- A donation made in good faith cannot be treated as applied for non-charitable purposes.
- The Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust had been held by the Tribunal to be a religious and charitable trust in a subsequent order.
- The basis of the ITO and AAC's reasoning was invalidated by the Tribunal's later decision.
Revenue's Arguments
- The conclusion of the Income Tax authorities that the donation was not for a charitable purpose was correct based on the materials on record.
- The Revenue maintained that the trust was not a valid charitable trust, or at least the onus was on the assessee to prove otherwise.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CIT, West Bengal-I v. Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust (ITR No. 125 of 1966) | Whether the Trustees had discretion to apply income for both charitable and non-charitable objects affecting exemption under section 4(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. | The case was remitted to the Tribunal to decide on the charitable nature of the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust, influencing the court's acceptance of the Tribunal's conclusion on exemption. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the factual matrix, including the existence of a trust deed with public charitable and religious objects and the Tribunal's prior findings that the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was a public charitable trust. The court noted that although the trust deed was not before the Tribunal in the present case, the Tribunal had accepted the trust's charitable nature in a previous order.
The court acknowledged that the question of whether the trustees had discretion to apply income for non-charitable purposes was under judicial consideration in a related case before the High Court, which had remitted the matter to the Tribunal. The Revenue's counsel confirmed that the Tribunal had held the trust to be a public charitable trust, and no further steps were clarified.
Given the undisputed fact that the assessee paid the amount in good faith to the representative of the trust, the court held that the question of the trust's charitable status or the application of money was not relevant for deciding the assessee's entitlement to exemption. The court thus upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the assessee was entitled to exemption on the sum paid.
Holding and Implications
The court held that the Tribunal's conclusion that the assessee was entitled to exemption in respect of the sum of Rs. 10,850 paid to Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was correct in law.
The direct effect of this decision is that the assessee's claim for exemption is allowed, and each party is to bear its own costs. The opinion does not establish any new precedent beyond affirming the application of existing principles regarding good faith donations and the evidentiary burden in proving charitable application of funds.
Sabyasachi Mukharji, J.:— It appears that the assessee is a trust. The assessment year in this reference is 1960-61. There was a trust. It applied for refund under s. 48 of the Indian I.T Act, 1922, for the assessment year 1960-61, the relevant accounting period ending on March 31, 1960. The income derived by the trust was from dividends. The assessee had paid on March 9, 1960, a sum of Rs. 18,950 to another trust called Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust. While the ITO scrutinised the statement filed, he came across this item. According to him, this Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was a private trust. He observed that the assessee could not prove that the donation was for any public charitable or religious purpose. He, therefore, taxed the sum of Rs. 10,850 at the maximum rate.
2. Before the AAC, on appeal, the assessee contended that the donation to the trust was made under the belief that it was a charitable trust and that if a donation was made in good faith, it could not be said that the money had been applied for non-charitable purposes. In the alternative, it was pointed out that in the case of Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust the AAC had held, in his order for the assessment year 1961-62, dated April 28, 1964, that the trust was a religious and charitable trust although he had dismissed the appeal of the said trust on the ground that the deed of endowment was not a valid document. The AAC in disposing of these contentions held that for getting the benefit of exemption, the onus was on the assessee to prove that the money contributed had been applied for religious and charitable purpose and that the assessee had failed to do so. Hence, the claim was considered to be not tenable. Thereafter, the assessee went up on appeal to the Tribunal. It was submitted that the conclusion drawn by the I.T authorities was wrong and that the trust had been held to be a valid public charitable trust by the Tribunal in its order in ITA No. 4143 of 1964-65, dated April 18, 1967. It was, therefore, urged that the basis of the reasoning of the ITO and the AAC could no longer be taken as valid. The Revenue submitted that the conclusion of the I.T authorities on the materials on record was correct.
3. The Tribunal held, after considering the order dated April 18, 1967 in ITA No. 4143 of 1964-65, that the assessee could not be charged with having paid the amount for a non-charitable purpose. It, therefore, accepted the assessee's claim.
4. It appears further that on December 30, 1959, a deed of trust had been executed in the case of Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust and the deed of trust was found to contain public charitable and religious objects. The Tribunal on February 8, 1961, held, when certain amounts were transferred to the accounts of the trust, that it could be said that the trustees held the amount for religious or charitable purpose and that the exemption under s. 4(5)(i) in respect of the income of the said trust would come into operation as on that date. It is the conclusion regarding the nature or character of the said trust which was followed in the order under reference. The Tribunal, on the present occasion, could not go into the question as to whether the terms of the Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust deed were in arty manner void or uncertain as the trust deed was not before it in the present occasion.
5. In those circumstances, the following question has been referred to us:
“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the conclusion of the Tribunal that the assessee was entitled to exemption in respect of the sum of Rs. 10,850 paid to Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust is right in law?”
6. It may be that the Tribunal held (as it did,) an the facts and circumstances of the case that the case of Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was pending on a reference in the Hon'ble High Court. We are shown a copy of judgment of the Hon'ble Mr. Justice Deb and the Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.N Pyne delivered on March 6, 1975, from which it appears that ITR No. is 125 of 1966 (CIT, West Bengal-I v. Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust), wherein the question was as follows:
“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal erred in refusing to permit the Department to raise a contention that the Trustees had a discretion to apply the income of the Trust for both charitable and non-charitable objects and, hence, the assessee is not entitled to exemption of its income under section 4(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922?”
7. The matter was, therefore, remitted to the Tribunal to decide the question whether Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was a charitable trust or not.
8. Learned advocate for the Revenue on instruction states that as far as his instruction went the Tribunal had held that the said Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was a public charitable trust. He could not enlighten us any further whether the Revenue had taken any steps or not thereafter. If that is the position, and, further, in view of the fact that it is not disputed that the factual contention of the assessee was that it had paid on good faith to the representative, it is also not disputed before us, that whether it was charitable trust or not and whether it received money from the assessee for charitable purpose or not is not relevant for us; in the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the opinion that the conclusion of the Tribunal that the assessee was entitled to exemption in respect of the sum of Rs. 10,850 paid to Shri Lakshmi Nath Seva Trust was right in law.
9. The question is, therefore, answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee; In the facts and circumstances of the case, each party will pay and bear its own costs.
Suhas Chandra Sen, J.:— I agree.
Alert