- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Panchanan Monda & Anr. v. Sm. Sulata Roy Mondal
Summary of Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs alleged that plaintiff no.1 (husband of plaintiff no.2) acquired .7 decimals of land out of plot no.70 by sale deed dated 18.12.1955 and that plaintiff no.1 purchased two cottahs of land from plot no.73 from the defendant by a kobala dated 4 July 1959. Adjacent plot no.71 and the remaining portion of plot no.73 belonged to the defendant and lay to the west of the plaintiffs' land. The defendant had a small ditch on her land with a private passage to the east of that ditch; the plaintiffs' land lay east of the ditch and contained a wall.
The plaintiffs alleged that, with strained relations between the parties, the defendant deepened the ditch and by steep excavation converted it into a tank, thereby removing lateral support to the plaintiffs' wall and building. In the middle of Sravan (record shows both 1372 B.S. and 1373 B.S. in the opinion), a portion of the plaintiffs' land and the western portion of their wall were alleged to have been engulfed by the defendant's tank and adjoining vacant space subsided. The defendant allegedly refused to rebuild the damaged wall or reclaim the subsided land. The suit sought declaration of title, confirmation of possession and a mandatory injunction directing the defendant to rebuild the wall and reclaim the land.
The defendant denied the allegations, contending inter alia that the plaintiffs had no lateral support from the defendant's land, the ditch was not converted into a tank, the story of crumbling wall was false and that no loss was caused to the plaintiffs.
Procedurally, the learned Munsif issued a writ of local investigation and a pleader-commissioner reported in the plaintiffs' favour. The Munsif accepted that report and decreed the suit. The defendant appealed; the appellate court reversed the Munsif's findings and dismissed the suit. The plaintiffs brought the present second appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendant's excavation (conversion of a ditch into a tank) deprived the plaintiffs' land and building of lateral support such that the plaintiffs are entitled to relief (declaration/possession and mandatory injunction).
- Whether a proprietor has a natural right of lateral support for buildings (as distinct from unburdened land) from adjoining/subjacent soil, or whether support for buildings is an easement which must be acquired (by prescription or otherwise).
- Whether, absent negligence in excavation operations, damages or injunctive relief are available to the owner of a building whose structure is affected by a neighbour's excavation.
- Whether the plaintiffs had established acquisition of any easement of lateral support (for example by prescription) or shown that their land would have subsided even in its natural, unburdened state.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The pleader-commissioner's report and the depositions supported the plaintiffs' version that the defendant deepened the ditch and caused loss by removing lateral support to the plaintiffs' wall and building.
- Relying on authorities (Gale on Easements and Halsbury's), the appellants argued that where land has been affected by withdrawal of support and a building on it is affected, damages may be recoverable if the land has been deprived of its natural right of support as described by Illustration (e) to Section 7(b) of the Indian Easements Act; the principles of that section apply in West Bengal.
- The evidence of the plaintiffs' witnesses (P.Ws) supported the claim of damage caused by the defendant's action.
Respondent's Arguments
- Relying on Ram Gopal v. Gopi Krishna (AIR 1957 MP 227), the respondent argued there is a distinction between the natural right of support to land in its unburdened and natural state and the right of support for buildings; the latter is an easement and must be acquired. In absence of an easement, a neighbour may lawfully excavate even if damage to a building results, provided there was no negligence in the excavation.
- Both parties referred to Dalton v. Angus ((1881) 6 AC 740) for the proposition that a right to lateral support for a building can be acquired by prescription after 20 years' uninterrupted enjoyment.
- Reference to Bengal Provincial Ry Co. v. Rajani Kanta (AIR 1936 Cal. 564) was made to show that the natural right of support is available only to land in its unburdened and natural state and that if there is no easement and no negligence, the defendant is not liable for damage to a building.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ram Gopal v. Gopi Krishna AIR 1957 MP 227 | Distinction between natural right of support to land (in unburdened state) and right of support for buildings (which is an easement and must be acquired); neighbour can excavate unless negligent. | The court relied on the distinction to hold that plaintiffs had not established a right to lateral support for their building absent proof of an easement or of negligence by the defendant. |
| Dalton v. Angus (1881) 6 AC 740 | A right to receive lateral support for a building may be acquired by prescription after 20 years' user openly, continuously and without interruption. | The court noted this principle but found no evidence that the plaintiffs had acquired such a prescriptive easement. |
| Bengal Provincial Ry Co. v. Rajani Kanta AIR 1936 Cal. 564 | The natural right of support from a neighbour's land applies only to land in its unburdened and natural state; there is no right for support of a building unless an easement exists; absent negligence the neighbour is not liable for damage to a building caused by excavation. | The court found the facts of the present case almost identical and applied this principle: since no finding of negligence was made and plaintiffs did not show subsidence would have occurred in the land's unburdened state, plaintiffs could not succeed on the injunction claim. |
| Ramgopal v. Gopikrishna (supra) | Discusses the principle that rights under Illustration (e) of S.7(b) of the Easements Act apply to land in natural unburdened state and not to structures unless prescription is shown. | The court applied this principle to conclude plaintiffs had not shown their land would have subsided in its natural state and had not acquired an easement; therefore relief for damage to the building could not be granted on that basis. |
| Rashiklal v. Savailal AIR 1955 Bom. 285 | Effect of Illustration (e) of S.7(b) of the Easements Act: right applies only to land in unburdened and natural state and not to structures unless there is prescription; although the Act does not apply to Bengal, the principles are applicable. | The court relied on the articulation of this principle to support its view that the Easements Act principle (as applied) did not give the plaintiffs a right to support for their structures absent prescriptive acquisition or evidence that the unburdened land would have subsided. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the factual findings and the authorities cited by both parties and proceeded as follows:
- The court accepted the legal distinction drawn in the cited authorities between a natural right of support for land in its unburdened and natural state and a distinct right of support for buildings or structures, which is an easement and must be acquired (for example, by prescription).
- It noted that Dalton v. Angus recognizes acquisition of lateral support for a building by 20 years' uninterrupted public user, but observed that the plaintiffs had not established any such prescriptive right.
- The court found the facts of the case closely paralleled Bengal Provincial Ry. Co. v. Rajani Kanta: the defendant's excavation did not cause immediate damage; damage (subsidence/cracks) manifested only after the rains (monsoon). The court emphasised that there was no finding by the courts below that the defendant's act was negligent. In the absence of negligence, the authorities establish that a neighbour is entitled to excavate his own soil even if later damage to an adjoining building results (in absence of an easement).
- Separately, the court observed that the plaintiffs failed to prove that the plaintiffs' land would have subsided even if it had been in its natural and unburdened state by reason of the excavation. That defect was material because Illustration (e) to Section 7(b) of the Easements Act, and the authorities discussing it, apply to land in its unburdened state, not to structures, unless an easement has been acquired.
- Because the plaintiffs had not shown either (a) negligence by the defendant, or (b) acquisition of an easement/right to lateral support (or that the unburdened land would have subsided), the court concluded the plaintiffs were not entitled to the mandatory injunction they sought to compel rebuilding and reclamation.
- The court also identified a procedural or substantive error in the Subordinate Judge's judgment: the plaintiffs had sought declaration of title and confirmation of possession, which were denied in the written statement; that portion of the decree was erroneously set aside by the Subordinate Judge and required correction.
Holding and Implications
Appeal allowed in part.
Holding (direct effect):
- The appellate judgment and decree under challenge were set aside in part.
- The suit was decreed in part: it was declared that the plaintiffs have title to the extent shown by the pleader-commissioner, and the plaintiffs' possession of such land was confirmed. The pleader-commissioner's map, report and field-book were ordered to form part of the decree.
- The plaintiffs' prayer for a mandatory injunction (to rebuild the damaged portion of the wall and to reclaim the land subsided into the tank) was dismissed for want of proof of negligence or of an acquired easement/right to lateral support for structures.
- There was no order as to costs.
Implications:
The decision directly affects the parties by confirming plaintiffs' title and possession to the extent found by the pleader-commissioner while denying the mandatory injunctive relief sought to remedy alleged subsidence and wall damage. The court applied established principles distinguishing rights to support of unburdened land from rights to support for buildings (which require an easement or proof of negligence) and did not expand those principles beyond the authorities cited.
1. The plaintiffs have alleged that plaintiff no. 1 is husband of plaintiff no. 2. By a sale deed dated 18.12.1955, her husband purchased .7 decimals of land out of the plot no. 70 together with the structures standing thereon from one Bholanath Saha. Plaintiff no. 1 purchased two cottahs of land from the plot no. 73 from defendant by a kobala dated 4th July, 1959. The adjacent plot no. 71 and the remaining portion of the plot no. 73 belong to defendant and they lie to the west of the plaintiffs' land. Defendant had a small ditch on her land and there was a private passage to the east of that ditch. To the east of that ditch the plaintiffs' land is located. On that land the plaintiffs have a wall. The parties are on strained relations. With a view to causing mischief to the plaintiffs, the defendant deepened that ditch and converted it into a tank by steeply carrying out the excavation. As a result of such steep excavation, the lateral support of the plaintiffs' wall and building was lost. In the middle of Sravan, 1372 B.S, a portion of the plaintiffs' land and western portion of their wall became engulfed by the defendant's tank. The vacant space on the west of the plaintiff's wall also subsided into the tank. The plaintiff's request in this respect was ignored and the defendant did not rebuild the damaged portion of the wall and reclaim the portion of the land which had subsided into the tank. The suit is for confirmation of possession on declaration of the plaintiffs' title to the disputed land and for a mandatory injunction directing the defendant to rebuild the portion of the plaintiffs' wall, which had crumbled down, and to reclaim that portion of the land, which had gone down into he tank.
2. Defendant filed a written statement denying the plaintiffs' allegations. It has been alleged inter alia that the plaintiffs had no such lateral support and the ditch was not converted into a tank. The story of the wall crumbling down and the portion of the plaintiffs' land going down into the tank is false. No loss was caused to the plaintiffs.
3. The learned Munsif issued a writ of local investigation. The pleader commissioner reported in the plaintiffs' favour. Accepting that report and relying on the plaintiffs' version the suit was decreed. Defendant went up on appeal. The appellate court reversed the learned Munsif's findings and dismissed the suit. Hence this second appeal by the plaintiffs.
4. It has been contended on behalf of the appellants that the plead r-commissioner's report and deposition clearly proved the plaintiffs' version. Reference has been made to p. 273 of Gale on Easements, 13th Edn., to show that there is no natural right to the support of a building par se. Support to that which is artificially imposed upon land cannot exist ex jure naturae because the thing supported does not itself so exist. If, however, land has been affected by the withdrawal of support and a building on it has also been affected, and it is shown that the withdrawal of support would have affected the land in its natural state, in other words, that the land has been deprived of its natural right of support, damages may be recovered for the consequent injury to the building. Halsbury's Laws of England, 3rd Edn., Vol. 12 p. 606, has been referred to show that the owner of land has no natural right to support for buildings or of the additional weight which the buildings cause. Support to that which is artificially imposed upon land cannot exist ex jure naturae, because the thing supported does not itself so exist. The mere fact that there are buildings open the land does not preclude an owner from his right against a neighbour of subjacent owner, who act in such a manner as to deprive the land of support, so long as the presence of the buildings does not materially affect the question, or their additional weight did not cause the subsidence, which followed the withdrawal of support. Section 7(b) of the Indian Easements Act speaks of the right of every owner of immovable property to enjoy without disturbance by another the natural advantages arising from its situation. Illustration (e) thereof says that the owner of land has the right that such land, in its natural condition, shall have the support naturally rendered by the subjacent and adjacent soil of another person. The principles of that section apply to West Bengal. The evidence given by the P.Ws clearly supports the plaintiffs' version of damage to the plaintiffs' land, wall and building by the defendant's action.
5. The learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent has referred to the case of Ram Gopal v. Gopi Krishna AIR 1957 MP 227, where it has been stated that there is a distinction between a natural right of support to one's land in unburdened and natural state from the adjacent and subjacent land of the neighbouring owners and the right of support for buildings or structures standing on the land. While the former right is a natural incident of one's ownership of the land, the right for the support for building or structure on land is an easement and can be claimed only as an easement. If the owner of a building has not acquired such a right of easement of lateral support for his building from his neighbour's land, the neighbour would be within his rights in carrying on excavation on his soil even if by so doing damage is caused to the building of his neighbour, provided, of course, there is no negligence in the excavation operations.
6. Both the sides referred to the leading case of Dalton v. Angus in (1881) 6 AC 740. A question arose in that case whether a building could acquire a right to lateral support from adjacent land by 20 years' uninterrupted enjoyment. It has been held that such right could be acquired by prescription. A right to receive later support may he acquired by building by 20 years' user openly, continuously and without interruption.
7. In the case of Bengal Provincial Ry Co. v. Rajani Kanta in AIR 1936 Cal. 564, the allegation was that the defendant company had burrow pits on their own land for a long time and the plaintiffs had their hut near those pits. In 1927 or 1928 they replaced their hut by a masonry building, which was raised close to the pits. In February, 1930, the defendant company deepened the pit. But at that time no damage was caused to the plaintiffs' building. After the rains had set in July, 1930, the cracks appeared in the building. So damages were asked for from the railway company on account of damage caused to the plaintiffs' building. It has been stated that the natural right of support from neighbour's land is available only in respect of land in unburdened and natural state. An owner has no right for the support of his building or of his land burdened with the additional weight of his building unless such a right has been acquired as an easement. If there is no easement to have such lateral support, the neighbour is within his rights to make excavation provided that he does not act negligently. If there is no negligence, the plaintiff is not entitled to any damages caused to his building.
8. In this case, the facts are almost identical because the plaintiffs have alleged that after defendant deepened the ditch, no immediate damage was caused to their land, wall or building. Only after the break of monsoon, i.e, in the middle of Sravan 1373 B.S, a portion of the plaintiffs' land and the western portion of their wall were engulfed by the tank. There is no finding by the courts below that the defendant's act was negligent. So on that score alone, the plaintiffs' are liable to be non-suited.
9. There is yet another defect. In the case of Bengal Provincial Ry. Co. v. Rajani Kanta (supra), there was no evidence that the plaintiffs' land would have subsided even if it had been in a natural state and unburdened with their building by reason of the excavation made by the defendant Company. This principle was discussed in the case of Ramgopal v. Gopikrishna (supra), cited on behalf of the respondent. This case was also discussed by Gajendragadkar, J. in the case of Rashiklal v. Savailal reported in AIR 1955 Bom. 285. It has been stated in that case that the effect of illustration (e) of S. 7(b) of Easements Act is that the right, which is referred to in that section, is applicable only to the land in its unburdened and natural state. It is not applicable to the structure built on the land unless there is a case of prescription. It may be stated that though that Act does not apply to Bengal, the principles of the Act nevertheless apply.
10. Applying the principle to the facts of the case it appears that the plaintiffs made out no case that they acquired any easement right to support to their building from the defendant's land. There is no evidence on the side of the plaintiffs to show that their land would have subsided even if it had been in its natural state and unburdened with their building, by reason of the excavations made by the defendant. Due to this defect in the point, the prayer for mandatory injunction must be dismissed, and I find accordingly.
11. There is a mistake in the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge because the plaintiff asked for declaration of title and confirmation of possession. The plaintiffs' title was denied in the written statement. So this portion of the decree was erroneously set aside by the learned Subordinate Judge.
12. The appeal is allowed in part. The judgment and decree appealed against be set aside. The suit is decreed in part. It is hereby declared that the plaintiffs have title to the extent shown by the pleader commissioner. The plaintiffs' possession in such land is hereby confirmed. The commissioner's map, report and field-book do form part of the decree. The prayer for mandatory injunction is dismissed.
13. There will be no order as to costs.
Appeal allowed in part.
Alert