- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Central Coalfields Ltd. v. Rabindra Nath Dutta & Anr.
Summary of the Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This revisional application was filed by the tenant-defendant against an order made in Title Suit No. 122 of 1977 (Second Court of the Subordinate Judge at Alipore) brought by the plaintiff-landlord for eviction. The tenant was occupying the suit premises at a monthly rent of Rs. 1,150/- (payable according to English calendar month). In the eviction suit the defendant filed two applications under S. 17(2) and S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act.
The defendant's pleaded case included that they had tendered twenty months' rent (April 1974 to November 1975) amounting to Rs. 23,000/- by cheque which the plaintiff refused to accept, and that rent had been deposited month by month with the Rent Controller since May 1976. The Subordinate Judge, by the impugned order dated 16 July 1979, disposed of the application under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A). He found admitted arrears for April 1974 to April 1976, assessed those arrears at Rs. 28,750/-, assessed statutory interest up to July 1979 at 8 1/3% amounting to Rs. 10,789.22, refused to grant liberal instalments, and directed the deposit of the entire amount of Rs. 39,539.22 by 20 August 1979. The defendant sought revision of that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Subordinate Judge could direct the tenant to deposit the entire arrears under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act when a part of those arrears was time-barred (i.e., not legally recoverable) on the date of the suit/order.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant / Tenant (Mr. Mitra)
- Argued that where part of the arrears is time-barred and therefore not legally recoverable on the date of the suit (August 1979), the Subordinate Judge could not lawfully have directed deposit of the entire arrears under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A).
- Relied on this Court's Bench decision in Raghunath Singh v. Paial & Co., 65 CWN 1093, and a single Bench decision following it (N.N. Ghosh Chowdhury v. Tripti Rani Chakraborty, ILR 1976 (2) Cal. 359) to support the contention that only arrears which the tenant is under a legal obligation to pay can be required to be deposited.
Respondent / Landlord (Mr. Das Gupta)
- Contended that the decisions relied upon by Mr. Mitra were overruled by the Supreme Court in Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir, AIR 1978 SC 287, which, when applied, requires deposit of the entire arrears irrespective of whether any part is time-barred.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Raghunath Singh v. Paial & Co., 65 CWN 1093 | Bench decision construing S. 17(1) to require deposit only of arrears which the tenant is otherwise under legal obligation to pay (i.e., excluding time-barred arrears). | The Court rejected that restrictive construction of S. 17(1), holding there is no scope to import such a qualification into the provision; the Court treated the decision as inconsistent with the proper construction and with subsequent Supreme Court authority. |
| N.N. Ghosh Chowdhury v. Tripti Rani Chakraborty, ILR 1976 (2) Cal. 359 | Single Bench decision following the Bench decision in Raghunath Singh (i.e., applied the restrictive view that time-barred arrears need not be deposited). | The Court noted that this single Bench decision merely follows the Bench decision and expressed doubt as to its correctness in light of later authority. |
| Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir, AIR 1978 SC 287 | Supreme Court interpretation of a parallel provision in the U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act that a tenant must deposit the entire arrears (including time-barred portions) to obtain relief. | The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision as effectively overruling the earlier Bench decision(s) and as supporting the view that S. 17(1) requires deposit of the entire amount in arrears for entitlement to relief. |
| Vasudev Udpa v. Krishna Udpa, ILR 44 Mad 629 | Authority relied upon (and approved by the Supreme Court) concerning the obligation of a tenant to deposit amounts to obtain relief; interpreted as imposing duty to deposit amounts the tenant is otherwise under legal obligation to pay. | The Court described that this decision was relied upon by counsel for the applicant in earlier decisions that favored the restrictive view; but the present Court expressed doubt as to the correctness of applying that authority to exclude time-barred arrears from deposit requirements under S. 17(1). |
| Daya Debi v. Chapala Debi, 63 CWN 976 | Earlier decision of this Court relied upon to support the restrictive interpretation that only legally payable arrears can be ordered deposited. | The Court recorded that the learned Judges in the prior Bench decision relied on this decision; the present Court did not accept that reliance as controlling. |
| Nashiban Bibi v. Parulbala Dutta, 62 CWN 778 | Single Bench decision approved by the Bench in support of the restrictive view regarding deposit of only legally payable arrears. | The Court noted that the prior Bench had approved this decision but expressed reservations about that approach in light of Supreme Court authority. |
| Sujit Kumar Gupta v. Kartick Chandra Manna, 1979 (2) Cal. High Court Notes 280 | Single Judge decision expressing doubts about the correctness of the Bench decision (Raghunath Singh) that limited deposit obligations to legally payable arrears. | The present Division Bench agreed with the view expressed by the single Judge that the earlier Bench decision is open to doubt and noted that it stands overruled by implication by the Supreme Court's decision in Khadi Gram. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court commenced its analysis by examining the language of S. 17(1) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, which it quoted in full. The quoted provision requires that, on institution of a suit by the landlord, "the tenant shall subject to the provisions of sub-s. (2), within one month... deposit in court or with the Controller or pay to the landlord an amount calculated at the rate of rent at which it was last paid, for the period for which the tenant may have made default including the period subsequent thereto upto the end of the month previous to that in which the deposit or payment is made together with interest..."
The Court interpreted the statutory text to mean that the tenant must deposit or pay the rent for the entire period for which he has made default, together with statutory interest. It reasoned that the term "payable" in the provision qualifies only the term "amount" for purposes of determining the date from which interest is calculated, and does not introduce a limitation excluding arrears barred by limitation from the deposit requirement.
The Court rejected the restrictive construction introduced by the earlier Bench decision in Raghunath Singh, which would have limited the deposit requirement to arrears that the tenant was "otherwise under legal obligation to pay" (i.e., excluding time-barred arrears). The Court observed that such a qualification is not found expressly in the statutory text nor follows by necessary implication; inserting it would amount to judicial alteration of the statute rather than interpretation.
The Court also placed S. 17(1) in the context of sub-section (4) and the parallel principle in S. 114 of the Transfer of Property Act, concluding that the statutory scheme contemplates deposit of the entire arrears as a precondition for obtaining the relief under the Act.
Finally, the Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Khadi Gram Udyog Trust (interpreting a parallel U.P. statute) which laid down that a tenant must deposit the entire arrears irrespective of whether any part is time-barred. Applying that authority and the textual analysis, the Court held that the earlier Bench decision (and the single Bench decision following it) cannot be followed and stand overruled by the Supreme Court authority.
The Court also dealt with the concrete figures in the impugned order: both parties agreed that the Subordinate Judge had miscalculated the statutory interest. The parties agreed that statutory interest on the arrears amounted to Rs. 10,182.29, making the total amount payable Rs. 38,932.29 (rather than Rs. 39,539.22 as assessed by the Subordinate Judge). The Court therefore modified the order on this point and directed that any excess payment may be refunded or adjusted.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revisional application was disposed of and the impugned order of the learned Subordinate Judge was upheld subject to modification of the interest calculation.
Immediate consequences and implications for the parties (as stated in the opinion):
- The Court affirmed that, to obtain relief under S. 17(4) (and by necessary implication S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A)), the tenant must deposit the entire amount in arrears for the period of default as calculated under the statute, irrespective of whether any part of those arrears is time-barred.
- The Subordinate Judge's order was modified only to correct the interest calculation: statutory interest was agreed to be Rs. 10,182.29 and the total payable towards the arrears and interest was fixed at Rs. 38,932.29 (instead of Rs. 39,539.22). Any excess paid or deposited may be refunded or adjusted.
- The revisional application was disposed of and there was no order as to costs.
- Justice B.C. Chakraborty agreed with the opinion; the order was formally modified in accordance with the Court's direction.
Note on precedent: The Court's conclusion aligns the construction of S. 17(1) with the Supreme Court's decision in Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir (AIR 1978 SC 287), and the Court treated earlier contrary Bench authority as no longer controlling in light of that Supreme Court decision.
Anil K. Sen, J.:—This is a revisional application at the instance of the tenant-defendant arising out of a suit for eviction which has been heard on contest by the plaintiff landlord. The facts relevant for our present purposes are not in dispute. The defendant-petitioner is a tenant under the plaintiff in respect of suit premises on a monthly rent of Rs. 1150/- payable according to English Calendar month. The plaintiff instituted Title Suit No. 122 of 1977 in the second court of the learned Subordinate Judge at Alipore for eviction of the defendant on certain grounds including a ground that the tenant-defendant had forfeited their protection under S. 13 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act (hereinafter referred to as the said Act) on the ground of default. In this suit the defendant filed two applications—one under S. 17(2) and the other under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A) of the said Act. The case made out in these applications was to the effect that when the defendant tendered twenty months' rent from April 1974 to November 1975 amounting to Rs. 23,000/- to the plaintiff by a cheque, the plaintiff refused to accept the same. The defendant further pleaded that the rent was being deposited month by month with the Rent Controller since May 1976. Admitting the arrears for the period from April 1974 to April 1976 in the application under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A) of the said Act the defendant prayed for an order allowing them “to deposit the arrears of rent legally payable with interest in monthly instalment equal to one month's rent beginning from November 1978.” In their application under S. 17(2) the defendant prayed for adjudication of a dispute as to whether the deposits made with the Rent Controller since May 1976 are valid or not and “further determine as to whether any portion of the rent in arrears has become barred by limitation and as such not legally payable.” The learned Subordinate Judge by the order impugned dated July 16, 1979 has disposed of the application under S. 17(1) read with s. 17(2A) of the said Act which was strongly contested before him by the plaintiff. He found the defendant to be in arrears for the admitted period from April 1974 to April 1976 and assessed the rent in arrears for those months at Rs. 28,750/-. He further found that the defendant is liable to pay statutory interest on such arrears upto July 1979 at the state of Rs. 81/3% and assessed the same at Rs. 10,789,22. He refused to grant any liberal instalment as prayed for by the defendant and directed the entire amount of Rs. 39,539,22 to be deposited by August 20, 1979. Feeling aggrieved by the order as aforesaid the defendant has preferred the present revisional application.
2. Mr. Mitra appearing in support of this revisional application has raised a solitary point. He has contended that when a part of the arrears was not legally recoverable on the date of the suit, that is on August ???, 1979, being time barred the learned Subordinate Judge could not have directed deposit of the entire arrears under S. 17(1) read with S. 17(2A) of the said Act. Reliance is placed on a Bench decision of this Court in the case of Raghunath Singh v. Paial & Co. 65 CWN 1093 and a single Bench decision following the aforesaid Bench decision in the case of N.N Ghosh Chowdhury v. Tripti Rani Chakraborty ILR 1976 (2) Cal. 359. The point thus raised by Mr. Mitra has been contended by Mr. Das Gupta appearing on behalf of the plaintiff. According to Mr. Das Gupta, the decisions relied on by Mr. Mitra stand over-ruled by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir AIR 1978 SC 287.
3. The Bench decision of this Court relied on by Mr. Mitra no doubt well supports the contention raised by him. Unfortunately for Mr. Mitra in that case he himself had failed to convince the learned Judges that in order to get relief under S. 17(4) of the said Act, the tenant must deposit the entire arrears whether the whole or any part of it is time birred or not. To us it appears that it was rightly contended by him then that S. 17(4) of the said Act incorporates in substance the same principle as underlies S. 114 of the Transfer of Property Act and when the liability for the time barred rent in arrears is not extinguished though its recovery is barred it was incumbent upon a tenant to discharge that liability in order to be entitled to relief under S. 17(4). Necessarily Mr. Mitra then relied on the well-known decision in the case of Vasudev Udpa v. Krishna Udpa, ILR 44 Mad 629 which has been approved by the Supreme Court. The learned Judges there, however, rejected such a contention raised by Mr. Mitra when they held that “the first part of sub-s. (1) of S. 17, on its true construction, imposes upon the tenant the duty to deposit or pay the amount to the plaintiff as landlord on account of arrears of rent which the tenant is otherwise under legal obligation to pay to him.” Accordingly it was held that when the tenant had no legal obligation to pay the time barred arrears, he cannot be made to pay or deposit such part of the time barred arrears under S. 17(1) nor can there be any order made under S. 17(2) of the said Act directing any such payment or deposit. The learned Judges relied on an earlier decision of this Court in the case of Daya Debi… v. Chapala Debi…Opposite Party., 63 CWN 976 in holding as such and approved a single Bench decision in the case of Nashiban Bibi v. Parulbala Dutta 62 CWN 778. With great respect there are however, good reasons to doubt the correctness of the view so expressed as pointed out by a learned single Judge of this Court in a later decision in the case of Sujit Kumar Gupta v. Kartick Chandra Manna, 1979 (2) Calcutta High Court Notes 280.
4. Section 17(1) provides as follows:— “On a suit or proceeding being instituted by the landlord on any of the grounds referred to in S. 18, the tenant shall subject to the provisions of sub-s. (2), within one month, of the service of the writ of summons on him or where he appears in the suit or proceeding without the writ of summons being served on him, within one month of his appearance deposit in court or with the Controller or pay to the landlord an amount calculated at the rate of rent at which it was last paid, for the period for which the tenant may have made default including the period subsequent thereto upto the end of the month previous to that in which the deposit or payment is made together with interest on such amount calculated at the rate of eight and one-third per cent per annum from the date when any such amount was payable upto the date of deposit, and shall thereafter continue to deposit or pay month by month, by the 15th of each succeeding month a sum equivalent to the rent at that rate.” The first part of this sub-section death provides that the tenant shall deposit in Court or pay to the landlord an amount calculated at the rate of rent at which it was last paid for the period for which the tenant may have made default. To that what is to be added is interest at the statutory rate calculated from the date when any such amount was payable upto the date of deposit. Even the term ‘payable’ as used in this sub-section qualifies the term ‘amount’ only for the purpose of determining the date from which the interest is to be calculated. Sub-section (1) on its terms quite clearly requires the tenant to deposit in Court or pay to the landlord the rent for the entire period for which he may have made default irrespective of whether any part of it is irrecoverable being barred by law or not. The learned Judge's deciding the case of Raghunath Singh… v. Messrs. Patel & Co.…Opposite Party. (supra) introduced on their own construction a restrictive clause into this sub-section to the effect that such arrears must be the arrears which the tenant is otherwise under a legal obligation to pay. We do not think there is any scope for incorporating into the provision a restriction of that kind which the legislature in its wisdom had not incorporated. We are not supposed to alter the law by judicial pronouncement but we are merely to interpret the law as made by the legislature. The restriction as has been brought in by the learned Judges on construction of sub-s. (1) neither follows expressly from the provision thereof nor by necessary implication. Moreover, such a restriction, in our view, is against the very spirit of the provision which read with sub-s. (4) provides for relief of the nature contemplated by S. 114 of the Transfer of Property Act. This is the reason why we have expressed ourselves to say in agreement with the learned single Judge of this Court that there are good reasons to doubt the correctness of the view expressed in the aforesaid Bench decision. The other single Bench decision relied on by Mr. Mitra merely follows the Bench decision.
5. We are quite conscious of the position that sitting in a Division Bench when we are not agreeing with Bench decision normally we are to refer the matter to a larger Bench but that is not required of us in the present case as we agree with the learned single Judge when he said in the case of Suchit Kumar Gupta v. Kartick Chandra Manna (supra) that this decision stands overruled by necessary implication by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Sri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir. In that case the Supreme Court was considering the parallel provision of U.P Urban Buildings (Regulation of Leiting, Rent and Eviction) Act (13 of 1972). The material provision of that Act provides in case of a suit for eviction on the ground of default, if at the first hearing of the suit the tenant unconditionally pays or tenders to the landlord or deposits in Court the entire amount of rent and damages for use and occupation of the building due from him together with statutory interest thereon and the landlord's costs of the suit the Court may, in lieu of passing a decree on that ground, pass an order relieving the tenant against his liability for eviction on the ground. Interpreting the aforesaid provision the Supreme Court laid down that in order to be entitled to the relief so provided the tenant-defendant must deposit the entire arrears irrespective of whether any part of it is time barred or not. Mr. Mitra appearing in support of the present revisional application before us wanted to distinguish the above decision on the ground that under the U.P Urban Buddings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act (13 of 1972) what the tenant is to deposit is the arrears due so that when time barred arrears remain due, notwithstanding recovery thereof being barred by law of limitation, it might have been rightly held that the tenant's liability extends to the extent of requiring him to deposit even the time barred arrears but such is not the provision in the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act. We have carefully considered this contention raised by Mr. Mitra but we have failed to find any material difference with regard to the material provision in the two statute. While under the U.P Act the tenant was required to deposit the entire amount of rent and damages due here as we have indicated hereinbefore under S. 17(1) the tenant is required to deposit or pay to the landlord the entire amount calculated at the rate of rent at which it was last paid for the period for which the tenant may have made default. Substantially the provision is the same and the requirement is that the entire amount in arrears has to be deposited by the tenant in order to entitle him to get relief under sub-s. (4) thereof. This being the position, we are of the view that the decisions relied on by Mr. Mitra stands overruled by the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Khadi Gram Udyog Trust v. Shri Ram Chandraji Virajman Mandir.
6. The only point raised by Mr. Mitra, therefore, fails. Mr. Mitra in his fairness has not disputed the propriety of the learned Judge's order refusing to grant any liberal instalment in view of the fact that the tenant-defendant is a Government undertaking and also in view of the fact that the entire amount had already been deposited by the tenant-defendant in the court below. Both the patties, however, agree before us that the learned Subordinate Judge had not calculated the interest correctly. They agree that statutory interest on the arrears would amount to Rs. 10,182.29 so that the total amount payable towards arrears under consideration and the interest thereon would be Rs. 38,932.29 and not Rs. 39,539.22 as assessed by the learned Subordinate Judge. Subject to the modification of the order in this regard, the order passed by too learned Subordinate Judge is upheld. The excess amount if paid or deposited may be refunded or adjusted. The application is disposed of accordingly. There will be no order for costs.
B.C Chakraborty, J.:—I agree.
Order modified.
Alert