Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Promode Kumar Mittal And Others v. Southern Steel Ltd. And Others.

Calcutta High Court
Oct 30, 1979
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an application under ss. 397, 398, 402, 403 etc. of the Companies Act, 1956, arising from intra-family disputes within the Mittal family over control and management of companies, specifically Southern Steel Ltd. The petitioners are Mohan Lal Mittal (the eldest brother) and his sons; the respondents include Indra Sen Mittal, R.K. Mittal and other brothers and persons aligned with them, together with other directors of the company.

The petitioners allege that they (together with another son, Laxmi Niwas Mittal) hold one-tenth of the issued and subscribed capital of Southern Steel Ltd and so are qualified under s. 399. The petition raises multiple factual complaints concerning board and administrative actions in May–December 1976, summarized as follows (as pleaded by the petitioners):

  • A board meeting called for 14 May 1976 could not be held for want of quorum and was adjourned to 16 May 1976; the petitioners allege they were not given notice of the adjourned meeting and that the 16 May meeting (held at Hyderabad) was unlawful.
  • The company secretary (V.S. Modi) purportedly called a board meeting on 31 May 1976 at the registered office in Calcutta; petitioners allege irregularity concerning notice for that meeting.
  • Allegation that respondent No.5 (R.K. Mittal) took away company documents and papers from the registered office and refused to return them.
  • Allegation that despite this Court's refusal in 1970 to transfer the registered office from Calcutta to Hyderabad, respondent No.5 shifted the administrative office to Hyderabad on 7 June 1976 to circumvent that order.
  • Allegations that required accounts from the Hyderabad factory were not sent, preventing preparation/publication of trial balance and balance-sheet; auditor's objections not forwarded or addressed appropriately.
  • Allegations that secretary and senior officers were transferred from Calcutta to Hyderabad without lawful ground or board resolution.
  • Allegation that the registered office was purportedly shifted (by letter dated 21 December 1976) to No. 8, Old Post Office Street, Calcutta without a board resolution or tenancy at that address.

The respondents filed detailed answers denying the material allegations. Key factual points and context in the respondents' pleadings (and other facts found by the court) include:

  • R.K. Mittal called the 14 May 1976 meeting (notice dated 3 May 1976); Mohan Lal purported to postpone it by a notice dated 5 May 1976, which R.K. Mittal disputed.
  • The 14 May meeting failed for want of quorum and was adjourned to 16 May 1976; respondents contend no fresh notice was required for that adjourned meeting and that the 16 May meeting was validly held.
  • The Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation financed the company and insisted that the registered office be shifted to Hyderabad (where the factory and main business were situated); respondents say appropriate resolutions were passed to effect the shift.
  • Respondents denied that R.K. Mittal removed documents improperly and denied many of the petitioners' factual assertions about accounts, claiming instead that irregularities, increased expenses and recruitment at the Calcutta office justified administrative changes.
  • The company was incorporated on 14 January 1976 with registered office at No. 2, Brabourne Road, Calcutta; the factory and main business were in Hyderabad; shares were quoted on the stock exchange.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether any fresh notice was necessary for the adjourned board meeting fixed for 16 May 1976 after the 14 May 1976 meeting failed for want of quorum.
  2. Whether the acts complained of by the petitioners (including transfer of registered/administrative office, transfer of officers, withholding of accounts and alleged removal of documents) constituted oppression or mismanagement under ss. 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as represented by Mr. R.C. Nag et al.)

  • The adjourned meeting held on 16 May 1976 was invalid because no fresh notice was given to the petitioners; therefore the resolutions passed thereat were illegal.
  • The respondents suppressed the court's 1970 order refusing transfer of the registered office to Andhra Pradesh, which the petitioners said was a material suppression amounting to oppression and misleading the court.
  • The transfer of the secretary and administrative office to Hyderabad, and shifting of documents and accounts, were challenged as irregular and prejudicial acts amounting to oppression and mismanagement.
  • The correctness of the minutes of the 16 May 1976 meeting was also challenged by the petitioners.

Respondents' Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The adjourned meeting of 16 May 1976 was lawfully held; under the Companies Act and the company's articles no fresh notice was required for an adjourned meeting.
  • The 5 May 1976 purported postponement notice issued by Mohan Lal was without authority; a director acting alone cannot unilaterally postpone a meeting convened by the company.
  • There was no unlawful removal of documents by R.K. Mittal; respondents denied the alleged acts of taking papers and books.
  • The Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation, as financier and having a nominee director, required the registered office to be shifted to Hyderabad where the factory and main operations were situated; respondents maintained the transfer and related administrative changes were justified and in the company's interest.
  • Secretary and senior officers transferred to Hyderabad were said to be necessary given increased expenses and new appointments at the Calcutta office; respondents also alleged those officers were aligned with Mohan Lal, explaining some of the conflict.
  • Interim orders and steps taken subsequently had regularised the acts complained of, reducing or removing any basis for relief now sought.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the pleaded facts, the company’s articles of association, and the statutory provisions (Companies Act, 1956) pertinent to adjourned meetings and board authority. The court's step-by-step analysis, stated in the opinion, is as follows:

  1. Identified the factual focal point: the 14 May 1976 meeting failed for want of quorum and was adjourned to 16 May 1976; the core legal question was whether any fresh notice was required for the adjourned meeting.
  2. Consulted the Companies Act and the company's articles. The court held that article 146 of the articles of association applied to the adjourned meeting and empowered the directors present at the adjourned meeting to fix the day, time and place of the adjourned meeting; article 147 (relied on by the petitioners) applied only to convening a meeting for the first time and so was inapplicable to an adjourned meeting.
  3. Concluded that, under article 146 and the applicable statutory provisions, no fresh notice was necessary for the adjourned meeting. Consequently, the meeting held on 16 May 1976 was legal and valid; the resolutions passed at that meeting did not suffer from the alleged illegality.
  4. Addressed the broader allegations of oppression and mismanagement under ss. 397 and 398. The court found no substantiated grounds in the petition that constituted oppression or mismanagement within the statutory meaning. The court rejected the submission that respondents had materially suppressed the earlier 1970 refusal to transfer the registered office, noting changed circumstances between 1970 and 1979 and the legitimate interest of the financier (Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation) and the company’s business being in Andhra Pradesh.
  5. Weighed the conduct and motives of the petitioners and respondents. The court viewed the application as mala fide and stated that Mohan Lal had initiated a spate of litigation after intra-family arbitration failed, and that some actions (such as transfer of secretary and administrative office) were in the best interests of the company and its shareholders rather than oppressive.
  6. Considered subsequent events and interim orders: the respondents submitted, and the court accepted, that interim orders and steps taken after the complaints had removed or regularised the acts complained of; the court took these subsequent events into account in denying relief.
  7. On balance, the court found no legal infirmity in the adjourned meeting or the other acts alleged, no proved oppression/mismanagement as per the Companies Act provisions relied upon by the petitioners, and no basis to grant the relief sought.

Holding and Implications

APPLICATION DISMISSED WITH COSTS

Direct effects and specific orders made by the court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The application under ss. 397, 398, 402, 403 etc. of the Companies Act, 1956, is dismissed with costs.
  • The Special Officer, Mr. C.R. Dutt, Barrister-at-Law, is discharged. Any arrears of remuneration due to him are to be paid out of the funds of the company.
  • The remuneration of the Special Officer is fixed at "100 g. ms." (as recorded in the opinion).
  • All parties and the Special Officer are to act on a signed copy of the minutes.
  • The petitioners were informed they are at liberty to sell their quoted shares at the market rate.

No new legal precedent was stated to have been laid down by the court in this opinion; the decision resolved the application on the statutory and articles-based interpretation and the facts of this dispute between family factions.

Show all summary ...

Salil K. Roy Chowdhury, J.:— This is another application under ss. 397, 398, 402, 403, etc., of the Companies Act, 1956, in the series of litigations between Mohan Lal Mittal group and his opposing group. These applications are the outcome of family disputes as all the companies concerned in these applications are under the control and management of the Mittal family as the directors are either the members of the Mittal family or their relatives or nominees or stooges. They reveal a general pattern of running parallel management, one group trying to oust the other group from the companies in which the majority shares belong to the respondents. The present application is by Mohan Lal Mittal, the eldest brother of the Mittal family, and his sons as petitioners and the respondents are Indra Sen Mittal and the group of brothers and persons supporting him and the other directors of the company who are merely relatives, friends or stooges of the Mittal family. The petitioners allege in para. 8 of the petition that they themselves along with another son of Mohan Lal Mittal, Sri Laxmi Niwas Mittal, hold 1/10th of the issued and subscribed capital of the respondent-company, Southern Steel Ltd., and, therefore, they are qualified under s. 399 of the Companies Act, 1956.

2. The allegations which are the basis of the present application under ss. 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956, are that the meeting fixed to be held on the 14th of May, 1976, could not be attended to by the petitioners and was not held due to want of quorum. It is alleged that the said meeting was adjourned till 16th of May, 1976, and was held without any notice to the petitioners that the meeting was fixed on the 16th of May, 1976, and the alleged meeting on the 16th of May, 1976, was held at Hyderabad and various resolutions were passed. The next allegations are that the secretary of the company, V.S Modi, duly called a meeting of the board of directors to be held on the 31st of May, 1976, at its registered office at Calcutta, for which notice was duly given by the directors. Respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, did not attend the said meeting on the 31st of May, 1976, at the registered office at Calcutta, and it is alleged that in the said meeting it was resolved that all the meetings of the respondent-company, the Southern Steel Ltd., would be held at the registered office at Calcutta. Next it is alleged that respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, took away various documents, papers and books of the respondent-company forcibly which were required to be kept at the registered office at Calcutta and in spite of demand and request he did not return the same. It is further alleged that, in spite of the rejection of the application for transfer of the registered office at Calcutta, from Calcutta to Hyderabad, by this court in 1970, respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, to circumvent the order of this court, shifted the administrative office of the respondent-company from Calcutta to Hyderabad with effect from 7th of June, 1976. There were other allegations that the accounts of the respondent-company have been lying ready and the trial balance-sheet could not be prepared for want of accounts of the Hyderabad factory which were not sent deliberately by respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, nor the auditor's objection forwarded by S.R Batliboy in respect of its irregularities, and discrepancies of the Hyderabad factory were answered by respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, as a result of which the balance-sheet could not either be prepared or published. The petitioners' further allegations are that the said respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, without any lawful ground or without any resolution of the board of directors, transferred the secretary and senior officers of the respondent-company from Calcutta to Hyderabad. One of the other allegations is that the said respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, by his letter dated the 21st December, 1976, disclosed that the registered office of the respondent-company has been purported to be shifted to No. 8, Old Post Office St., Calcutta, from No. 2, Brabourne Road, Calcutta, and it is alleged that no resolution was passed in any meeting of the board of directors of the respondent-company nor any tenancy was ever obtained by the respondent-company at No. 8, Old Post Office St., Calcutta.

3. The respondent duly answered the said allegations alleging that the petitioners have no right to ask for postponement of the meeting to be held on the 14th of May, 1976. The said meeting was attended by respondent No. 3, Indra Sen Mittal, and respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, but it was adjourned due to lack of quorum till 16th of May, 1976, and the adjourned board meeting was duly and lawfully held on the 16th of May, 1976. It was further submitted by the respondents that no notice is required to be given for any adjourned meeting either under the Companies Act or under the articles of association of the company. The respondents denied the validity and legality of the purported notice to convene a meeting of the board alleged to be held on the 31st of May, 1976, issued by the alleged secretary, V.S Modi. Respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, also denied that any paper and document has been taken away by him as alleged. The respondents, in my view, rightly submitted that the company being financed by the Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation was committed to shift its registered office from Calcutta to Hyderabad where admittedly the company's factory is situate and the main business is conducted and as the said Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation was insisting upon the said transfer, the resolution was passed accordingly on the 16th of May, 1976. It is further alleged by the respondents that according to the resolution of the said adjourned meeting dated the 16th of May, 1976, the accounts in respect of the establishment at Calcutta was to be sent to Hyderabad. It is also denied by the respondents that the accounts at Calcutta were ready as alleged by the petitioners. It is further denied that the trial balance-sheet of the Calcutta office was ever sent to Hyderabad as alleged by the petitioners. The respondents alleged that there was enormous increase and unjustified expenses incurred at the Calcutta office and the appointment of eleven new persons at the Calcutta office warranted the said transfer of the Secretary and the senior officers from Calcutta to the Hyderabad office. It is specifically alleged, and in my view quite rightly from the facts disclosed in the pleadings and documents placed before the court, that the said secretary and the senior officers were henchmen of Mohan Lal Mittal, petitioner No. 3, the prime mover of the present application and the person behind the whole dispute. The respondents also denied that no tenancy has been taken in respect of premises No. 8, Old Post Office St., Calcutta, where the registered office of the respondent-company has been duly transferred from No. 2, Brabourne Road, Calcutta, for which proper resolution has been duly passed.

4. It appears from the facts of the case that on the 14th of January, 1976, the respondent-company was incorporated as a public limited company having its registered office at No. 2, Brabourne Road, Calcutta, and the main business of the company has been to manufacture and/or get cold rolled, narrow strips and strapings from skelp and factory of the company was situated at Hyderabad. It also appears that the respondent-company is a public limited company and the shares are quoted in the stock exchange. On the 3rd of May, 1976, by a notice, respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, as a director called a meeting of the board of directors of the company at Hyderabad to be held on the 14th of May, 1976. It appears that on the 5th of May, 1976, petitioner No. 3, Mohal Lal Mittal, as a director issued a notice to all the directors intimating postponement of the meeting to be held on the 14th of May, 1976, due to unavoidable circumstances. It is not understood how a director has the power individually to postpone a meeting duly convened by the company and the said right was duly disputed by respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, by a letter dated the 8th of May, 1976. On the 11th of May, 1976, the said R.K Mittal, respondent No. 5, who is admittedly the whole-time director of the respondent-company intimated the directors the supplementary agenda to be taken up in the meeting to be held on the 14th of May, 1976. Thereafter, the meeting scheduled to be held on the 14th of May, 1976, could not be held due to lack of quorum and it was adjourned till 16th of May, 1976. The whole dispute in this application turns on the question whether any fresh notice of the adjourned meeting was necessary to be given to the directors and it appears to me from the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, and the articles of association of the company that for an adjourned meeting no fresh notice is necessary and, therefore, in my view, the meeting held on the 16th of May, 1976, appears to be legal, valid and according to law and it is not ultra vires or illegal as alleged by the petitioners. The articles of association of the respondent-company relied on by the petitioners being 147 has no application as that applies only in convening a meeting for the first time and has nothing to do with the adjourned meeting which has already been convened and the article applicable in the present case is article 146 which gives power to the directors present in the meeting which failed for want of quorum to adjourn the said meeting to such day time and place as the director or directors present at the meeting may fix. Therefore, there is no question of any fresh notice for the adjourned meeting which was scheduled to be held on the 14th of May, 1976, and was duly held on the 16th of May, 1976, to which date it was adjourned by the directors who were present on the 14th of May, 1976. The resolutions passed therein do not suffer from any illegality or infirmity as alleged by the petitioners in any way whatsoever.

5. Mr. R.C Nag, appearing with Mr. R.K Lala, Mr. Sudipta Sarkar and Mr. A.K Bose, for the petitioners, mainly challenged the validity of the meeting held on the 16th of May, 1976, and also the correctness of the said minutes of the meeting which is alleged to be subsequently disclosed to the petitioners.

6. I have already set out the charges made by the petitioners and the answers thereto by the respondents and, in my view, there is no ground whatsoever substantiated by the petitioners which can constitute an oppression or mismanagement within the meaning of s. 397 or s. 398 of the Companies Act, 1956. Mr. Nag's submission is that the respondents have suppressed the fact that the court in 1970 refused to transfer the registered office of the company to Andhra Pradesh which is a material suppression and which should be held to be an oppression and misleading the court. In my view, such comment is not justified as we are in 1979 and the situation in 1970 and in 1979 can never be the same and, on the other hand, it cannot but be admitted that it is entirely different and the application for transfer of the registered office which is now to be made before the Company Law Board may be granted as admittedly the factory and main business of the company are in Andhra Pradesh. It is only that all the companies belonged to the Mittal group and, therefore, originally the registered offices of the companies were situated in Calcutta and now there is a split in the Mittal family. The said Mohan Lal Mittal, the eldest brother, his sons and their stooges and relatives have formed a group whereas Inder Sen Mittal and R.K Mittal and their relatives have formed another group and the spate of litigation has started making reckless allegations against each other. Serious comment was made by the petitioners for whom Mr. Nag appeared and with his usual force and thoroughness tried to make a point of the transfer of service of the secretary to Hyderabad and shifting of the administrative office at Hyderabad. In the facts and circumstances of this case, in my view, those acts cannot constitute any oppression or mismanagement in any way whatsoever. On the other hand, it appears to me that those acts on the part of respondent No. 5, R.K Mittal, as the director-in-charge of the respondent-company, appears to be conducive to the best interests of the company and its shareholders. Further, I do not find any substance in the submission of Mr. Nag that the adjourned meeting held on the 16th of May, 1976, pursuant to the notice dated 3rd of May, 1976, issued by the said R.K Mittal as director-in-charge to be held at Hyderabad has any legal infirmity or constitutes any oppression as alleged by the petitioners. Article 146 of the articles of association of the company is quite clear that the directors present on the 14th of May, 1976, when the meeting failed for lack of quorum, had the jurisdiction and authority to fix the date and time of the adjourned meeting and which they did and the meeting was duly held on the 16th of May, 1976, when the resolutions were duly passed. In my view, there is no ground whatsoever in the petition and I find no substance in the submission of Mr. Nag as to the allegations of oppression and mismanagement of acts prejudicial to the public interest. On the other hand, this application is absolutely mala fide and has been made at the instance of Mohan Lal Mittal against his other brothers who were no longer agreeing with him as to his despotic and karta-like attitude and treating the company and its properties, assets and its affairs as the personal and family properties of the Mittals.

7. Mr. S.B Mukherjee, appearing with Mrs. U.B Mukherjee, quite rightly submitted that after the arbitration between the members of the Mittal family proved abortive, the series of applications were started by the said Mohan Lal Mittal and the respondents have also made applications to prevent the said Mohan Lal Mittal from doing mischief or acts detrimental to the companies belonging to the Mittal group. It is the said Mohan Lal Mittal who has used the secretary, Mr. Modi, for the purpose of convening the alleged meeting on the 31st of May, 1976, and pass some sort of resolutions, and practically tried to run a parallel management of the company at Calcutta.

8. Mr. Mukherjee rightly submitted that as the business and factory of the company is in Andhra Pradesh and the Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation has its nominee-director in the Board, it is insisting on the transfer of the registered office of the company to Hyderabad in Andhra Pradesh and for that purpose appropriate steps have been taken. He further submitted that pursuant to the interim orders made in this case from time to time all the acts complained of by the petitioners, if there is any basis therein, have been removed and have been regularised and, therefore, there is no more any substance or merit in this application at the present stage. He rightly submitted that the court is to take notice of all the “subsequent events to grant relief finally after the trial of the matter. He referred to the interim orders which were passed from time to time and the meetings held under the chairman appointed by this court and the resolutions passed by the majority shareholders and directors present therein. In my view, Mr. Mukherjee is quite right in his submission and, therefore, I do not find any merit or substance in the application which should be dismissed with costs. The petitioners are at liberty to sell their shares at the market rate as the shares are quoted shares in the stock exchange.

9. In that view of the matter, the application is dismissed with costs. The Special Officer, Mr. C.R Dutt, Barrister-at-Law, will stand discharged. If any arrears of remuneration is due to be paid to him it is to be paid out of the funds of the company. The remuneration of the Special Officer is fixed at 100 g. ms.

10. The Special Officer and all parties to act on a signed copy of the minutes.