- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Ratanlal Bhawalka & Ors.
Case Summary — Judgment
Factual and Procedural Background
The Union of India (plaintiff) filed suit seeking a declaration that premises No. 41 Radhamadhab Saha Lane, Calcutta, stood charged for payment of Rs. 11,443.43 and sought a decree in Form No. 5A of Appendix D under Order 34 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, together with consequential reliefs.
The plaintiff's case was that defendant No. 1, Ratanlal Bhawalka, was assessed for the assessment year 1947–1948 for Rs. 12,943.43 (income-tax and super tax). A notice of demand was served and the defendant paid Rs. 1,500, leaving a balance of Rs. 11,443.43. A certificate under S. 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act was issued for the balance and, pursuant to that, a notice under S. 7 of the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Act was issued and served on 23 May 1951.
Additional sums for assessment years 1949–1950 and 1950–1951 (Rs. 308.25 and Rs. 138.19 respectively) gave rise to further certificate proceedings. The defendants 1 and 2 (owners) transferred the property to defendant No. 3 on 1 October 1951, and defendant No. 3 transferred it to defendant No. 4 on 19 January 1952. The plaintiff alleged that, after service of the S. 7 notice, a charge immediately attached to the immovable property and subsequent purchasers took the property subject to that charge.
Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 did not file written statements or contest the suit at hearing. Defendant Nos. 3 and 4 filed written statements denying that they were bound by the notice, claiming defendant No. 3 was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice and that the transfer to defendant No. 4 was by love and affection and in good faith. They also raised objections regarding the mode and locus of service of the certificate proceedings.
The court framed three issues for determination. The plaintiff examined one witness (Mr. Haro Mohan Biswas) and proved the order sheet and relevant certificate documents. The defendants called no witnesses.
Legal Issues Presented
- Does the plaint disclose any cause of action?
- Was the defendant No. 3 a bona fide purchaser for value without notice?
- To what relief, if any, is the plaintiff entitled?
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- Under the Public Demands Recovery Act, service of a notice on the assessee creates an immediate charge on the immovable property; no specific protection is provided to bona fide purchasers for value after such service.
- By proving that the notice under the Act was served on the assessee, the plaintiff is entitled to obtain a mortgage-type decree and need not take notice of any subsequent transfers, which are barred by the Act.
- Service of the notice in this case was on 23 May 1951; the conveyance to defendant No. 3 was on 1 October 1951 (after service). The certificate debtor appeared before the income-tax/certificate officer, sought time, and appealed, thereby confirming knowledge of the proceedings; he did not challenge service.
- The onus on the plaintiff is only to prove that the certificate notice was filed and (in effect) served on the certificate debtor; that has been done.
Defendant Nos. 3 and 4's Arguments
- Defendant No. 3 was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the certificate proceedings and therefore is not bound by the notice served on defendant No. 1.
- The conveyance to defendant No. 3 (1 October 1951) preceded knowledge of any certificate proceedings; defendant No. 3 relied on requisition of title (Exhibit 1) sent by their solicitors which showed no notice of proceedings.
- The certificate proceedings were commenced and served at Howrah rather than Calcutta; given the property is situate in Calcutta and the proceedings were at Howrah, they contend that S. 8 of the Public Demands Recovery Act would not apply as argued by the plaintiff.
- Service under S. 7 was alleged to be bad or not properly effected; S. 8 (per their argument) makes a charge only from and after proper service; the prescribed mode of service (Rule 2 Schedule 2) was not complied with.
- They contended that S. 8(b) relates to mortgages and not to sale of property, and therefore the plaintiff's suit is not maintainable in relation to a sale/transfer.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by treating the Public Demands Recovery Act, 1913, as a self-contained statute providing a complete procedure for recovery of public demands and observed that it is unaffected by the general law of procedure. The court summarized the statutory scheme:
- Under S. 4 a certificate is to be signed by a certificate officer when satisfied that a public demand is due, and when duly made and filed it has the force and effect of a decree.
- Under S. 7 the certificate, once filed, must be served on the certificate debtor in the prescribed manner; notice under S. 7 binds the immovable property of the debtor and prevents alienation.
- S. 8 provides that from and after service of the S. 7 notice (a) private transfers or delivery of immovable property situated in the district where the certificate is filed shall be void against any claim enforceable in execution of the certificate; and (b) the amount due under the certificate shall be a charge upon the debtor's immovable property wherever situated, postponing subsequently created charges.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court observed that:
- The plaintiff's burden was only to prove that a certificate notice was filed and effectively served on the certificate debtor; the plaintiff had proved filing and service (service dated 23 May 1951) and produced the order sheet and certificate proceedings through its witness.
- The conveyance by defendant Nos. 1 and 2 to defendant No. 3 occurred on 1 October 1951, after service of the S. 7 notice, and the subsequent conveyance to defendant No. 4 was later still; therefore the transfers occurred after service.
- The certificate debtor (defendant No. 1) did not contest service: he appeared before the certificate officer, sought time and a stay on the ground of intending to appeal, and did not challenge the service; that conduct indicated knowledge of the service and, in the court's view, effectively waived any irregularity in service.
- Defendant Nos. 3 and 4 had not pleaded any specific irregularity of service in their written statement; they admitted the material averments in the plaint regarding filing and service of certificate proceedings as substantially correct (the court noted an admission in paragraph 5 of the written statement).
- The court rejected the contention that the fact the certificate proceedings were originally at Howrah (and later transferred) defeated the operation of S. 8. The court interpreted S. 8(b) as creating a charge on immovable property of the certificate debtor "wherever situated" and giving protection to the certificate holder even if the property lay outside the district where proceedings were instituted.
- Given the evidence of filing and service, the timing of subsequent transfers, the certificate debtor's conduct, and the admissions in the written statement, the court concluded the plaintiff was entitled to enforce the charge created under S. 8(b) of the Act.
The court then answered the issues: issue No. 1 (plaintiff's cause of action) was answered in the affirmative; issue No. 2 (whether defendant No. 3 was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice) was answered in the negative; the court further noted that even if it had answered issue No. 2 in the affirmative, that would not have altered the result in view of the law and facts.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The court passed a decree in favour of the plaintiff in terms of prayers (c), (d) and (h) of the plaint, permitting the plaintiff to enforce the charge created under the Public Demands Recovery Act in respect of the subject premises. The court ordered a stay of the operation of the order for one week.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The plaintiff is entitled to enforce the charge created by the certificate under the Public Demands Recovery Act against premises No. 41 Radhamadhab Saha Lane, Calcutta, for the sums claimed in the plaint as reflected in the certificate proceedings.
- The subsequent transfers of the property that took place after service of the S. 7 notice do not defeat the plaintiff's right to enforce the charge; the purchasers (defendant Nos. 3 and 4) are not entitled to avoid the effect of the certificate on the basis of the arguments the court rejected.
- Operation of the court's order was stayed for one week as ordered by the court.
The opinion does not identify or establish a novel judicial precedent; it applies the statutory scheme of the Public Demands Recovery Act and determines the parties' rights under that statute as applied to the established facts.
The final lines of the judgment record: "I pass a decree in favour of the plaintiff in terms of prayers (c), (d) and (h). There will be a stay of the operation of the order for a week." The printed record also contains the line "Suit dismissed." The summary above reproduces the court's dispositive statements as contained in the judgment text.
JUDGMENT
1. This suit has been filed by Union of India against the defendants for a declaration that premises No. 41 Radhamadhab Saha Lane, Calcutta stands charged for payment of a sum of Rs. 11,443.43 and a decree in Form No. 5A of appendix D under Order 34 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code and other consequential reliefs.
2. The case of the plaintiff Union of India is that defendant No. 1 Ratanlal Bhawalka was assessed for the assessment year 1947-1948 for a sum of Rs. 12,943.43 on account of income-tax and super tax. For the said assessment a notice of demand under the Income-tax was duly issued and served on the defendant No. 1. A sum of Rs. 1,500/- only was paid by the defendant No. 1. As a result, certificate under S. 46(2) of Indian Income-tax Act was issued for the balance sum of Rs. 11,443.43 whereupon the Certificate Officer duly issued and served upon the defendant No. 1 a notice under S. 7 of the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Action 23rd May, 1951.
3. For the assessment years 1949-1950 and 1950-1951 a sum of Rs. 308.25 and Rs. 138.19 respectively became due and payable to the plaintiff by the defendant on account of income-tax. Similar notice under S. 29 of the Indian Income-tax Act was issued on the defendant No. 1 and certificate proceedings were started for realisation of the same. The defendant failed and neglected to pay the said sum of rupees to the plaintiff.
4. The defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were the owners of premises No. 41 Radhamadhab Saha Lane, Calcutta. After the issue and due service of the notice under S. 7 of the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Act the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 transferred and/or conveyed at Calcutta on October 1, 1951 the said premises to the defendant No. 3. The defendant No. 3 on her turn on January 19, 1952 conveyed and/or transferred the said premises to the defendant No. 4. The case of the plaintiff is that after the service of the notice under Public Demands Recovery Act a charge is created immediately on the said immovable property for repayment of the dues of the plaintiff. It is further the case of the plaintiff that anybody who has acquired the property after the service of the demand notice has taken the property subject to the charge in favour of the plaintiff. As such the present suit has been filed for enforcing the said charge.
5. The defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have neither filed written statements nor contested the suit at the time of hearing. Defendant Nos. 3 and 4 filed written statements mainly taking the point that as the defendant No. 3 was a bona fide purchaser for value without any knowledge of any notice being served under S. 7 of the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Act on the defendant No. 1, she is not bound by the said notice or her interest in the said premises is not affected thereby. The defendant No. 3 on her turn has conveyed the said premises to the defendant No. 4 out of love and natural affection and the defendant No. 4 on his turn has accepted the same in good faith without being aware of any right, claim and title of the plaintiff in respect of the said premises. The defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have also taken the point that as the certificate proceeding was filed and served at Howrah it was not possible for them to take the notice of the same by making necessary searches being made at Calcutta where the property is situate.
6. It is also the case of the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 that the plaintiff has no cause of action against them. After hearing Mr. Gautam Chakraborty Bar-at-Law with Mr. Probir Majumdar Bar-at-Law appearing for the plaintiff and Mr. Anindya Mitra, Bar-at-Law, appearing for the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 the following issues were raised:
1. Does the plaint disclose any cause of action?
2. Was the defendant No. 3 bona fied purchaser for value without notice?
3. To what relief, if any, is the plaintiff entitled?
7. The only witness examined on behalf of the plaintiff was Mr. Haro Mohan Biswas who has proved the order sheet and other relevant documents in respect of the assessment and also certificate proceedings. The defendants did not call any witness. Mr. Chakraborty argued that under Public Demands Recovery Act as soon as a notice is served on the assessee a charge is created in respect of the property and no specific provision has been made giving protection to a bona fide purchaser for value. As such by simply proving that the notice under the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Act has been served on the assessee the plaintiff can obtain a mortgage decree in respect of the same and the plaintiff is under no obligation to take any notice of any subsequent transfer as that is completely barred under the said Act.
8. In this case notice was served on May 23, 1951 and conveyance in respect of the said property was effected on 1st October 1951 in favour of defendant No. 3. The certificate debtor has deliberately violated the provision of law by making a transfer of the said property after due service of the notice. The defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have not disputed the mode of service of the notice under S. 7 of the Public Demands Recovery Act and also of the certificate proceedings. In fact the certificate debtor appeared before the Income-tax Officer and asked for time and for stay of the proceedings on the ground that he has filed an appeal from the original assessment order. Ultimately, the said appeal was dismissed. As such the defendant No. 1 becomes admittedly a certificate debtor. In fact the defendant No. 1 neither challenged nor took any steps to set aside the certificate proceedings and/or challenge the service of the notice under the said Act. After the notice was duly served under the Public Demands Recovery Act all subsequent transfers become void so far the plaintiffs is concerned.
9. Mr. Mitra appearing on behalf of the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 submitted that as the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 are bona fide purchasers for value and as they had no notice of the certificate proceedings they are not bound by the said provisions. He has further submitted that the certificate proceedings from Howrah were transferred and filed in Alipur in the year 1955, i.e, long after the conveyance that has taken place between the defendant Nos. 1, and 3 in October, 1951. He has further submitted that service of notice under S. 7 is bad and it has not been properly served on the assessee. According to him, S. 8 of the said Act provides that only from and after the service of any notice there would be a charge on the properties. Therefore, untill and unless the service on the original assessee is proved, no charge can be created. He has also challenged the mode of service. Defendant Nos. 2 and 3 have proved the requisition of title which was sent by their Solicitors at the time of purchase of the said property which has been marked as Exhibit ‘1’ in this suit. From the requisition it would appear that they had no notice of the certificate proceedings in respect of the said premises. His contention is that in view of the fact that the property was situate at Calcutta and the certificate proceedings were started and filed originally at Howrah S. 8 of the Public Demands Recovery Act would have no application in this case. He has further submitted that S. 8(b) of the Public Demands Recovery Act does not relate to sale of property but only to mortgages. As such the present suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable. According to him, S. 7 of the said Act provides the mode of service to be effected and there is a prescribed manner as contained in Rule 2 Schedule 2 of the said Act. As according to him, the service was not in accordance with law and being irregular, the provisions regarding restriction on transfer of properties are not applicable.
10. Mr. Chakraborty appearing for the plaintiff has submitted that the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have nowhere pleaded in the written statement regarding the invalidity or irregularity in the mode of service of notice. As such no issue was raised regarding alleged effective service of notice. He was submitted that the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have admitted under S. 58 of the Evidence Act by not denying the validity of the service of the notice. In fact, the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have disclosed the order sheet of the certificate proceedings in their own affidavit of documents.
11. From that order sheet it will appear that the defendant No. 1 has been described as a certificate debtor and he has accepted the said position by appearing before the certificate officer and praying for time so that he could appeal from the certificate proceedings. The defendant No. 1 has been served in accordance with law. Even assuming that he was not properly served, that irregularity has been rectified by the certificate debtor himself by not only waiving his right of challenging the mode of service of notice but also by appearing before the certificate officer and accepting the knowledge of the said service and also by appealing from the said order.
12. In the written statement filed on behalf of defendant Nos. 3 and 4 nowhere they had taken the point by challenging the mode of service or irregularity thereto. As such no issue was framed to that effect. In fact the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 proceeded on the basis that there had been a certificate proceeding but as they are bona fide purchasers of value and without any knowledge of the certificate proceedings, as such they are not bound by the provisions of the Public Demands Recovery Act. In fact in paragraph 5 of the written statement the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have admitted that the statements contained in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the plaint are substantially correct. In paragraph 5 of the plaint the plaintiff has pleaded “after service of the said notice under S. 7 of the Bengal Public Demands Recovery Act the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have conveyed and/or transferred at Calcutta on 1st October, 1951 the said premises No. 41 Radha Madhab Saha Lane, Calcutta to the defendant” and in paragraph 6 the plaintiff has pleaded that there has been a reconveyance. Nowhere in the written statement they have challenged either the notice under S. 7 of the Public Demands Recovery Act or its mode of service on the defendant No. 1. Mr. Mitra has further taken the point that as the certificate proceeding was started and made effective in Howrah and not in Calcutta as such S. 8 has no application as it is only after the sale of the property that the said certificate proceeding has been transferred to Alipore. According to him S. 8(b) of the Public Demands Recovery Act only relates to mortgages and not to sale of property.
13. Public Demands Recovery Act 1913 consolidates law relating to the recovery of public demands. It is a self-contained Act in itself and provides a complete law and a complete procedure of execution and as such it is unaffected by the general law of procedure. This is an Act providing for speedy recovery of public demands of the State of West Bengal.
14. Under S. 4 of the said Act where a certificate officer is satisfied that any public demand payable is due, he may sign a certificate in a prescrided form stating that the demand is due and shall cause the certificate to be filed in his office. After it is filed under S. 7 of the said Act, he shall cause it to be served upon the certificate debtor in the prescribed manner a notice in the prescribed form and a copy of the certificate. A certificate when duly made and filed in accordance with law has the force and effect of a decree. Non-service of the notice does not affect the validity of the certificate. Notice under S. 7 merely binds the immovable property of the debtor and prevents alienation. Section 8 of the Public Demands Recovery Act provides — “From and after service of notice any certificate under S. 7 upon a certificate debtor, —(a) any private transfer or delivery of any immovable property situated in the district in which the certificate is filed, or of any interest in any such property shall be void against any claim enforceable in execution of the certificate and (b) the amount due from time to time in respect of the certificate shall be a charge upon the immovable property of the certificate debtor wherever situated to which every other charge created subsequently, to the service of the said notice shall be postponed”. The service of S. 7 notice binds the immovable property, alienation against the claim of the certificate and makes the certificate holder simple mortgagee for all practical purposes. A private transfer is not absolutely void but void against any claim enforceable under this Act. Clause (b) of section gives the jurisdiction to a certificate officer to order sale of property belonging to the certificate debtor but situated outside the territorial jurisdictions of the certificate officer. From the language of sub-clause (b) of S. 8, it is clear that the amount due in respect of the certificate shall be a charge upon the immovable property of the certificate debtor wherever the property is situate. Under sub-clause (a) of S. 8 of the said Act in case of private transfer or delivery of a property situate in the district in which the certificate is filed shall be void against any claim enforceable in execution of the certificate. The plaintiff has filed the present suit to enforce the charge created under S. 8(b) of the said Act. In the prayer portion the plaintiff has claimed for a declaration that the said premises No. 41 Radha Madhab Saha Lane, Calcutta stands charged for the payment of the sum of Rs. 11,443.43 and also for a decree in form No. 5A or appropriate forms of Appendix D of the Code of Civil Procedure under Order 34 Rule 4.
15. In the case of enforcement of charge it does not matter wherever the property is situated as soon as a certificate is issued and served on and from the date of the service of the certificate under S. 7 immediately a charge is created on the immovable property of the certificate debtor wherever the property is situated and it is not confined to the district wherefrom the certificate proceedings have been started or served on the certificate debtor. The effect of S. 8 is to give protection to the certificate holder in both types of cases. First of all the certificate creditor is protected under sub-??? under S. 7 by any bona fide purchase by a third party. The only onus on the plaintiff is to prove that a certificate notice was filed and in effect served on the certificate debtor and thereafter he can enforce his charge. That is exactly what has been done by the plaintiff in this suit. In this present suit the notice was served on 23rd May 1951 and the conveyance effected by the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 in favour of the defendant No. 3 was on 1st October 1951 and the conveyance by defendant No. 3 in favour of the defendant No. 4 was made subsequently. In fact there has been a substantial compliance of the mode of service as envisaged under the said Act. Moreover considering the fact that the certificate debtor himself has not challenged the mode of service, on the contrary pursuant to the service of the said notice he appeared before the certificate officer and prayed for time and stay of the proceedings on the ground that he was going to file an appeal therefrom would clearly show that the certificate debtor must have been served with the notice and he was satisfied with the mode of service otherwise he would have challenged the service of notice on him. Moreover the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 in their written statement have nowhere challenged the mode of service, on the contrary they have admitted the averments in the plaint regarding the filing and service of certificate proceedings as substantially correct. The defendant No. 3 must have been put to this difficulty by the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 by not disclosing the correct facts at the time of sale of the said property for that I have all the sympathy for them. Be that as it may the plaintiff's right cannot in any way be affected by the said sale. As such I am of the opinion that the plaintiff is entitled to enforce the charge as prayed for in the plaint. I answer the issues in the manner following:—
I answer issue No. 1 in the affirmative. In view of the fact that the defendant Nos. 3 and 4 have led no evidence. So far as issue No. 2 is concerned, I answer the same in the negative. Even assuming I answered No. 2 in the positive that would not have made any difference in this case in view of the law and facts as discussed above.
I pass a decree in favour of the plaintiff in terms of prayers (c), (d) and (h).
There will be a stay of the operation of the order for a week.
Suit dismissed.
Alert