Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jhabarmull Agarwalla v. Kashiram Agarwalla And Others.

Calcutta High Court
Mar 15, 1968
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On August 3, 1964, the police seized nine trunk loads of documents when opposite party No. 1, Kashiram Agarwalla, was removing them. The petitioner filed a complaint against opposite parties Nos. 1 and 2 the same day before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, who took cognizance and directed inquiry by the police. After inquiry, the magistrate summoned the opposite parties under section 424 of the Indian Penal Code.

The Income-Tax Officer (opposite party No. 3) applied on September 21, 1964, under section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure, seeking possession of the seized documents for examination in connection with assessment proceedings. The Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate initially permitted inspection and later ordered on October 9, 1964 that the documents be made over to the Income-Tax Officer for one month. That order became subject to review applications and transfer of the case: the case was transferred on November 2, 1964, and the transferee Magistrate rejected reconsideration on November 14, 1964.

The petitioner obtained a rule (i.e., instituted the present proceeding) on December 14, 1964; further proceedings were stayed. At the time of the opinion, the seized documents had not yet been made over in compliance with the magistrate's October 9 order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an Income-Tax Officer has power under section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure, to call for and have produced documents in the possession of a criminal court (i.e., whether the Income-Tax Officer's statutory powers include the civil court power under Order XIII, rule 10).
  2. Whether the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate had jurisdiction to make over the seized documents to the Income-Tax Officer—specifically, whether the documents were part of the magistrate's record and therefore available to be made over pursuant to the requisition under section 131(1) read with Order XIII, rule 10.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Dutta)

  • The Income-Tax Officer's powers under section 131(1) do not include the particular power conferred on a civil court by Order XIII, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure; the officer's powers should be read only as corresponding to specific provisions of the Code (i.e., clauses (a) and (c) of s.131(1) correspond to Order XI, rule 14 regarding calling documents from a party to a suit).
  • The seized documents were not part of the record of the case arising out of the petitioner's complaint; therefore, the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to make over those documents to the Income-Tax Officer.

Other Parties' Arguments

This opinion does not contain a detailed account of the opposing parties' legal arguments beyond references to the Income-Tax Officer's application and citations of earlier decisions supporting the view that an Income-Tax Officer can call for documents under the relevant provisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. State [1961] 42 I.T.R. 753 Illustrated an instance where the Income-Tax Officer called for documents from a Chief Presidency Magistrate under the then section 37(1) of the Income-Tax Act read with Order XIII, rule 10 of the Code; indicated that proceedings had been conducted on the assumption that such a power existed. The court referred to this decision to show that a similar statutory provision (section 37(1) of the old Act) was acted upon as conferring the power to call for documents; it treated that decision as indicating the judges' view and accepted its guidance in holding that section 131(1) confers the relevant power.
Ganpatrai Rawatmull v. Collector, Land Customs, Calcutta [1961] 42 I.T.R. 107 Decision by D.N. Sinha J. taking a similar view that an Income-Tax Officer could call for documents under the statutory provision read with Order XIII, rule 10. The court cited this decision as supporting the proposition that an Income-Tax Officer has the power under Order XIII, rule 10, and expressly agreed with the view expressed therein.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act, which confers on the Income-Tax Officer "the same powers as are vested in a court under the Code of Civil Procedure ... when trying a suit" in respect of specified matters (discovery and inspection; enforcing attendance and examining on oath; compelling production of books of account and other documents; issuing commissions). The court rejected the petitioner's narrow reading that those powers were to be tied only to specific named rules of the Code (for example, that clauses (a) and (c) correspond only to Order XI, rule 14).

The court explained that Order XI, rule 14 gives the civil court power to call for documents from a party, but the civil court also has powers to obtain documents from third persons (for example, Order XVI, rule 1, to summon a witness to produce a document) and Order XIII, rule 10 to call for documents from another court. Because section 131(1) confers, in broad terms, "the same powers as are vested in a court" on specified matters, the Income-Tax Officer must be understood to have all relevant civil-court powers relating to the production of books of account and other documents, which includes the power under Order XIII, rule 10 to call for documents from other courts.

The court cited earlier decisions (Union of India v. State and Ganpatrai Rawatmull) that had proceeded on the assumption that the Income-Tax Officer could call for documents under the comparable earlier statutory provision; although one of those cases did not expressly decide the point, the court found them indicative and respectfully agreed with their views.

The court then addressed the jurisdictional contention. It observed that the documents had been seized by police before the complaint was filed, but the petitioner's complaint specifically referred to the seizure and prayed that the seized books of accounts be kept in the custody of the court. When the magistrate took cognizance and summoned the opposite parties, the magistrate effectively treated the seized documents as documents in that case. Subsequent magistrate orders and police reports (including a police report of September 12, 1964 stating that the documents were kept in police malkhana as per the court's order dated August 3, 1964) supported that the magistrate had directed the police to keep the documents in its custody and thus was seised of them as part of the case record.

On that basis the court concluded that the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate had jurisdiction to make over the seized documents to the Income-Tax Officer pursuant to the requisition under section 131(1) read with Order XIII, rule 10, and found no ground to interfere with the magistrate's order directing the police to make over the documents.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The rule is discharged; the magistrate's order directing the police to make over the seized documents to the Income-Tax Officer is upheld.

Direct consequences and directions given by the court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The records are to be sent down at once and the seized documents are to be made over to the Income-Tax Officer (opposite party No. 3), breaking seals and locks if necessary.
  • The Income-Tax Officer is directed to return the documents after one month of receipt.
  • After return of the documents, the criminal case should be heard as expeditiously as possible.
  • The petitioner's prayer (Mr. Roy's prayer) for a stay of operation of this order to enable the petitioner to obtain a stay from the Supreme Court was rejected.

Broader implications:
The court adopted an interpretation of section 131(1) that includes civil-court powers, specifically the power under Order XIII, rule 10, to call for documents from another court. The opinion expressly states agreement with prior decisions reaching a like conclusion. The opinion does not frame or declare any further novel precedent beyond applying and endorsing those authorities; its practical effect is to confirm that an Income-Tax Officer may requisition documents from a criminal court under the cited statutory and procedural provisions and that a magistrate who is seised of seized documents may lawfully make them over in response to such a requisition.


End of summary based solely on the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

R.N Dutt, J.:— This rule is directed against an order made by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, making over certain documents seized by the police, to the Income-Tax Officer, Companies Dist. III, ‘E’ Ward, Calcutta.

2. On August 3, 1964, at about 3 p.m when opposite party No. 1, Kashiram Agarwalla, was removing 9 trunk loads of documents, the police seized them.

3. The same day the petitioner filed a petition of complaint against opposite party No. 1 and his wife, opposite party No. 2, before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate. He directed the petition of complaint to be put up on the next day and on August 4, 1964, he examined the petitioner and then sent it to the police for enquiry and report. The police made an enquiry and submitted a report and thereafter the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate summoned opposite parties Nos. 1 and 2 under section 424 of the Indian Penal Code. The Income-Tax Officer, Companies District III, ‘E’ Ward, Calcutta, who has been made opposite party No. 3 in this rule, in the meantime filed an application before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate on September 21, 1964, under section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure, praying that the seized documents be made over to him for a period of two months for his examination in connection with the assessment proceedings against opposite party No. 1. The Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate at first permitted him to inspect the documents, and, subsequently, on a further petition from the Income-Tax Officer, he made an order on October 9, 1964, making over the seized documents to the Income-Tax Officer for one month. When opposite parties Nos. 1 and 2 appeared before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, he transferred the case on November 2, 1964, to Shri R. Mahapatra, Presidency Magistrate, for disposal. Opposite party No. 1 in the meantime filed an application for reconsideration of the order making over the seized books to the Income-Tax Officer. When the case was transferred, the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate recorded that the transferee court would consider this application. Subsequently, Shri R. Mahapatra rejected this application for the reconsideration on November 14, 1964. The petitioner thereafter obtained this rule on December 14, 1964, and further proceedings were stayed. We are informed that the documents had not as yet been made over to the Income-Tax Officer in compliance with the order of the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate dated October 9, 1964.

4. Mr. Dutta appearing before us for the petitioner has contended that the Income-Tax Officer made the prayer before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate under section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure, but the powers given to the Income-Tax Officer under section 131(1) of the Act do not include the power conferred on the civil court under Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure. Section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act reads as follows:

“131.(1) The Income-Tax Officer, Appellate Assistant Commissioner and Commissioner shall, for the purposes of this Act, have the same powers as are vested in a court under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), when trying a suit in respect of the following matters, namely:

(a) Discovery and inspection;

(b) enforcing the attendance of any person, including any officer of a banking company and examining him on oath;

(c) compelling the production of books of account and other documents; and

(d) issuing commissions.”

5. Mr. Dutt submits that under clauses (a) and (c) read together, the Income-Tax Officer has the powers of a civil court under Order XI, rule 14, of the Code, but he has no powers under Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code. This argument cannot be accepted. Order XI, rule 14, confers powers on a civil court to call for documents from a party to the suit. But the civil court has also the power to call for documents from a third person. Under Order XVI, rule 1, the civil court has the power to summon a witness to produce a document. Similarly, under Order XIII, rule 10, the civil court has the power to call for a document from some other court. The powers conferred on the Income-Tax Officer under section 131(1) of the Act have not been specified with reference to particular provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure but all the powers which the civil court has under the Code have been conferred on the Income-Tax Officer on some specified matters. One such matter is “compelling the production of books of accounts and other documents”. Section 131(1) must, therefore, be construed to confer on the Income-Tax Officer all the relevant powers which the civil courts have under the Code of Civil Procedure regarding the production of books of account and other documents. Since Order XIII, rule 10, confers such power on the civil court to call for documents from other courts, the Income-Tax Officer too has such powers under section 131(1) of the Act. We should in this connection refer to the decision of S.K Sen and K.C Sen JJ. in Union of India v. State [1961] 42 I.T.R 753.. There in that case the Income-Tax Officer called for certain documents from the Chief Presidency Magistrate under section 37(1) of the then Income-Tax Act read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure. Section 131(1) of the present Act is in the same terms as section 37(1) of the old Act. Mr. Dutt has, however, submitted that all concerned proceeded in that case on the assumption that the Income-Tax Officer can call for documents from a Magistrate under Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code and this point was not specifically raised and considered. It is true that this point was not specifically considered but the decision no doubt indicates the mind of the judges and no objection was raised in this respect on behalf of the assessee that the Income-Tax Officer has not the power under Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code to call for documents from a Magistrate. Similar view was also taken by D.N Sinha J., as his Lordship then was, in Ganpatrai Rawatmull v. Collector, Land Customs, Calcutta [1961] 42 I.T.R 107.. For the reasons we have discussed, we respectfully agree with the views expressed in these cases and we hold that the Income-Tax Officer has the power under Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code.

6. Mr. Dutt has then argued that the documents in question were not part of the record of the case arising out of the complaint of the petitioner and as such the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate had no jurisdiction to make over the same to the Income-Tax Officer. We have said that the documents were seized by the police before the complaint was filed and the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate took cognizance of the case but we find that the petitioner in his petition of complaint referred to the seizure of these documents from opposite party No. 1 alleging that opposite party No. 1, being a director of certain companies of which the petitioner was also a director, were secreting the documents and made prayer that the seized books of accounts may be kept in the custody of the court. It is true that the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate made no formal order for treating the seized documents as seized in this case. But when the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate took cognizance of the case on the basis of this complaint of the petitioner and opposite parties Nos. 1 and 2 were summoned in consequence, there is no doubt that the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate treated the seized documents as documents seized in this case as prayed for by the petitioner. Moreover, from the subsequent orders made by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate in respect of these documents, it is clear that he was treating these documents as documents seized in this case and subject to his orders. When he directed the documents to be made over to the Income-Tax Officer, the petitioner made an application that, in order to avoid delay in the trial of the case, the Income-Tax Officer might be directed to take possession of the documents after the disposal of the case. That shows that even the petitioner treated the documents as seized in this case and subject to the orders of the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate. Then again, we find that after the police seized these documents on August 3, 1964, the police made a report of this seizure to the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate and the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate directed the police to keep the documents in its custody. I have been able to trace a copy of this report in the lower court records but I have not been able to trace the relevant order made by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate. The learned advocates on either side also tried their best but could not trace that order but I find that the police in a further report submitted to the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate on September 12, 1964, specifically said that the seized documents were kept in the police malkhana as per the learned court's order dated August 3, 1964. Presumably, therefore, there is no doubt that the learned Magistrate made an order on August 3, 1964, directing the police to keep the documents in its custody. Thus, in either view of the matter, there is no doubt that the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate was in seisin of the seized documents as part of his records and as such he had jurisdiction to make over the documents to the Income-Tax Officer in compliance with his requisition under section 131(1) of the Income-Tax Act read with Order XIII, rule 10, of the Code of Civil Procedure. We do not, therefore, see any ground to interfere with the order made by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate on December 9, 1964, directing the police to make over the seized documents to the Income-Tax Officer.

7. In the result, the rule is discharged. Let the records be sent down at once and the seized documents be made over to the Income-Tax Officer, opposite party No. 3—by breaking open the seals and locks, if necessary. The Income-Tax Officer will return the documents after one month of the receipt thereof and thereafter the case should be heard as expeditiously as possible.

8. Mr. Roy's prayer for stay of operation of this order to enable the petitioner to bring a stay order from the Supreme Court is rejected.

K.K Mitra, J.:— I agree.