- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ajoy Raj Singh v. Baj Bahadur Singh & Ors. Opposite Party.
Factual and Procedural Background
This Rule challenges an order of the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, which directed that a lorry seized by police be made over to the accused (opposite party No. 1) on a bond.
The petitioner had filed a petition of complaint alleging cognizable offences relating to a lorry (No. WBA 2079). The Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate directed police to investigate under section 156(3) CrPC. The police treated the petition as an FIR, arrested opposite party No. 1 and seized a lorry (No. WBK 1425) from him. After arrest, opposite party No. 1 was produced before the Magistrate, who granted bail and kept the seized lorry in police custody.
Opposite party No. 1 applied on multiple occasions (12 Feb, 22 Feb and in March 1965) for the lorry to be made over to him on bond. The Magistrate initially refused on 12 Feb and 22 Feb after police reports; on 22 March 1965 (order dated 22 March, recorded as March 22, 1965 in the opinion) the Magistrate directed the lorry be made over to opposite party No. 1 on execution of a bond of Rs. 5,000 and similar surety, conditional on production on call. The petitioner then applied for making the lorry over to him; that application was rejected on 24 March 1965. The petitioner obtained this Rule challenging the Magistrate's order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate had the competence to make over a lorry seized by the police during investigation to the accused under section 523(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- Whether the Magistrate's order making over the seized lorry to opposite party No. 1 had the effect of stifling or prejudicing the police investigation.
- Whether the bond amount fixed by the Magistrate (Rs. 5,000 with a like amount as surety) was adequate and appropriate in the circumstances.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (represented by Mr. Dutt)
- The Magistrate lacked competence to make over property seized by police during investigation under section 165 CrPC by invoking section 523(1) CrPC.
- Section 523(1) should apply only where the seizure was made under section 51 or section 550 CrPC; because it specifically mentions section 51 but not section 550, it should not be read to cover seizures under section 165.
- The wording of section 523(1) ("alleged or suspected to have been stolen or found under circumstances which create suspicion of the commission of any offence") is the same as section 550 and therefore should be limited to those contexts; section 165(1) uses different language ("reasonable grounds for believing") and is therefore distinct.
- Under section 165(5) a police officer making a seizure during investigation must send a copy of the seizure list to a Magistrate; the Magistrate should not have the power to deal with such seized property under section 523(1).
- The impugned order stifled investigation because the lorry required further expert examination (including by manufacturer's representatives in India) to determine discrepancies in make/year, engine and chassis numbers.
- The bond fixed (Rs. 5,000) was insufficient.
Opposite Parties' Arguments (represented by Mr. Mukherjee)
- No detailed opposing legal argument is recorded in the opinion. Mr. Mukherjee stated that he had no objection if the amount of the bond was increased.
Magistrate's Position
- The learned Magistrate stated that he passed the order making over the lorry under section 523 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- The Magistrate had before him police reports and apparently acted after receiving a report that forensic examination (by Forensic experts) was complete.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Purshottam Das Banarsidas v. State, A.I.R. 1952 All. 470 | Supports the petitioner's contention that Magistrate should not deal with seizures under section 165 by invoking section 523. | The court noted this decision supports Mr. Dutt but expressly disagreed with its views in the present case. |
| Sk. Muktear v. The State, A.I.R. 1954 Cal. 350 | Held that section 523 is attracted to a seizure made by the police during investigation. | The court relied on and adopted this Court's earlier decision as supportive of the view that section 523 applies to seizures under section 165. |
| Md. Ali v. The State, A.I.R. 1957 Andhra Pradesh 146 | Part of a line of authority holding that section 523 covers seizures where there is no enquiry or trial (i.e., seizures during investigation). | Referred to as supportive authority for the proposition that section 523 applies to seizures under section 165 or generally before enquiry or trial. |
| Ganeshi Lall Ranchoddas v. Satya Narayan Tewari, A.I.R. 1958 M.P. 39 | Same trend: section 523 applies to police seizures where there is no enquiry or trial. | Referred to as further supportive authority; the court respectfully agreed with these decisions. |
| Tarachand v. The State, 52 Cr. L.J. 1476 | Another decision expressing the trend that section 523 applies to seizures made by police in investigation. | Referred to as part of supporting authorities for the court's conclusion. |
| Ali Kunju v. Ali Kunju, A.I.R. 1960 Kerala 343 | Held that section 523 covers cases where there is no enquiry or trial, including seizures under section 165. | Included in the list of authorities whose trend the court accepted in reaching its conclusion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in several linked steps, grounded in statutory interpretation and the factual sequence of events recorded in the Magistrate's file and police reports:
-
Statutory framework: The court reviewed provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure relevant to seized property:
- Section 516A — empowers a Magistrate to deal with seized property during any inquiry or trial;
- Section 517 — empowers the Magistrate to deal with seized property after an enquiry or trial is concluded;
- Section 523 — empowers the Magistrate to deal with seized property “in all other cases.”
- Interpretation of section 523(1): Although section 523(1) specifically mentions section 51 CrPC and does not specifically mention section 550 CrPC, the court rejected the contention that the omission should be read to exclude seizures made under section 165. The court reasoned that the wording of section 523(1) is intentionally wide so as to cover all conceivable cases of seizure by the police without reference to a Magistrate.
- Relation between section 165 and section 523: The court contrasted the purposes and language of section 165(1) and section 523(1). Section 165(1) gives police the power to search during investigation when they have "reasonable grounds for believing," while section 523(1) uses broader language ("suspicion of the commission of any offence") appropriate to a provision meant to address seizures in all other cases. The court held that these differences reflect distinct purposes and do not exclude seizure under section 165 from the operation of section 523.
- Reporting requirement: The court observed that both section 165(5) and section 523(1) require reporting of seizures to a Magistrate — there is no material difference in the requirement that a police officer report the seizure at once to a Magistrate.
- Precedential support: The court considered existing decisions and rejected the Allahabad High Court decision (Purshottam Das Banarsidas) that supported the petitioner's position, but accepted and followed the Calcutta High Court decision (Sk. Muktear) and other High Court authorities which held that section 523 applies to police seizures during investigation.
- Whether the Magistrate stifled investigation: The petitioner argued that the order stifled investigation because further examination (including by manufacturer's representatives) was needed. The court noted that the Magistrate refused earlier applications while police forensic examination was incomplete and only made the order after police reported forensic examination complete. The Investigating Officer did not inform the Magistrate before the order that examination by the manufacturer's representatives was necessary; that suggestion came after the order. For these reasons the court concluded that the order was not to stifle investigation.
- Discretion and public interest considerations: The court observed that the Blue Book (registration), insurance certificate and other relevant documents were in the name of opposite party No. 1 and emphasized the public interest in not keeping a roadworthy lorry idle given transport difficulties. On these facts the court found the Magistrate properly exercised discretion in making the lorry over to the person in whose name necessary documents stood.
- Bond adequacy and remedy: The court accepted the submission that the original bond amount was insufficient and increased it as a condition for discharging the Rule. The court also required that the order be carried out after one month, during which police must take necessary steps to have the lorry examined by the manufacturer's representatives in India if available.
Holding and Implications
The Rule is discharged subject to conditions.
Direct effect on the parties (as ordered by the court):
- The lorry shall be made over to opposite party No. 1 on his furnishing a bond of Rs. 20,000 with two sureties of Rs. 10,000 each.
- The order for making over the lorry is to be carried out after one month from the date of receipt of the record by the Magistrate.
- During that one-month period the police are to take necessary steps to have the lorry examined by the manufacturer's representatives in India, if they are available.
Legal holding of general importance stated in the opinion:
- The court held that section 523(1) CrPC is attracted to a seizure made by the police under section 165 CrPC; in other words, section 523(1) applies to police seizures made during investigation (i.e., cases where there is no enquiry or trial yet).
The opinion records that Niyogi, J. agreed with this judgment.
R.N Dutta, J.:— This Rule is directed against an order passed by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta making over a lorry seized by the police to the accused opposite party No. 1 on a bond.
1. The petitioner filed a petition of complaint before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta making certain allegations of cognizable offences against the opposite parties in respect of lorry No. WBA 2079. The Additional Chief Presidency-Magistrate without himself taking cognizance of the alleged offences directed the police to make investigation under sec. 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The police thereupon treated the said petition of complaint as the First Information report and started investigation into the alleged offences. During investigation the police arrested opposite party No. 1 and seized lorry No. WBK 1425 from his possession. The next day, the police produced opposite party No. I before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate who granted him bail. The police simultaneously informed the said Magistrate about the seizure of the lorry and prayed for custody of the same which was directed to be kept with the police. Subsequently on February 12, 1965 opposite party No. I filed an application before the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate for making over the lorry seized from him to him on bond. The Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate obtained a report from the police and rejected the application at that stage. Thereafter on February 22, 1965 opposite party No. I again applied for making over the lorry to him but this time again on perusal of a further report from the police the prayer was refused at that stage. Then again in March, 1965 opposite party no. 1 filed a further application for making over the lorry to him and this time after perusal of a further police report the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate passed an order on March 22, 1965 directing that the lorry should be made over to the opposite party No. 1 on his executing a bond of Rs. 5,000/- on condition to produce it on call and on furnishing a surety of the like amount. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an application for making over the lorry to him, but the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate rejected that application on March 24, 1965.
2. Mr. Dutt, who appears for the petitioner, first submits that the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate had no competence to pass the order making ever the lorry seized by the police during investigation, to opposite party no. 1. The learned Magistrate in his explanation has said that he passed the order making over the lorry under section 523 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Mr. Dutt contends that when the police makes a seizure in course of investigation under section. 165 of the Code the Magistrate has no competence to pass an order in respect of such seizure under sec. 523(1) of the Code. He argues that the Magistrate can act under section 523(1) of the Code only when the seizure is made either under section 51 or under section 550 of the Code. This argument cannot be sustained. Section 516A of the Code empowers the Magistrate to deal with seized property during any inquiry or trial. Section 517 of the Code empowers the Magistrate to deal with the seized property after an enquiry or trial is concluded. Section 523 of the Code empowers the Magistrate to deal with the seized property in all other cases. Section 523(1) specifically mentions section 51 of the Code, but does not specifically refer to section 550 of the Code. Mr. Dutt submits that the words used in section 523(1) viz. “alleged or suspected to have been stolen or found under circumstances which create suspicion of the commission of any offence” are the same as used in section 550 of the Code. But if by these words the Legislature wanted to refer to the seizure under section 550 of the Code only, the Legislature would have specifically referred to section 550 as it has specifically referred to section 51. Mr. Dutt then refers to the words used in section 165(1) viz., “reasonable grounds for believing” and submits that these words are not identical with the words used in section 523(1) which speak of ‘suspicion of the commission of any offence’. But the purpose of these two sections is different. Section 165(1) gives the police a power to make a search during investigation without reference to the Magistrate and it says that a police officer can make such a search only when he has ‘reasonable grounds for believing etc.’ The language of section 523(1) is as it should be in wider terms so as to cover all conceivable cases of seizure by the police without reference to the Magistrate. Mr. Dutt then argues that under section 165(5) a police officer making a seizure during investigation has only to send a copy of the seizure list to a Magistrate; but section 523(1) directs that the seizure shall forthwith be reported to a Magistrate. There is no material difference in the provisions contained in these two sections in this respect. What is required is that when a police officer makes a seizure without an order from a Magistrate he must at once report this to a Magistrate. From the terms of section 523(1) of the Code therefore it cannot be said that seizure by the police during investigation under section 165 of the Code is excluded from its operation.
3. Mr. Dutt submits that the Magistrate can only aid investigation but can have no power to stifle investigation but in the particular facts of this case the effect of the order passed by the learned Magistrate was to stifle investigation. The petitioner's allegation is that the number of the lorry, of the engine and of the chassis were changed. The lorry was, therefore, required to be examined by Forensic experts. It appears that the learned Magistrate refused to make over the lorry to opposite party no. 1 on February 12 and 22, 1965 because the police reported that the examination by the Forensic experts was not till then complete. The order for making over the lorry was passed only after the police reported that the examination by the Forensic experts was over. Mr. Dutt, however, contends that the lorry is required to be examined by the representatives in India of the Foreign company which manufactured the same. The petitioner's case is that his lorry was of 1959 make but the lorry seized was shown as of 1954 make. It is certainly desirable that the manufacturer representatives in India, if available, should examine the lorry to find out, if possible, the year of the make of the lorry. But we find that the Investigating Officer did not inform the Magistrate at any time before he passed the impugned order that such examination was necessary for his investigation. He informed the Court about it only after the learned Magistrate had passed the order. It cannot, therefore, be said that the order of the learned Magistrate was to stifle investigation. Even if it be assumed that the order was not proper at the particular stage of investigation, it can never be argued that because of the possibility of a Magistrate making an improper order the Magistrate should be deprived of the power to deal with property seized by the police during investigation. The police while making an investigation has power to arrest an accused and to make a seizure. But the Code provides for the production of the accused before the Magistrate within 24 hours and the Magistrate has been given powers to grant bail. Similarly, the Code provides that the police must report the seizure to the Magistrate and the Magistrate has been given power to deal with such seizure. If the Magistrate is deprived of this power the police will be left with arbitrary powers to deal with the seized property during investigation, may be to the detriment of the interest of the person entitled to the possession thereof. Mr. Dutt refers to the Allahabad High Court decision in (1) Purshottam Das Banarsidas v. State, reported in A.I.R 1952 All. 470. This decision supports the contention of Mr. Dutt. But with respect and for the aforesaid reasons we disagree with the views expressed therein. Our view gets support in this Court's decision in (2) Sk. Muktear v. The State, reported in A.I.R 1954 Cal. 350, where Chunder, J. held that section 523 of the Code is attracted to a seizure made by the police during investigation. The trend of the recent decisions of the other High Courts also is that Section 523 of the Code is a general provision applicable to all cases before there is any ‘enquiry or trial’. Reference may be made to the decision in (3) Md. Ali v. The State, reported in A.I.R 1957 Andhra Pradesh 146, (4) Ganeshi Lall Ranchoddas v. Satya Narayan Tewari, reported in A.I.R 1958 M.P 39, (5) Tarachand v. The State, reported in 52 Cr. L.J 1476 and (6) Ali Kunju v. Ali Kunju, reported in A.I.R 1960 Kerala 343. It was held in those cases that section 523 of the Code is attracted to the seizure by the police under section 165 of the Code or that section 523 of the Code covers all cases where there is no enquiry or trial. We respectfully agree with these decisions and we hold that section 523(1) is attracted to a seizure made by the police under section 165 of the Code and hence, to the facts of this case.
4. Since the police did not make the seizure under section 550 of the Code it is not necessary for us in this case to consider the argument of Mr. Dutt about the effect of section 550 of the Code not being made applicable to the Calcutta Police.
5. Lastly, Mr. Dutt argues that the order is not a proper order on the facts of this case. It appears that the Blue Book, the Insurance Certificate and other relevant documents stand in the name of opposite party No. I. It is common knowledge that we have serious transport problems in our country. It is not desirable that a lorry in a fit condition to be on the road should be kept idle. We, therefore, think that the learned Magistrate properly exercised his discretion when he directed the lorry to be made over to the person in whose name all the necessary documents stand.
6. Mr. Dutt finally submits that the bond of Rs. 5,000/- is too insufficient. Mr. Mukherjee, appearing for the opposite parties, has no objection if the amount of the bond is increased.
7. In the result, the Rule is discharged subject to this that the lorry would be made over to the opposite party no. 1 on his furnishing a bond of Rs. 20,000/- with two sureties of Rs. 10,000/- each and this order will be carried out after one month from the date of the receipt of this record by the Magistrate during which period the police will take necessary steps to have the lorry examined by the manufacturer's representatives in India, if available.
Niyogi, J.:— I agree.
S.K.B
Alert