Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Leonard Biermans Wor... v. Second Industrial Tr...

Calcutta High Court
Jul 6, 1961
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

An industrial dispute between Messrs. Leonard Biermans (the company) and their workers was referred to the Second Industrial Tribunal by an order dated 5 August 1959. The dispute concerned the workers' demand for introduction of a scheme for payment of gratuity. The Tribunal concluded that the company had been running at a loss for several years and was not in a position to bear the burden of gratuity; accordingly the workers' claim was rejected and an award was published under section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 by notification dated 23 July 1960.

The Workers' Union challenged the propriety of that award by filing this Rule. The principal contention advanced by the Workers' Union was that the Balance Sheets on which the Tribunal relied were inadmissible in evidence or, alternatively, were not true statements of the company's economic position and should not have been relied upon because the company had failed to produce the underlying books of account.

Procedurally, the Union applied on 2 December 1959 for production of numerous books and registers (ledgers, cash books, journals, sale registers, production registers, stock books, import registers, income-tax clearance certificates for years 1953–1959). The Tribunal ordered on 12 December 1959 that the company produce audited balance-sheets at hearing and allow inspection of any books called for by the Union's lawyer in the company's office. The Union later complained inspection was obstructed; the company said it objected only to inspection by two retrenched former employees who accompanied the Union's lawyer and asserted the lawyer left without inspecting. On 27 February 1960 the Tribunal recorded that the Union would not press production on condition that the company produced balance-sheets for 1954–58; the company produced audited balance-sheets for 1953–59 which the Union's lawyer inspected. The Union later renewed a request to produce further registers (May 1960), but at the hearing that application was not pressed. The Tribunal ultimately relied on the balance-sheets, profit and loss accounts and other documentary and oral evidence to find the company economically incompetent to introduce a gratuity scheme.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the audited Balance Sheets (and Profit & Loss Accounts) exhibited before the Industrial Tribunal were admissible in evidence and could be relied upon by the Tribunal.
  2. Whether the Tribunal could rely solely on Balance Sheets and Profit & Loss Accounts to determine the company's financial position in the absence of production of the underlying books of account and registers.
  3. Whether the Tribunal's finding that the company was financially incapable of introducing a gratuity scheme (and thus the rejection of the workers' claim) was proper on the materials before it.

Arguments of the Parties

Workers' Union's Arguments

  • The Balance Sheets filed with the company's written statement were inadmissible in evidence.
  • Alternatively, the Balance Sheets did not contain true statements about the company's economic position and should not have been relied upon because the company failed to produce the underlying books of account (ledgers, cash books, journals, sale registers, production registers, stock books, import registers, income-tax clearance certificates for 1953–1959).
  • The Union alleged obstruction of inspection (an incident on 5 January 1960 when two retrenched ex-employees accompanied the Union's lawyer and the manager objected to their presence).
  • At a later stage the Union accepted production of audited balance-sheets alone (on condition they be produced), but then renewed its application for production of further books and registers, alleging possible manipulation and seeking broader inspection.

Company's Arguments

  • The company objected to production of books of account to the Tribunal, asserting they were unnecessary; it was willing to produce audited balance-sheets and allow inspection by the Union's lawyer in the office on convenient dates.
  • The company contended it refused inspection only to two outsiders (retrenched ex-employees) who accompanied the Union's lawyer; it maintained it was prepared to show the books to the Union's advocate but alleged that the advocate left without inspecting.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harchura Tea Estate v. Labour Appellate Tribunal (A.I.R. 1959 Cal. 650) Authority expressing that an Industrial Tribunal may accept evidence not strictly admissible under the Indian Evidence Act (reflecting quasi-judicial character). Relied upon to support the view that an Industrial Tribunal is entitled to proceed on oral or documentary evidence that might not be strictly admissible under the Indian Evidence Act.
Indian Hume Pipe Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen (A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 1081) Balance Sheet accepted as good evidence to prove that certain amounts out of reserve were actually used as working capital (in that case). Noted as an instance where balance-sheet evidence was accepted, but the court also observed later authorities limited the breadth of that proposition.
Khandesh Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 571) Clarification that Indian Hume Pipe Co.'s observations were not to be read as establishing that a balance-sheet alone is sufficient to prove facts about utilisation of reserves as working capital. Used to show the Supreme Court's caution that balance-sheets alone may not suffice to prove certain factual claims about finances without supporting evidence.
Trichinopoli Mills Ltd. v. National Cotton Textile Mills Workers' Union (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 1003) Balance-sheets do not, by themselves, prove utilisation of reserves as working capital; employer must prove such important facts by evidence (affidavit or otherwise) and allow opportunity for cross-examination. Applied to emphasize that reliance on balance-sheets to prove utilisation of reserves requires supporting evidence and an opportunity to contest that evidence.
Petlad Turkey Red Dye Works Co. Ltd. v. Dyes and Chemical Workers' Union (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 1006) Reiteration that statements in balance-sheets cannot be presumed correct; burden lies on the party asserting correctness to prove by relevant and acceptable evidence. Invoked to support the principle that balance-sheet figures are not to be automatically presumed correct and must be proven where their correctness is contested.
Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen (1959 (II) S.C.A. 280) For bonus calculation, Supreme Court accepted gross profit at foot of Profit & Loss Account without submitting it to close scrutiny, but cautioned that mala fide entries and glaring extraneous items must be excluded. Referred to indicate that a Profit & Loss Account may be accepted in certain contexts without exhaustive scrutiny, subject to exclusion of mala fide or extraneous items.
Express Newspaper (Private) Ltd. v. The Union of India (A.I.R. 1958 S.C. 578); citing Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (1955 I.A.C. 155) Support for the proposition that provident fund alone may be insufficient and that where finances permit, two retirement benefits (provident fund and gratuity) should be allowed. Invoked in the discussion of the principle that gratuity is a retirement benefit and the general trend in authorities favouring gratuity in addition to provident fund where finances permit.
Bharatkhand Textile Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. Textile Labour Association (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 833) Supreme Court view that it is not necessary for a company to possess a large surplus to cover the entire theoretical liability for gratuity at once; schemes are long-term and funds may be built up year by year. Applied to explain that inability to set aside the whole theoretical liability immediately does not by itself defeat a gratuity claim—what matters is the capacity to build up a fund over time; contrasted with the present case where the company sustained consistent losses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a structured way:

  1. Statutory and doctrinal starting point: The opinion reviewed the scope of the Indian Evidence Act and the Industrial Disputes Act. It observed that sections of the Industrial Disputes Act (section 11(3) and section 11(8)) confer on industrial tribunals certain powers akin to civil courts for particular purposes and deem certain inquiries to be judicial for limited penal and procedural purposes. However, tribunals are not fully civil courts for all purposes and proceedings before them are quasi-judicial rather than strictly judicial.
  2. Consequence for evidence: Because proceedings before an Industrial Tribunal are quasi-judicial, section 1 of the Indian Evidence Act does not make the Act applicable of its own force to such proceedings. An Industrial Tribunal is therefore entitled to act upon oral or documentary evidence that might not be strictly admissible under the Indian Evidence Act.
  3. Precedent synthesis on balance-sheets and profit & loss accounts: The court analysed a series of Supreme Court decisions. It noted (a) some decisions accepted balance-sheet figures in particular factual contexts; (b) subsequent decisions clarified that a balance-sheet by itself is not conclusive proof of certain detailed factual claims (for example, utilisation of reserves as working capital); and (c) the employer asserting such utilisation must prove it by relevant acceptable evidence and permit opportunity for challenge (cross-examination). It also noted a decision accepting gross profit in P&L for bonus calculations while warning against mala fide or extraneous entries.
  4. Application to the facts: The court rejected the Workers' primary contention that the balance-sheets were inadmissible. On the alternative contention (that balance-sheets should not have been solely relied upon without supporting books), the court recognized that balance-sheets and profit & loss accounts are summaries prepared from underlying books and are admissible and may be relied upon if correctly prepared.
  5. Burden and circumstances justifying further proof: The court accepted that where materials or circumstances cast doubt on authenticity, the company would be liable to adduce further evidence to prove correctness of its accounts. In this case, the Union had initially demanded production of books and later waived that demand on condition the company produce audited balance-sheets; those were produced (1953–59) and inspected by the Union's lawyer. The court characterized the Union's later request for further production as "in the nature of roving discovery" aimed at fishing for materials and said that was not permissible.
  6. Conclusion from evidence: Given that audited balance-sheets and profit & loss accounts were produced and inspected and that there was other documentary and oral evidence which the Tribunal considered, the court concluded that the Tribunal was entitled to proceed on the basis of those documents in determining the company's financial position. On the merits of the gratuity claim, the Tribunal found, and the court accepted, that the company was consistently sustaining losses for several years and could not presently build up a gratuity fund; consequently it was justified in rejecting the claim for introduction of a gratuity scheme.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Rule challenging the Tribunal's award is discharged.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The Tribunal's award rejecting the workers' claim for a gratuity scheme (on the findings that the company was running at a loss and could not bear the burden of gratuity) is upheld by this court.
  • The court held that audited Balance Sheets and Profit & Loss Accounts are admissible and may be relied upon by an Industrial Tribunal; however, where there are materials to doubt their authenticity or correctness, the party asserting them must adduce further supporting evidence. In the present case the Tribunal was entitled to rely on the documents produced (and other evidence) because the Union had inspected the balance-sheets and had not sustained its challenge to require production of the underlying books.
  • The court allowed the Workers' Union the future opportunity to renew their claim for gratuity if the company's financial position improves: "Nothing contained in this judgment shall disentitle the workers from renewing their claim for gratuity when the company sees better days."
  • There is no order as to costs in this Rule.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new broad precedent beyond applying and synthesising existing authorities; it applies established principles about admissibility and the weight to be given to balance-sheets and profit & loss accounts in the quasi-judicial context of an Industrial Tribunal.
Show all summary ...

2. An industrial dispute between Messrs. Leonard Biermans (hereinafter referred to as the company) and their workers was referred to the Second Industrial Tribunal, by an order dated August 5, 1959. The scope of the dispute was the demand by the workers for introduction of a scheme for payment of gratuity. The Tribunal came to the conclusion that the company was running at a loss for the last few years and was not in a position to bear the burden of gratuity. In that view of the matter the workers' claim for gratuity was rejected and the Tribunal passed an award accordingly. The award was published under section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, under a notification, dated July 23, 1960.

3. The propriety of the award is being disputed in this Rule at the instance of the Workers' Union.

4. A single point was argued for my consideration in this Rule.

5. It was contended that the Balance Sheets of the company, on the basis of which the Tribunal came to the conclusion about the financial incompetency of the company, were inadmissible in evidence, alternatively that they did not contain true statements about the economic position of the company and should not have been relied upon, particularly after the company had failed to produce their books of account on the basis whereof the Balance Sheets were purported to have been prepared.

6. It is necessary for me at this stage to refer to certain orders made by the Tribunal relating to production and inspection of documents. On December 2, 1959 the Workers' Union filed an application for a direction on the company to produce the following looks and documents, on the plea that the Balance Sheets filed along with the Written Statement did not show the correct financial position of the company, namely, (1) Ledgers, (2) Cash Books, (3) Journals, (4) Sale Registers, (5) Production Registers, (6) Stock Books, (7) Import Registers (8) Income-tax Clearance Certificates, all of the years 1953 to 1959.

7. On the aforesaid application the Tribunal passed the following order, on December 12, 1959:—

“The company objects to the production of books of account to the Tribunal. I do not think that the books are necessary. The company should produce the audited balance sheets at the time of hearing and allow inspection of any books of account called for by the Union's Lawyer in their office on such dates as may be convenient to both the parties.”

8. Thereafter, the Workers' Union filed an application before the Tribunal complaining that the company did not make inspection of the documents possible by their lawyers. Paragraph 7 of the application is set out below:—

“That on 5-1-60 Sri Chatterjee went to inspect the books along with two other members of the Union but the Manager objected to the very presence of those members of the Union on the floor of his Office on the alleged ground that they were retrenched persons and as such inspection was not possible because the Advocate could not get any assistance from the Union members.”

9. On the aforesaid allegation the Workers' Union prayed for production of the books and documents, called for by the Workers' Union, before the Tribunal.

10. The company filed an objection to the prayer made by the Workers' Union, the material portion of which is set out below:—

“That with regard to the allegations contained in paragraph 7 of the Union's application it is submitted that on 5-1-60 Mr. T.P Chatterjee, Advocate, came for the inspection of books along with two ex-employees of your petitioner, who were retrenched in the month of September, 1959 and as such your petitioners objected in showing the Company's Books to the two outsiders. Your petitioner was quite willing to show the Books to the learned Advocate for the Union but the learned Advocate for the Union left without making any inspection.”

11. On February 27, 1960, the Tribunal recorded the following order on the application for production:—

“Heard the lawyers. The application by the Union for production of documents is not pressed on condition that the company produces Balance Sheets for the years 1954–58. The Company's lawyer undertakes to produce the audited Balance Sheets within a week. They should be produced accordingly within 7-3-60. The application is rejected as not pressed.”

12. From the order dated March 7, 1960, it appears that the company produced the audited Balance Sheets for the years 1953 to 1959 and the lawyer for the Workers' Union was allowed opportunity to inspect the Balance Sheets as desired by him.

13. It appears, however, from the order dated May 31, 1960, that the Workers' Union, apprehending manipulation in the Balance Sheets and Profit and Loss Accounts, renewed the prayer for production of certain books and documents, namely, the Sale Registers, Production Registers, Stock Registers, Purchase Registers, Flint Paper Import Register, Order and Supply Registers, Cash Books and Bank Books all of the years 1954 to 1959. Thereupon the Tribunal passed the following order:—

“The Union's lawyer Sri T.P Chatterjee has filed a petition in duplicate in the matter of production of some more documents by the company.

Keep the petition in the record and make over one copy to the company. The company is to take note of it.

The case is fixed for hearing on 23.6.60”

14. At the hearing of the case, the application for production of document does not appear to have been pressed. The Tribunal, however, rejected the plea of the Workers' Union not to accept the Balance Sheet figures as correct until they were supported by relevant books and registers, with the following observations:—

“It has been argued that the figures in the balance-sheets should not be accepted as correct without proof from relevant books and registers. I should mention in this connection that the Union made an application on 2nd December, 1959 praying for a direction on the Company to produce certain registers and account books and allow inspection thereof. The Company objected to such production and the matter was heard on 18th December, 1959 when the Company was directed to produce the audited balance-sheets and to allow inspection of the account books mentioned in the application by the Union's lawyer in the company's office. The Union complained on 6th January, 1960 that the company had not allowed such inspection. It appears, however, from the petitions and correspondence on record that the company did not actually refuse inspection either by the General Secretary or by the lawyer of the Union but objected to inspection by two representatives of the Union who accompanied the lawyer. In terms of the order passed on 18th December, 1959 the Company was quite justified in refusing inspection by persons other than the Union's lawyer. The persons objected to were retrenched employees of the Company. The inspection could have been made by the lawyer and the Secretary of the Union but this was not done. This matter was heard on 27th February, 1960 when the Tribunal was informed that the application for production of the account books would not be pressed by the Union on condition that the Company produced its balance-sheets for the years 1954–58. The Company then produced its audited balance sheets for 1953–59 which were inspected by the Union's lawyer. Finally the Union filed a petition on 30th May, 1960 stating that it challenged the correctness of the figures in the balance-sheets and that the company should support the figures by production of its account books and registers. It has been argued that the balance-sheets should be wholly rejected because the company has not adduced any evidence in support of the same from its books and registers.

“Reference has been made in this connection to two recent decisions of the Supreme Court in the cases of (Khandesh Spinning and Weaving Mills Company, Ltd., (3) and Petland Turkey Red Dye Works Company, Ltd., (5) reported in 1960, I L.L.J pages 541 and 548 respectively. In these cases, however, the formula laid down by the Full Bench of the Labour Appellate Tribunal for the calculation of net surplus for award of bonus was being considered and the question which arose for decision was whether the figures in a balance-sheet could be taken as proof of a claim of what portion of the reserve had actually been used as working capital without any evidence being given in support of such a claim apart from the balance-sheet. It was held that a mere statement in a balance-sheet was not sufficient proof on the point and that the burden was on the party who asserted such statement to be correct to prove the same by relevant and acceptable evidence. The observations in these two cases were thus made in connection with the particular question which arose for decision therein and it cannot be contended that the result of these decisions is that all the statements and figures in an audited balance-sheet should be suspected and held to be incorrect until they are supported and corroborated by other evidence.”

15. The arguments in the alternative forms advanced on behalf of the petitioner Workers' Union deserve careful consideration.

16. Under section 1 of the Indian Evidence Act, the Act of its own force applies to all judicial proceedings in or before any court. The expression ‘Court’ is defined in section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act as follows:—

“Court includes all Judges and Magistrates, and all persons, except arbitrators, legally authorised to take evidence.”

17. Under section 11(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act:—

“Every Board, Court, Labour Court, Tribunal and National Tribunal shall have the same powers as are vested in a Civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (V of 1908), when trying a suit, in respect of the following matters, namely:—

(a) enforcing the attendance of any person and examining him on oath;

(b) compelling the production of documents and material objects;

(c) issuing commissions for the examination of witnesses;

(d) in respect of such other matters as may be prescribed; and every enquiry or investigation by a Board, Court, Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, shall be deemed to be a judicial proceeding within the meaning of sections 193 and 228 of the Indian Penal Code (XLV of 1860).”

18. Section 11(8) of the Industrial Disputes Act further provides:—

“Every Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal shall be deemed to be a Civil Court for the purposes of sections 480 and 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (Act V of 1898).”

19. On an analysis of all the aforementioned sections, it will appear that industrial Tribunals are authorised to take evidence and may be treated as Courts within the meaning of section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act. But proceedings before such Tribunals are to be deemed as judicial proceedings only within the meaning of sections 193 and 228 of the Indian Penal Code and such Tribunals are to be deemed as Civil Courts only for the purposes of sections 480 and 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. For all other purposes the Tribunals shall not be deemed to be Civil Courts and the proceedings before them shall not be treated as judicial proceedings.

20. It is often said that the proceeding before an Industrial Tribunal is a quasi-judicial proceeding. “The use of the term ‘quasi’ for which the best synonym is ‘not exactly’ is *** a confession of vagueness, an announcement that precise definition is impossible. Yet, if it cannot be defined with precision, it can at least be explained in concrete terms. The term describes the application by administrative officers of a broadly stated legislative policy to concrete cases by a procedure patterned after that used by a Court of law.” (See ‘American Administrative Law’ by Bernard Schwartz, Ed. 1950, pp. 57–58). The Industrial Disputes Act was enacted, as the preamble shows, to make provisions for investigation and settlement of industrial disputes and for other purposes appearing in the said Act. The object of the Act is, inter alia, to enforce industrial peace through the medium amongst others of Tribunals under a procedure patterned after the procedure in courts of law, although not under the same procedure. A proceeding before an Industrial Tribunal, although deemed to be a judicial proceeding for certain purposes, is not strictly a judicial proceeding in the sense that it calls for a decision on a question of legal right in dispute between the parties involving either a finding of fact or application of a fixed rule or principle of law or involving both. Since the proceeding before an Industrial Tribunal is not wholly a judicial proceeding but merely a quasi-judicial proceeding, section 1 of the Indian Evidence Act does not make the Act applicable of its own force to such a proceeding. An Industrial Tribunal therefore, is entitled to proceed on the basis of oral or documentary evidence, which may not be strictly admissible in evidence under the Indian Evidence Act. This is also the opinion expressed by P.B Mukharji, J. in Harchura Tea Estate v. Labour Appellate Tribunal (1) (A.I.R 1959 Cal. 650).

21. In the view that I take I overrule the first branch of the contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner Workers' Union that the Balance Sheets exhibited before the Tribunal were not admissible in evidence.

22. I now turn to the alternative branch of the contention that the Balance Sheets should not have been solely relied upon, in the absence of supporting books of accounts to find out the economic position of the company.

23. What were exhibited before the Tribunal were not merely the Balance Sheets but also the Profit and Loss Accounts of the company.

24. A Balance Sheet is a statement prepared from records kept on the basis of double entry showing, as at a given date, the sources from which an enterprise derived its funds (for example, from shareholders, creditors, partners or proprietors) and the various ways in which those funds were invested or applied (for example, in fixed assets, current assets, investments, loans and advances and other claims). It is a statement in a summarised form of the balances of the ledger accounts remaining after all revenue and expense accounts have been closed by transfer to revenue or profit and loss account.

25. A Profit and Loss Account is an account designed to show the amount of net profit earned or net loss incurred during the financial period covered by the account, also the various headings under which the profits had been earned and expenses incurred. The balance of the Profit and Loss Account, in case of profit, is included in the liabilities column of the Balance Sheet and, in case of loss, in its asset column.

26. The evidentiary value of Balance Sheets came up for consideration before the Supreme Court several times in recent years. To begin with there is the case of Indian Hume Pipe Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen (2) (A.I.R 1959 S.C 1081) in which the Balance Sheet of the company was accepted as good evidence to prove that certain amounts, out of reserve, were actually used as working capital. It was however, pointed out by the Supreme Court, in the case of Khandesh Spinning and Weaving Mills case (3) (A.I.R 1960 S.C 571) that the observations in Indian Hume Pipe Co.'s case (Supra) was not intended to lay down the law that a Balance Sheet by itself was good evidence to prove any fact as regards the actual utilisation of reserves as working capital. Then again, in the case of Management of Trichinopoli Mills Ltd. v. National Cotton Textile Mills Workers' Union (4) (A.I.R 1960 S.C 1003) the Supreme Court observed that the Balance Sheet itself did not prove the fact of utilisation of any reserve as working capital and that the law required that such an important fact as the utilisation of a portion of the reserve as working capital was to be proved by the employer by evidence given on affidavit or otherwise and after giving an opportunity to workmen to contest the correctness of such evidence by cross-examination. The same view was reiterated by the Supreme Court in the case of Petlad Turkey Red Dye Works Co. Ltd. v. Dyes and Chemical Workers' Union (5) (A.I.R 1960 S.C 1006).

27. Before I part with this point, I need notice another decision by the Supreme Court reported in (6) 1959 (II) S.C.A 280 (Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen) in which the Supreme Court, in laying down a formula for calculation of Bonus, held in favour of accepting the gross profit appearing at the foot of the Profit and Loss Account of a company without submitting such statement to close scrutiny. Nevertheless the Supreme Court held out a word of caution, namely, mala fide entries in the debit side and also glaring items of extraneous credit and debit must be excluded therefrom.

28. From the aforesaid decisions it appears that Balance Sheets and Profit and Loss Accounts, both summaries prepared from the account books by the company, are admissible in evidence before the Tribunal and may be relied upon if correctly prepared.

29. But as the Supreme Court observed in Petlad Turkey Bed Dye Works Company's case (5) (supra):—

“It has to be borne in mind that in many cases the Directors of the Companies may feel inclined to make incorrect statements in these Balance Sheets for ulterior purposes. While that is no reason to suspect every statement made in the Balance Sheets, the position is clear that we cannot presume the statements made therein to be always correct. The burden is on the party who asserts a statement to be correct to prove the same by relevant and acceptable evidence.”

30. The question then is, was the company liable, in the instant case, to adduce further evidence in proof of its Balance Sheets and Profit and Loss Accounts and to prove that the aforesaid two sets of documents presented the correct financial position of the company? The answer to the Question would be in the affirmative, if there be materials or circumstances to doubt the authenticity of the two sets of documents. At one stage of the proceeding, it is true, the Workers' Union did express a doubt as to the correctness of the Balance Sheets and called for production of books and documents on which the same were based. The Workers' Union, however, later on gave up that stand and elected to be satisfied if only the company produced its audited Balance Sheets. That the company did. The Workers' Union also had inspection of the said documents. The last call by the Workers' Union to compel the company to produce their books of account and other documents was in the nature of roving discovery in which they aspired to fish, out of the account books, some materials to show that the Balance Sheets and the Profit and Loss Accounts had not been correctly prepared. This they were not entitled to do and the Tribunal below acted rightly in not encouraging them so to do.

31. In the particular facts and circumstances of this case, I hold that the Tribunal below was not wrong in proceeding on the basis of the Balance Sheets and Profit and Loss Accounts, exhibited in the case, in finding out the financial position of the company. Then again, there were other documentary and oral evidence which the Tribunal considered in arriving at the conclusion as to the economic incompetency of the company to introduce a scheme for payment of gratuity.

32. The fundamental principle in allowing gratuity is that it is a retirement benefit or a benefit after long service, a provision for of age and the trend of the recent authorities is in favour of allowing the employees the double benefit of provident fund and gratuity. Bhagawati, J., in Express Newspaper (Private) Ltd. v. The Union of India (7) (A.I.R 1958 S.C 578) quoted with approval the following observation of the Labour Appellate Tribunal in the case of Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (8) (1955 I.A.C 155):—

“We are, therefore, of the considered opinion that Provident Fund provides a certain measure of relief only and a portion of that consists of the employee's wages that he or his family would ultimately receive and that his provision in the present day condition is wholly insufficient and two retirement benefits when the finances of the concern permit ought to be allowed.”

33. The Supreme Court had again to consider the reasonableness of introduction of gratuity scheme in the case of Bharatkhand Textile Manufacturing Co. Ltd., Ahmedabad v. Textile Labour Association (9) (A.I.R 1960 S.C 833) in which Gajendragadkar, J. observed:—

“The scheme has been further attacked on the ground that before framing it the industrial court has not considered the extent of the liabilities already imposed on the industry. It has been strenuously argued before us that in assessing the extent of the liabilities the actual liabilities accrued as the result of the scheme has not been taken into account and the serious strain imposed on the industry by the imposition of excise duty has also been overlooked; on the other hand, undue importance has been attached to bonus shares and no account has been taken of the industry's obligation to contribute to the State Insurance Scheme. We are not impressed by these arguments. The argument about the actual liability accrued is really theoretical and cannot have much practical significance. If it is Suggested that in framing a scheme of gratuity the capacity to pay should be determined only if the employer can set apart a fund to cover the whole of the liability theoretically accrued, then gratuity schemes can be very rarely framed. Such schemes are long-term schemes and a fund to cover the total liability in that behalf must inevitably be built up in course of time year by year.”

34. From the latest pronouncement of the Supreme Court it will appear that it is not necessary for a company to possess a large surplus in hand so as to cover at a time the whole of the liability for gratuity theoretically incurred. Therefore, if the financial position of an employer is such that it is possible for such employer to build up a gratuity fund by setting apart some money year by year then a claim for introduction of a gratunity scheme should be allowed.

35. In the instant case, however, the Tribunal was satisfied that the company was consistently sustaining losses for the last several years and was not in a position to bear the burden of gratuity. Faced with losses year by year, it is not possible for the company even to start building up a gratuity fund at present. That being so, the Tribunal was right in rejecting the claim for gratuity.

36. In the view that I take, I discharge the Rule.

37. Nothing contained in this judgment shall disentitle the workers from renewing their claim for gratuity when the company sees better days.

38. There will be no order as to costs in this Rule.

S.K.B