Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sm. Kshiroda And Another v. Debendra Nath Kar .

Calcutta High Court
Aug 5, 1955
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 18 April 1946 the respondent-plaintiff (Debendra) instituted a suit seeking a declaration that he was the sole shebait of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Paban alias Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur and for confirmation of his possession in that capacity; alternatively he sought recovery of possession and a declaration that a Criminal Court order under Section 145 CrPC in favour of defendant No.1 was illegal and not binding on him. There were consequential prayers for injunction and mesne profits.

The trial Court decreed the suit. On appeal the learned Subordinate Judge affirmed the decree but upon grounds different from the trial Court: the trial Court had relied on a purported Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7), while the Subordinate Judge upheld the decree on the ground of res judicata and rejected Ex. 7 as inadmissible. The contesting defendants Nos. 1 and 2 (including Kshiroda as defendant No.1) have taken the matter in second appeal to the present Court.

There is no dispute in the record that the suit property belongs to the deity; the principal controversy concerns whether Debendra is the sole shebait or whether defendant No.1 Kshiroda is a co-shebait.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff (Debendra) is the sole shebait of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur or whether defendant No.1 (Kshiroda) is a co-shebait.
  2. Whether the previous appellate decision in Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937 operates as res judicata on the question of shebaitship between the parties (i.e., whether the earlier decision in favour of Haradhan, Debendra's predecessor, precludes re-litigation by Kshiroda).
  3. Whether the purported Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7) is admissible in evidence and, if admissible, whether it establishes the plaintiff's exclusive title to the shebaitship.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff (Debendra / Haradhan's position in earlier suit)

  • Claimed to be the sole shebait of the deity and sought declaration and confirmation of possession in that capacity.
  • Relied upon a purported Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7), alleged to have been left by the common ancestor Gopi Charan (alias Gopi Mohan), and relied on the prior appellate decision (Ex. 1(b)) as establishing his exclusive title.

Defendant No.1 (Kshiroda)

  • Asserted a claim to be a co-shebait with Haradhan (and later with Debendra) and contested Haradhan's/existing plaintiff's claim to exclusive shebaitship.
  • In the earlier rent suit she appeared as a pro forma defendant but actively contested the claim and successfully urged the trial Court to make her a co-plaintiff; she later unsuccessfully challenged the appellate decision that found Haradhan to be sole shebait.

Tenant (principal defendant in the earlier rent suit)

  • Contended that the rent suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) was not maintainable because Kshiroda was a co-shebait and should have been joined as a plaintiff to represent the deity, and that there was no plea of her unwillingness to do so in the plaint.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Deokee Nundun Roy v. Kalee Pershad, 8 Suth WR 366 (A) Cited for the proposition that description as a pro forma defendant or the fact that an earlier suit was a rent suit is immaterial to the question of res judicata. Relied on as authority supporting the court's conclusion that the earlier appellate decision is res judicata on the shebaitship issue despite Kshiroda having been described as a pro forma defendant.
Maung Sein Done v. Ma Pan Nyun, 59 Ind App 247 : AIR 1932 PC 161 (B) Authority cited among cases supporting the res judicata proposition in similar circumstances. Included in the group of authorities the court cited to support applying res judicata to the present dispute over shebaitship.
Monjur Mondal v. Ahammad Mondal, 56 Cal WN 506 : AIR 1953 Cal 155 (C) Another case cited in support of the proposition that prior final decision binds parties on the same issue even if earlier parties were characterized as pro forma. Used as supporting authority for the court's application of res judicata.
Gobind Chunder v. Taruck Chunder, ILR 3 Cal 145 (FB) (E) Cited as a direct supporting authority on the point that earlier decisions operate as res judicata between parties or their representatives. Relied upon as part of the cluster of cases supporting the res judicata conclusion.
Toponidhee Dhirj v. Sreeputty Sahanee, ILR 5 Cal 832 (P) (F) Referred to as a direct supporting authority on the res judicata proposition. Counted among the authorities the court regarded as directly supportive of applying res judicata here.
Panchu Mandal v. Chandra Kant Saha, 14 Cal LJ 220 (G) Cited as authority relevant to the court's res judicata analysis. Used to bolster the conclusion that the earlier appellate judgment precludes relitigation between these parties on shebaitship.
Midnapore Zemindari Co. Ltd. v. Jogendra Kumar, 33 Cal LJ 186 : AIR 1921 Cal 750 (H) Authority cited on points relevant to res judicata and representative succession in title disputes. Adduced in support of the court's finding that Debendra, as successor, is bound by and benefits from the earlier appellate decision.
Harekrishna Datta… v. Gourhari Setna Poddar…., ILR 59 Cal 1250 : AIR 1932 Cal 894 (I) Cited among precedents supporting the court's view on identity of parties/issues and res judicata. Referenced as part of the body of case law supporting the res judicata conclusion.
Radha Madhub Holder v. Monohur Mukerji, 15 Ind App 97 (PC) (J) Cited as an authority relevant to the court's res judicata proposition. Included as supportive precedent confirming the court's approach to res judicata here.
Jitendra Nath v. Biswanath Bagchi, AIR 1952 Cal 201 (K) Specifically cited for Sen, J.'s observations affirming the proposition that an earlier appellate decision can operate as res judicata between parties or their representatives; the court referred to a "text illustration" used by Sen, J. The court expressly relied on and adopted Sen, J.'s observations in Jitendra Nath as directly supporting the res judicata conclusion in this case.
Midnapore Zemindary Co. Ltd. v. Kumar Nares Narain Roy, 33 Cal LJ 317 : AIR 1921 Cal 368 (L) Listed as relevant authority that to some extent supports the court's conclusion. Referenced as additionally relevant in backing the court's application of res judicata.
Krishna Chandra Gajapati v. Challa Ramanna, 36 Cal WN 365 : AIR 1932 PC 50 (M) Cited as a relevant case supporting the conclusion reached by the court on res judicata. Counted among the decisions that support the court's view that the earlier appellate decision is conclusive between the present parties on the shebaitship issue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed two principal strands of reasoning from the courts below: (1) the trial Court's reliance on the purported Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7) to establish exclusive shebaitship, and (2) the learned Subordinate Judge's reliance on the doctrine of res judicata arising from an earlier appellate decision (Ex. 1(b)) in Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937.

On the Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7) the present Court agreed with the Subordinate Judge's view that Ex. 7 was inadmissible in evidence and that the Subordinate Judge's construction and treatment of Ex. 7 were correct. The Court stated it had "little to add" to the Subordinate Judge's judgment on that point.

The principal analytical focus was on whether the earlier appellate decision operated as res judicata on the question of title to the shebaitship as between Debendra (the present plaintiff and successor of Haradhan) and Kshiroda (the present defendant). The Court examined the earlier rent suit's facts: Haradhan (Debendra's predecessor) sued as sole shebait; Kshiroda appeared as a pro forma defendant but actively contested claim and was ultimately treated by the trial Court as co-plaintiff; on appeal the lower appellate Court considered whether the suit was maintainable and whether Haradhan or Kshiroda was the shebait; that appellate Court answered the question in Haradhan's favour, found Kshiroda had no share, removed her from the plaint as co-plaintiff and allowed Haradhan's cross-objection in full.

The Court observed that the earlier appellate decision contained all necessary elements to constitute res judicata on the shebaitship issue between the present parties: identity of parties in representative capacity (Debendra as successor to Haradhan; Kshiroda as opposing party), identity of the issue (claim to shebaitship), and the fact that the issue had been necessarily and finally decided by the appellate Court in the earlier suit.

The Court then surveyed and cited a series of precedents which, it said, support the proposition that an earlier final decision by an appellate court can operate as res judicata on the question of title to representative positions (such as shebaitship) even where the earlier party was described as pro forma or the earlier suit was a rent suit. The Court singled out the observations of Sen, J. in Jitendra Nath v. Biswanath Bagchi (AIR 1952 Cal 201) and expressly adopted those observations, describing them as directly supportive of the view taken.

On these bases — identity of parties and issue, the decisive earlier appellate finding in Haradhan's favour, and supporting authorities — the Court applied the rule of res judicata against the appellant's contention and affirmed the Subordinate Judge's decision sustaining the decree for the plaintiff.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court affirmed the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge and sustained the decree passed by the two Courts below. In consequence, the appeal fails and is dismissed. Emphasis on the final disposition:

APPEAL DISMISSED

Implications:

  • The decree in favour of the plaintiff (Debendra) confirming his exclusive shebaitship of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur is sustained.
  • The Court applied res judicata to bar re-litigation of the shebaitship question between Debendra (as successor to Haradhan) and Kshiroda, relying on the earlier appellate decision in Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937.
  • The purported Nirdeshnama (Ex. 7) was rejected as inadmissible by the Subordinate Judge, a view the Court affirmed.
  • No order as to costs was made: there will be no order for costs in this Court or in either of the two Courts below.
  • Leave to appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent is granted (procedural note recorded in the judgment).
  • The opinion does not indicate that a new legal precedent was created; rather, the Court applied and affirmed established authorities to reach its decision.

This summary is strictly confined to the material and findings explicitly stated in the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or inferences beyond the text have been added.

Show all summary ...

1. On 18th April, 1946, the respondent plaintiff instituted the present suit for a declaration inter alia that he was the sole shebait of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Paban alias Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur and for confirmation of his possession in that capacity, or, in the alternative, for recovery of possession upon a further declaration that the Criminal Court's order under Section 145 of the Cr PC in the defendant No. 1 appellant's favour in respect of the said land was illegal and not binding upon him (the plaintiff). In the plaintiff's suit, there were other consequential prayers in the shape of injunction and recovery of mesne profits. The suit was decreed by the trial Court and, on appeal, that decision has been affirmed by the learned Subordinate Judge. The contesting defendants Nos. 1 and 2 have now come up in second appeal.

2. There is no dispute that the suit property belongs to the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur. The contest really centres round the question as to whether the respondent-plaintiff is the sole shebait of the said deity or whether the defendant No. 1 appellant is also a co-shebait. The plaintiff's exclusive title to the disputed shebaitship was found by the learned Munsif upon consideration of the alleged Nirdeshnama, said to have been left by common ancestor Gopi Charan alias Gopi Mohan, of which Ex. 7 was put forward by the plaintiff as a true and correct copy, and also upon a previous appellate decision (Ex. 1(b)) in a former suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) which was held to be inter partes and res judicata on the point. The lower appellate Court has upheld the decree only on the ground of res judicata while differing from the trial Court on the question of construction of the Nirdeshnama and also its authenticity, rejecting the copy (Ex. 7) as inadmissible in evidence.

3. On the materials before me, the latter part of the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge, namely, on Ex. 7, seems to be quite correct both as to construction and admissibility, and the other question also, namely, res judicata, appears to have been rightly decided by him. On Ex. 7, I have little to add to the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge but the question of res judicata presents some apparent difficulty and requires a little discussion and elucidation. The previous suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) was for rent in respect of some land of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur. The suit was brought by the present plaintiff Debendra's father Haradhan as sole shebait of the deity against the tenant as principal defendant and the present defendant No. 1 Kshiroda as a pro forma defendant upon the express allegation that she (Kshiroda) was claiming to be a co-snebait and upon a specific denial of her said claim. In the plaint of the said suit. Haradhan claimed to be the sole shebait, denied the-present defendant No. 1 Kshiroda's claim for shebaitship or co-shebaitship or her right to represent the deity at all with an alternative statement that, if Kshiroda was held to be a co-shebait with him she might be joined as a co-plaintiff to represent the-deity. The tenant's defence inter alia was that the suit was not maintainable as Kshiroda was a co-shebait witii Haradhan and she ought to have joined to represent the deity as plaintiff and there was also no statement in the plaint as to her unwillingness, to do so. The pro forma defendant Kshiroda appeared in the suit to contest Haradhan's exclusive-claim to the shebaitship of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur and she set up and asserted her claim to be a co-shebait. The trial Court, upheld Kshiroda's contention and directed her to be made a co-plaintiff to represent the deity and passed a rent decree in favour of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur represented by shebaits Haradhan and Kshiroda. The tenant (principal defendant) appealed for getting rid of the decree and Haradhan also, claiming to be the sole shebait, filed, a cross-objection, challenging Kshiroda's right to the shebaitship (co-shebaitship) and her right to represent the deity along with Haradhan. The-tenant's appeal was dismissed but Haradhans' crossobjection was allowed by the lower Appellate Court, and the learned Judge overruled the arguments of Kshiroda's lawyer in support of the trial Court's, decision, holding her to be a co-shebait. Against this decision, Kshiroda took a second appeal (S.A No. 676 of 1938) to this Court which failed at the-preliminary stage of hearing under O. 41, 11, 11 of the CPC (Vide Ex. 1(c)).

4. I ought to mention here some express findings in the lower appellate Court's above judgment (Ex. 1(b)). I have already said that one of the question in the above rent suit (Rent suit No. 1247 of 1937) was whether the suit was maintainable and, in that connection, the lower appellate Court held in its said judgment (Ex. 1(b)) that, for the purpose of deciding whether the suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) was maintainable or not, it was necessary to see whether the plaintiff was the 16 annas shebait or whether the pro forma defendant Kshiroda was also a shebait jointly with him. This question was eventually answered by the learned Judge in the plaintiff Haradhan's favour and he-found that the plaintiff was the sole shebait and was-entitled “to succeed in the suit and to maintain the suit”. lie also recorded a clear and unambigious finding that pro forma defendant Kshiroda was not a shebait to the extent of 8 annas share or any share-whatsoever and that she should be removed from the plaint as co-plaintiff, to which category she had been transferred under the trial Court's order. The plaintiff Haradhan's cross-objection was thus allowed in full.

5. I have set out above the appellate decision-(Ext. 1(b)) in some detail just to show that it contains all the necessary elements to constitute it res judicata on the question of title to the relevant shebaitship as between the parties to the present suit, namely, Debendra and Kshiroda. Admittedly Debendra inherited Haradhan's interest in the she-baitsliip of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur. In relation to that shebaitship, therefore, Debendra is Haradhan's successor or representative. The primary contest in the present suit relates to the claim to the said shebaitship, plaintiff Debendra claiming exclusive title to the said shebaitship and defendant Kshiroda claiming to be a co-shebait with him. That was also one of the outstanding issues or matters in controversy in the former or previous Suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) which the appellate Court on that occasion considered and found it necessary to decide and actually decided in favour of Debendra's predecessor Iiaradhan. In the present suit, Debendra, claiming to be the sole shebait of the deity, is the plaintiff and Kshiroda, alleged to be claiming and actually claiming to be a co-shebait, is tile main defendant. In the previous suit, namely, Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937, Debendra's predecessor Iiaradhan, similarly claiming to be the sole shebait of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jiu Thakur was the plaintiff and Kshiroda also, alleged to be claiming and actually claiming to be a co-shebait, was a defendant and although she was described in the said suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937) as a pro forma defendant, she was undoubtedly a primary party interested in the shebaitship and, indeed, the real contestant on this point, who eventually failed before the Appellate Court. It is thus clear that; he requisite identity of parties, namely, of parties in their representatives litigating under the same title and the requisite identity of the issue, namely, the dispute or the rival claims as to the shebaitship, are well established and as that issue was held necessary and heard and finally decided by the Appellate Court in favour of the present plaintiff Debendra's predecessor Haradhan in the previous suit (Rent Suit No. 1247 of 1937), it operates as res judicata on the said question in the present suit in plaintiff Debendra's favour and against the defendant Kshiroda. In the context, set out above, the fact that Kshiroda was described as a pro forma defendant in the earlier suit or that the said earlier suit was a rent suit is utterly immaterial on the question of res judicata (Vide Deokee Nundun Roy v. Kalee Pershad, 8 Suth WR 366 (A); Maung Sein Done v. Ma Pan Nyun, 59 Ind App 247 : (AIR 1932 PC 161 (B)) and Monjur Mondal v. Ahammad Mondal, 56 Cal WN 506 : (AIR 1953 Cal 155 (C)), since affirmed in L.P.A No. 10 of 1952 (Cal) (D) and Gobind Chunder v. Taruck Chunder, ILR 3 Cal 145 (FB) (E); Toponidhee Dhirj v. Sreeputty Sahanee, ILR 5 Cal 832 (P); Panchu Mandal v. Chandra Kant Saha, 14 Cal LJ 220 (G); Midanapur Zemindari Co. Ltd. v. Jogendra Kumar, 33 Cal LJ 186 : (AIR 1921 Cal 750) (H) and Harekrishna Datta… v. Gourhari Setna Poddar…., ILR 59 Cal 1250 : (AIR 1932 Cal 894 (I)); See also Radha Madhub Holder v. Monohur Mukerji, 15 Ind App 97 (PC) (J). The view I have taken above is directly supported by the observations of Sen, J. in Jitendra Nath v. Biswanath Bagchi, AIR 1952 Cal 201 (K) at p. 203, where the learned Judge stated the relevant proposition through the medium of an act illustration and affirmed it in unequivocal terms. I respectfully agree with the said observations and, if I may point out with respect the two early decisions of this Court, relied on by Sen, J. and also cited above by me, namely, ILR 5 Cal 832 (F) and ILR 3 Cal 145 (FB) (E), appear to be direct supporting authorities on this point. I have, further, no doubt in my mind as to the soundness of the proposition, enunciated and affirmed by Sen, J., and I respectfully adopt the same. To some extent also the other two aecisions, reported in Midnapore Zemindary Co. Ltd. v. Kumar Nares Narain Roy, 33 Cal LJ 317 : (AIR 1921 Cal 368 (L)) and Krishna Chandra Gajapati v. Challa Ramanna, 36 Cal WN 365 : (AIR 1932 PC 50) (M), are relevant and they support the conclusion which I have reached in the circumstances of the present case.

6. In the above view, I affirm the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge, applying the rule of res judicata against the appellant's contention on the question of title to the shebaitship of the deity Sri Sri Iswar Dadhi Baman Jui Thakur.

7. That is sufficient to sustain the decree, passed by the two Courts below in the plaintiff's favour.

8. This appeal, accordingly, fails and it is dismissed, but, in the circumstances, there will be no order for costs either in this Court or in any of the two Courts below.

9. Leave to appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent is granted.

G.M.J

10. Appeal dismissed.