- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Muchiram Chand v. Paresh Nath Maity And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (R.P. Mookerjee, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The lands in Khatian No. 238 in Mouza Harendtanagore (Touzi No. 2858, district of 24-Pergannas) belonged to the plaintiffs, described as the Maitis or Chakdars. Certain other persons, described as the Pramaniks, were recorded as settled raiyats in respect of those lands. Subordinate Khatians Nos. 239 to 243 recorded interests in the names of other persons; Muchiram Chand (hereafter “Muchiram”) held a subordinate tenancy described as a Korfa right.
The Maitis filed a rent suit (Rent Suit No. 1910 of 1943) for arrears of rent for 1345 to 1349 B.S. The suit was decreed ex parte and, in execution, a sale proclamation was issued and the Maitis purchased in the execution sale. After issue of the sale certificate the Maitis filed an application under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act seeking annulment of the encumbrance described as Muchiram’s Korfa right, alleging that it arose from leases which had been sold in the rent sale.
Muchiram applied to set aside the sale; his application was dismissed. On 27-6-1945 the Maitis filed Title Suit No. 53 of 1945 seeking declaration of title to lands described as appertaining to Khatians Nos. 238, 239 and 241 (inclusive of subordinate Khatians) and claiming khas possession if eviction followed; alternatively confirmation of possession. Muchiram defended asserting (a) his subordinate Korfa interest was not sold in the rent execution because the rent suit concerned only the raiyati holding, (b) notices (in the rent suit and under Section 167) were not duly served on him, and (c) his title remained unaffected.
On 7-12-1945 Muchiram filed Title Suit No. 99 of 1945 seeking declaration and confirmation of his title and possession (or recovery in the alternative). Both suits were heard together and on 14-7-1949 the learned Subordinate Judge decreed the Maitis' suit and dismissed Muchiram’s suit. Muchiram appealed to this Court in two appeals: First Appeal No. 101 of 1950 (from Title Suit No. 53 of 1945) and First Appeal No. 187 of 1949 (from Title Suit No. 99 of 1945).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Muchiram’s alleged Korfa right in the subordinate Khatians was extinguished or barred by the ex parte decision in the rent suit (and whether Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code applied to bar his claim).
- Whether the notice issued under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act — purporting to annul Muchiram’s encumbrance (Korfa right) — had been duly and properly served in accordance with Order 5, Rules 15–17 (in particular amended Rule 17) of the CPC, so as to effect annulment of the Korfa right.
Arguments of the Parties
Maitis' Arguments
- The rent suit related to the raiyati holding, execution of the decree resulted in a sale that affected encumbrances, and the Maitis obtained a sale and thereafter served notice under Section 167 Bengal Tenancy Act to annul Muchiram's Korfa right; hence their title extends to the subordinate Khatians.
- As an alternative or in support, the learned Subordinate Judge relied on Section 47 CPC to hold that Muchiram’s claim was barred because he suffered an ex parte decree by not appearing in the rent suit.
Muchiram's Arguments
- He had no subsisting interest in the raiyati holding and the rent suit related only to the raiyati holding; therefore his subordinate Korfa tenancy was not the subject-matter of that suit and could not have been extinguished by the rent decree or the sale.
- The notice under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act (which, if properly served, would annul his Korfa right) was not duly served on him; alternatively, even if service occurred, it did not comply with the requirements of Order 5, Rules 15–17 (particularly amended Rule 17) of the CPC, and thus was ineffective.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rasik Chandra v. Jagabandhu, AIR 1929 Cal 392 | Authority illustrating that service (or notice) under such statutory provisions must be proved affirmatively; knowledge alone is insufficient. | The court relied on the principle to emphasize that when a party claims a notice was served under Section 167, affirmative proof of service is required rather than mere knowledge of issuance or intimation. |
| Gopallal v. Amulya Kumar, AIR 1933 Cal 234 | Support for the proposition that strict proof of service is necessary under statutory annulment/notice provisions. | The court invoked the case as supporting authority for requiring proof of proper service of the Section 167 notice before annulment can be held to have taken effect. |
| Jhabarmull v. Bhagatram, 51 Cal WN 189 | Illustration of the requirement that service must be established and not merely inferred from knowledge or surrounding circumstances. | The court cited it to buttress the position that mere knowledge or informal intimation does not satisfy the formal service requirements where the claimant asserts formal service occurred. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in two principal stages corresponding to the two short questions identified.
- On the applicability of Section 47 CPC: The Court found the learned Subordinate Judge's reliance on Section 47 CPC to bar Muchiram's claim was misconceived. The rent suit (Rent Suit No. 1910 of 1943) concerned the raiyati holding only and did not include the subordinate Korfa tenancy. The pleading, decree and sale documents left no doubt that the Korfa tenancy was not the subject-matter. Merely because Muchiram was impleaded (though not a proper or necessary party) and an ex parte decree was obtained, it did not follow that his subordinate tenancy rights were extinguished. The Court emphasized that Section 47 CPC and the principles underlying it were irrelevant to extinguish a separate subordinate tenancy which was not litigated or decreed upon.
- On the validity of service under Section 167 Bengal Tenancy Act: The Court accepted that the Section 167 notice had been issued, but the core question was whether it had been duly served. The peon's report showed that when service was sought at the address given (Lat No.15 Harendra Nagar) the peon found that Muchiram was not present, was reported by witnesses as being "in his own house" and they could not state when he would come; the cultivator Rajani Nayek was intimated of the substance but refused to give a receipt; consequently the peon affixed a copy of the notice from the roof of Muchiram's but and reported service.
- The Court applied the amended Rule 17 of Order 5 CPC (quoted in full in the opinion) and held that service under Section 167 must be strictly and properly effected, and proof of service is obligatory on the purchaser seeking annulment. The Court reiterated that knowledge or intimation is not a substitute for proper service in the ordinary case and, when a party asserts that service occurred, it must be proved affirmatively; the Court cited Rasik Chandra, Gopallal and Jhabarmull in this context.
- The Court scrutinized the peon's conduct and reporting. It observed that the peon should have exercised greater diligence when told that Muchiram was "in his house" — particularly because evidence showed Muchiram had two residences (Lat No.15 and Lat No.16) and his wife lived at Lat No.15. The peon should have attempted to locate him or ascertained whether he was likely to return within a reasonable time. The Court held that Rajani Nayek, a 'bhagchasi'/'cultivator' under Muchiram, was not shown to be an agent empowered to accept service nor an adult family member; thus intimation to him did not constitute proper service under the rules.
- Consequently, the Court held the peon's method and report did not satisfy the requirements of Order 5, Rules 15–17 (particularly amended Rule 17). Therefore the Section 167 notice was not properly served and could not annul Muchiram's Korfa right. As a result the Korfa rights subsisted and remained unaffected by the rent sale and subsequent proceedings.
The Court thus reversed the Subordinate Judge’s holding on Section 47 CPC, found insufficient service under Section 167, and concluded the Maitis could not establish title to the subordinate Khatians.
Justice Sarkar concurred in the judgment.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: APPEALS ALLOWED.
Holdings as to the suits and consequences:
- Both appeals were allowed with costs (hearing fee one set of five gold mohurs).
- Title Suit No. 53 of 1945 (the Maitis' suit) was dismissed.
- Title Suit No. 99 of 1945 (Muchiram's suit) was decreed in his favour.
- The parties will bear their own costs in the Lower Court.
Implications:
The immediate effect is the preservation of Muchiram's Korfa tenancy rights in the subordinate Khatians: those rights were not annulled by the rent execution/sale nor by the purported service under Section 167 because service was not proved to have been properly effected. The opinion does not articulate any broader legal rule or announce a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities to insist on strict compliance with service requirements; it confines its consequence to the direct effect on the parties' titles and possession as set out above.
R.P Mookerjee, J.:— For a proper appreciation of the points in Issue reference has to be made to certain proceedings which had taken place before the filing of the two suits out of which the present appeals arise.
2. The lands described in Khatian No. 238, situated in Mouza Harendtanagore in Touzi No. 2858 in the district of 24-Pergannas belonged to the plaintiffs who will be hereafter described the Maitis as Chakdars. Certain persons who will be described hereafter as the Pramaniks were recorded as settled raiyats in respect of the said lands.
3. The interests recorded in the subordinate Khatians Nos. 239 to 243 were entered in the name of other persons. The Maitis filed a suit for the realization of the arrears of rent for 1345 to 1349 B.S in respect of the ‘raiyati’ holding. The persons impleaded as defendants were the Pramaniks as also Muchiram Chand on the allegation that it was being claimed by the latter that he was a co-sharer. This suit was decreed ‘ex parte’. In execution of the decree, a sale proclamation was issued and the Maiti decree-holders purchased the same. It will have to be considered as to what was put up to sale in this execution case. After the issue of the sale certificate an application was filed by the Maitis under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act for annulling the encumbrance describing the same as the Korfa right held by Muchiram under the ‘raiyati’ on the strength of leases taken by Muchiram from others which had been sold in the rent sale.
4. According to the Maitis, the notice of annulment was duly served. According to Muchiram it was not. About this time Muchiram filed an application for setting aside the sale which had taken place in execution of the rent decree mentioned above. This application was ultimately dismissed.
5. On 27-6-1945, the Maitis filed Title Suit No. 53 of 1945 for the declaration of their title to the lands in suit describing the same as apperttaining to Khatians Nos. 238, 239 and 241, inclusive of the subordinate Khatians. It was allege that the plaintiffs we re entitled to ‘khas’ possession after eviction of defendant 1 from all the lands in suit if the former are dispossessed from the tenancy of the suit; otherwise for confirmation of possession.
6. The defence of Muchiram was that his interest had not been sold in execution of the rent decree obtained by the Maities as the subject matter of the claim was limited to the ‘raiyati’ holding only in which Muchiram had no subsisting interest.
7. It was further alleged that the notice in the rent suit had not been served upon him. It was further contended that the notice of annulment issued under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act had not been duly served upon him. His title, therefore, had not been affected either by the sale under the rent decree or after the filing of the petition under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
8. Another suit was filed on 7-12-1945, by Muchiram against the Maitis on the lines of the defence as entered by him in the suit filed by the Maitis that his title had not been affected by the proceedings referred to already and his Korfa right had not been affected by the so-called service of notice of annulment. He accordingly prayed for declaration of his title and for confirmation of possession, or in the alternative for recovery of possession if he is found to have been dispossessed.
9. These two suits were heard together and disposed of by one judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge on 14-7-1949. The claim of the Maitis succeeded with the result that their suit was decreed and the suit by Muchiram was dismissed.
10. Two appeals have been taken to this Court by Muchiram. First Appeal No. 101 of 1950 arises out of Title Suit No. 53 of 1945, i.e, Maitis' suit. First Appeal No. 187 of 1949 arises out of Title Suit No. 99 of 1945, i.e, Muchiram's suit.
11. Two short questions arise for consideration. The learned Subordinate Judge has held that the claim by Muchiram in respect of the Korfa right is barred under Section 47 of the CPC. This is wholly a misconceived proposition. Rent Suit No. 1910 of 1943 was by the Maitis in respect of the ‘raiyati’ holding. It did not include the subordinate tenancy held by Muchiram as a Korfa tenant.
12. The description given in the plaint and as incorporated in the decree leave no room for doubt about this fact. That Muchiram had been impleaded, though he was neither a proper nor a necessary party, will not in any way affect his right in the subordinate tenancy. It is now admitted by both the parties that Muchiram had no interest in the ‘raiyati’ holding.
13. It is not appreciated why the learned Subordinate Judge proceeded on the footing that Muchiram was duty bound to appear in the rent suit and bring to the notice of the Court that he was an unnecessary party and that he was not interested in the subject matter of that suit. His failure to do so had the effect, according to the learned Subordinate Judge, of suffering an ‘ex parte’ decree to be passed against him with the result that “his so-called Korfa right” was also extinguished in the process.
14. We cannot understand how this legal consequence can follow when the Korfa tenancy was not the subject matter of the suit. It is also not understood how Section 47 of the CPC can at all be attracted and be trotted out as a bar to the enforcement of the rights of Muchiram. Neither the provisions contained in Section 47 of the CPC nor the principles underlying the same can have any relevancy to the point now before us.
15. The rights, if any, which Muchiram had as Korfa tenant remained intact by the rent decree and the sale which followed. The sale proclamation and the writ for delivery of possession make it abundantly clear that the Korfa right was neither sold, nor was it the subject matter of the writ for delivery of possession thereafter.
16. Even if the objection raised by the Maitis under Section 47 of the CPC be not available, the next plea which was taken by them was under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and requires a serious consideration.
17. If the notice under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act had been duly served the right which Muchiram had been annulled. The attack by Muchiram is of a two-fold character. It is stated that no such notice had at all been served, and even if served, it did not satisfy the provisions contained in O. 5, Rr. 15 to 17 of the CPC. That the notice had gone out cannot be disputed.
18. The only question for our consideration is whether the notice was duly served. When the notice was taken out for service, it was not served on Muchiram personally. The relevant portion of the peon's report indicates that when he went to serve the notice at the address given, viz., Lat No. 15 Harendra Nagar, it was found by him that he was not present. It was reported to him by the witnesses who were present at the place that he was in his own house and they could not state when he would be coming.
19. It was further recorded that as regards Muchiram who was party No. 1 in the notice which, was being served, his cultivator Rajani Nayek was intimated of the substance of the notice, but he refused to give any receipt for the service. Accordingly a copy of the notice was hung up from the roof of the but of Muchiram. The notice was accordingly served.
20. The notice required to be served under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act has to be duly and properly served. Such service is to be clearly proved and it is obligatory on the purchaser who gave the notice annulling encumbrance to show that the notice had been served in the prescribed manner. Section 167, Bengal Tenancy Act is also required to be very strictly interpreted.
21. It is not the knowledge of the issue of such a notice or of the intention to annul the encumbrance which is required under this section to be proved but the service of the notice under the section. Though there are certain exceptions under which knowledge or intimation may some times be sufficient to impute notice, but when the case of a party is that such a notice was actually served, it has to be proved affirmatively. See in this connection ‘Rasik Chandra v. Jagabandhu’, AIR 1929 Cal 392 (A), ‘Gopallal v. Amulya Kumar,’ AIR 1933 Cal 234 (B), and ‘Jhabarmull v. Bhagatram’, 51 Cal WN 189 (C).
22. We are, therefore, to examine whether the nature of the service, as disclosed in the peon's report referred to above satisfies the conditions laid down under R. 17 of O. 5 of the CPC. Rule 17 with the amendment as made by this Court runs as follows:
“Where the defendant or his agent or such other person as aforesaid refuses to sign the acknowledgment, or where the defendant is absent from his residence at the time when service is sought to be effected on him thereat and there is no likelihood of his being found thereat within a reasonable time and there is no agent empowered to accept service of the summons on his behalf, nor any other person, upon whom service can be made, the serving officer shall affix a copy of the summons on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain, and shall then return the original to the Court from which it was issued with a report endorsed thereon or annexed, thereto stating that he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under which he did so, and the-name and address of the person (if any) by whom the house was identified and in whose presence the copy was affixed”.
23. If the defendant is absent from his residence when the service is sought to be effected on him, there is a duty cast upon the peon to ascertain whether there is any possibility of the person to come back to the place. In the present case Rajani Nayek whose name is mentioned in the peon's report transpires to be a ‘bhagchasi’ under Muchiram.
24. That fact by itself will not make him an agent empowered to accept service or a person otherwise empowered to receive a notice meant for Muchiram. It is not alleged that he was an adult male member of the family residing with him.
25. An attempt was made on behalf of Muchiram to show that the address as given in the notice, i.e, Lat No. 15 Harendra Nagar was not the place where Muchiram used to reside.
26. It was attempted to show that Muchiram's address was Lat No. 16 Tarangar, the address given in the ‘pottas’, Ex. A series, but the fact remains, as disclosed in the deposition of Muchiram in Miscellaneous Case No. 294 of 1944 during the proceedings for setting aside the sale (Ex. 11) that his wife lived in Lat No. 15, and he also lived both in Lat No. 15 and in Lat No. 16. He had two places to reside in. That by itself will not, however, make the service of notice as described by the peon a sufficient compliance with the strict provisions contained in Rr. 15 to 17 of O. 5 of the CPC.
27. In the circumstances of this case, it was the duty of the peon to be more definite before he could submit a report of effective service of the notice. The serving peon ought to have used all due and reasonable diligence to find the defendant when he heard that he was in his house, meaning thereby in Lat Tarangar within a very short distance of the place where the notice was being served.
28. We must accordingly hold that the notice under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act had not been properly served. The result, therefore, was that the Korfa right of Muchiram under the subordinate Khatians had not been annulled. That right subsisted and it had not been affected by the rent sale which had taken place earlier.
29. The legal effect, therefore, is that the claim by the Maitis in their suit that their title subsists in the subordinate Khatians must fail. The claim put forward by Muchiram in his suit to the effect that his rights as a Korfa tenant in the subordinate Khatians had not been affected either by the rent sale by the Maitis or by the alleged service of notice under Section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act must be allowed.
30. The result, therefore, is that both the appeals are allowed with costs, hearing fee (one set) five gold mohurs. Title Suit No. 53 of 1945 stands dismissed and Title Suit No. 99 of 1945 is decreed.
31. The parties will bear their own costs in the Lower Court.
32. Sarkar, J.:— I agree.
S.L.L
33. Appeals allowed.
Alert