Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahadeb Ram Kahar v. Tinkori Roy .

Calcutta High Court
Apr 15, 1954
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a tenant's Second Appeal arising from a suit for ejectment. At trial the suit was dismissed on the ground that "the defendant's tenancy is non-ejectable falling under section 7(5) of the Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act XX of 1949". On first appeal the learned Subordinate Judge reversed that decision, holding that "the defendant cannot claim the advantage of section 7(5) of the Act". The tenant (defendant) brought this Second Appeal, principally contending that he is protected under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949.

Material facts (undisputed): The suit land is one cottah recorded as C.S. Plot No. 4591, Mouza Chinsurah, and is non-agricultural land within the meaning of West Bengal Act XX of 1949. The defendant's tenancy began under a written kabuliyat dated 6 January 1929 (23rd Jaistha, 1336 B.S.) for five years (to the end of Chaitra, 1340 B.S.). That registered lease expired, but there was payment and acceptance of rent and continuance of possession thereafter. As a result, "holding over" under section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act applied, and the tenancy renewed from month to month under section 106. Rent was accepted up to 1350 B.S.; from 1351 B.S. the plaintiff refused rent and, in August 1949 (beginning of Baisakh, 1356 B.S.), served a 15 days' notice to quit purporting to terminate the tenancy at the expiry of that Bengali month. The present suit was instituted on 19 September 1949.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a tenancy created by "holding over" under section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act, arising on the determination of a lease in writing (the registered five-year kabuliyat in this case), constitutes holding of "non-agricultural land" "without a (any) lease in writing" within the meaning of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949.
  2. If the answer to (1) is affirmative, whether the tenant is entitled to protection under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949 (i.e., where the land "has been held" by the defendant "for a term of more than one year but less than 12 years" and no six months' notice was given).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Defendant / Tenant)

  • The tenant contended that he is protected under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949 because his tenancy by "holding over" should be regarded as tenancy "without a (any) lease in writing".
  • He relied on the factual premise that (a) there was an original five-year registered kabuliyat which expired, (b) rent was accepted and possession continued, and (c) the period of holding over exceeded one year but was less than twelve years, and there was no six months' notice as required by clause (iii).

Respondent (Plaintiff)

  • At the trial level the plaintiff successfully argued (or the trial Court found) that the defendant's tenancy was non-ejectable under section 7(5) of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949.
  • On appeal the learned Subordinate Judge disagreed with that trial finding and held that the defendant could not claim the advantage of section 7(5). The plaintiff also refused to accept rent from 1351 B.S. onwards and served a 15 days' notice to quit in August 1949, thereafter instituting the ejectment suit on 19 September 1949.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kai Kushroo Bezonjee Capadia v. Bai Jerbai Hirjibhoy Warden (Federal Court) [53 C.W.N 73, 79 (F.B.)] Held that tenancy by "holding over" is a "new tenancy in law". The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that holding over produces a new tenancy distinct from the expired registered lease, and thereby is not holding under the expired lease instrument.
Gopal Chandra Rudra v. Khater Karikar (Bench of this Court) (33 C.W.N 1207) Recognized that after expiry of an original term a party may hold under a new agreement inferred from acceptance of rent and conduct; holding over is not under the registered patta. The Court cited this decision (including Rankin, C.J.'s observations) to confirm that holding over can amount to a new subletting/agreement otherwise than by a registered instrument and hence not the original registered lease.
Thakur Raghuraj Singh v. Rai Bahadur Harikishnan Das (48 C.W.N 439 P.C.) Principle that a remedial statute should be liberally construed. Used to justify a liberal construction of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949 so as to give effect to the protective scheme of the statute.
Rai Ram Taran Banerjee Bahadur (and after him Soshi Coomar Banerjee) v. D.J. Hill [(1950) S.C (C.W.N) 74 at p. 85] Authority supporting liberal construction of remedial enactments (cited per Mahajan, J.). Cited to reinforce the interpretative approach that the West Bengal Act, being remedial, should be construed liberally in favour of tenant protection.
Amulya Chandra Roy v. Kumar Pashupati Nath Malia [55 C.W.N 385 (F.B) at p. 392] Another authority supporting remedial, liberal interpretation of tenant-protective legislation. Relied upon to support the Court's view that the Act's scheme and intent favour protection of tenants holding non-agricultural land and that holding over should not be excluded from "without a lease in writing".
Raj Kumari Debt v. Barkatulla Mondal (Full Bench) (I.L.R 39 Cal. 278) Referenced in the context of avoiding lacunae in statutory interpretation of tenancy statutes. Invoked to support the proposition that the statute should be interpreted so as to avoid leaving tenancies by holding over outside its protection when that would create an undesirable gap in the remedial scheme.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first allowing the tenant to raise the statutory point under section 9(1)(b)(iii) in this Court because the relevant facts were admitted by both parties even though that point was not expressly dealt with by the learned Subordinate Judge.

The Court then set out the essential legal question: whether a tenancy by "holding over" under section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act, arising on the determination of a registered "lease in writing", constitutes holding of non-agricultural land "without a (any) lease in writing" within the meaning of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949. The answer would determine whether the tenant fell within the protection of section 9(1)(b)(iii).

The Court's analysis followed two complementary lines of reasoning:

  1. Precedential and statutory analysis of "holding over": The Court relied on the Federal Court decision in Kai Kushroo Bezonjee Capadia and the Bench decision in Gopal Chandra Rudra to conclude that "holding over" produces a "new tenancy in law" even if the practical terms remain the same as the expired lease. The language of section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act—speaking of the determination of the lease and its "renewal" in the absence of an agreement to the contrary—was read to reinforce the concept of a renewed or fresh grant rather than continuation under the original written lease instrument.
  2. Remedial statutory construction: The West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949, being remedial, should be liberally construed to effectuate its object of protecting tenants of non-agricultural land. The Court reasoned that excluding tenancies by holding over from the phrase "without a (any) lease in writing" would create a lacuna: tenancies whose holding-over period plus the expired written lease period total less than twelve years would be left without protection, contrary to the scheme and intent of the Act. Authorities on remedial construction were cited to justify construing the Act so that holding over falls within "without a lease in writing."

The Court considered section 7(4) (which expressly deals with holding over) but concluded that section 7(4) did not compel a contrary construction; rather, section 7(4) aims to extend protection to many cases of holding over that would not otherwise fall under section 7(2) or section 9(1)(b).

Synthesising the points above, the Court articulated a scheme for application of the Act to tenancies by holding over:

  • If the period of the tenancy by holding over is "more than one year but less than twelve years" (even when combined with the earlier expired lease the total is still less than twelve years), it will attract the protection of section 9(1)(b).
  • If the period of holding over by itself is "not less than twelve years", it will attract the protection of section 7(2).
  • If the period of holding over is less than twelve years, but the period of the expired lease together with the period of holding over is "twelve years or more", then section 7 (as contemplated in section 7(4)) applies and the higher protection under section 7 is available.

Holding and Implications

Decision: The Court accepted the appellant's contention and held that a tenancy by "holding over" is within the expression "without a (any) lease in writing" for the purposes of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949. Consequently, the tenant was entitled to the protection of section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the Act.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The appeal succeeds.
  • The judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge are set aside.
  • The decree of the learned Munsif (except as regards costs) is restored.
  • The plaintiff's ejectment suit is dismissed and the plaintiff's claims in the suit are rejected.
  • The parties are directed to bear their own costs throughout.
  • Leave under clause 15 of the Letters Patent was sought and refused.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasises a liberal construction of the remedial West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act so as to include holding-over tenancies within the phrase "without a (any) lease in writing", thereby preventing a statutory lacuna. The Court's decision is presented as an interpretation of the statute to effectuate tenant protection; the opinion does not purport to lay down additional precedent beyond the interpretative holding applied to these facts.

Show all summary ...

1. This is the tenant's Second Appeal arising out of a suit for ejectment. The suit was dismissed by the trial Court on the ground that “the defendant's tenancy is non-ejectable falling under section 7(5) of the Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act XX of 1949”. On appeal that decision was reversed by the learned Subordinate Judge who held that “the defendant cannot claim the advantage of section 7(5) of the Act”. Hence this Second Appeal by the tenant whose principal contention is that he 13 protected under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the said Act XX of 1949 (The West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949). This contention was also raised before the learned Munsif but it was rejected by him. In the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge there is no reference to this statutory provision and, possibly, this point was not urged before him and the arguments were concentrated on the other section, viz., sec. 7(5). As, however, the point (which is ground No. 1 in the Memorandum of Appeal to this Court) arises on facts which are now admitted by both parties, I have allowed the defendant-appellant to raise it in this Court and, having entertained it, I have also given the plaintiff respondent full opportunity to meet the same.

2. Shorn of unnecessary details, the undisputed facts, as they stand at present, may be stated as follows:

The suit land which measures only one cottah in area is recorded in the Settlement Records as C.S Plot No. 4591 of Mouza Chinsurah. It has been found to be “non-agricultural land” within the meaning of West Bengal Act XX of 1949 and both parties have accepted that position. The defendant's tenancy started under a kabuliyat, dated the 6th January, 1929, corresponding to the 23rd Jaistha, 1336 B.S, which was for a period of five years, viz., 1336 B.S to 1340 B.S, i.e, from 1st Baisakh, B.S 1336, to the end of Chaitra, 1340 B.S As the kabuliyat was before the amended section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, it is not hit by the third paragraph of the said section. There was thus a valid lease between the parties for a period of five years expiring with the end of Chaitra, 1340 B.S, and, as, admittedly, there was payment and acceptance of rent and continuance of the tenant's possession after the determination of the said lease, there was “holding over” under section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act and the defendant's tenancy was renewed from month to month under section 106 of the said Act. The rent was accepted duly up to 1350 B.S From, however, 1351, B.S the plaintiff refused to accept rent and, in August, 1949, corresponding to the beginning of Baisakh, 1356 B.S, he served on the tenant a 15 days' notice to quit purporting to terminate the tenancy with the expiry of the said Bengali month. On the 19th September, 1949, the present suit was instituted. The defence material for our present purpose is the tenant's claim of protection under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949, there being admittedly no “six months” notice” “expiring with the end of a year of the tenancy”, as contemplated in the said clause (iii). The short point which thus arises for consideration is whether the defendant's tenancy by “holding over” is “without a lease in writing” within the meaning of the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949. In other words, the question is whether a tenancy of “non-agricultural land” by “holding over” under section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act, arising on the determination of a “lease in writing”—the registered kabuliyat for 5 years in the present case—constitutes holding of “non-agricultural land” “without a lease in writing”, as contemplated by the said Act. If the answer be in the affirmative, this appeal must succeed and the plaintiffs' suit must fail under section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the Act as, admittedly, the suit land “has been held” by the defendant “for a term of more than one year but less than 12 years” and there has been no “six months” notice”, as prescribed by the said clause (iii). An answer in the negative to the question posed will at once lead to the dismissal of the appeal and the affirmance of the appellate decree in the plaintiff's favour.

3. In my opinion, the appellant's contention ought to be accepted. The tenancy by “holding over” is a “new tenancy in law”, although, practically speaking, the terms of this “new tenancy” may be the same as of the old or the “determined” or “expired” tenancy. This is clear from the observations of Mukherjea, J., in the majority judgment delivered by him in the Federal Court case of Kai Kushroo Bezonjee Capadia v. Bai Jerbai Hirjibhoy Warden (1) [53 C.W.N 73, 79 (F.B)]. It is also supported by the Bench decision of this Court in the case of Gopal Chandra Rudra v. Khater Karikar (2) (33 C.W.N 1207), where at p. 1211 of the report, Rankin, C.J, speaking of the defendant's tenancy by “holding over” after the expiry of the term of his registered patta, observed inter alia as follows: “it is clear on principle that defendant No. 4 in 1922 was holding under a new agreement and was not holding under the registered patta. The lessor's consent was not given by a registered patta but is to be inferred from the circumstances, from the acceptance of rent and from the conduct of the parties. I think, therefore, that there has been after the expiry of the original term a new subletting otherwise than by a registered instrument”.

4. It is true that the case in 33 C.W.N 1207 was one under the Bengal Tenancy Act to which section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act was not in terms applicable, but there can be no question that the general principles, underlying the theory of “holding over” between landlord and tenant, would apply. This was plainly present in the mind of the learned Chief Justice when, referring to the doctrines of “holding over at Common Law and in England”, he expressly recognised that “those doctrines are not applicable to their whole extent to cases under the Bengal Tenancy Act” and then enunciated and applied in the passage, quoted above, the general principles, underlying those doctrines and universally recognised in the law of landlord and tenant. To my mind, therefore, the appellant's tenancy by “holding over” was a “new tenancy”,—may be on the “old” terms for all practical purposes, —and he is “holding over” not under the “expired” kabuliyat or registered lease or “lease in writing” but really “in spite of if”. This is also fairly clear from the language of section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act itself, which admittedly governs the present case, when it speaks of “determination of the lease” and then enacts that “the lease is, in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, “renewed”, the idea being the “renewal” or “grant anew” or a new or “renewed” or “fresh”—vide Kai Khusroo Bezonjee Capadia v. Bai Jerbai Hirjibhoy Warden (1) [53 C.W.N 73, 79 (F.R)], —grant of the “expired” or “determined” lease, the word “renewed” emphasising the continuance of the old terms subject to the “agreement to the contrary”, as mentioned in the section.

5. There is also another approach to the problem before us. The West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949, is admittedly a remedial statute and so it ought to be liberally construed—vide Thakur Raghuraj Singh v. Rai Bahadur Harikishnan Das (3) (48 C.W.N 439 P.C) and Rai Ram Taran Banerjee Bahadur (since deceased) and after him Soshi Coomar Banerjee v. D.J Hill (4) [(1950) S.C (C.W.N) 74 at p. 85], per Mahajan, J., as he then was, and Amulya Chandra Roy v. Kumar Pashupati Nath Malia (5) [55 C.W.N 385 (F.B) at p. 392]. Broadly speaking, the “scheme and intent” of this Act is to give protection to tenants holding “non-agricultural lands” for more than one year, the extent of the protection varying according as the period is less than twelve years or more. This has to be kept in view in interpreting the provisions of this statute. If tenancies by “holding over” do not come within the expression “without a (any) lease in writing”, as used in the Act, such tenancies would be altogether outside its protection where the period of “holding over” plus the period or term of the “expired” lease would be less than twelve years (vide secs. 7 and 9). This would be hardly in consonance with the “scheme and intent” of this statute and an interpretation which will have this effect ought not to be accepted for this remedial enactment. Thus, even apart from section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act or the general law of “holding over” as between landlord and tenant, a tenancy by “holding over” would appropriately come within the expression “without a (any) lease in writing”, as used in the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949. A lacuna which the statute would otherwise disclose will thus be avoided and, in the absence of compelling circumstances pointing to the contrary, this interpretation ought to be accepted [vide in this connection the Full Bench case of this Court, Raj Kumari Debt v. Barkatulla Mondal (6) (I.L.R 39 Cal. 278)].

6. In taking the above view of the statute, I have not overlooked the provisions of section 7(4) of the Act but, in my opinion, those provisions do not warrant or compel a different construction. It is quite true that section 7(4) expressly deals with cases of “holding over” but that is plainly for the purpose of extending the protection of the Act to a large number of “non-agricultural tenancies” which would not otherwise come under section 7(2), or, even under section 9(1)(b), even if tenancies by “holding over” are held to be “without a (any) lease in writing” within the meaning of the Act.

7. To my mind the true position under the Act seems to be as follows:

Where the period of the tenancy by “holding over” is “more than one year but less than twelve years”—even, when taken along with the period of the “expired” “lease in writing” which preceded it—it will have the lesser protection of section 9(1)(b). If the period of the tenancy by “holding over” is by itself “not less than twelve years” it will have the greater protection of section 7(2). If, however, this period be less than twelve years but it is “twelve years or more”, when taken along with the period of the “expired” “lease in writing” in the wake of which it followed, it will still have the higher protection of section 7, as contained in section 7(4).

8. I do not find, therefore, anything in section 7(4) to rule out the view that tenancies by “holding over” would come within the expression “without a (any) lease in writing”, as used in the West Bengal Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act, 1949.

9. In the above view of the matter, I accept the appellant's contention that he is entitled to the protection of section 9(1)(b)(iii) of the Act of 1949 and that the plaintiffs' claim for ejectment must fail under the said statutory provision.

10. This appeal, accordingly, succeeds, the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge are set aside and the decree of the learned Munsif save as regard costs, is restored. The plaintiff's suit stands dismissed and his claims made in the suit, stand rejected.

11. In the circumstances of the case, I direct that the parties will bear their own costs throughout.

12. Leave under clause 15 of the Letters Patent is asked for and it is refused.