- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Steel Brothers & Co., Ltd.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Reference under s.66)
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a Reference under section 66 of the Indian Income-tax Act made by the Commissioner of Income-tax, Calcutta. The question posed was whether, on the facts found by the Tribunal, the commission payable to the assessee under its agreement with Attock Oil Company was governed by section 42(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act for the purpose of computing the assessee's total income.
The assessee is Steel Brothers & Co. Ltd., incorporated in the United Kingdom and acting as managing agent of Attock Oil Company (also incorporated in the United Kingdom). Both companies maintained offices in London. Several agreements between them (made in London) set out the assessee's remuneration:
- A 10 December 1913 agreement provided that Steels would act as managing agents and sole/exclusive agent for purchases and sales and receive a commission of 2½% on purchase and on sale price of goods purchased or sold for the Oil Company.
- A 14 November 1921 agreement modified clause 5 so that Steels would receive commission on sale price of goods sold for the Oil Company by any agent or sub-agent and specified that the commission covered services of "supervision and control" and general advice by Steels' managing partners or administrative staff; commission was payable only where the Oil Company actually received sale proceeds.
- Subsequent agreements (11 June 1924 and 16 April 1930) removed the assessee's exclusive agency for disposal of certain products and appointed Burma Oil Company as exclusive selling agent, but the commission payable to Steels under the 1921/1913 provisions remained unaffected.
For assessment years 1940–41, 1941–42 and 1942–43 the assessee received commissions of Rs. 4,44,816; Rs. 7,71,667; and Rs. 8,83,560 respectively, relating to sales of oil manufactured by Attock Oil Company and sold in India by Burma Oil Company. The products were manufactured in India, business processes and sales occurred in India, and the assessee was a non-resident for tax purposes.
The Income-tax Officer held the income accrued in India because the sales were effected in India. On appeal, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner concluded that the assessee's activities in relation to delivery and sale had been taken over by Burma Oil Company and that Steels' commission was for supervision, control and general advice from London; he therefore held that section 4(1) did not apply and that section 42(3) was the appropriate provision. The Tribunal agreed with the Appellate Assistant Commissioner.
The Commissioner of Income-tax (applicant) made the present Reference under section 66 challenging the Tribunal's conclusion and contended that section 4(1) — not section 42(3) — applied.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts found by the Tribunal, the commission payable to the assessee under the agreement with Attock Oil Company was governed by section 42(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act for the purpose of computing the assessee's total income (i.e., whether the commission accrued or arose in India or was taxable under section 4(1)).
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant (Commissioner of Income-tax) / Dr. S.K. Gupta
- Contended that section 4(1) of the Income-tax Act applied (i.e., the assessee's income accrued or arose in British India and was chargeable under section 4(1)).
- Relied on precedents: Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. Chunilal B. Mehta and Burugu Nagayya v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Madras to support the contention that control exercised from elsewhere did not prevent profits from arising where transactions took place.
Respondent / Assessee (Steel Brothers) — Mr. Sukumar Mitra
- Contended that the assessee's income did not accrue or arise in India and, if taxable at all, the proper provision was section 42(3) (i.e., income attributable to operations in India only insofar as reasonably attributable to operations carried out in the taxable territories).
Income-tax Officer and Appellate Authorities
- The Income-tax Officer treated the assessee as non-resident and held the income accrued in India because sales were effected in India.
- The Appellate Assistant Commissioner held that the assessee had ceased to do the actual sales and that the commission was for supervision, control and advice from London; he held section 4(1) had no application and section 42(3) was the proper section.
- The Tribunal agreed with the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and applied section 42(3).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. Chunilal B. Mehta [I.L.R. (1938) Bom. 752] | Illustrates a factual situation where transactions took place in New York and profits arose there although control was exercised from Bombay (i.e., location of transactions can determine where profits arise even if management/control is elsewhere). | The court considered the case but held it distinguishable on its facts and therefore not applicable to the present case. |
| Burugu Nagayya v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Madras [(1949) 17 I.T.R. 194] | Related facts in which a non-resident carried on business outside British India and sold a major portion through brokers in Bombay; used to purchase in one place and sell major portion elsewhere — cited to address where profits are regarded as arising. | The court found the facts of that case different from the present case and therefore treated the precedent as distinguishable and not controlling. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying the competing statutory provisions and their scope:
- Section 4(1) charges residents and non-residents alike in respect of income which accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise in British India.
- Section 42(3) provides that, where a business's operations are not all carried out in the taxable territories, only such profits as are reasonably attributable to operations carried out in the taxable territories are deemed to accrue or arise there.
The court then examined the facts found by the Tribunal and the nature of the assessee's entitlement to commission. Key points in the court's analysis were:
- The contractual arrangements (especially the 1921 modification) showed that the commission payable to the assessee covered "supervision and control" and general advice provided by the managing partners or administrative staff in London.
- Although the oil products were manufactured and sold in India (by Burma Oil Company), the remuneration paid to the assessee did not arise from the assessee's doing the physical sales in India; instead, it arose from supervisory and advisory services rendered from London.
- Because the assessee's remuneration was attributable mainly to supervision and control exercised from London and not to performing the sales in India, the commission could not be said to have accrued or arisen in India for the purposes of section 4(1).
- The precedents relied upon by the applicant were examined and held distinguishable on their facts: in Chunilal B. Mehta the transactions and profit-generating activities occurred in New York despite control from Bombay; in Burugu Nagayya the pattern of buying and selling and the flow of operations differed from the present facts. For these reasons, those cases did not lead the court to a different conclusion.
- Concluding from the factual findings, the court held that if the assessee were taxable in respect of this income, the proper statutory provision to apply would be section 42(3), not section 4(1), because the income was for services rendered (supervision/control) from outside British India and not the product of sales effected in India by the assessee itself.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court answered the question in the Reference in the affirmative — that is, on the facts found by the Tribunal the commission payable to the assessee was governed by section 42(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act (and not by section 4(1)).
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The court held that the assessee's income did not accrue or arise in India; if the income is taxable, the appropriate provision is section 42(3) rather than section 4(1). The assessee was awarded the costs of the Reference and two counsel were certified.
- Broader precedent: The opinion limits its conclusion to the facts found and treats the cited authorities as distinguishable; the court did not purport to establish a new general rule beyond applying statutory tests to the factual matrix in this case.
Judges: Banerjee, J. (delivering the opinion) and Harries, C.J. (concurring).
Banerjee, J.:— This is a Reference under sec. 66 of the Indian Income-tax Act made at the instance of the Commissioner of Income-tax, Calcutta. The question on which we are to express our opinion has been formulated as follows:
“Whether on the facts found by the Tribunal, the Tribunal was right in holding that the commission payable to the assessee under the agreement with Attock Oil Co., was governed by section 42(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act for the purpose of computing the total income of the assessee?”
2. Section 42(3) of the Act is as follows:
“In the case of a business of which all the operations are not carried out in the taxable territories, the profits and gains of the business deemed under this section to accrue or arise in the taxable territories shall be only such profits and gains as are reasonably attributable to that part of the operations carried out in the taxable territories.”
3. The facts of the case so far as they are relevant to this judgment may be shortly stated as follows. The assessee is Messrs. Steel Brothers & Co. Ltd., which was incorporated in the United Kingdom and was the managing agent of Attock Oil Company which was also incorporated in the United Kingdom. These companies have their respective offices in London. There were several agreements between the assessee and the Attock Oil Company which were all made in London, whereby the remuneration payable to the assessee was fixed. It is not necessary to set out the agreements in extenso. The relevant portions are as follows:
The first agreement is dated December 10, 1913. Clause 5 of the agreement is this:
“In addition to such employment as Managing Agents, Steels shall also be employed as sole and exclusive agent of the Oil Company for the purchase of all ships, machinery, plant, stores, live-stocks, etc., required by oil company…. and as sole executive agent of the Oil Company for the sale of all products of Oil Company. As remuneration for the services of Steels as Agent of Oil Company………the Oil Company shall pay to Steels:—
(A) a commission at the rate of 2½ per cent, upon the gross price of the Oil Company of all goods so purchased by Steels for the Oil Company, and
(B) a commission at the rate of 2½ per cent, on the sale price of all goods sold by Steels for the Oil Company.”
4. The second agreement, dated November 14, 1921, modified clause 5 which I have set out above to a certain extent. Clause 3 of the second agreement which modifies clause 5 is as follows:
“The commission payable to Steels under clause 5 of the principal agreement shall be payable on the sale price of all goods sold for the Oil Company by any Agent or Sub-Agent and the commission to be paid to Steels under such clause as hereby amplified, is not to cover expenses incurred by Steels but is to cover services and remuneration of Steels in connection with the head ‘supervision and control’ and general advice by the Managing Partners of Steels or the Administrative staff in their employ. Steels will not be entitled to commission under such clause except where the Oil Company do in fact receive the sale-proceeds of the goods. The right of Steels to receive commission under such clause shall not be in any way prejudiced as regards the future by the fact, that in the past Steels have not actually claimed or received commission on certain purchases made by Steels for the Oil Company”.
5. The difference in the two clauses is obvious. Under the first agreement the assessee was to receive commission or remuneration for sale of goods made by it on behalf of the Oil Company. Under the second agreement it was entitled to remuneration for goods sold for the Oil Company by any agent or sub-agent.
6. The third agreement, dated June 11, 1924, introduced a further modification. By that agreement the assessee agreed to part with its exclusive agency for disposal of Aviation Spirit, Benzene, Petrol, Kerosene of the Attock Oil Company. By another agreement, namely, dated April 16, 1930, it consented to Burma Oil Company Limited being appointed the exclusive agent for disposal of Attock Oil Company's on her products. But the commission payable to the assessee on sales even after Burma Oil Company had become the sole selling agent of Attock Oil Company remained unaffected. That is to say, cl. 3 of the agreement, dated November 14, 1921, read with cl. 5 of the agreement, dated December 10, 1913, remained intact so far as they provided for payment of remuneration to the assessee though its position as the selling agent of Attock Oil Company was taken up by Burma Oil Company. The assessment years in question are 1940–41, 1941–42 and 1942–43. The assessee received from the Oil Company Rs. 4,44,816, Rs. 7,71,667 and Rs. 8,83,560 respectively as commission on sales of oil manufactured by the Oil Company and sold by their selling agent the Burma Oil Company.
7. In the assessment years in question the products of the oil company were manufactured in India and the business processes were carried out in India, and the sales by Burma Oil Company took place in India. It is clear that the assessee is a non-resident company and the Income-tax Officer rightly treated it as a non-resident company. It has various activities and, amongst others, is the managing agent of the Oil Company.
8. The Income-tax Officer held that the income of the assessee accrued in India because the sales were effected in India. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner on appeal however took a different view. He held that the assessee had ceased to do anything with the actual sale of the Oil Company's products. All the assessee's activities connected with the delivery and sale of the Oil Company's products had been taken up by the Burma Oil Company and the commission which was paid to the assessee was for supervision, control and general advice from London.
9. According to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner sec. 4(1) of the Income-tax Act had no application. He held that as there was business connection between the assessee and the Oil Company the proper section to be applied was sec. 42(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act. From the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner there was appeal to the Tribunal. The Tribunal agreed with the view expressed by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and held that in this case sec. 42 would apply and not sec. 4(1).
10. This reference arises out of the Order made by the Tribunal and the contention before us on behalf of the applicant, the Commissioner of Income-tax, is that it is not sec. 42 but sec. 4(1) that applies. Section 4(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act is as follows:
“Subject to the provisions of this Act, the total income of any previous year of any person includes all income, profits and gains from whatever source derived which—
(a) are received or are deemed to be received in British India in such year by or on behalf of such person, or
(b) if such person is not resident in British India during such year.
(c) if such person is not resident in British India during such year, accrue or arise or are deemed to accrue or arise to him in British India during such year.”
11. Under sec. 4(1) it is clear that residents and non-residents are alike chargeable in respect of income which accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise in India. Under sec. 42 income is deemed to accrue or arise in India if it accrues or arises directly or indirectly (among others) through or from any business connection in India.
12. It is quite clear in this case that what the assessee has been paid is not its commission or remuneration for selling goods of Attock Oil Company which took place in India, but for its supervision, advice and control from London. The assessee's remuneration cannot be said to have accrued or arisen in India because it is not by selling the goods that the assessee earned the income. It is attributable mainly to the supervision and control it exercised from London.
13. Dr. S.K Gupta on behalf of the applicant before us has referred to The Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. Chunilal B. Mehta (1) [I.L.R (1938) Bom. 752] and to the case, Burugu Nagayya v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras, Madras (2) [(1949) 17 I.T.R 194]. But these cases are quite distinguishable. In the first case which was decided by their Lordships of the Privy Council the transactions took place in New York and the profits arose there although the control was from Bombay. In the other case the applicant was a non-resident and had been carrying on business in gold and silver in Secunderabad, outside British India. He used to purchase gold at Secunderabad and sell the major portion of it at Bombay through brokers. The rest of it used to be sold in Hyderabad itself, a small portion of it being locally sold at Secunderabad. The Bombay brokers with whom the assessee in that case was in touch would telegraphically intimate to the assessee the current prices of gold in Bombay and thereupon advices would be sent from Secunderabad notifying to them the quantity of gold that would be available for sale at those rates. Soon thereafter, gold would be sent to Bombay through a representative of the assessee who would get it assayed in the mint and gave the same to the broker who after selling it paid the sale-proceeds to the assessee's agent. It is quite clear that the facts of the two cases are different from the facts of the case under consideration. Here the remuneration of, the assessee was not payable for doing anything in India, but for supervising and controlling the operations from London. So far as the Oil Company is concerned it is quite true that their income was derived from the sale of oil in India, and the sale having taken place in India their profits accrued in India. But so far as the assessee is concerned we cannot see how it can be said that its income accrued or arose in India. The assessee was originally the selling agent of the Oil Company, but it divested itself of that right in consideration of a portion of the remuneration being paid to it for its supervision and control of the business from London. The assessee became entitled to receive the income when the sale-proceeds actually reached the hands of the Oil Company. It seems to us therefore that in no sense can it be said that its income, profit or gain accrued or arose in India.
14. Mr. Sukumar Mitra on behalf of the assessee has contended in this reference by urging before us that the income did not accrue or arise in India. He said that the assessee could be taxed, if at all, under sec. 42 and not under sec. 4(1). We think his contention is right and in this Reference we hold that the assessee's income did not accrue or arise in India. If the assessee is liable to be taxed, the proper section applicable is sec. 42 of the Indian Income-tax Act.
15. We therefore answer the question asked in the affirmative. The assessee is entitled to the costs of this Reference. Certified for two Counsel.
Harries, C.J:— I agree.
P.S
Alert