Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Amritha Reji v. Union Of India

Kerala High Court
Oct 29, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Judgment

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a student of Std. XI at Kendriya Vidyalaya who had appeared for the Std. X examination conducted by the third respondent with Roll No. 641116. She secured 470 out of 500 marks. For most subjects she obtained an aggregate of 96% and Grade A1, but in Social Science she obtained 86 marks and was placed in Grade A2 (see Ext. P1 marklist). The petitioner expected 98 marks in Social Science. A rechecking request (Ext. P2) produced a response stating there was no change in the mark allotted. Exts. P3–P12 were produced to show an excellent prior academic record (average 98.3% in class examinations).

The petitioner sought supply of a photocopy of the answer book and answer key; these requests were denied by Exts. P15 and P16 on the ground that the information is exempt under S. 8(1)(e) of the Right to Information Act. A subsequent request for verification of the answer book was also refused (Ext. P17) for the same reason. The petitioner relied on Ext. P21, an order of the Central Information Commission directing production of answer sheets in another matter.

This Court, by interim order dated 2.11.2009, allowed verification of the sealed answer book that had been produced before the Court; the petitioner and her parents have since verified the same.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's request for revaluation of her Social Science answer paper could be allowed.
  2. Whether, under the relevant Examination Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Education (1995), a candidate is entitled to revaluation or inspection of answer books beyond the statutory verification procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • To maintain transparency and to assuage the student's concerns, the Court should direct revaluation of the Social Science answer paper.
  • Given the student's consistently excellent performance (as shown in Exts. P3–P12), it was contended that proper valuation may not have been done and revaluation is necessary to do complete justice.
  • Reliance was placed on the Apex Court decision in Sahiti v. Chancellor, Dr. N.T.R University of Health Sciences ((2009) 1 SCC 599) as supportive of a direction for revaluation in appropriate circumstances.

Respondents' Arguments (Central Board of Secondary Education)

  • There is no provision for revaluation under the Examination Bye-Laws. The relevant procedure is limited to verification as set out in Clauses 61(i) and 61(iv) of the Bye-Laws.
  • Valuation is carried out by a scientific method and according to a Marking Scheme which provides uniform standards, reduces subjectivity, and includes checks and cross-checks to eliminate human error; hence, a general revaluation is not warranted.
  • The only possible errors contemplated are minute tabulation errors, for which the bye-laws provide a rechecking mechanism rather than a revaluation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sahiti v. Chancellor, Dr. N.T.R University of Health Sciences ((2009) 1 SCC 599) The Apex Court upheld an order by the Vice Chancellor directing revaluation where such power was traceable to Ss. 12(2) and 12(3) of the University Act; demonstrates that revaluation directions can be upheld where statutory power exists. The Court distinguished Sahiti as factually and legally different because the power to order revaluation in Sahiti derived from specific statutory provisions of the University Act, which are not analogous to the Bye-Laws of the CBSE. Thus Sahiti did not support directing revaluation under the CBSE Bye-Laws.
Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Chairman, Bihar Public Service Commission (2004) 6 SCC 714 Where rules do not provide for re-evaluation of answer-books, a candidate has no right to claim re-evaluation; a court-ordered re-evaluation in such circumstances is improper and gives rise to practical problems. The Court relied on this principle to hold that in the absence of provision for revaluation in the CBSE Bye-Laws, the petitioner cannot claim revaluation as of right and the Court cannot direct it in a writ petition.
Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education v. Paritosh ((1984) 4 SCC 27 : AIR 1984 SC 1543) Establishes the proposition that where relevant rules do not permit re-evaluation, courts should not order re-evaluation; the absence of statutory or rule provision precludes a right to re-evaluation. The Court followed this dictum to reinforce that Clause 61(iv) and the Bye-Laws (which do not provide for revaluation) preclude directing revaluation in this petition.
Judgment of a Single Judge of this Court in O.P No. 22325/1999 The same CBSE Bye-Laws were considered and, following Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education, the petition to quash Clause 61(iv) was not allowed; no special reason existed for revaluation. The Court noted that this earlier decision of the same Court supports the position that the Bye-Laws do not permit revaluation and that a petition for such relief cannot be allowed absent special circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the governing Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Education, 1995, in particular Clauses 61(i) and 61(iv). Clause 61(i) permits a candidate to apply for verification of marks, which is expressly limited to checking that answers have been evaluated, that there has been no mistake in totalling marks for each question, that marks have been transferred correctly on the title page and award list, and that supplementary answer books are intact; it expressly states that "No revaluation of the answer book or supplementary answer book(s) shall be done." Clause 61(iv) states that "No candidate shall claim, or be entitled to, revaluation of his/her answers or disclosure or inspection of the answer book(s) or other documents."

The Court reviewed the CBSE's account of the valuation process (paras. 4–6 of the statement), which explained that evaluation is carried out according to a Marking Scheme designed to reduce subjectivity and to ensure uniform standards, with checks and cross-checks to minimize human error; accordingly, apart from tabulation errors, the Bye-Laws provide a verification mechanism and not a revaluation remedy.

The Court then relied on binding and persuasive authority establishing the legal principle that, in the absence of any rule or statutory provision for re-evaluation, candidates have no right to claim re-evaluation and courts should not order re-evaluation. The Court specifically invoked the decisions in Pramod Kumar Srivastava and Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education and noted a prior decision of this Court (O.P No. 22325/1999) applying the same principle to identical Bye-Laws.

The Court considered the petitioner's reliance on Sahiti (2009) but found it distinguishable: in Sahiti the authority to order revaluation was supported by specific statutory powers under Ss. 12(2) and 12(3) of the University Act. Because the CBSE Bye-Laws do not provide equivalent statutory power or a provision for revaluation, Sahiti could not be applied to justify ordering a revaluation in the present case.

Concluding its analysis, the Court held that, given the express terms of the Bye-Laws and the settled legal position, it could not direct a revaluation of the answer book. However, consistent with the Bye-Laws, the Court directed that if the petitioner files an application for verification of the Social Science answer book under Clause 61(i) within one month and attaches a copy of the judgment, the Board will consider the application and complete the verification expeditiously and communicate the result to the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The petitioner's prayer for revaluation of the Social Science answer book is not granted; the Writ Petition is DISPOSED OF as above.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Court refused to order revaluation because the Examination Bye-Laws do not provide for revaluation and relevant precedent establishes that courts should not direct revaluation where no rule or statutory provision exists.
  • The petitioner is permitted to apply for verification under Clause 61(i) of the Examination Bye-Laws of the CBSE within one month, attaching a copy of this judgment; the Board will consider and complete the verification and communicate the result expeditiously.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications:

  • The Court emphasized that the legal position is settled that in the absence of a provision for revaluation, courts will not direct revaluation; the decision adheres to established precedents and does not announce a new legal principle beyond applying those precedents to the facts of this petition.
Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. The whole question that is raised herein is whether the petitioner's request for revaluation of answer papers could be allowed.

2. She is a student in Std. XI at Kendriya Vidyalaya. She appeared for Std. X examination conducted by the third respondent with Roll No. 641116. She secured 470 out of 500 marks. For the subjects, namely, English Comm., Hindi Course-A, Mathematics and Science, she got aggregate of 96% and secured A1 grade. For the subject Social Science, the petitioner got only 86 marks and she was placed in Grade A2. This is clear from Ext. P1 marklist. According to her, she was expecting 98 marks in Social Science. A rechecking was sought which was also answered by Ext. P2 stating that there is no change in the mark already allotted to the petitioner. Exts. P3 to P12 are produced to show that she had an excellent track record in her class examinations etc. It shows that she had been securing an average of 98.3% marks throughout. Initially, she sought for supply of a photocopy of the answer book and answer key which was replied by Exts. P15 and P16 stating that the information sought for is exempted under S. 8(1)(e) of Right to Information Act. Again she sought verification of answer book which was also turned down by Ext. P 17 for the same reasons. The petitioner is relying upon Ext. P21, an order passed by the Central Information Commission wherein a direction was given to provide answer sheets to the appellant therein. Mainly, it is contended that the provisions in the bye-laws are arbitrary and discriminatory.

3. After hearing parties, this Court passed an interim order dated 2.11.2009 whereby the answer book which was brought before this Court by the learned counsel for the second respondent in a sealed cover was allowed to be verified by the petitioner along with the parents. It is submitted that the same has already been verified by her.

4. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner Shri V. Chitambaresh submitted that to maintain transparency, and to assuage the feelings of the student, a revaluation of the paper, could be directed by this Court. Reliance is placed on the decision of the Apex Court in Sahiti v. Chancellor, Dr. N.T.R University of Health Sciences ((2009) 1 SCC 599). It is further pointed out that as the student was having excellent performance throughout, really it is felt that proper valuation was not done. Therefore, to do complete justice to the student, a direction can be issued for revaluation of the answer book of Social Science.

5. The learned counsel for the Central Board of Secondary Education, Shri Devan Ramachandran relying upon the averments in the statement filed on behalf of respondent Nos. 2 to 4 submitted that there is no provision for revaluation under the bye-laws. The method for valuation of papers have been detailed in paragraph Nos. 4, 5 and 6. It is pointed out that the valuation of papers have been done in an extremely scientific manner and as per a Marking Scheme.

6. Paragraph Nos. 4,5 and 6 of the statement are extracted below:—

“4. Without prejudice to the above, it is submitted that the valuation of papers in the examination are done in an extremely scientific manner and as per a Marking Scheme. The Marking Scheme provides general guidelines to reduce subjectivity in the marking by the evaluations. The Scheme specifically provides that the answers given in the Marking Scheme are the suggested answers and that the content therein are thus indicators, and marks have to be strictly as per the scheme after assessing the answer of a student to verify if he or she has answered conveying the meaning of the answer indicated in the Marking Scheme. The Scheme specifically mandates that the evaluation has to be done as per the answers given in the scheme and that it should not be done according to one's own interpretation or other consideration.

5. This ensures that no evaluator values the answer scripts as per his/her subjective opinion but strictly in an objective manner in lines of the answers to each question provided in the Marking Scheme. The evaluation is thus done applying uniform standards with checks and cross checks at different stage and there are also measures for detection of malpractices etc. It is submitted that by employing such a strict Marking Scheme every endevour has been taken to eliminate the possibility of human error on the part of the evaluators.

6. It is submitted that in the above background the only minute chance of error could be in the tabulation part, redress for which is adequately addressed in the bye-laws by providing for a method of rechecking of the marks awarded.”

7. It is also stated in paragraph (9) that her answers to question Nos. 1 to 10 are as per the Scheme and she has, therefore, been granted full marks as per the Scheme for these answers. As regards questions 11 to 17,19 to 24 and 26 to 29 her answers do not tally totally to the answers in the Marking Scheme and as a consequence she has been awarded proportionate marks to the extent to which the answers tally with the Marking Scheme.

8. Evidently, the relevant clauses under the Examination Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Education, 1995 are Cls. 61 (i) and 61 (iv) which provides as follows:—

“A candidate who has appeared at an examination conducted by the Board may apply to the concerned Regional Officer of the Board for verification of marks in any particular subject. The verification will be restricted to checking whether all the answer's have been evaluated and that there has been no mistake in the totalling of marks for each question in that subject and that the marks have been transferred correctly on the title page of the answer book and to the award list and whether the supplementary answer book(s) attached with the answer book mentioned by the candidate are intact. No revaluation of the answer book or supplementary answer book(s) shall be done.”

9. Clause (iv) reads the following:—

“No candidate shall claim, or be entitled to, revaluation of his/her answers or disclosure or inspection of the answer book(s) or other documents.”

10. Therefore, revaluation of answer book or supplementary answer book(s) has not been provided.

11. The learned counsel for the C.B.S.E in this context placed reliance on the principles laid down in the decision of the Apex Court in Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Chairman, Bihar Public Service Commission, Patna (2004 (3) KLT SN 38 (C. No. 52) SC = (2004) 6 SCC 714) and that of a learned Single Judge of this Court in O.P No. 22325/1999. In Pramod Kumar Srivastava's case after relying on the Judgment in Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education v. Paritosh (1984 KLT SN 55 (C. No. 94) SC = (1984) 4 SCC 27 : AIR 1984 SC 1543), it was held as follows in paragraphs Nos. 7 and 8.

“In the absence of any provision for re-evaluation of answer-books in the relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to claim or ask for re-evaluation of his marks. In such a situation, the prayer made by the appellant in the Writ Petition was wholly untenable and the Single Judge had clearly erred in having the answer-book of the appellant re-evaluated. Adopting such a course will give rise to practical problems and in the larger interest, they must be avoided.”

12. This Court in the Judgment in O.P No. 22325/1999 considered the very same Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Examination and, following the dictum laid in Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education's case (1984 KLT SN 55 (C. No. 94) SC = (1984) 4 SCC 27 : AIR 1984 SC 1543), it was held that the petitioner's prayer for quashing Cl. 61(iv) of the Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Examination, 1990 cannot be allowed. Finally, it was observed that there is no special reason for revaluation of the answer sheet.

13. Therefore, the legal position is well settled that in the absence of the provision for revaluation, no candidate can claim revaluation of answer papers as of right and this Court will not be justified in issuing a direction as such in a Writ Petition. Herein, the relevant clauses of the Bye-Laws, as already noticed, do not provide any facility for revaluation. In that view of the matter, the prayer sought for by the petitioner to direct the C.B.S.E to revalue the answer book is not liable to be granted.

14. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner placed strong reliance on the decision of the Apex Court in Sahiti and Others's case ((2009) 1 SCC 599). The question considered therein was whether the order passed by the Vice Chancellor of NTR University of Health Sciences Act, 1986 directing revaluation was within his power conferred under Ss. 12(2) and 12(3) of the Act. Therein, the relevant provisions of the University Act which conferred certain powers to the Chancellor under which the Vice Chancellor ordered revaluation was considered elaborately. It was held that such powers are traceable to Ss. 12(2) and 12(3) of the Act. It is in that context, the Apex Court upheld the direction issued by the Vice Chancellor to conduct a revaluation. Here, the position is different. Therefore, the said dictum is clearly distinguishable. As far as the Bye-Laws are concerned, there is no provision for revaluation. Therefore, in the light of the decision of the Apex Court in Maharashtra S.B.O.S & H.S Education's case (1984 KLT SN 55 (C. No. 94) SC = (1984) 4 SCC 27 : AIR 1984 SC 1543), this Court will not be justified in directing a revaluation. What is provided under the relevant Bye-Laws is a facility for verification of marks. If the petitioner makes an application for verification of the answer book in respect of the subject Social Science, along with a copy of this Judgment, within one month under Cl. 61 (i) of the Examination Bye-Laws of the Central Board of Secondary Education, 1995 the same will be considered and after completing the same, the result will be communicated to the petitioner expeditiously.

15. The Writ Petition is disposed of as above. No costs.