- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Beena v. Balakrishnan Nair
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner challenged concurrent findings of the courts below that she had issued a cheque (Ext.P1) for Rs.1,00,000/- dated 22.10.2002 to respondent No.1 for discharge of a legally enforceable debt, and thereby committed an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The cheque was presented and dishonoured for insufficiency of funds on 18.11.2002 (proved by Exts.P2 and P3). Respondent No.1 issued a statutory notice on 27.11.2002, received by the petitioner on 30.11.2002 (Exts.P4–P6). A reply (Ext.P7/Ext.P6 depending on the record) was sent on behalf of the petitioner with differing accounts of the underlying transactions. Respondent No.1 gave evidence as PW1, asserting a loan of Rs.1,00,000/- and issuance of Ext.P1 to discharge that liability. When questioned under Section 313 of the Code, the petitioner offered varying defences, including that she did not know respondent No.1 and had no transaction with him, and alternative accounts involving loans from a third party (V.K. Rameshan) and blank cheques.
The learned magistrate convicted the petitioner, sentencing her to simple imprisonment for three months and directing payment of Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation (default six months' imprisonment). On appeal, the Additional Sessions Judge confirmed the substantive sentence and compensation but reduced the default sentence to three months. The petitioner filed this revision challenging conviction and/or sentence as excessive.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner issued the cheque (Ext.P1) for the discharge of a legally enforceable debt and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
- Whether the petitioner rebutted the statutory presumption under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
- Whether the sentence imposed by the courts below was excessive and required modification in the interests of justice.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Before the court under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the petitioner contended she had no transaction with respondent No.1 and that he was not known to her.
- Alternate account presented: she had borrowed Rs.15,000/- from one V.K. Rameshan and given two blank cheques as security; although she paid the principal, cheques were not returned and one was allegedly misused.
- In a reply (Ext.P7/Ext.P6), a different statement was made that she had borrowed Rs.28,000/- from respondent No.1 and given four signed blank cheques.
- Before the revisional court, learned counsel contended that the finding regarding execution of the cheque is incorrect and that the sentence awarded is excessive.
Respondent No.1's Arguments / Evidence
- Respondent No.1 stated that the petitioner borrowed Rs.1,00,000/- from him and issued Ext.P1 (cheque dated 22.10.2002) to discharge that liability.
- The cheque was presented and dishonoured for insufficiency of funds (Exts.P2 and P3).
- Statutory notice was issued and served on the petitioner (Exts.P4–P6), and the petitioner received the notice.
- Respondent No.1 gave evidence as PW1 and his testimony stood uncontradicted in material respects according to the courts below and this revisional court.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court observed that an accused may raise inconsistent or contradictory pleas, but inconsistency affects the accused's overall credibility. The court compared the petitioner's varying accounts:
- The petitioner asserted before the court that she did not know respondent No.1 and had no transaction with him.
- However, the reply recorded as Ext.P6 (sent on her behalf) admitted borrowing Rs.28,000/- from respondent No.1 and giving four signed blank cheques—this admission contradicted the claim that respondent No.1 was a stranger.
- The court found no evidence supporting the petitioner's alternate account involving V.K. Rameshan, nor evidence that Ext.P1 was given to Rameshan as security.
- Nothing in the record was held to displace or discredit the evidence of respondent No.1 (PW1) that the petitioner borrowed Rs.1,00,000/- and issued Ext.P1 to discharge that liability.
- On these factual findings, the courts below were justified in concluding that the petitioner issued the cheque for discharge of a legally enforceable debt and failed to rebut the statutory presumption under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
Regarding sentence, the revisional court considered the facts, circumstances and nature of the offence and concluded that the substantive sentence could be moderated from the prior orders while preserving a compensatory fine payable to the complainant. The court adjusted the mode and duration of imprisonment and fixed a time frame for payment of the fine.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: Revision allowed in part: the conviction of the petitioner is upheld, but the sentence is modified.
Direct consequences and orders made by the court:
- The conviction of the petitioner for the offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is maintained.
- Substantive sentence modified to simple imprisonment till rising of the court.
- The petitioner is sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.1,00,000/- in the trial court; in default of payment, she shall undergo simple imprisonment for three months.
- If the fine is realised, it shall be paid to respondent No.1 as compensation under Section 357(1) of the Code.
- The petitioner is granted three months' time to deposit the fine in the trial court, and she must appear in the trial court on 14.9.2009 to receive the sentence.
- Crl.M.A. No.5502 of 2009 is dismissed.
The opinion does not announce or rely upon any new legal precedent; the decision affirms the factual findings of the courts below and adjusts sentence in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction.
THOMAS P. JOSEPH, Judge.
Notice to respondent No.1 is dispensed with in view of the order I am proposing to make and which is not prejudicial to him. Public Prosecutor takes notice for respondent No.2.
2. Petitioner against whom the courts below entered a concurrent finding that she issued the cheque for Rs.1,00,000/- for the discharge of a legally enforceable debt/liability and thereby committed offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (for short, "the Act) has come up in revision.
3. According to respondent No.1, petitioner borrowed Rs.1,00,000/- from him and for the discharge of that liability issued Ext.P1, cheque dated 22.10.2002. That cheque on presentation was dishonoured for insufficiency of funds on 18.11.2002 as proved by Exts.P2 and P3. Thereon respondent No.1 issued statutory notice to the petitioner on 27.11.2002 which the petitioner received on 30.11.2002. Issue and service of notice are proved by Exts.P4 to P6. Petitioner sent Ext.P7, reply contending that she had borrowed only Rs.28,000/- from respondent No.1 and at that time had given four signed blank cheques. Respondent No.1 gave evidence as PW1 and testified to his case. He asserted that petitioner borrowed Rs.1,00,000/- from him and that for the Crl.R.P.No.1820/2009 discharge of that liability issued Ext.P1, cheque. When questioned under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, "the Code"), petitioner contended that she had no transaction with respondent No.1 and that he is not even known to her. According to the petitioner, she had borrowed Rs.15,000/- from one V.K.Rameshan and given two blank cheques as security. Though she paid the principal amount to V.K.Rameshan, cheques were not returned and one of those cheques was misused. It is contended by the learned counsel that the finding of the courts below regarding execution of the cheque is not correct.
4. It is true that it is open to an accused to raise inconsistent or contradictory pleas. But when appreciating the evidence that petitioner has no consistent case will also be relevant. In this case as against contention raised by the petitioner that she does not even know respondent No.1 and had no transaction with him, what is stated in Ext.P6, reply sent on her behalf is that she had borrowed Rs.28,000/- from respondent No.1 and given four signed blank cheques. Therefore contention of petitioner that respondent No.1 is a stranger to her and there is no transaction between them cannot be accepted. There is no evidence to show either that petitioner had any transaction with V.K.Rameshan or that as security Ext.P1, cheque was given. There is also no evidence to show that petitioner had borrowed Rs.28,000/- from respondent No.1. Nothing is brought out to disbelieve the evidence of respondent No.1. Courts below in the circumstances are justified in holding that the petitioner issued the cheque in question for the discharge of a legally enforceable debt/liability and that she failed to rebut the presumption under Section 139 of Crl.R.P.No.1820/2009 the Act. Hence conviction of the petitioner is legal and proper and required no interference.
5. Learned magistrate sentenced the petitioner to undergo simple imprisonment for three months and pay Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation. In default of payment of compensation, petitioner was directed to undergo simple imprisonment for six months. In appeal, learned Additional Sessions Judge confirmed the substantive sentence and the direction for payment of compensation but reduced the default sentence (six months) to three months. Learned counsel contends that the sentence awarded is excessive. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and the nature of offence committed, I am satisfied that simple imprisonment till rising of the court and fine of Rs.1,00,000/- is sufficient in the ends of justice. In case of non-payment of fine, petitioner shall undergo simple imprisonment for three months. Fine if realised shall be paid to respondent No.1 as compensation under Section 357(1) of the Code.
6. Learned counsel requested four months' time to deposit the fine in the trial court. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I am inclined to grant three months' time to the petitioner to deposit the fine.
Resultantly, this revision is allowed in part to the following extent:
i. Substantive sentence awarded to the petitioner is modified as simple imprisonment till rising of the court.
ii. Petitioner is sentenced to pay fine of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One lakh only) in the trial court and in default of payment to undergo simple Crl.R.P.No.1820/2009 imprisonment for three months. Fine if realised shall be given to respondent No.1 as compensation under Section 37591) of the Code.
iii. Petitioner is granted three months time to deposit the fine in the trial court.
iv. Petitioner shall appear in the trial court on 14.9.2009 to receive the sentence.
Crl.M.A.No.5502 of 2009 will stand dismissed.
THOMAS P.JOSEPH, Judge.
cks
Alert