- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
James K. Joseph v. Government Of India
Structured Summary of the Judgment
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, a retired member of the Indian Audit and Accounts Service who had served as Accountant General of Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Kerala and later as Joint Secretary (Establishment) in the Ministry of Personnel, applied on 23-8-2004 for appointment as an Administrative Member of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Ernakulam Bench, in response to vacancies notified for the period 1-1-2004 to 30-6-2004.
The Selection Committee initially recommended the petitioner and Sri N. Ramakrishnan, IAS. Sri N. Ramakrishnan was appointed. After an adverse Intelligence Bureau (IB) report concerning the petitioner’s antecedents was placed on file, the Selection Committee withdrew its earlier recommendation for the petitioner; the Chief Justice of India concurred and the appointing authority approved the withdrawal. The petitioner filed the present writ petition (under Article 226 seeking mandamus) on 6-6-2005 challenging the denial of appointment and alleging arbitrariness and discrimination violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The petitioner also sought to implead and challenge a later appointee (additional second respondent).
The first respondent (Union of India) denied that the Selection Committee had recommended the petitioner for appointment and contended that the petition rested on surmise; it also informed the court that the Union had appealed against a High Court decision in Kali Das Batish and that the Apex Court had stayed that judgment. The petitioner pursued Right to Information requests and produced correspondence and material (including Exts. P4–P13) alleging that the IB report and related notes were false and engineered by another officer, and that no enquiry had been held as claimed in the IB note.
After hearing arguments, the Court considered whether judicial review could be exercised to issue mandamus directing appointment in the face of the Selection Committee’s withdrawal (following IB inputs) and concurrence by the Chief Justice of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a candidate whose name was initially placed on the Selection Committee's recommendatory list acquires a right to appointment so as to sustain a writ in the nature of mandamus when the Selection Committee later withdraws the recommendation after receiving an adverse IB report and the Chief Justice of India concurs with the withdrawal.
- Whether a court can judicially review, and effectively sit in appeal over, the findings or inputs of the Intelligence Bureau and the consequent decision of the Selection Committee and the concurrence of the Chief Justice of India in matters of appointment to the CAT.
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to appointment on the basis of his contention that the IB report and related materials relied upon to withdraw the recommendation were factually incorrect or fabricated.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner submitted that he was eligible and qualified for appointment, having held posts equivalent to Joint Secretary and having substantial experience in that cadre.
- He contended that the Selection Committee had initially recommended him and that the Government was bound to appoint him to one of the vacancies.
- He alleged that the Intelligence Bureau report and the Joint Secretary's note (Ext. P10) contained false or engineered allegations (including reference to an adverse inquiry while he was Accountant General of Kerala), influenced by Sri K.J. Alphonse, IAS, and that Ext. P13 proved no such enquiry ever occurred.
- Relying on precedents (including State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai, S.R. Venkataraman, R.S. Mittal, Dr. A.K. Doshi), the petitioner argued that if administrative action was prompted by a mistaken belief in non-existing facts, the action was infected by abuse of power and could be set aside and remedied by appointment.
- He sought mandamus directing the Government to appoint him as Administrative Member of the CAT.
First Respondent's (Union of India) Arguments
- The first respondent disputed that the Selection Committee had finally recommended the petitioner for appointment and maintained that the petition was based on conjecture.
- It relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (2006) to contend that where the Chief Justice of India has been consulted and has concurred with the decision not to appoint (after consideration of relevant materials including IB reports), the matter is not amenable to judicial review and the courts should not sit in appeal over such decisions.
- The first respondent emphasized that the Selection Committee, after receiving the IB report, reconsidered and withdrew its earlier recommendation; the Chief Justice concurred and the appointing authority approved the withdrawal, placing the matter beyond judicial interference in the view urged by the respondent.
Additional Second Respondent's Arguments
- The counsel for the additional second respondent submitted that the second respondent had ceased to hold office and that any relief sought against her had become infructuous by efflux of time.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kali Das Batish v. Union of India, 2005 (1) SLR 412 (High Court of Himachal Pradesh) | The High Court had examined the IB report and held it to be without substance, directing fresh consideration where the ground for denial was proved to be non-est. | The petitioner relied on this High Court decision; the court noted that this decision was under challenge before the Apex Court and that the Apex Court later decided Union of India v. Kali Das Batish. The High Court decision was part of the factual matrix but the court treated the Apex decision as authoritative. |
| Union of India v. Kali Das Batish, (2006) 1 SCC 779 : AIR 2006 SC 789 | Held that the High Court cannot sit in appeal over the decision of the Government and the concurrence of the Chief Justice of India; stressed that consultation with the CJI under Sections 6–7 of the Administrative Tribunals Act is not a formality and that antecedent verification (e.g., IB reports) is a relevant and permissible ground for non-appointment; mere inclusion in select list does not confer a right to appointment. | The Court treated this Apex Court decision as controlling: it concluded that where the Selection Committee withdrew a recommendation after IB inputs and the Chief Justice of India concurred, courts should not sit in appeal over such decisions and judicial review is barred to the extent of reappraising the IB material or substituting the court's view for that of the Selection Committee/CJI. |
| Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597 | General principle concerning protection of fundamental rights and scope of judicial review (cited by petitioner). | Cited by the petitioner in support of his fundamental-rights based contention; the Court noted the reliance but applied more directly on appointment jurisprudence and subsequent authorities dealing with review of selection/appointment decisions. |
| E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, 1974 (1) SLR 497 SC | Principles on arbitrariness and equality under the Constitution (cited by petitioner). | Referenced by the petitioner; the Court considered it among authorities but declined to allow relief because appointment process here involved CJI concurrence and IB inputs as held by later Apex authorities. |
| Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India, (1979) 3 SCC 489 : AIR 1979 SC 1628 | Principles on selection processes and fairness in administrative decision-making (cited by petitioner). | Noted among petitioner's authorities; the Court relied on more specific appointment cases to resolve the matter and found them controlling. |
| State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai, AIR 1964 SC 1006 | High Court's power under Article 226 to grant consequential reliefs where a right has been infringed (cited by petitioner). | Quoted by the Court to describe the broad remedial powers of courts under Article 226; applied in evaluating petitioner's claim for consequential relief (appointment) but ultimately not permitting relief because of controlling appointment law. |
| S.R. Venkataraman v. Union of India, (1979) 2 SCC 491 : AIR 1979 SC 49 | Held that administrative orders based on a mistaken belief in non-existing facts are infected with abuse of power and can be set aside. | Relied upon by the petitioner to argue that a decision based on a non-existing fact (if proved) must be set aside; the Court analyzed this principle but distinguished the present context because the Selection Committee, after receiving IB inputs, reconsidered and the Chief Justice concurred. |
| R.S. Mittal v. Union of India, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 230 | Appointment authority cannot ignore select panel without justifiable reason; if no reason is given, interference may be warranted. | Cited by petitioner to contend that a justifiable reason was required to decline appointment; the Court noted the principle but found that here a reason (adverse IB report) was placed before the Selection Committee and Chief Justice and withdrawal was accordingly made. |
| Dr. A.K. Doshi v. Union of India, (2001) 4 SCC 43 | Whether the Appointments Committee can rely on materials not placed before the Selection Committee; held that additional material, if relevant and arising later, may be placed before the Appointments Committee but not otherwise interfere with the selection process. | Cited by the petitioner to argue wrongful reliance on materials; the Court considered the doctrine but emphasized that the IB report was a later-arising, relevant input which was placed before the Chief Justice and Selection Committee and acted upon in the prescribed consultative process. |
| K. Ashok Reddy v. Government of India, (1994) 2 SCC 303 | Recognized limits of judicial review; certain consultative processes (e.g., CJI's role) are an "inbuilt check" against arbitrariness and may be immune from judicial review on grounds of bias/arbitrariness. | Relied upon to support the view that consultation with the Chief Justice of India is an inbuilt safeguard and that courts should not ordinarily substitute their view for that of CJI/Selection Committee in appointment matters to the CAT. |
| Delhi Administration v. Sushil Kumar | Emphasized verification of character and antecedents as a valid criterion in appointments (even for police constables), illustrating the legitimacy of antecedent verification. | Used by the Apex Court in Kali Das Batish and cited in this judgment to show that antecedent verification is a legitimate and important criterion; the present Court invoked the same logic to validate IB inquiries as relevant in appointments to sensitive posts. |
| National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences v. Dr. K. Kalyana Raman, 1992 Supp (2) SCC 481 : AIR 1992 SC 1806 | Function of Selection Committee is administrative (not judicial); Selection Committees are not always required to record reasons in absence of statutory requirement. | The Court relied on this authority to note that the Selection Committee was not obliged to record reasons for non-selection in the absence of a rule or regulation and that the Committee's administrative decision (including withdrawal after IB input) could not lightly be treated as vulnerable to judicial substitution. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by summarizing the factual matrix: the Selection Committee had initially recommended the petitioner, the petitioner’s case was referred to the Intelligence Bureau because he had taken voluntary retirement (necessitating antecedent verification), and the IB returned a note (17-12-2004) containing adverse inputs including a reference to an unfavourable inquiry while the petitioner was Accountant General of Kerala. On receipt of the IB report, the Joint Secretary prepared Ext. P10, the matter was placed before the Selection Committee as directed by the Chief Justice of India, the Selection Committee withdrew its earlier recommendation, the Chief Justice of India concurred, and the appointing authority approved the withdrawal.
The Court then examined the legal authorities cited by both sides. It reviewed authorities relied on by the petitioner which support relief where administrative action is based on a mistaken belief in non-existing facts (e.g., S.R. Venkataraman) and cases which constrain arbitrary non-appointment where no justification is given (e.g., R.S. Mittal, Dr. A.K. Doshi).
However, the Court considered the Apex Court's decision in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish to be directly on point and controlling. That decision holds, inter alia, that:
- consultation with the Chief Justice of India under Sections 6 and 7 of the Administrative Tribunals Act is not a formality but an effective consultative safeguard to ensure suitability for judicial office;
- the antecedent verification by agencies such as the IB is a legitimate and important criterion in appointment to sensitive judicial/tribunal posts;
- the High Court cannot sit in appeal over the Government's decision or over the Chief Justice of India's concurrence by attempting to disprove IB inputs; and
- mere inclusion in a select list confers no vested right to appointment.
Applying these principles, this Court reasoned that because the Selection Committee reconsidered after receiving the IB report, withdrew the recommendation, and the Chief Justice of India concurred with that withdrawal (and the appointing authority approved), the matter fell squarely within the ambit of Kali Das Batish. The Court concluded that it could not reappraise the IB material, sit in appeal over the Selection Committee’s reconsideration or over the concurrence of the Chief Justice of India, or substitute its own judgment for the consultative process mandated by the law.
The Court also observed that Selection Committees perform administrative functions and are not required to record reasons for selection or non-selection in the absence of any statutory requirement (citing National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences v. Dr. K. Kalyana Raman), so the absence of a formal reasons memorandum did not of itself establish arbitrariness here.
Confronted with the petitioner’s evidence (Ext. P13 and related material) disputing the IB findings, the Court nevertheless held that the approach of re-examining IB material was barred by binding authority. Because the procedural consultative safeguards (placement of materials before the Chief Justice and the Selection Committee’s reconsideration) were followed, this Court declined to exercise judicial review to direct appointment.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is dismissed. The Court held that the petitioner is not entitled to the reliefs prayed for and refused to issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the Government to appoint him as an Administrative Member of the CAT.
DISPOSED OF
Direct Consequences for the Parties
- The Writ Petition fails and is dismissed; the petitioner will not be appointed pursuant to this proceeding.
- No costs were awarded by the Court.
- Relief sought against the additional second respondent was noted as infructuous as she had ceased to hold office (as argued by her counsel).
Broader Implications and Legal Principles Affirmed
- The judgment reaffirms the Apex Court's principle that consultation with the Chief Justice of India under Sections 6 and 7 of the Administrative Tribunals Act is a substantive safeguard and not a mere formality; such concurrence limits the scope of judicial re-examination of appointment decisions for CAT membership.
- The Court adopted the principle that antecedent verification (including IB reports) is a legitimate criterion for appointments to sensitive judicial/tribunal posts and that courts should not sit in appeal over such materials where the consultative process has been followed.
- The decision reiterates that mere inclusion of a name in a Selection Committee's list does not confer a vested right to appointment; hence, presence on a select list alone does not sustain a writ for mandamus to appoint.
- The Court emphasized that Selection Committees perform administrative functions and are not required to record reasons for non-selection in the absence of statutory obligation, limiting judicial intrusion into such administrative choices when proper consultative steps have been taken.
This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided opinion and does not include information beyond that source.
JUDGMENT
1. In this Writ Petition, the petitioner seeks a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the first respondent to appoint him as Administrative Member in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench. The brief facts of the case are as follows:
2. The petitioner was a member of the Indian Audit and Accounts Service. During the period from 1988 to 1995 he was the Accountant General for the State of Maharashtra, the State of Tamil Nadu and the State of Kerala. Later, during the period 1995–1996 he was Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Personnel of the Government of India. While the petitioner was holding office as Joint Secretary (Establishment) in the Ministry of Personnel of the Government of India, he took voluntary retirement from service. Thereafter, he had also served as the Managing Director of the Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation and the Kerala State Road Transport Corporation. Three vacancies of Administrative Member in the Central Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the CAT for short) arose during the period from 1-1-2004 to 30-6-2004. The Government of India notified the vacancies and invited applications from eligible candidates. The petitioner applied for appointment as Administrative Member in the CAT by submitting Ext. P1 application dated 23-8-2004 to the Joint Secretary (Administration), Ministry of Personnel, Government of India. The petitioner states that the post of Accountant General is a post equated to the post of Joint Secretary to Government of India and that only civil servants, who are consistent and outstanding in their performance are posted as Joint Secretary to Government of India. According to him,” he had 8 years of experience in the category of Joint Secretary and was therefore eligible and qualified to be appointed as Administrative Member in the CAT.
3. The Selection Committee constituted by the Government of India in terms of Order No. A-1013/54/90-At dated 15-4-1991 and 23-4-1991 considered the applications received from various candidates and recommended the names of the petitioner and Sri. N. Ramakrishnan, IAS for appointment as Administrative Members in the CAT. Sri. N. Ramakrishnan, IAS was appointed as Administrative Member in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. Since the petitioner was not appointed, he filed this Writ Petition on 6-6-2005, joining the Government of India represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Personnel as the sole respondent, contending that as the Selection Committee has recommended his name, the action of the Government of India in denying appointment to him is arbitrary and discriminatory and violative of the fundamental rights guaranteed to him under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. He has further contended that two vacancies of Administrative Members existed in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench, that Sri. N. Ramakrishnan IAS, one among the two persons recommended by the Selection Committee for appointment against the said vacancies was appointed and that as per the norms, the Government of India is bound to appoint him as Administrative Member in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. The petitioner has in the Writ Petition placed reliance on the decision of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Kali Das Batish v. Union of India, 2005 (1) SLR 412 and the decisions of the Apex Court in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597, E.P Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, 1974 (1) SLR 497 SC and Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. The International Airport Authority of India-, (1979) 3 SCC 489 : AIR 1979 SC 1628 relied on by the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in support of his contentions. In the Writ Petition as filed, the petitioner had prayed for a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the Government of India to appoint him as Administrative Member in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. After the Writ Petition was filed, Smt. Sathi Nair, the additional second respondent in the Writ Petition was appointed as Vice Chairman of the CAT by Ext. R2(a) order dated 22-10-2003 and posted in the Chennai Bench. Later, by Ext. R2(b) order dated 3-6-2005, she was transferred to the Ernakulam Bench. The petitioner thereupon filed LA. No. 93 of 2006 to implead her as the additional second respondent in the Writ Petition and LA. No. 2831 of 2006 to amend the Writ Petition by incorporating a prayer to quash the appointment of the additional second respondent as Administrative Member of the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. Both the applications have been allowed.
4. The first respondent has filed a counter affidavit denying and disputing petitioner's averment that the Selection Committee had recommended him along with Sri. N. Ramakrishnan, IAS for appointment as Administrative Member in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. The first respondent has also raised a contention that the Writ Petition is based on surmises and conjectures and that the allegations in the Writ Petition are baseless and are not tenable. It is also stated that the Union of India has filed an appeal before the Apex Court, challenging the correctness of the decision of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Kali Das Batish v. Union of India, 2005 (1) SLR 412, that the judgment of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh has been stayed by the Apex Court and that a final verdict in the matter is awaited.
5. The petitioner has filed a reply affidavit dated 3-7-2005 and an additional reply affidavit dated 16-7-2008. In the reply affidavit dated 3-7-2005, the petitioner has stated that he had applied to the Central Public Information Officer (Administrative Tribunal) to disclose the reason for which he was denied appointment, that in Ext. P4 letter dated 22-11-2005 the Central Public Information Officer (Administrative Tribunal) informed him that the Selection Committee had not finally recommended him for appointment as Administrative Member in the CAT, that as the answer contained in Ext. P4 was vague, he had sent Ext. P5 letter dated 23-8-2006 to the Central Public Information Officer (Administrative Tribunal) requesting him to give the specific reason for denying him appointment, that in Ext. P6 reply dated 8-9-2006, the Central Public Information Officer (Administrative Tribunal) informed him that he Was initially recommended by the Selection Committee for appointment as Administrative Member, that after receipt of the verification report on his character and antecedents, the matter was resubmitted for consideration by the Selection Committee and that as the report was adverse to him, the Selection Committee withdrew their earlier recommendation to appoint him and that the recommendation of the Selection Committee to withdraw their earlier recommendation to appoint him as Administrative Member was concurred with by the Honourable the Chief Justice of India and approved by the appointing authority. The petitioner has further stated in the reply affidavit dated 3-7-2005 that though he had submitted Ext. P7 appeal against Ext. P6, it was turned down by Ext. P8, that he thereupon submitted Ext. P9 appeal to the Central Information Commission and that till date, the appeal has not been disposed of or the information sought made available to him under the Right to Information Act, 2005.
6. In the additional reply affidavit dated 16-7-2008, the petitioner has averred that though the report of the Intelligence Bureau was not furnished to him, it was furnished to Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad, an Advocate practising in the High Court of Jharkhand who was also denied appointment as Judicial Member of the CAT. A copy of the letter sent by the Central Public Information Officer (Administrative Tribunal) to Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad together with the relevant portions of the files is produced and marked as Ext. P10. In Ext. P10, it is stated that while the petitioner was the Accountant General of Kerala, he had to face an enquiry in connection with the recruitment of contingency staff from among the relatives of Class IV staff in the office of the Accountant General and that as the report of enquiry was not favourable to him, he proceeded on voluntary retirement. The petitioner submits that there is no truth in the allegations levelled against him in Ext. P10 and that the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau was false. He relies on Ext. P13 letter dated 26-6-2008 sent by the Central Public Information Officer in the Office of the Comptroller & Auditor General of India to contend that no enquiry whatsoever was held in connection with the recruitment of contingency staff in the office of the Accountant General of Kerala and that the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau was one engineered by Sri. K.J Alphonse, IAS, with whom he was not on good terms. The petitioner also submits that as the Managing Trustee of Resurgent Educational and Charitable Trust he had sacked its Director Sri. K.J Roy, brother of Sri. K.J Alphonse, IAS for indulging in corrupt practices and that it infuriated and prompted Sri. K.J Alphonse to engineer the submission of a false report by the Intelligence Bureau.
7. I have heard Sri. S. Kalyanam, the learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioner, Sri. P. Parameswaran Nair, the learned Assistant Solicitor General of India appearing for the first respondent and Sri. S. Radhakrishnan Nair, the learned counsel appearing for the additional second respondent. The learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioner, relying on Ext. P13 letter submitted that the information which led to the petitioner's disqualification, is not correct and that the Intelligence Bureau had at the instigation of Sri. K.J Alphonse, IAS, filed a false report as regards the petitioner's character and antecedents on extraneous considerations and without verifying the facts, solely with a view to deny him appointment as Administrative Member in the CAT. The learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioner contended that as it is now evident that the note submitted by the Joint Secretary did not reflect the true state of affairs and as Ext. P13 proves that there was no enquiry against the petitioner as reported by the Intelligence Bureau, the Government of India is bound to reconsider its earlier decision and to appoint the petitioner as Administrative Member of the CAT. The learned Senior Advocate contended that it was at the intervention of Sri. K.J Alphonse, IAS, who is named in Ext. P10 itself that a false report about the character and antecedents of the petitioner was submitted by the Intelligence Bureau and that as no enquiry as reported by the Intelligence Bureau was ever held against the petitioner, the injustice meted out to the petitioner has to be remedied by this Court. He contended that as the decision taken by the first respondent not to appoint the petitioner was prompted by a mistaken belief as regards the existence of a non-existing fact or circumstance, the decision is un reasonable and that such a decision which is based on reasons of fact which did not exist has therefore to be held to be an abuse of power. The learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioner, relying on the decisions of the Apex Court in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai, AIR 1964 SC 1006, S.R Venkataraman v. Union of India, (1979) 2 SCC 491 : AIR 1979 SC 49, R.S Mittal v. Union Of India., 1995 Supp (2) SCC 230 and Dr. Dr. A.K Doshi v. Union Of India., (2001) 4 SCC 43 contended that as the petitioner has demonstrated that the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau was based on a non-existing fact, the decision taken by the first respondent not to appoint him, is liable to be set aside and the petitioner is entitled to be appointed.
8. Per contra, the learned Assistant Solicitor General appearing the first respondent contended that as the Selection Committee chaired by a Sitting Judge of the Honourable the Supreme Court of India had withdrawn their earlier recommendation to appoint the petitioner and as the Honourable the Chief Justice of India had concurred with the decision of the Selection Committee and the appointing authority had accepted it, the petitioner cannot challenge his non-selection and seek a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the Government of India to appoint him as Administrative Member in the CAT. He also relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish, (2006) 1 SCC 779 : AIR 2006 SC 789 to contend that the decision taken by the Selection Committee to withdraw their earlier recommendation and the decision taken by the appointing authority not to appoint the petitioner are not justiciable and that this Court cannot therefore exercise the power of judicial review and issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the first respondent to appoint the petitioner as Administrative Member in the CAT. The learned counsel appearing for the additional second respondent submitted that the second respondent has ceased to hold office and that the relief prayed for against the second respondent has become infructuous by efflux of time.
9. I have considered the submissions made at the Bar by the learned counsel appearing on either side. Shorn off details, the petitioner's contention is that the Selection Committee which had initially recommended him for appointment as Administrative Member in the CAT withdrew their recommendation on the basis of a false report filed by the Intelligence Bureau which was furnished to them by the Joint Secretary (AT) along with Ext. P10 note and therefore the petitioner is entitled to be appointed as Administrative Member in the CAT. Since the controversy centres round the correctness of the statements in Ext. P10, the relevant portions thereof are extracted below:
“Joint Secretary (AT)
In its meeting held on 11-10-04, the Selection Committee for Vice-Chairman/Members of the Central Administrative Tribunal, recommended three persons for appointment as Administrative Member and three persons for appointment as Judicial Member. The Committee also recommended one candidate to be placed on the Waiting List for Administrative Member and one candidate to be placed on the Waiting List for Judicial Member.
2. After seeking approval of MOS (PP) and concurrence of the Chief Justice of India, proposals for the appointment of three Judicial Members and one Waiting List Judicial Member and for the appointment of two Administrative Members and one Waiting List Administrative Member have been forwarded to the ACC. One case of Administrative Member has been under process because a reference was made to the Intelligence Bureau.
3. The IB inquiry process is normally used only in the cases of Members of the Bar who are being considered for posting as Judicial Members. Such IB inquiry is not asked for in the cases of Administrative Members, or of officers of the Judicial Services being considered for Judicial Member because all such persons would have a service record, ACRs etc. The case of Shri James K. Joseph, IA & AS (Retd.) was however referred to the IB because Shri Joseph had taken voluntary retirement from service in May, 1996. Given the long period that elapsed from his retirement and the absence of vigilance status, ACR dossier, etc. orders of MOS (PP) were obtained in 18-10-04 and the case referred to IB.
4. The IB's comments have been received in note of 17-12-04. The report makes mixed reading. There are references to Shri Joseph's association with the BJP, though having retired from Government service, Shri James K. Joseph is free to take part in political activities. There is also a reference to an ongoing feud between him and Shri K.J Alphonse, IAS, on a matter related to the Resurgent Kerala Educational and Charitable Trust, Trivandrum. It should be noted that we have independently received various documents from Shri K.J Alphonse related to the same matter. It should also be noted that while the complaints against Shri James K. Joseph are serious, Shri K.J Alphonse himself is highly controversial and no judgment can be passed in the matter without a better knowledge of the facts.
5. There is yet another issue mentioned in the IB report which is probably more serious. It is stated that during his posting as Accountant General, Kerala, Shri Joseph had faced an inquiry in connection with recruitment of some contingency staff from amongst relatives of Class IV staff of the AG Office. The IB report clearly states that the inquiry report in the matter was unfavourable and that Shri Joseph had consequently proceeded on voluntary retirement.
6. In my view, this is a fairly serious complaint. We do not have details of inquiry report with us, but I do not also think it is worthwhile to make inquiries from the AG's office at this stage. Given the information revealed by the IB report, it seems fairly clear that Shri James K. Joseph's general reputation is somewhat controversial. In the circumstances, it is recommended that we do not accept the recommendation of the Selection Committee. It should be made clear that the facts brought out by IB were not brought to the attention of the Selection Committee which had before it only a simple CV of Shri James K. Joseph.
7. We may accordingly seek orders of MOS(PP) to reject the recommendation of the Selection Committee. Since the proposal to appoint the two other Admn. Member and a Waiting List candidate is already in ACC, there should be no difficulty about filling the vacancy with the Waiting List candidate.”
10. The pleadings and the materials on record disclose that the Selection Committee that met on 11-10-2004 had recommended the name of the petitioner for appointment as Administrative Member of the CAT, that as the petitioner had retired from service in May, 1996 his case was referred to the intelligence Bureau for verification of character and antecedents and that the Intelligence Bureau had in its note dated 17-12-2004 reported that while the petitioner was the Accountant General of Kerala, he had faced an enquiry in connection with the recruitment of contingency staff from amongst the relatives of Class IV staff of the Accountant General's office, that the report of enquiry was unfavourable to the petitioner and consequently he proceeded on voluntary retirement. After the report of the Intelligence Bureau was received, the Joint Secretary (AT) prepared the note evidenced by Ext. P10 which I have extracted above on 24-12-2004. Thereafter, as can be seen from Ext. P6, the file was placed before the Selection Committee as directed by the Honourable the Chief Justice of India and in view of the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau, the Selection Committee withdrew their earlier recommendation to appoint the petitioner as Administrative Member of the CAT. Ext. P6 also discloses that the recommendation of the Selection Committee to withdraw their earlier recommendation to appoint the petitioner as Administrative Member in the CAT, was concurred with by the Honourable the Chief Justice of India and approved by the appointing authority. It is in this background that this Court has to consider whether the petitioner is entitled to seek a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the first respondent to appoint him as Administrative Member in the CAT.
11. I shall now refer to the decisions or the Apex Court relied on by the learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioner. In State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai (supra) a Constitution Bench of the Apex Court considered the question whether the High Court has power under Article 226 of the Constitution to order refund of tax which was illegally collected. It was held that if a right has been infringed - whether fundamental right or statutory right - and the aggrieved party comes to the court for enforcement of the right, it will not be giving complete relief if the court merely declares the existence of such right or the fact that the existing right has been infringed. The Apex Court also held that where there has been only a threat to infringe the right, an order commanding the Government or other statutory authority not to take the action contemplated would be sufficient and that where the right has been actually invaded, the High Courts have the power to give consequential reliefs for the purpose of enforcement of fundamental rights and statutory rights. In S.R Venkataraman v. Union of India (supra), the Apex Court was dealing with the case of a public servant ordered to be retired prematurely in public interest. Taking note of the admitted fact that there was nothing on record which would justify an order prematurely retiring the appellant from service, the Apex Court held that when a public body is prompted by a mistaken belief in the existence of a non-existing fact or circumstance, there would be an error of fact and that what is done under a mistaken belief, might almost be said to have been done in bad faith. It was held that an administrative order which is based on reasons of fact which do not exist must therefore be held to be infected with an abuse of power.
12. In R.S Mittal v. Union Of India. (supra), the Apex Court while considering the question whether the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet was entitled to deviate from the recommendation made by the Selection Board, held that though a person on the select panel has no vested right to be appointed to the post for which he has been selected, the appointing authority cannot ignore the select panel or act on its whims. It was held that when a person has been selected by the Selection Board and there is a vacancy which can be offered to him, keeping in view his merit position, then there is no justification to ignore him for appointment and that there has to be a justifiable reason to decline to appoint a person, who is on the select panel. On the facts of the case, the Apex Court held that no reason whatsoever, not to talk of a justifiable reason has been given as to why the appointments were not offered to the candidates recommended by the Selection Board and accordingly directed the recommendations of the Selection Board to be placed before the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. In Dr. Dr. A.K Doshi v. Union Of India. (supra), the Apex Court considered the question whether it was open to the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet to rely on materials which had not been placed before the Selection Committee to deny appointments to candidates recommended by the Selection Committee. The Apex Court held that after the Selection Committee which makes the selection recommends one or more names for appointment, the recommendation along with the materials considered by the Selection Committee should be placed before the Appointments Committee without further addition or alteration and that if in an exceptional case the Appointments Committee feels that certain material which was not available to be considered by the Selection Committee has come into existence in the meantime and the material is relevant for the purpose of appointment, then the matter should be placed before the Appointments Committee with the additional material for its consideration. The Apex Court held that the action of the Appointments Committee in not appointing candidates recommended by the Selection Committee and in appointing a person in the reserve panel, amounted to interference with the process of selection and that the Appointments Committee has attempted to set at naught the selection.
13. An issue similar to the one involved in the case on hand arose before the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra), referred to and relied on by the learned Assistant Solicitor General appearing for the first respondent. The Government of India had invited applications to fill up 7 vacancies of Judicial Members and 3 vacancies of Administrative Members in the CAT for the period from 1-7-2001 to 31-12-2001. Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad, two practicing Advocates applied for appointment as Judicial Members in the CAT. The Selection Committee chaired by a Sitting Judge of the Apex Court that met on 18-7-2001, considered the names of 121 persons for selection to the aforesaid vacancies and recommended the names of 7 persons including Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad for appointment as Judicial Members of the CAT. In accordance with the established procedure, their antecedents were got verified through the Intelligence Bureau. The report of the Intelligence Bureau was not favourable to Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad and therefore the Government of India decided that it would not be desirable to appoint them as Judicial Members of the CAT. The Government also proposed to appoint two among the candidates in the waiting list in the place of Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad. The concurrence of the Honourable the Chief Justice of India was thereupon sought. The Honourable the Chief Justice of India concurred with the proposal of the Government of India and therefore, Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad were not appointed.
14. Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad thereupon filed a Writ Petition in the High Court of Jharkhand challenging the action of the Union of India in not appointing him as Judicial Member and also sought a direction to the Central Government to appoint him as he was included in the select list. The High Court of Jharkhand held that the mere inclusion of the name of a candidate in the select list does not confer on him a right to be appointed to the post and that in the matter of appointment to a Judicial post, the appointing authority had not only the right, but also a duty to verify the character and antecedents of the candidates on the basis of the report and inputs from the Intelligence Bureau and that it was open to the appointing authority not to appoint any person included in the list prepared by the Selection Committee. The High Court of Jharkhand also held that exclusion of the name of Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad on the basis of the report of the Intelligence Bureau, which Was made available to the Honourable the Chief Justice of India and whose concurrence to the proposal was obtained by the Government of India after apprising the Honourable the Chief Justice of India of all the relevant facts, left no scope for judicial review. The Writ Petition was accordingly dismissed. Though Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad attempted to seek a review of the judgment, the review petition was also dismissed. He thereupon moved the Apex Court in appeal.
15. Sri. Kali Das Batish had also likewise filed a Writ Petition in the High Court of Himachal Pradesh. The High Court of Himachal Pradesh proceeded to examine the correctness of the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau and held that the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau as regards his performance as a Lawyer, was without substance. The High Court of Himachal Pradesh held that as the ground on which the petitioner was denied appointment has been proved to be non-est, he is entitled to have his case considered afresh without reference to the report submitted by the intelligence Bureau. The Writ Petition was accordingly allowed and the Government of India was directed to consider his case afresh and to appoint him against vacancies if any available or against the next arising vacancy [vide Kali Das Batish v. Union of India, 2005 (1) SLR 412.] The Union of India challenged the judgment of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in the Apex Court joining Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad as respondents in the appeal. The appeals filed by Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad and Union of India were heard together by the Apex Court. It was argued on behalf of Union of India before the Apex Court that the High Court of Himachal Pradesh exceeded its power of judicial review and erred in interfering with the decision of the Union of India and the appointing authority not to appoint Sri. Kali Das Batish as Judicial Member of the CAT. It was argued that the High Court of Himachal Pradesh failed to bear in mind the fact that the proposal to appoint the candidates along with all the relevant papers including the report of the Intelligence Bureau had been forwarded to the Honourable the Chief Justice of India for his concurrence and that the Honourable the Chief Justice of India had after consideration of all the materials concurred with the proposal of the Government of India to appoint candidates other than Sri. Kali Das Batish and Sri. Ram Kishore Prasad as indicated in the proposal submitted by the Government of India. Accepting the contentions of the Union of India, the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) held as follows:
“10. The Union of India has challenged the judgment of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh in CWP No. 812/2003 by its Civil Appeal No. 6663/2004 in which K.D Batish and Ram Kishore Prasad are the First and Second Respondents, respectively. Ram Kishore Prasad was a Respondent in the writ petition before the Himachal Pradesh High Court and, therefore, appears to have been made a Respondent in this case also..
11. The learned Solicitor General made a frontal attack on the judgment of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh contending that the High Court has far exceeded its powers of judicial review and grievously erred in interfering with the decision of the Union of India and the appointing authority not to appoint the First and Seconds Respondents to the posts of Judicial Members of the CAT, after obtaining the concurrence of the Chief Justice of India. He also contends that the High Court erred in adopting the extraordinary procedure of calling for an affidavit of the Registrar General to be filed on the basis of instructions obtained from Justice Khurana of the same High Court to be used as substantive evidence in the decision of the said writ petition, though the High Court itself was aware that it was an “unusual procedure.”
12. The learned Solicitor General further contends that the High Court singularly failed to keep in mind the scope of Sections 6 and 7 of the Act, that along with the proposal for appointment of the candidates all the relevant papers, including the IB report, had been forwarded to the Chief Justice of India for his concurrence, and that, after consideration of all the material, the Chief Justice of India had concurred with the proposal of the Government of India for the appointment of the candidates as indicated in the proposal.
13. There is merit in the submissions of the ld. Solicitor General. It appears that the High Court has acted in the matter as if dealing with an appointment made by an executive officer. It must be remembered that, the CAT is a Tribunal constituted under Article 323-A of the Constitution and is expected to have the same jurisdiction as that of a High Court. Consequently, Parliament has taken great care to enact, vide Sections 6 and 7 of the Act, that no appointment of a person possessing the qualifications prescribed in the Act as a Member shall be made, except after consultation with the Chief Justice of India. The consultation with the Chief Justice of India is neither a routine matter, nor an idle formality. It must be remembered that, a member of an Administrative Tribunal like the CAT exercises vast judicial powers, and such member must be ensured absolute judicial independence, free from influences of any kind likely to interfere with independent judicial functioning or militate thereagainst. It is for this reason, that a policy decision had been taken by the Government of India that while considering Members of the Bar for appointment to such a post, their antecedents have to be verified by the IB. The antecedents would include various facts, like association with anti-social elements, unlawful organizations, political affiliations, integrity of conduct and moral uprightness. All these factors have necessarily to be verified before a decision is taken by the appointing authority to appoint a candidate to a sensitive post like Member of the CAT. In Delhi Administration v. Sushil Kumar this Court emphasized that even for the appointment of a Constable in Police Services, verification of character and antecedents is one of the important criteria to test whether the selected candidate is suitable to a post under the State. Even if such candidate was found physically fit, had passed the written test and interview and was provisionally selected, if on account of his antecedent record, the appointing authority found it not desirable to appoint a person of such record as a Constable, the view taken by the appointing authority could not be said to be unwarranted, nor could it be interdicted in judicial review. These are observations made in the case of a Constable, they would apply with greater vigour in the case of appointment of a Judicial Member of the CAT. It is for this precise reason, that sub-section (7) to Section 6 of the Act requires that, the appointment of a Member of the CAT cannot be made “except after consultation with the Chief Justice of India”. This consultation should, of course, be an effective consultation after all necessary papers are laid before the Chief Justice of India, and is the virtual guarantee for appointment of absolutely suitable candidates to the post.
14. Unfortunately, the High Court seems to have proceeded on the footing that the appointment was being made on its own by the Central Government and that there was an irregular procedure followed by the Secretary by giving undue importance to the 1B report. It was most irregular on the part of the High Court to have sat in appeal over the issues raised in the IB report and attempted to disprove it by taking affidavits and the oral statement of the Advocate General at the Bar. We strongly disapprove of such action on the part of the High Court, particularly when it was pointed out to the High Court that, along with the proposals made by the Government, the Minister of State had specifically directed for submission of the IB report to the Chief Justice of India for seeking his concurrence, and that this was done. We note with regret that the High Court virtually sat in appeal, not only over the decision taken by the Government of India, but also over the decision taken by the Chief Justice of India, which it discarded by a side wind. In our view, the High Court seriously erred in doing so. Even assuming that the Secretary of the concerned department of the Government of India had not apprised himself of all necessary facts, one cannot assume or impute to a high constitutional authority, like the Chief Justice of India, such procedural or substantive error. The argument made at the Bar that the Chief Justice of India might not have been supplied with the necessary inputs has no merit. If Parliament has reposed faith in the Chief Justice of India as the paterfamilias of the judicial hierarchy in this Country, it is not open for anyone to contend that the Chief Justice of India might have given his concurrence without application of mind or without calling for the necessary inputs. The argument, to say the least, deserves summary dismissal.”
16. In Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) the Apex Court held that it is not open to the High Court to sit in appeal not only Over the decision of the Government of India, but also the decision taken by the Honourable the Chief Justice of India by attempting to disprove the issues raised by the Intelligence Bureau. The Apex Court approved the reasoning of the High Court of Jharkhand that when the decision to appoint or not to appoint a candidate as Judicial Member of the CAT has been made with the concurrence of the Honourable the Chief Justice of India, there is no scope for judicial review. The Apex Court also cautioned that the courts exercising the power of judicial review shall keep in mind the recognised limit, albeit self-recognised, to the exercise of such power, which was highlighted by the Apex Court in K. Ashok Reddy v. The Government of India, (1994) 2 SCC 303. In K. Ashok Reddy v. The Government of India (supra) the Apex Court accepted the principle that reviewability of discretionary power would depend on the subject matter and held that the transfer of a Judge of the High Court based on the recommendation of the Chief Justice of India would be immune from judicial review as there is “an inbuilt check against arbitrariness and bias indicating absence of need for judicial review on those grounds.” The Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) also held that the mere inclusion of the name of a candidate in the select list gives him no right to be appointed and that if there was no right, there could be no occasion to maintain a writ petition for the enforcement of a non-existing right. The issue raised in the case on hand is in my opinion, covered against the petitioner by the decision of the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra). The pleadings and the materials in the case on hand disclose that though the Selection Committee had initially recommended the name of the petitioner for appointment as Administrative Member of the CAT, after the report from the Intelligence Bureau which contained adverse remarks about him was received, the matter was placed before the Honourable the Chief Justice of India, who in turn, placed the matter before the Selection Committee. The Selection Committee considered the matter and decided to withdraw their earlier recommendation. The Honourable the Chief Justice of India concurred with the decision of the Selection Committee to withdraw their earlier recommendation and the appointing authority also concurred with it. The petitioner was therefore not appointed though Sri. N. Ramakrishnan, IAS whose name was also recommended by the Selection Committee was appointed as Administrative Member in the CAT, Ernakulam Bench. The attempt made by the petitioner in this Writ Petition is to demonstrate that the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau was not factually correct and that it was engineered by Sri. K.J Alphonse with whom he was not on good terms. The petitioner relies on Ext. P13 to contend that no enquiry was held against him as reported by the Intelligence Bureau while he was the Accountant General of Kerala. The Apex Court has in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) held that the High Court exercising the power of judicial review cannot sit in appeal over the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau, attempt to disprove it and in that process sit in appeal over the decision taken by the Honourable the Chief Justice of India as regards the choice of candidates selected for appointment as Judicial Members of the CAT. Therefore, this Court cannot entertain the petitioner's plea and hold as requested by him that as the Selection Committee had withdrawn their earlier recommendation based on the report submitted by the Intelligence Bureau, which the petitioner attempts to prove was false, the decision taken by the Government of India not to appoint him is arbitrary and is liable to be invalidated.
17. The Selection Committee headed by the Honourable Mr. Justice K.G Balakrishnan, presently the Chief Justice of India, had after the report of the Intelligence Bureau on the petitioner's character and antecedents was placed before them along with the relevant files, reconsidered the matter and decided to withdraw their earlier recommendation to appoint him as Administrative Member of the CAT. The Honourable the Chief Justice of India concurred with the decision of the Selection Committee and this was accepted by the appointing authority also. As held by the Apex Court in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) the consultation with the Honourable the Chief Justice of India mandated in Sections 6 and 7 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 is not an empty formality, but one intended to ensure that only suitable candidates are selected for appointment as Members of the CAT. As held by the Apex Court in K. Ashok Reddy v. Government of India (supra) the consultation with the Honourable the Chief Justice of India is “an inbuilt check against arbitrariness and bias,” indicating the absence of need for judicial review on those grounds. Further, the Apex Court has in National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences v. Dr. K. Kalyana Raman, 1992 Supp (2) SCC 481 : AIR 1992 SC 1806 held that the function of a Selection Committee is neither judicial nor adjudicatory, but purely administrative and that they are not required to record reasons for the selection or non selection of a candidate in the absence of any rule or regulation requiring them to do so. No provision requiring the Selection Committee to record reasons for not selecting candidates seeking appointment as Members of the CAT was brought to my notice. Therefore, the Selection Committee was not bound to record reasons for not selecting the petitioner, though they had before the report of the Intelligence Bureau was received, recommended his name for appointment as Administrative Member. This Court exercising the power of judicial review cannot therefore, as held by the Apex Court, sit in appeal over the decision of the Selection Committee or of the Honourable the Chief Justice of India who approved it, substitute its own decision and invalidate the decision of the Government of India. It is also now well settled by a series of decisions of the Apex Court including the decision in Union of India v. Kali Das Batish (supra) that the mere inclusion of a candidate in the select list does not confer on him a right to be appointed and that if there was no right, there could be no occasion to maintain a writ petition for the enforcement of a non-existing right. Therefore, the petitioner cannot, in my considered opinion; assail the decision taken by the Government of India not to appoint him as Administrative Member of the CAT. For the reasons stated above, I hold that the petitioner is not entitled to the reliefs prayed for in this Writ Petition. The Writ Petition fails and is accordingly dismissed. No costs.
Alert